Chapter 1: Sam
Chapter Text
Player: I am going insane
Sam: I've known that for a while
Sam: You don't try and date your furniture when you're mentally stable
Player: I haven't tried yet!
Player: It's been a few days and besides the first day I haven't put them on
Sam: Really?
Sam: You have so many attractive people living in your house and you don't want to see them?
Player: It's a lot okay
Player: Like I'm just supposed to stay quiet about all of this?
Sam: I mean
Sam: You don't have to
Player: What do you mean?
Sam: You've already told me this much, so what's the harm of telling me more?
Sam: It's not every day you have a friend who gets to date their furniture, why wouldn't I want to hear all about it?
Player: You realise if I start I won't be able to stop, right?
Sam: I am aware of your quirks
Sam: And I can't say I'm not really curious
Sam: Personally, if I had those glasses, I would really want to see what my bath looks like
Sam: My bath is a pretty sexy bath if I say so myself
Player: And you called me weird
Sam: Yeah, cause you are
Sam: I can admit my bath is sexy because at least I'm not trying to have sex with it
Player: I'm not trying to have sex with mine either!
Player: Not yet at least
Player: I don't know what they look like
Sam: This is what I mean
Player: I can't believe you are acting like you are better than me when you are actively trying to get me to bang my furniture
Sam: I am a complex woman
Sam: A complex woman who wants to see her bestie find love and see what it's like to have someone live out the life of those object romances we used to binge read in high-school
Sam: Omg remember those?
Player: I do
Player: But I'm not going to bang my door
Player: He's already friendzoned me
Sam: A knob put to waste
Player: You're a pervert
Sam: You're the one who implied they would bang their door if he allowed it!
Player: You would too if you saw him!
Player: That's something I should test
Player: Take a few pictures and see if they work
Sam: Maybe if you put the dateviators over the camera?
Player: I'm too deep into this
Player: Why do I let you convince me bad ideas are good ideas
Sam: I've never done that
Sam: Every idea I've ever suggested has been good
Sam: Except working at Valdivian
Sam: And I apologise for that
Player: Nah, its fine
Player: You did your best, it was just bad timing
Sam: Aren't you sweet
Sam: Talk to your furniture that way and I'm sure you'll have then in bed in moments
Sam: Instant threesome
Player: I truly have no choice here, do I?
Sam: Nope, not at all
Sam: Go and smooch a couch for me
Player: I'll put them on tomorrow
Player: It's getting late
Sam: Awww
Sam: Fine
Sam: You better keep me updated
Player: I will
Sam: And if there's any you don't want I'm sure I can suddenly need a new piece of furniture
Player: I'm not letting you bang any of my furniture
Sam: Fine
Sam: Could have been freaks together, but I guess you just want to be a freak alone
Player: You are one confusing woman
Sam: But you love me
Player: That's debatable
Sam: You're going to ditch me for your furniture
Player: I hope I do
Sam: YOU WEREN'T SUPPOSED TO AGREE
Chapter 2: Johnny Splash
Notes:
I rambled on a bit with this one, but I had a little bit of starting story I had to sprinkle in with Johnny's story. This is mostly how these will play out, in segments that range a certain amount of time. This one is the most cohesive, as Johnny is both the first one Player sought out and is the first they started dating, but in the future, the only real timeline the chapters provide will be the order of dating.
Also, shoutout to my friend Kyle who has been happily listening to me liveblog pretty much my entire Date Everything experience and was the main inspiration for this fic.
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
Player: Okay
Player: I did what you asked
Player: And holy shit my shower is hot
Sam: Sexy wise or temperature wise?
Player: Both
Player: Also that is why sometimes I wake up with no hot water
Player: Johnny's gone and used it all for himself
Sam: Johnny?
Player: My shower
Player: His name is Johnny Splash
Sam: JOHNNY SPLASH?
Sam: Like a knockoff Johnny Cash?
Player: Yep
Player: Even wants to be a singer
Player: Although he speaks like Elvis
Sam: Maybe that's why people get the urge to sing in the shower
Sam: Is his singing sexy?
Player: Not in the slightest
Player: But he's really passionate
Sam: Oh no
Sam: Your poor ears
Player: It's not that bad
Player: If I didn't want to hear him I could just date the glasses off
Sam: Let's hope you don't have to listen too much then
Sam: As long as his voice is sexy without the singing you'll be fine
Player: His voice is something
Player: But I'll have to put up with the singing
Player: I promised to help him get a career in it
Sam: YOU DID NOT
Player: He was just so sweet
Player: What was I to do?
Sam: The things we do for dick
Player: Don't act like this is that bad
Player: I just think he deserves to be happy
Player: That reminds me!
Player: I've got a picture for you!
Player: (Picture of Johnny Splash leaning against his shower head)
Sam: Omg
Sam: I see why you said yes to him
Sam: Omg is that a loofah rose?
Player: Told you he was hot
Player: And that voice
Player: He's so sweet with it
Sam: Must have made showering with him a delight
Sam: What's he like naked?
Player: You really are a pervert
Player: And I wouldn't know, I took the glasses off to shower
Player: But I am realising now that he's probably been looking at me showering for the last few years
Player: I need to invest in a shower curtain
Sam: Until that turns human too
Player: They still wouldn't be able to see me
Player: I met Johnny outside the shower
Sam: Guess that makes sense
Sam: But holy shit, if all your furniture is that fine, I wouldn't be able to control myself
Player: I have no idea how I am controlling myself
Player: I've been alone for too long
Sam: But you’ve got a chance to not be alone anymore
Sam: Just keep doing what you’re doing, helping him with his dream, and he’ll be in love with you in no time
Player: You’ve got high hopes for me
Sam: Someone has to
Sam: So go out there and woo your shower!
Player: What did I do in my last life to deserve this weird life?
~
Player: Progress with Johnny has been made
Player: We’re gonna get him on American Maestro, figure out how to let him sing a song for them without him leaving my house, and then I need to figure out how his singing abilities are gonna get way better in a matter of days
Sam: Sure you haven’t bitten off more than you can chew?
Player: When did I ever say I didn’t?
Sam: True true
Sam: So, what has the time together when not working on his singing career held for the two of you?
Player: A lot actually
Player: We’re talking about our families, I’ve shared some of my own hobbies, and I think we’ve been flirting?
Sam: You just think?
Player: It might have just been him being very southern?
Player: It’s hard to tell sometimes
Player: Remember, who are basically the only non professional relationship I have had since highschool
Player: How am I supposed to know what flirting is and isn’t?
Sam: Keep forgetting that
Sam: But I say flirt back a little, see if he’s into it or if he shuts you down
Sam: If he’s as sweet as you say, you will still be able to be friends
Player: What would I do without you?
Sam: Not get a boyfriend because you were scared of dating your shower obviously
Player: I take back any praise I’ve ever given you
Sam: I deserve that
Sam: Is showering any sexier now that he’s flirting with you?
Player: Not really
Player: I asked him about it and he says he mostly just looks away, but if I ever run out of something mid-shower, as long as the dateviators are nearby I can just ask him and he’ll hand another of it
Sam: I can’t believe I am jealous of you over a shower
Sam: He really is sweet
Player: That’s what I’ve been saying!
Sam: If he ends up not being into you, you need to send him my way
Player: He’s my shower, I think he’s stuck in my house
Sam: Then I’ll come over
Player: You live states away
Sam: I’ve done worse for hot men
Player: Thank fuck you didn’t get these glasses instead of me
~
Player: I am horrible at talking to people
Player: What was I thinking when I decided that trying to befriend and date my furniture was a good idea?
Sam: What happened?
Player: Johnny got pissed at me
Sam: For the flirting?
Sam: I am so sorry I put you up to that, I shouldn’t have
Player: No, not that
Player: He liked the flirting, and I thought we were getting somewhere, but then I tried to bring up how he might need a lot of practice if he decides to send in his singing as it is, and then he started accusing me of being jealous
Sam: No way he did that
Sam: Did he force you out of the bathroom?
Player: No, it took a few minutes, but he collected his cool again and just said he was stressed, and that he needed some time to himself
Player: He said I should come back in a few days, but what if he doesn’t mean it?
Sam: Listen, I don’t know much about him besides what you told me, nut from what you have told me, I think he will accept you back
Sam: But he better do so after even more apologising
Sam: Or else I’m coming over and busting up his piping
Player: Please don’t break my shower I can’t take baths when I’m sad
Player: But thanks for being on my side here
Player: It means a lot to me
Sam: I’d do so anytime
~
Sam: Hey
Sam: I was curious about what you said, and I decided to watch American Maestro
Player: So you saw Johnny?
Sam: Yeah
Sam: Are you guys better now?
Player: Much better
Player: He gave me a better apology, and he wanted me to watch the episode with him because he wanted to share such a momentous occasion with me
Sam: I feel really bad for him
Sam: Being put on a joke reel couldn’t have been good for him
Player: He took it a lot better than I had been hoping
Sam: Wait really?
Player: Yeah
Player: After what transpired between us, he realised he wasn’t meant for a career, but that didn’t mean he couldn’t still love it
Sam: Aww, ain’t that sweet
Player: It is
Player: It’s good to see him so happy about his singing, I have actually grown quite fond of it these days
Player: I leave my dateviators right outside the shower these days, and sometimes, when the water pressure is low, I can hear just the faintest singing
Player: Odd how they work
Sam: I’m glad you love to hear him sing
Sam: Personally, I would not be able to handle it
Sam: You really weren’t kidding when you said it was bad
Player: Well I can
Player: And that is why he asked me to attend all singing events around the house to watch him
Player: As his partner
Sam: NO YOU ARE NOT JUST DROPPING THIS NOW
Sam: YOU TWO ARE DATING???
Player: I couldn’t find a good place to slip it in…
Sam: You should have interrupted me for that!
Player: To be fair, that whole lead up was super important
Player: We got together like right after that whole thing was settled
Sam: Indulged in some shower sex?
Player: NO
Player: We’ve not gone that far yet, he wants to be a gentleman about it
Sam: Should’ve expected that
Sam: But I am still curious so you better tell me all about it when you finally get there
Player: I’ll make sure to never tell you
Sam: Rude!
Sam: But yeah, super excited for you!
Sam: I can’t remember the last time I saw you actually date
Sam: But honestly kinda shocked you found love so quickly
Sam: Had I been you, I would have tried out a little more before settling
Player: Well
Sam: Well?
Player: Who says I have to say I’m done now?
Sam: I cannot let you break Johnny’s heart like that
Player: I won’t!
Player: But these objects don’t seem to mind polyamoury for the most part
Player: If love happens, I don’t want to say no to it just because I already love Johnny
Player: He’s fine with it
Sam: I am begging you to start conversations with the right information
Player: I should really do that
Sam: But if that's true, know that I am the number 1 supporter of your object harem
Player: What am I to do with you?
Sam: Give me all the deets!
Notes:
Next up is Timothy!
Comment if you enjoy, it is the best way to tell me you like my stuff!
Chapter 3: Timothy Timepiece
Notes:
I never did Timmy's route, so we only get Timothy. Sorry.
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
Player: When I was told I could see my objects as people, I expected them all to look human
Player: I was wrong
Sam: Omg what is it this time?
Player: I’ve got a catboy in my home
Sam: A CATBOY???
Sam: SHOW ME NOW
Player: I can’t!
Sam: But my picture…
Player: He was really upset I tried to talk to him without an appointment
Player: Said I needed to understand the importance of schedules
Player: But he said it like shhhhedules
Sam: Were he not a catboy I would find that very annoying
Sam: But its not everyday you get to meet a real life catboy
Sam: IF ONLY I COULD SEE HIM
Player: I was getting there
Player: So if I want a picture I have to make an appointment for it
Player: So I am meeting him at noon tomorrow
Sam: Having to schedule a meeting just to get a photo is insane
Player: I didn’t exactly get a choice
Player: I live with him, I would prefer him to not hate me
Player: I already don’t feel safe outside my home, I can’t feel unsafe inside as well
Sam: No, I totally get that
Sam: What kind of man makes you do that though?
Player: One who happens to be an object obviously
Sam: Wait let me guess what this is
Sam: Is this your clock?
Player: Was it the schedule thing that let you guess?
Sam: Kinda
Sam: Also the fact you’ve been obsessed with cat clocks since highschool
Player: How dare you
Player: It’s been since middle school
Sam: My bad for not knowing you at age 12
Player: Exactly
Sam: So who even is this guy? If I can’t have a picture, can I have a name?
Player: He says his name is Timothy Timepiece
Sam: That certainly sounds like a catboy clock name
Player: I kinda expected him to be cuter
Player: Anime sets unrealistic expectations
Sam: I’m sure you can worm your way in and show all his cute sides
Sam: At noon for some reason
Player: Guess I’ll be playing by his shhhedule for a while
Sam: What we must put up with for love
Sam: Get your weirdo harem by any means necessary
~
Player: The meeting went well
Sam: Didn’t you get fired?
Player: Not that kind of meeting
Player: The meeting with Timothy
Sam: Oh righttt
Sam: Do I get a picture now?
Player: Yes, I managed to convince him
Player: (Picture of Timothy looking rather refined with a pocket watch)
Sam: He looks like a gentleman
Sam: Wasn’t expecting that
Player: It makes his obsession with shhhedules make a little more sense
Player: It was all clocks and shhhedules and timeliness with him
Sam: You’re not gonna give up on shhhedules with him are you?
Player: Nope
Player: Join me
Sam: I’ll check my shhhedule
Player: Yeah!
Sam: So was this meeting just for the picture?
Player: No, he has also decided I need dating advice
Sam: That is probably good
Sam: You will need it
Player: I know, but I’d rather it not be said out loud
Sam: Yeah
Sam: That’s why I am messaging it to you
Sam: But I could send a voice note
Player: Please don’t
Sam: Fine fine
Sam: What kind of advice did he give?
Player: Why don’t you give your best guess given what I’ve said?
Sam: The advice was keep a shhhedule wasn’t it?
Player: Yeah
Player: Said I needed to keep a shhhedule no matter what or my date would hate me
Sam: That’s a bit harsh
Player: Well what else am I supposed to get from him? He obviously thinks shhhedules are the most important thing
Sam: All of this really diminishes the cuteness of a catboy
Player: Does it though?
Sam: You really are lonely
Player: Are you saying he’s not attractive?
Sam: That is not what I am saying
Sam: What I am saying is how do you find him cute?
Player: He is so passionate about time
Player: Is passion suddenly not cute?
Sam: But passion about time?
Player: You should have seen him!
Player: He lit up when I understood what was being taught
Player: He is not as stuffy as he looks with his shhheduling
Sam: Well, if he is the catboy available, he will be the catboy you get
Player: I would choose him even if I had multiple catboys
Player: But I don’t think I own anymore cat themed stuff
Sam: Well, got your next meeting shhheduled?
Player: Yep!
Player: In a few days I am meeting him at 3pm
Player: And I’ll see what other advice he has to give
Sam: Think it will also be time based?
Player: Absolutely
Sam: At least you will get better at time management from all of this
~
Player: Just had the weirdest meeting of my life
Sam: Tell me all about it
Sam: I just had the most boring meeting of my life and I need some intrigue in my life
Player: You are stuck with boring job things while I am going on dates with my household objects
Sam: I can’t believe you are winning when that is what you spend your day doing
Player: But anyway
Player: Had another meeting with Timothy today
Sam: That sure does explain why the meeting was weird
Player: This one was on shhhedules again, and the importance of sticking to them even for momentary pleasures
Sam: I mean
Sam: That could be good advice?
Player: He was again, very excited that I was taking in what he was saying
Player: But he almost seemed excited in another way
Sam: YOU HAD A HORNY CATBOY IN YOUR PRESENCE AND YOU DIDNT START WITH THAT???
Player: I did start with that!
Player: I said I had a very weird meeting
Sam: That did not prepare me for this news!
Sam: How did you get him horny?
Player: I didn’t!
Player: He made himself horny talking about shhhedules
Sam: IM SORRY WHAT
Player: I don’t really understand it either
Player: But to be fair, he was talking about how a good shhhedule would get anyone I wanted into my bed
Player: As long as I put time in my shhhedule for it
Sam: So what I’m hearing is you need to put some time in the shhhedule for your dear Timothy
Player: Timothy has shown no interest in me
Player: Just a whole lot of interest in shhhedules
Sam: Not even slightly interested in seeing where this could lead?
Player: Now I never said that
Sam: So why not go for it?
Sam: Not everyone gets a chance to bang a catboy
Player: Good thing its me and not you doing this
Player: You would break at talking to a catboy
Sam: I would
Sam: I hate that you are living my dream in this scenario
Player: I’m not as much of a weirdo now
Sam: You still are, just I am too
Player: Damn
Sam: When is your next meeting with him?
Player: 9pm
Sam: That sure is late
Sam: You sure he’s not trying to get you into bed with him?
Player: No
Player: But it is safer to assume
Sam: Your loss
~
Player: I think he may be into me???
Sam: Fork found in kitchen
Player: That doesn’t even make sense
Player: But like, he let me touch his pocket watch
Sam: Is that a euphemism?
Player: No, but he cares so much about those things!
Player: I would have never expected he would have let me touch them
Player: And then there feels like there was this push and pull of todays conversation
Player: And it wasn’t even about time this time!
Sam: Omg wait really?
Sam: Your objects surprise me more every day
Sam: What was the lesson this time?
Player: About holding a high standard of love for yourself so you can guarantee a high level of love from others
Sam: Damn
Sam: Thats actually really good advice
Sam: I’ll need to use that for my next date
Player: Wait til I put the cherry on top of this conversation
Player: He set it not knowing I would show up
Player: He wanted to see how much he could count on me
Sam: You need to get him in bed right this instance
Sam: He is so into you
Player: I feel like that's a jump
Sam: Who knows?
Sam: Do you have your next meeting shhheduled? Maybe you can ask him about it then
Player: Yes
Player: It’s tomorrow at 9am
Sam: Then you have to wait less than 12 hours
Sam: You’ll get your answer
Player: I hope he is as into me as you guess he is
~
Player: THIS IS NOT A DRILL THIS IS NOT A DRILL
Player: TIMOTHY IS PART OF THE POLYCULE
Sam: HOLY SHIT NO WAY
Sam: You really asked him about his feelings???
Player: Didn’t even have to!
Player: He shhheduled that meeting to tell me his feelings
Player: He was so romantic, calling me dear and telling me how calm he felt around me
Player: And want to know the best part?
Sam: Of course I do!
Player: He said that his heart beats not only with the clock now, but with my heart
Sam: I would have crumbled
Player: I did crumble
Sam: Were you able to shhhedule a date?
Player: No, but he did say he would make time for me whenever I wanted to spend time with him
Sam: Damn you just keep winning
Sam: That means you’ve got a lot of time for bedtime activities
Player: Oh I know that well
Sam: QUIT DROPPING THIS INFORMATION LIKE THAT
Sam: YOU BANGED THE CATBOY???
Sam: OR HE BANGED YOU???
Player: I was shocked as well!
Player: He even broke shhhedule for me
Sam: Tell me about it!!!
Player: Later! I promise
Sam: Meanie
Player: I’ve got things to do today
Sam: Is that thing your clock?
Player: Keep pushing and I won’t tell you anything
Sam: I can’t believe you are treating me like this
Player: I can’t believe I went from having my love life suck to having two boyfriends
Sam: You truly are living the life
Sam: And I would be if you TOLD ME WHAT ITS LIKE TO FUCK A CATBOY
Notes:
Next up is Mac! I may be a bit attracted to black hair.
Comment if you enjoy! It is very encouraging!
Uxiecilly_Lace on Chapter 1 Wed 25 Jun 2025 04:33PM UTC
Comment Actions
RedBloodTea on Chapter 1 Wed 25 Jun 2025 05:08PM UTC
Comment Actions
HomestuckTrash68 on Chapter 1 Wed 25 Jun 2025 07:09PM UTC
Last Edited Wed 25 Jun 2025 07:09PM UTC
Comment Actions
RoseyTheRabbit on Chapter 1 Wed 25 Jun 2025 09:26PM UTC
Comment Actions
Tizra_Roar on Chapter 1 Wed 25 Jun 2025 11:09PM UTC
Comment Actions
Tiloopadoo on Chapter 1 Thu 26 Jun 2025 03:25AM UTC
Comment Actions
hi (Guest) on Chapter 1 Thu 26 Jun 2025 02:08AM UTC
Comment Actions
littengamer909 on Chapter 1 Thu 26 Jun 2025 03:16AM UTC
Comment Actions
MicrowavedAutism on Chapter 2 Thu 26 Jun 2025 01:09PM UTC
Comment Actions
Tiloopadoo on Chapter 2 Thu 26 Jun 2025 01:11PM UTC
Comment Actions
FlowerRainDrops on Chapter 2 Fri 27 Jun 2025 05:01PM UTC
Comment Actions
StarWrites on Chapter 3 Fri 27 Jun 2025 03:01PM UTC
Comment Actions
RoseyTheRabbit on Chapter 3 Fri 27 Jun 2025 03:14PM UTC
Comment Actions
Rickybeat08 on Chapter 3 Fri 27 Jun 2025 08:05PM UTC
Comment Actions