Archive of Our Own ^beta

Chapter Text

Shock was what Maddy felt when she found all those pictures on Nate’s phone. It made her question a lot about her relationship with Nate. 

Why would he have other men nudes in his phone? She pondered pretty often. Everyone knew Maddy had all the power in the relationship, which is why she couldn’t let him get away with this. 

She didn’t tell him about what she and she didn’t go snooping for answers either, but she did spread the rumors and everyone knew. Nate hated walking down the hallways, feeling every pair of eyes burn into his back. The whispers being spoken every time he was near. It enraged him and for what Maddy was planning on doing to him; she needed him to be enraged. While Nate was busy being the talk of the town, Maddy was researching. She knew that if she was going to approach Nate with the Information; she knew it had to be perfect. 

While she was researching explanations of the spectrum of sexuality showed up fairly quick, she dug deeper. She clicked through most of the site. That was until she stumbled upon an article about pegging. She almost immediately fell in love with the idea. She visited multiple sites about the topic and ordered everything she would need. Everything arrived within a week. Her parents would be gone for the weekend for their anniversary, so Maddy invited Nate over. Of course, he arrived almost immediately, already planning on having his way with Maddy.

“Hey baby,” she greeted him with a kiss on the cheek.

Before he could open his mouth to respond, she lifted a finger and shushed him. She grabbed his hand and led him to her room. He sat on her bed while she straddled his lap and wrapped her hands around his neck.

“I missed you. It feels like I haven’t seen you in forever,” he huffs out. His voice cracks slightly with his words, Maddy notices immediately.

“What’s wrong?” He tries to brush her off, but she’s not having any of it. Maddy grabs his chin and forces him to look at her and she sees the tears in his eyes.

“Who made you cry?”

“It was nothing! It is nothing!”

“You know better than to raise your voice at me. Now look at me and tell me who did it.”

Nate wasn’t going to tell any names. He was afraid of what would happen to him if he did or if he told anyone what they did to him. He breaks down sobbing uncontrollably. Maddy comforts him the best she can, holding him close to her.

“You know it’s okay to not be straight. Sexuality is a spectrum and if you like men, I’m fine with it. I won’t judge you and I’d still love you, no matter what.”

That sets Nate off immediately. The once crying boy stands up to his full height and shoves Maddy off of him.

“What the fuck are you talking about? I’m not fucking gay!”

“I never said you were Nate-“

“But you were fucking insinuating it!” 

“Nate-“

“No! Shut the fuck up. You did enough”

Maddy gets up and tries to comfort him, but he pushes her away again except this time he slaps her. The sound of her gasp fills the room. Nate's eyes fill with fear.

“I’m sorry please Maddy, I’m sorry.”

“No, you’re not sorry, but you’re gonna be.”

She pushes him on the bed, starts stripping off his clothes. He tries to stop her, but she swats his hands away and slaps him across his face. Nate stops trying to fight her, realizing it’ll just make her even more angry. She stops when she gets to his belt she takes it off gently and puts it to the side. She quickly strips the rest of his clothes off. 

Maddy manhandles him over her lap, and he lets her. She grabs the belt and folds it in half and looks down at Nate.

“Do you know why this is about to happen to you?“

“Maddy please no-“

She cuts him off by bringing the belt down hard on his ass.

“You should’ve just kept crying and shut your mouth, to think that i actually planned on being nice to you.”

She strikes his ass twice more and Nate starts struggling against her grip, trying to get away from the pain she’s inflicting on him

“Maddy please stop- just please I can’t-“ 

“Shut the fuck up!” 

He starts sobbing as she continues beating his ass with the leather belt in her hand. She doesn’t stop until his ass bruised and some spots start trickling blood. Maddy pushes Nate off of her lap as he hit the floor with a thud. She then stands up.

“If you even move one inch, I will crush your balls with my bare hands.”

Maddy gets up and walks over to her closet taking out a 8 inch dildo and a harness to put it in. Once she strips off her clothes and gets the strap-on ready, she walks back over to Nate. 

“Open your mouth now!” She growls at him.

“No.”

“No? So you’ll let your teammates shove their cocks down your throat, but you won’t let me?”

His eyes widen at her words. 

“You knew what they did to me?” Nate cries out as tears run down his face once more.

“Of course I did. Who do you think they were recording it for? Now be a good boy for mommy and open up.” 

He knew better than to piss her off even more, so he opened his mouth like a good boy. Maddy thrusts her thick cock all the way down his throat. He gags as her cock presses into the back of his throat. Maddy runs her fingers through Nate’s hair as he slowly takes her thick member from his mouth to lick the tip. He looks Maddy in the eyes as he swirls his tongue around the tip and licks back down to the base. She gets impatient as Nate takes his slow time blowing her. She grips his head again and thrust all the way back down his throat.

She gives him a few seconds to adjust before she starts snapping her hip against his mouth.

“Who knew Nate Jacobs would be so good at sucking dick?” He felt so humiliated being used like this, but he allowed it because he knew it could be much worse.

She continues to fuck his throat with deep strokes before Nate starts rapidly tapping her leg. She pulls out completely and Nate backs away and starts coughing and gasping for air. He looks at Maddy as if he was pleading for her to stop.

“Aw, did you expect me to feel bad? Learn how to breathe through your nose like any other cock whore!” 

She slaps him across his face and drags him back in front of her cock.

“Be a good boy for mommy and open your slutty mouth again.” She gently taps her silicone cock against his flushed face to encourage him. 

He nods and opens his mouth for the last time. Maddy starts fucking Nate’s throat even harder than before, if possible. Nate already knew his voice was going to be wrecked. Maddy, however, was focusing obscene everything looks and sounds. All she can hear are the sounds of gagging on her cock and struggling to breathe. She didn’t think he would look so good on his knees with a thick cock down his throat. She starts wondering what he would look like bent over with his back arched while he gets pounded from behind. She gets an idea just then.

“Get up and bend over, bitch boy.” She pulls out of his mouth, finally giving his throat a break. Nate shakes his head and tries to run from Maddy. She catches him before he can even get off the ground and manhandles him over the bed.

“I was actually going to give you lube and prep you since it’s your first time, but nevermind.”

“Maddy- please no! Plea- “He’s cut off by Maddy shoving her entire cock in his tight virgin ass. Nate screams out in pain, never feeling anything like this before. He can feel himself almost tear as she pulls halfway out and thrust every inch back in. He starts silently crying, trying to imagine he’s somewhere else and not having his anal virginity taken by his girlfriend raping him.

“Please pull out. I don’t want it! Please, I’ll be good. I’ll be nice. I’ll do anything!” She slaps him and starts fucking him even harder.

“If you really didn’t want this, your pathetic dick wouldn’t be as hard as it is now.” she counters as her 8 inch cock fills Nate’s ass. He cry’s out and just lays there and lets her take him because he knows there’s nothing he can do that’ll stop her. He shuts down completely, almost like when McKay got the team to hold him down while he used his throat for his pleasure. He can almost taste how bitter his cum was when he came. Nate didn’t even want to swallow, but he had no choice. They all had their hands on him. 

Maddy fully enjoys striping Nate of his confidence, courage, and manhood just with a single snap of her hips. Nate dissociates from his body, if he can even call it that anymore. After getting violated and used, he feels so grimy. He knows he can’t get help. Everyone will just assume he asked for it since she spread the rumors. He tries not to enjoy being raped, but the constant rubbing against his prostate is making him feel different. He just wished his body would agree with his mind so Maddy would stop.

She notices him getting harder by the second, so she makes sure to fuck him even deeper and harder than before. She wraps her hand around Nate’s neck, pulling his back up against her chest. He hates the feeling. She doesn’t care she leans in to his ear and whispers.

“If you want this to be over soon, you’re going to ride my cock and show me how much you want it.” The words feel bitter on her tongue, but Nate has done so much to her that she stopped caring about his feelings.

He weakly nods and lets Maddy pull out of him. She gets settled in the middle of the bed and glances at her boyfriend. She saw his tear-stained face, knowing that she broke his trust and shattered his heart. She feels terrible for a second, just a mere second, before she’s patting her lap and beckoning him over to her. He crawls over to her and hovers over her enormous cock. She strokes his thighs as he eases his way down on her cock. He hates every second of it, but can’t help moaning out because it’s in so deep.

Maddy touches him gently while he lightly bounces to try to get used to the stretch. He wonders if she feels bad about her actions while her hands are on him, but one look at her gaze, he knows she doesn’t. Maddy decides that he’s taking too long, so she moves her hands to his hips and impales him onto her cock again. He knows from the jolt of pain that coursing through his veins that she made him rip. She stares at the toy, disappearing into him every time she moves his hips. She notices the blood but can’t get herself to care anymore. Nate's cock starts leaking and they both know he’s close. It didn’t matter how much pain he was in his body still enjoyed the sensation. 

Tears ran down his face as he blows his load all over himself. Maddy laughs at him, shoves him off her dick. She gets up to go clean herself up. Leaving Nate shaking coated in his own cum with blood leaking from his hole. It was then that Nate realized he had no control anymore and that he never really knew Maddy.

Chapter Text

It was midnight in the Perez household. Nate and Maddy's high school years long gone with Maddy at the top of her modeling career and the only thing that Nate managed to achieve in all this time is being her doting house husband. She told him not to wait for her tonight and that she probably wouldn't be back until morning. Of course, Nate didn't listen he already knew she was probably with another guy getting fucked the way she deserves but that didn't stop him from staying up all night imaging how his cock would taste on his tongue or how hard he was pounding Maddy while the only thing Nate could do was get painfully hard in the chastity cage, she locked him in on their wedding day.

Nate knew he wasn't allowed to touch himself no matter the circumstances, but as his mind wandered, the more painful his erection got. He got off the huge California king bed that Maddy brought last year and reached under it searching for the box of toys that she kept. He quickly found the box and opened it being greeted with a collection of dildos and vibrators of all shapes and sizes. The one that caught his eye was a 7-inch girthy purple dildo. He grabbed it and shoved the box back under the bed. He couldn't wait to get the toy inside of him jumping on the bed pulling his pink frilly panties to the side before lifting his legs and shoving it deep inside of him. He was already stretched out from Maddy making him clean the entire house dressed as a slutty maid with a thick butt plug filling him up. His eyes were rolling into the back of his head as he relentlessly pounded his ass with the toy. 

Maddy opened the front door of their shared modern mansion giggling holding Chris hand. " Come on we already fucked before we got here, and you already want to go again?" she whined. Chris just wrapped his hand around her throat shoving her into the house slamming the door behind him "A man has needs you should know this." She throws her head back and moans as his hand slides into her skirt.  She grabs his wrist, and he slaps her hard across the face. "Bedroom now." he groans. She leads him through the many long hallways opening the door being greeting with a moaning Nate who was still wrecking his own tight hole.

"Holy shit-" Chris rushes out. Nate quickly covers himself up his face turning red. 

"You dirty slut! I come home a few hours late and you just could wait to get fucked?" Maddy

Mortified Nate stays silent just staring at them wide eyed. Chris and Maddy walk over to Nate towering over him. Maddy slaps him across the face hard it would be surprising if he doesn't wake up with a bruise in the morning.

"What so now you're too fucked out to answer dumb whore!" 

"I'm sorry please don't punish me I'll be a good girl I swear!" Nate apologizes letting out a humiliating moan as Chris shoves his hands away and starts to move the toy that nudging against his bundle of ne r ves. 

"You look so pathetic." Chris taunts. Nate just let out a moan as Chris starts to pick up his pace. "I bet you like that don't you. You're such a little cumslut." He says pulling the toy out of Nate's twitching hole and plunging it back in. Maddy rids herself of her clothes and moves over to sit on Nates face "Eat me out bitch!" she yells smothering him with her thighs.

Nate lets out a muffled moan as he laps at her pussy. Chris removes the toy from Nate's ass and throws it on the floor. He takes off his pants and boxers and shoves his dick deep inside of him. Maddy grabs a handful of Nate's hair, forcing her hips down on his face. Nate is a moaning mess. He has never felt this full before. Maddy starts to grind down on his face and all he can do is lick her clit, making her moan. Chris grabs Nate's legs and throws them over his shoulders and fucks him harder and faster. Nate is in heaven, but he can feel himself getting closer to the edge. Maddy grabs his balls and starts to squeeze them hard.

"I'm not letting you cum slut, you need to earn it."

Nate moans in response. Chris leans over and starts to kiss Maddy, their tongues colliding and Maddy's pussy gets even wetter. Nate continues to lick at her clit, trying to make her cum. His balls start to ache, and he feels like he is going to burst. He grabs at Maddy's thighs, trying to push her off of him. Maddy pulls away from Chris's lips and slaps Nate hard in the face again.

"I said not yet!" she screams. "Keep licking my pussy or you will regret it."

Nate eyes roll back as Chris keeps pounding him using him as a fleshlight. Maddy keeps squeezing Nate's balls, making his orgasm impossible. Nate lets out a muffled scream, and his body starts to shake. He tries to fight his orgasm, but his body gives in. Nate starts to cum. His cum spurts out all over his chest. Maddy slaps him again, "I didn't give you permission to cum slut!". Nate moans in response. Chris just laughs and starts to fuck Nate even harder.

Nate's eyes roll into the back of his head and his body goes limp. He has never experienced an orgasm like this before. He feels like he is floating on air. Chris keeps pounding him, and he can feel another orgasm building. Nate tries to move away from Chris, but his legs are too weak.

"Stop fighting me, you know you like it," Chris says, grabbing Nate's hips and pulling him closer. Nate whimpers and tries to squirm away, but it is no use.

Nate's orgasm hits him hard, his back arching as his cock spurts out another load of cum. His whole body is shaking, and he lets out a loud moan. Chris continues to pound him, not letting up. Nate is a whimpering mess, his body overstimulated. Maddy moves off of Nate's face, and Chris pulls out of him. Nate lets out a small whimper, feeling empty. He is still shaking and lets out a small sob.

"You look so beautiful when you cry." Chris taunts.

"Please..." Nate sobs, "I can't take anymore."

Chris just laughs and grabs Nate by the hair, forcing him to his knees. "Open your mouth." he groans. Nate just shakes his head. Chris grabs Nate's jaw, forcing his mouth open. He shoves his cock into Nate's mouth, and Nate chokes.

"Don't worry, you will get used to it." Chris says, thrusting into Nate's mouth. Nate tries to move away, but Chris holds him in place. Chris's thrusts get faster and faster. Nate starts to gag, tears running down his face. Chris moans as he cums into Nate's mouth. Nate swallows the cum, not wanting to anger Chris.

"Good boy." Chris says, pulling his cock out of Nate's mouth. Nate gasps for breath. He is exhausted, his body sore. Chris lays Nate down on the bed and climbs over him. "Now it's my turn." He says, grabbing Nate's legs and spreading them. Chris pushes his cock into Nate's ass, and Nate whimpers. Chris starts to thrust, and Nate moans. He doesn't have the energy to fight anymore. He lets Chris use him, and he enjoys it.

Chris keeps pounding him, and Nate's cock starts to get hard again. Nate can't believe he is enjoying this, but he can't help it. Chris's cock feels good inside of him, and he wants more.

Chris moans as he cums deep inside of Nate, and Nate's cock spurts out another load. Nate is exhausted, but he doesn't want it to stop. He looks at Chris with pleading eyes.

"More." He begs.

Chris just laughs and pulls out of him, leaving Nate a quivering mess. Nate whimpers, feeling empty. Chris kisses him, and he melts into it. Chris pulls away and looks at Maddy.

"I think he learned his lesson." He says, laughing. Nate just lays on the bed, his body spent. He feels ashamed for enjoying it, but he can't deny that he wants more.

"Yes, I think he did." Maddy says, smiling. Nate knows that this won't be the last time Chris fucks him. He can't wait.

Maddy walks over to Nate and smirks. "See you're just a little whore, aren't you? You love being fucked by Chris, don't you?" Nate just nods his head. "Say it bitch!" Maddy yells slapping him.

"I-I'm a little whore and I love getting fucked by Chris." Nate replies, humiliated. Maddy smiles and kisses him.

"Good boy." She says, climbing onto the bed and straddling him. "Now let's see how much you can take."

She grabs his cock and lines it up with her pussy and sinks down on it. Nate lets out a moan as he feels his cock being engulfed by her warmth. She starts to ride him, and Nate grabs her hips, trying to steady her. She slaps him hard across the face. "Don't touch me!" She yells.

Nate lets go of her hips, and she continues to ride him. She is relentless, and Nate can't take much more. He feels his orgasm building, and he tries to hold it back. Maddy keeps riding him, and Nate's eyes roll into the back of his head. He lets out a loud moan as he cums deep inside of her. She continues to ride him, not letting up. Nate is spent, his body tired, but he doesn't want it to stop. Maddy keeps riding him until she orgasms.

She climbs off of him, and Nate lets out a small whimper. His cock is sore, and he feels empty. Maddy just laughs and walks to the bathroom. She comes back with a towel and wipes the cum off of Nate's chest. She throws the towel at him.

"Clean yourself up, you're a mess." She says, walking out of the room. Nate just lays on the bed, his body sore. He knows he will be sore tomorrow, but he doesn't care. He enjoyed every second of it.

Chris just laughs and walks out of the room. Nate just lays there in his own shame. He doesn't know what he was expecting when he married Maddy, but it certainly wasn't this.