Work Text:
The Grand Nexus Colosseum thrummed with a cacophony of anticipation. Beings from a thousand disparate realities filled the stands – stoic elves beside chattering robots, robed wizards next to chrome-plated cyborgs, all united by one morbid fascination: the multi-fandom death match tournament. And tonight’s main event promised a paradox of violence and whimsy.
"Llllladies and gentlemen, denizens of the multiverse!" bellowed Xylos, the Arbiter of Fates, his voice echoing from unseen speakers, "Prepare yourselves for a clash of titans, a bout of buccaneers, where only one can sail into the next round!"
A roar erupted as the first combatant materialized in the center of the obsidian arena. He strode forth with an arrogant swagger, a crimson coat flaring behind him, a feathered tricorne perched atop his dark wig. His left hand was a gleaming, wicked steel hook. His right clutched a gleaming cutlass. A snarl peeled back his lips, revealing teeth filed surprisingly sharp.
"From the treacherous shores of Neverland, the scourge of the seas, the bane of Peter Pan… Captain James Hook!"
The crowd’s cheers were tempered by a ripple of unease. Hook radiated a palpable aura of cruelty. He swept his gaze across the audience, then fixed it on the opposing entrance, his eyes glinting with hungry malice.
Then, a shimmer, and the second combatant appeared. The cheers turned into a bewildered murmur, then outright guffaws from some of the more cynical spectators.
He was a man, yes, but one seemingly crafted from primary colors and a boundless, if slightly unsettling, cheerfulness. He wore a crisp blue naval coat, white trousers, and comically oversized boots. A pristine white hat, topped with a golden 'C', sat squarely on his head, framing a neatly trimmed white mustache and a perpetually wide-eyed, innocent expression. In his hand, he held not a weapon, but a large, polished, wooden ship’s wheel, roughly the size of a dinner plate.
"And his opponent," Xylos declared, a hint of suppressed amusement in his tone, "a man who has navigated the treacherous waters of breakfast tables and defeated the dastardly Jean LaFoote… the one, the only… Cap’n Horatio Magellan Crunch!"
Hook stared. His sneer deepened into an expression of utter contempt. "A… a cereal mascot?" he spat, his voice a guttural rasp. "Is this some jest? I, Captain Hook, am to soil my blade on a sugary buffoon?"
Cap’n Crunch, despite the derision, remained unnervingly polite. He gave a slight, almost deferential bow. "Pleasure to meet you, Captain Hook, sir! Though, if I may be so bold, this seems like quite the predicament. Perhaps we could… talk this over? Share a bowl of… ah, no, wrong setting." He gestured vaguely with his ship’s wheel.
"Talk?" Hook roared, drawing his cutlass with a flourish that sent sparks flying. "There is no talk in the Nexus, you fool! Only steel and blood! And your blood, I assure you, will be quite the unappetizing color!"
The arena’s light shifted to a stark, blood-red. Xylos’s voice boomed one last time: "The rules are simple. One must die. The other emerges victorious. Let the battle… COMMENCE!"
Hook charged, a predatory gleam in his eye, his cutlass a silver blur. He moved with a speed that belied his age, a lifetime of piracy honed into lethal efficiency. Cap’n Crunch, surprisingly agile for his bulky frame, raised the ship’s wheel just in time, the flat wood deflecting the blow with a resounding clack.
"Whoa there, easy, Captain!" Crunch exclaimed, his smile faltering only slightly. "No need for such… forceful maneuvers!"
Hook snarled, pressing his attack. He feinted left, then right, his cutlass dancing around Crunch’s defenses. The Cap’n, relying on instinct and a surprising core strength, spun the wheel, using its spokes to parry, deflect, and occasionally, with an accidental thwack, land a glancing blow on Hook’s arm or shoulder. Hook, accustomed to the elegant parry and riposte of proper swordplay, found Cap’n Crunch’s blunt, almost clumsy deflections maddeningly effective.
"Stand still, you oversized breakfast item!" Hook roared, thrusting his hook hand forward, aiming for Crunch’s gut.
But Cap’n Crunch pivoted, his boots sliding on the arena floor (perhaps a hidden layer of milk?), and the hook snagged only air. He spun the wheel, not as a shield now, but as a rudimentary flail, its spokes whirring menacingly close to Hook’s head.
"Perhaps we could simply shake hands and call it a draw?" Crunch offered, ducking under a vicious horizontal slice that would have cleaved him in two. His breath hitched as the blade whistled past his hat.
"NEVER!" Hook shrieked, his face contorted with rage. This was beneath him! This colorful, saccharine dolt was making a mockery of his very existence! He lunged again, abandoning finesse for brute force, aiming to carve Crunch into sugary chunks.
Cap’n Crunch realized, with a heavy heart, that there was no talking his way out. This wasn't a skirmish over a treasure map or a stolen box of cereal. This was death. His eyes, usually wide with innocent wonder, hardened. A flicker of something primal, something born of years sailing treacherous cartoon seas, ignited within him.
He met Hook’s next furious lunge not with a parry, but with a surprising counter. As Hook committed to his swing, Crunch lowered his center of gravity, then, with a guttural roar that surprised even himself, he thrust the ship’s wheel forward, using it like a battering ram.
The heavy wooden wheel slammed into Hook’s chest just as the pirate’s cutlass came down. The blow wasn't elegant, but it was impactful. Hook gasped, his breath knocked out of him, the cutlass slicing harmlessly through Crunch’s sleeve instead of his arm. For a moment, he faltered, stunned.
That was all Cap’n Crunch needed. The cheerful smile was gone now, replaced by a grim determination. He gripped the wheel with both hands, its polished wood suddenly feeling less like a toy and more like a tool. He swung it in a wide, powerful arc, a sailor’s simple, devastating blow.
The weighted edge of the ship’s wheel connected with Captain Hook’s head with a sickening CRACK. The tricorne flew off, and the pirate’s eyes rolled up into his head. He crumpled to the ground, a limp puppet, his cutlass clattering beside him. A dark, viscous liquid, more black than red, began to seep from beneath his wig, staining the obsidian floor.
A hush fell over the Grand Nexus Colosseum. The absurdity of the combatants was momentarily forgotten, replaced by the grim reality of the outcome. A cereal mascot had killed a legendary pirate.
Cap’n Crunch stood over the prone form of Captain Hook, the ship’s wheel still clutched in his hands. His chest heaved. The clean blue coat was smudged, his hat askew. His eyes were no longer wide with innocence, but small, haunted, and weary. There was no joy, no triumph, in his victory. Only the hollow, metallic tang of an impossible choice made.
Xylos’s voice, now subdued, echoed through the silence. "Victory… to Cap’n Horatio Magellan Crunch."
The crowd erupted, not in cheers, but in a mixture of awe, horror, and a grudging respect.
Cap’n Crunch didn’t acknowledge them. He simply turned, his shoulders slumped, and walked slowly towards the exit vortex, the ship’s wheel dragging slightly on the ground. He had won. But something precious, something undeniably cheerful and innocent, had died with Captain Hook on the cold, hard floor of the Grand Nexus Colosseum. The Crunch had been served, and it was anything but sweet.