1 - 20 of 28 Works in Post-Nerdy Prudes Must Die (Hatchetfield)
Navigation
Listing Works
-
Tags
Summary
Wiggly’s ‘bitch of a sister’ sends him to earth, stripped of his powers and in his human form. Just his luck, he’s found by Macnamera in the middle of the Witchwoods. Things could NOT get any worse for him. Right?
-
Dirty Dudes Must Die - Electric Boogaloo by iamavacado
Fandoms: Nerdy Prudes Must Die - Team StarKid, Nerdy Prudes Must Die - Fandom, Starkid, Hatchetfield Series - Team StarKid, Team Starkid - Fandom
18 Aug 2025
Tags
Summary
Grace, with the power of the Black Book, starts killing off "dirty dudes" under everyone's nose. Peter and Steph realize that not only does she have the book and is using it to murder supposed 'perverts', she will probably destroy anyone who gets in her way. Peter and Steph have to team up to take Grace down before she levels Hatchetfield (and Clivesdale) to rubble.
Takes place directly after the credits roll of NPMD. (Think of the impliCATIONS)
-
Tags
Summary
After sacrificing what she cherishes most to get rid of the ghost of Max Jägerman, Grace Chasity starts to spiral and question everything. She decides to leave Hatchetfield to get as far away as possible from everything that led to that night. When she ends up at a coffee shop in Marion Ohio, she begins to find answers and more.
-
Run Rabbit! by SioDymph
Fandoms: Hatchetfield Series - Team StarKid, A Very Potter Musical Series - Team StarKid
13 Aug 2025
Tags
Summary
After Prom, Peter's life became a living hell. Constant nightmares about everything that happened. And the desperate wish that he could go back and change things.
But what if he could? Tinky offers him a chance to go back. But it won't be easy, he needs to do a couple "favors" for Tinky first. Will Peter have what it takes to earn his redo-button from Tinky?
And how far will Peter be willing to go to get his "perfect ending"?
-
Tags
Summary
It’s been three years since the events that shook Hatchetfield, and the town has gone back to being the quiet, uneventful island that it always was. But The Lords in Black are still around, hiding in plain sight. More specifically: Grace Chasity’s apartment.
Grace is now twenty-one, with a job at the Recreation Center, and five peculiar “roommates”. She wouldn’t have gotten where she is without them, but has noticed that more recently, they’ve been spending less and less time in The Black and White, and more time hanging around in her apartment. Grace doesn’t mind. It’s better than living alone!
-
Tags
Summary
Grace Jägerman (previously Chasity) always loved church. Always showed up early, helped the pastors, volunteered, did everything in her power to be the best person in church, but things are changing lately. Church is getting a little too "progressive theses days, they are even talking about bathing without bathing suits!! It's time to come back to the right way of following God, the gracious way of following Him.
Grace's bible study slowly becomes more and more cultish, and it's noticed, not only by the people in town, but by forces beyond it.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 1
- Chapters:
- 1/?
- Kudos:
- 1
- Hits:
- 70
-
Tags
Summary
It's the Homecoming dance at Hatchetfield High, and some of the first moments of peace that Stephanie and Peter have experienced since getting rid of Max Jägerman. The night takes an unexpected turn when The Lords in Black get involved, thanks to Grace. But their interference is uncharacteristically innocent.
After weeks of fear and tragedy, Steph and Pete get a truly magical night, and start to consider what their relationship might truly be.
-
Tags
Summary
“You’re worth nothing.” The blue being scowled.
“I know that!” Pete shouted. “I know I’m worth nothing, I know it’s not fair, but I don’t care, just bring them back! Take me.”
“If we take you, then who’s going to accept our gift?” The green one said. “There’s no point in taking you. We need someone else.”
“I can’t kill anyone.” Pete said, shaking a little. “I won’t kill anyone!”
~~~
Pete summons the Lords in Black in an attempt to bring Richie and Ruth back from the dead, but the price the Lords require is a hefty one, and they give him a deadline to get it done.
Can Pete do it for the sake of bringing his friends back? Or will he let their names be forgotten by the entire town forever, nothing but a whisper in the wind.
-
Tags
Summary
Though Grace’s mission is to end lust, that doesn’t mean she doesn’t still deal with her own sins of lust, though now instead of trying to pray them away, she now asks the Lords in Black for help, this night it’s Nibbly that answers her call for help.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 2,031
- Chapters:
- 1/1
- Kudos:
- 24
- Hits:
- 355
-
Tags
Summary
A poem about a girl twisted by fate.
☆ ~ ☆ ~ ☆
A Grace Chasity poem.
-
My Experiences Dating Max Jagerman: A Victim's Story by Calculus_Is_TOUGH
Fandoms: Hatchetfield Series - Team StarKid
22 Feb 2025
Tags
Summary
Dear potential reader,
I never wanted to date Max Jagerman, okay? But when it's your only way out of eternal torture, you'd do it too, right? Well, it ended up becoming torture of its own. If this story somehow finds its way out of my head and into your vision, I don't want you to take pity on me. Perhaps what happened was deserved. I just simply want you to heed my warnings. Don't ignore the red flags.
Signed,
Richie Lipschitz-Jagerman
-
unattainable temptations (take a bite) by tapestryoftrauma
Fandoms: Hatchetfield Series - Team StarKid
22 Jan 2025
Tags
Summary
“I want to get out of Hatchetfield,” is what she says, as confident and sure as ever. It’s humid and hot in the hallway—and Grace’s leg hairs prick up on goosebumps at the cool swash of air blowing out through Steph’s door, and she wishes her home had AC like Steph’s apartment does. “I need to get out,” she corrects, pulling at both the straps of her backpack, better sitting them on her shoulders. “Come with me?”
For a long while Steph stares at her. Not with judgement, not like Grace is mad—which she probably should, because Grace is sure the both of them are broken and that’s why this moment doesn’t feel as stupidly weird as it should. Steph sucks in her bottom lip, leans against her front door as her eyes blink slow and tired, something Grace can’t read in her eyes.
“Alright,” is her answer. Short and sweet. “For how long?”
~~~
Or Grace and Steph, the only two left alive after Max's ghostly rampage, go on a totally not homoerotic road trip after the events of NPMD
Series
- Part 8 of wasn't always this way (lautity fics)
-
if i implore you, could i be your lamb? by theillyrianwolf
Fandoms: Hatchetfield Series - Team StarKid
15 Jan 2025
Tags
Summary
After what happens with Max, Grace can only see one way out. Everything's going well - the boys are disappearing, and no one's noticing. Except... Steph's been acting strange. She's looking at Grace like she can see into her soul, can see what's going on in her head, and Grace is... afraid. Afraid she'll find out her secret. Afraid of how she'll react.
Well, her secrets, she should say.
[a post-npmd exploration of what would happen if Steph found out about Grace's little murder spree. also an exploration of Grace's trauma and sexuality]
-
We'll Survive The Crisis Babe by SillyVision_Corner
Fandoms: Hatchetfield Series - Team StarKid
09 Dec 2024
Tags
Summary
The aftermath of a certain summoning has some lasting consequences on Lex Foster's life
At the otherside of Hatchetfield, Grace Chasity is struggling to keep up with acting like a normal teen, carrying out a bunch of dark lords demands, and her new on and off relationship with the still dead Max Jägerman
-
richie would've wanted this by possibly_evil
Fandoms: Hatchetfield Series - Team StarKid
08 Dec 2024
Tags
Summary
While Paul and Gary are mourning Richie, the nerds drop off some of his stuff. Unfortunately, Grace mixes a certain book into the pile.
-
The lords in black in highschool by Eliasisananagram
Fandoms: Hatchetfield Series - Team StarKid
17 Oct 2024
Tags
Summary
Basically crack au where the lords in black take their human form and go to hatchetfield high inspired by this
https://www.tumblr.com/marvelmaniac715/731683478148644864/the-nerdy-prudes-never-really-send-the-lords-in -
The Book Has All but Closed on Your Life by JustALittleLady
Fandoms: Hatchetfield Series - Team StarKid
13 Oct 2024
Tags
Summary
It was a lovely day at Hatchetfield High. The sun was shining, the birds were singing, and the nerds were nerding.
As for the lovers… Well, let’s just say that, after everything that Pete and Steph have gone through, these two deserve their happily ever after, no?
Only—destiny and Grace Chasity have other ideas.
Or: Some time after the events of NPMD, Pete and Steph try to take the next step in their relationship when Grace Chasity passes by and sees them getting… dirty.
-
Honor Thy Mother and Thy Father by Trollinstinct
Fandoms: Hatchetfield Series - Team StarKid
09 Oct 2024
Tags
Summary
Mark and Karen Chasity work hard so that Grace can be the best christian she can be, so when she befriends Pete and Steph they forbid her from speaking with them.
But there is something dark within their little girl, and will their own secrets come to out?
-
Tags
Summary
Gabe never even had a chance with Grace Chasity.
-
if i didn't know better (i'd think you were still around) by tapestryoftrauma
Fandoms: Hatchetfield Series - Team StarKid
05 Jun 2024
Tags
Summary
Karen loved quietly.
She can say I love you as many times as she wants here, but it's too late. It was too late eighteen years ago. Karen has always been quiet, and so she stays silent.
//
Or: a character study of Karen Chasity post-NPMD, facing the reality of her daughter's decent into Lord in Black caused madness and the effects that has on her family