Work Text:
The October air carried the scent of cinnamon and fried dough through Stars Hollow's town square, Rory Gilmore adjusted the strap of her canvas bag and watched her five-year-old daughter dart toward the nearest booth.
"Ellie, wait up!" she called, but her daughter was already tugging on Jess Mariano's hand.
"Uncle Jess, look! They have face painting!" Ellie's pointed excitedly at a booth decorated with rainbow balloons.
Jess raised an eyebrow at Rory over Ellie's head. "Uncle Jess?"
"Don't look at me. She came up with that one herself." Rory caught up to them, slightly breathless. "You know you didn't have to come.”
"Someone has to carry your extremely heavy bag full of juice boxes and wet wipes." Jess shifted the canvas bag higher on his shoulder
The truth was more complicated, and they both knew it. Jess had been spending more time in Stars Hollow lately, supposedly helping Luke with the diner while Caesar recovered from knee surgery, but his visits had grown longer, more frequent. He'd been at Rory’s for dinner three times last week. He'd fixed Rory's leaking faucet without being asked, just noticed it dripping and dealt with it. He'd read Charlotte's Web to Ellie until she fell asleep on his lap, his voice low and steady in a way that made Rory's chest ache with something she wasn't quite ready to name.
"Please, Mama? Can I get my face painted?" Ellie's blue eyes, so much like Rory's own turned pleading.
"Sure, sweetie. What do you want to be?"
"A dragon!"
Jess snorted. "Of course you do."
Twenty minutes later, Ellie sported scales and whiskers across her cheeks, and they'd barely made it ten feet before Lorelai intercepted them near the cotton candy stand.
"Well, well, well. If it isn't Stars Hollow's cutest little family unit." Lorelai's grin was pure mischief as she looked between Jess and Rory, but there was something warmer underneath it now. Something that hadn't been there twenty years ago.
"Mom…"
"I'm just saying what everyone's thinking. You three have been practically inseparable lately. Miss Patty has started a betting pool."
"There's a betting pool?" Rory's voice pitched higher.
"On when you two will make it official. I put twenty bucks on Halloween. Seemed thematic." Lorelai plucked a piece of cotton candy from the cone in her hand, then looked at Jess directly. "For what it's worth, I'm rooting for you this time..."
"Mom!" Rory started, mortified.
"What? I'm being nice! I'm saying I approve! This is me approving!" Lorelai grinned. "Kirk bet on Christmas, but he always goes for the obvious sentiment. I've got faith in you two not being total idiots about this for too much longer."
Ellie, oblivious to the subtext, was already pulling them toward the game booths. "Come on! I want to see the toys!"
"Run while you can!" Lorelai called after them. "But you can't hide from true love! Believe me, I tried!"
They walked in silence for a moment, navigating around clusters of townspeople. Rory snuck a glance at Jess, contemplating the ways time has changed him. The sharp edges had softened somehow, though he still had that intensity in his eyes when he looked at her. But now there was patience there too, a groundedness that seventeen-year-old Jess could never have managed.
She remembered that boy, brilliant and angry and so scared to count on anyone. The Jess who'd left without saying goodbye and picked fights with Dean. The Jess who'd showed up at Yale and asked her to run away, and the boy who helped her find herself again.
This Jess was different. This Jess had called last Tuesday to ask if Ellie wanted him to pick up a specific book she'd mentioned. This Jess stayed for the boring parts, helping with dishes, sitting through Ellie's endless questions about why the sky was blue, working breakfast shifts at Luke's without complaint. This Jess didn't run.
"Sorry about that," Rory said quietly. "My mom being intense."
"It was nice though, " Jess's voice was careful. “Different.”
"It is.” And it was. Her biggest regret about her relationship with Jess, was how her mother had acted about it all. But Jess was no longer that boy that her mother disliked, she'd watched him transform over the years, through awkward encounters and long stretches of silence, and the way he'd slowly, carefully worked his way back into her life. Not demanding anything, just... present. Available. Safe.
Safe. That was the word she kept coming back to. Jess Mariano made her feel safe now, which would have seemed impossible twenty years ago.
"Look, Mama!" Ellie pointed at a booth festooned with enormous stuffed animals. "I want the purple dragon!"
The prize in question hung from the ceiling, easily three feet tall and gloriously ridiculous. Rory squinted at the sign: "Ring Toss - Three rings for $5."
"Those games are rigged," Jess said immediately, “The rings are barely wider than the bottles."
"Scared?" Rory couldn't resist.
"Of wasting money on a mathematically improbable outcome? Yes. But if you want me to try, I'll try."
"Please, Uncle Jess?" Ellie grabbed his hand with both of hers. "You could win it!"
"Kid, I appreciate your faith in me, but…"
"What's the matter, Mariano?" Rory stepped closer, "Afraid you'll lose?"
His eyes narrowed, but he was fighting a smile. "I know what you're doing."
"I'm not doing anything. I'm just pointing out that you're refusing to even try." She was enjoying this, the familiar dance of their banter. "Very unlike the guy who once fought a swan."
“Not sure it was as much a fight as an unprovoked attack,” Jess's expression shifted to something between amusement and exasperation. "You're never going to let me live that down, are you?"
"Nope." Rory crossed her arms, the challenge in her voice unmistakable. "Double or nothing, if you win, I'll stop teasing you about being scared of carnival games. If you lose, you have to enter Jackson's pie-eating contest."
"That's not double or nothing, that's just…"
"Double or nothing! Double or nothing!" Ellie started chanting, bouncing on her toes.
"Fine. But when I fail spectacularly, I'm blaming both of you."
He handed over five dollars to Kirk, who was manning the booth with military precision.
"Three rings," Kirk announced. "Land all three on bottles to win the grand prize. Land two for a medium prize. Land one for a small prize. No prizes for zero successful tosses."
"Thanks for that breakdown, Kirk. Really clarified things."
But there was no real bite to it. Jess picked up the first ring, testing its weight. He lined up his shot. The ring sailed through the air and bounced off a bottle with a hollow clank.
Ellie groaned. Rory pressed her lips together to keep from laughing.
"Physics is harder in practice," Jess muttered, picking up the second ring.
This one hit the rim of a bottle and spun off. The third didn't even come close.
"Tough luck!" Kirk said cheerfully. "Would you like to try again? Perhaps with a better understanding of parabolic motion?"
Rory was openly grinning now. "So about that pie-eating contest…"
"Double or nothing," Jess said.
"What?"
He pulled out another five dollars, and there was something in his expression, determined but not angry, focused. "Double or nothing. I win, you have to admit I'm actually good at things. I lose, I'll do the pie contest, and you can lord it over me for the rest of the day."
"Deal." Rory stuck out her hand, and when Jess shook it, his grip was warm and sure and sent electricity up her arm.
This time, he approached it differently. He took his time, studied the angles, adjusted his stance. No rushing, no frustration. Just patience. The first ring landed with a satisfying thunk around a bottle neck.
Ellie squealed. "You did it!"
"Two more," Jess said, more to himself than anyone else.
The second ring followed the first, landing true. Rory found herself holding her breath as Jess lined up the final shot. The ring arced through the air and…
Perfect.
"Winner!" Kirk declared, hauling down the purple dragon with both arms. "Congratulations on your mastery of carnival physics!"
Ellie launched herself at Jess, who caught her with an oof of surprise, and the look on his face, surprised joy mixed with something tender made Rory's eyes sting with unexpected emotion.
"You won! You won the dragon!" Ellie's arms wrapped around his neck.
"Yeah, well." Jess handed her the enormous stuffed animal, which was nearly as big as she was. "Beginner's luck. Or possibly just physics."
But Rory saw the way his expression softened when Ellie hugged him tight, dragon and all. She saw him rest his hand on her daughter's head, protective and gentle. And she felt something shift in her chest, a door opening that she'd thought she'd locked years ago. Because this wasn't the boy who'd broken her heart by leaving. This was a man who stayed, who showed up, who was here in every way that mattered.
"I told you I'm good at things," Jess said to Rory, but his voice was quieter now, almost uncertain, like he still needed her approval, still cared what she thought, but was willing to wait for it.
"You did," she agreed, her throat tight. "Though I think you still like being dared."
"Only by people who know which buttons to push." His eyes held hers. "And only when it matters."
They stood there, looking at each other while Ellie named her dragon ("Professor Scales the Third"), and Rory thought about how many times they'd done this dance, challenged each other, pushed each other, circled around what they actually meant. The difference was that now, she wanted to stop circling.
Before she could say anything, Miss Patty descended upon them like a theatrical hurricane.
"Jess Mariano! I heard you were in town and staying in town quite frequently, I might add!" She looked him up and down approvingly. "Still devastatingly handsome, I see. Though you've gotten more distinguished. Very silver fox in training. And playing daddy to Rory's little one! How modern!"
"We're not…" Rory started.
"Just friends," Jess finished, but it sounded hollow even to his own ears.
"Mm-hmm." Miss Patty winked. "That's what they all say, dear. But I've seen you three together. I've seen the way you look at them when you think no one's watching. That's not 'just friends.'" She leaned in conspiratorially. " I'm rooting for you. We all are."
She swept away, leaving a different kind of awkwardness in her wake, not embarrassment exactly, but the weight of truth spoken aloud.
"We should keep moving," Rory said, but her voice was unsteady. "Before anyone else comments on how we look like a family."
"Do we?" Jess asked quietly.
Rory's breath caught. "Do we what?"
"Look like a family."
She glanced at Ellie, who was dragging her dragon through the grass, chattering to it about all the festival booths they'd visit. She thought about the three of them at her kitchen table every morning this week, Jess helping Ellie with her alphabet while Rory graded papers. She thought about how Jess had learned to make Ellie's favorite pancakes, how he'd installed a nightlight in her room without being asked, how he'd been there for every small crisis and celebration.
She thought about how different this was from everything that had come before. The boy who loved her, but never enough to stay. The boy who never thought things through, who’d wanted her to run away with him even though they’d barely spoken in a year. The boy who showed up with a book so beautiful that it had taken her breath away, who’d looked at her and seen the girl she’d thought was lost forever.
But this Jess, he was different to even that boy. He’d grown up. Didn’t expect or want anything that Rory wasn’t ready to give. He had learned that love wasn't about grand gestures or running away together. It was about showing up for the small moments, the boring Tuesdays, the tantrums and the homework and the endless requests for one more story before bed. It was about helping Luke at the diner without complaint, about learning the rhythms of a town he'd once hated, about choosing to be here.
"Maybe," she admitted, her voice barely above a whisper. "Maybe we do."
Jess nodded slowly, something vulnerable crossing his face. "Would that be so bad?"
"No," Rory said, and realized she meant it. "It wouldn't be bad at all."
Ellie was back, grabbing both their hands to drag them toward the pumpkin display, and Rory realized her hand was still in Jess's even after Ellie had run ahead. She should let go, probably.
She didn't let go. Neither did he.
The afternoon unspooled in a series of small-town moments that felt both absurd and perfect. Taylor lectured them about proper festival etiquette when Ellie accidentally knocked over a display of gourds, but even he seemed charmed when Jess patiently helped her rebuild it. Kirk tried to recruit Jess for his Revolutionary War reenactment ("You have the bone structure of a young Benedict Arnold!"), and instead of getting defensive or sarcastic, Jess just declined politely and moved on.
Luke appeared with a tray of diner samples, mini burgers and fries in paper boats. "How's it going?"
"Uncle Jess won me a dragon!" Ellie announced proudly, holding up Professor Scales.
"Did he now?" Luke's eyes flickered between Jess and Rory, and something knowing passed over his face. "Well, that's... that's good.”
After Luke left, they continued wandering. Lane waved from the stall she was helping run, giving Rory an extremely unsubtle thumbs-up. Through it all, Jess stayed close, trading barbs with her in that old rhythm, quick, sharp, familiar but gentler now.
He bought Ellie an apple cider without complaint. He won her a goldfish at the ping-pong toss despite his earlier protests about the ethics of carnival animals ("This is how it starts," he muttered. "First a goldfish, next thing you know we're building a whole aquarium"). He hoisted her onto his shoulders when she couldn't see the pie-judging contest, and when she shrieked with delight, Rory saw him smile, really smile, unguarded and happy.
"You're good at this," Rory said as they paused near the gazebo, watching Ellie run in circles with a group of other kids.
"At what? Succumbing to the whims of a five-year-old?"
"At being here. At being..." She gestured vaguely, trying to find the words. "Present. Patient. Good with her. Good for her."
Jess shoved his hands in his pockets, eyes following Ellie. "She makes it easy. She just... she says what she wants, what she needs. No games, no hidden meanings. It's refreshing."
Unlike me, Rory thought but didn't say. Unlike all the complicated history between us.
"Still," she pressed. "You didn't have to come back to help Luke. You have a business to run in Philadelphia. You don't have to keep coming back."
"I know." He turned to look at her, and the intensity in his gaze reminded her of every important moment they'd ever shared. But there was none of the desperation now, none of the barely controlled chaos. Just steady certainty. "But I want to. That's the difference, Rory. I'm not here because I have to prove something or because I can't figure out what else to do with myself. I'm here because this is where I want to be."
"Even though it's Stars Hollow? The place you hated with your whole being when you were seventeen?”
"I'm not that kid anymore. I know what matters now. And watching Ellie with that dragon, seeing you smile when you think I'm not looking, helping Luke with the morning rush and listening to Miss Patty's stories and even dealing with Taylor's nonsense, that matters more than whatever pain I went through when I was seventeen." Jess's voice was quiet but firm.
Rory's throat felt tight. "Jess…"
"I'm not saying I have it all figured out," he interrupted. "I'm still working out how to balance Truncheon with being here more. But I'm trying, Rory. I'm actually trying this time, to be better. To be someone you and Ellie can count on.”
Before Rory could respond, Ellie collapsed in the grass nearby, clearly exhausted despite her protests. The sun was starting to set, painting the town square in shades of amber and rose.
"I think someone's hit her limit," Jess observed.
"Yeah. We should probably head home."
They collected Ellie, who insisted on carrying both Professor Scales and her goldfish (in its plastic bag), though she was clearly dead on her feet. By the time they'd walked the three blocks to Rory's house, Ellie had fallen asleep in Rory's arms, her head on her mother's shoulder, her face still decorated with dragon scales.
"Here, let me," Jess said, carefully extracting the dragon and fish from Ellie's grip so Rory could shift her more comfortably. He held the door open, then followed them inside.
The house was quiet and dim. Rory carried Ellie straight to her room and tucked her into bed, dragon tucked beside her. She paused for a moment, brushing curls away from her daughter's face, struck by how much her life had changed. Five years ago, she couldn't have imagined this, single mom in Stars Hollow, exactly where she'd sworn she'd never end up.
But she also couldn't have imagined Jess, steady and patient and here in ways that mattered.
When she came back out, Jess was in the kitchen, setting up the goldfish bowl he must have found in the cabinet. He'd already filled it with water and was carefully transferring the fish.
"You don't have to do that," Rory said softly.
"I know. But Ellie will want to see it when she wakes up. Kid's going to need a whole aquarium at this rate." He smiled slightly. "We might have gone overboard with the carnival games."
"We might have?"
"Fine. I might have. But you kept saying 'double or nothing.' Several times."
Rory moved into the kitchen, leaning against the counter. "Thank you. For today. For coming. For winning the dragon and the fish and being so patient with her. For... for everything, really."
"You don't have to keep thanking me for spending time with you guys."
"I know I don't have to. I want to." She took a breath, feeling like she was standing on the edge of something important. "You've been showing up, Jess. Really showing up. For both of us. Helping Luke so you'd have an excuse to be in town more, learning Ellie's favorite foods, fixing things around here without me asking. More than anyone. More than I expected or probably deserved, given our history."
"Rory…"
"Let me finish." Her hands twisted together. "My life is messy and complicated. Single mom in Stars Hollow, exactly where I swore I'd never end up. Teaching at Chilton, writing freelance articles, still working on that second book, raising a kid alone. It's not exactly the life I dreamed about when I was young."
"Is it the life you want now?" Jess asked quietly.
Rory considered that. "Yeah. It is. It's not perfect, and it's not what I planned, but it's mine. Ellie's amazing, and I'm doing work that matters, and I'm... I'm okay. Better than okay, actually."
"You're more than okay. You're incredible." Jess said it simply, like it was obvious fact. "You're raising an amazing kid; you're teaching the next generation. The fact that it doesn't look like what you imagined doesn't make it less."
"That's what I'm trying to say, though. You get that now. You see my life as it actually is, not as some fantasy or obstacle. And you've been here for it anyway. For the boring parts, the hard parts, the parts that aren't romantic or exciting. Morning shifts at Luke's, helping with homework, all of it."
Jess stepped closer, his expression serious. "Did you think I was here out of obligation? Or guilt? Or because I felt sorry for you?"
"I didn't know. I thought maybe…"
"No." He said it firmly. "I'm not here because I feel sorry for you, Rory. I'm here because I never stopped…" He paused, searching for words. "I never stopped caring about you. About what happens to you, about your happiness. And then there's Ellie, and she's incredible, and being around both of you feels like…" He stopped, frustrated with his inability to articulate it. "It feels right. Like the life I was supposed to have been working toward all along, I just didn't know it."
Rory's heart was pounding. "Why didn't you say anything before? These past few months?"
"Because I didn't want to mess it up again. Push too hard, too fast, demand something you weren't ready to give. I've done that enough times." His voice went quiet. "I figured if I just kept showing up, kept being here, maybe eventually you'd see that I wasn't going anywhere. That I've changed.”
"I never needed you to change, just stop being so scared. And you have, I can see that. I have seen it. The way you are with Ellie, so patient, so present. The way you just... fit into our routine without making it about you. The way you fixed my faucet without being asked, and learned to make her favorite pancakes, and remembered that she likes the blue cup better than the red one."
"The blue cup is objectively better. It has better weight distribution."
Rory laughed again, but her eyes were bright with unshed tears. "See? That's what I mean. You care about the details. The small stuff. You're not trying to sweep us into some grand adventure. You're just... here. And it feels safe. You feel safe, Jess. That's new."
Something flickered in his eyes, surprise, maybe, or vulnerability. "Safe?"
"Yeah. Safe." She moved closer, closing the distance between them. "When we were younger, you felt like chaos. Exciting, brilliant chaos, but chaos all the same. I never knew if you were going to kiss me or disappear. Show up at Yale or vanish for months."
"Rory, I'm sorry…"
"I'm not trying to rehash old fights. I'm trying to tell you that now it's different. Now when I look at you, I don't feel that anxious uncertainty. I feel like you're solid ground. Like you're someone I can count on, someone who'll be there tomorrow and the day after that. Someone who's chosen to be in our lives, not because you need to prove something or because you're running from something else, but because you actually want to be here."
Jess reached up, carefully tucking a strand of hair behind her ear. His hand lingered near her face, and Rory found herself leaning into the touch.
"I do want to be here," he said. "More than I've wanted anything in a long time. But I didn't want to assume, I didn't want to push my way into your life or make you feel like you owed me anything because I've been around."
"You're not pushing. I'm asking." Rory's voice dropped to barely above a whisper. "I'm asking you to stay. Not just for today or this week but really stay. Be part of this; this life Ellie and I have built. If you want that. If that's not too boring or too Stars Hollow or too…"
She didn't get to finish because Jess kissed her.
It was soft at first, tentative, like they were both afraid of breaking something precious. His hands framed her face, gentle, and Rory's hands found his shoulders, fingers curling into his jacket. Then she pulled him closer, and the kiss deepened, years of history and longing and finally, finally being ready at the same time pouring into it.
It felt like coming home and starting something new all at once, familiar and thrilling and right in a way that made her wonder why they'd waited so long. Made her grateful that they had, because they wouldn't have been ready for this five years ago, or ten, or twenty. They'd needed to become these people first, her a mother finding her footing, him a man who'd learned patience and commitment and how to stay.
When they finally broke apart, both slightly breathless, Jess rested his forehead against hers.
"I'm staying," he said. "For the record. I'm staying for all of it, the boring Tuesdays, the terrible town meetings, Kirk's insane schemes, Luke's early morning shifts. All of it."
"Good. Because Ellie would never forgive me if I let you leave now. She's pretty attached to her Uncle Jess."
"Just Ellie?"
Rory smiled, her hands still on his shoulders, feeling the warmth of him, the solidness. "She's not the only one."
"So, what do you say?" Jess asked softly, echoing her earlier dare with a small smile. "Double or nothing?"
Rory's breath caught at the callback, at what he was really asking. Not just about carnival games or silly bets, but about them. About taking the risk, going all in, betting on a future together.
"Double or nothing," she agreed, and kissed him again.
From Ellie's room, they heard a sleepy voice call out: "Mama?"
Rory sighed but couldn't stop smiling. "Duty calls."
"I'll be here when you're done," Jess promised, and that simple statement felt more meaningful than any grand declaration.
Ellie had just kicked off her blankets and needed to be tucked back in. She stirred when Rory adjusted Professor Scales beside her.
"Did Uncle Jess leave?" Ellie mumbled, still half-asleep.
"No, sweetie. He's still here."
"Good. I like when he's here." Ellie snuggled deeper into her pillow. "He should stay always."
"Maybe he will," Rory whispered, pressing a kiss to her daughter's forehead.
When she returned to the living room, Jess was examining the books on her shelf, and the sight of him there, comfortable, belonging made her chest feel full.
"She okay?" he asked.
"She's perfect. Asked if you'd left."
"What'd you tell her?"
"That you're still here." Rory moved to the couch, and Jess joined her without hesitation. She curled into his side, fitting against him like they'd been doing this for years. "We should probably talk about this. About what it means, how we explain it to Ellie, logistics..."
"We will," Jess agreed, his arm around her shoulders. "But maybe not tonight. Tonight can we just…"
"Be here?"
"Yeah."
So, they sat in the quiet cottage, Rory's head on Jess's shoulder, his fingers tracing absent patterns on her arm. Through the window, the last light of the festival glowed in the distance. Somewhere, townspeople were definitely already gossiping about them, probably already planning their wedding. Miss Patty was probably already choreographing their first dance.
Rory found she didn't care. For the first time in years, maybe ever, she felt certain about something. About someone. About the fact that this man, this version of Jess Mariano who'd learned patience and commitment and how to love without chaos, was exactly who she wanted beside her.
Later, after they'd talked for hours about logistics and feelings and how to navigate this new territory, after Jess had checked on Ellie one more time before leaving (and looked so natural doing it that Rory's heart ached), he paused at the door.
"Same time tomorrow?" he asked. "I'm covering breakfast at Luke's, but after that, Ellie mentioned something about wanting to teach me how to play her favorite board game."
"You know it's going to be intensely complicated with rules she makes up as she goes, right?"
"I expect nothing less." He kissed her again, soft and sweet. "See you tomorrow, Rory."
"See you tomorrow."
After he left, Rory stood in her doorway for a long moment, watching his taillights disappear down the street. Then she went back inside, checked on Ellie one more time, and crawled into bed with a smile on her face.
For once, she was ready to take the bet.
Double or nothing.
The whole future.