Chapter 1: An Unexpected Arrival
Notes:
I just want more stories in which Ben is happy and gets laid more than any other character in the show. Is that too much to ask? This is a slow burn, but get ready for it to become absolutely unhinged. You've been warned.
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
Life has been nothing but one long, continuous scream, so it's only natural a woman's blood-curdling scream is the first thing I hear when I jolt awake.
My thumping heartbeat races wildly out of control as I reach for the knife I keep under my pillow, only for warm sand to sift through my fingers. Sand? I struggle to piece together my surroundings as I scoot myself into a sitting position. I was curled up on my tiny apartment bed when I dosed off not too long ago, and now I'm lying on a beach.
I sit in a confused stupor as the world around me carries on in complete chaos. Men and women run screaming in all directions, their words blurring together in disharmony.
The man nearest me bellows, "WALT!"
I'm suddenly more awake than I've ever been before in my life, and I push my aching body to my feet, stumbling half blind in the general direction of the screaming mob. Behind us a massive whirling plane engine belches out thick black smoke that causes bursts of air to fling sand around. I have to cover my eyes to keep from going blind.
A nightmare. I'm having a nightmare.
My foot gets caught on a chunk of debris, and I stumble forward onto my hands and knees.
A pair of strong arms hoist me up, and I can already feel the bruises forming from his grip. A man's gruff voice is in my ear, yelling, "Get up! Move!" I try to use my legs, but suddenly I'm flying, weightless, crashing down hard on my back as debris rains down around me.
I can't move. I can't breathe. I'm powerless to stop my vision from tunneling. It flashes back to the forefront in a bright blinding light that makes me squint. I can no longer hear the noise around me over the deafening ringing in my ears.
Am I dead?
Somehow I manage to roll my stiff neck to the right and lock eyes with a man staring right at me. Only, he's not. He's dead.
I roll my head to the left and see the ocean. I watch, transfixed, as it crashes against the shore over and over again with a frothy abandon. A young woman kneels in the sand beside me, sobbing.
When I wake up, the sun has disappeared. Someone built a roaring fire and dragged me near it. I scoot away from its heat.
I can move my arms. I can move my legs!
I could cry from relief. That's when I notice that multiple fires have been lit all along the beach. People sit hunched near the flames, talking quietly amongst themselves and checking each other for injuries.
"The princess has awoken." Sawyer stands next to my fire, a lazy smirk on his lips as he lights a cigarette and takes a long drag. "You're pretty busted up, Buttercup."
I have no idea what he's talking about. I have no idea where I am. I have no idea why a fictional character is talking to me.
Boone squats down and reaches towards me to offer what looks like gauze, but it might just be the remnants of someone's t-shirt. I stop mid-frown when a sharp pain bolts through my skull. I reach up and gently tap the spot that burns like a hot poker. When I pull my hand away, my fingers are covered in blood.
"May I be excused?" I raise my hand, finding my voice at last. "I need to go to the nurses office, please."
"Hey, guys, I don't think she's okay," Boone says to some random man sitting across the campfire.
"Yeah," Sawyer interjects, "well, last I checked, none of us were doing okay, bucko. What do you want me to do about it?"
"Here, honey." An elderly woman offers a bottle of water. "You'll be alright. Just need to make sure you hydrate."
I blink rapidly at them all, fighting a growing pain in my midsection. There's a question forming on my tongue, but it's quickly drowned out by another and another and another until my chest constricts my useless dry lungs and no amount of trying can help bring my brain the air it needs to think properly.
"Doctor, over here," I hear the old woman shout before it all fades to grey. I'm too hot, too cold, too tired to care.
I wake up the next morning fully expecting to find myself wrapped too tightly in my bedsheets, safe and sound in my apartment, surrounded by junk food and sweat. Instead, I wake up and find myself sleeping in sand, gauze wrapped tightly around my head, my clothes absolutely reeking of campfire smoke.
After asking Rose where we're supposed to use the bathroom, I grab one of the salvaged roles of toilet paper and head into the jungle, just beyond the treeline. Then, I trek a little deeper because the last thing I want is to be too close to the beach and have someone interrupt me while I pee.
I'm almost finished when a snapping of brush sounds from behind me, but when I spin around, there's nobody there. I'm a sitting duck. Don't panic. Just get back to the beach. I take a steading breath and break out into a sprint in the direction of the beach, bursting through the trees, and abruptly crashing into a man so hard my vision goes white.
"I'm sorry," he says. "I'm so sorry! Are you okay?"
I groan in pain and look up into the worried face of Charlie Pace. "Yeah," I mumble, already hurrying away towards the main crowd. "I'm fine."
As I sit in the sand and watch people dig through luggage, I pinch myself multiple times, and the pain feels real. The pulsing wound on my forehead feels real. I don't understand.
I can clearly see Sun and Jin just down the shore. Jin is digging around in the ocean for edible sea creatures. Wait, when did that happen? Episode 1? 2? 3? I can't remember…
The gash on my head begins to throb painfully, so I push my aching body to my feet and wobble my way through camp in search of Jack.
Instead, I find Sawyer. "Stop leaking blood all over my beach, Doublemint," he jabs playfully. "If you're looking for the Doc, he headed off that way."
"Doublemint?" I look up, confused, and notice that he's chewing gum.
He pulls out a pack and shakes it in the air. "Found this in your pocket last night."
Even through the dizziness I can feel embarrassment flaring up. I want to say something witty, but I'm too tired to think. I frown in his general direction before continuing my slow shuffle in search of Jack. “You pickpocketed an unconscious girl?”
I don't have time for this. Something is obviously wrong with my mind. Maybe I'm in a coma? Maybe I'm in a psych ward, and all these people are just patients that my mind has twisted to appease the fangirl within? Whatever the case may be, I'm tired of it.
I turn to head in the direction Sawyer pointed, hoping that Jack will know what to do to help clear the half-formed thoughts in my head, when I notice a figure standing in the trees. A woman. Only a sliver of her is visible, and only for a split second, before she disappears into the jungle.
If someone back home were to tell me that I would be spending the rest of my life trapped in some sort of parallel dimension with a group of fictional characters on an island that doesn't exist . . . I would have scheduled them an appointment with a psychiatrist.
But here I am—an unexplained anomaly existing within a fictional realm of incomprehensible implausibility.
“Please try to limit movement," Jack tells me as he finishes tying a fresh bandage around my skull. "Your forehead is healing remarkably well, but you may still feel dizzy for the next few days. Probably best if you take it easy for a while."
"Okay," I answer. "Has anyone found any–" It's hard to think again, and the question I wanted to ask is gone. “Any…” I pinch my fingers a few inches apart and shake, miming the word that’s on the tip of my tongue.
"Medicine?"
I nod, instantly regretting the movement and the pain it brings. Yes, medicine. That's what I was thinking of.
"Haven't found anything yet, but we're sifting through luggage as fast as we can." Jack takes a look around the makeshift tent I'm squeezed under. I can read pity in his eyes. "I need to attend to the other survivors. Have someone come find me if you feel especially nauseous. Or," he adds, "start to lose your vision."
"Lose my vision?" What little nausea had subsided comes rushing back until I feel so faint I worry I'm about to pass out.
"I wouldn't worry," Jack says, quick to placate my panic. "You seem to be healing just fine. Hey, excuse me–" I look over at the person he's addressing and air gets stuck in my throat. "This is Cora. Can you check in with her and let me know if she needs anything? I've got to make the rounds."
How does Jack know my name? When did I tell him my name?
"Yeah, no problem," Ethan replies happily, all smiles. "Anything to help. Hi," he says, addressing me with an outstretched hand, "name's Ethan."
"Cora." I reach for his hand on autopilot, struggling to smile over the sudden rush of memories. This man is Ethan, the Other who kidnaps Claire, hangs Charlie, and is eventually shot in the chest by one of the survivors. I remember.
It's this moment that brings me back to reality. I'm in danger. I don't know how, but I seem to be in the beginnings of my favorite TV show. A show notorious for random deaths. I begin to remember all the characters who will die in the coming days, weeks, months and blanche at the thought that I can so easily be one of them.
"You okay?" Ethan asks wearily. "You're shaking."
I'm still gripping his hand, having never let go of our handshake, so I quickly pull away. "Sorry."
"No worries. We're all a little out of sorts at the moment." I watch as Ethan's expression morphs from a casual smile to a brief pensive stare before his lips pull back up into a much less enthusiastic grin. "How's your head?"
"It hurts," I answer honestly. "But Jack seems to think I'll live."
He nods, his eyes traveling the length of my face. After what seems like forever, he asks, "You were on this plane?"
I'm struck by such an odd question. As I struggle to focus, my hairline breaks out in a sweat as I realize why he asked it.
My name is not in the manifest.
"No, I just fell out of the sky like rain," I say, huffing a nervous laugh. When Ethan glances up in confusion, like he's actually considering the possibility of my sarcasm, it takes all my concentration not to choke on my words. "Yes," I deadpan. "I was on this plane. Why do you ask?"
"Checking to make sure your mind isn't slipping away," he answers quickly. "Gotta keep the brain active, right? You remember where you're from?"
"Los Angeles," I answer truthfully. "Where are you from?"
"Canada," he replies automatically. “So, Cora from California, huh?"
He stares at me for an ungodly amount of time before I offer up an awkward, "Yep."
"Guess you're pretty familiar with beaches, then. So, that's good." Ethan keeps eyeing different parts of my body, but it's not like he's checking me out. It's more like he's looking for something. "You have any tattoos?"
Is it normal to ask someone that? The absurdity of his question makes me want to laugh. In fact, the urge to laugh hysterically is starting to overpower all other sensations. "No, I'm afraid of needles."
"What's Cora from California's last name?" He's smiling again, but I can tell he doesn't mean it.
I think about lying, but I honestly don't trust myself to remember my own lie. "Collins, officer. Am I being arrested?"
He doesn't laugh. "What year were you born?"
"You know what, I think I'll just wait for the real doctor to assess my memory, thanks." I glance around, taking note of the closest people in case I need to call for help.
"I'm a real doctor."
"Okay." I huff out a laugh, but I can feel the shaking in my chest summoning more. "I think I'm good, thanks."
It's bad enough my social awkwardness makes it near impossible to interact normally with other human beings. But to top it all off, I'm a nervous laugher, which basically means that nine out of ten times if something upsets me I'll start laughing instead of crying. It usually plagues me at the absolute worst, most inappropriate of times. Like right now.
Ethan regards me with an air of confusion. "What's so funny?"
Like a heaven-sent angel, Hugo approaches. "You dudes hungry?"
A relieved grin pulls at my lips. "Yes, thank you so much."
"Oh, hey! You're awake! How's your, uh," Hugo reaches up and taps his forehead.
"Hurts like the Dickens," I answer, desperate for him to see the plea for help in my eyes. "But Jack says I'll live, and I'm kinda holding him to that."
"Cool, cool. So, uh, do you want chicken or beef? They're day old airline enchiladas, so try not to be too disappointed."
I laugh and take a chicken tray. "Thanks."
"So I know you've been, like, kinda unconscious these past few days, but … I mean, the bright side is we're all equally screwed, right?"
"Thank you for the optimism." It dawns on me that Hugo hasn't offered Ethan any food. When I turn to check, he's nowhere to be found.
As the day drags on, I grow bored. Life in early Season 1 isn't exactly as exciting as I pictured it would be. Not without all the editing out of menial tasks the survivors must do. It also doesn't help that everyone is so wrapped up in their own problems that they can't be bothered with mine. I've maybe spoken to two survivors all day, none of them the core cast.
Luckily, before I go crazy enough to do something embarrassing, Jack seeks me out to check my bandage. He unwraps my forehead and I watch his face fill with surprise or confusion, I can't quite tell.
"Is it getting worse?"
"No, actually," he says slowly. "It's…you've completely scabbed."
"That's good though?" Of course I know it's good. But the look on his face makes me think I've developed gangrene.
"Good, yes. Just unusual." Jack leans away, resting his hands idly at his sides. "Two days ago, this laceration needed numerous stitches. Now it's completely sealed. Should have taken a week, at best." He leans back in, frowning in thought as he assesses the wound. "It doesn't even look like it will scar."
"So," I notice I'm shaking and tighten my fists. "You don't think I need antibiotics?"
"Not at the rate you're healing." He shakes his head, smiling. "I'm going to ask you a few questions to check your memory. It would be better if I could give you a PET Scan, just to be sure, but unfortunately I don't see that happening anytime soon."
"Okay."
"Do you know what year it is?"
I open my mouth to answer 2014, but I catch myself just in time. It's not 2014 in this reality. I can't remember when LOST takes place. It's the early 2000's, I just can't remember the exact year.
"Uh," I stammer, making a best guess. "I…uh, 2003?"
Jack blinks, his eyes looking down and away at something before looking back at me. "No, I'm afraid you're missing a year. It's 2004."
"Oh."
"Do you remember your birthday?"
"December 19, 1994."
He gives me another worried look. "Are you sure?"
I pause, realizing the math makes no sense from his perspective. I don't know how to make the math make sense, so I sit in silence.
"You're 10 years old?" he asks.
"No." I can feel my face reddening. "No, I'm not 10 years old."
"Hey," Jack says, reaching out to pat my shoulder. "Don't get discouraged. There's a high probability your amnesia will lift completely. Just give it some time. Don't force it. It'll only frustrate you."
"Sydney, Australia," I blurt out, desperate for him to not think I'm a damn fool. "Oceanic 815 was taking off from Sydney, Australia."
"See? You still have some short term working great. That's a start." He's all encouraging smiles, but it ends up making me feel like a patronized child. "Were you traveling alone?"
I look up at this. "What?"
"Did you have anyone with you on the flight? Family? A partner?"
My family. Are they here? Were they on the plane, too?
My mother. My sisters. My brother. If they're here, I haven't seen them. I try to push myself to my feet, but Jack rests a hand on my shoulder.
"Easy," he urges. "You need to take it easy."
"No, I need to find my family." Standing makes me nauseous beyond belief, and to my horror I bend forward and projectile vomit all over the front of Jack's shirt.
"I'm sorry," I groan.
"No, it's okay."
"I'm so sorry," I repeat, turning away to cough up another mouthful of bile.
"Don't worry about it. Just, please lay back down."
Everyone within earshot is staring at me. I hate it. I hate being the center of attention. I hate it more than anything I can think of. Too embarrassed to complain, I lie back down on my blanket in the sand.
Nobody talks to me for the rest of the day.
Hugo makes his rounds at night and distributes the last remaining pieces of food—some papayas and airline peanuts.
"Tonight we feast like kings," I tell him, holding up the pathetic portion of food.
He smiles, but doesn't stay to chat. He's probably afraid I'll vomit on him.
If Hugo doesn't even want to be around me, I'm in serious trouble. I search the wreckage for a reasonably sized sharp piece of metal and cling to it as I go to sleep with the goal of using tomorrow to make some friends.
I wake up right before sunrise to find Ethan sitting cross-legged beside me, one of his hands brushing lightly through my hair.
Notes:
Ben reveal in the next chapter! Let’s get spicy, baby.
Comments are my main motivating factor, if you are so inclined :)
Chapter 2: Take What You Want
Chapter Text
I scream and scream and scream, terrified by Ethan’s closeness.
"Sorry," he says, wincing and holding out a hand in surrender. I watch as he tries to secretly pocket a few strands of my hair. "I've been waiting for you to wake up."
"Did you just take some of my hair? Did you seriously just take some of my hair?"
"No," he answers too quickly.
“Get away from me,” I lash out and slice his hand with the metal wreckage I fell asleep with. “Help! Somebody help!”
"Why did you do that?" he asks, glancing down at the bloody gash in his hand. Ethan's face morphs from confusion to annoyance as he scoots closer, desperately shushing me, telling me he has antibiotics, but I just keep screaming and trying to stab him with the metal.
When two people I’ve never seen before confront him, he dismisses them with an exhausted, “She’s being hysterical! She just stabbed me!”
I’m up and staggering through the sand in search of somewhere safe. Somewhere far away from the trees. Jack approaches, looking worried after all my screaming. I aggressively swipe at my nose and point a trembling hand behind me. “Keep him away from me!”
I make myself scarce, huddled inside the wreckage, still clinging to the metal now coated in Ethan's blood.
My stomach rumbles painfully. I’m not used to being hungry. My mother was always feeding anyone and everyone who came into our house. It was a big part of her Italian upbringing. I had a measly papaya for breakfast and it’s almost midday.
Despite my hunger, I remain hidden, listening for the familiar sounds of family. Part of me hopes they aren’t here, so I won't have to worry about something bad happening to them. But another part of me, the selfish part, hopes I’m not here alone.
It's been over a year since I could afford a plane ticket home. I made the mistake of going to a graduate school as far away from Los Angeles as possible, in an attempt to distance myself from my parents. Unfortunately, staying away from my parents meant staying away from my siblings.
I never should have left them behind. I should have picked a state school so I'd always be nearby. I left home, and now I'll never see them again. What is wrong with me?
I grip the metal so tight, blood drips down my arm. For the first time in a very, very long time I don't laugh the pain away. I curl into myself and I begin to cry.
I wake up the next morning exhausted. My tears have glued sand all over my cheeks. I don't remember falling asleep. It must have been sometime during the night because it felt like I cried forever. I don't think there's a tear left in me to shed.
As I crawl out of the wreckage in search of food, Jack makes his rounds and checks my wound. He has the good grace not to question my red, puffy eyes.
I wait for him to talk to me about hurting Ethan, but Jack doesn't say anything. I ask, "Have the antibiotics helped anybody yet?"
"What?"
"Ethan," I explain. "He found some antibiotics."
"I never distributed them," Jack tells me in a hushed tone.
“No?” I suddenly surge with guilt. “Please don’t save them all for me. There’s plenty of people here with more than a cut on their head.”
“Have you met Steve? His wife is…she’s in critical condition and won’t make it without antibiotics. Steve heard what was happening yesterday. There was a fight. Had to wrestle the medicine bottle away from Ethan. I had a good look at them.” Jack pauses. “They weren't antibiotics."
Hair prickles up my neck as an icy chill runs through me. “Then what were they?”
“I’m pretty sure they’re an incredibly high dose of tranquilizer."
I squint, trying to keep my cool, but I feel the blood drain from my face.
Jack sits in the sand, studying me. "What did he do to make you stab him?"
I open my mouth to tell him the truth, but now the truth sounds silly. I stabbed him because he took some of my hair. As I consider lying, I realize my fear wasn't silly at all. "He scared me," I tell Jack. "I woke up and he was touching my head. Running his fingers though my hair." The memory makes my body involuntarily twitch in disgust. "Please keep him away from me."
"Don't spread the word," Jack orders softly. "Ethan has been missing since yesterday. Ran off into the jungle after Steve took the capsules from him. Keep this between us. I don't want to incite a panic."
I open my mouth to say something—thank you, will do, no problem, sure thing, uh-huh—but nothing comes out. Not a gasp or sigh or whimper. Not even air.
I thought moving closer to the ocean would offer protection, but now I don’t feel safe anywhere.
“This vacation just keeps getting better and better,” I say, the laughter building up from the past few days finally breaking through. Once I start laughing, I can’t stop. The woman kneeling in the sand a few feet away shoots me an annoyed look.
Ethan has gone missing. The pills he so adamantly wanted me to take were powerful tranquilizers. What does this solve, and what problems does this create?
What was his original mission? Help abduct Claire. Run tests on her. Help save her baby? Wasn’t he trying to help save her baby? I can’t remember.
That still doesn’t explain what the hell he wants with me. Unless he thinks I’m also pregnant? I’m not sure if I feel more insulted than furious.
“Are you okay?” I look up to find Claire. “I heard you scream yesterday.”
“Fine,” I answer quickly. “I’m fine.”
“Do you know what’s going on?” I watch as she absentmindedly runs a hand across her swollen belly. “Nobody will tell me anything, and I’m getting worried.”
I smile, pleased with this opportunity to finally establish a friendly relationship with someone. “Please, sit with me.” I scoot over and offer her a seat on my blanket. “I’m sorry to say I also have no idea what’s going on.” Reaching up to touch my bandaged forehead, I add, “Got my good sense knocked out on impact.”
She winces with sympathy pain, sits beside me, and looks around my living space. "Where's your suitcase?"
“I…” Caught off guard, I ponder what the easiest story to remember would be and settle for, "I couldn’t find it."
“I’m so sorry.” The sincerity of her sadness is heartwarming. "You know what? Feel free to borrow any of my clothes. I'm sure you're getting tired of having to wear the same thing over and over."
"Are you politely trying to tell me that I smell?"
She laughs.
I hold out a hand for her to shake. "I'm Cora, by the way."
"Claire. Nice to meet you."
I spend the next few hours talking to Claire and letting her read my horoscope. "Sagittarius?" she muses. "Very interesting."
I sit up straight in anticipation. "What can you tell me about myself?"
"You're a fire element, your ruling planet is Jupiter . . . oh, and your symbol is an archer."
"What exactly does all that mean?"
"Well," Claire continues, "you're a very passionate person who knows what they want out of life and out of love. But your friendliness will earn you a reputation of being overly flirtatious, so be careful."
I heave an amused laugh. "Yeah? Okay."
For a moment, I forget. Forget the fact that none of this should be happening, forget that Ethan has singled me out and tried to sedate me, forget that I have no idea where my family is. It is easy to forget because Claire is so easy to talk to. I spend less time worrying about what I should say, so the conversation flows without dozens of awkward silences or weird facial expressions from me. She speaks, and I listen. I speak, and she listens.
She even lets me feel her stomach when baby Aaron pushes out a foot. I close my eyes and swell with the best thoughts I can think of, mostly consisting of be healthy, be safe. But putting a hand against her stomach makes my eyelids droopy.
“You know,” I tell her, yawning. “I’ve never actually been able to nap before, but now all I can seem to do is sleep.”
“Please, go right ahead.” Claire pulls a magazine out of nowhere and smiles happily. “I’ll give you the scoop on the latest Hollywood gossip when you wake up.”
Cold fingers press hard against my mouth.
I blink awake in the dark. My first instinct is to scream, but the hand blocks my ability to draw a breath, and I panic, instinctively reaching for the sharp metal weapon in the sand beside me. As I reach up, another hand grips my wrist with such strength that I stop fighting out of fear.
“My lady,” a woman whispers close to my face. “Do not be afraid.”
I blink and blink and blink just to make sure I’m actually seeing this. I’m staring up at a woman, her face smeared black around the eyes, blonde hair tightly braided up one side of her head, her body covered in fur. It takes me a moment to process that she is, in fact, human.
“We are here to rescue you,” she continues urgently, easing up on her grip. “You must get up before we are seen. Follow us. Hurry.”
Where am I? My eyes shoot around, desperate to make sense of what’s happening. Am I being hazed? I don’t even belong to a sorority. I stare wide-eyed at the woman’s painted face in the moonlight. That’s when I hear the rush of what sounds like water. The ocean. I hear the ocean. Why do I hear the ocean? Moonlight. Why can I see the moon? Why am I outside? She removes her hand from my mouth and I immediately whisper, “Please don’t hurt me.”
“I would never hurt you.” She tilts her head, her eyebrows frowning with confusion. “Have you healed yourself recently?”
“Healed from what?” I whisper, paranoid to communicate any louder than she is. “What’s happening?”
“You’re very confused, aren’t you?” Her face softens when I nod. “I don’t have time to explain now, but please believe the last thing I would ever do is harm you. These people,” she nods in a random direction, “may want to harm you. We need to get you somewhere safe.”
We? She releases me and stands, beckoning me to follow. That’s when I notice I’m on a beach. Tents and blankets spread out all around me and down the shore. I try to see if I recognize anyone, but I don’t.
I take a split second to think this through. Do I believe this woman? Are these sleeping people my actual captors? If I scream and wake them all up, will this woman and her supposed people kill everyone at camp? This woman doesn’t seem to wish me dead. She knows my name. I’m pretty sure she just called me Lady Cora.
Well, shit. I guess this is happening.
I feel my body already breaking out in a cold sweat as I stand and quietly follow behind the cloaked woman, running purely on adrenaline. As we break the treeline, more people emerge as if from thin air. I count five in total, but I don’t doubt there are plenty of others hiding just out of sight.
It’s surreal how we’re suddenly moving as one unit, hurrying in an unknown direction, following the commands of a male voice speaking a language I only partially understand. I catch words I’m familiar with here and there, and over the course of a few conversations, I realize with bewilderment that they’re not speaking Swedish. They’re not even speaking Icelandic.
They’re speaking Old Norse.
“Hold on,” I pant desperately. We’ve been running long enough that I now have to stop and catch my breath every few minutes, hacking loudly into the open air. I’m so exhausted I genuinely don’t care if they kill me at this point.
“We stop here,” the leader announces, and I all but collapse on the jungle floor. “Get her water, Liv.”
The woman from the beach kneels beside me and offers a canteen. I don’t bother worrying if its poison. I twist off the top and chug it as fast as humanly possible, stopping only when some goes down the wrong pipe and I choke.
When I’ve had my fill of water and can breathe again, I look around at the men and women congregating near the stream. They talk freely, although I can only understand some words. Old Norse is a dead language, like Latin. There are plenty of languages that evolved from it, but no modern society speaks it fluently.
At least, that’s what my linguistics professors all claimed. But these people’s diction and pronunciation sounds an awful lot like the translation work I’ve been conducting for my thesis.
“I’m Erik.” I look up at a sizable man, his face painted with the same lines and dots as the others. Beneath a cloak of brown fur, he wears dark leather fastened with a belt holding at least two axes. He stands over me, bends forward in a quick bow, straightens, and turns to point out the people standing behind him, all similarly dressed in robes of animal hide. One by one, they bow as well. “This is Gorm, Liv, Inga, and Revna. We are the last of Clan Wolf.” He pauses, but I don’t know what he expects me to say. “You truly bless us with your return, my lady.”
I want to be polite so they don’t decapitate me, but when I try to say nice to meet you all, nothing comes out. Do something. Do something, you’re just staring at them. I at least have the wherewithal to close my gaping mouth, deciding instead to nod my introduction.
“How severe is your injury?” Liv asks, already reaching to unwrap my gauze. “I brought blessed moss if you require it. Oh, it’s healed.” I reach up and touch nothing but smooth skin, and she barks a musical laugh. “No wonder you’re so disoriented.”
I’ve felt this way a few times before in my life – usually during times of great stress. It feels like a sort of out of body experience. Like going to see a movie and suddenly looking around the theatre, fully aware you’re alive and you exist and wondering if everyone else knows they exist. That is what I feel now, staring up at these people armed to the teeth but seemingly friendly.
I exist. I’m alive. And I desperately want to stay that way.
“I am honored to meet you all.” They seem surprised to hear me speak, and it makes me swallow twice before I can continue. “I’m… I don’t know how to say this, but I have no memory of–” I look from one face to another. “Of any of you.”
“You wouldn’t.” Erik smiles at me. “I was only a child when we first met. You would have known my father, Sigurd. Or my grandfather, Torsten.”
“I think she means she has no memory of our clan,” Inga interjects. “She needs to rest.”
“I’m sorry.” Are they angry? Should I have pretended to know them? “I hit my head pretty hard. It's been difficult to think.”
Erik and Liv begin a conversation in Old Norse, a few of the others piping in randomly. I look away from them to keep my confusion hidden.
What the hell is going on? Are these people The Others? I thought they spoke Latin?
“We will rest when we reach the Temple,” says Erik. “And we will slow our pace for you, my lady. It is only an hours walk.”
“I’m afraid we cannot allow that.” Everyone turns towards the voice, and I follow their eyes to four figures standing across the stream. “Erik, my friend. We need to talk.”
A rush of relief and adrenaline courses through me at the sight of the man. Richard Alpert. A familiar face at last. At his left are two women I’ve never seen before, each of them flanked on either side by enormous grey wolves. It takes my brain a few seconds to process that the figure to Richard’s right is Benjamin Linus.
I’m filled with equal parts excitement and terror as my brain goes into overdrive remembering who these people are. Ben was without question my favorite character on the show, but it’s one thing to fangirl safely in the privacy of your own home and a completely different thing to come face-to-face with an emotionally void, manipulative murderer in real life. Especially because I’ve started to remember where I am.
I was just at the beach with the survivors of Oceanic 815. That’s who those sleeping people were. I think of Claire, and I pray she was left unharmed.
“It’s that trash from the Temple,” I hear one of the woman beside Richard sneer. “I can smell them from here.”
“Quiet, Jane,” Richard snaps. “Erik, I understand your excitement at Cora’s return, but we really need to talk.”
Erik raises his arms, palm out, bowing dramatically. “Then let us talk.”
Richard shoots a glance in my direction and then back to Erik. “In private.”
“If you’re here to convince me to let her stay with your people, then you’re wasting your breath.”
“He’s yelling,” one of the wolves says. “Do we subdue him?”
“Wait until you’re ordered,” the other responds. He shifts his weight from left paw to right paw and lowers his head. “They haven’t told us to do anything yet.”
I look around to see if anyone else finds it weird that those two giant dogs standing next to Richard’s group are talking to each other.
Jane steps forward with a rifle in one hand, pointed at the ground but still a warning. “Jacob demands an audience—”
“I don’t answer to your god,” Erik spits out. With a flick he’s unstrapped the axe at his hip, gripping the handle, looking eager to sink it into the woman. “I answer to mine.” Jane raises the rifle, but Erik only smiles. “You better have impeccable aim, little girl.”
“Eddard,” Jane calls sharply, and the bigger wolf trots forward.
I thought Erik was angry before, but this sets him off into an even deeper rage. “You dare threaten me with my birthright?” he screams, pointing at the wolf. “You filthy thieving whore!”
“Bite him,” the smaller wolf barks.
“No. You see how I hold, young one?” The larger wolf at Jane’s side growls. “She has not ordered me to attack anyone. You must wait for commands.”
Ben points at me and says something I do not understand to my group, his accent much less refined than the rest of them, but whatever he said seems to have gotten Erik’s attention. Erik turns around to face me and nods to one of his people.
“May I, my lady?” Liv takes hold of my arm and carefully pushes up the long-sleeve of the oversized pullover I borrowed from Claire. We both stare at the pale underside of my arm, and I wonder what it is she’s looking for. Nothing is wrong with my arm. I look up at her, expecting a smile.
Liv looks confused. She releases her grip and stands, stepping back towards Erik.
Richard steps forward and aggressively smacks down the barrel of Jane’s rifle, so it points at the ground and not at Erik. “Now can we talk?”
I was so sure these people weren’t going to kill me, but now the same group that were staunchly assuring me they mean no harm look at me with suspicious contempt. I don’t know what to say to make this situation better, so I blurt out the question I so desperately want the answer to.
“So,” I ask, pointing at the wolf standing next to Jane, “can anyone else understand what those dogs are saying?”
“No. Jane. Stop,” Ben says each word as a separate command, his voice rising with panic.
I watch, confused, as Jane rushes towards me practically frothing with rage. She raises the butt of her rifle and swings it down hard on my face.
I am unimaginably hungry.
Heavy with a weight I cannot explain, my head swings down, hanging limply. I’m sitting on a hard floor. I open my eyes with a sharp gasp as I wait for my vision to adjust to the light. I’m sitting next to a washer machine. A single bulb lights what looks to be someone’s basement. The small room leads to a flight of stairs and a closed door.
“Hello?” I call out into the silence. The door opens. All I can see is a white mass descending the stairs with slow, heavy steps. Halfway down I realize what this thing is and my stomach cramps so badly, I wince in pain.
Listening to the sounds of its massive claws scraping the floor as it walks closer, I back up as far as I can against the wall, staring up into the face of a polar bear.
Chapter 3: The Oldest Of Friends
Chapter Text
Hot air and water droplets blow against my face as the polar bear exhales heavily. It sniffs my hair, my face, my clothes. It pokes and prods with its wet nose. It sits and stares at me for what seems like hours.
Then, in perfect English, it asks, “Where have you been?”
I can barely see anything through the stinging rivulets of sweat pouring down my face and into my eyes. Being this close to a bear—a talking bear—has shut off my brain. All I can do is gape and wait for it to maul and eat me.
Just like I suspected, the bear opens its mouth full of sharp teeth and leans towards me. I close my eyes and wait for the pain, but all I feel is a rough tongue slide up my face. Instead of a scream, all I can muster is a disgusted, “Ugh.”
“Margo, come here.”
I finally regain control of my arms and swipe a shaking hand across my eyes until I can see who the new voice belongs to. A man stands at the bottom of the stairs holding what looks like a plate.
“She’s back,” the polar bear roars excitedly over and over. It’s massive body spins away from me and strides towards the man. In the bear’s excitement, it crashes a little too hard into his side, and he stumbles, barely righting himself.
“Yes,” the man says, sounding exhausted. “Yes, I know. Margo, no, the sandwich is not for you. Get down.” I watch as his mouth twitches in a battle not to smile. He pets the top of bear’s head as it continues to chant excitedly.
“Who are you?” I whisper, but my voice rattles so much I don’t think he heard me. “Did you drug me?”
He pauses so long I don’t think he’ll answer. “No, we didn’t drug you.”
“I don’t feel right.”
“This should help.” He places the plate and a cup of water on the ground in front of me before turning towards the stairs. “Come, Margo.”
“No,” the bear refutes. Its body sways as it saunters back over to me, plopping down next to the sandwich and resting its massive head on my lap. “I’m staying right here.”
His demand is more stern this time. “Margo, come here.”
I blink, thinking, remembering. I know this person. Only, I don’t. I know of this person.
Ben sighs, abandoning his demands that the bear follow him. I watch his facial movements to see if I can tell how dangerous the situation is, but there is no expression when his eyes meet mine. “Enjoy your sandwich,” he says before disappearing up the stairs, snapping the door shut behind him.
My stomach reminds me that I have not eaten in a while, and I’m much too weak to plan an escape right now. I reach for the sandwich and take a ravenous chunk, barely chewing before swallowing. I’m expecting something simple, like chicken-salad or ham. I look between the slices of bread and find only multiple thinly sliced vegetables pasted together with garlic mayo.
“I missed you,” the polar bear says, still relaxed against my lap. “Where have you been?”
I scarf down the sandwich before I can answer. I am talking to a bear. I’m locked in a basement. Ben Linus just gave me a sandwich. I’m still hungry. Oceanic 815 just crashed on The Island.
I am talking to a bear.
I reach for the cup of water and bring it up to my lips. My hands shake so much a good portion splashes down my chin and dots my sweatpants. I clear my throat and say the only thing I can think of. “How long have I been gone?”
“My whole life,” the bear answers. “I’m so happy you’re back. I was hoping I’d get to see you again before the end.”
I finish chugging the water and gasp air, waiting for this all to make sense. “The end of what?”
“I’m old,” the bear laughs. “Very old. I’m slower than I used to be, and I’m tired most days. I won’t be around much longer.”
Even though the bear seems happy, her words form a pit in my stomach. I don’t know this bear, but she seems to know me, and it makes me sad to think she won’t be alive much longer. I wasn’t allowed to have pets as a child, though I desperately wanted a dog. Now I have what seems like a very old, very excitable, very very large dog, and I won’t get to enjoy her company for long.
My hands stop shaking as I run my fingers through her thick fur. “Where am I?”
“Home,” she answers happily.
There’s a commotion upstairs behind the door. I’m not sure what to expect, but I also know staying trapped in this basement isn’t a smart alternative. Besides, I have a bear who seems to adore me. Odds are slightly more in my favor if it comes to fighting.
“Margo,” I say, “we should get out of here.”
“You want to go outside? I can take you for a walk, like old times.”
“Yes, that sounds wonderful,” I reply.
She mistakes my excitement to be free from this basement with excitement to go on a walk and all but lunges for the stairs. At the sound of her roar, the door opens. The man who opened it has no time to second guess his decision before Margo charges forward, knocking him down in the process. I stick to her like glue, squinting as I emerge into what looks to be a normal, average house.
I quickly try to count the amount of people sitting and standing in the room adjacent to the kitchen—some I recognize from the stand-off earlier, and others I don’t—as they fall silent and stare at me. Erik and Liv bow their heads, but the rest of them continue to stare. I look at the man Margo knocked over and recognize Richard.
I need to get out of here. I’m not sure what they’re talking about or what they’re planning, but I want no part in it. “We are going to go outside now,” I announce and follow closely behind Margo as she heads to the front door. She sits patiently, swaying slightly with excitement, as she waits for me to open the door.
My first step outside mushes against my foot. I look down in disgust to see I’ve stepped in a large bowl of what looks like macaroni salad. Next to this bowl is another crockpot of food, next to yet another offering of decorative cuts of fruit. There’s no space to walk amongst the dozens upon dozens of intricate flower bouquets wrapped with ribbon and fancy prepared meals stacked tightly together spanning from the door down to the grass of the front yard.
There’s no way to leave this house without stepping on flowers or food.
In my confusion, the only thing I can think to do is reach down and read a folded note that was taped to the macaroni salad. It looks to have been written by a very young child.
It reads: Hello Lady Cora, I helped make this macaroni salad with no animals in it. I have never eaten an animal before. Please don’t kill my family even though sometimes my parents eat fish. Thank you! Love, Indiana
PS. This is a drawing of me and my pet lizard Scales. He’s my best friend. Please talk to him when you are not busy and tell me if he’s happy.
There’s a hand on my shoulder, and I drop the note. ”Hey,” I stutter with cold, unrelenting fear, "what are you doing?” I’m pulled over the threshold and back into the house. An annoyed looking Richard closes the door and, thankfully, releases my shoulder.
“Margo seems satisfied it’s her,” says Ben. He’s standing next to a couch seating Jane and a woman I’ve never seen before. Erik and Liv stand together on the other side of the room. I’m acutely aware that they’re the only ones not glaring at me.
It takes me a second to register what Ben just said. “I’m who?” I try to ask, but I’m drowned out by Jane.
“Yes,” she says, “well, that settles it. Your senile bear is all the proof I need.”
“Are we going to ignore how she healed her head?” Erik interrupts loudly. “Or how she can understand your bear enough to win its trust? Your talks of tests are tedious and dull and a waste of my time. She should be returned to her rightful place at—”
I don’t know how to process anything that’s happening, so I stand perfectly still. Being invisible and ignored is an art I’ve all but mastered. Erik and Jane get into another shouting match, and I can feel my anxiety rising with every angry word. The disorientation from earlier has completely worn off, and now I’m excruciatingly aware of how afraid I am. Maybe I should take Margo and go back to the basement. At least they wouldn’t be able to stare at me there.
Richard speaks, and I jump. I had forgotten he was so close, so I reflexively move away from him further into the kitchen. I reach out for Margo, and I’m comforted when she taps her nose against my hand.
“She is free to do as she likes as soon as it can be verified she is who she claims she is,” says Richard.
I haven’t claimed to be anybody. I try to say this, but my voice won’t work, as usual.
“I’m taking her to the only person on this island old enough to know if this is her or not,” Richard continues. “We’re going to see Jacob.”
I cover my ears as both Erik and Liv burst into angry rebuttals.
Margo licks my arm. “It’s alright. You don’t have to be afraid. They yell a lot, but we’re not in danger. Sit with me.” Sitting helps. I wrap my arms around her neck and she starts grooming the side of my head.
“You have custody of our Goddess,” Erik rants, “but we’re not even allowed to know where your God resides?”
“One of you may come with me,” Richard says in a pacifying tone. “Will that settle this?”
I continue to sit on the kitchen floor of an unknown person’s house, being comforted by an elderly polar bear, and hating myself for allowing these people to talk over me and discuss my future without my consent.
Richard and Erik follow behind me. Richard aims a rifles at the ground, ready in case I try to run away.
Ha. Run away. I can't even keep up with them. What are they worried about?
Margo trots happily at my side. Ben seemed aggravated she was going with us, but there was no convincing Margo otherwise. Besides, I wasn’t about to give up the one sense of security I have. Margo is the only person—only living thing—that doesn’t seem to have some kind of ulterior motive and just wants to hang out with me. As much as I don’t want to get on Ben’s bad side, I also don’t want to play my cards wrong and put myself into even greater danger.
There’s a part of me that feels dead inside with embarrassment. I haven’t showered in days, and my clothes are in desperate need of a wash. Even though the sweatpants Claire let me borrow technically fit, I still had to roll up the too-long legs. I look pathetic. I’m covered in sticky perspiration, and it feels like I'm choking up a lung. I’m not sure what hurts more, my legs or my feet.
I legitimately think I’m going to die, but I’m too embarrassed to complain. When I look back to gage how Richard and Erik are doing, neither of them are red-faced or particularly sweaty. I think of all the comments my father would make if he could see me now. I’m too fat, too slow, too weak, too lazy. Of course I want to complain about the length of the walk because any length is too far for a worthless piece of shit like me.
“Tell me what’s wrong,” Margo offers. “You’re upset.”
Without thinking, I give her my standard reflex. “I’m fine.”
By mid-afternoon, I finally see the foot statue over the tops of the palm trees. Little black specks dance behind my eyelids as I stumble across the beach. I'm thirsty and exhausted. Sand kicks up into my shoes and grinds against my feet. I can't help but roll my eyes.
“Cora will enter on her own,” Richard says when we stand before the foot. He motions towards a door hidden on the side. “Erik and I will wait for you out here.”
Margo inhales deeply and perks up. “Jacob! Come inside with me, Cora. He’s very nice.”
“I’m taking Margo,” I tell Richard. For some reason, he makes no argument. Erik seems pleased to let me proceed alone as long as Margo is with me.
With no other reason to stall, I push on the door enough to let Margo slip through, and then I follow her into the dark.
"I suppose you're looking for me."
I spin around and come face to face with the man of mystery himself. Jacob has always looked high to me. I think it's the heavy-lidded eyes and drowsy demeanor. His dirty blonde hair is a mess, as usual, and he's wearing his usual plain cotton pants and shirt while sitting on a chair by a fire-pit, carving a small token out of wood. Margo licks his face before walking back to stand by my side.
Before I can think of a response to meeting such a confusing character, Jacob spares me the trouble. “They don’t believe you are who you say you are, do they?”
For some reason, this doesn’t embarrass or otherwise leave me gaping and unsure. This statement makes me angry. I finally say the words I wanted to scream back at the house. “I haven’t claimed to be anyone.”
“So who are you?” he asks, sounding bored.
“I thought you’re supposed to have all the answers,” I snap. My exhaustion from this trip has made all social awkwardness seem less important. I just want to confirm whatever Richard wants to confirm so I can take a hot shower. “My name is Cora.”
“I know.” Without even looking up from the wood he’s whittling, Jacob gives a lazy smile. “Have a seat,” he offers, motioning to a split log near the pit. “No use in standing after walking the whole way here. You must be exhausted.”
I sit and worry I will never be able to stand again.
Jacob finally looks up from his whittling project. “What do you remember?”
“About what?”
“Anything. Yourself. This island. Me.”
I sigh. “Honestly? I don’t know. I thought I knew a lot about this place, but—” I wonder if there is any harm in confiding with Jacob. Nobody talks directly to him except Richard. He seems to know me like Erik and Liv seem to know me. Maybe if I’m honest, he can give me some answers to what the hell is going on. “I don’t think I’m supposed to be here.”
Jacob's eyebrows rise. "Ah," he says, returning his attention back to his token. It looks like some sort of wooden animal. “Why is that?”
“Because right before I woke up from a plane crash for a flight I wasn’t on, I was asleep in my apartment, watching this—” I wave my arms around for emphasis. “—on a TV. None of this is real.” I pause. “Does that mean somewhere someone is watching this on a TV? Did I get caught in some kind or wormhole? Am I in another dimension? Am I dead?”
“That’s why I like you. Always asking the hard questions.”
I frown at him, but then it dawns on me. Jacob has powers. “Can you send me back?” I surge with newfound energy, and somehow I stand. “Can you send me back to my dimension? Send me back to my family?”
“I can’t,” he answers. “Believe me, I would if I could.”
“Why?” I can already feel the hope leaching out of me, and I have to sit again. “Because you want me gone?”
“No,” he says, sounding amused. “Because we’re friends.”
We are? Could have fooled me by the way Erik talks. I was under the impression those who live at the Temple have some sort of beef with those who live in the DHARMA barracks. “We don’t have beef?”
“It was my understanding you’re vegetarian.”
I don’t want to laugh, but I do. “No, I mean, we’re not warring with each other?”
“No.” Jacob pulls a bottle of wine out of nowhere and takes a swig. “Not unless you’re hiding something.”
“If we’re not fighting, why are they?”
“Lack of communication.” He shrugs and takes another swig of wine. “Because that’s what people do. They argue. They fight. They die for what they think is important.”
That’s dumb.
Jacob smiles again and corks the wine. “I suppose we should get you back to your people before they riot. Tell Richard I’d like to speak to him, please.”
The late afternoon is graciously cooler, so it’s a slightly easier walk back to the barracks. I don’t know what Jacob said to Richard, but whatever it was seems to have worked. His rifle now hangs across one shoulder, not ready to point at me.
We don’t get very far into the jungle before Margo perks up, sniffing. “James!” In a rather lengthy stride, Margo takes off through the trees.
“No,” I yell. “Margo, come back! Stop!”
“It’s James, Cora,” I hear her explain while continuing her pace. “Come see! James has returned.”
I try to run after her, but my legs refuse to move. Margo scampers out of sight and I hang my head, taking in a deep breath and preparing to pursue. “Can one of you please follow her?” I ask Richard and Erik. “I honestly can’t take another step.”
A loud crack echoes through the jungle, and I look up in confusion. It’s not raining. It’s not even overcast. The second, third, forth and fifth cracks echo wildly in the distance, and Richard pulls me to the ground.
“Erik,” says Richard, already swinging the rifle off his shoulder. I watch Erik reach for his axe. “I’ll watch her. Confirm who’s shooting.”
That wasn’t lightning? That was a gunshot? Someone’s shooting at us?
No. Someone’s shooting at Margo.
“Margo,” I say aloud. “Margo?”
Richard shushes me.
Erik returns with Sawyer, kicking him to a kneel before us. “There was more, but this is the man who shot your bear.”
“Easy,” Sawyer grumbles, his hands raised over his head in surrender. “No need to break my damn legs.” At the sight of me, Sawyer’s angry expression turns to confusion.
“I need to help her,” I mumble. If I can heal myself, surely I can heal other people too. “I need to heal her wounds.”
“No, my lady,” Erik says sadly. “Do not trouble yourself with such a morbid sight. The bear is dead. I have confirmed it. You cannot help her now.”
My mouth opens, and I think I’m about to scream. Instead, I start laughing and wrap both arms around my middle. I laugh so hard my stomach cramps. I try to shake my head to let everyone know I’m not laughing because I think it’s funny, but this only makes me more hysterical.
I gasp in-between an especially breathy laugh, furiously blinking away tears, and rasp, “Get me out of here.”
Chapter 4: Bury The Lede
Chapter Text
I have no idea how long it takes to arrive back at the Barracks, but I vaguely remember Erik carrying me on his back.
Erik and Liv have left to stay in a separate guest house. Liv was insistent they escort me to the Temple tonight, and I’m pretty sure I made some kind of screech in response. She also insisted we three stay together, and I honestly don’t remember what I said to convince her otherwise. I just want to be completely alone for a while. No conversations, no questions, no noise. Just me and dead silence.
I choose the biggest knife in the kitchen and slip it under my pillow.
I thankfully have enough strength to stand slumped under running water like a zombie, sloppily rubbing soap across my skin every once in a while. I only think to turn off the shower when the water starts to run cold. I wrap a too-small towel around myself and step out into the bedroom. Cool air prickles my skin as the moisture on my exposed shoulders begins to dry. I don’t bother exploring the room in the guesthouse I was given. I advance towards the neatly made bed and collapse onto the comforter, pulling just enough over me to keep me warm.
Just think of this as a fancy hotel.
As my fingers rub over the familiar wooden handle of a knife, I try to conjure good thoughts to fall asleep to, but it turns out there’s no need. I’m asleep as soon as my head hits the pillow.
I’m aware something is wrong, but I also can’t move.
“Sincerest apologies for the intrusion,” Ben says from my doorway as I stir awake. “But I have an urgent request that could not wait until morning.”
You will not kill me. I'll kill you first. My fingers strangle the knife handle under my pillow, ready to spring into action if need be. As I slowly come-to, I realize I’m still wrapped in a towel and frantically use my free hand to make sure it hasn’t come loose. “What the hell are you—” I stop short when I see he’s not alone.
Alex stands close to my bed and awkwardly bows when I look at her. “I’m so sorry we didn’t knock, but this is an emergency and we didn’t want to get caught banging on your front door.”
Still gripping the hidden knife in one hand, I grope the comforter with my free hand and pull the edge closer to me so I can fully cover my entire body. Now that adrenaline is pumping through my veins, I’m awake enough to be angry. “Why are you in my house?”
“We brought you clean clothes,” Alex offers, looking embarrassed. She pats a neatly folded stack of clothing she’s placed beside me on the mattress.
You couldn’t have called to tell me that? You couldn’t have left them at my door? Even in my fury, I still find myself trying not to offend. “Please get out of my house.”
“We will let you dress,” says Ben, who at least has the decency not to look at me. “But then I will need you to come with us.”
My head is heavy with the need for sleep, and I can feel an exhausted rage forming deep inside. “Whatever you want can wait till morning. I’m going to sleep.”
“I’m afraid this can’t wait till morning,” he answers sharply. “And you’re the only one who can help.”
“Oh God,” I exhale in a defeated sigh. “What do you want?”
“We need to burn her,” says Alex.
“Burn who?"
“We need to burn Margo before your people find her,” answers Ben.
At the mention of her name, I look at him. “Why?”
Ben’s wandering eyes finally land on mine. “It’s customary that they. . . repurpose the remains of dead animals. They cannot kill, but they always find uses once an animal dies of other means. Erik knows where Margo’s body is.”
I nod, but I don’t see the issue. She’s already dead.
Ben stares silently at me, as if any of this is supposed to make sense enough for me to leap out of bed and enthusiastically follow them into the night. If this is some kind of weird mind-game, I’m way too tired to figure out what his motive is.
“I don’t. . . ” Ben looks away and blinks rapidly a few times. “I don’t want them to skin her.” When he looks back at me, his words are softer. “Please. We just want to give Margo—all of her—a proper funeral, but I don’t know where her body is. Richard is the only other person who knows where she died, but he’s gone.”
I groan and flop back against my pillow. “Where’d he go?”
“Who’s to say? He comes and goes often.”
I am so tired it feels as if my body has been buried under several layers of sand. In my stupor, I close my itching eyes to think. Is this worth it? Will this get me back on Ben’s good side? Or if not “good” side at least knock me down a few slots on the list of people he’d like to kill? Are my numb legs even capable of standing?
When I open my eyes, I see them both differently. I spot the jitteriness behind Ben’s calm facade. I note Alex’s red puffy eyes, which probably means she’s been crying. I may be sad Margo is dead, but I hardly knew her. Ben and Alex are mourning an old friend. I want to help if it will bring them closure.
It’s what my grandma would have told me to do.
Taking a deep breath, I say a silent prayer for strength and finally let go of the knife. “Ok. But I’m not walking.”
“Of course not.” It surprises me how Ben cannot hide the intense relief in his voice. “I will ride Coco and you and Alex will take Brego. I’ll go on ahead and bring the horses to the valley. Meet Alex outside once you're dressed. And please,” he adds, “be quiet.”
I stare up at Alex and instantly regret all of this. “I don’t know how to ride a horse.”
“That’s totally fine,” she assures me. “Just sit behind me and I’ll do the hard part.”
Brego hasn’t said anything, but I still feel weird not asking his permission before hopping on his spine. “Hi,” I say to the motionless brown horse. “Excuse me, Brego?”
“Yeah?” He sounds agitated. I wonder if he was asleep when Ben retrieved him.
“I’m so sorry, but I need to ask a favor. May I ride on your back?”
“Sure,” he says in a whinny-sigh. “Everyone else does.”
I feel terrible asking a creature as tired as I am to carry me deep into the jungle. I know there’s no other choice, but it still doesn’t feel good. “But…do you mind?”
“No.”
“Ok,” I tell him in my most cheerful tone. “Thank you so much.”
I reach for Alex’s hand so she can help pull me up onto the saddle just as I feel Ben’s hands from behind grab me under the arms and hoist. It’s over the second I notice it, and I have no energy to voice my discomfort with the contact anyway. I’m just happy to be sitting and not walking.
My relief at not having to walk doesn’t last long. There is absolutely nothing comfortable about riding a horse. With every clop of Brego’s hooves, the hard saddle digs into my aching glutes. It is no time at all before I lose all feeling in my butt.
I worry we will never find Margo. I try my best to retrace the path Richard took me to Jacob’s foot, but what would have been a difficult task in the light is near impossible in the dark. Everything looks the same.
It’s all made even worse by the incessant yelling of birds overhead. What would sound like nothing more than beautiful chirping to a regular person sounds like a combination of catcalls, complaints, and just a general TMI to me. It’s like being in a club full of loud people with no music playing.
“There it is,” I choke out and point at the foot in the distance. “We came back in that direction. She’s over there.”
At long last, we come to a halt. I yawn and try to process this whole situation by its positives. The only positive I can think of is how we’re halfway to being done with this mission and back home to my nice soft pillow.
“You can just stay on the saddle if you want,” says Alex. She’s smiling, but in the moonlight I can see her watering eyes. “Dad and I will start digging.”
“I thought you were burning her?”
“We have to dig around her first,” she explains, “like a campfire, so we don’t light the whole jungle ablaze.” Alex hops off Brego, hands me the reigns, and pulls a shovel from the saddle.
Ben and Alex approach Margo’s body with their shovels and what looks to be a canister of gasoline. I watch and wait for them to start digging, but they don’t. They just stand perfectly still, side-by-side, not touching, not physically consoling each other, just staring.
I wonder if I’m being disrespectful by just sitting here. I’m doing them a favor. They asked me to bring them to the body, and I did. My job is done. I don’t have to do anything but sit here and wait for them to conduct whatever ceremony it is they came here to do.
I can barely hear Ben talking, and it sounds like he said my name, so I ask Brego to take me closer. As I approach, Ben turns and glares at me—but not just any ordinary glare. No, this is one of those special calm glares that sends chills up your spine and brings to your attention that somebody is about to be murdered.
What is your problem? It isn’t until Alex turns around, startled, that I realize I’ve spoken aloud.
“This didn’t have to happen,” Ben seethes under his breath. “You could have told her to stay home. She would have listened to you.”
I look at Margo and see the blood streaks in her white fur. Flies buzz around her wounds, of which I count four. I could have sworn there were five shots fired. Then I notice what must have been the final blow right between her bloodied eyes.
My throat tears. Ben’s insinuation hits my chest like a physical punch because he’s right. I probably could have persuaded Margo to stay home if I’d tried. If she had just stayed home, she’d still be alive. I feel so sick I barely get out, “I didn’t kill Margo.”
“No, of course not,” he retorts dismissively. “You just watched.”
I can’t think of a response, so I frown, but only so I can cover my watering eyes with a squint. Only, no tears come. I’m literally too tired to cry.
What am I supposed to say? Erik told me she was dead, and he was right. There’s a bullet hole in her skull to prove that. But. . . I didn’t check for myself. What if Erik had been wrong? What if I could have saved her?
Ben exhales quietly through his nose, steadying himself. He sounds less angry when he says, “Please take Brego back to the Barracks. He knows the way.”
I look at Alex because I can no longer look at him. “What about you?”
“Alex and I want to stay here a while longer after we’ve lit the pyre,” Ben answers for her.
Alex looks seconds away from wailing, and now I cannot look at her either. I glance towards the jungle and my delirious brain invents all sorts of terrifying reasons why trusting a horse I don’t know to take me back to a compound I’m not familiar with is one of the dumbest ideas of the night. “I don’t mind waiting.”
I watch as Ben’s expression hardens again. “Intrude on our funeral if you must,” he snaps. “It’s not as if you haven’t ruined enough already.”
“Dad,” Alex whispers. Even though I can barely hear her, I still notice the crack in her voice.
Ben turns and begins shoveling without another word. I’ve been dismissed.
“Alex, are you sure you don’t mind if I take Brego back?” I close my itchy eyes in the hopes of re-moisturizing them, but it just feels like sand is chafing my inner eyelids. “I desperately need to sleep.”
She tries to smile but ends up swiping away at her now wet face. She waves me away with a hand before turning and digging into the ground with her shovel.
“Brego.” I grip the reigns and pray there isn’t anything complicated about this. “Take me home, please.” I almost fall off his back as he darts forward into a gallop.
To keep from falling asleep, I think of my grandma. Everything was good before she died. Our house had never been perfect, but it was at least less depressing with her in it. She was the most fearless woman I know. Not only did she move across the world to live with us after my grandfather died, but she learned English all on her own and worked as a maid on the weekends to help with household bills. Grandma was an old-school, no-nonsense Sicilian who took absolutely no shit from anyone, including my dad. When she passed, it was as if my dad had been given permission to evolve into his final abusive form. Being subjected to his constant threats of violence made the pain of her absence unbearable.
If Grandma could see me now—half-awake, riding aimlessly atop a horse who I can talk to—she would absolutely laugh her ass off. Then she’d make me something to eat.
I focus back on the road just in time to see the tree branch that smashes into my face and throws me off Brego.
I’m surprised I don’t slip into unconsciousness as I hit the ground hard. A tight swelling has already started in my right eyelid, and it hurts to open. My forehead throbs from the impact and an annoying ringing echoes through both ears. I reach up to stop the pain in my eye.
No, don’t heal. You’ll pass out again and get eaten alive by wild animals in your sleep.
“You’re not very coordinated,” Brego laughs, doubling back and trotting circles around me.
I moan and roll onto my side. Everything hurts. Muscles in my arm shoot pain up into my neck. I think I landed on my wrist. It better not be broken.
“Brego,” I beg. “Please, I will literally get you anything you ask for. Just please get me back home in one piece.”
How many ibuprofen can you take before it becomes lethal? Three is apparently not enough to help with my aching. . . everything.
“We cannot leave you alone for one night without you being assaulted.” Liv paces the length of the kitchen as I attempt to cook myself pancakes. “Who was it, my lady? Point them out.”
“It wasn’t anybody,” I grumble. “I already told Ethan about it. He helped me find my guesthouse last night.” As I crack an egg to add to the mix, I wonder if this still means I’m vegetarian. I think so? As long as the egg wasn’t fertilized, I’m not actually eating a chicken.
“You expect me to believe that?” Liv asks.
“You don’t have to protect these stuffy assholes,” Erik cuts in. “We should have burned this place to the ground years ago. Please, give us a reason.”
Calm down, Erik. Is he being serious? I turn to give him a disapproving look. “You want the truth?” I need more sleep. I will never have enough sleep. “I went for a late-night ride on a horse named Brego. Wanted to clear my head. Wasn’t paying enough attention and ran into a low-hanging branch. Taa-daa. Lamest black eye in history. Here, eat your pancakes.”
I serve them both first, then I practically burn all my tastebuds shoveling the hotcakes into my mouth as fast as I can spear them on a fork. I scarf down three and return to the stove to make more.
“If we leave after breakfast, we should arrive at the Temple just before sundown—”
“No,” I cut Erik off in a panic, and I can feel my face instantly redden at my rudeness. “Please, no more travel. I barely got any sleep last night. I want one full day of rest.”
Erik opens his mouth to argue, but nods instead. “As you wish, Lady Cora. We will reconvene in the morning.”
I barely had time to sleep in this morning before Erik and Liv were pounding at my door to check on me. “Please, let me come to you tomorrow. I want to wake up naturally.”
“I tried to tell him that this morning,” Liv says, shooting Erik a playful smirk. “We will let you sleep as long as you need. Come find us when you wish to leave.”
With a deep bow, they turn and walk out the front door, and my guesthouse is blissfully silent again.
After I’ve eaten my fill, I wander around the house in search of answers. There’s nothing of real note in the living room or kitchen, so I check the hall closet. I end up in the bathroom, looking into a mirror. Of all things, I’m shocked. My skin looks amazing. Flawless. Freakishly flawless, except for the purple-black bruising around my right eye. Otherwise, it’s perfectly toned. I can’t see a single pore. Even my blonde hair looks healthier than it's ever been before. It almost looks like I’m actually glowing.
I snort a laugh. Do I look this way because I have powers, or because this is what characters on this show are supposed to look like?
After checking the bedroom and finding nothing but an empty closet, I sit on the ugly couch in the living room and listen to the steady ticking of a clock on the wall. I take the clock off its hook and stick it in the hall closet, but even the silence isn’t enough anymore.
This is insane. If I was going to wake up, surely I would have by now.
Now what?
Do I try to leave the island? Does my family even exist off-island? Somewhere in California, is there an alternate universe 10-year-old Cora?
I grip my ribs as my chest tightens, my breath creaking like a rusty hinge. It feels like the walls are closing in on me, and I need fresh air.
I’m surprised to find Liv sitting on my porch stairs, surrounded by a completely new batch of flower and food offerings. Liv has a bowl of something in her lap, and she’s in the middle of licking her fingers when she looks up at me. “Lady Cora,” she says, already standing. “Sorry, I hope you don’t mind. Whatever that was is delicious.”
I blink at the sheer amount of bowls and bouquets and wonder if I’m going to have to deal with this everyday. “Have you been sitting out here the whole time?”
“Yes, my lady. Where can I escort you?”
I glance across the lot, but I don’t see him. “Where’s Erik?”
“Back at the guesthouse. Do you need anything?”
I don’t want to tell her about my desire to wander aimlessly because I don’t want a chaperone, but I also don’t want to hurt her feelings. “No,” I lie. “Just checking on you.” I look around at the nearest offerings of food and contemplate bringing them inside. “Do you want to come in?”
“Oh, no,” she says. “It’s nice out. I’m fine here.”
I force a smile. “Ok, cool. I’m. . . ok, bye. Thank you.” I close the door to stop my awkward rambling and think up a Plan B.
There has to be a back window I can climb out without being seen.
Sure enough, at the back of the house, the bedroom has a large enough window for me to fit through. I get one foot over the ledge, but I misjudged the height and quickly lose my balance. With a painful thud, I slide out the window and crash to the ground.
I hear snickering and look up. Across the lot from my window, Jane and four other women all sit on the front porch of a house, watching me with amusement.
“That is tragic,” I hear one of the girls snicker, and the rest of them burst into stifled laughter.
My face burns as I push myself to my feet and brush the dirt off my hands.
Jane smiles at me. She’s slender, all muscle, with long back hair tied back in a loose ponytail. The most striking feature on her face are her dark eyebrows set in two bold straight lines that make her look like she's stuck in a perpetual frown. At her feet is a family of wolves, the largest of which sits close enough for her to pet him.
“I heard you lost a fight with a tree,” Jane taunts.
Ha, ha, ha. Hilarious. I keep my eyes locked on a house in the distance and walk past them, trying my best to ignore whatever it is they’re whispering now. If there’s one thing I’ve learned from public school, it’s that you cannot win in these situations. All you can do is leave with as much dignity as possible.
“Hello,” a voice calls from below. I look down to find a small red fox trotting along beside me. “Headed anywhere in particular?”
"Just out for a walk,” I answer. “Actually, you wouldn’t happen to know of a good shaded spot to sit, would you?”
“You should try the gazebo. It’s not far. Mind if I tag along?"
“Sure. What's your name?" I ask.
"Todd," he answers with a flick of his bushy tail. "And you are the illustrious Cora, are you not?"
"I suppose I am."
“You suppose? Dear me, how dreadful it must be not to know who you are."
“Or where I am,” I mumble. “My list of problems is rather long.”
The fox barks a laugh. “To be fair, I hear you go by quite a long list of names, so I wouldn’t feel too bad for not being entirely in the know. It's just nice to meet someone who understands me," Todd continues. "The humans here are nice. Bereft of intelligence, but nice all the same."
I laugh, finally releasing the tension from last night. "Why do you say that?"
"I can understand what they are saying, but they cannot understand what I am saying. You call this intelligence?"
"You can understand English?" I ask in amazement.
"When you've lived with humans your entire life, you learn their language one way or another. It shouldn't be that surprising. Oh, joy,” he mumbles sarcastically. “Child at 3 o’clock.”
I turn and watch a little girl, maybe five or six, hurry towards me. Both her hands are cupped. “Hi!” she exclaims, revealing a lizard delicately lounging against her palms. “Hi, Lady Cora. Are you in a good mood even though you got a black eye? My mom says I can’t talk to you until we know you’re in a good mood.”
“Hello.” I can’t help but laugh at her bluntness. “You must be Indiana.” My smile widens when she excitedly shakes her head. “I read your letter. And this must be Scales.”
The tiny green lizard lifts his head to look at me. “You got bug?”
“Please tell me if I’m a good lizard mom,” Indiana begs. “He sleeps a lot. Is he sick?” Without warning, she holds up the lizard and it climbs onto my shirt.
Scales clings to my stomach with his tiny talons and repeats, “You got bug?”
“Are you hungry?” I ask.
“Yes, she does not feed me enough bug.”
“Ah, I see.” Indiana looks at me expectantly, so I give her a reassuring smile. “He says you take good care of him.”
“No,” Scales cuts in. “I said I want more bug.”
“I take really good care of him,” Indiana assures me. “Scales is my best friend.”
“Tell you what,” I say. “How about you give him a few extra bugs everyday? It will make him less sleepy.”
“Yes, thank you,” says Scales.
Indiana reaches forward and gently plucks Scales off my shirt. “Feeding him more will make him happy?”
“He’s already happy, but feed him more and he’ll be the happiest lizard in the world.”
“Ok! I just didn’t want him to get fat.”
The statement pinches at the nerves in my face, like I’ve bitten into a lemon. I take a steadying breath and try to keep things in perspective. She’s a child. She didn’t mean anything by it. She was talking about Scales. She wasn’t even talking about you. What is wrong with you?
“INDIANA?” A panicked woman scrambles across the grass towards us, pulling Indiana to her side and then stepping forward to shield her. “I am so sorry, Lady Cora.” The woman presses her hands together and falls to her knees in the grass in front of me. “Please forgive me. I turned around for one second and my daughter’s out the door. I hope she has not disturbed your peace.”
I don’t know what I find more horrifying about all this: the intense wobble in her voice that trembles like she’s about to burst into tears, the way she’s shielding her child from me, or the fact that her face is already starting to sweat.
I can feel color flood my cheeks. It’s only when I look around to make sure nobody is gawking that I realize there’s nobody around to gawk. “No, no, that's really not necessary . . ."
She looks up, eyes wide and worried. “Our family prays to your altar every Friday without fail. And we’re very strict vegetarians.”
“But sometimes Mommy and Daddy eat fish,” says Indiana.
I watch all the color drain from the woman’s face. “No we don’t,” she refutes quickly, sounding even more panicked.
“Indiana was just asking about her lizard,” I say, but it comes out more like a question. “He needs a little more food at feeding time.” I say this in the hopes of putting this woman at ease, but she only ends up even more upset.
“An honest mistake,” she begs, curling inward like a shrimp. “We will ensure he’s properly fed from now on, I swear.”
“It’s not a problem,” I say, appalled and embarrassed. “Really, don’t worry about it.”
“Yes, we will fix this. I swear we will.” The woman uncurls, kisses her hands, and places them over my feet. “Thank you. We’ll. . . we’ll do that right now! Come, Indiana.” Before I can think of anything else to say, the woman has hoisted the girl into her arms and hurried back into her house.
“Close your mouth,” Todd chuckles. “You’ll catch flies.”
“What . . . what was that all about?”
Todd tilts his head, studying me. “I do find it rather dull how they’ve kept you in the dark for so long. Would you like to hear what I know? As long as you keep it between us, of course. I’d rather not be skinned alive and worn as a cape for divulging secrets.”
“I won’t say anything.”
“There was an incident here with the original owners of these houses—a purge, if you will—many years ago. If my sources are to be believed, you incited it. After most were killed, the island natives split in two. One group believed you should rule the island, the other believed you had been corrupted and could no longer be trusted. Those who still worshiped you stayed at the Temple a few miles inland. Those who chose to follow Jacob remained here.”
I’m hearing what he’s saying, it just doesn’t process. That’s not what happens. Ben purges Dharma as his initiation into the Others. I blink, thinking about the bizarre conversation I just had with a woman who acted like I was about to behead her. “I have an altar?”
“Your brain sure is bouncy, isn’t it?” Todd tilts his head. “It’s not far from here. Would you like to see it?”
I follow Todd around a bend into an entirely new set of houses. No one is walking around. No one is sitting on their porches. It is eerily abandoned. “Does anyone live here?”
“Oh yes,” Todd answers. “All of these houses are occupied.”
“Where is everyone?” I answer my own question when I catch someone peeking through their blinds. The slats quickly close when I stare too long.
“You cannot exactly blame them,” Todd says, sounding amused. “The last time you were here, a lot of people died.”
I'm not sure whether to believe him or not. It sounds so outside the realm of possibility, I wonder if this is some kind of trick. "How do you know all of this?"
“I make it my business to know,” says Todd. “Ah, here we are.”
Across a grassy plain, at the edge of the treeline, I see a tall wooden carving of a bear, a boar, a wolf, and a large bird perched on the bear’s back. A flat platform lies at the base of the statue, covered in orchid bouquets and folded pieces of paper.
As we get closer, I notice the grass in this area is brown and crunchy beneath my shoes. In fact, the nearest trees are nothing more than dead husks with skeletal branches blowing in the wind. Compared to the lush vibrancy of the rest of the grassy plain and surrounding jungle, this little plant graveyard gives me the creeps.
I stand in front of the altar and pick up one of the slips of paper. It reads: Please help my mom get better soon. Another says: Please keep Eugene safe during the negotiations. Another reads: Please bless me with a successful pregnancy.
“What is all this?”
“Prayers,” says Todd.
“What is that?” I point at the wooden statue, but what I mean is why is everything in this vicinity dead?
“A simple question, at last.” Todd trots over to the shrine and turns towards me, curling his tail around himself. “This, my dear, is where you were murdered.”
Chapter 5: Offerings Of A Different Kind
Chapter Text
The world seems to still. I don’t know what to do with myself. Sitting helps, but not much. I don’t even have it in me to read more prayers. I feel my full stomach grumble, wanting more.
Todd jumps off the altar, studying me with his cunning black eyes. “You’re not taking this very well.”
You just told me I was murdered, Todd. Yeah, I’m not taking this very well. I huff a laugh, but it quickly devolves into something unstable. Breathing in deep through my nose, I try to calm myself before I fly into the same panic that gripped me after Margo’s death. “How did I die?”
“I know a lot,” Todd tell me. “That is one of the few things I cannot confirm. Too much idle gossip, and nobody can keep their story straight.”
I instinctually reach out to pet him, hoping for the same comfort that Margo offered, but I pause halfway to his ears. "Um, I’m sorry, may I pet you?"
"I must admit I don't usually let people poke and prod me. But I will most definitely accept a good scratch behind the ears from you."
I scratch his ears and take in the nice weather. Sunshine, green grass in the distance, a floral scent on the wind. There were worse places for me to end up out of space and time.
“I promise I’m not stalking you.” I turn towards the voice and find Alex standing nearby in the dead grass, looking sheepish. “I saw you come out here and I just wanted to make sure you’re ok. Oh, hi Todd.”
Alex looks similar to my brother and sisters—thin and tall, brown eyes, dark hair, a well-defined jawline—the only main difference being my siblings were much tanner. Nothing like myself. I inherited the majority of my DNA from my father, unfortunately. I'm on the shorter, stockier side, with cheeks that bunch up when I smile. I at least received my mom’s long dark eyelashes instead of my dad’s invisible blonde ones. It’s something, at least. Sometimes it was all that kept me holding on in the wake of adoption jokes and general family alienation.
When she makes no move to sit next to me, I pat a patch of crispy grass and she decides to take a seat.
“So,” I start, motioning dramatically at the altar, “I apparently died here.”
Todd trots over and rests his head on his paws beside her. Alex smiles at the fox but doesn’t reach to pet him. “Yeah. This must be really weird for you. But you’re back now! So that’s good.”
No, no, no. That’s not how this works at all.
If these people think I’ve come back from the dead, it’s because I actually did die in the 70’s. The current me will become the past me when we time-travel.
Maybe if I find out what happened, I can stop it. From what I remember, island time travel runs on the“whatever happened, happened” logic. Theoretically, nothing can be changed about the past because whatever I’m going to do in the 70’s is what’s already happened. I am destined to die here.
I still want to know.
“Do you know what happened to me?”
Alex shakes her head no. “I guess it doesn’t really matter now that you're back, right?”
There must be someone on this island that knows how I died.
Alex clears her throat. “I’m shocked Erik and Liv let you come out here by yourself.”
“I kinda snuck out the window,” I admit with a shrug.
“Did you tell them about last night?”
“No,” I answer, frowning. “I figured it wasn’t a good idea to tell the people who hate you that you’ve already started bullying me.” Heat creeps up my face when her mouth presses into a hard, worried line. “Sorry, I was joking. Bad joke. I’m not mad at you.”
We sit in silence for so long, my face warms even more. I don’t know how to restart the conversation. I wipe my sweaty palms on the pants she gave me last night.
“Where did you get these clothes?” I ask when the silence becomes unbearable. Everything fit like a glove, even the bra, which is absolutely unheard of.
“They’re yours,” she says and falls silent again. I don’t even bother asking what she means. “Why didn’t you heal your eye?”
“Makes me tired. Wasn’t worth the trouble. Why? How bad does it look?”
“I’ve seen worse,” she assures me, smiling. “I’m really sorry about my dad.”
“That's ok.” I relax a little at her calmed state. It’s easier to talk to her if I pretend she’s one of my younger sisters. “I mean, I’m pretty sure picking fights at a family funeral is a coping mechanism.”
“Yeah, he’s not usually like that. He feels really bad. I could hear him moving around in the kitchen all night. He just. . . they were really close.” Alex grins at a memory and rips brown clumps from the ground. “Margo used to babysit me after my mom died. Mom never liked her much, though.”
I nod. Then I realize what she’s said. “You knew your mom?”
“Yeah.” She tilts her head in confusion and rips up more grass. “She came to live with me for a few years when I was a kid. I didn’t know her for very long before she got sick.”
Alex pauses, and I rack my brain to try and make sense of this, but it looks like a lot of what’s happened so far doesn’t make any sense. “I’m sorry,” I tell her. “That must have been hard.”
“I don’t miss her. I mean,” she adds quickly, “I kind of do, but not. . . I don’t know. Not the way I think I’m supposed to, you know?” She pauses, looking embarrassed. “That’s terrible, isn’t it?”
“No, I don’t think so.” And I don’t. It’s like all my distant relatives I never met in Sicily. I may feel sad if I hear they’ve gotten sick or passed away, but it's not the same as losing someone you’re close to. I wouldn’t be surprised if Alex was more torn up over Margo’s death than she was her mother’s. “If you didn’t really know her, that makes sense. Just to confirm,” I add, “your mom’s name was Danielle, right?”
“Mm-hm,” she hums confirmation.
Yay. Even more information I don’t understand. None of this is matching up to my knowledge of what’s supposed to happen. There are actual Vikings here, I apparently destroyed Dharma, Danielle Rousseau was welcomed into the Others, and I have bootlegged island powers that make me hibernate if I use them.
I don’t even know if I can use them on other people. Would it feel the same as when I heal myself?
I think about how nauseous I was while my forehead healed and suddenly remember how sleepy I was when I touched Claire’s stomach. “Alex, do you know what the plan is for the survivors?”
“They’re having a meeting about it now,” she says, wagging a thumb back towards the houses. “Your people want custody of them all. Ours want custody of a few.” She leans her head back in the sun. “They’re always fighting.”
“What about the man who shot Margo?”
Alex snaps her head up. “What about him?”
I need some semblance of normalcy or I’m going to spend the rest of my existence here flying from one anxiety attack to the other. I need to talk to someone who isn’t fundamentally different from the character I know from the show. I need to talk to Sawyer.
“I want to see him. Please, Alex.” Judging from her expression, she wants nothing to do with the man who just shot and killed her friend. I try guilt instead. “You owe me a favor. Please. I really need to talk to him. Can you show me where he’s being kept?”
The door leading into the recreational room has been barred with chains and a padlock.
“Great,” I huff sarcastically. “Now what?”
“Just break it,” Alex suggests. At my confused expression, she adds, “You’re freakishly strong. Just. . .” Alex mimes ripping the chains apart.
Huh. I get a good grip on the chain and pull. I change my grip, take a deep breath, and pull harder, but no matter the strain, no matter how hard I concentrate, it’s clear nothing’s happening. “Uh, Alex? I think you’ve been lied to.”
I watch her expression morph into wide-eyed worry at something behind me a split second before I hear a familiar voice ask, “What do you think you’re doing?”
I stumble forward, away from him, spinning around only when I’ve bumped into Alex.
Ben looks curiously from me to Alex, seemingly waiting for an explanation. I think about asking to speak with Sawyer, but I don’t get the chance. “Go home, Alexandria,” he says.
“I was just—”
“Home. Now.”
I expect her to fight, or at least whine a complaint. I don’t expect her to give me a small shrug of apology and listen to him.
Ben glances at Alex as she walks away, and then he turns to me, stepping closer and nodding with amusement at the chains. “Did you not think to just ask for the key?”
“Sorry.” I hate my face for betraying me and enflaming at his teasing tone. “May I please have the key?”
In a few steps, Ben’s standing in front of me. He’s taller than I am—most people are—and I have to look up at him. It leaves me feeling vulnerable in a way I cannot explain, and I suddenly wish I had brought that kitchen knife with me.
“No.” His eyebrows furrow slightly, as if he’s confused as to why I’d ask.
“Right.” I can’t figure out where to look. “Okay.”
“Wait. Wait, Miss Collins,” he calls as I try to sidestep him and get the hell out of here. “A word, please.”
I feel my heartbeat quicken even more at his much more friendly tone. “Please tell me you don’t need another favor.”
This time he snorts a brief laugh. “No. Actually, it dawned on me this morning that we’ve yet to be properly introduced.” He holds out a hand to shake. “Benjamin Linus. Pleasure to meet you.” His grip is firm, and his hands are warm and dry. He offers me a smile—one of the lopsided ones that are more smirk than smile.
“Cora,” I say. His lopsided smile grows into a grin, but his eyes are dark with lack of sleep. He looks as annoyed and tired as I feel, and I wonder how long it took to conclude Margo’s funeral. When he releases the shake, I cross my arms over my chest.
I expect him to nod and leave. Maybe make a sarcastic remark. Try and pry information out of me. The last thing I expect him to say is, “I believe I owe you an apology.”
I look up in surprise. “Huh?”
“I shouldn’t have pressured you into helping us last night, and for that I hope you can forgive me. I must confess, I’ve never been very good with grief.” He waits for me to respond, but I’m dumbstruck by his relaxed expression.
“Happy to help.” I wonder if Ben’s the only person who hates me because Margo is dead. Alex doesn’t seem to hate me. Did Margo have other friends? “I’m sorry for your loss.”
“Thank you.”
I haven’t seen him smile once since I’ve been here, and now it just freaks me out. There’s something forced, something manic about it. I want to get back home so Liv and Erik can get me out of here. I glance behind him, but I don’t see either of them. I don’t see anyone.
“Liv is not going to be pleased when she realizes you’ve given her the slip,” Ben comments, sounding amused. “It took a lot for her to relinquish her spot at this morning’s meeting to that hothead Erik, but she insisted on being the one to watch over you while you’re here.”
“Nobody told me there was a meeting.”
“Sorry for the lack of invite. It was my understanding that you needed sleep.” He draws out the last two words in emphasis. “You must still be exhausted. Do you want to sit down? I know somewhere we can continue this conversation.” He pauses, waiting, but I make no move to walk in the direction he’s pointing—the direction Alex headed off in.
Continue this conversation? Great. What does he want this time? I rack my brain for memories of his character so I can keep myself in check. Selfish. Egotistical. Deceitful. Power-hungry. Charming.
Charming, yes. It’s almost all in the voice. His way of saying things so softly, yet so assuredly. It’s actually rather difficult to focus on what he’s saying when he speaks because everything he says sounds like he’s flirting with me, which just makes me more embarrassed.
He looks sincere—I’ll give him that much—but I don’t want this conversation to go on any longer. He’s talking to me for a reason. Ben doesn’t waste small talk. He got what he wanted. He got Margo. This must be pure damage control so I don’t get angry and tell Liv and Erik what really happened last night.
No, he does still need me.
Right. Spinal tumor. He needs me to help him recover from surgery once Jack operates on him.
Jack. The survivors. Claire.
Sawyer. Remember the entire reason you’re here?
“I want to talk to Sawyer,” I manage to say. “Please.”
Ben takes a few steps away, ignoring me, before glancing back to make sure I’m following. “You coming?”
If the meeting is over, where is Erik? Did Liv figure out I’m missing? Why the hell did I leave without telling her? What is wrong with me? Why didn't I at least grab a knife? Sweat dots the back of my neck, and it’s suddenly difficult to swallow. “The last time I followed you somewhere, I got this.” I point at my black eye. “I want to talk to Sawyer.”
“No harm will come to James,” he promises solemnly. “You have my word. Don’t you want a briefing about our negotiations? We’ve come to a consensus about what’s. . . what’s to be done with. . .” His speech slows to a stop as he stares, confused.
I look behind me, but we’re still the only two people in the area.
“Your eye,” he explains. “You just healed your eye.”
“No I didn’t.” I blink and realize he’s right. The tightness has lifted. My fingers probe the surrounding area, but it no longer feels bruised. A rush of lightheadedness hits. “Oh, great.” I heave an exasperated sigh. “I have no idea how this works.”
“You should probably sit down,” he suggests.
I follow him to the nearest house because I’m dizzy and don’t know what else to do. If I wasn’t this dizzy, I’d try my luck wandering around and finding my own house. How hard could it be? It’s the one covered in offerings.
But I am dizzy. And I don’t think I would make it.
I wish Todd was still here, but he wandered off while Alex and I walked to the rec room. A witness would be nice in case something happens to me while I’m passed out. I take a seat on someone’s porch and the shade instantly cools my feverish skin.
My one consolation is that now that I’m sitting, I don’t think I’m in immediate danger of blacking out. Instead of the tunneling vision and nausea I remember from the beach, I just feel lightheaded. I focus on breathing and staying conscious.
“Would you like to come in?”
I look over to find Ben half inside the doorway. Something about his stance seems awkward, but I can’t place it. All I know is this must be his house, and I am not going inside. “No, thank you,” I say. The fresh air is the only thing keeping me from vomiting on your porch. “The fresh air is nice.”
He nods in a curt jerk of his head and disappears.
This is giving me a migraine.
A slice of cake hovers in offering close to my nose. I smell the familiar scent of my favorite dessert, and my mouth instantly fills with saliva.
“I whipped up an apology cake last night,” Ben explains, handing me the plate, fork, and a glass of milk. “Apologies for getting off on the wrong foot.” He motions at the chair next to me. “Do you mind if I sit with you?”
I nod for him to sit because I don’t have any idea how to say go away.
“Thank you,” he says. Once he’s seated, he spears a corner of his own slice and waits, his fork hovering over the plate. It takes me a second to realize he’s waiting for me to eat first.
I expect it to be serviceable. It’s easy to make good tiramisu. A little more difficult to make great tiramisu. But what I put in my mouth reminds me of the cake my grandmother used to make. It’s such a shock to my tastebuds I stop chewing and just let it sit on my tongue for a second.
Ben sounds defeated when he asks, “Is it that bad?”
I look over to find Ben eyeing me intensely. I quickly finish chewing and shake my head. “No, this is excellent. Where did you learn to make tiramisu like this?”
Of all the things I’ve said today, for some reason this is what seems to throw him off. There’s a bewildered pause before he says, “Cookbook.”
I don’t laugh because I think it’s funny, I laugh because this has been the weirdest week of my entire life.
Ben clears his throat. “May I ask you a question?” I nod for him to continue, and he places his fork down against the plate with a clank. “How does it work? Is it a direct word-for-word translation, or is it more intuitive?”
"No idea." I shovel cake in my mouth and shrug. “It just sounds like they’re speaking English.” I think about Scales’ speech compared to Margo or Brego. “Some better than others.” Cold sweat creeps up my neck and down my back as a wave of nausea hits out of nowhere. I put the fork down.
Instead of prodding further, Ben sounds annoyed when he asks, “Can you please give me a warning if you’re going to fall unconscious?”
Instead of feeling nervous at his tone, it just pisses me off. Why am I still here if I don’t want to be? I need to go back to the guesthouse. Hopefully Liv won’t get in trouble. Hopefully I won’t get in trouble.
A plump raccoon pulls himself up the porch steps and waddles over to my chair, reaching up with two grasping hands. “Gimme.”
“Leave her alone, Rocket,” Ben chastises. The raccoon waddles closer to Ben’s chair and stands on two legs, this time pointing a claw at something behind Ben. “No,” says Ben, “I’m not looking behind me so you can steal my cake. That trick only works once.”
Rocket huffs with annoyance.
I cut a piece and bend down to hold it out for him. Instead of accepting the small portion in my hand, Rocket quickly reaches up and scoops the rest of my cake off the plate.
“You’re my new favorite,” Rocket tells me as he retreats down the steps on two feet, the cake cradled in his hands.
Did I just get played by a raccoon? I frown at his comedic figure in the distance. My slice is gone in only a few greedy mouthfuls, and I feel my stomach protest. Despite the wavering nausea, that cake was delicious, and I had all of maybe three bites.
Hey, wait a second. “I thought you were going to tell me about the meeting.”
Ben is already standing to take my plate. “Do you want another piece?”
No, I would like to know about the meeting. “No, thank you.”
“Would you like some lunch?” he offers. “I can make—”
I leap up out of my seat and stumble down the stairs in a mad dash to get in the grass. It feels like my body is desperately trying to purge itself of everything it’s eaten since the 3rd grade. Once I run out of food, my stomach keeps contracting until I end up sweaty and gagging on nothing.
I feel a hand on my shoulder and violently shrug it off.
“It’s me,” says Alex. “I’m putting your hair up. Here, I got you some water.”
I gag again, frustrated that I cannot stop heaving even though I’ve run out of everything including bile. Through the welling tears, I see someone approaching.
“I’m assuming this is going to be a no for the orange trees?”
“Tom,” I hear Ben warn, “do you honestly think now is the appropriate time?”
“Aw, come on,” Tom begs. “Those things haven’t produced fruit in like 2 years. I love oranges so much—”
“She’s not blessing the orange trees, Tom,” Ben snaps. “Go home.”
Alex holds a water cup in offering and I rinse my mouth out. I take a few gulps and immediately throw it back up.
I hear Alex whisper, “Are we in trouble?”
For a second I think she’s talking to me. Then I hear Ben answer, “No, she has to stop eventually.”
Another voice joins the conversation.
“While I have you all here at this disgusting impromptu assembly, just wanted to make it abundantly clear I’m not going with you to orgy island, Linus.” Jane holds up a hand when Ben tries to counter. “I’m not going to orgy island. Never again. Not happening.”
“I thought you’d be excited to join us? Erik mentioned they patched their masonry ovens. There will be plenty of bread. And jam,” he adds, giving her a knowing look, but this only makes her more hostile. “You’re going,” he concludes. “We need a female representative present.”
“I literally could not give less of a shit,” Jane sneers. “Take Veronica.”
“She’s on assignment.”
“Take Cole. Jessie. Beatrice?”
“They’re not equipped for this sort of thing.”
Jane shakes a thumb at the man standing beside her. “Put a wig on Tom.”
Tom makes a face. “Hard pass.”
“I’ll go,” Alex offers. “Please dad?”
“Yeah,” Jane adds excitedly. “She’s finally of age. Take Alex.”
Ben frowns. “You’re going, Jane.”
“You owe me so much vacation time.” Jane makes an exaggerated groan of annoyance and blinks at me, as if she’s just noticed I’m here. “And you better not have drank all my milk.”
Is she talking to me? She’s looking at me.
“Or messed up my bookshelf,” Jane continues. “They’re not organized by alphabetical order, so I hope you weren’t trying to be helpful.”
“I was staying in your house?” My stomach begins to churn again. “I’m sorry. I thought it was a guesthouse.”
“I had to stay with Daphne. She owns a damn peacock.” Jane narrows her angry eyes at me. "Do you have any idea how loud a peacock is?”
“I’m sorry.”
“Whatever,” she dismisses and looks at Ben. “I cannot wait to get this over with. When do they want to leave? Oh, look at that,” she huffs sarcastically. “I’ll just ask them myself.”
“Dad?” Alex asks nervously.
I follow her eyes and find a furious Erik and Liv storming towards us.
“It’s all right,” Ben tells her calmly. “Stay here. I’ll talk to them.”
Jane snorts. “I hope he gets clocked.”
“Erik or Ben?” Tom asks.
“Either would be fine by me,” she clarifies and cracks her neck. “It’s so boring around here.”
After the fiasco that was riding Brego wildly through the night, I never thought I’d miss riding horseback, but I have officially made up my mind.
Walking is worse.
The direction we’re headed is opposite the one I took to see Jacob, so the terrain is brand new, although not much different from the rest of the island. Fortunately, there are far less birds here. If I hear voices, they all belong to the excited norsemen who joined our travel party halfway through. Most laugh at what the other is saying, and there seems to be an overwhelmingly positive vibe.
I wish I could understand their language better.
“They are excited to return home,” Liv tells me. “Most have not seen their wives for a month.”
Unfortunately, Liv wasn’t quite as forgiving of my window escape as I’d hoped. Although she didn’t technically yell at me, her disappointment and worry were more than enough to shame me into silence. She didn’t even seem particularly upset that I healed my eye and got sick. Now she stays glued to my side.
“Why were they away so long?”
“In preparation for your return,” she says. “Last minute negotiations and such.”
Speaking of negotiations. . . “Liv, do you know what’s going to happen to the survivors from the beach?”
“I wasn’t at the meeting, as you know.” She gives me a look, and I regret asking. “But I spoke with Erik. They’ve been fed and sheltered,” she answers. “We have some of our best guards watching over them for now, until we can wrap up Jacob’s ridiculous demands.”
“What demands?”
Liv sighs, and I worry I’m annoying her. “His followers have a list of people they claim ownership of. It’s not how we have ever distributed followers. Erik will not allow it.”
I’m relieved to hear Claire and the rest of the people back at the beach at least have food and shelter for the time being. The people Liv is referring to must be Jacob’s candidate list. Jack. Kate. Sawyer. Hugo. Sun. Jin. Claire? I honestly can’t remember who else was on it.
I wonder how big the list is. Surely it can’t be massive. But then why would Erik so passionately shut down a conversation about distributing the survivors amongst the two communities?
Liv is the first person to give me a straight and informative answer as to what the hell is going on, but before I can ask her anything else, we break through the trees and enter a long stretch of sandy beach, headed towards a large longship.
“We’re taking a boat?” It comes bursting out of me without warning. “Wait, where are we going? I thought the temple was inland?” That’s what Todd said.
“Who told you that?” Liv holds out a hand to help me board a long plank leading up into the ship. “Your temple is across the water on a smaller island. Ah, we’re in luck. The winds are good today. We may not even need to row.”
Do not freak out. This obviously isn’t the first time they’ve sailed this ship. Just make sure you sit in a middle seat, and nothing will happen. Vikings are famous seafarers. We won’t sink. We definitely won’t sink.
“My Lady?”
I don’t know how to swim.
“Thanks.” I grab hold of Liv’s outstretched hand and try my best not to give away the levels of rising anxiety welling inside my chest as I walk up the narrow plank. Once inside, I stand awkwardly out of the way, trying to figure out where to sit.
“You three near the prow, in case we need to row,” a man points at me and then points at the bench seats closest to the front of the boat.
“Shotgun,” Jane yells, pushes past me, and plops down on the front seat, stretching out her long legs across the bench. She fishes around in a backpack for something, pulls out a walkman and a pair of sunglasses, and relaxes.
She’s taking up most of the bench, but I’m definitely not sitting on the edge, nearest the water. I take a seat next to her feet. I can hear the music in her headphones from here.
“Pardon me, Miss Collins.” Ben hoists a bag over the bench beside me, climbs over, looks at Jane, and frowns. “Really?”
“Oh, I’m sorry,” Jane says. “I can’t hear you.” With a few taps on the side of the walkman, the music in her already loud earphones gets even louder.
Ben sits next to me in what little space is left, his posture tense and ridged. In fact, he’s pressed so hard against the side of the boat, he’s somehow managed not to touch me at all. I look at him out of the corner of my eyes, but he’s not looking at me. He’s focused on the men remaining on the island as they toss up the ropes securing the ship to the beach.
Suddenly, we’re moving, and I’m not ready. We lurch forward and start drifting right, and the momentum is strong enough for me to finally panic. I grab the nearest thing and cling for dear life, which just so happens to be Jane’s legs.
“Can you not?” she yells and shakes me off.
“Sorry,” I whisper, even though I know she can’t hear me.
A roaring whoosh sounds from behind me. I twist around to see what’s happening and watch as a few men pull at ropes to unfurl a massive painted sail that fills with the wind. With this newfound speed, the boat gains a steady push and pull of gravity as it slightly bobs up and down across the waves.
I can’t swim, and I think I may already be seasick.
One of the norsemen brought a lute and a few of them join together in song as he plucks away at the strings. I wish it was enough to distract me from what feels very much like intense carsickness.
“What’s that?” I ask, pointing at the plain sack at Ben’s feet, partly because the nausea is making me delirious, and partly because I’m nosy. I noticed when I looked back at the sail that he’s wearing a backpack, which I assume has his provisions. Jane only brought a backpack.
Ben glances at me for a moment, and then looks back out at the sea. “A gift for your seer.”
A seer? “What specifically does she see? Fortunes?”
“Prophecies. Glimpses into the future. Although,” he adds with exceptional dryness, “the current one is particularly cryptic.”
Finally! Answers at last. I relax a little and start forming a long list of things I want to ask, but it doesn’t last long. I am most definitely about to throw up.
I’m seated on the inner part of the ship, so I can’t just lean over and throw up in the ocean. I’m either getting sick all over Jane or all over Ben. I convulse slightly at the thought, my fist to my mouth, sending out a silent prayer to keep the food I ate before we left in my stomach a little longer. In one swift movement, Ben shakes open the bag and offers it, which I barely grab in time.
“Alright, you win,” Jane says in disgust and moves her legs off the bench, scooting away from me.
I spit the rest of my residual sick into the bag. Only after the nausea begins to subside do I start burning with embarrassment. “I’m so sorry,” I finally apologize when Ben doesn’t say anything.
“Apology not necessary.”
“I ruined your gift.”
“The gift is in this other bag.” Ben pulls another bag up off the floor and rests it on his knee. “That bag was always for you.”
“Don’t worry, Lady Cora,” Liv bellows from somewhere behind us. “You’ll get your sea-legs back in no time.”
I glance back at her only to find Todd wrapped comfortably around her shoulders. He waves at me with his tail.
I’m not sure what I expected. A crowd? At least a small crowd? We’ve docked on a shore where maybe five women await us. Honestly, it’s a relief. Crowds mean a higher chance of people touching me.
One of the men straight up jumped off the ship and swam to shore when he saw his wife. I heard her laugh and call him a dumbass in English. The rest of the men secure the oars, tie the sail, and walk down the plank like the rest of us.
It was windy at sea, but it’s somehow even more windy on the shore of Hydra Island. Enough to make me unsteady on the walk off the ship. A man sees me struggling and grabs me under the arms, setting me down firmly on the dock. I’ve never been so happy to be back on dry land.
Liv approaches, looking happier than I’ve ever seen her. Todd is gone again. “First line of business is to talk to my daughter. She’s in the Hall of Freyja. It’s this way.”
As we walk further into the trees, more women appear, although most are much older than I expected. They don’t say anything. They just stare at me, smiling. Everyone is dressed in something embroidered with flowers and bright colored necklaces. Im surprised nobody has their hair braided. Instead, they wear it long and flowing.
From out of the on-lookers, an elderly woman approaches. I expect her to delve into some sort of long-winded welcome, tell me she remembers me, or fall at my feet and make me feel guilty for her ailing knees.
I don’t expect her to hurry right by me and spit angrily in Ben’s face. Even more surprising is the fact that he doesn’t even flinch. He simply continues walking and reaches up to wipe the spittle off on his shirtsleeve.
“Yeesh,” Jane comments in disgust and hurries her pace so she’s no longer next to him. “Her aim’s getting better.”
“What was that about?” I ask her.
“Your people are famous for holding grudges,” Jane says cryptically. “No forgetting, no forgiving. Just lots of spitting.”
I want to ask her what kind of grudge that woman has against Ben, but now I cannot help but notice that lots of women are muttering something, spitting on him, at him, and in his general direction. The old woman must have broken some kind of emotional dam because someone throws a small rock.
Jane grabs my shoulder and strangles it in an effort to keep me from turning to tell them to stop. “Don’t,” she hisses. “You’ll only make it worse. Trust me, he’s used to it by now.”
Up a small hill, amongst a stretch of healthy green grass, an enormous longhouse covered in brightly colored flowers of every shade sits in the middle of what looks to be a bustling fish town.
Ben stops before we reach the door to the floral building and takes a seat on a bench. “Men aren’t allowed in,” he answers before I can ask.
Jane sighs heavily. “Well, let’s get this over with.”
Two women tug open one of the massive wooden doors and beckon us inside. We walk down a small hallway lined with candles, each wall painted with incredibly realistic images of naked women. It immediately makes me stifle a giggle out of pure shock.
“What is this place?” I whisper to Jane.
“What do you mean what is this place?” Jane snaps irritably. “Its your temple.”
We exit the hallway and enter what looks like a sizable greenhouse. Vines hang down from the high ceiling, interspersed with even more flowers and enormous candle-lit chandeliers. Crammed shoulder to shoulder, silent but obviously excited, are dozens upon dozens of young women of various ages. Some carry babies, some rest a protective hand on the top of their young children’s hair. They’ve made a narrow walkway for us, and it feels beyond claustrophobic.
I keep following Liv because I don’t know what to do with myself. “Liv said we were going to the Hall of Freyja.”
“Yeah,” Jane says, looking at me like I’m stupid. “Congratulations, we’re here.”
That’s when the first woman touches my hair. I shrink away, but this only gives access to the women standing on the other side of the walkway to run their fingers through. The women smile and tell me something, or ask me something, I have no idea. I just want them to stop touching me.
I’m so distracted by the unpleasant feeling of multiple strangers running their fingers over my scalp that I crash into the back of Liv. We’ve stopped at the far side of the longhouse, where an elevated throne of plants lies at the top of a platform.
On either side of the platform are two large painted statues carved of wood. The left is of a terrifying woman wearing a heavily layered outfit, long bulky cloak, and an intricate headpiece.
The right statue is dancing, arms raised gracefully above her head, hips slightly tilted, eyes heavy-lidded and sultry, clothed from the waist down in a slitted skirt, but completely and utterly topless. I double and triple-check the face to make absolutely sure this is supposed to be me, but there is no mistaking that face or that body for anyone else.
People are looking at this. Children are looking at this. Everyone can clearly see this naked statue of my breasts. Who carved this? Whose idea was this? Just. . . why? I am so beyond mortified, I burst into loud laughter, immediately bringing a hand up over my mouth and regretting the noise I make.
Jane nudges my side. “They just repainted those. Nice.”
I want a crack in the earth to swallow me whole and crush me to dust so I don’t have to be here anymore.
“Way to keep us waiting,” a sarcastic voice calls from atop the throne. “We were told you’d be here almost three days ago.”
Through the swirling smoke and candlelight, I focus on the face of the man and my nose slowly scrunches in confusion. “Miles?”
Miles Straume steps off the throne platform and approaches, looking at Jane. “Should I be worried or flattered that she already knows who I am?”
Liv gives a long, drawn out shout of joy before lifting Miles up off the floor in a bear hug, kissing the side of his head.
“Light of my life,” he wheezes, “you’re crushing me.”
“You’re the seer?” I ask aghast. I’m confused as to how he’s even here. He’s not supposed to be here until much later, shipped in on a freighter offshore. Yet here he stands, dressed in an embroidered tunic, belt, and pants, smiling at me with pity in his eyes.
“Ok good, you don’t actually know what’s going on.” Miles laughs and shakes his head. “Nah, I’m no seer. You’re here to talk to my beloved spawn. That’s the only reason I’m allowed access in here.” I was so thrown off by his presence that I didn’t even notice there’s a woman sitting on the throne. “Go on up,” says Miles, “she's waiting for you. She’s been waiting for three days.”
Chapter 6: Violent Marriage Proposals
Chapter Text
Nonna is going to kill me. My nonna is going to come back from beyond the grave and kill me for being a part of this pagan nightmare.
I look up at the woman sitting atop the throne and contemplate how realistic it would be for me to turn around, leave this building, walk into the ocean, and drown.
Is that the key to getting back to life as normal? Does this place work on video game logic? If I die here, will I wake up back in my old life?
Jane gives me a small shove toward the platform, but I'm so lost in thought I can't hear what she's saying. I decide it's completely unrealistic to try and escape this room and even more unrealistic to try and drown because I'm never going to be left alone ever again. It was a blessing to only have to deal with Liv and Erik following me around, but now I'm crammed in a room of who knows how many women who don't look like they're going anywhere anytime soon.
Maybe I'm already dead and this is my version of Hell?
"What are you doing?" Jane hisses. "It's so hot in here. Hurry this up. I want to leave."
I start climbing the steps towards the woman. She's clothed in an enormous flowing cape made of brown feathers. A strip of light leather is wrapped around her forehead like a headband, the lower half cut into thin strips hanging over her eyes so she can see me but I cannot see her. As I get closer, something feels off. Her proportions make no sense. Although her height matches that of an average adult, her arms are too short and her head is too small. It isn't until she speaks that I realize she looks so odd because she's a small child.
The little girl opens her mouth and the tiniest, sweetest voice I've ever heard comes out. "How are you feeling, Lady Cora?"
Existential. "Good," I answer. "How are you feeling?"
"My shoulders are a little sore from holding up the community in your stead." She leans forward conspiratorially and whispers, "My dad said to say that."
"That ruins the joke, Aiko." Miles walks up behind me and stands next to her chair. "You going to tell her you're sitting on a stack of books, too?"
"I'm sitting on a stack of books, too," she says, smiling.
Todd appears, scampering up the steps and leaping into Aiko's lap, sending the girl into a fit of giggles as he licks her face. So far, the only thing that makes any sense to me is the fact that Todd would be friends with the island seer.
"Can I take this off now, dad? It's itchy." Aiko is suddenly lost in heaps upon heaps of brown feathers as she slips down over the edge of the throne and pops up at my feet, freed from the massive cloak. "You can have it back now, Lady Cora."
I'm honestly too confused to think of something to say, so I pull the cloak off the throne, move the books Aiko was sitting on, and take a seat.
Without warning, Aiko is climbing up onto my lap, and it takes all my willpower not to ask her to please get off. She finally settles her tiny form and then turns her head to look at me. Only, she's not looking at me. At this distance I can see her eyes peaking through the leather fringe. She's looking in my general direction, but her eyes are unfocused.
"How old are you?"
"Aiko," Miles scolds, but he doesn't sound even slightly angry. "You don't ask people that."
"I'm six." She raises the appropriate amount of fingers. "I want to see you, please."
"Okay," I say because what else am I supposed to say.
I've heard stories of the blind touching people's faces as a way of constructing a mental image of what they look like. She begins with my chin first and works her way upward, her little fingers tracing the length of my nose and curve of my cheeks. "You're really pretty for an old lady."
I try to offer a friendly smile, realize I'm a dumbass because she can't see me, and say, "Thank you."
When she's finished, she smiles and takes my hand, her eyes shifting around randomly.
"Anything?" Miles asks.
"No," Aiko replies and lets go of my hand. "Not right now." She brightens at a sudden thought and starts bouncing slightly in my lap. "Is Ben here? I hope he brought me more chocolate."
I wonder what my life would have been like if my dad had ever smiled at me with a fraction of the affection Miles smiles at Aiko. "Let's go check, little bug," he tells her. "We'll let you get settled in, Cora."
Let me get settled into what? Am I supposed to be doing something?
Miles scoops Aiko up and balances her on his hip as he carries her down the stairs and hands her to Liv. I can still hear her chanting "chocolate, chocolate, chocolate!" as they maneuver their way through the crowd and out the hall.
As if a hive-mind, every woman and child in the room dips down at the exact same time into a crouch, and leans forward onto their knees. Those without babies lean forward into a bow. Those holding small children lower their heads instead.
"May I be frank?" Todd asks with a flick of his red tail. I didn't realize he was still here. "Your return to this island is the most interesting thing to happen since the day I was born. And do you want to know what else I think?"
I look down at him, happy to avert my eyes from the large crowd of women. "I'm sure you're about to tell me anyway."
Todd looks up, and I don't like what I see in his mischievous eyes. "I think you're in for a world of trouble." And with that he hurries away after Aiko.
I haven't decided yet, but I think I might be able to survive in this role. All I have to do is what I always do when things reach a point of absolute overload—shut off my brain and substitute thoughts and anxiety with whatever random song comes to mind.
Currently, I'm listening to Believe by Cher.
If I'm supposed to be doing something, nobody informed me. I just sit atop the throne and space out. Time passes quickly in this state, which is both a blessing and a curse because now I'm hungry and my growling stomach snaps me out of my musical trance and brings back the anxiety. In order to eat, I have to talk to someone. But I don't want to talk to these women because Jane, Liv, Miles, and Aiko have left the Temple long ago and I'm not sure any of the remaining women speak English.
Thankfully, Jane returns at some point and starts yelling at me from the base of the stairs. "You're allowed to leave, you know? Hurry up and come down here. Your whack-ass followers are trying to convince me to wear a bunch of ceremonial crap for the engagement party."
Engagement party? "Who's getting married?"
Jane cups a hand to her ear. "What?"
I stand up and walk down the stairs, trying my best to ignore the eyes of the crowd who have done nothing for the past few hours except stare silently at me. Jane is so much taller than Ben, I have to tilt my head back to look up at her face. "Do you know who is getting married?"
Jane shrugs, already headed towards the hallway exit.
I whisper, "Do you know if any of these women speak English?"
"You didn't ask them yourself?"
I didn't ask because I thought it would be rude. "I've been sitting up there this whole time."
Jane sighs and glares down at me with contempt. "You really need to pull your head out of your ass," she sneers, "or we're all royally screwed."
An older woman named Gail leads me to an even larger longhouse than the Hall of Freyja. I assume this is where everyone eats because it's filled with banquet tables and benches. Near the back of the hall are two doors hidden in the wall, leading into a secret fully furnished bedroom. For a moment I stare in confusion at all the fur on the bed and the floor and the walls. Then I remember what Ben said before Margo's funeral. These all belonged to animals that died of natural causes.
I still haven't decided how all of this makes me feel.
"I hope you've settled in nicely so far?" Gail asks. "I had all of your clothes sent here as soon as word reached me you'd arrived. They've been recently washed. Should smell like lavender," she tells me excitedly.
The part of me that my mother raised—the part that struggles to tell an elder what to do—takes over, and I end up standing awkwardly near the bed while the woman chatters nonstop. Gail's tall with a regal nature to everything she does, like a retired Disney Princess. Or a lawyer.
I want her to leave, but she pulls different colored gowns from a wardrobe and starts laying them beside me on the bed for a vote. "I'm so sorry," I ask wearily, "but do I know you?"
Gail's eyes cloud with sadness for a moment while she debates how to answer. "You don't remember me?" She laughs, but I can tell she doesn't mean it. "Unlike you, I grew old."
"I already know your name is Gail, but. . ." I hold out an unsteady hand for her to shake. "It's nice to officially meet you."
She doesn't immediately take it. "So it's true?" Gail asks sadly. "You have no memory of your past life?"
"Yeah." I retract my hand. "Sorry."
"Well, that's . . ." She frowns, sighs heavily, and turns to sift through more gowns. "I suppose I should have realized something was amiss when you didn't call for me upon arrival. Oh, you can start undressing, dear. I'm almost done."
I open my mouth, but nothing comes out, and I end up gaping at her in a mixture of horror and confusion.
"I used to be your lady in waiting," Gail explains. "I was responsible for bathing you, dressing you, fixing your hair and makeup for parties, and suiting you up for battle. There is literally nothing you have that I haven't seen a dozen times before." She smiles and turns back to the wardrobe. "If there is, I'll be sure to throw a rock at it."
I itch at my arm for no reason other than to do something. "Sorry, it's just . . ." I don't know you.
But Gail isn't even listening to me. She continues to pull out dresses, judge them accordingly, and either put them back or place them on the bed, humming as she does it. Gail doesn't fit into the adorable grandmother stereotype, but I still feel a foreign sense of peace around her. I don't know her, but she feels safe. As I stand immobile, trying to figure out a way to get out of undressing, I feel almost as foolish as I do awkward. After all, she's an old woman. Even if she hadn't been my lady in waiting once upon a time, there still isn't anything I have that she doesn't.
But I detest the sensation of being naked. You're ultimately vulnerable to everything, and I have absolutely no interest in looking at my body and even less interest in letting someone else see it, even if that someone else is a woman who has apparently already seen me naked countless times.
"You don't have to do that," I tell her, my face already warming with embarrassment. "I'll just wear what I came here in. It's fine."
"Normally I wouldn't begrudge you," she says. I watch her eyes trail from my feet to my head, and I feel even worse about myself. "But not tonight. It would be an insult to the happy couple to show up in anything less than your best."
Wedding party. Right. "Who's the happy couple?"
"Bjorn and Poppy." Gail answers with a cheerful smile. "It was a long time coming. Those two have been head over heels since they were children." She lays one last dress down and nods at the pile. "Well, these are the ones I recommend. You have quite the selection. Just let me know which ones you'd like to try on first."
"Thank you." I pick up a long dress and immediately put it aside in the "no" pile. It's deep red with black detailing and has the lowest, most dramatic cut I've ever seen in my life down the front center. This slit would probably reach my bellybutton. How are my boobs even supposed to stay covered in this? Unless, that doesn't matter? I mean, there's literally a topless statue of me in the longhouse next-door.
I huff a sigh and keep looking. Absolutely everything is low cut, and one of the dresses is a single layer of completely sheer organza. Why even wear anything at that point?
Eventually, I settle on a gown that offers the most coverage, which still isn't saying all that much. The dress itself is white, but it's speckled with colorful fabric flowers of various sizes across the bodice. Instead of sleeves, a chain of fabric flowers hang down across each bicep. It's beautiful, but my worry is of being grossly overdressed. I want to wear a dress that matches the more plain ones I've seen on the other women here.
Gail will have none of it. "Alright," she tells me, shaking out the gown and holding it open, "step in."
I'm peer pressured to take off my shirt and pants and bra and stand shaking and upset in my underwear while she straps me into the gown. I stand perfectly still while her fingers work to lace the corseted back, stopping to ask if it's too tight along the way.
I take one look at myself in the mirror and feel sick. "I don't want to wear this."
"Oh?" Gail finishes tying the back and stands beside me. "Which one do you want to try on next?"
None of them. This was the only gown that had any chance of covering my chest in a meaningful way, but even this is ridiculous. The corset has pushed my boobs up and together in such a vulgar way I feel like a reject tavern wench from a renaissance faire. I feel like this dress is trying to pathetically accommodate for the fact that I don't have a thin waist, and my body is not supposed to be wearing a dress that belongs on someone like Claire or Kate or Juliet or—
"Cora?"
I jerk my head to look at her, surprised to hear someone call me by my name and nothing more. Not Lady Cora. Just Cora. My eyes find hers and all at once I realize I'm about to cry.
"What's wrong, sweetheart?"
Get ahold of yourself. Are you serious? I breathe in through my nose and try to swallow down the lump in my throat. "I don't want to wear this, Gail."
Instead of showing me more from the wardrobe, Gail takes a seat at the edge of the bed and clasps my hands in hers. "Why are you upset?"
I blink and she's my grandmother, comforting me after an especially terrible day at school. I had spent weeks building up the courage to break out of my standard look of sweatshirts and wore a tighter fitting t-shirt with a vintage graphic on the front. It barely took any time at all to regret it. Young people are cruel, but even more so if you're fat.
I want to talk to Gail as if she were my grandma, but she's not. She wouldn't understand why I'm the way that I am, and why it's useless to ask me questions like "why are you upset?" because it's never one thing. It's a million things.
"I must admit," she says kindly, "I haven't the slightest clue as to how your rebirthing process works, but you must be terribly confused having come back without any memories. This is a lot to take in for the uninitiated."
"I don't know what's going on." I decide to be honest. "I don't know what's going on at all, Gail."
She sits and talks to me. Talks about what to expect at the banquet being thrown in a few hours. Talks about what will be and what won't be expected of me during the specific engagement ceremonies throughout the night. She instructs me in how to say "approach me later" in Old Norse in case I get overwhelmed by someone who has gotten too drunk to speak English.
I calm down, except for the fact that I still don't know what to wear. "Can I please just wear what I came here in?" I whisper, crossing my arms self-consciously over my chest. "Please?"
Gail searches my face, thinking. "Stay here, I'll be right back."
"Whatever it is you're about to say, don't." Jane holds up a fork. "Or I'll stab you with this, and it's not even slightly sharp."
"You think you look ridiculous?" I motion to my hair, which has been braided with dozens of flowers to match the flower chains Gail offered me to cover my chest. I don't know where she got them, but I feel a lot better behind a protective layering of necklaces made of big blooming plants. "I'm a walking advertisement for the Home Depot gardening department."
Jane sighs, looking legitimately more miserable than me. She's been forced into a light blue dress with daisies embroidered all over it, and someone made her take her long dark hair out of its usual tight braid. Not surprisingly, no one was able to convince her to put actual flowers anywhere near her head.
I take a seat next to her at one of the long banquet tables because Liv is sitting next to Miles across the room with the men, and I don't know anyone else. For some reason, the stuffed hall has been segregated by sex, with a large opening in the middle separating each side of the room. The party is in full bloom, complete with music and happy chatter. Food has been piled high on each table, and I waste no time serving myself.
"This is so stupid." Jane rubs her eyes. "I'm not nearly drunk enough to deal with any of this."
"I made that bread, my lady," a woman across the table tells me, beaming.
I nod and take a bite, my eyes immediately widening. "This is really good."
"I made this soup," another woman announces. A bowl and spoon is placed in front of me.
Food comes out of nowhere: fish pies, clam soups, fried eel, breads, butters, jams, tarts, fruit, salads.
I lean towards Jane and whisper, "Is this actual seafood?"
"Feeling a little morally grey?" She takes a long gulp of whatever alcohol they're serving and laughs. "Apparently fish are too vapid for these people to feel sorry for killing. Which is incredibly convenient for me because I love clams." Jane reaches over and steals my soup.
Something tells me the people living at the barracks don't know about this.
A particularly loud group of men bark a laugh on the other side of the room, so I lean a little to the side so I can see past the woman sitting opposite me. That's when I notice him, seated near the end of a table. He's changed out of the blue button-down he came here in and is wearing a loose cotton shirt that matches the earth tones of the other men seated around him.
Ben finishes saying something and the man next to him bursts into loud laughter, while the others seated nearby pound their drinks on the table and all talk over each other. They go back and forth in some sort of heated but friendly debate until Ben cracks a smile at something they've said and they all start laughing again.
It's so weird being able to see him—to be able to get a good look while his attention is elsewhere. It's also weird to see him getting along so well with the same people threatening violence just a day ago. Maybe it's the lighting, but he looks especially attractive when he's smiling because he's enjoying himself and not because he has to. I'm particularly good at being able to tell the difference.
I continue to watch him talk to the people nearby and notice his ears stick out from under his neatly combed black hair. For some reason, this makes me smile just as his tired eyes lift up from his plate and find me. I immediately look down at my food, then over at the band, watch as one of the women goes absolutely nuts on a lute, then up at Jane, then grab whatever drink is in front of me and take an anxious gulp, immediately turning to spit it out on the floor behind me.
I try to cough the taste away. "What is this?"
"Mead." Jane gives me an amused look. "You apparently couldn't get enough of this stuff back in the day. They even started a cute little bee farm here to make fresh honey."
"I liked this?" This mead is so strong it burns my tongue and stings my nostrils. "This tastes terrible."
"More for me then." Jane grabs my cup and takes a long gulp. "Look alive. The happy couple is coming this way."
"Goddess," Bjorn announces, "words cannot describe our joy to have you attend our wedding. You honor us with your presence, and we humbly ask that you receive our gifts in exchange for your blessing." He turns to who I assume is Poppy and lifts a puppy out of her arms by its scruff. "I offer you the strongest of the litter."
I look from the tall bearded man to the small yapping wolf pup. "For me?" I ask in a state of shocked disbelief.
Poppy wrings her hands nervously, still smiling. "Do you like him?"
Despite the fact that the women nearby have fallen completely silent to hear what I have to say at the offering, I'm too giddy to care. I honestly couldn't care less if the entire room was watching me. Someone is offering me a dog. Someone is offering me an adorable fluffy little wolf puppy, and I surge with what feels like the rush you get when you miss a step walking down a flight of stairs.
I can't stop a big smile that pulls tight across my face as I reach out and grab hold of the dark grey wriggling furball. "Hello," I coo.
"Hello," he barks happily as I plop him in my lap. "Who are you? Are you my friend? You want to be my friend?"
"Yes, I'd like that very much," I answer. "What's your name?"
"His name is Fenrir," Bjorn tells me as the happy puppy jumps up and licks at my chin. "He will make a fine companion, my lady."
"Yes," I agree, laughing as I struggle to get a grip on Fenrir so I can pull him off my face. "Thank you so much."
Just like Gail warned, the night unfolds with the bride-to-be offering me a talent in return for blessing her with strong children. Poppy sits on a chair in the empty space between the women's and men's tables with an instrument I believe is called a tagelharpa. It looks like a bigger, boxier violin played seated on your lap instead of against your neck. The hall falls silent as she plays, singing in a language I don't understand. It feels too sad to be a wedding song.
Jane looks much more relaxed now that she's had a few cups of alcohol. In fact, when I lean towards her to ask a question, she smiles and pats the top of my head. "What's the song about?"
"Slaughter," she answers and chuckles quietly. "All their songs are about slaughter. Or sex. One or the other. Hey, pass me the barbecue sauce, will you?"
"Barbecue sauce?" Just down the table is a bottle of Dharma barbecue sauce. "How'd they get that?"
"Traded it," says Jane. "They love trading, and they lose their shit over sauces. I got a really nice pair of boots once for a bottle of honey mustard."
Poppy finishes another song, and I bounce Fenrir in my lap and applaud, everyone quickly following suit. Maybe these parties aren't so bad. Good food, good music. Fenrir makes it easier to talk to people when I need to. I can do this.
"Congratulations to the happy couple," a man bellows from across the room. I look over to find Erik walking into the center of the hall. "But I have my own announcement to make."
Jane mumbles, "You're sailing off into the sunset, never to be seen again?"
"I have chosen my own bride." Erik puffs out his chest, nodding at the men who begin cheering and smashing their cups against the table. There's a dramatic pause as he revels in the encouragement from the men, and then he raises a finger down the table from me and yells, "Charlotte!"
A choir of surprised oooh's and ahhh's echo up and down the table. I crane my neck to see who he's pointing at, and sure enough it's exactly who I think it is. Charlotte Lewis, looking as surprised as everyone else, forces a smile at the announcement.
"Come over here," he says, "my little—"
I look back at Erik just in time to watch a cup smash into his chest, splashing mead up onto his face and hair and clothes. It takes me a moment to realize Jane is standing, fixing Erik with the same frothy rage she had for me the first time we met, right before she knocked me unconscious.
All the hairs on my arms stand on end as the music stops and the entire hall falls silent.
Erik wipes a hand across his face and begins laughing. "I see this one still cannot handle her mead."
Jane steps away from the table and begins walking towards Erik, swaying slightly, but Ben intervenes before she can reach him. The height difference would be funny if the room wasn't quiet enough for me to hear Ben say, "You're drunk and he's goading you, that's all. Ignore it. We can't afford this right now."
Her shoulders relax slightly at his words, and she reluctantly turns to walk back to the table.
"You are fierce, Jane. I'll give credit where it is due," Erik yells into the silence. "But for all your talents in combat, I've decided I much prefer a beautiful wife."
Jane swings back around, her fist landing hard against his jaw. She becomes a flurry of punches and blocks, but what surprises me most of all is the sound. A punch to the face doesn't sound anything like what I thought it would. It's much quieter than in movies.
I cling to Fenrir as everyone stands at the same time, yelling encouragement for one side or the other and moving closer to the fight. The woman sitting next to me groans and puts her face in her hands.
"How much has she had to drink?"
Even Fenrir cannot stop the rush of anxiety when I look up at Ben. "A lot," I tell him. "What's happening?" He gives me a look and I gesture wildly at the fight, as if I could possibly mean something else.
"They were engaged once," Ben yells over the cheering, suddenly yanking me sharply out of the way of a cup that smashes into the wall behind me. "Sorry," he apologizes and releases my wrist, nodding towards the brawl. "As you've probably surmised, it didn't exactly work out."
"Should we do something?" I ask just as a man walks up to Jane, hands raised, calmly trying to talk sense into her. Without hesitation, Jane swivels towards him, smashes his mouth with her elbow, and then turns back to Erik to deliver another blow to his face. Eventually, she grabs him in a headlock, and the both of them swing around, smashing into tables.
"If you want to stop her," Ben offers, "be my guest."
Most of the men have started forming a circle around the fight, and I can't really see what's happening anymore. I want to get a better look at who's winning, so I take a step towards the circle, but Ben reaches out and grabs my wrist again.
"I didn't actually mean to go stop her," he says, looking panicked.
I turn sharply and frown at the contact. I'm so sick of people touching me. "Get your hand off me."
Fenrir twists around in my arms and bites him. "Friend says back off," he growls.
"Ow." Ben retracts his hand and flexes his fingers. Blood trails across his skin, and I stumble an apology and start to scold Fenrir. "No," Ben interrupts. "No, it's alright. He's technically just doing his job. It's just a scratch. You," he says to Fenrir, "have very sharp teeth."
I look back at the circle, but I still can't see much. "Does this happen often? With Jane?"
"Surprisingly no." Ben wipes his bloody hand on a cloth napkin and picks up the nearest loaf, ripping off a small bite and dipping it in jam. "Your people may make excellent bread, but we make superior ice cream."
I hug Fenrir tighter. "Ice cream?"
"And cheese," Ben adds. "We make much better cheese. Our cows are happier."
I don't know enough about cows to tell if that was supposed to be a joke or not. And besides, his representative is beating the living snot out of the island jarl. A jarl who already threatened to burn the barracks to the ground. Why the hell is he talking about ice cream and cheese?
A voice sounds from below, "Cora, I need to speak with you."
"Hello funny smelling dog," Fenrir barks.
I look down at a nearby bench and watch Todd wrap his tail around his body. "Oh," I say. "Hi, Todd. Did you watch the fight?"
"I'm not here to talk about the fight," he says quickly.
Ben's eyes shoot from me to Todd, watching as we talk.
"I've decided you amuse me," Todd says. "I'm ecstatic to finally be able to have a conversation with a human, and I'd hate for something to happen to you, so I'll say this. Benjamin is the cleverest human I've ever met. He's almost fox material, and I don't just hand out praise of that magnitude."
A whole slew of questions form, but I stop to think of something that won't give away the topic of our conversation to Ben, who is still very much listening to everything I'm saying. "The point, Todd?"
"I've heard things," Todd says ominously. "Strange things."
My stomach begins to ache. "Like what?"
"Inconsistent gossip, really. Nothing I can confirm. Just . . . be weary of who you talk to. Not everyone here is happy you've returned." Todd glances at Ben and then licks my hand. "I don't like the way he's looking at me. Farewell for now, Cora."
As soon as Todd has scampered off, Ben says, "Sounded like you had quite the conversation."
Particularly loud cheering sounds through the hall. I look back at the circle as Jane roughly shoves her way through and heads for the door. I can tell by her walk that she is either injured or very, very drunk. Possibly both. All I know for certain is Erik has been absolutely destroyed. One of the men pours a cup of something over his head to wake him up while the rest of them laugh.
"Please excuse me, Miss Collins." Ben bids me goodnight with a nod. "I need to ensure she doesn't light anything on fire. That, unfortunately, has happened with some frequency."
Now that the fight is over, and all of the people I'm acquainted with have left, I take a look at Erik. Most of his face is already swollen, and a steady stream of blood drips out his nose. "Is he going to be okay?" I ask the bearded man standing nearby.
"He's going to be very angry in the morning, my lady," he laughs. "But he'll live, if that's what you mean. Don't you trouble yourself with him. We'll get him out of here for you."
Erik stumbles in and out of consciousness—mumbling bitterly—as two men sling his arms over their shoulders and drag him out.
There's a hand on my arm. I turn, fully prepared to yell, but I stop when I realize who it is.
"Are you going after Jane?" Charlotte asks worriedly. She stands before me in a beautiful green dress that highlights her red hair and blue eyes. "Can you please tell her I didn't know he was going to propose? I didn't even know he was trying to court me, to be honest."
I had no plans to chase after Jane, but now I'm intrigued. "I'm sorry, should I congratulate you? I think you just got engaged. Charlotte, right?"
"Yes, Lady Cora. I. . . yes, thank you," she finishes softly.
"You don't seem very happy about the engagement." I shift Fenrir in my arms and scratch behind his ears. "Wait, did you say you didn't know he was. . . courting you?"
Charlotte looks miserable. "No, my lady."
"Do you want to marry him?"
She stumbles for an answer, eventually settling for, "It is an honor to be proposed to by our jarl."
Something is wrong, and I think I know what it is. I study her face, suddenly less anxious than I've ever been since I ended up on this island. "Are you afraid to reject him?"
The look in her eyes is all the answer I need. I think of my mother—trapped in a loveless abusive marriage and raised on the belief that divorce is the worst thing that could happen to a women—and it feels like I'm breathing in soup, but with each breath I feel more stable, more powerful. I could not protect my mother, but maybe I can protect this woman from being forced into the same circumstances.
"Nobody is going to force you to marry them," I assure her. "Not even Erik. I promise you that much. Look, would you like me to talk to him for you? Maybe tomorrow, after everyone has sobered up?"
"No, my lady, you don't have to—"
"Do you want me to talk to him?" I ask again. "I will gladly speak on your behalf if you don't feel comfortable."
Charlotte looks like she's going to cry. When she reaches out to squeeze my hand, I squeeze back in reassurance. "He did this to embarrass her," she whispers. "Jane's my best friend."
My eyebrows shoot up in surprise. "Wow, what an asshole." I catch what I've just said and grimace. "Sorry."
Charlotte smiles sadly, but it doesn't last long. "I need to make sure she's okay."
I put Fenrir down and brush his fur off my dress. "Do you know where we can get her some water? She's gonna need a lot of it."
It takes no time at all to find them both. Ben's practically dragging her back up the hill leading to the village. Jane flops her long legs, but is otherwise limp. I stop walking when I hear she's crying hysterically.
"Let me go," Jane wails in-between sobs. "I want to die!"
"No, you don't." Ben struggles, so I hurry down to help, with Charlotte following close behind. "She's way past the point of reasoning, Charlotte," Ben warns when he sees us. "I think you'd better leave."
"Is she hurt?" Charlotte asks.
"Just her pride," he answers. "She's fine, Charlotte. Incredibly intoxicated, but otherwise fine." Ben stoops down and hoists Jane up onto his shoulders the way Locke carried boar in the first season. "I've got her. You really should go. I don't want her to get any worse."
Charlotte shoots me a worried look, and I mouth, "I'll watch her." She nods, hands me the bucket of water she pulled from the nearby well, and walks up the path to a collection of smaller houses.
"I cannot apologize enough for this," Ben huffs as he carries her back up the hill.
I follow him down a path, trying my best not to slosh the bucket of water. "It's fine. I don't drink, so I'm used to being the sober one in the group."
We approach a house off the main path, and I walk ahead to open the door for him. About a dozen cots line the room, a small fire already lit in the center. Ben carries Jane to the far corner of the room and shakes her off his back onto the cot. She flops with a groan, her left arm hanging off the side, and then immediately starts crying again.
"Here." I hold out the bucket in offering. "We should probably try and convince her to drink this."
"She's crazy," Fenrir says at my feet. "What's wrong with her?"
I look at him and get an idea. "No biting," I say and pick him up, plopping him on her chest.
Jane stops crying when Fenrir sniffs her face. "Hey Brandon," she coos and kisses his snout. "How's my good little boy?"
"Who's Brandon?" Fenrir asks me.
I look at Ben for an answer, but his eyes are closed as he pinches the bridge of his nose. His voice comes out low and flat. "I can't even say what I'd truly like to say to you, Jane, because I know you won't remember it in the morning. And you should go." It takes me a second to realize the last part was directed at me.
I stare at Jane—take in her slurred speech, her mood swings, the weird jellylike way her body moves—and a memory resurfaces. A memory I've pretended didn't happen. One that nobody in our family talks about because it could land mother in jail. For the first time since it happened, it assaults my mind full force, and it's like I'm experiencing it for the first time all over again.
My heart is pounding hard and sporadic. Blood screams in my ears. My eyes sting with sweat, but I don't dare blink.
I barely hear Ben ask, "Are you alright?"
"I want to stay with her." I suddenly feel like I'm going to throw up. "What if she stops breathing?"
"Why would she stop breathing?" I'm looking at Jane, but I can feel his eyes on me. Eventually, he relents with a quiet sigh. I hear the strain of a cot as he takes a seat. "Stay, then. I guess the damage has already been done."
"Is this a friend?" Fenrir asks me. "She smells like wolf, Cora." He sneezes in Jane's face, and she laughs, flopping a limp arm down in the dirt and reaches up with the other to scratch behind his ears.
"That was a good sneeze," Jane coos happily. "Such a good sneeze. Good boy."
"Can I ask you something?" I blurt out and look over at Ben. He doesn't look terribly interested in talking, but he nods for me to continue anyway. "Any idea why Jane hates me so much?"
"Mm," he hums. "I'm not so sure hate is the right word."
I reach up and swipe sweat off my forehead. "She knocked me unconscious before we even shook hands. Actually, we've never shook hands."
Ben nods slowly, thinking. "Yes, well, I think that had more to do with the fact that you brought her wolves into it. You can talk to them, and it frightened her. Even if she does hate you, I wouldn't take offense," he adds with a smirk. "She dislikes just about everyone."
"So. . . what happened?" I wait for him to explain more. "With her and Erik?"
"Bold of you to assume Jane would have told me. She's not exactly forthcoming with personal matters."
We fall into silence, and I pass the time by watching the flicker of light from the fire-pit. It causes shadows to dance across the floor and walls and ceiling in the same way the candles did in the Temple. Thinking of the Temple reminds me of Aiko. "Did Aiko talk to you today?"
"Yes," Ben says simply and falls silent again.
I won't lie. His intense disinterest in conversation stings, but I just can't seem to keep my mouth shut. "You didn't mention she was six."
"You didn't ask."
"How did it go? With Aiko?"
"It could have gone better," he answers flatly.
"What did she say?"
Ben closes his eyes. "With absolutely all the respect in the world, can we please condense the game of 20 questions? I haven't slept in two days."
"Sorry." I turn to look back at Jane and find her, mouth open, snoring. Fenrir looks at me with confused eyes, so I lift him up back in my arms and hold him tight against my chest.
"Thank you again," Ben says randomly. "For not telling any of them about Margo's funeral."
"You knew I wouldn't tell them."
"I suspected you wouldn't tell them," he corrects. "But that doesn't make me any less appreciative that you didn't."
"This morning, Erik—" I start, but I stop when I see the expression on Ben's face.
"Yes?"
I don't know how serious Erik was, but in case he was serious, I think I should give someone a warning. Alex is at the Barracks. Indiana and her mother are at the Barracks. There's a whole community of people living there that may be in danger if extra precautions are not taken. "He sort of. . . threatened to burn all your houses to the ground? But I don't know if he meant it," I add quickly. "He seems like someone who likes to threaten."
Ben's expression remains blank and unreadable. "I don't suspect that was an idle threat at all."
I don't realize I'm shaking until Fenrir reaches up and licks my chin. "Why is he so intent on killing you all?"
"Erik has been raised on the belief that the only way to get into the afterlife is by dying in glorious combat. In recent years he's become consumed with the idea of war, but the last major war between our people was almost thirty years ago. He was nothing more than a toddler then. Essentially," Ben sums up, "he's young and very bored."
"So. . . he's a dumb jock?"
Ben's too tired to laugh, so he exhales slowly instead, the corners of his mouth twitching up. "I will reluctantly give him a little more credit than that, but you're not terribly off base."
He makes it seem much more complicated than it is. Surely all I have to do is put on a serious face and tell these people to leave Ben's people alone. But maybe Ben already knows that? Maybe this little speech is just to make me feel guilty enough to settle this dispute all on my own without him actually having to ask me for help.
"You never did tell me about the meeting," I say. "I might be able to help."
Ben stands for some reason, looking at the fire-pit. "It was unnecessarily long for what can be summed up as a complete waste of time. We asked for a small handful of the survivors, and Erik refused."
"I'll talk to him," I say. I already have to talk to him about Charlotte. "I'll convince him this whole thing is. . . really, really stupid."
"If you can convince that man of anything, I will eat this shirt."
I smile. "Deal."
Ben locks eyes with me and smiles with what looks like pure, unadulterated warmth, like he did at the feast. It's pathetic how much power a simple smile has over me. I'm suddenly thankful the lighting in here is dull, so he can't see my embarrassed flush.
"I could slit your throat wide open," he says just above a whisper. "Immortality doesn't mean you can't bleed out."
My eyebrows pull down in a frown. It takes my foolish, infatuated brain a moment to realize he has a knife.
"Do you have the slightest idea how easy it would be to kill you right now? I have my back to the door," he continues, "and you have your back to a wall. The only available window is behind me. You don't have a weapon on you. All you're holding is a cute novelty that won't be of any real use for another six months when his adult teeth finish growing in." Ben steps closer and narrows his eyes. "Is Charlotte the only one who knows you're in here?"
I can't tell if he's bluffing, or what the point of bluffing would be, but I do know he has it in him to kill an island deity. Three years from now, he's going to stab Jacob the way he's threatening to stab me.
Despite the cool night air, its actually rather warm in this guesthouse, but I feel all the heat leave me at the realization that he's right. If I wanted to leave, I have next to no options that don't result in me getting stabbed, or at least cut. The inevitability of it all makes me slightly calmer, but I still feel my arms tremble against Fenrir.
I glance at the knife and huff a nervous laugh. "You're not going to kill me."
"That's a hell of an assumption to make," he snaps. "Tell me something. . . do you know how long it would take for me to carry Jane to one of the canoes down by the dock? Exactly two minutes. Do you know how long it would take for me to row us both back to the mainland?" he continues without pause. "Forty minutes if she were conscious enough to help. An hour and a half on my own. Most of your people are either asleep or too drunk to be of any help to you. I could kill you and be back home long before morning. I'd have quite the head-start."
I stop shaking as a calmness completely washes over me, and I think about how good that bread was for dinner. Crunchy exterior, soft and flavorful interior. Perfect with jam or honey or dunked in soup or just all on its own. I wish I knew how to make bread. I can make decent pizza crust, but that's about it. I wonder if these people know how to make pizza? Ben said they make their own cheese, right? I wonder what kind of cheese they make. . .
Ben lowers the knife and leans close to my face, looking both confused and intensely irritated. "Are you even listening to me?"
Wait a second.
I blink at him as a realization hits.
It doesn't make sense. He can't kill me. That's not how the space-time continuum works in this universe. If he kills me now, I won't live long enough to time travel back to the 70's, and none of this will exist. But it does exist. Which means he can't kill me. And besides, what he's saying is sounding less and less like a threat and more like a lecture.
If he's not trying to kill me, he must be trying to scare me.
It takes such a concentrated effort to clear my throat and look him in the eye, I worry I'll collapse from exhaustion right where I stand. "Okay," I say as clearly as I can muster, "you've made your point. So who is actually trying to kill me?"
Ben doesn't move. He doesn't blink. But something in his expression changes regardless. He leans away from my face, sheathing the knife. "I don't know," he finally answers. "So I would stop being so trusting if I were you. You're no good to any of us dead. Again." He takes a step to the side, freeing the narrow path to the door, and I walk past him. "Cora."
I can't tell from his tone if he's more angry than worried. When I turn to look at him, his expression also gives nothing away. "What?"
Ben studies me in silence before walking towards me, stopping closer than I'd like. The bags under his eyes are so dark with lack of sleep, it looks like he's been punched. He produces a hunting knife in a simple leather casing and holds it out for me to take. When I don't move, he grabs one of my hands and places it in my palm, curling my fingers closed over it.
"Until Aiko can tell us information of actual use," he says with an air of finality, "assume absolutely everyone is trying to kill you."
My bedroom behind the wall in the banquet hall seemed rustic and charming while Gail helped me get ready for the party. Now, as I settle into bed and try to get comfortable, it feels like a tomb.
I crawl to the edge of the bed and unsheathe the knife Ben gave me. It glistens and shines my reflection in the pale torchlight.
What little comfort I gained from finding out my door locks is contradicted by my newfound worry of other ways people could kill me. Although it's highly unlikely someone can break through the thick plank of wood wedged into built-in slats across both doors, they could light the longhouse on fire. They could have poisoned my food and drink. They could already be hiding in here, waiting for me to fall asleep.
Fenrir follows me around the room, sniffing everything, as I hold the knife steady and search the wardrobe against the wall and the trunk at the foot of the bed. Fenrir assures me we're the only two people in here, but I check every nook and cranny myself. Even this does not bring peace of mind.
I shake out the sheets, pound the pillow with my fists. Nothing works. "Fenrir," I ask, "can you please bark and wake me up if you hear anyone come near?"
"Yes, Cora," he replies, but it's not like it makes a difference.
I don't sleep for even a second.
Chapter 7: Blood, Sweat, and Tears
Chapter Text
DHARMA, 1974
It won’t stop screaming.
A small green bird perched on top of the hospital continuously throws his head back and emits an ear-piercing screech. I watched LaFluer throw a shoe at it earlier, but the frightened bird merely dogged the footwear and landed back on the roof with yet another ungodly wail.
“That bird sure is loud.”
“Huh?” Annie looks over at me and then looks up at the roof. I’ve interrupted her thoughts. “Oh, yeah. Uh-huh.”
I strangle the small bouquet of flowers Annie and I spent all afternoon picking. She trembles with nerves beside me, but I don’t know how to comfort her. Especially because she’s right to be nervous. We messed up real bad.
“Do you think she’ll accept our apology?” Annie whispers.
I shrug and try not to think about what will happen if she doesn’t.
Unable to take the suspense any longer, Annie pulls open the hospital door and rushes inside. I follow closely behind, happy that the shrill bird is significantly quieter inside.
A nurse is quick to stop us. “I thought I told you two no visitors yet.”
“Let them in, Jules,” a tired voice comes from behind a curtain. “I need to talk to them."
The second I see Miss Collins, I regret coming here. Maybe we should have waited a few days before trying to make amends?
Miss Collins is awake, but just barely. Sweat drips down her pale forehead, and her eyelids are droopy and reddened. Her usually friendly expression is blank, but her eyes cut scathingly through both of us the second we step around the privacy curtain shielding her hospital bed.
We stand before her, watching as she glares at us without actually glaring at us.
“Miss Collins?” I don’t know what to say, so I hold out the flowers in offering. Honestly, I’m just incredibly happy she’s not dead. “How are you feeling?”
She doesn’t reach for the flowers. Her response is quiet and calm, but it’s just as bad as if she were screaming. “I was just stabbed in the ribs, Benjamin. How do you think I’m feeling?”
“Sorry.” I don’t bother trying to fight the heat that rushes into my cheeks and leaves my face red.
She inhales deeply, and I tense in preparation for her to actually start screaming, but her voice is still soft when she asks, “What were you two doing that close to a negotiation?”
“It was my idea,” Annie offers. “I wanted to get close enough to see Freyja’s face.” But Miss Collins won’t have any of it.
“I’m not interested in playing the blame game. You were there, too, Ben.” At the mention of my name, I look up at her, only to instantly fill with shame and look away. “Were my instructions not clear enough? Did something I say confuse you two?”
It takes Annie a second to answer because I cannot. “No.”
“Have I ever insinuated those people were anything but dangerous? Do you two think this is some kind of game?”
Even Annie is too upset to answer this time. We shake our heads no.
“Oh good,” Miss Collins huffs sarcastically. “I was beginning to worry this was all my fault.”
I have never felt this stupid in my entire life. Looking back on what we did makes me so embarrassed, my stomach churns.
Just this morning, Miss Collins was explaining the differences between a horse, a donkey, and a mule when the alarm sirens started blasting through the speakers. She ordered Annie and me to get inside the nearest house before following a group of security, but we didn’t listen.
Usually when the norsemen come to negotiate the terms of the treaty, it’s only Jarl Sigurd and two or three others. This time she was with them—their goddess—covered in heaps of brown feathers and beads and bones, riding atop an angry sounding elk with enormous painted horns.
Annie and I thought we were sneaky, hiding behind a house near the meet-up, when we were found by one of the norsemen who lifted me up by my shirt collar. I was so afraid I was going to die, the rest of what happened is a blur. All I remember for certain is suddenly my feet were back on the ground, and Miss Collins was screaming for us to run.
We’re her favorite students, her star students, and it’s our fault she was stabbed.
“We’re sorry,” Annie whispers.
Miss Collins sighs, her eyes flickering shut, and I can tell she’s not mad. She’s disappointed, and that’s much worse.“I don’t want your apologies. I want you both to listen to me when I tell you to do something. You could have died.” She extends both her hands, wincing, and we each grab one. “Promise me,” she proclaims, her sweaty face suddenly going serious. “Don’t you ever scare me like that again.”
“We promise,” we answer in unison.
Miss Collins releases our hands and sinks back into her pillow, her face looking especially white against the hospital’s bleached sheets. “Thank you for the flowers, but I need to sleep now.”
The nurse is quick to usher us out, the hospital door slamming shut behind her with a click, and the screaming bird is suddenly ringing in my ears.
It is a relief when Annie finally speaks.“She looked like she was in a lot of pain.”
“Should we bake her a cake?” I suggest. Miss Collins always makes us dessert when we have a bad day. “We can write ‘sorry’ in icing?”
“No, I don’t feel good. I’m going home,” Annie answers. “I’ll see you tomorrow.”
“Wait. . . do we have school tomorrow? Who’s going to teach us if Miss Collins is in the hospital?”
“I’ll ask my mom.” She sounds like she's going to cry. “Bye, Ben.”
I watch Annie’s slumped form cross the courtyard and disappear into her house. She’s always been the adventurous one. The one with her head held high no matter who bullies us. For a long time, I thought she wasn’t afraid of anything. It feels unnatural to see her so deflated.
I stand alone, long after Annie is gone, and worry that we’ve somehow done something unforgivable.
I worry things are never going to be the same again.
Time becomes meaningless.
I don’t know when it happens—as I lie awake, griping the knife for dear life—but I go from feeling panicked but overall well to feeling intensely sick. Each beat of my heart feels rushed but also irregular, bringing with it a thick dotting of sweat on my hairline and nose and neck. When my hand goes numb, I relax my grip on the knife, but I never regain sensation. I flex my fingers and realize both my hands have gone numb.
I jolt at the sudden sound of banging against the door.
“My lady,” a muffled voice yells. “Are you awake? It’s Gail. The sun has only just risen, but I’m afraid you’re needed at the beach. It’s urgent.”
It’s morning? In my sleep deprived state, I roll over and blink in a useless attempt to clear the heavy weight banging around in my skull. This is exactly why I always wrote my essays long before they were due. Freshman year taught me pulling all nighters destroys my sleep/wake cycle in ways that take a solid week to remedy. In my experience, procrastination has never been worth it.
What assignment did I forget to do?
I stand up and immediately fall to my knees. All feeling in both my feet has disappeared, but it feels just like my hands—no matter what I do, they won’t wake up.
Oh my God, I’ve been poisoned. I’m going to die. First my hands and feet, and then the rest of me. I feel Fenrir lap at my face in worry, so I pet him in a feeble attempt to calm down. I can still move, I just can’t feel anything.
Am I drunk? Is this what it’s like to be drunk? Did the small amount of mead I accidentally swallowed last night somehow give me a hangover?
Am I just hysterical? I feel hysterical. Breathe. Just breathe. Maybe staying up all night wasn’t a good idea.
Gail bangs on the door again, sounding much more anxious than before, and I scramble to remember what’s going on. I look down at the knife in my hand. Gail has been nothing but kind to me since I got here. She’s taken care of me and answered my questions and taken the time to explain my role. I don’t care that Ben said to assume everyone is trying to kill me because I don’t think it’s Gail.
I keep the knife though.
I pull up the wood plank and heave open the door. Gail starts to explain what’s going on at the beach but almost immediately stops. “Cora. . . what happened?” She doesn’t apologize when I frown. “You look. . . very unwell,” Gail continues. “Are you running a fever? Do you need a doctor?”
I can’t imagine what kind of treatment a norse doctor would give me, but you can bet it’s not FDA approved, so I think I’ll pass. “I’m fine, Gail.” I’m almost too tired to feel embarrassment at becoming paranoid from lack of sleep. That’s what this is, right? Paranoia? “Had terrible insomnia and stayed up all night. Although, I think I bent my arms at a weird angle. They fell asleep.”
She nods, but her eyes say she doesn’t believe me. “I won’t waste more time talking. Follow me. You’ll see for yourself.”
I find them standing in the middle of the hill leading down to the docks and the beach.
Jane rubs at her temples as I approach. She’s changed back into her pants and t-shirt but looks just as aggravated as she did in the dress from last night. “Oh, what the hell?” She turns to gauge Ben’s reaction. “Did you know about this?”
Ben, for once, looks equally as incensed as she does. “No,” he says slowly, “I did not.”
I squint in the early morning sun and finally see what they’re talking about. Why are the survivors here? I want to ask Jane or Ben what’s going on, but it turns out I don’t need to.
Jane spots me as I walk closer and her worried expression darkens. “You need to do something about this,” she hisses at me. “This wasn’t part of our negotiation. And you look terrible. Are you hungover, too?”
“Thanks,” I mumble.
“No, I mean you look really terrible.” Jane steps close enough to pull one of my eyelids open to look at my pupil. I yank my face away, but she doesn’t grab for me again. “Do you feel sick?”
I flex my fingers. I clap once. Nothing. Not even the prickly numbness that comes from waking a limb back up. Just to be safe, I tell her, “My hands and feet have been asleep for a while.”
Jane points at a young woman curiously standing nearby and orders, “Get Annie.” When she doesn’t move, Jane yells, “Now!” and the young woman breaks out in a run up into the main village.
Annie? I wonder if she means the Annie. The little girl from Dharma. Ben’s only childhood friend. Annie is a common name, but if Miles and Charlotte are here, it only makes sense Annie would be too.
I look back at the survivors and notice the group is far too small to be everyone. In fact, it’s definitely not everyone because the only survivors standing awkwardly on the docks are female.
“Miss Collins,” Ben starts, pausing when his eyes shift to something behind me.
“Negotiations are off the table,” Erik answers from behind us, flanked on either side by Gorm and Inga. All of his cuts and bruises look even worse in the bright sunshine. He steps closer and shoots Ben a look. “I’ve decided we’re no longer in need of your council. Feel free to return to your people in one of our smaller ships. Please follow me, Lady Cora,” he says more kindly. “We have much to discuss.”
To my immense shock, instead of yelling something snide or punching him in the face, Jane does nothing but watch Erik walk past her down the hill.
Jane sighs, but not dramatically. It comes out more like an anxious snort. “Well,” she says, glancing stoically at Ben. “Here we go.”
“Why’d you bring them here?” I ask Erik.
From what I can remember from the show, tensions were already high enough when the survivors were struggling to live together. Granted, Sawyer started a lot of the fights this early on—and he’s still locked in a room back at the barracks—but he wasn’t responsible for everything. Jin and Michael definitely had a fight over a watch. I can’t imagine how bad it’s become now that family and married couples have been separated.
I watch Fenrir trot through the survivors asking, Hi, are you a friend?
“The men don’t exactly get along great.” A pain starts in my back. I flinch a hand up to grip where my kidneys are, and I completely reconsider whatever norse medical care they have here. Something is definitely wrong. “They’re going to kill each other.”
“Saves us the trouble.”
“I’m sorry?” I turn and stare blankly at Erik. “What do you mean?”
“I mean they’re a waste of resources, my lady. We can always use them,” he explains, nodding at the confused female survivors standing farther away on the beach. “No need for the men.”
I feel all the blood rush from my head and I totter unstably. “Did you kill them?”
I have never felt so happy to hear a response. “No, not yet,” Erik tells me.
“Not ever,” I snap loudly, and the man standing to his right flinches. I can’t remember a time my body ached this much, and the pain makes it easier to voice my anger. “Nobody is killing anybody. Gorm, right?” The viking who flinched is quick to bow his head. “And Inga?” She looks surprised I remember her name. “Some of these women are already married. None of you are to kill anyone. Understand?”
“I insist you rest, my lady,” says Erik. “You have had an exhausting few days, and we can take it from here.”
No, you nut-job. I want you to tell me exactly what you plan to do. What the hell is going on? I reach up and swipe at the sweat trailing down my face. “What’s the plan? This isn’t even all of the women.”
This news dents Erik’s self-assured smile just a little. “What do you mean?”
I take one last look around just to make sure, but I don’t see her. “I mean this isn’t—” I look over at the tall bearded man standing beside me, but I can’t remember his name. His face is swollen and bruised, and I wonder who he pissed off to get that bad of an ass-whooping. “I mean . . . this isn’t everyone.” I find Claire amongst the crowd and hurry towards her in the sand, happy to find someone familiar. “What happened? Where’s Kate?”
“Don’t talk to her,” Shannon pipes in. At least, I think it’s Shannon?
Wait. Who’s Shannon?
I blink at the crowd and struggle to place who they are. A blonde pregnant woman stares at me, brows furrowed. I take a step back and look down at my shoes sinking into the sand. I’m wearing leather boots. I’m dressed in a ridiculous gown.
I try to remain calm and back away from them all. A group of women dressed in shades of pink and purple and light blue stare at me as I turn to gauge more of my surroundings, but I only become more confused. Did I fly home for Christmas break after all? We never take family trips to the beach. I don’t see mom.
I spot two people wearing regular clothes amongst a group cosplaying as vikings, and I feel a rush of relief. “Excuse me,” I ask a tall brunette. “I’m sorry to bother you, but what beach is this?”
She looks incredibly unfriendly when she says, “I knew there was something wrong with you. We need to get to the infirmary while you can still walk.”
“I’m sorry?” I struggle to remain calm as I fight against her vice-like grip of my wrist. “Who are you?”
“Ben,” the woman says, “get her other arm.”
I feel the pressure of her grip tighten even more, and I have the good sense to start causing a scene. I’m being abducted. I’m being abducted in broad daylight, and they’re probably trying to sell me into some kind of sex trafficking ring. Why isn’t anyone doing anything?
I scream at the top of my lungs and push against the woman. I don’t even push that hard but she ends up slamming into a tree a few feet away and landing in a heap with a surprised exhale.
It feels like I’m going to die. Everything hurts. And to make matters worse, I’ve reached a point of hysterical fight-or-flight that plugs me up like a bad case of allergies. I can feel tears trailing down my face and my nose runs a stream of snot over my lips. I reach up to swipe it and pull away red. My nose is bleeding? I’ve never had a nosebleed before.
I’m slowly surrounded by worried looking women with braided hair and identical dresses in varying shades of pastel. I cover my ears with the palms of my hands as they all ask me questions at the same time. How do they know my name?
“Everyone back the hell up,” an elderly woman bellows louder than I thought was possible for someone of her age, and the crowd closing in on me quickly parts. She strolls past them with an air of authority. I wonder if she’s a police officer, although I don’t know why a police officer would be dressed the way she is. “Hello, Miss. My name is Gail.”
I hold up my shaking hands. “I think I’m bleeding?”
“Yes,” she replies calmly. “There’s been an accident, and we need to take you to the hospital. What’s your name?”
“Cora.” I look down at my embroidered dress dotting with blood, at the flower chains around my neck, at the trees and numerous women dressed in a mix of historical and modern clothing, and then look back at Gail. “Where am I?”
“A renaissance festival,” she answers with a smile. “I’m with security. Let’s get you to the doctor, shall we?”
We walk through trees—Gail steadying me—until we reach a tall metal building covered in vines and foliage. This is the weirdest Renaissance Faire I’ve ever been to.
I see my reflection in the shiny metal door and stop, reaching up to swipe at my nose, but all I pull away is clear mucus. Fear pools in my stomach until the ache is unbearable. I stare at the blood covering my face and allow the situation to process. My nose isn’t bleeding.
I’m crying blood.
I stand on the same beach I started this nonsense adventure on, only this time the group of survivors is infinitely smaller and entirely male.
There’s an argument down the beach. Erik is yelling at a very distraught Jin, who I can only assume is furious they’ve taken Sun away from him. I don’t know who starts it, but the two men begin taking swings at each other.
It doesn’t last long. One of the bearded men hands Erik a long-handled axe, and all at once I realize how serious the situation is.
It doesn’t matter that I order them to stand down. I scream for him to stop, but he’s not listening.
The axe comes down heavy, severing Jin’s head from the rest of his body.
It’s as if I have breached the surface of water. Air hovers in my throat, uselessly stagnant. I can’t breathe.
Suddenly, I can.
“Easy,” a woman soothes as I gasp wildly. “You’re okay.” In a hushed whisper, I hear, “Flora, honey, go get your mother. Tell her she’s awake. What did you see,” she adds, louder than before. “Cora? Cora, honey, what did you see?”
It takes me a second to realize the voice is talking to me. “Who are you?" I blink into the harsh overhead lighting and try to remember where I am. Unfocused beams of white and yellow scratch at my eyes like a wild animal. A door opens, shoes shuffle, and there’s a warm hand on my arm. I squint up into the kind face of a freckled redhead.
“Cora?” I blink more rapidly, confused as to how she knows my name. “Hi, I’m Dr. Freeman. Call me Annie.” When I don’t answer, she steps forward and checks a beeping monitor next to the table I’m on, and I notice she has a rifle strapped to her back. “I’m glad to see you’re awake. Are you in any pain?”
“No.” My panic lessens when I see Gail is standing beside me. She was the voice I heard upon awakening. I can’t stop blinking. “How long was I out?”
“About 24 hours.”
“What happened?”
“Let me up,” a tiny voice commands from the floor. “Let me up!” Gail bends down, and suddenly Fenrir is plopped on my chest, eagerly sniffing my face. Once he’s assured I’m okay, he makes a circle and gets comfortable on my chest.
“You were poisoned,” Annie says and checks the IV I didn’t notice was stuck in my arm. “You’re lucky to be alive. There was enough in your bloodstream to have killed eight people.” I hear a click and the beam of a flashlight blinds me as she checks my pupils. “If you’re not in any pain, that should mean it’s mostly left your system by now.”
It comes back to me, slowly. Feeling terrible all night. The insomnia. Paranoia. Confusion. Crying blood. I tried everything at the party. It could have been any of the foods that were shoved in front of me last night. Is anyone else sick? Or dead?
Dead. I remember my nightmare. Try as I might to clear my throat, my voice whinges out of me like a croaking bullfrog. “Where’s Erik?”
“His house is not far from here,” Annie answers curiously. “Why?”
“Stop him,” I beg. “Please, he can’t go back to the beach. He. . . the axe! He’s going to kill them—”
“Slow down,” Gail soothes as I stumble frantically over my words. “Who is going to kill who?”
I can’t get the words out. He’s going to behead Jin, and who knows how many others. “I had a nightmare—” My face flushes at how ridiculous this must sound. “It was just a nightmare.”
“No, it wasn’t,” Gail counters. “Aiko isn’t our only seer.”
What little relief came upon waking turns back into anxiety. “I had a dream Erik is going to kill people at the beach. On the mainland. I. . . I don’t know when.”
Gail’s jaw shifts slightly as she thinks. “Annie, is Christopher still watching Erik?” Annie nods. “And Benjamin?”
“Left to go find Loki.” Annie peals a layer of tape off my inner arm and pulls out my IV. I quickly look away and try not to throw up. “Needed to send a letter to Alex.”
Gail humphs. “He needs to bring that girl here. She’ll be safer here.”
Annie rests a hand on my back and helps me sit up. “You know why he won’t.”
A set of metal double doors at the end of the room swing open, and a slew of chattering young women enter, followed by Jane, Liv, Miles, and Aiko.
For a while, it’s as if I’m not even here anymore. The only one paying me any attention is Gail, and even then, she’s more of a silent comfort. Miles is angry with Jane over something, and Aiko clings tightly to him, looking very upset. Four young redheaded girls all attempt to talk over each other until Annie tells them to quiet down. I assume they’re her daughters, but nobody introduces themselves.
I lock eyes with Jane and scan her bruised eye, eventually trailing down to a sling holding her right arm tight against her chest. Did she get in another fight with Erik?
“You dislocated my arm yesterday,” she says from across the room. “Tossed me like the Hulk flicking a fly.”
“I’m so sorry—”
“No,” she cuts me off excitedly, “this is great. If you can just channel that energy again, it would solve a lot of our problems. If there’s one thing Erik will listen to, it’s blunt-force trauma. Please tell me you can channel it at will?”
I don’t have a chance to answer before Miles carries Aiko over to my bed and sets her down beside me. Now that she’s close, I can see just how frightened she looks. “Okay, little bug,” says Miles. “It is very important you tell us exactly what you see.”
“I don’t want to,” she whispers. “Not again, please.”
“Aw, you can do this,” Miles encourages and fidgets a strand of her black hair. “That’s why you’re my favorite daughter.”
“I’m your only daughter,” she says, smiling.
Liv approaches and rests a comforting hand on the top of Aiko’s head. “We’ll be right here, sweetheart.”
I feel her tiny fingers curl around my own, and Aiko’s eyes shift from side to side. She blinks out of her stupor and says, “Lady Cora's going to rip a big tree out of the ground.”
Miles hesitates before asking, “Is that all you saw?”
Aiko grabs my fingers again, and she’s quiet for a long time. Then, as if she were burned, she lets out a startled cry and backs away, her unseeing eyes wide, slowly devolving into frightened tears. Miles picks her up to comfort her, but whatever she saw has left her inconsolable.
The sound of slightly rusted metal squeaks as someone else enters the room. I don’t look at him—I cannot tear my eyes away from poor Aiko—but I recognize Ben’s hushed voice.
“She’s still upset?”
“Not about you,” Jane answers, and her uneven tone breaks the spell Aiko’s fear has over me. I turn to look at Jane, and my stomach rapidly sinks at her uncharacteristically worried expression. “You need me to go back to the mainland and get Alex?”
“No, Loki is flying her a message as we speak.”
“Ben. . .” Jane finally looks away from where Liv and Miles are desperately attempting to comfort Aiko. “You better hope Loki reaches her before whatever Aiko saw comes true.”
Dad used to order all of us around like slaves or cattle. He was always on a power trip, sober or drunk. There were times when I’d actually see red from the things he’d say to me or my sisters or my mom. Casper never really got the brunt of his tirades, and I suspect that’s because of some misogynistic bullshit that he was the son while we were the expendable daughters.
I have spent the majority of my life fantasizing about how amazing it will be when I grow up and move out and never have to take orders from anyone ever again. Now, as Gail helps me prepare to bluff my way through the violent and confusing politics of people who supposedly worship me, I wish more than ever that someone would just tell me what to do.
“Has Aiko said anything yet?” I haven’t been able to get her traumatized wails out of my head, and it makes it infinitely worse that I have no idea what she saw because no one will talk to me about it.
“Liv is attempting to coax it out of her,” Gail answers. “The poor girl’s only six, Cora. It will take a little time.”
“I know.” I feel embarrassed having asked. “Sorry.”
“Cora needs a weapon,” Jane offers, “or this meeting isn’t going to last long. The bigger the better. If we have to pretend she’s formidable, it might as well be an all-out attempt. You people ever find her axe?”
“No, but I think I still have her darts.” Gail finishes tying the back of the modest blue dress I requested and starts rummaging thorough one of the trunks in my room. “Ah-ha. Here’s something.”
“I still think she should wear the feather cloak.” Jane eyes my clothing with an air of annoyed disproval. “There’s nothing about this dress that screams listen to me asshole, or I’ll rip your head off.”
“You dress her like a warrior, Erik is going to expect a war. It's best we don’t give that boy any more encouragement.” Gail is in the middle of tying a long strip of leather with finely-sharpened knives holstered around my waist when one of the young redheads from the hospital sprints into my longhouse bedroom, panting and coughing a frantic plea.
I think her name is Flora?
“Fauna,” Gail exclaims, “what is it? Is it Erik?”
“Flint—” she tries to explain, but she sprinted her too fast and cannot catch her breath. I scoop her up a glass of water and wait for her drink. “Flint’s going to get himself killed, lady Cora. Please, you have to stop him.”
I glance at Gail and she says, “It’s her brother.”
“What happened?” I ask. “Where is he?”
Fauna’s eyes are practically bulging out of her skull with fear. “He’s challenged Thor to a Holmgang.”
The word is familiar. I remember it from one of the recent lectures I attended about Norse culture. It’s a sort of gentleman’s duel for Vikings to settle disputes that cannot or will not be settled with payment of money.
“Are they fighting right now?” I ask. “And. . . and Thor’s a . . . regular person, right?” I don’t think I can handle having to stop a fight between someone else with super powers.
“Ugh,” Jane complains loudly. “We don’t have time for this. The meeting’s starting soon.”
We haven’t even reached the rapidly forming circle before I hear Annie shouting.
I look over at a smiling young woman and ask, “What’s going on?”
“Oh! Freyja, hello! Isn’t this exciting?” Mashing her hands together, she brings them up under her chin, still smiling. “They both proposed, so I’m marrying the winner.”
“You foolish boy,” Annie seethes into the face of a teenager. “You would throw your life away for a girl who doesn’t even care which one of you wins?”
Flint tries to stand tall and look impressive, but he’s fairly young. I’m not even sure he’s hit puberty yet judging by the size of him. “That’s not true—”
“Oh really?” Annie interrupts even louder than before. “Go and ask her yourself. Right here, in front of Thor. Ask her which one of you she hopes wins.”
Flint’s jaw grinds from one side to the other as he stares silently at his mother. “Will you not watch me fight?”
“How dare you ask me that,” Annie exclaims, but her voice is less sharp. It’s dulled with fear. “I will not stand around and watch my only son die for such a worthless cause.”
I get a good look at the man Flint will be fighting and completely understand Annie’s panic. Thor is easily three times Flint’s size in both height and muscle mass. Thor grips his sword with ease, while it looks like Flint is struggling to keep his up off the ground.
I take a step forward towards Flint, as if my body is on autopilot. “How old are you?”
Much like he did with his mother, Flint puffs up with pride. “Thirteen, lady Cora.”
“I’m sorry. . . what?!” He’s my little brother Casper’s age. “Yeah, no.” I point at Thor and tell him to go home. “Congratulations, Thor. I have absolutely no doubt you would have won. You need me to bless the engagement? Consider it blessed. Holmgang’s over, everyone.”
“You do the boy a great disservice, my lady.” I didn’t know Erik was here, but his slightly condescending tone is enough to make both my hands ball into tight fists. “Flint is not a child.”
All I can think about is my own thirteen year old brother, who loves video-games and heavy metal and still asks mom to cut the crust off his sandwiches. “What planet are you from where a thirteen year old isn’t considered a child?”
“His fighting spirit is admirable for one so small. You dishonor him by calling off the Holmgang. Who knows? You may have tarnished his chances of reaching Valhalla.”
“Stop filling my boy’s head with lies,” Annie seethes lowly, shaking the strap of the rife off her shoulder to better grip the gun. “Stay away from my family. I don’t need an axe to kill you.”
Erik regards Annie with an air of amusement before dismissing her with a smirk and turning to wander back to the longhouse.
“Stop,” I say, but he keeps walking. I hope he didn’t hear me because we have a big problem if he did. “Stop,” I say louder, and Erik, thankfully, halts.
“Yes, my lady?”
“Erik,” I say, struggling to keep my eyes from flicking away to literally anything else within range. Remember what Gail said. Keep eye contact. This is important. This is more important than a decree to leave Charlotte alone, or to let the female survivors go back to the mainland. I have to convince him not to go to war and obliterate an entire society of people living in the barracks.
No pressue.
“I need to talk to you.”
Chapter 8: Too Much Sacrifice Is Never Enough
Chapter Text
Dharma, 1974
LaFluer is good friends with Miss Collins, so he probably knows where she is. But when I enter the security hall to ask him, I hear him yelling at one of the other personnel. His usually friendly expression disappears completely as soon as he sees me.
“What the hell are you doing in here?”
I look behind me just in case, but he’s definitely talking to me.
“Ben, you need to go home. Right now,” Horace orders. “We’re in the middle of something.”
“Look, LaFluer, listen to me,” one of the new security recruits begs. “Listen. . . I’m telling you, I didn’t miss. I swear it was dead center. Right between the eyes.”
“You don’t get it, man,” Horace butts in, sounding more unnerved than usual. “It doesn’t matter if you got a clean headshot. Do you have any idea what you’ve just done?”
The new member looks wildly from LaFluer to Horace. “I cut off the head of the snake,” he splutters. “I finally killed their goddess. I even killed that elk of hers. I thought that’s what you’ve been trying to accomplish?”
“Hey guys?” Phil says from across the room. He points up at one of the security monitors. “They’re here.”
“How many?” Horace asks.
I move closer to see what he’s looking at. Freyja rides atop the same elk this man claims to have killed. Does that mean her animals are immortal too?
“It’s just her and Jarl Sigurd,” says Phil.
“That’s impossible,” the new recruit stutters. “I killed her.”
“You stupid son of a bitch.” LaFluer grabs him by his collar and shakes him violently. “You can’t kill a goddess!”
I jump at the blast of security alarm that blares through the outside speakers. The alarm suddenly fizzles out until I don’t hear a siren at all. All of the men in the room turn to look at the double-doors leading out into the courtyard.
LaFluer swears. “I say we toss this trigger-happy dumbass out to the wolves. I’m not dying because Ryan wanted to be Quick Draw McGraw.” Yanking the man behind him, LaFluer makes a break for the stairs just as a horrible crash echoes from outside and people start screaming.
I hurry around LaFluer and reach the doors first. If this new guy just tried to shoot Freyja, I want to be as far away from him as possible when the norsemen get here. I reach for the handle, but before I make contact, both double-doors are ripped from their hinges, and I find myself staring up into a seven foot tall looming figure with a pair of glowing white eyes.
Everyone has a specific rumor as to what the norsemen’s Goddess is like. Tony says she eats human hearts. Carol says she eats human souls. Jeromy says she has the head of an elk. Brian says she has the head of a wolf. Samantha thinks the feathers she’s covered in are actual wings she can use to fly.
Annie and I have wanted to know what she looks like since the moment we learned she existed. Now, as I stare at her painted face and eyes that blind me with angry light brighter than jeep headlights, I cannot even fully process what I’m looking at. I can’t move. I can’t blink. I can’t even close my mouth.
“He went rogue,” LaFluer yells and pushes me out of the way. “He acted alone. Please, by all means, take him.”
“What?” Ryan yells in protest, but LaFluer has already pushed him towards Freyja.
Without hesitation, she whips out a long arm from within mounds of brown feathers and grabs Ryan by the throat, lifting him up off the ground. He chokes so hard, it sounds like he’s throwing up. In a rush of bones and beads, she turns and walks out into the middle of the courtyard and drops him at her feet. Now that I’m not blinded by her eyes, I can see two antlers sticking out of her otherwise human head.
I can’t hear what Ryan is saying, but his body language suggests he’s trying to beg forgiveness. She reaches out again, this time slowly, with her hands gently resting on either side of his face, so it looks like she’s comforting him.
Ryan's head bursts open like a smashed pumpkin, spraying blood all over. Bits of his brain dangle in-between Freyja’s fingers like mango pulp. She lets his body drop with dead weight at her feet and shakes off the chunks from her hands.
“Jesus,” LaFluer whispers beside me.
“Consider this your final warning,” Jarl Sigurd announces over a woman’s frightened screams, his voice accented like the rest of his people’s.“You and your people will stay on your land while our animals stay on theres. We will not ask again.” He looks very much like he wants to kill us all. “You should all be on your knees, thanking our merciful Goddess. You attempt assassination and all she required as penance is the one who pulled the trigger. If it were up to me, I would gut you all in a heartbeat.”
And then they are gone.
As everyone around me begins nervously chattering, I feel the immediate fear leaving my body, and it’s easier to think. I’m not going to die. I’m not going to die, and I just met my chance to make sure Horace and Annie and Miss Collins don’t die either.
I finally met Freyja, and I think I know how to win her favor.
“I’m not sure I understand,” says Erik. “What exactly is it you’re asking?”
I have absolutely no idea. I don’t know what possessed me to think I could solve this by just talking to Erik. He’s been polite, never once interrupting, but I can tell he has zero interest in my attempts to argue for peace. At this point, I’m just babbling.
I take slow breaths through my nose and furrow my brow in a desperate attempt to look like I’m not struggling to conceal my anxiety. “Okay, look. . . do you think I’m stupid?”
Erik blinks, his head slowly tilting like a curious bird. “Of course not.”
“Good,” I respond with hearty relief. I half expected him to say yes. “Because I’m not. And I’m getting really sick of people treating me like I am. I may not know exactly what’s going on, but that’s because nobody feels inclined to explain anything. It’s not my fault my rebirth wiped my memory.”
Erik stares off into the trees, seemingly lost in thought. “I apologize on behalf of the clan, my lady. We were unsure if your memory would return by now. I see that it will not.” He nods. “I would be happy to share my knowledge with you. What exactly is it you would like to know?”
Uh-oh. My brain goes completely silent. There’s a dozen questions I want to ask, and now that someone is finally offering unlimited answers, I cannot think of a single one of them. To buy me some time, I simply say, “Thank you.” Think. Think. Think. Think. Think. “Why are you at war with the . . .” Others? Barrack-dwellers? What are they called in this universe? “People on the mainland?”
“They worship a false god,” he answers. “They should be making offerings to you or the other Aesir—”
Is that it? “That doesn’t offend me,” I interrupt happily. “Why should it offend you? I don’t care. Let them make offerings to whatever they want.”
Erik looks at me like I have bats flying out of my ears. “This. . . doesn’t offend you?”
I’m Catholic, so technically all of this is blasphemous anyway. “No.” Although Erik is calm and isn’t making any special attempt to seem domineering, my hands still shake with nerves. I squeeze them and fold them behind my back. “Besides, that’s not entirely true. They have a shrine for me back at the barracks that their people regularly make tribute to.” This is going good. He’s not yelling. I think he’s listening to me. I start to remember other reasons I needed to talk to him. “I know you brought the female survivors here for your people, but . . . did you know some of them are already married?”
He nods for me to continue, as if my point was not evident.
“That’s. . . bad,” I finish lamely. “I mean. . . if you want to assimilate the survivors into your clan, you have my support. They have to stay somewhere, and from what I can tell, you do a good job of protecting your people.” Like I’d hoped, Erik doesn’t take this as condescending and looks pleased with the praise. “I don’t have a problem with that. I have a problem with killing off a bunch of men because you don’t want genetic competition. It’s. . . honestly, it’s gross. People should be able to choose who they marry.”
I can’t believe it. He’s not yelling at me. In fact, he actually looks like he’s agreeing with me.
“And another thing. . . uh, I had a talk with Charlotte. I’m sorry, but she doesn’t want to marry you.”
Erik snorts a short burst of air. “I have no interest in Charlotte.”
I may have been single all my life, but that doesn’t mean I’m ignorant to the whims of the heart. I people watch. I’ve seen plenty of movies. I’ve shipped enough fictional couples to notice carefully concealed affection when I see it. “If you still love Jane, why’d you call off the engagement?”
“I did not end things with Jane,” he says, sounding surprised I would suggest it. “Is that what she told you? One day I was engaged, and the next moment she informed me I was not. She’s the one who proposed. Did she tell you that? Our marriage was to be the great uniting of our people.”
For once I feel lightheaded from intense excitement. This is amazing. Is it really this simple? I used to matchmake for my friends all the time. I’m a fantastic wing-woman, if I do say so myself.
I think I might actually be able to help these people.
Ben exhales sharply through his nose in what I suspect is a concealed laugh.
Jane shoots a confused look at him, and then stares back down at me. “Are you insane?”
I shrink away slightly at her tone, the adrenaline running out of me. “This is great news. I thought you’d be more excited.”
“I would rather boil myself alive in a vat of my own piss than marry that man,” she states flatly.
“Erik said you proposed to him.” I’m so confused. “Why'd you break the engagement?”
Jane rolls her eyes. “Irreconcilable differences.”
“You don’t think you can reconcile?” Unbelievable. This was such a simple solution, but of course she has to be difficult. “You have no interest in marrying Erik? None whatsoever?”
“Look at that,” Jane exclaims sarcastically, turning and shooting Ben another look. “She’s catching on.”
I’m so upset, I have to bite the inside of my cheek to keep from laughing. “I’m just trying to help.”
“You want to help? We don’t need a matchmaker, we need you to harness your powers so you can effectively babysit your people. We need you to prove you’re a god worth listening to. We need you to stop being such a disappointment.”
“Jane,” Ben warns.
“What, Ben?” She whirls around and yells, “We’re all thinking it. She’s our best chance at stopping the genocide of our people? Look at her. Tell me you were expecting someone so short and. . . docile. Oh, gee,” she says in a higher octave, “Why can’t we just all hold hands and roast marshmallows over the fire? Tee-hee!”
She’s mocking me. I come to her with a viable answer to her people’s problems, and she mocks me. She has the power to end this war by sucking it up and at least attempting to talk through whatever relationship drama happened between her and Erik, and instead she shoves all the blame back on me. How is any of this my fault?
“Oh, shut up,” I snarl.
It’s only after Jane cuts off mid-sentence and blinks at me with surprise that I realize I spoke aloud. Now that it’s out, I can’t seem to stop.
“You think this is funny?” I continue loudly. “You think this is funny? You people came to me for help. Everyone keeps telling me the worlds gonna end if I don’t do this or I don’t do that, and you people cart me around like some brainless ameba, and you leave me in the dark when telling me what’s going on would mean I could actually be of some help. And what do I get out of all this?” I jab a finger up at her. “You knocked me unconscious the first day I got here!”
“It was day four,” she mumbles.
“And their people,” I turn and jab my finger at the general direction of the door, “just tried to poison me! So please, Jane, explain why the hell I should care about what happens to any of you?!”
“Hm. You’re still short. But this,” Jane swirls a finger around, gesturing to my outburst. I watch as her slightly raised eyebrows flatline, her mouth slowly forming a smile. “I can work with this.”
I never could understand my dad’s problem. His controlling nature was so aggressive, my siblings and I had to learn Italian in secret because for some xenophobic reason, he only wanted us to speak English.
I grew up with the mentality that women are to stay home, breed, and keep their mouth shut because what on earth could we intellectually offer? Even though I obviously don't agree with any of that, it's been drilled into me all my life. Sometimes I can't help but relapse back into the days when I really would shut up and sit down when my father ordered me to.
Like right now.
On the bright side, I was able to convince them all not to kill the male survivors of Oceanic 815. Unfortunately, that re-opened the can of worms about equal distribution of survivors between Ben’s people and Erik’s people, of which Erik refuses to budge.
I try not to flinch as Erik continues to rant, but it’s proving more difficult than I’d hoped. Unlike when he was speaking to me directly, he is very angry and loud and reminds me a little too much of my father. It also doesn’t help that the majority of norsemen at the meeting—sorry, Thing, as Gail so often corrects—seem to agree with Erik’s argument.
“We are a people of war,” he explains. “We have always been a people of war who have prayed to a goddess of war. Long before my ancestors set foot on this island, our people valued strength and power. But with every new generation, our people grow soft. We are losing our culture, my lady. Your culture. I won’t let that happen.”
A few of the older men grumble in agreement. A few of the younger men look at me to see if I have anything to add.
Freyja’s not the goddess of war. Is she? I though she was the goddess of love and fertility? What was it my professors said? She was responsible for guiding people into the afterlife? Or was that the Valkyries?
How would risking the lives of both these societies be more beneficial than seeking a permanent truce? The less dead people, the better. Maybe I should bring that up? Make them feel guilty for wanting to give me more work by carrying more dead people to Valhalla or Hel or wherever?
Should I slam my palms against the table? Leave the Thing without another word? What am I supposed to do? I look at Jane, but she’s no help. Ben is busy writing something. Annie wasn’t allowed to attend the Thing. And the rest of the men in attendance are either ignoring me or staring blankly at my seat at the end of the long table.
“I guess. . .” I clear my throat and start again. “I don’t think we should. . .” I have no clue what I’m saying. I’m tired, I’m starving, and I’m one-hundred percent done with living this weird stressful version of the show. I just want to go home. Nobody’s listening to me anyway.
“Since when did you all decide to elevate the position of jarl to that above the Vanir?” I look up at the voice and lock eyes with Liv. “You want to talk of madness, Erik?” she continues. “That is madness. You are my dearest brother, and a strong leader, but you are mortal—nothing else. To claim otherwise is blasphemy.”
The grumbling returns, only this time, I think it’s in my favor.
“Lady Cora,” Liv continues, and I can’t help but feel elated at being rescued. “I for one would like to hear what you have to say.”
We set sail immediately back to the mainland, and now I stand in the same spot I stood in my nightmare, staring at the entirely male group of Oceanic 815 survivors. Some of them are characters never fully introduced in the show, but the ones I know—Jack, Charlie, Sayid, Jin, Hugo, Boone—stare at me with a mixture of everything from fascination to pure unadulterated hatred.
Like I did with the women, I double check my observation before clearing my throat and announcing, “Where are the rest of them?”
“This is everyone,” Erik answers.
“Michael Dawson and John Locke are missing. Not to mention Kate Austen is missing from the women’s group.” It feels good to be right—and yes, I mentioned the characters by first and last name just to spite Erik—but my voice still falters at the look on his face. “This isn’t everyone, Erik. And what have you done with the tail end survivors?” I give him a moment to answer before saying, “You do have the tail end survivors, don’t you?”
Erik turns and speaks old norse to one of his men, and they laugh.
I try my best to ignore him and ask the survivors where Michael, Locke, and Kate are. Much like when I asked the women back at Hydra, all these men do is glare at me. That is, until I ask Hugo.
“Hey, so like. . . I know you’re an animal god or whatever, but. . . just try not to freak out okay?” Hugo fidgets while he thinks of the best way to approach the subject. “Before we got, you know, surrounded by these Viking dudes. . . they may have gone into the jungle to. . . uh. . . to hunt boars and . . . stuff. Sorry about that.”
“These hunters should be punished, my lady.” Liv follows closely beside me, with Jane and a small group of guards not far behind, as we trek deeper into the jungle. “It is illegal to hunt the sacred island boar.”
Thankfully, Liv knows how to track because I’m completely turned around. Every tree looks the same to me. For all I know, we could be going in circles.
I don’t think we should punish someone who didn’t know the law before breaking it. We just need to find them and tell them not to hunt boar anymore. Why is everyone’s first reaction to inflict corporal punishment?
“Mom! Mom,” Fenrir barks excitedly at my feet. “I smell blood! Lots of blood!”
A child’s scream pierces through the trees and makes my hairs stand on end. “Did you hear that?”
A wailing little piglet comes bursting out of the tall grass. He halts abruptly when he sees us and turns to flee in the other direction. “Help!” he cries in perfect English. “Help! There are more of them!” In his mad dash to escape, the piglet gets his stubby little legs caught in a tangle of vines and he crashes down, screaming louder than ever. “Don’t eat me,” it begs as I get closer. “Don’t eat me! Mama! Help!”
“It’s okay,” I say in my most reassuring voice. “We’re not going to hurt you.”
“Liar! You hurt my brothers!”
“No, that wasn’t me,” I promise the frightened piglet. “I’m here to protect you.”
“You’re here to eat me and my family,” he refutes and thrashes in the tangled vines. When Fenrir trots closer to sniff him, the boar says, “Stay away from me! I’ll bite you!”
“Please don’t bite us,” I beg. “We just want to help you. See?” I hold out my empty hands. “I’m not eating you. Fenrir’s not eating you. None of us are eating you.”
The piglet finally stops thrashing and oinks, “You’re not going to eat me?”
“No, I’m not. Come here, it’s alright.” I gently untangle his legs and scoop up the little baby boar, cradling him in my arms and brushing a hand over his bristly black hair. His birth must have been recent because he’s no bigger than a loaf of bread. He looks up at me with big, frightened eyes. “Fenrir,” I say to the excited pup at my feet, “can you smell humans from here? Take us to them.”
We find Locke, Michael, and Kate in the middle of tying up a dead boar. Once they realize they’re surrounded, they surrender without a fight. But I barely notice.
I point at a fully grown boar stumbling towards me on unstable hooves. “That one’s hurt,” I say to no one in particular.
“Please,” the dying boar gurgles at me, “why is this happening? Make it stop.” It looks like they attempted to slash his throat, but they didn’t cut deep enough to make it quick. “I think I’m dying. . .”
“Brother!” The much smaller piglet in my arms thrashes wildly. “No!”
I reach for the larger injured boar as he coughs up blood and collapses, unmoving.
Liv pulls me back. “You cannot help him now. Look, he has already passed. You two, take the survivors back to the beach. We’ll discuss the terms of a trial later. Just get them out of here. Cora? Cora? Cora, we need to return to the beach.”
I stare up at the hanging boar, sliced open from its throat to its back legs, blood spilling out of it, organs already partially removed. I flinch away from a hand on my arm and turn to find Liv.
“My lady,” she says softly, "I’m sorry. You could not have helped him. Either of them. We will ensure their lives are celebrated tonight.”
I nod. Gag on the stench of blood in the air. Hold the wailing piglet tighter to my chest. Struggle not to gag again. Nod.
The norsemen waste no time lighting massive campfires on the beach and butchering the piglet’s dead brother and mother to use for meat and God knows what else. I didn’t stay to find out. I don’t want to smell it anymore.
I sit in the sand with Pumba’s warm little belly in my lap and Fenrir’s floppy limbs flinging sand in the air as he scouts out the surrounding area. Pumba stopped oinking a while ago, and now he sits perfectly still, taking a depression nap while my people cook his family just down the shoreline. I wait for laughter or tears, but I just feel irritated.
“It’s not wise to be out here alone, my lady.”
“I’m not alone, Gail.” I wave a hand behind me towards the trees, not bothering to look up. “Liv’s been watching me from behind that brush since we returned. I don’t think she knows I know.”
“Cora,” Gail pauses. “I can’t imagine what you’re feeling right now, but just know they view this as a funeral of sorts. A remembrance for who those boar were as living things.”
“By cooking and eating them?” I snap.
Gail walks closer to where I sit watching the waves crash against sand as the sunset melts every shade of orange together. “I brought you some fruit instead,” she says. “You need to eat something.”
“No offense, Gail, but I don’t even know for certain you don’t want me dead.”
Gail retracts her offering and takes a seat next to me in the sand. “I never knew my parents. Grew up in foster-care. Nasty place with equally nasty caretakers who made it very clear they were taking me in for the money.” She shakes the bowl to mix up the cocktail of berries and chunks of assorted island fruits, picks a mango slice at random, and offers me the bowl again.
“No thanks. I know how this works,” I say as she takes a bite. “I’ve read The Princess Bride.”
Gail laughs and reaches for more fruit. “Long story short, I worked all my young life to be the best of the best. The brightest. The sharpest. I excelled in college and was set to start research projects that would change the world. There was only one problem.” She pauses, and I wonder if she expects me to make a guess. “I was a woman.”
Oh, right. She would have been attending college in the 60’s or 70’s judging by her age. I’m sure that was. . . lovely.
“There was always some bright-eyed-pea-for-brains young man who’d waltz into the lab and try to take credit for my work. I had a few projects completely stolen because the department always sided with the man. I was so disheartened, I almost dropped out of the science program all together. That’s when I was approached by the Dharma Initiative. They told me I was a highly sought after candidate.”
Gail offers me the bowl again and smiles when I relent and take a handful of blackberries. Poison me. I don’t care anymore. I’m starving.
"You can only imagine how flattered I was,” she says. “Of course I accepted their offer of employment. The Initiative was conducting new and exciting research, and I was eager to be a part of their next big scientific breakthrough."
“How did you end up with the norsemen?” I ask, already reaching for more fruit.
“You brought me to them,” she answers. “After I was finally approved to work on Hydra Island, I discovered the cruelty of their animal experimentation. I expressed my concern, but they threatened to imprison me if I didn't continue with the experiments. I didn’t take their threats lightly, as I had no family to inquire about my absence, and I was afraid they would have done worse than imprison me if I didn’t fall in line. You gave me another option. You took me from Hydra and brought me to your people on the mainland, and with them I have stayed for the past 30 years."
“But you don’t live on the mainland.”
Gail smiles. “Yes, well. All of the women and children moved to Hydra after the Great Liberation.”
“Why only the women?”
“It’s safer there,” she answers. “The monster cannot cross the ocean.”
“Oh.” I reach for more berries. “What’s the Great Liberation?”
“It goes by a few different names. The Great Liberation. The Incident. The Hydra Catastrophe. You stormed Hydra, freed the experiments, and. . . well, dear, you killed everyone else on that island.”
Gail hands me the bowl as I shovel mango and papaya and berries in my mouth as fast as I can. Maybe if I eat more, what she’s saying will make sense.
“Cora, when you saved me from the Initiative, you gave me more than a place to stay. You taught me not to take shit from anyone.” Gail gives me a knowing look and nods towards the fire down the beach. “Especially not some cocky bastard with delusions of grander.”
I don’t say anything, but she keeps talking.
“This is my home just as much as it is Erik’s and his men. I cannot imagine living anywhere else. I have taught more children than I could ever hope to count.” Gail smiles fondly. “Annie was my star pupil. She’s made a fine doctor.” Gail takes one of my hands and squeezes. “Cora, you are the closest thing I’ve ever had to a family,” she whispers with such sincerity, I have no choice but to believe her. “And I will personally disembowel anyone who tries to hurt you. Oh, you have some mango on your chin, dear.” Rubbing her sleeve over my skin, Gail cleans the mess and smiles.
“Miss Collins,” Ben’s voice is almost drowned out by the crashing waves. “I need to speak to you. No, you can stay Gail,” he adds when she starts to stand. “In fact, I’d prefer if you did. Christopher just delivered some. . . less than encouraging news. We have no other choice. It’s time we tell her.”
I reach for more fruit, but my fingers probe an empty bowl. “Tell me what?”
“Here?” Gail asks in surprise. “Are you sure you want to discuss this here?”
“At least I know we’re alone here,” he answers softly, and I get his reasoning. Ben's standing close, but the rough high tide drowns out his voice. If anyone wanted to eavesdrop, they’d have to be close enough for us to know they were near.
Instead of taking a seat on my left, Ben walks behind me and takes a seat on the opposite side of Gail. I notice he also has a bowl full of fruit and what looks like carrots.
I frown in confusion. “You’re not eating boar?”
“I don’t eat anything that once had a mother.” Ben pops a berry in his mouth and chews. “I’m afraid I’m going to have to be frank about this. Time is not our ally at the moment.” One, two, three berries. I watch him chew. Another berry. Chew. Another. Chew.
“Benjamin,” says Gail. “Do you want me to tell her?”
“No. Sorry. I. . . Miss Coll—” Ben pauses, puts the bowl down beside him in the sand, and finally looks over at me. “Cora, I’m afraid I need to ask for another favor.”
The laugh I’d been waiting for all afternoon comes bursting out of me. “Yeah," I tell Ben, "sorry, but I don’t think Erik will be interested in marrying you.”
“We don’t mean Erik,” Gail cuts in. “There is one position above him in the governing hierarchy.”
Who ranks a jarl? Liv? No, she’s already married. “There is?”
“Yes,” Gail says with a small nod. “A Goddess.”
I wait for them to explain more, but they both just stare at me.
There are only two things that can placate Erik’s insatiable need for tradition: war or a marriage between the two governing factions. A few years ago, that was slated to be Jane and Erik. Now, apparently everyone expects me to bite the biggest bullet of my life by marrying a complete stranger.
Gail speaks first. “What do you think?”
I find myself squinting instead of laughing. “I think you need to come up with another plan.”
Ben’s eyes dart away towards the water before looking back at me. “Did you not hear what I said? My contact just disclosed Erik's secret intent to kill my people tomorrow with or without your consent. Kill them. Take their children. I’m not even sure he’ll spare the women at this point.”
I know it makes me a horrible human being, but I don’t care. I’m not going to forsake a life’s worth of promises to myself because a group of grown adults want to act like the children from Lord of the Flies. “Yes, I heard you. You’re both going to duke it out tomorrow.”
“Duke it out?” he questions slowly. Ben looks from me to Gail and gives his head a small shake of disbelief. “This isn’t a schoolyard brawl, Cora. I just had to evacuate my daughter so she won’t have to watch the death of everyone she’s ever known.”
I know. I know, and I’m sorry. “My answer is no. Think of another plan.”
“There is no other plan,” Ben says snidely. “Just because I haven’t explained to you every failed idea we’ve attempted up to this point doesn’t mean I’m presenting this last resort lightly. You think I haven’t exhausted every alternative option before relying on marriage to you?”
In one swift motion, I lean over Gail and slosh my cup of water in his face. Pumba wakes up and hops off my lap, asking what’s going on. Ignoring whatever Gail is trying to say to me, I stand and walk toward the fires as Pumba and Fenrir follow so closely I almost trip on them.
A few people try to get my attention as I approach the collection of roaring fires, but I am filled with a single-minded determination. I find her sharpening a knife.
Jane raises an eyebrow when she sees me. “Not here,” she says and stands, motioning for me to follow her away from the chattering men. “Something tells me you weren’t a fan of the idea.”
“You can end this.”
“I like your optimism,” she says. “It’s cute.”
“You can stop all of this, right now. Why won’t you?”
“We can’t assassinate Erik.” Jane inspects her sharpened knife in the faint moonlight glow, not even looking at me. “There’s about ten norsemen ready to replace him and his ideological hangups. Ben was supposed to explain that to you.”
“I’m not talking about assassinating Erik,” I hiss. “Why won’t you marry—”
“He’s not my type,” she interrupts.
Jane's nonchalantness—the casual way in which she condemns her own people—enrages me. “You’re willing to risk everyone’s safety because he’s not your type? What is wrong with you? You proposed to him. He’s obviously still in love with you. Why won’t you at least try to talk to him? What’s so wrong with him?”
Jane sheathes the knife. “He’s a man.”
I frown at her in confusion. Yes? And? “Oh. Ohhh.” I sink into a crouch in the sand at the revelation, and poor Pumba takes the opportunity to try and climb back into my lap. Now that this plan is completely shot to hell, my head lulls as the adrenaline dies down. “Sorry,” I whisper, “it just . . . seemed like you were jealous. I mean, you beat Erik up pretty badly because he got engaged to someone else.”
“I wasn’t—” I watch as her angry expression instantly drops. She takes a seat next to me. “When I was leader,” she says more gently than I’ve ever heard her speak, “I thought I could fix everything myself. I was trying to do what’s right. I was trying to help my people. I thought I could. . . I thought I could get over it. But Erik is obsessed with tradition. You think he’d marry me without wanting children? Just the thought of that man’s—” Her entire face puckers. “In the end, I just couldn’t go through with it.”
“Well, I’m not getting married in your place.”
“Ugh,” she exhales up towards the moon. “I knew Ben would butcher this. Forget whatever he told you and listen to me. We are asking you to sign a contract and host a small party. That’s it. It would be the complete opposite of traditional. You two wouldn’t even be living on the same island. You can go back to Hydra and sit on your throne and bless newborn babies all day, and we can go back to the barracks and not die.”
What she’s saying makes complete sense, and at the same time, it makes me sick to my stomach—surprisingly more sick than the thought of an actual war. “I can’t.”
I wait for her to yell at me, but she lowers her voice and calmly says, “I’m listening.”
Where to begin? How am I supposed to explain the entire history of my intensely religious Italian family? The massive dysfunction of my parents marriage? The fact that not a single one of my Sicilian relatives have ever gotten a divorce? Years and years of crying myself to sleep at night and promising I would never get married so I could always be in control of every aspect of my life?
People lie. People change. People learn to hate each other after it’s too late.
How am I supposed to explain all of this in a way Jane would understand or care about?
“I’m sorry, but I’m not marrying anyone. It’s. . . an ethics issue.”
“Oh,” she scoffs, “and letting a few dozen people get slaughtered isn’t against your ethics? Got it. If you’ll excuse me, I need to get a head start back to my friends at home.” When I try to apologize, Jane spins back around. “Do you want to know what the shittiest thing about all of this is? I grew up with the norsemen. All those men sitting around the fire? They’re my friends just as much as my neighbors back at the Barracks. So no matter who dies, it isn’t about sides to me anymore. A lot of my friends are going to be dead tomorrow.”
I want to scream at her that what she’s asking of me isn’t fair. Marriage may not be that big of a deal to her, but it’s a sacred thing in my family. Marrying a complete stranger is out of the question. It’s insulting.
I stay seated in the sand and watch Jane walk away towards where Ben and Gail are standing near the shore. Pumba rubs his little wet snout against my arm, but I don’t pick him up. I run a hand over his bristly back to calm him down and watch as Jane tells Ben something, gesturing angrily in my direction. They go back and forth until he nods down at the sand and the two strap on their backpacks and disappear into the trees.
I’ve been knocked unconscious, poisoned, threatened, guilted, and pressured since the moment Ive gotten here. I haven’t even been able to eat a real meal without something happening to induce vomiting. No one here has my best interest at heart because they’re so preoccupied with their own. I’m being treated like a genie who grants unlimited wishes.
So what if these people war with each other? Who cares?
It’s not my problem.
Pumba continues to silently rub his snout against my arm. I look down and see him for what he is—a frightened child whose family was just killed in front of him.
It’s not my problem.
Like Ben said, the kids won’t be harmed.
Tomorrow, Indiana will probably share Pumba’s fate. How could I ever look at her again knowing I could have stopped it? How many other children live at the Barracks? How many other children are about to lose one or both of their parents?
Loud laughter echoes over from the where the largest group sit with Erik, talking cheerfully. I take note of their weapons. The rest of the norsemen guard the very confused looking survivors broken up into three smaller groups around three separate fires.
Erik brings up a chunk of Pumba’s—Mother? Brother? There’s no way to tell—roasted family member and takes a ravenous bite.
Tracking them down is near impossible in the darkness, especially since I only had Gail to point me in the general direction they left in. Fenrir would be more useful if he wasn’t so easily distracted. It takes a concentrated effort not to huff loudly as I snake my way through the beaten path of trees and brush and long blades of jungle grass. Jane raises her gun for half a second when I finally hurry up behind them.
“Would all of this stop?” I smack away bugs and thank all that is holy in this world that I don’t have the ability to understand insects. “Can you guarantee our marriage would stop the war?”
“Honestly?” Ben falls silent and closes his eyes. When he opens them, he’s looking very intently at a fern. “There’s honestly no guarantee of anything. All I know for certain is the only alternative they will respect is war.”
“We just sign a piece of paper?” I ask. My whole body is shaking, and not from the temperature. “And that’s it? You stay on this island and I go back to Hydra?”
They both stare at me like they cannot quite figure out if I’m agreeing to their demands or just being difficult.
“You can go wherever you’d like. They’re technically both your islands. But yes,” Ben answers quickly when I frown. “It’s essentially down to penning a comprehensive yet thorough treaty alongside the usual wedding license—”
I turn and start the walk back to the beach.
“Is that a yes?” Jane yells after me. “Hey? Hey! Cora, stop!”
“Yes, it’s a yes,” I answer. It’s difficult not to sound as angry as I feel, but even more so when Jane huffs a laugh.
“No,” she says, smirking, “I meant you’re going the wrong way. Beach is this way.”
“Okay.” I clear my throat, but the yelling continues. “Excuse me?”
One of the norsemen paces in the sand, jabbing the air with a finger and yelling in an indecipherable language. A few men push him and laugh. A few look at me and immediately lose interest.
I inhale a lungful of air and order as forcefully as I can, “Excuse me? I need to say something.” But it still isn’t enough to get everyone’s attention.
I can smell the roasted boar and it makes my stomach groan in protest. I can never have bacon again. Sausages. Pasta Carbonara. Prosciutto. I can never eat some of my favorite dishes ever again without hearing the confused gurgling pleas of Pumba’s dying brother. And here they all are, eating away at a creature I could hold a conversation with just a few hours ago.
A pain shoots through my eyes and my chest tightens with what I can only assume is panic, but for some reason it doesn’t feel like panic. It feel like I’m drowning. My chest hurts like I’m breathing water, but instead of losing consciousness, I feel like I could punch through a brick wall. A man sitting nearby looks over at me—his eyes quickly filling with fear—and he drops his helping of boar in the sand.
“Sit down,” I scream, and the entirety of the group practically collapses to the sand in a mad scramble to seat themselves. Even the survivors hurry to sit and scoot away from me.
This might be the angriest I’ve ever been. Looking around at all the frightened faces—who usually gossip about me behind my back or ignore me completely—somehow makes it easy for me to say exactly what I’m thinking. “Since some of you can’t seem to honor commitments, I find myself with no choice but to fulfill them for you.”
I pause, expecting pushback, but nobody so much as coughs.
“You want to go back to the old ways? Fine. You want me to lead by example? Fine. There will be no war because I’ve decided to end what you two started.” I point at both Jane and Erik. “There will be no war because I will be the one to unite our peoples through marriage.”
I watch as the northmen pause to process what I’ve said and then collectively lose their shit.
“No,” Erik begins, “my lady—”
“Do not speak,” I seethe through clenched teeth, and he sits back down. “Correct me if I’m wrong, Erik, but isn’t this entire mess your fault to begin with? You want the old ways, congratulations. Here they are.”
“He hasn’t told you?” Erik stays seated but smiles smugly in Ben’s direction. “Go on then. Tell her.”
I look over to see Ben’s uncomfortable expression flickering in the campfire’s blaze and immediately realize something is wrong. “Tell me what?”
“Tell her what you did,” Erik commands. “Remind everyone what you are.”
“I—” Ben opens his mouth to answer but changes his mind. It’s confusing to see him so shaken. He’s supposed to be the one person on this island who always has a plan, but it legitimately looks like he doesn’t know how to respond. For a second I find his eyes, but he cannot keep the contact.
“You coward,” Erik sneers. “Goddess, he is the reason you were reborn. He is the one who killed you.”
Chapter 9: An Angry Goddess
Chapter Text
DHARMA, 1975
Our classroom is my sanctuary. It's the one place I can go without fear of being bullied. I've been the target of Doug and his gang of brainless followers since I first moved here. Recently they've even started picking on Annie just because she's my friend. They knock books out of her hands and steal the homework out of her binder.
Annie is friends with the entire class—aside from the stupid bullies—but she’s the only classmate who doesn’t make me feel like an outsider. She’s off somewhere with Susan. I guess I can’t hog her attention all the time.
It's easiest to spend my time here, after the school day has ended. The classroom is peaceful and deserted. Best of all, I don't have to worry about my father. There are some things worse than school bullies.
Miss Collins noticed the bruises on my arms today during class, but she thankfully never asked where they came from. I don't think I'd be able to admit that I got them for accidentally dropping my dad's uniform on the floor while trying to hang it in the closet for him. I was sweaty with fear that Miss Collins would make a big deal about it, but she just gave me one of her sad smiles, ruffled my hair, and wandered off to chastise someone in the back of the room.
I like Miss Collins, and not just because she tells interesting stories or bakes the class cookies or gives us presents all the time. She takes special effort to know everything about us. She has a genuine interest in our hopes and dreams and aspirations for the future and gives good advice for how to achieve it. She protects all of us equally— even Doug—from whatever it is that's troubling us. Miss Collins is first adult I actually trust, and life doesn't seem so scary when I'm near her.
It also doesn't hurt that Annie and I are her favorite students.
Annie's crazy about Miss Collins, too. Especially because they both share a love of animals. She’s constantly lecturing the class on the importance of respecting the Goddess Freyja and her sacred island animals so we don’t start a war with the norsemen. Miss Collins is almost as protective of the island's wildlife as she is of us. She's constantly bringing in new animals for us to interact with. But with some of the bigger ones—like Shadowfax the horse —we have to hold class outside.
We were standing around outside, listening to a lecture about the history of horses, when I looked up at Miss Collins right when the sun hit the back of her head. Her hair burst with a shimmering golden glow that almost blinded me, but I couldn't close my eyes. She laughed at something I didn’t hear, and continued the lecture with a smile at the questions the class was asking. For some reason, it made me indescribably happy that she was happy.
About a year ago, when our old teacher Mrs. Goodspeed disappeared and was replaced with Miss Collins, she was practically bursting with chaotic happy energy that made school fun for the first time since I’ve been here. It was hard to be in a bad mood around someone so upbeat and cheerful.
But lately, that energy has dulled significantly. I feel like I see her looking more upset than happy most of the time, and it makes me sweaty with anxious worry that maybe Annie and I have something to do with it, even though we haven’t disobeyed her once since the incident with the norsemen.
The doorknob squeaks and jiggles. I jump up from my seat on the floor and panic. Where to hide? Where to hide? Nobody ever comes in here at this time of day!
I leap towards the little pushcart where we hang up our rain jackets for monsoon season. Nestling myself deep within them, I hold my breath as a janitor walks in, wheeling a mop bucket in front of him.
Dad.
"What the hell?" he mumbles, looking around the classroom in disgust. Miss Collins makes us move our desks to the outer rim of the classroom. She wants everyone to interact with each other, and it also makes it easier for her to bring animals in for us to play with. My favorite is Prince Humperdinck, our class pet rabbit. He shed a lot today, and now his pure white fur rolls around in little fluffy tumbleweeds.
My dad churns the mop in the sudsy bucket and prepares to clean the floor. I hunker down deeper into the cloaks and pray he doesn't move this pushcart to clean behind it.
The door opens again, and I hear a welcoming voice. "Oh, Roger," says Miss Collins. "I didn't know you were in here."
"Huh?" Dad turns to look at her, and that expression crosses over his features—the one he uses when he doesn't want to talk to someone but is trying very hard not to be rude. "Oh, hello, teach."
“You can call me Cora."
"Yeah," he says. "Okay."
"Your son is in my class," she says. "Actually, since you're here, I figure we can discuss him."
"Yeah?" he snaps at her. "What's he done now?"
"Done? Oh, no, no. Ben's one of my best students. Very curious. Very eager to learn. His brain is like a sponge. It's fascinating."
"Huh." Dad laughs. "You sure we're talking about the same kid?"
Even from my hiding spot I can see Miss Collins' lips twitch in a losing fight to keep smiling. It's as if her cheerful glow is slowly draining away, and in its place is something terrifying. She smiles silently at my dad for an uncomfortable amount of time.
"Do you need something?” he asks, sounding annoyed. “I’m kinda busy here.”
“Do you take your job seriously, Roger?”
My dad shrugs. “What’s so serious about mopping floors?”
“Mm,” she hums. “I take my job very seriously.”
“Good for you.”
"Do you know anything about dragons, Roger?”
"Do I know about what?"
“Dragons,” she repeats. "Mythical creatures of unparalleled power. They are most famous for hoarding and defending treasure." Miss Collins straightens up, and even though she's still shorter than my dad, she looks infinitely scarier than he does. “Think of me as a dragon. Which would make my students my priceless hoard."
"What the hell are you talking about?"
Miss Collins sighs in annoyance. "Okay, if you can't wrap your head around dragons, think of me like a bear. Mother bears maul other animals to death to protect their cubs. My students are my cubs, and I am more than happy to maul anyone and everyone who threatens their safety."
“You've got a few screws loose, don't you?” Dad shakes his head and starts to mop the floor. “You sure you should be teaching kids?”
Miss Collins yanks his mop away, and I watch my dad’s hands raise up in surprise, like he doesn’t know whether to flinch away or fistfight.
"I don't think you understand me," she states in a low voice. “It's my job to make sure my students are safe. If they don't feel safe, they don't learn. So when students show up to class with bruises, I have cause for being concerned."
"What I do with my kid is none of your business. I can’t believe this,” he scoffs. “Who do you think you are? Olivia would never have spoken to me like this.”
“Olivia may have tolerated your shit, but I assure you I do not.”
Dad doesn't look afraid, but then again he's never been the brightest crayon in the box, as Miss Collins always says. "I'm sure Horace would love to hear about this."
“Oh, I’m sure he would!” Miss Collins smiles. "Think about that for a moment, Roger. Who do you think anyone is going to believe? The island drunk, or the poor little school teacher who enjoys knitting and baking and hosting class outdoors?”
“Are you threatening me?”
“No,” she exclaims, laughing as if he’s just said the funniest thing she’s ever heard. “A threat would be if I told you to stop abusing your son or I’m going to douse you in oil and light you on fire. See the difference?”
Dad finally has the sense to look afraid as she bursts into even harder laughter.
“I know what you’re thinking. She’s insane! I should go report this and get her fired!”
“Yeah,” my dad says. “That’s exactly what I’m thinking.”
“And who, exactly, will you report this to? Will they even know who you are? Because I guarantee they know who I am. You want to know the funny thing about community, Roger? Power is being liked. Power is having friends. And you don’t have any friends. You’re an unpleasant alcoholic who smells bad. So you have two options. You can either take my advice—” She pauses, smiling. “—or you can choose not to. But one thing is for certain.” Miss Collins leans in and whispers, “If I have to talk to you again, I will bury you alive in an unmarked grave, and no one will even notice you’re gone.”
Miss Collins stares up at him with such intense loathing that it makes me afraid she’s actually going to kill him. All the muscles in my body twitch with the desire to burst out of this coatrack and tell her to please stop. I don’t want my dad to die, I just want him to stop hitting me.
“I hope we have an understanding,” she says, dropping the mop down beside him. “And don’t bother reporting this parent-teacher conference, Roger. We both know there aren’t any cameras in this room, and you’ll only make a fool of yourself.” She walks back to the door and throws it wide open. "Now," she says with a cheerful smile, "get the hell out of my classroom. I'm quite capable of cleaning it."
The door clicks shut behind him, and the classroom falls dead silent.
Before I can decide whether or not to reveal myself, Miss Collins speaks. "It's alright, Ben. You can come out now."
“Shut up, Erik,” Jane screams from across the raging fire. “He did not kill Cora.”
I simply wait for all the attention to fall onto the arguing pair, and then I back away from the fire and disappear into the trees.
It’s difficult to see where I’m going, but honestly it’s a massive comfort that the shrill hiss and click of night bugs overpowers the random babble of birds overhead.
“Where are we going?” Fenrir asks.
“I don’t know. But you two stay close to me, okay?”
“Yes, mama,” Pumba answers.
I stop and kneel in front of the both of them. “You two are brothers now. Stay together. I’m going to look after you, but you need to stay close and listen to me. Understand?” When they agree with a bark and oink respectively, I place a kiss on the tops of their heads and continue on into the unknown.
“Why are we running away from the humans?” Fenrir asks.
“I don’t trust the humans.”
“Why not?”
“Because they can’t seem to make up their minds. We’re just going to find a nice cave somewhere where we can—” My feet are abruptly pulled out from under me. I'm yanked up into the sky, swinging in midair, trapped in some sort of net. Why is this even here? I thought Rousseau was adopted by the Others?
Without any warning, the skies open up wide, and it begins to pour. I dangle silently in the darkness for a good thirty seconds before I’ve mustered up the strength to be angry.
“WHY?” I twist my fingers in the rope net and shake them with all my might. “Why is this happening to me? I never skip Mass! I pray every night! Why, God? Tell me what I did wrong!” My legs have squeezed through two holes near the bottom of the net, and it's giving me a horrid wedgie. I feel a panic attack arising as my breath gets shallow and wheezes out of my lungs like a rusty hinge. “You want Hail Mary’s? Whatever I did to deserve this, I’ll make it right, I swear! I. . . I—” I can’t breathe. My chest hurts. Am I having a heart attack?
“Mama! Are you okay?”
No, not a heart attack. I don’t think? Panic. It’s just panic. “Pumba, I need you to go get help. Both of you, stay together. No, no, no, no! Fenrir, stop! Listen to me. Listen to me! I need you to go get help. Stop chasing bugs!” I swing my hanging legs in the air like two angry piñatas as the rain soaks through my hair. “Boys, this is actually very painful up here. Can you please focus?”
“Okay! Wait. . .”
From out of the faint moonlight filtering in through the trees, I watch Fenrir lift his head and sniff the air. “What?” I ask. “Fenrir, what do you smell?”
“I smell help! I’ll go get them.” Fenrir trots off into the trees and returns excitedly barking, “I brought help!”
“Oh great,” I huff sarcastically and lean my head against the net. “It’s you.”
Ben slops through mud and vines until he’s standing in front of me, looking up at where I’m stuck. “Are you hurt?” he asks.
“Who, me? I’ve never been more comfortable.” I pull apart a particularly thick clump of rope so I can see him better through all the rain. “I love having all the circulation in my legs cut off. You should try it sometime.”
He says something I can’t quite hear over the torrential downpour, but it sounds suspiciously like, “Don’t move.”
“Yes, thank you,” I snap angrily. “I was just planning on running away, but now I guess I’ll stay put—” I suck in a lungful of air right as I freefall back to the ground and land hard on my buckling ankles. As a shriek of pain rips through my throat, I feel the net loosen around me until I’ve been entirely cut free. Ben sheathes his knife and holds out a hand to help me up.
“Stop screaming,” he orders. “You’re fine.”
I can’t believe I ever felt sorry for you. I can’t believe I almost just agreed to marry you.
Ignoring his outstretched hand, I scoop up a fistful of mud and fling it at him.
Ben frowns down at the splatter across his shirt. “Very mature. Thank you.”
I scoop up another handful and fling it at him. This time my aim was a little high and he gets a face-full of muddy sludge.
I immediately feel terrible. “Sorry! I’m so sorry. Are you okay? I didn’t mean to—”
Ben holds out a hand to keep me away as he swipes his eyes clean and spits as much as he can out of his mouth.
Wait, what am I apologizing for? He didn’t refute Erik when he said he killed me. Is that why nobody has been telling me the full story? Did he follow me out here to finish the job? Is that the master plan? What the hell is the master plan?
I shake off the rest of the net, grab Pumba under one arm and Fenrir under the other, and take off running in a random direction. Mud splashes up onto my dress and cakes my boots as I dodge in-between trees for what seems like a lifetime before heading into a long stretch of tall grass. I’ve stopped trying to navigate and just sprint as fast as I can until I reach a steep embankment and stop before I accidentally slide down it.
“Wait,” I hear Ben calling behind me. “Wait . . . would you please listen to me? I can explain.”
“I officially don’t care what you have to say. No, you know what? Tell me one thing. How are you still alive?” I ask, genuinely curious. “Why did they let you live if you killed me?” Ah, maybe this whole thing was a coup?
Ben takes an angry step forward. “Because I didn’t kill you.”
“Well, you sure weren’t in any hurry to deny Erik’s accusation.” There’s nowhere to run, but I find that—much like earlier on the beach—instead of feeling scared, I just feel intensely irritated. “Why is it whenever you show up, terrible things happen to me?”
Ben freezes, his dark hair plastered to his forehead from all the rain. “I can explain if you would just listen.”
Pumba and Fenrir are getting heavy, so I put them down in the mud. “Please, don’t let me stop you.”
Residual mud sloshes down his face as he blinks at the ground, thinking. “In 1977. . . you were found dead with—” Ben pauses to clear his throat. “—sixteen stab wounds in your back and abdomen.”
A thought occurs to me, and suddenly a lot of things make sense. “That’s why they spit on you. The women on Hydra. That’s why they hate you.”
“They hate me because I was there,” Ben finally answers. “I’m the only one who saw what happened.”
I look up at him, equal parts excited and terrified to finally learn how I’m going to die. “If it wasn’t you, who was it?”
Ben is still staring off into space when he answers, “I don’t remember.”
“You don’t remember. Of course you don’t.” I can’t roll my eyes hard enough. “So what you’re saying is the person who killed me 30 years ago may still be on this island? Perfect. Fantastic. I'M ECSTATIC.” I’m aware I’m being juvenile, but I can’t seem to stop. Everything I usually scream in my head just keeps pouring forth in real time. “This is great news! Thank you for sharing, Ben. You’ve been so helpful. I guess we know who just tried to poison me. . . only, no! We don’t. Because you can’t remember!”
I have no real reason to believe him, especially considering who he is, but I start to feel bad at the intensely chastised look on his face. “I’ve tried to remember.”
“Evidently not hard enough.”
“I’ve tried everything,” he refutes sharply. “Therapy. Hypnosis. Some very strange new age techniques. The memory is just . . .” He waves a hand halfheartedly around. “It’s just gone.”
It’s like he’s bitterly deflating. Reluctantly retreating into himself. It’s so pitiful, so completely out of character, I find myself apologizing again. “I’m not . . . I’m really not doing well right now. I’m sorry. I didn’t mean to hit you in the face with mud.”
His lips press together in a hard line and he nods. “I suppose suspecting everyone of secretly plotting an assassination gives you license to be at least a little irritable.”
“Everyone excluding you, of course?”
“I didn’t kill you,” he answers so softly I almost can’t hear him over the rain. “But to your people, not remembering who stabbed you is the same as being the one with the knife.”
“Why did Erik say you killed me?”
“Probably guessed you’d react the way you did. He’s deflecting. Which is good, because that means our plan actually holds water. It means he’s scared.”
I nod, too tired to be angry anymore even if I wanted to be. And then I realize something else. I died in 1977. That means Ben was. . . 12? 13? “How did you know me?” I ask him. “In the 70’s. Why were you with me when I died?”
The rain cuts off so abruptly, the sudden silence is startling.
“You were my teacher,” he finally answers, still looking at the ground. “I don’t remember where we were going or why we were out there.”
I try not to sound angry, but it’s frustrating to be so close to closure. “What do you remember?”
His eyes dart around like Aiko’s as his face settles into something resembling blankness. He doesn’t answer for so long, I’m worried I broke him.
“Nevermind,” I say quickly. “Forget it. Let’s just get back to the—”
“Help me,” he answers in a strangled huff. “That was the last thing you said before you died. All I remember was you lied down in the grass, and you reached out your hand and asked me to help you.”
“Help me what? Live? Or something else?” But the question is completely useless. “I know, I know,” I say before he can answer. “You don’t remember. Got it. Okay, can we just go back to the beach? I want to at least dry off by the fire.”
“You were headed towards the barracks when you ran off.” Ben nods at the land behind me. “We’re much closer to that than we are the beach. Erik was heading there anyway. Might as well save us some time.”
I turn and peer down the muddy slope leading to a steep drop-off bedded with sharp rocks. “Is there another way down? I don’t think. . . we—”
Ben pulls a gun out of quite literally nowhere and spins around towards the two figures I’m staring at behind him. A teenager leaning hard against a makeshift crutch grabs hold of the small child at his side and pulls him behind his back.
“Stop!” I hurry over and push Ben’s handgun down towards the mud. “Don’t point that at them.”
"Who are you?" the teenage boy asks us. "Were you on the plane, too?"
I don't know who these children are—these brothers from the crash. The eldest introduces himself as Peter and the small child is named Darcy. They were sitting in the front of the plane, but that makes no sense. In the show, the only survivor from the front of the flight was the pilot, who almost immediately died after Jack, Kate, and Charlie found and questioned him.
I don't know who these children are, and I think that means they were never meant to survive.
Ben leads the way back to the barracks while I try and keep Peter's spirits up. Upon impact, most of the bones in his right ankle were shattered, and I can tell he's in great pain. I'd offer to help heal him, but without at least trying to reset the bone, all I'll accomplish—if I even accomplish anything at all—is to heal his ankle in its broken and deformed state. I need a doctor to set it before I can heal it. Maybe Ethan can. Or Jack? Peter's making good time using a walking stick to keep up with us, but I offer to support him if he needs it.
"It's okay." I smile at the inquisitive look on Darcy's face as Fenrir and Pumba trot alongside him, sniffing his clothes. "You can pet them."
"He can't hear you," says Peter. "He's deaf."
Although the norsemen have not yet arrived, all hell breaks loose when we finally make it back to the barracks.
Alex never left.
I sit on Ben's front porch and listen to them argue—genuinely argue—for the first time since I arrived. It was such a shock to see her defiantly standing in the doorway, I haven't even had the chance to take a shower or change my clothes. Peter sits on the chair beside me. Darcy sits at our feet, playing tug-of-war with Fenrir while Pumba cheers him on.
Peter stabs at the lasagna I stole from Ben's fridge, taking a tentative bite every once in a while. We sit in silence for a long time before he asks, "Cora, what's happening?"
Nobody ever told me what it was Aiko saw. Jane mentioned Alex was in danger, but that's what Aiko saw for Ben. Does it have anything to do with me? What was it Aiko saw about me? What was it that scared her into tears? "I have no idea." I take another big bite of lasagna and shake my head. "Are you sure he's not hungry?"
Peter signs to Darcy, who shakes his head and happily continues trying to wrestle the edge of his shirt out of Fenrir's growling mouth.
They arrive at the first glimpse of sunrise over the mountains.
"Inside," I tell Peter. "Take your brother inside. He can stay with Fenrir and Pumba." Peter glances nervously from me to the advancing norsemen who somehow got through the sonic fence. "It's okay. Go."
"My lady," Erik announces when he's close enough, "we were worried when we could not find you last night."
"Yeah, I'm sure you were."
"I assumed you may have been coerced into coming here. I'm glad to see I was correct."
I prepare myself for the inevitable mood-shift of this conversation. Erik is here for a war. These pleasantries can only last so long before he gets bored and starts. . . I don't know? Decapitating random people?
"I've had time to think over this arrangement you proposed," Erik continues. "And I have decided you're right."
"I'm right?" I try not to act excited in case this is some kind of trick. "About what, exactly? The marriage pact?"
"Yes," he answers. "I have decided I will allow it."
"Oh, you'll allow it." Screw you, pompous asshole. "Thank you for your permission, Erik."
"If he lives."
If he. . . what? "What are you talking about?"
Erik isn't paying me any attention. He's too focused on something behind me. "You want a peace treaty, Benjamin? Win it. Here. Now."
I watch as Jane flits around Ben's house and tests the weight of three different sharp swords.
Richard stands by a bookshelf, watching the entire ordeal with an oddly passive expression. I wonder if Richard is worried about the war? Is he somehow exempt from the slaughter? Does he actually care about what's going to happen? "You can't do this," he says.
"Sure I can," Jane answers happily. "This is, quite literally, a dream come true."
"He didn't challenge you to a holmgang," I argue. "He challenged Ben."
"You're allowed a stand-in warrior. It's their greatest loophole." Jane feels the weight of a particular sword and finally makes her selection. "Besides, have you forgotten I grew up with these people? I've been trained by the best. This won't last very long."
Ben stands next to his desk with an unreadable expression. As Jane continues rambling about the impending duel, Ben removes a syringe from his desk drawer. I watch in confusion as he taps the contents a few times with his index finger, presses the plunger until a tiny spray of fluid shoots out of the needle, and then he walks up behind Jane and stabs her in the neck.
Richard and Gail are already headed towards Jane's unconscious body. "What the hell—"
"Seer Helga told me to practice swordsmanship." Ben walks back across the room to one of the many bookshelves and lifts a long box hidden behind some framed displays of butterflies. "Me. Not Jane. Why do you think that is? For all her braggart bravado, if Jane goes out there, I don't think she'd be coming back."
"You didn't have to poison the girl."
"What would you suggest I have done, Gail?" Ben stares at the both of them with increasing agitation. "You think she would have sat idly by and taken no for an answer? At least now we know she's in no danger of being disemboweled. Jane won't wake up until long after this is all over."
Richard and Ben exchange a confusing glance before Richard asks, "Are you sure you know what you're doing?"
Ben lifts a sword out of the box he took from the bookshelf. "I sincerely hope so."
"You're not serious." Alex gets up from her seat on the couch next to me. "Dad, you're not seriously going to do this. He's gonna kill you."
Ben shoots her a look and heads for the door. "Thank you, Alex."
Alex turns and looks at me for help, but I have no idea what to do. I've never even held a sword before, let alone fought with one. When she realizes I have nothing to say, she chases after Ben out into the courtyard.
Aiko saw something bad happen to Alex. That's why Ben told her to leave. And now here she is, running outside to try and stop a fight between her dad and a homicidal maniac. Is this the moment where something bad happens to her? Am I just going to sit here and let it happen?
Damnit. Damnit. Damnit.
I stand to follow Alex out the door and Gail yells, "Cora?" She's kneeling beside Jane's body on the floor where she's cushioned her head with a couch pillow. "Cora, you need to stay inside. You have to stay inside! Stop!"
I step down the stairs and onto the grass, headed in the direction of a rapidly forming circle. "Excuse me? Excuse me, I need through." When nobody moves out of my way, I push people until I've made it into the middle of the circle.
"Go back inside, Alex," Ben snaps forcefully, but neither of them are my focus.
"No, no, no," I tell Erik as I walk across the grass towards him. "No, we're not doing this."
"Of course we are," he answers cheerfully. "It's the most fair solution I can think of. If I kill him, our people will inherit a considerable amount of new villagers, and we can cut this Jacob worship in the bud once and for all. If Ben somehow manages to kill me, he gets his peace treaty and I die in glorious combat."
That's the dumbest thing I've ever heard. "You have to listen to me. I'm your Goddess."
"I listen to the Goddess who led my father and grandfather into battle." He's no longer bothering with polite smiles or tone. "Talks of peace are an insult to their memory as much as it is an insult to yours."
I can do this. I can be angry. My eyes dart at the people standing nearest, but I don't recognize anyone. "I said no."
Erik takes a step closer, towering over me and reeking of campfire smoke and sweat. "And what," he mocks lowly, "are you going to do about it?"
I wait for my throat to close. I wait for all the hairs on my arms to stand on end. I wait for the overwhelming feeling of power to surge through my veins like it did last night.
I don't feel anything.
"Cora?" Gail muscles her way through the crowd. "You need to come back inside, right now."
"I couldn't agree more. Get her out of here," Erik orders. "All three of them."
"How dare you speak to me like that," Gail snarls. "I changed your diapers, young man."
Someone clamps their hand on my arm and suddenly I'm being pulled away from the circle. "Get your hands off me," I scream, but it's no use. They pull me to the recreational room, break the lock with an axe, and shove me inside. I turn around just in time to see them shove Alex and Gail inside behind me before they pull the doors shut.
I rush over to yank the door open, but it won't budge. They must have slid a long-handled weapon in-between the handles to jam it when pushed or pulled. "Open these doors!"
"Well, howdy, ladies." Sawyer sits reclined on a deck chair in the corner of the room. "What are you three in for? Let me guess. . . tax evasion?"
Alex begins to pace erratically. "They can't do this!"
"Help yourself to some lemonade," Sawyer continues, "but stay away from the cereal. That's all mine."
I ignore him and pick up the nearest thing I see—which happens to be a metal chair—and fling it at the window. "Alex, grab something and help me break this open."
"You're wasting your time, Buttercup," Sawyer scoffs. "You think I haven't already tried to escape this room? Every window is bolted shut."
I slam the chair against the window again and again until I'm out of breath, but Sawyer's right. All I've managed to do is pull a muscle in my arm. The metal bars blocking the window aren’t even dented.
I abandon the chair and look through the window. For some reason, the circle of people are sparse on this side facing the rec room, so I can actually see what's going on. Erik did this to spite me. He probably told people to move so I could have full view of the fight I forbade.
Alex squeezes in next to me. "What's going on? Have they started?"
"Started what?" Sawyer walks over to a window and peeks through the bars. "Are they fighting each other with swords? What, you people didn't have any bullets to reload the gun you stole from me?"
Each of the two have been given what looks like a wooden shield alongside their respective swords. They circle each other for a long while.
"Come on," Sawyer complains and munches on a handful of Dharma cereal. "Kill each other already."
Alex frowns at him. "That's my dad."
"Congratulations, sweetheart," he says snidely. "You're about to become an orphan."
Erik strikes first, and his blow lands hard against Ben's shield. Again and again, the sword swings down and cracks against wood until I start to worry it's about to break. In the span of a single miscalculated second, Ben's shield finds an opening and smashes against Erik's face.
"That's gotta hurt," Sawyer mumbles and absentmindedly pops more cereal in his mouth like popcorn. "So are either of you gonna tell me what the hell is going on here?"
Erik only becomes more angry as time goes on. It's apparent he was expecting this all to be over by now, and honestly so did I. But between Ben's much better timing and a steady series of solid parries, the fight is more evenly matched than Erik anticipated. A shield smashes into one of their faces, then the other, then a sword is dodged at the last second, and they spin around the circle again and again until both their faces are bloodied.
I try my luck at the doors again, but no matter how hard I pull or push or bang my fists against the metal, they remain locked. "This is so stupid!"
Alex gasps and turns away from the window.
"What?" I hurry back to where Sawyer is making low "Oooooo" sounds. Neither of them have shields anymore, and it looks like Erik's new strategy is to just swing hard and fast. I can hear the metallic clanking from here.
"Wait, wait, Alex look." Ben swings upwards and catches Erik off guard long enough to follow through with a kick straight to his gut. "I think he's winning." I smile at her to try and placate what looks very much like a panic attack. She starts nodding but doesn't come back to the window.
There's a part of me that dreads the final blow. It makes me nauseous to think I might see one of them fatally stabbed or beheaded at any second. But at the same time, I cannot seem to look away when Ben disarms Erik.
"He won," I yell. "Ha! Alex, come look. I'm not kidding. Look, it's over! Ben won!" I feel her trembling hands on my arm and put my own sweaty fingers over hers.
"He's still alive?"
"Yes," I say. "Look! He won!"
"No," Gail clarifies, "Erik. He's still alive. He's not supposed to be alive."
“What are they saying?” I ask. Ben’s the only one left with a sword, but he doesn't stab him. “I can't hear what they're saying."
"Foolish boy," Gail whispers. "What are you doing? End this."
Ben holds out a hand and helps Erik up. They each clasp the other's forearms in a gesture I've come to recognize as a norsemen handshake.
Sawyer sighs dramatically. "Would somebody tell me what the hell is going on?"
With his free hand, Erik removes a knife from his belt and sinks it into Ben's side.
It's suddenly freezing as I blink at the commotion in a shocked confusion. Alex panics all over again, spinning away from the window as Erik knocks Ben down onto his back and picks up his sword. Ben barely has a chance to grab hold of Erik's disarmed sword in the grass before the two are fighting again.
"That's cheating," I breathe in disbelief. "He can't do that, that's cheating."
Erik raises his sword over his head, rearing back to strike again. I watch him swing down hard, and although metal meets metal, the impact reverberates throughout Ben's body. It's evident he can't take anymore.
I turn to Alex, and she looks so much like my sisters. I never wanted them to see our parents fighting. I tried so hard to shield them from the truly terrible parts of our family. I watch her sobs grow more unsteady, but I cannot hear her crying anymore. All I hear is a steady ringing in my ears.
Although my vision never changes, my eyes sting as if I haven't blinked for a solid hour. Every inhale burns, filling me with something heavier than air. Breathing ignites a fire in my lungs that seeps out to every pore, every hair follicle, until I feel like my body is made of solid stone.
People part for me like the running of the bulls, but Erik is so focused on delivering the final fatal blow, he isn't aware I'm suddenly feet from him until it is too late. His expression fills with surprise and he takes a step back, but he has started something that I intend to finish. I've never hit someone before, so when I punch him in the stomach, I'm unsure how much force to use and accidentally hit him so hard he falls over, gasping.
Words I've always wanted to say to my father pour out of me in a violent string of threats and swears that echo through the courtyard like screams in a cave. I'm aware of his fingers desperately clawing at my hands, I watch his mouth open and close as he chokes and turns a dark shade of red, he even kicks and swats at me violently, but I don't feel it, and I don't let go.
I strangle him—both hands around his neck—until I'm satisfied he's going to start listening to me. And then I grab him by the collar and the back of his pants, lift him up off the ground, and launch him.
I only meant to toss him, but my body is still humming with energy and I have no reference for this strength. Erik flies wildly across the courtyard, his legs clipping the side of a nearby house, sending him spinning through the air, stopping only when his body slams into the ground and eventually rolls to a stop. He doesn't immediately move.
All the hairs on my body are still buzzing when I turn around and walk over to Ben. His face is a crosshatch of bloody cuts and already swelling bruises. Alex presses a worried hand against the blood seeping through the side of his shirt, and she slowly flattens against him, eyes wide in terror as I approach. Ben rolls his eyes up at me, sighs deeply at the realization of what's happened, and relaxes completely against the ground.
I crouch down to pick up his sword and start back across the stretch of pavement to pick up Erik's sword. One in each hand, I walk up to where he lies sprawled out in the grass, trying his hardest to crawl away with one unbroken arm. By the look on his face, Erik must think I mean to kill him. I toss his sword at his side with a dull thunk.
"Pick it up," I order, but he only stares at me. I lift the sword in my hand and press its blade against his neck. "You want a personal escort to the afterlife?"
Yelling has made me dizzy with euphoria, but the fact that he's just gaping at me makes each word I say louder and louder until it feels like my voice is physically pressing him against the grass.
"You want to laugh at me behind my back? You want to lock me in a room and start a war so badly? You want to cheat your way to victory? Well, guess what? You don't get to be a coward." He's rolled over in an attempt to crawl away, so I use my foot to push him onto his back, so he has to look at me. "I hate cowards. So pick it up. Fight me." Erik darts his eyes to the glimmering metal tightly gripped in my hand, and his refusal to answer only makes me angrier. "Pick it up, you pathetic little prick," I scream into the silence.
From out of the fog, I hear Gail say, "Put him down. Cora, honey, it's over. Stop. Stop. Drop him. Cora, put him down."
All at once I snap back to reality.
Erik's pleading face is between my hands. I let him go, and he lands at my feet with a painful moan. I blink down at Erik and look over at Gail's hand on my arm and try to keep my expression from giving away my confusion.
"Forgive me," Erik begs, still looking frightened and confused. A long patch of bloody skin along his cheek has been scratched off from his impact with the sidewalk. "Forgive me, Freyja. Please." One of his arms must be broken because he struggles to position himself so he is practically flat against the earth at my feet.
I think I broke his arm. Is that. . . bone?!
"Please," Erik rasps. "I'm sorry. I'm so sorry."
Even though the breeze is cool, I feel myself sweating like I've just run a marathon. Whatever energy surge I conjured up is rapidly depleting. That's definitely bone sticking out of his arm.
"Please. I will never defy you again."
I would have thought this moment would be satisfying, but I just feel a complicated mixture of horror and resignation. I can't take back what I did, so I might as well make the best of it. "No," I agree, "you won't, because you're no longer jarl." He looks up, immediately changes his mind, and averts his eyes. "You will be able to vote on your replacement, and you may speak your mind at the Thing, but nothing more."
I definitely broke both of his legs, judging from the angle they're twisted. Now that I'm not as angry, I can hear the pain in his voice. "Yes, Freyja."
I'm all turned around and not really sure where to go. All I know for certain is my vision is tunneling, and if I don't get out of the public eye fast, all this exertion will be for naught.
"Holmgang's over," I announce with as much strength as I can muster. "Go home, everyone." It's only when I look up to glare at the onlookers and scare them into listening to me that I realize there isn't anyone here.
Richard carried Jane back to her house and put her on the sofa to sleep out the rest of her tranquilization. I sit at Jane's kitchen table because she's not awake yet, and I didn't know where else to go. Gail won't stop fussing with my hair. Ben sits silently across the table. I have no idea where Alex is. Judging by the way she was looking at me earlier, I wouldn't be surprised if she's too scared to talk to me ever again.
Gail keeps busy by unbraiding my hair and running a brush through it. Apparently, the silence is too much for her to handle. "Looks like it's almost time for a haircut."
I reach up and realize my hair doesn't fall right below my shoulders like it did when I first crashed here. In only a few days, it's grown down my back almost past my hips. I'm too tired to ask why.
Gail rests a hand on the top of my head, but instead of feeling angry or itchy, I find the contact comforting. "Would you two like some tea?" she asks. "I'm sure Jane won't mind if we make one pot." Without waiting for us to answer, she disappears into the kitchen and riffles through the cupboards.
Ben washed the blood off his cut face, but the remaining skin is already darkening with bruises. He taps a thumb against the table. "I suppose it's the understatement of the century to say thank you?"
All the confusing rush of emotions from earlier get lodged in my chest again, and I end up sounding more angry than I intend. "For what? Accidentally breaking Erik's entire body? Yeah, don't mention it." Don't be a bitch. This isn't even his fault. I feel bad even before the words have finished leaving my mouth.
"I didn't come here to patronize. I truly mean it. Thank you." Ben's expression softens for a second, like his eyebrows are relaxing for the first time in years. "I had nowhere else to take Alex."
"I should heal him," I think aloud. "Erik. I should at least try."
Ben tilts his head a little. "Why would you do that?"
Again, I cannot stop myself from lashing out. "I broke both his legs and one of his arms. He could have internal damage. His femur was sticking out of—"
Gail is suddenly soothing a hand up and down my arm, smiling tersely, and I realize I've stood up so forcefully, I've knocked my chair over. Embarrassed, I sit back down and cover my face with a hand.
I've never hurt someone before. I've never caused physical injury to another person. That was the way my father operated, and it has been my life's goal to be absolutely nothing like that monster.
"He's not going to die, if that's what you're worried about." Ben accepts a steaming teacup from Gail and adds a single sugar cube. "Ethan's resetting the bones as we speak. Erik should be good as new in a few months. And—one can only hope—much more open to following your orders."
I accept a teacup from Gail, but I honestly just want to attack the refrigerator with a reckless abandon. I don't even care what it is I eat anymore. Food is food is food, and I'm starving.
But I don't get up and pillage the fridge. I don't reach for casseroles and puddings and quiches and scrape them out of their containers with my bare hands. I would rather starve to death than gorge in front of Ben and Gail and make a complete fool out of myself. Instead, I sit at the table and try not to sulk. "Why didn't you kill him?" I ask. "That's how holmgangs work, right? I was watching you fight. You disarmed him. You could have killed him."
Ben fixes me with a completely blank, yet somehow intense expression. "Would you prefer I had killed him?"
That's not what I mean, and he knows it. I can tell.
"He conceded." Ben takes a sip. "Before he literally and metaphorically stabbed me in the back."
I forgot he was stabbed. My eyes trail from his battered face to a small patch of blood seeping through the backside of his shirt. "Let me heal that."
His eyebrows come together so fast you'd think I'd been the one to stab him. "No, thank you."
There's something condescending about his tone that pisses me off. I feel the need to defend myself. "I just went berserk and didn't even feel nauseous afterwards. I think I'm getting used to it."
"Thank you," he says without a detectable trace of sarcasm. "But I've already gotten eight stitches. No need to worry about me."
I don't know what to say, so I busy myself with stirring my cup. "It really would have come down to war?"
"Slaughter, more like," Ben answers solemnly. "There are more of your people than there are of mine. Honestly, they could have killed us all and taken this compound long ago."
"Why didn't they?" I quickly backpedal when he gives me a look. "Sorry, that came out wrong. I'm glad they didn't. I'm just curious as to why."
"That," he says, "I have never figured out."
Gail has finished with the tea, but I have no idea what she's still doing in the kitchen. "Did you know this would happen?" I ask Ben. "The holmgang?"
He shakes his head no. "The unfortunate thing about consulting with seers is they are often so vague their advice is rarely as helpful as it should be. Aiko wasn't even the one who helped me prepare for this."
"She wasn't?"
"No, credit for that goes to the previous seer. Even then, all she would tell me is to familiarize myself with swordsmanship."
"But you knew you would be okay?"
"No," he says, and the way he says it makes me believe him. "I was very much aware of the risk involved."
"You fought Erik without knowing you would win?" Now I feel even worse. "What would have happened if I hadn't been able to break through the doors?"
Ben glances out the window. "My head would be rolling around out there on the sidewalk." He looks back at me and smiles. "So thank you for stopping him. I'm rather attached to my head."
I aggressively stir my tea some more as I try to think of something to say. Hooray? We did it? Congrats on not being dead? "How does it feel?"
"I'm afraid you'll need to be more specific."
I wave my spoon around and try to ignore my aching stomach. "Finally achieving world peace."
"Ah," Ben says with a raise of his eyebrows, "but we haven't. Technically."
"What do you mean?"
"If there's one thing I know about people like Erik, it's that for every one of him, there are six very quiet Eriks. If we don't set an example in a way they respect, we're going to have to deal with this all over again in a year or two or three or ten. I don't know about you," he says and takes another sip, "but I'd prefer to never go through that again."
"Are you seriously suggesting we still get married?" I push my teacup away without having taken a single sip. "What's the point? Everyone's going to listen to me now."
"A treaty to your people is just a piece of paper." I don't know when Gail came back, but she offers me a plate of cookies she found in the pantry and takes a seat beside me. "A marriage is something completely different. Just look at the Initiative. They had multiple treaties with the norsemen, and none of them lasted very long. If you want this goodwill to last, I'm afraid Benjamin's correct."
I don't know if it's because I'm starving or not, but the idea doesn't bother me like it did yesterday. I just want people to stop threatening each other so I can sit on a beach all day and contemplate how everything I previously believed about the universe is a lie.
I sigh, give into the voice in my head, and shove a cookie in my mouth.
Ben finishes his tea, but Gail doesn't offer to pour him any more. I catch them having a non-verbal conversation—mostly consisting of Gail glaring at him—and my stomach begins to sour.
"What?" I ask, exhausted. "What's going on? What could it possibly be this time?"
"Oh, nothing too egregious." Ben smiles, but it's the same forced one from a few days ago, when he would spend the entire conversation evading my questions. "I just need to apologize up front for a. . . small piece of misinformation Jane gave you about the wedding ceremony."
Chapter 10: Questionable Doctor-Patient Relationships
Chapter Text
Dharma, 1975
I wait until the patrol makes their hourly rounds, and then I run towards the fence. It’s a ways away from the houses, and I have to hide a few times to keep from being seen, but I eventually break free of the trees and run across the route I know doesn’t have cameras.
It’s so dark tonight, I almost don’t see her.
Miss Collins is standing near one of the pylons, crouching down to type in the key code. After she’s shut off the fence, she walks through the pylons and disappears into the jungle.
What is she doing out here?
The key code I’d stolen from security crumples in my hand, no longer needed. I stay hidden behind some brush for a while, and then I follow her as quietly as I can. I have no idea where I am. For a long time I worry I’ve completely lost her in the darkness, and then I see her among the trees and breathe a small sigh of relief.
I trail behind her for what seems like forever. Then, in the blink of an eye, she steps behind a tree and completely disappears. I hurry towards where I last saw her, but she’s gone. All there is in the dark are bugs and birds.
“If you’re going to follow someone, you should at least have a general idea of where they’re going.”
I spin around and trip over my own feet in a mad dash to protect myself from the voice behind me.
“I’d ask what you’re doing out here,” Miss Collins whispers, “but I’ve honestly given up trying to lecture you. It’s obvious you have a reckless disregard for your own safety.” She looks around. “Is Annie with you?”
“No, it’s just me. I need to see Freyja,” I try to explain. “I brought her an offering. I . . . I—” I thought I could make peace with the norsemen if I bring their god an offering I rescued from the recent shipment of exotic animals. If I prove to her some of us are good, then maybe she won’t kill us. I struggle to explain myself to Miss Collins and end up unstrapping my satchel and showing her a family of ferrets. “I stole them from the shipment headed to Hydra.”
“I see,” Miss Collins whispers, nodding slowly. “Well, you’re never going to find the norsemen by wandering around out here alone. Come on. Rules,” she adds sharply and spins around to fix me with a serious expression. “Freyja is more dangerous than many of us could possibly hope to understand, and she’s not in a particularly good mood lately, so you need to be on your best behavior. Do not speak unless spoken to. Under no circumstances are you to interrupt. And do not ever look at her face. Understand?”
I shake my head so hard it feels like it’s going to flop right off my shoulders. We start walking again. “Miss Collins?” I whisper.
“Yes?”
“Why are you out here?”
“I’m a mediary,” she answers. “A go-between. I speak the norsemen’s language, so I think they inherently trust me more than the other hostiles.”
I stop walking. “You’re. . . a hostile?”
“I’m a lot of things.” She turns and smiles but doesn’t stop walking. “Why? Are you going to report me?” Before I can answer, she says,“Quiet, now. We’re almost there.”
Everything smells of campfire smoke and worn leather. A few kids my age stop playing and stare at me as we enter their camp. A family of wolves snarl and wrestle in the dirt. A bearded man sharpens a knife. A woman is singing in a language I don’t understand.
Miss Collins grabs my shoulder, and I snap back to attention. We’re standing in front of large canvas tent.
“You remember the rules?” she asks. “Let me do all the talking.”
Why did I come out here? Why did I think Freyja would be interested in listening to anything I have to say? What if she doesn’t understand my intent? What if she gets angry that I have ferrets in my satchel?
“Ben?” Miss Collins soothes a hand across my shoulder. “I won’t let anything happen to you. Just remember not to look at her.”
I duck under a thick tent flap and step into a smokey space lit only by a few candles. As much as I try to fight it, my eyes go straight to the other side of the tent where Freyja sits on an intricately carved wooden throne. Her hair is a tangle of waves and loose braids all wrapped around a pair of antlers. Even though her eyes aren’t glowing, I still can’t really tell much about her face because it’s entirely painted in lines and dots and patterns.
I shut my eyes tight and hope she didn’t notice me looking. It’s a cool night, but my entire body breaks out in a nervous sweat. Miss Collins whispers for me to kneel.
Freyja speaks first, but I don’t know what she’s saying. I don’t even know who she’s talking to because I’m so focused on looking at the dirt floor. Miss Collins replies and the two go back and forth. I wait for instructions.
“She wants to know why you’re here,” Miss Collins translates.
I freeze, still bowing, still sweating, still staring at the ground. I open my mouth to explain, but my voice gets stuck in my throat. I know why I’m here, but I can’t seem to formulate the words to explain myself. Would she even understand me if I did?
Miss Collins says something, and all the hairs on my arms stand on end as Freyja rises in a sudden whoosh of jewelry and bones and starts walking towards me. I shoot a panicked look at Miss Collins, and she mouths, “It’s okay.”
Her boots are right in front of me, and I don’t know what to do.
“Show her what you brought,” Miss Collins whispers.
The ferrets squeak and squawk when I open the satchel and hold them out for Freyja to take. I feel her grab the bag and lift it out of my hands. I hear the ferrets squeak some more. Then Freyja starts laughing. I almost blackout when she leans down and pats the top of my head.
“She accepts your offering and thanks you for your effort.” Miss Collins waits for Freyja to walk back to her throne—now throughly entertained by the playful ferrets—and then she pulls me up and hastily leads me out of the camp. “You did good, Ben.” I start to smile at the praise until I realize she’s being sarcastic. “I am eternally frustrated you can’t seem to listen to a word I say, but thank you for at least listening to my rules regarding Freyja so you don’t get us both killed.”
“I’m sorry. I just wanted to make sure she knows we’re—” I remember how easily Freyja popped Ryan’s head in the courtyard. “—not all like Ryan.”
“Ben,” she sounds tired. Miss Collins slows down to a complete stop and starts compulsively trying to flatten my cowlick. “Freyja is dangerous, but she has strict rules. Nothing is going to happen to anyone who doesn’t deserve it.”
“She killed Sammie’s dad.” I know she doesn’t know, because nobody knows. He died just a few hours ago, and I only know about it because I just happened to be near the vans when I overheard LaFluer and Phil arguing quietly over whether or not they should tell anyone.
But instead of looking shocked at the news that the father of one of her students was just murdered, Miss Collins sighs. “Then I guess he must have done something unforgivable.”
“But—”
“Ben, everything is under control,” she assures me. “Okay? I promise.”
As Ben finishes explaining, I feel my lips twitching with the beginnings of a nervous chuckle. I shove another cookie in my mouth. “It lasts how long?” It feels like my brain is turning into mush that will run out my ears. Breathy half-laughs shake out of me like an uncontrollable case of hiccups.
“Traditionally four days.”
“And everyone from both islands are attending?”
Ben nods as if this is all no big deal. “It’s incredibly rare,” he adds, “but sometimes my people fall in love with your people and we have to contend with separate wedding parties—one here and one on Hydra, of which none of my people are ever invited. Usually, weddings here are relatively low-key, but this is—as you can imagine—a special circumstance, and your people are sailing in to have a joint celebration.”
“They’re sailing here?” I only chew the next cookie twice before swallowing the dry, jagged chunks and reaching for another. “All of them?”
“And as far as I know, those currently at the Temple on the mainland are making the hike here as well.” Ben takes a cookie from the plate but doesn’t eat it. “This one is especially guaranteed to be a large party. Your people are very fond of feasts—”
“No.”
“Yes,” he refutes with a hint of confusion. “I’m very certain they are fond of—”
“No,” I interrupt and pause to fully let myself get a few good hardy chortles out of my system before taking a steading breath. “I’m done. With all of. . .” I wave my arms around. “This. I’m not marrying you. There’s not going to be a big wedding. If anyone causes you problems, come tell me and I’ll. . . scare them or something.” Ben looks taken aback by my outburst, but Gail doesn’t even flinch. “I want to go back to Hydra, Gail. When can we leave?”
“Cora,” she says calmly, “I think you need to—”
I interrupt her, too. “Am I being kept prisoner here?”
“Of course not.”
“Good. Then I’d like to go back to Hydra. Now.” Without waiting for her answer, I grab the last two cookies and push out of my chair.
Juliet lights up with surprise when I open the door. “Oh, excuse me,” she says.
I take a step back. She’d had one hand raised as if to knock, but I don’t know who is more surprised by the weird timing of things. As if just now remembering who I am, Juliet hastily starts to bend forward.
“Please don’t bow,” I order.
“I’m sorry, Cora. Lady Cora,” she apologizes and quickly rights herself, which only leaves me feeling more uncomfortable. “I’m still not entirely sure how to address you. Is this a good time?”
“A good time for what?” I cross my arms. “I’m about to leave for Hydra.”
“Would you mind if I took a quick blood sample before you go?”
A laugh huffs out of me. “No thanks.”
“It would be over before you know it. I just need one vial.”
Get out of my way! “I don’t need a blood-test,” I explain. “I just had a wellness check a month ago and I’m fine.”
Juliet opens her mouth to respond, realizes what I’ve said, and looks confused. “No, it’s for research. Ethan gave me some of your hair to test, but so far…” Her throat pulses as she swallows nervously. “We haven’t noted any anomalies. You have remarkably unremarkable hair.”
I start laughing again out of frustration, and she smiles, but she misunderstands. I’m not laughing at her stupid remark about my hair, I’m laughing in response to growing impatient that she’s not moving out of my way.
“If we can figure out what makes you. . . special,” Juliet continues, “and we can isolate it, you could advance patient care by hundreds of years. You could save countless lives without making yourself sick all the time.”
I’m in Hell. I’m in a nightmare I’ll never wake out of. This is my life now. Never a moments peace. Never a moment alone. People are going to follow me around from dawn till dusk and ask me for favors until the day I croak for good. We need you to stop a war. We need you to talk to our animals. We need you to marry a random person you just met. We need you to donate parts of your body to science so we can study it. We need. We need. We need.
Nope. I don’t have to do anything I don’t want to anymore. And I definitely don’t want someone jamming a needle in my veins.
I look up at Juliet and smile widely. “Get out of my way, please.”
I don’t get very far before Liv approaches.
“What,” I whine as she and a horde of bodyguards walk towards me. What do you people want now?
Unlike most everyone else I’ve encountered since the holmgang, Liv doesn’t look afraid of me—just apologetic for interrupting my walk. “Apologies, my lady, but these men have been very vocal about requesting an audience. They say it’s vital.”
“You’re the healing god, right?” A survivor I’ve never seen before pulls down the collar of his shirt to show me his skin. “Hey,” he exclaims when one of the men guarding me presses a knife to his chest. “Easy there, fella. I’m just showing her my injury. Look, I’ve had this really bad rash since the crash and I’m worried it might be something serious. Can you heal this? It’s not infected, right?”
“Why do you get to see her first?” Another unknown survivor yells, “You’ve got a rash. My hand is practically split open! I deserve to see her first!”
Another chimes in, “Get in line. My leg’s been infected for like two days, man. I need to see her now!”
The only person I recognize is Jin, but I cannot understand a word he’s saying. Is he asking for Sun back? Have they not brought back the female survivors yet?
Someone sprained their ankle. Someone thinks they’ve sprained their ankle. Someone has a gash down the side of their face. Someone lost a fingernail. Someone has a bad case of acne. Someone has a cut here and there and everywhere—
I take a seat in the grass and chomp big bites of the last two cookies. I should have looked for the full bag in the cupboards. I should have pillaged the fridge. This is only making me more hungry.
A familiar calm flows through me, like I’m floating on a lake. All the yelling and bickering and passionate ranking of injuries fades away and is replaced with You Should Be Dancing but the Bee Gees.
“Cora? Can you tell me where you are?”
I blink. I’m sitting on a couch across from a woman sitting in a chair. All the noises from before have been cut short. We’re the only two people in here. My cookies are gone. Did I eat them? “What—” I look around the room for some sort of indication that I’ve been here before, but I have no idea whose house I’m in. “Uh. . . where am I?”
“Do you not remember walking through my front door?”
I recognize this woman as Goodwin’s wife, Harper. The more I remember about Goodwin's character, the more the very thought of him starts to agitate me. He had an affair with Juliet and just pretended like his wife didn't exist. Casted her aside the second someone else caught his eye, just like my own father did. I remember my friends would make jokes about Harper and laugh at the mole on her face, but I always pitied her. Personal bias, I guess.
“My name is Harper. I’m the resident therapist.” Harper fixes me with a tense smile, but I can see the pen shaking in her trembling hand. “Gail brought you here a few minutes ago.”
I’m trying so very hard not to stare at her mole. “She did? Where is she?”
“I’m right here.”
I look over and wonder how the hell I didn’t see Gail standing right next to the couch I’m sitting on. Thank goodness it's comfortable. Usually the seating in medical facilities are either rock hard or so plush you get swallowed alive by the fluff. This sofa is perfect. Not too soft, not too firm. If I were to own a couch, I would—
“This session will go smoothest if you are honest with me,” Harper says. “Try to relax and don't overthink anything. Just tell me whatever comes to mind. Now, it’s my understanding you just had a small altercation outside.”
She must be referring to Erik, and I want to scream, What the hell about me almost killing a man qualifies as a “small altercation” to you?
Holy shit. What the hell is wrong with me. I almost killed someone. I almost killed Erik.
If Gail hadn’t stopped me. . .
“You’re thinking hard about something over there," says Harper. "Would you like to share?”
I shake my head. “No.”
“What would you like to talk about?” Harper asks, smiling. Only, it's not really a smile. I can tell. My mother had mastered that art.
Immediately, my throat closes up at the memory of my mother. I wish I could see her right now. I just want to go home. “None of this is real,” I whisper.
“What was that?”
“I said none of this is real.”
Harper clicks her pen and begins writing. “What isn’t real?”
“All of this. You. Gail. The island. This is all in my head.”
“I’m not real? Hm.” Harper continues scribbling notes. “I certainly feel real to me. What makes you think this is all in your head?”
“Because I’ve never met you before, but I know who you are.” I can’t seem to stop talking. It feels so good for this not to be a secret anymore. I’m not from here. I don’t know how any of this works, but I know I’m from a place where this is all a fictitious world. The island is literally just Hawaii. “I know all about you and your cheating husband.”
Harper's pen freezes midsentence. I watch her eyelids flutter before she looks up, but she doesn’t interrupt me.
“I know Goodwin’s cheating on you with Juliet. And I know why Juliet was brought here and. . . actually, I know most everything about everyone on this island. I even know how this is all going to end.”
Instead of looking awestruck at my revelation, Harper simply nods. “Yes, I assume that’s the biggest perk of being a Goddess of foresight.”
I catch myself before saying I’m not a Goddess because I don’t want to have to deal with a million more questions or some kind of prescription for an anti-psychotic. Instead, I stay silent.
Harper flips through the papers on her clipboard. “How are you acclimating to being back on Midgard? I’m sure it’s been a difficult adjustment for you.”
I snort.
“Is there any part of this experience that is particularly frustrating?”
I snort again.
“I’m afraid we’re not going to make any progress unless you use your words.”
“You’re asking me if I’m frustrated?” I lean forward and feel Gail’s hand on my shoulder, but I shrug her off. Not even she can help calm me down. “Frustrated about what, Harper? Not knowing where I am? Not knowing where my family is? Being targeted by assassins? Being threatened with an arranged marriage? Never fully being alone? Not having showered in days? Look at my dress, Harper! I’M COMPLETELY COVERED IN MUD!”
Harper struggles to keep a blank expression, but her wavering voice gives away her fear. “All very valid points.”
“And now I have Juliet on my back? Asking for blood samples?! Like I’m some kind of science experiment? Telling me all this as if I don’t have the option to say get away from me? And the survivors—”
I’m standing. When did I stand?
I note Harper’s fearful wide-eyed expression as she melts against her seat until she’s practically the chair itself. It’s the same terror I saw in Alex after I threw Erik. But instead of feeding the rush of power from before, her fear drains my rage and makes it easier to calm down. In a single second, my chest tightens with tears.
“I’m sorry, Harper.” I sit back down as my face warms with shame. “I didn’t mean to yell. I’m. . . I’m being asked to accept a lot of things that just don’t make any sense to me and. . . this is all way too. . . overwhelming. I’m very sorry.”
“This is helpful for me to hear,” she practically whispers. I hear her pen click. She clears her throat. “Walk me through what you're experiencing.”
I lean back into the plush sofa and blink back tears. “I just feel. . . I don’t know? Like I can't process emotion anymore. It's like my brain’s malfunctioning or something. I'm in a constant battle not to snap at people. Honestly, I think that’s what’s most frustrating for me. It’s become impossible for me to be. . . I don’t know. . . nice?”
“And this makes you feel even worse,” Harper adds. “Makes you even more frustrated, so you’re more inclined to lash out?”
I nod.
“When did you first notice this had become an issue?”
“Well, I mean, I used to think really sarcastic things all the time in my head. That’s normal, right?”
“Very normal.”
“But the problem is I can't keep thoughts in my head anymore. They just blurt out before I can stop them, and then I end up feeling terrible but I don’t know how to apologize so then I feel even more terrible and I get more frustrated with myself and—” I’m talking way too fast, but Harper doesn’t ask me to slow down. “It feels like when I'm not consumed with anger, I'm fighting not to burst into tears. There’s no real in-between.”
"Don't worry," Harper assures me, scribbling something down. "These are all common symptoms of depression."
I frown. “I’m not depressed."
Harper clears her throat but doesn’t say anything. She just keeps writing until the silence starts driving me crazy. “You mentioned a list earlier,” she continues. “A list of things you find frustrating. Did I hear you mention assassination?”
I take in a deep breath and try to remain calm. “Someone from Hydra tried to poison me.”
Harper shoots Gail a panicked expression. “Were they found?”
“Yes,” Gail answers. “Benjamin is dealing with it.”
I spin around in my seat. “You know who it was?”
“Process of elimination,” she says. I start to ask more questions and Gail reaches out and strokes my cheek with her thumb. “I’ll explain it when you’re done here.”
“You also mentioned your family,” Harper continues, and I jerk back towards her.
“What about my family?”
“Tell me about them. You have any siblings?”
I ignore the question and ask my own. “Are they here?”
Instead of saying no, Harper shoots another look at Gail.
“What?” I surge with panicked hope. “Why are you looking at her? Gail?” I ask desperately. “Is my family on this island?”
“No, dear,” Gail answers softly. “I’m afraid your parents and siblings are not in our world.”
With absolutely no warning at all, the anger inside of me extinguishes completely. Fighting it is useless. Instead of laughing, I look from Gail to Harper as my face rapidly crumples up. Harper hands me a tissue box.
I blow my nose. “I’m sorry.”
“Don’t apologize. You may find this shocking, but you’re not the first person to cry on my couch.”
I laugh and blow my nose again. This whole thing has me exhausted. I wonder how much longer they’re going to keep me here. Is this some kind of test? If I get up and leave right now of my own free will, will Harper make note and tell everyone I’m unstable and need to be committed? I wipe at my face and blow my nose until I’ve calmed down. I need to start acting normal.
Harper sits quietly while I gather myself. She’s nicer than I thought she’d be, but then again, you’d have to be pretty stupid to be openly rude to someone who just did what I did to Erik. “If you’re okay to continue,” she says, “there is one last thing I’d like to talk about today.”
I nod.
“I’d like to find out what your process is for dealing with stress.” She smiles when I look confused. “You’re about to inherit the most powerful position on either island. That comes with no shortage of responsibilities, but I think if we can arm you with the skills needed to handle pressure, you’ll do just fine. Now. . . think about a recent time you were immensely stressed about something. Walk me through your thought process.”
That’s a long list to choose from. I can’t even keep track anymore. I think about the survivors asking for me to heal them. I think about what it felt like to know I could help them but to not know how. I think about being disappointed in myself. I think about how that led to feeling— “I have this. . . thing I do when I’m scared. Really scared. I kinda just. . . it’s not really that I think of something else, it’s more like. . . it’s more like I. . .”
“Space out?” she finishes for me. “Block out the noise around you with other thoughts?”
“Yes,” I say with a rush of relief that someone finally understands. “Exactly. It’s mostly music for me. Whatever randomly pops in my head. Everything else just kind of disappears, and I can calm down. It’s almost like an out of body experience because it doesn’t feel like it’s happening to me.” As I watch her close her notebook and settle into her chair, my relief lessens. “If that makes any sense,” I add self-consciously.
Harper stares at her folded hands and thinks for a moment before finally looking at me. “Cora, what you’re describing is not a universal reaction to stress.”
“It’s not?”
“No, what you’re describing is called disassociation. It’s a trigger response to overwhelming stimuli in which you detach yourself from reality in order to feel calm and in control of the situation. If I’m being completely honest, it's a very dangerous response for someone with your. . . capabilities.”
“Oh.” It feels like I’m being chastised, so I sink a little lower in the couch. “How do I stop it?”
“I suggest you keep a journal. Whenever you start to feel anxious, focus on something tangible in the immediate area and write it down. Sketch it. Focus on it and let it ground you before your mind has a chance to wander off. Here, I’m sure I have an extra somewhere.” Harper hurries into another room and emerges with a simple spiral-bound notebook and a pencil. “How would you describe your mood right now?”
“Calm,” I say.
I know she’s been afraid of me this whole time, but I’m still surprised by the level of relief in her voice. “Good. Very good. Come talk to me whenever you’d like. Just send a raven if you’re on Hydra and I’ll come to you. And remember to use this notebook.”
My parents didn’t believe in therapy—they said it was a waste of money—but I feel a lot better already. It isn’t until we’ve walked all the way back to Jane’s house that I realize there was one thing she never asked me to talk about. One thing I noted in my long laundry list of frustrations.
Harper never asked me about the wedding.
“Sit down, young lady.” Gail raises an eyebrow in warning. “Do I need to put you on lockdown, or are you going to behave?”
Jane presses an icepack to the back of her head. “No,” she scoffs. “Linus isn’t worth the effort it would take to dig a grave. Plus, didn’t he get his ass handed to him?”
“Only because Erik cheated,” I snap.
“Right,” Jane says, drawing out the word. “I just can’t believe I missed it. You actually did it? You figured out how to fully berserkr?”
I don’t know whether to frown or laugh at the delighted expression on her face. “You mean berserk?”
Jane removes the ice pack and stares at me in bewilderment. “How does a Norse God not speak Norse?”
I roll my eyes and finish the quick to-do list I created. I’m trying to note all the loose ends I need to settle on this island before I can finally take a ship back to Hydra to spend the rest of my life sitting under palm trees and playing with Fenrir and Pumba.
- Figure out what’s happening to the survivors and reunite family members
- Heal any life-threatening injuries
- Apologize to Juliet for acting like a psycho (maybe give blood?)
- Visit Erik and see if he’s healing okay
- Check on Peter and Darcy and make sure Peter’s ankle gets fixed
- Order a scout team to scope out any potential wandering survivors
- Talk to Richard—he may know something helpful
- Talk to Jacob—he’s the oldest thing on this island, so he definitely knows something
- Try the mainland’s famous cheese
Gail doesn’t put up a fight when I ask to go on a walk alone. I’m not sure if it’s because the person responsible for trying to kill me has been caught—I need to add that to my list of things to inquire about—or because “always being followed” was a major point of contention I mentioned to Harper. Either way, it instantly puts me in a better mood to walk outside alone and not have sixteen people vying for my attention.
I check my list again. I don’t know where the infirmary is, so I can’t check on Erik. I don’t know where the survivors are being kept. I don’t know which house is Juliet’s or Richard’s. I guess I could ask someone. Unlike when I first arrived, people are actually out and about. And by “out and about” I mean they’re siting immobile on their porches like mannequins, desperately pretending like everything is normal.
One man stands with a garden hose in hand, watering flowers in his yard. He forces what looks like a smile when I approach. “Hello, lady Cora. Nice weather we’re having.”
I smile to try and put him at ease. “Uh, yeah. It’s pretty nice.” Hose water sloshes over the garden bed in shaky streams, and his nose is already sweating. I guess my smile didn’t help. “Sorry to bother you but I—”
“Oh, no,” he quickly refutes, “you’re not bothering me at all. Is there something you need? Would you like an offering? I just made some lunch.”
I’d sigh, but I think that would only scare him more. “I’m just looking for Richard’s house.”
In a rushed attempt to answer me as quickly as possible, he uses the hand he’s holding the hose in to point and completely drenches the front of my dress. Instead of going wide-eyed and flying into an apology, he freezes, mouth agape. He isn’t even able to fully form the beginning of a word. I hear a door slam and turn to find the people at the nearest house have run inside.
I’m embarrassed by how frightened he is, so I start laughing. Oh, wonderful. Now it looks like he’s going to cry. But I can’t stop laughing. “Thank you. I was meaning to change out of this thing. I haven’t showered in like. . . I don’t know, three days?” I meant for the joke to show him I’m not angry, but he looks even more terrified.
No harm done! Please don’t cry! I’m so sorry I smashed a grown man’s body into little pieces this morning!
I can’t think of anything to say, so I just walk away.
I really don’t want to talk to Ben right now—not after my embarrassing mental break—but Ben’s house is the only one I know aside from Jane’s, and I have no desire to ask anymore panicked residents for directions.
I give three impatient knocks and wait for someone to answer. A few seconds later the door swings open to reveal Ben, his circular reading glasses perched precariously on the edge of his swollen nose. One of the deeper gashes on his forehead have been sealed with a neat little row of stitches.
“Hi,” he says, sounding surprised.
I stare at the small wobbly rodent perched on his shoulder. “Is that a ferret?”
“Haha, hey Noodles,” the ferret squeaks. “Come over here. This one speaks ferret!”
“Yooooo, no way.” Noodles scampers across the floor towards me like a piece of rubbery, overcooked pasta. His little claws dig into my dress as he climbs up and settles on my chest. “Say something funny.”
I look down at his little whiskered face. “Something funny.”
Both of them break out into raucous laughter, jump down to the floor, and disappear into the house at record speeds. Something glass breaks. Ben narrows his blackened eyes in annoyance but doesn’t turn around to see what they’ve broken.
“Sorry,” I say. “I’m not interrupting something, am I?”
“Aside from those two breaking everything I own? No,” he refutes and immediately steps aside. “Please, come in. If you’re looking for Fenrir, Darcy took the lot of them to the swing-set. Fenrir and the little boar seem rather fond of him.”
We should be looking for anyone still out there in the jungle. There may be more kids I don’t know about. “What happened to Peter? Did Ethan set his ankle?” I walk past Ben into the living room and take a second to get a good look around. When I was here before the holmgang, snooping out his interior decorating was dead last on my list of priorities. Wall-to-wall bookcases span both the living and dining area, and there are multiple nordic paintings above and in-between shelving. I hear the door close and turn around.
“Yes.” Ben still has a hand on the door-handle. “Ethan saw to him before attending to Erik.”
Good, I can cross that off the list. “Is there a team I can send to look for survivors? I want to make sure there’s no more children wandering around alone.”
“Already ordered.”
The lamp on his desk is on. It shines down and illuminates all the masses of paperwork he has stacked into neat little piles. I point. “What’s all that?”
“I’m reviewing some of the old Initiative treaties to use as a template for the new, more thorough one.”
“Hey, new girl,” one of the ferrets yells. “Hey! Hey! Hey! HEY! HEY! HEY! HEY! HEY! HEY!”
“Yes?” I snap. “What? I’m listening?”
He stands atop a particularly tall stack of papers on Ben’s desk and declares, “Want to see a trick? Hee-YAH!” In a messy flourish, the ferret twirls up into the air, sending the stack of papers flying all over the place.
“Alex,” Ben calls loudly and begins gathering the falling sheets. “Can you please take them out of here for a little while? I’m never going to get any work done.”
“Noodles! Jellybean! Come here!” Alex sulks into the living room from the hallway. Her eyes widen a little when she sees me. “Oh, hi Cora.” I don’t even have a chance to respond before she says, “Did my dad tell you I’m grounded for all eternity because I didn’t run away from home like a coward?”
“Not in front of guests, Alex, please.”
She ignores him and turns completely towards me. “Can I go back to Hydra with you? I’m sixteen now. I can legally go.”
I don’t know what to say. I’m honestly just glad she’s even talking to me.
“Alex,” Ben cuts in. “We can discuss this later.”
“That's not fair,” she complains, stomping her foot like a two year old. “You’re always telling me we’ll talk about it later, but we never do! You never let me do anything! I’m allowed to go, dad! Why won’t you let me go?”
I stand trapped in-between the two of them. I can't help but think of my sisters. If any of us had ever spoken to our father like this, we would have been pushing up daisies.
But Ben only turns away from her, rolling his eyes. “I will treat you like an adult when you start acting like one.”
It looks like Alex has a lot more she wants to say, but she’s so angry all she does is make a loud exacerbated noise and stomp down the hall with a ferret on each shoulder, slamming her bedroom door behind her.
Ben exhales and takes a seat at his desk in the corner of the living room. “This is not exactly riveting reading material, Miss Collins, so I’m happy you’re here. You can help keep me from falling asleep. Oh, I’m sorry. Can I get you something to drink—agh!” He’s stands too quickly, winces, and reaches for his stitches.
I shoot forward towards the desk. “Are you okay?”
Ben removes his hand from his side, and his face settles into annoyance when he realizes it’s dotted with red. “I must have ripped one of the stitches,” he grumbles.
“Let me heal it.” I walk closer to his desk, already reaching for the dark patch of blood at his side. “At least let me check to see if you really did rip one of the—”
Ben jerks away from me so violently, I wouldn’t be surprised if he just ripped all of his stitches. “Do not touch me,” he warns.
“Okay.” I back away. “Sorry.”
Ben silently stares at me long enough that I decide to sit across the room on the couch. Eventually, his expression settles into the recognizable mask of indifference. “Please, Miss Collins,” he says much more calmly. “I’m fine. I’ll get new stitches later.” He exhales slowly through his nose like this is all annoying him. “I haven’t even asked why you’re here. Do you need something?”
“I’m looking to talk to Richard.”
“He’s out again.” Ben lifts a piece of paper to inspect under the lamp. “I can let you know as soon as he comes back.”
“Oh. Okay. Thanks.” Notebook. To-do list. What else was there? I take a peek. “Do you know where I can find Juliet?”
Ben is busy shuffling papers into different piles. “Probably helping Erik in the infirmary.”
“Where’s the infirmary?”
“What do you need to talk to Juliet about?” Ben looks up from the papers. “Have you decided to give blood?”
“I. . .” I don’t know yet. Maybe? I mean, she makes a great point. If they can figure out a way to make some kind of healing shot, I wouldn’t have to throw up every time someone needs medical care.
“Miss Collins—”
“Please stop calling me that.”
“Alright.” All the hairs on the back of my neck stand on end when he says, “What would you like me to call you?”
“Just Cora.”
“Hm,” he muses. “Personally, I’d go with Cora the Just, but it’s a matter of semantics at that point.”
It takes me a second to realize he’s joking. This is weird. I start flipping through my notebook just to have something to do, even though its entirely blank except for the first page.
“At the risk of sounding like a broken record,” Ben finally says when I remain silent, “is there any hope you can reconsider the marriage? I think we may be able to persuade your people to cut down the length of the festivities to just one day. Would that help?”
I stop flipping through my notebook. “What?”
“Apologies if I seem a little zealous at the idea. It’s just the thought of someday having to go through this again, or Alex being forced to endure it, or anyone else for that matter.” Ben stops circling things and throws his pen down. “I just want this done, Cora. Done in the most final and concrete of ways so their children and their children’s children will grow up knowing the severity of breaking this treaty. Breaking this marriage pact would be more than a betrayal of the contents of a piece of paper. It would be a betrayal of familial bonds. And family to your people is almost as sacred to them as you are.”
What would my grandma say about all this? On the one hand, I’d be going against my principles. . . but, actually, I’d be upholding my principles at the same time. Sure, I’d be marrying a stranger, but does that actually matter if we’re never around each other? Does it matter so long as we never get divorced? Am I really losing any personal freedoms if the person I’m marrying thinks I’m a god and is too scared to give me any pushback? Are the generations of lives I’d be saving be worth the pomp and circumstance of this ceremony? I already know the answer.
“Okay,” I answer with finality, and he straightens in his chair. “Fine. I’ll do it.”
“You will?”
“What?” I ask as sarcastically as I can and repeat the words he said to me on the beach. “Don’t you think I haven’t exhausted every alternative option before relying on marriage to you?”
He opens his mouth to respond, thinks better of it, and nods instead.
I stop myself from saying It’s fine because it’s not fine. It hurts.
“I didn’t mean what I said,” he continues, but he’s so disinterested he’s not even looking up at me. I watch him glance from one paper to another and violently underline something. “I hope you can forgive my insensitive outburst, considering the situation we were in.”
I don’t believe his apology, and I’m surprised as a sudden wave of sadness hits. I feel myself start to drift off into the music, and I remember Harper’s advice. I focus intently on the pen in his hand as it scribbles and circles and crosses and swirls. Being trapped in reality only serves to replay his empty words in my head again and again as he continues to ignore me. It’s all so familiar. I’m used to insincere apologies. I’m used to being ignored.
I lock onto his pen again and start sketching it. It’s not a fountain pen, but it’s no ordinary Bic, either. “What did Aiko see about me?”
“What?” He sounds thrown off by the question.
I keep sketching. “Aiko’s vision about me. It scared her. What was it?”
I don’t expect him to actually tell me, so it’s a shock when he answers, “She saw you—” Ben trails off, looking slightly uncomfortable. I watch him tap his thumb against the pen in his hand. When he answers, it comes out in a quiet rush. “She saw you crush Erik’s skull in your bare hands.”
I remember the confusion of snapping back to reality, only to find Erik’s whimpering face smushed against my fingers. I was about to crush his head? I don’t even remember picking him up. I feel sick at the thought of Aiko having to see that. I can’t help but state the obvious. “She’s six.”
“Yes, I imagine her parents are going to put her out of commission for quite a while to recover.”
That poor girl. I wonder if there’s ever going to be a way I can make it up to her. I wonder if she just got added to the list of people who are always going to fear me. “That’s why Gail wanted me to stay inside,” I think aloud.
“Your reluctance to listen is what kept me all in one piece, so thank you for that. At the very least, Erik would have kept me alive to watch me bleed out. On the brightside,” he adds softly, “at least you would have been nearby.”
It’s futile to fight the embarrassed, sweaty flush that rushes across my face. “How is that the brightside?”
“Ease of access.” Ben looks up from the paperwork like my question was a personal insult. “To guide me into the afterlife.”
Oh. Right. That’s what he means. Guiding souls has apparently been added to my list of island duties.
Ben scrutinizes me from behind his desk as I grow sweatier waiting for him to say something else. Without another word, he turns his attention back to the piles of paper and begins circling and underlining things again.
Am I supposed to leave?
Oh, no, I’m still covered in mud!
I shoot up off the couch as if I’d been burned. All at once, I'm struck with a sudden traumatic memory.
I'm 13 years old. My mother has just driven me to my first co-ed party at the house of one of the most popular girls at school. I begged her to just drop me off and pick me up at 10pm, but she only agreed to let me stay if she met the parents first and assessed the situation. After she finally leaves, I head into the living room, where the party is taking place. The lights are down low, giving me goosebumps as I look for a place to sit.
I was punctual, and apparently that's not cool because there are only a few people here, and none of them belong to the popular crowd. I don't see my best friend anywhere, so I take a seat on the sofa and play with my skirt. I don't know why I wore a skirt. I hate skirts. I hate the feeling of vulnerability. I hate that I can't bend over without worrying I'll flash everyone.
I've had a massive stomachache all day, and even though I've been craving nothing but salt and chocolate for the past week, I stay away from the snack table filled with bowls of chips, Heresy's kisses, and a platter of tiny triangle sandwiches. If I start to gorge myself now, I'll never be able to stop, and this whole show of dressing up in uncomfortable clothes and hanging out with people who don't even like me will all be for naught.
That's when my world stops.
Patrick Higgins—the boy I've had a fanatic crush on since the 1st grade—has arrived.
I start aggressively straightening my clothes.
Patrick makes his way around the room giving people high fives and munching on the chips I crave so badly. To my complete shock, he plops down on the seat next to me. "Hey," he says.
"Hi," I manage to squeak out. I can't move. I've been completely paralyzed. I'm sitting as ram- rod straight as my spine will allow, my fingernails digging into my sweaty palms. In fact, my whole body has broken out into a sweat, and I'm forced to yank an arm up to wipe away beads of perspiration gathering on my forehead.
"Karly, right?"
My face is on fire. "Um, actually it's Cora."
Patrick slaps his forehead and says, "Oh, Cora! Right. So, when did you get here?"
I'm in complete bliss that he's even talking to me. "Just now," I say. I want to say more, but my throat has closed up.
He scoots closer and places a hand on my leg. "You look really nice tonight. I like this skirt.”
"Thanks," I breathe. And then my guts explode.
I end up doubled over, gasping. The pain is unbearable. I'm going to die. I stand up and stumble in the direction of the front door. I need to call my mother. I need to call 911.
Somebody screams. I turn around, and the host of the party is pointing at me with a trembling finger. "Ew, ew, ew, ew, ew!" she screeches bloody murder, her face slowly reddening with fury.
One of her friends screams, "She got it on your couch!"
I stand there in the middle of the room, writhing in agony, and utterly confused with what's happening. Then I see the blood.
I'm dying.
Of course, I wasn't actually dying, I just didn't fully understand what a menstrual cycle was. Catholic school and a very Catholic mother probably didn't help.
I snap out of my memory only to notice that Ben has been silently watching my cringing face while I relive one of the worst moments of my life. He squints at me in the lamplight. “Something wrong?”
“Oh. . . uh, no. No. Just. . .” Please don’t let there be mud on the couch. I could cry from relief when I don’t see any. “Do you mind if I look at your books?” As soon as this wedding nightmare is over, I’m never coming back here, so I might as well make the most out of snooping through Benjamin Linus’s house. Maybe I’ll discover something interesting.
Ben gives approval with a sort of shooing motion before returning his attention to the stacks on his desk.
His vast collection seems to be organized by genre, with a fiction section separated from an entire shelf dedicated to Scandinavian languages and culture. A few particularly old looking books and scrolls are housed in a glass case. I start at the top shelf display first and make my way down through a list of titles I’ve never heard of until my eyes zero in on something off to the back.
“Oh my God,” I blurt out. At the sight of it my heart breaks out in sporadic beats. “Is this a first edition?”
“Why? Do you want it?” When I turn to look at him, he’s already halfway across the room. “It’s yours if you’d like it.”
“No?” I’m so confused. Is he afraid of me, too? “No, that’s okay.”
“It’s the least I can do to thank you for your help.” To my absolute horror, he opens the glass case, lifts a worn copy of The Hobbit off its stand, and holds it out in offering. “Please,” he says earnestly, “I insist.”
How did he guess correctly? I didn’t tell him which of the dozens of books I was excited about. “I’m not stealing from your rare book collection.”
“It’s not theft if it’s a gift.”
“I. . . I’m all muddy.” It would be just my luck to have it survive all these years just to decompose within my very hands, not to mention the oils and sweat and whatever else is coating my fingers. “I don’t want to ruin it.”
“Then go wash your hands,” he chides, smiling.
Even after I scrub my hands and arms in the kitchen sink until my skin is raw, my fingers hesitate to make contact.
“Just take it,” he laughs lowly. “It’s not that delicate.”
The edges have some slight wear, and the cover illustrations are a few shades lighter with age, but besides that, it's a perfectly intact copy. “This is a first British printing?”
“It’s the oldest surviving copy, as far as I know.” Ben’s eyes dart from one side of my face to the other. “Why? Does that have some kind of significance?”
“Are you kidding? This has the original conversation between Bilbo Baggins and Gollum. It was completely rewritten after Tolkien starting working in earnest on Lord of the Rings in order to better fit with world-building continuity and he practically ordered the old versions to be stripped from the shelves and he never gave permission to reprint it and now the only way to know what the original says is to buy a rare copy at auction and—” Stop talking. Look at the way he’s staring. You are boring him to death. I stop talking and take a seat on the couch.
This cannot be happening. I run my fingers over the stiff spine, caressing the cover and the sides of the yellowed pages, barely applying any pressure for fear of destroying it. I probably look insane, but I honestly don't care. In my lap I hold what was probably the only good thing to come out of my childhood. "Where did you get this?"
“I stole it from a museum.”
“Really?” I ask in amazement.
“No, I bought it at an auction on a trip to Europe.” Instead of taking a seat across the room at his desk, Ben sits down so close to me I feel his pressed kakis brush up against my thigh through the layers of my dress. The air around him smells faintly of expensive cologne. “It was a hell of a time bidding against some rich entrepreneur from Switzerland.”
“Why bother?” I turn to look at him, and our faces are suddenly very close. I wish I could move. I wish my pounding heartbeat would slow down a little so I could think. I wish Ben would stop staring at me, but I don't know a polite way to tell him to stop. And it's not just that he's staring at me, it's the way his eyes focus so sharply, so intensely that you start to feel indecent. Five minuets ago, Ben was tense with hasty apologies, but now I'm the one bumbling around like an idiot. I look back down at the book. “I didn’t take you for a fantasy fan.”
“Is that so?” Ben’s voice has regained its usual velvety calmness, and I struggle to focus on the content of his words instead of the smoothness of his speech. “What did you take me as?”
I stare holes into the cover illustration and shrug. “Historical nonfiction?”
“Ah,” he draws out. “So you think I’m boring. Good to know. I’ll have to work on that.”
I’m actually very used to people flirting with me. There’s something that seems to transcend age about using the least attractive person in a group as your “in” so you can hit on the hot friends. It happened in middle school. In high school. All throughout undergrad. Hell, it happened just two weeks before I woke up on this island. Pretend to be nice to the fat girl, and her skinny pretty friends will think you’re such a nice guy.
It happens so often, I’m usually entirely impervious to it all. But it’s difficult to dismiss what’s happening right now because I don’t understand Ben’s angle. The war’s over. I even agreed to the stupid wedding ceremony. What else is there?
A huge chunk of anxiety lessens as I realize the answer. Actually, now that I think of it, everything else makes sense as well. It’s the reason why he reacted so violently when I offered to heal his stab wound. He doesn’t want me to waste my powers on something non-life threatening because he needs me to save my energy for his spinal operation. It’s why he looks so intensely upset when I use my powers and get sick. The more often I get sick, the less likely I’ll be to willingly heal him post-surgery.
Wait. The Other’s have a submarine. As long as Locke doesn’t blow it up, we can use it to send the survivors back home! If I can get them out of here as quickly as possible, I can save a lot of people who are going to otherwise die in the coming months.
“What’s the long-term plan for the survivors?” I ask, already feeling the relief of a slowing heart-rate. “Is there a way you can send them home in your submarine?”
“Some of them, yes.” Ben abruptly stands and walks back across the room to his desk. “I’m always very surprised by the bits of information you know versus what you don’t. Did Gail tell you we have a submarine?”
“No.”
He nods slowly, squinting like he doesn’t believe me. “Well, it can’t fit everyone in one go, so the return process may take a few months. Or do you know all about that as well?”
I honestly can’t tell if he’s angry, or if he’s just teasing me. “Not really,” I say.
“We’ll have to think of a means of separating them into smaller groups,” Ben muses and returns his attention back to the papers on his desk. Pen in hand, he begins underlining again. “I’m sure that’s going to be a fun debate, considering they were tripping all over each other just to have you heal a rash.”
“You saw that?”
“Heard it, more like. They were very passionate in their triage disagreements.”
“And what about the people on your list?”
Ben doesn’t look up. “What about them?”
“Are you sending them home, too?”
“Not immediately.”
“Why not?”
Ben taps the pen against the papers and flits his eyes around. “Don’t you know?”
Oh, I see. He’s worried I’ve figured out why he’s being so nice to me. I stand up and turn to gather my notebook. “You don’t have to lie to me, you know.” I hear him laugh from behind the desk. When I turn around, he’s smiling down at the paperwork.
“Lie to you,” he says. “That’s funny. As if Gail wouldn’t rat me out in a heartbeat.”
“You can just ask if you need my help.”
“Yes, I’ll be sure to do that if something comes up.”
As I near his desk, Ben all but turns to stone. His eyes are the only thing that move as they roll up to look at me. “Listen,” I say, “I know you have a spinal tumor that needs immediate removal.” Ben lifts his head up slowly, eyes wide with fear. I watch as his face rapidly drains of color in the lamplight, and I wonder why he seems so shocked I know. “You need to keep Jack on the island because he’s a spinal surgeon. I already know all of that, so you don’t have to be secretive about it anymore. If you want my help post-surgery, you can just ask.”
“I. . .” His pen slips out of his hand, but he doesn’t seem to notice. It’s only after Ben finally gets the answer out that I realize why he looks so scared. “I have a . . . what?”
Chapter 11: Survivor’s Guilt
Chapter Text
“You might feel a little pinch .”
She gave me fair warning, but I still cry out when the needle pierces the tender inside of my arm.
"The worst is over," Juliet says softly as she tapes the needle against my skin to hold it in place. "Thank you for this. Whoops, you alright?"
"Not great with needles." I don't flinch away from Juliet's steady hand on my shoulder because I absolutely need it to keep from falling forward off my chair. I focus on breathing and berating myself for already feeling lightheaded enough to pass out. Keep talking. Stay conscious. "I don't want to give blood anymore after this. Take as much as you need while I'm here."
Ben's off somewhere getting an x-ray and a new set of stitches while I'm left to make small talk with Juliet, which hasn't exactly been invigorating. Neither of us have much to say to each other rather than awkward pleasantries. I haven't learned all that much that differs from who she is in the show: she has a sister named Rachel, she came to the island under false pretenses, and she's been here for three years.
Juliet leans against a countertop in the infirmary. “You have any siblings?"
"I'm the oldest of four," I answer. Her question brings me back from the brink. "Two sisters and a brother." In the show, Juliet was surprisingly ruthless in her attempts to return home. But she hasn't even asked me once if I will let her leave. "So. . . three years, huh?" I inquire nonchalantly, still locked in a battle not to give into the creeping tunnel vision. "That's a long time. You haven't been back to visit your sister since then?"
"I visited home for my nephew's birth, and I visited again for his second birthday." Juliet removes the first filled vial of blood. "You look surprised to hear this."
"And you came back?"
"I sort of. . . owe these people a debt," she finishes cryptically. "I haven't finished my research."
"Research?" An annoyed laugh shakes out of me at the thought. "If someone lied to me about a job offer and was holding me hostage on an island, and then they were dumb enough to let me go home. . ." I shake my head and instantly regret the dizziness that follows. "I wouldn't have come back, that's for sure. Screw the research."
"If I can figure out how to do what I've been sent here to do, it will all be worth it. For more than just your people." Juliet stares at me as we wait for the second vial to fill with blood. Even though her voice is just as soft as usual, I'm surprised by her insulted tone. "Why did you tell Harper I was sleeping with her husband?"
“I’m sorry. I thought she already knew." I thought everyone knew?
"Knew what? Goodwin and I are not together," she says. "We've never been. . . is that a vision you had? That we become a couple?"
Is she lying? But what would be the point in lying? Especially to me? "You aren't having an affair with Goodwin?"
"No," she proclaims more passionately than I would have expected.
"Oh." What are the chances that I could be wrong? I've been wrong before. Who's to say a string of coincidences led to them not having an affair? "Oh, wow. I am so sorry, Juliet. I must have gotten bad intel. I can talk to her if you need me to."
"I think the damage has already been done. Don't worry about it," she adds kindly at my panicked expression. "I think she's hated me since the moment I shipped in on the sub. Harper had some. . . strong opinions when she confronted me earlier about what you said. I could tell she'd been saving them for a while."
"Sorry." I look away as she removes the second filled vial and exchanges it for an empty one. I wonder how many she's going to take. Please don't pass out. Now that she claims not to be in a relationship with Goodwin, I cannot help but be nosy. "So does that mean you're single?"
"You must be very bored if you're asking about my love life. The only long-term relationship I've ever had was with my ex-husband."
I snort. "Yeah, he seemed like a real winner. I won't say I'm sorry he was hit by a bus, but I will say I'm sorry you had to see it." From the way she's staring, I begin to worry I got that detail wrong as well.
"It's one thing for people to prepare me for a seer, but another thing entirely to experience one firsthand." Juliet looks me up and down with a flick of her eyes and that annoying smirk that I hate. "May I be honest?"
"Sure."
"You're not at all what I was expecting."
"Yeah," I sigh. "I've been getting that a lot."
Juliet's small tense smile grows more relaxed. "I meant it as a compliment."
Juliet's fine, I guess. Very soft-spoken. Very polite. In the grand scheme of things, I have little patience for cheaters, so Juliet was always pretty low on my list of favorite characters. But apparently she hasn't cheated? I honestly don't know how to feel with all this conflicting information. She seems sadder than I expected. Much sadder. It must be because of the women she couldn't save—the ones who died in childbirth.
Wait.
"Why are you even here?" I ask suddenly, startling us both. "Sorry, I just mean you're a fertility doctor, right? I saw about a dozen newborn babies on Hydra. Not sure fertility is an issue."
I catch the hint of a pathetically fake smile, but it's not the arrogant smirk I'm used to receiving. This one is full of legitimate pain. "For some," she finally says.
"What do you mean?"
"I haven't been able to figure it out yet." I see a whole mess of answers and emotions in her wandering eyes. "At first we thought it had to do with the mainland, so we sent pregnant women to Hydra. When that didn't work, I thought maybe it was linked to your people specifically, but there are a few women who have given birth without being genetically linked to your people. I've taken blood samples, tested the water, studied their diet. There's no comprehensive answer to what is happening or even who it's going to happen to. Some women just. . ." She goes still, and I regret asking.
"I'm sorry," I whisper when she makes no attempts to talk again.
"I wouldn't consider myself a religious person," she says randomly. "So when Richard approached me about working here, I didn't see it as. . . what your people call fate. Richard told me these labs were located near Portland." I watch as Juliet removes the last of the blood-filled vials, begins pealing off the tape, and pulls out the needle from my arm. "I was supposed to be working on a challenge that would shoot me up the ranks into research stardom. Then I got here, and suddenly their story changed. Talked about a fertility goddess who could heal the wounded. Who could ensure pregnant women didn't die in childbirth." She pauses and wipes my incision with a cotton-swab. "But this special being was dead. And now they needed an alternative to stop whatever is killing their women."
She pauses and locks eyes with me, and I feel compelled, yet again, to defend my recent behavior. "This whole thing," I admit much more calmly than I did to Harper, "has been very confusing for me."
"Don't take this the wrong way, but I'm currently talking to their fairytale," she says softly, pressing a bandaid against the crook of my arm. "So I'd say I'm just about as confused as you are."
I stare at the group and try to keep calm under the myriad of expressions they throw my way. The survivors are being kept in a variety of places, so I start with the closest area first. In this group, Hugo, Artz, Jack, the guy with the rash, and two other men I've never met stare up at me from their seat in the grass. The norsemen tasked with guarding them are quick to bow when they see me approaching.
"I'd like to talk to them, please," I tell the nearest guard. "Your name is?"
"Christopher, my lady." He stares at me a little too long before inclining his head of long black hair. "Talk to them all you'd like."
I'm in the middle of trying to figure out what exactly to say when Hugo exclaims, "Dude, that was terrifying. So, are you like, an X-Men or something?"
"No, you idiot," Artz chimes in. "Haven't you been paying attention? Our prison guards are Nordic. She's a Norse Goddess. Do any of you know anything about the Vanir? The Vanir are—"
"What have you done with Kate?" Jack demands angrily.
Jack is glaring at me with a particularly amusing Jackface. I try not to be biased, but I honestly thought the least interesting aspect of Lost was the perpetual "will they won't they" between Jack, Kate, and Sawyer. At the end of the day, it felt tedious and was included in the show only because people seem to be obsessed with stupid love triangles.
Ugh, spare me the pointless drama. I turn to Christopher. "The woman who helped kill the boar. Do you know where she's being kept?"
"Apologies, my lady. I don't know where she's being held until the trial."
"Trial?"
"For the two dead boar," he explains. "Normally, our people would have beheaded all three of them for killing a sacred boar, let alone two. But the murders technically occurred under Jacob's jurisdiction. You'll have to take up the legalities with Ben."
Jack's head seems to be spinning as he slowly pieces together what's happening. "Trial? She's on trial for killing a pig? It's a pig."
Hugo not so subtly tries to shush him, whispering, "Dude, Cora talks to animals."
"I don't care what she does," Jack rants. "I want to see that Kate's okay, and I want to see her now—"
Christopher backhands him so hard Jack's head flops back. "Watch your tone in our lady's presence."
"Hey," I yell. "Take it easy! Jeez." Jack pulls a hand away from bloodied lips, and I frown up at Christopher. "Did you have to do that? He just wants to know she's not hurt. Jack, I won't let anything happen to Kate."
"What's going to happen to us?" the man with the rash interrupts. "Please, don't kill me. I've got kids back home!"
"Nobody is going to kill you," I assure him. "In fact, I'm in the middle of negotiating your ticket off this island."
"You're gonna get us off the island?" Hugo interrupts. "How?"
The conversation devolves into madness, and I stop talking. What have you done with the women from the crash? If you can leave the island, why are you here? Where is this island located? When can we leave? How can we leave? Are these actual Vikings? Where did they come from? What are the extent of your powers? What the hell is going on?
To keep myself from spiraling into a daze, I open my notebook and start crossing off the things I've completed. I add Inquire about who poisoned me to the list just as Christopher yells something in Old Norse. I turn to look at who he's talking to and see Ben stop mid step, turn curiously towards us, and walk over. Continuing the conversation in Norse, Christopher gestures every once in a while to the survivors and then nods at me.
"For future reference," says Ben, "I believe she's requesting to be called Just Cora now. Excuse us a moment, please." Ben nods at Christopher and the other guards as he pulls me a few steps away from the group. "You need to ask me something?"
"Can I ask a favor?"
"I don't know," he retorts. "Can you?"
"I'd like for you to call off the trial. For the people who killed the boars."
"No," Ben says with a small shake of his head. "I don't think I should."
"I think you should."
"A thoroughly convincing argument. How will I ever rebut it?"
This day has been completely exhausting and is putting me in a bad mood. "I just think it's unfair to expect people to know laws that don't exist out in the real world."
"You know what laws do exist out in the real world? Murder charges." Ben's eyes narrow into displeased little slits. "Why does it look like you disagree?"
"It's not murder," I say and instantly regret it because now Ben's looking at me like I'm insane. "They're animals. It's different."
"I'm sorry, did I hallucinate all your conversations with Margo?"
At the mention of Margo, I perk up. "What are you doing with Sawyer?"
"Have you been faking your relationship with Fenrir?" Ben continues, completely ignoring my question.
Stop talking over me and stop evading my questions! "Where's Sawyer?" I repeat loudly. "Is he on trial too?"
"Yes," Ben snaps, "of course he's on trial. He killed Margo." I try to argue, but Ben's not listening. "Cora," he says sharply, officially dropping the teasing tone. "Can you talk to animals?"
"Yes."
"You can hold coherent conversations with them?"
He knows all of this. Why is he asking? "Yes."
"Would you say these conversations prove an intelligence worthy of respect?"
I snort a frustrated breath through my nose. "Yes."
"Then why are we even having this conversation?"
"Because they didn't know that!" I point at the group of survivors, who are trying to act like they can't hear me. All except for Hugo, who is staring with wide-eyed curiosity from one of us to the other as we argue. "That's the whole point. I didn't tell any of them I could talk to animals."
Ben studies me, nodding slowly, as if I'm a small confused child he pities for not being able to fully grasp the situation. "You do understand if this had happened even a quarter-mile more inland, your people would be within their legal rights to decapitate all three of the prisoners? No trial needed? At least we will allow the prisoners to speak in court."
"Really? You'll let them speak at their own trial? Wow, thank you for going above and beyond, Ben. I feel so much better about this." Sweat breaks out on my neck at the thought of more executions. "If this had happened more inland, I'd just order my people to release them."
"Is that what you're doing now?" he asks lowly. "Ordering me to release them? With all due respect, you don't plan to live on this island, Cora." I finally see what Ben looks like when he's not trying to befriend me for some alternative purpose, and the dangerous warning in his eyes makes me fall silent. "So, unless you plan on stripping away the rights to our own jurisdiction, this situation is my problem."
I'm not going to let people die because they didn't know not to kill the boar. Especially not Locke, Kate, and Michael. Michael has a kid. What about Walt? No. No more threats to orphan children. I steel myself and look back up at him. "There has to be some other way of handling this."
"Oh, wise goddess, what would you have me do?" Ben's question is tinged with so much bite, I don't think he actually expects an answer. "This may surprise you, but we have rules here. I can't pardon them from our laws simply because they're ignorant."
Ben seems very comfortable mocking me in front of my own guards. I frown up at him, no longer nervous. "Are you a vegetarian?" I barely give him time to nod before saying, "Have you always been a vegetarian? You've never had a burger before? Or a hot dog? A chicken sandwich? Yes, you have. I know you have, because you only became a vegetarian for my sake after your father brought you to this island. Someone had to teach you the rules. All I'm asking for is the same grace that was extended to you."
"Which means?"
"You can have your trial, but I want final say for the verdict."
A small smile quirks up the corner of his lips as his words hiss from behind his teeth. "That undermines our entire court system."
"Am I allowed to do that, Ben?" I can tell I've massively pissed him off, but I still can't help but push my luck. “What exactly am I allowed to do?"
"You," he says dryly and gives a breathy, humorless laugh. "You can do whatever you'd like."
I don't know what else there is to say, so I turn and start walking back to Jane's house on autopilot.
I've rounded the corner of the courtyard, so her porch is in sight, when I feel someone fall in step beside me. I look over without stopping and see Ben side-eying me with a small smirk.
"That went even better than I expected," he says. "Thank you for cooperating."
"Excuse me?"
"Asshole," Jane yells before I can ask Ben to clarify what he means. She's leaning over the porch railing with a bag of ice still pressed to the back of her head.
"Jane," Ben greets.
"Drop the smile, Linus. Your days are numbered."
Ben doesn't seem particularly interested in her threats and turns to address Gail. "It's done," he confirms.
“Good,” says Gail. “All this anxiety is bad for my bones.”
"Wait," I question, already feeling a flare of anger as I realize what's going on. "Are you telling me that whole argument wasn't even real?"
"Do you have this under control, Gail?" Ben waves a hand in my direction, and my entire face scrunches up in a seething scowl at being referred to as this. "There's somewhere I need to be."
"Yes, thank you, Benjamin,” Gail answers. “That will be all for now."
"Ladies." Ben addresses Jane and Gail and then turns to me with a deep nod of his head. "Just Cora."
There are a million questions I want to ask, but instead I just watch him walk away. Then I fix my smoldering fury on Gail.
"Please forgive me for keeping you in the dark," she pleads, "but you're not a very convincing actress, Cora. Trust me, I know. We needed a genuine reaction from you or he was never going to buy it."
Who? Buy who? Who's buying what? "What are you talking about?"
"You've done a very good job of frightening everyone," says Gail. "Which will serve you well with your own people, but I'm afraid fear isn't the solution to gaining the survivors allegiance. Jack is their de facto leader. If you gain his trust and respect with a show of compassion and leniency, you practically run their group."
"Why would I need to run their group? They're going home soon."
"Didn't Benjamin tell you?" she questions curiously. "The submarine can only accommodate eight extra people after accounting for the crew. It's going to be a rather long transition back to the outside world for these people. It's best if you're in their good graces while they're here. Wouldn't want them to get any ideas."
Judging by her white hair and delicate skin, Gail has been on this island for quite a while. More than thirty years, if my math is correct. And the way she always seems to know what's going on is a little suspect. Come to think of it, Ben seems to report to her whenever something is about to happen. I wonder if she's the one running everything. I wonder what she's still not telling me. "You're right about my acting skills." I huff a laugh to try and seem unperturbed. "It was a good plan, I guess. So, thank you."
Gail's eyes wrinkle in the corners when she smiles. "This wasn't my idea, dear."
Freshly showered at long last, I sit in a chair like a good little show-dog as the survivors are carted out one at a time and their "crimes" are listed before an audience comprised solely of Ben's people. Sawyer, Kate, Michael, and Locke each have the same confused argument about not knowing the animals were sacred and promise they will never do it again.
Fenrir and Pumba fidget in my lap as I wait for the four of them to all be addressed and speak their peace before reciting the carefully crafted response Ben discussed with me about an hour ago. In an effort to appease us both, Ben decided the only way to ensure a fair yet balanced outcome was to limit the four of them to a house arrest and a month of manual labor on their respective islands—Kate on Hydra, and Sawyer, Locke, and Michael wherever they keep the men.
It wraps up rather nicely. I nod and smile and accept their thanks as they're escorted out to go serve their time. Guess that means those four aren't going home anytime soon.
It's not like I did much, but it feels good to have this over and done with. I stand up and suddenly the entire room is standing, and the suddenness of it all frightens me. I'm quick to cover my wide-eyed stare with a fake relaxed smile as I hurry across the room. Pumba's little hoofed feet clack against the cement floor in quick succession as he follows behind me.
I'm almost out the door and into the free air when someone grabs my sleeve.
"One moment, please," Ben says. "I need to talk to you."
I yank out of his grip and continue for the door. "Can you not walk and talk at the same time? All I had for breakfast was some kind of oatmeal mush. I'm getting a headache."
"I'm hungry, too," says Pumba.
"I'm not," says Fenrir. "Wimp."
"Don't call me a wimp!"
"You're a huge wimp," Fenrir taunts. "You ran away when your family needed you. I never would have let someone kill my parents."
I whirl around in shock. "What did you just say? Hey. Hey!"
Pumba blindsides the wolf by tackling him hard in the side, pinning him up against a wall. I have to lift Fenrir up by his scruff to keep him from being rolled over and stomped into oblivion by the angry piglet. Pumba screams and turns to me, hoofing at my shin in a useless attempt to reach the yelping pup in my hand.
Fenrir's ears flatten against his furry skull when I say, "Apologize to him right now!"
"I'm sorry," he whines quietly and licks my fingers.
"Don't apologize to me," I say.
Fenrir hangs pathetically limp in my hand, like a sack of potatoes. "I'm sorry your parents died, Pumba. You're not a wimp."
Pumba only responds with a single angry oink.
I put Fenrir down and he flattens completely against the floor. "Why would you say something like that?" I ask angrily. "What is wrong with you?"
"I'm sorry."
"I don't want to have this discussion again, boys. You hear me?" I look up in search of the door and realize the room is silently watching the altercation.
Ben falls in step beside me as we finally walk out into the bright sunshine. "I have more information about the wedding," he announces, and I have a sinking feeling whatever it is he needs to say can't be good. "Despite my attempts to persuade them otherwise, it looks like your people actually want to add a day."
I stop walking and stare up at him in disbelief. I don't know what I was expecting, but it wasn't that. "A five day wedding? This is ridiculous. What do you even do during a five day wedding?"
"You're just as much a fertility goddess as you are a goddess of war. The elders are requesting your presence at both camps."
"Camps?"
"You're to spend one day on Hydra. One day at the mainland Temple. Two days with me. And, of course, the wedding day itself."
Two days with you? I throw a hand up and turn back towards Jane's house. "You know what? Nevermind. I don't want to talk about this until after lunch."
Jane eyes me with contempt as I pull another pot out of her fridge and place it in the oven to reheat. "Yes," she says, "please, help yourself to my food. Make yourself at home. Take a dump on my doormat while you're at it."
"I'm not stealing." I sit at the kitchen table with a plate of pineapple slices and a bowl of what I assume is potato salad. I don't even like potato salad, but my spoon sinks in deep anyway. "These were my offerings."
Jane sits next to me and spoons out a glob of the potato salad. "Ugh. Who made this? They should be exiled."
I shove another bite in my mouth and swallow it whole. "It's not that bad."
"You only say that because you're starving." She leans back in the chair, suddenly seeming amused. "I hear you're throwing a tantrum over the wedding."
"I am not throwing a tantrum." I shovel in more spoonfuls, but I've started to notice Jane was right about the quality. The more I eat, the more apparent it becomes that this person used way too much mayo. "I just don't see why Ben and I need to spend two days on a stupid scavenger hunt. It's a waste of time."
"Aw, come on," she nags, elbowing me in the ribs. "That's supposed to be the most exciting part of the wedding. All the young couples look forward to tromping around the island with their intended. It's a bonding experience."
"I don't want a bonding experience." I leave some in the bowl, throw in some pineapples, and place it on the floor for Pumba, who smacks it up happily. "I want all of this to be over with."
"Well, aren't you fun."
I drop my pen and give her a displeased look. "What do you do around here, anyway?"
"I'm a. . . what would you people call it? Sheriff? What a stupid name."
"You're the island police?"
"Trust me," she says, eyes widening. "I did not apply for this job."
When the oven timer beeps, I try my luck with what looks like curried cauliflower. It smells good, at least. I take a moment to write in my journal after every bite. I cannot keep track of the discrepancies from the actual show, so I'll need to log them. I start with a list of relationships. Jack still likes Kate. Juliet is not seeing Goodwin.
I glance up at Jane. "Are you dating anyone?"
"Aw, gross," she says. "Get the thought out of your head right now because you are definitely not my type."
"Yeah," I reply, frowning, "you're not my type either. I didn't mean me."
"I don't see how it's any of your business."
I scribble Jane = Stick Up Ass and read over my to-do list again. "Do you know who poisoned me? I heard they were arrested."
"It was Dolores."
Dolores? There's a viking named Dolores? Oh man, I wonder if there's a William. Bob the viking. Ha ha ha, that would be hilarious. Wait, focus. "How do you know it was her?"
"She very happily confessed."
I don't even remember meeting a Dolores. Why does she want to kill me? "What's going to happen to her?"
"She's holed up in a jail cell somewhere. Honestly, I'm shocked she hasn't been offed yet."
Offed? As in beheaded? Is that what's going to happen to her? Does she get a trial? "Does anyone know why she did it?"
"She's not talking, but I have a good theory." Jane starts cleaning her nails and ignores me. I clear my throat and she looks up in mock surprise. "What?"
"What's your theory?"
"I mean, it's pretty straight forward," she says and returns her attention back to her fingernails. "It's probably because you killed her parents."
I look up at the trees and wonder why I can't hear any birds. The branches are usually filled with endless chatter from a variety of them, both large and small. But from where I'm sitting in the grass, just outside the perimeter of the barracks housing, I don't hear a single voice.
Not that I'm complaining. It's a blessing to lean up against a tree and be lulled into a peaceful daze by nothing more than the soft rush of leaves caught in a breeze.
Jane's "theory" has left my brain uncomfortably scrambled for the time being. I didn't even ask her for more clarification before walking out here and getting comfortable so I can spend some time alone. I flip my notebook to a new page and start outlining Fenrir's head as he and Pumba run around in the grass.
I fill two entire pages with dozens of sketches of Fenrir and Pumba and the pretty patch of flowers a few yards away before I realize this isn't as therapeutic as it normally is. Filling my lungs up with crisp island air, I heave a sigh and make the walk back to the houses.
I'm halfway there when I pick up the faint shouts of an angry man. I follow the sound of his voice and stumble upon a crowd gathered around the cafeteria. Jin stands partially surrounded by people trying to convince him to give them back the handgun he's waving around with no real target in mind. He's beyond angry as he furiously makes demands in Korean.
How'd he get a gun? Who'd he steal it from? Hasn't anyone tried to explain to him that Sun is okay? How many days has it been since I asked them to bring Sun back? I think about how upset and scared he must be after strange people he can't understand up and stole his wife away from him and now hold him hostage in a strange facility on an unknown island. I add reunite Jin and Sun ASAP to my to-do list.
From somewhere in the crowd I hear Liv shout, "My lady?"
I look up from my notebook to find Jin pointing the handgun steadily at me. Don't panic. You can't die, remember? "For crying out loud, Jin." I know he can't understand what I'm saying, but the tired sarcasm comes out anyway. "What are you gonna do? Shoot me?"
Two bullets discharge his gun with thundering cracks.
Chapter 12: Getting The Band Back Together
Chapter Text
There's a sharp pain in my side as I'm tackled, and then my shoulder slams into the ground. All I register is the smell of grass. The heat of the sun. Someone is yelling. For a moment, I don't even know which way is up. Then, all at once, I remember and bring my hands up to my midsection.
Oh my God. He actually shot me. I've been shot.
I pull my hands away, but there isn't any blood. As I desperately probe my chest and stomach and sides, a nervous laugh bursts out of me. He missed. I'm not shot. Oh, thank God. I'm not shot.
Sloppy, sucking sounds pop and crinkle out of the woman lying next to me. Blood pumps from her chest as she grasps at both her wound and the air with a confused frown.
"Liv?" I push up onto my knees and assess the damage, as if I have any idea what to do.
"What happened?" I hear Jane before I see her. "Why are you all just standing around? Where the hell is Ethan?"
"No, no, no, no. . ." Gail kneels down beside me and brushes Liv's hair out of her face, evidently just as shocked and useless as I am. Suddenly, her head jerks up, as if she's just realized I'm here. "Were you shot, Cora?"
"No," I whisper.
"What happened?" Jane roars furiously. "Would somebody tell me what the hell happened?"
I stare at all the blood and whisper, "What do I do? Gail, help me. What do I do?"
"I don't. . ." Gail shakes her head and fixes me with watery eyes. "I don't know. I don't know how it works. I've never actually seen you do it."
I try to hold my hands steady as I press them over Liv's sopping leather chest-piece, but nothing happens. Closing my eyes, I breathe in deep and think about how much I don't want her to die. No changes in my temperature. No nausea. No headache. No discernible difference at all. She's dying, and I can't figure out how this works.
Jane is screaming in mostly incoherent swears. All I understand is, "Do I have to do everything around here?"
Ethan appears, but Jane has already hefted Liv up into her arms. Liv's being carried away, and I don't do anything but sit in the grass and watch her struggle to breathe. Jin's been knocked unconscious, but I think he's still alive. I can't tell from here.
My hands—coated in Liv's blood—grow sticky as they dry in the sun.
I can't tell if it's actually freezing in Jane's house or if my body is just in shock.
This is all my fault. I'm walking around with the attitude "nothing can kill me" without realizing that puts a target on all those around me. I can't die until I time travel back to the 70's, but everyone else on this island can die at any second, including in an attempt to save me from danger. I'm not being careful, and now Liv is bleeding out because Jin was pointing a gun at me and I didn't take him seriously.
I sit on Jane's sofa as Ben gives an update on Liv's condition. Ethan has removed the bullet, and even Jack stepped in to help operate, but no matter what Ben says, I know what isn't being said: she's not fixed. There's something wrong. Why else is he choosing his words so carefully? If she was patched up and expected to make a full recovery, he'd just say so.
"This is all your fault," Jane hisses, stabbing Ben's chest with a finger. "I told you we should have sent them all back to Hydra by now. What are we supposed to tell her family?"
Ben doesn't look particularly bothered. "That Liv died doing her job."
Jane leans in close to his face and whispers through her teeth, "Get out of my house."
Gail escorts him out, and the house is quiet.
I look down at my clammy hands. Even after scrubbing and scrubbing and scrubbing, there's still a tiny fleck of Liv's blood between my fingers. Gail was right about how terrible I am at acting, but I'm only half-faking my exhaustion when I ask, "Jane, would you mind if I took a shower?"
I'm surprised when she nods and waves me away towards the back of the house without a snarky comment or protest or warning as to what she'll do to me if I use all her shampoo. She just sits slightly slumped at the kitchen table. It's evident she's even more upset about this than Gail is.
As I stand up from the sofa and walk towards the long hallway leading to Jane's combined bedroom and bathroom, I watch Jane worry a thumb furiously between her eyebrows, and I know I'm doing the right thing.
I wait until the water in the shower has been running for about a minute, and then I carefully pull up Jane's bedroom window and climb out.
"Hi!" I rear back in surprise at the figure waiting for me just around the corner. "Gail! Hi. I was. . . I was just—"
"You don't think I know what you're doing?" She arches an eyebrow. "I know you better than you probably know yourself."
I open my mouth, but I cannot think up a lie. It wouldn't do me any good anyway. What else could I possibly be trying to do out here? "Gail, I'm sorry, but you can't stop me." Liv has a daughter. A daughter whose seer abilities have already traumatized her on my behalf. And now, also because of me, Aiko's mother is holed up somewhere, apparently dying. If I were ever going to push myself to figure out how these healing powers work, it would be now. I'm completely useless otherwise. "If I can't help Liv, what's the point?"
"The point of helping her?"
"The point of me?"
Gail opens her mouth, closes it, regards me. A few different emotions quickly flash through her eyes, and then her face settles into a soft smile. "You can quit worrying, Cora. I'm not here to stop you. I'm here to tell you she's not being kept in the infirmary."
"Why not?"
"Because a certain someone knew you wouldn't listen to reason and would try to do what you're doing right now. If you wait four more minutes, Juliet will take over for Ethan's shift. She'll be much more inclined to keep this between the two of you."
Sweet relief flows through me at this news. I follow behind Gail like a gosling, realizing I couldn't have saved Liv without her help anyway because I didn't even know where the infirmary is. If Ben had her moved somewhere else because he didn't want me helping, what's going to happen when he finds out Gail led me right to her? "I can go on my own if you tell me where she is. I don't want to get you in trouble."
"Trouble? With who? Benjamin?" This gets a soft but audible laugh out of her. "Honey, I don't answer to him," she says, waving me forward. "No self-respecting woman answers to anyone but you."
"Are you sure you don't mind if I watch?" Juliet stands off to the side, cloaked somewhat in the shadows of what looks like a library. She offers a timid smile, as if worried I need more convincing. "I won't bother you."
"Yes, please, stay," I beg. "It might be helpful for your research." Honestly, I could not care less about the research. I want Juliet here because she can offer her medical expertise if something goes wrong. Although, if something goes wrong, we're screwed anyway because—by her own admission—Juliet's not a surgeon, and neither is Gail. We'd have to call for help. Word would get out and everyone would know that Gail and Juliet were involved. Gail might not get in trouble, but maybe Juliet would. I should have told her to leave. I should tell both of them to leave so I—
"Are you sure you want to do this?" Gail's voice cuts through my panicked thoughts. "I don't know how it works, but you did tell me one thing. It's different than healing yourself. You said it's excruciatingly painful."
Liv is asleep. Or maybe she's just unconscious. Aren't those technically the same thing? I still have no idea what I'm doing, but I at least have the time to calm down and try. "Aiko's been through enough," I whisper. "I'm not sending her mother home with a hole in her lungs."
I first start by trying to slow my thumping heartbeat. Deep breath in. Slow breath out. Close your eyes. Think about how relaxing it'll be beneath a palm tree tomorrow when you go back to Hydra. It'll be a permanent vacation. Most people would kill for a permanent vacation.
Okay. Now, focus. Please, don't die, Liv. Please don't die. Heal. Whatever it is that needs healing, heal it. All of it. Is it working? Just. . . I can't move my hand.
Pins and needles rush up through where my palm makes contact with Liv's exposed skin. It branches off into microscopic veins of ice that burn a network of complicated trails up my arm. I gasp—partly from the pain but mostly out of fear—as the icy burn passes through my shoulder and settles on my chest.
"Agh," I exhale and bring a hand up between my breasts. "Ow."
"What happened?" Juliet walks closer from out of the shadows, sounding worried. "Are you hurt?"
"I'm fine," I lie. "It feels like heartburn. Bad heartburn."
Liv's eyes flicker open. She coughs, notices me, smiles. I watch her brows knit in confusion. A wandering hand probs where Ethan or Jack stitched the bullet wound closed, but the stitches are no longer needed. Even from here I can see it's healed.
Liv sucks in a few clear breaths, her eyes wide. "My lady, what did you do?"
"You can't die." I press my hand harder against my chest and cough a laugh. "You're my first pick for Jarl."
Gail flits around Liv in a flurry of gentle hands, brushing back hair and soothing against her arm. "Oh, blessed child. I'm so happy you're alright." Gail's wavering voice gives away just how serious Liv's injuries must have been. The two begin talking in Norse.
Every inch of my skin is unpleasantly damp. A pressure builds up between my spinal vertebrae, so I bend forward and snap back until I feel a nice crackle of relief. I wonder if Ben's x-rays have developed yet. Maybe in this reality he doesn't have a tumor? Oh, wow, this hurts. Holy Mother of God, I need to sit down.
"I'm so sorry to press the issue," Juliet says from right in front of me. When did she get so close? "Can you tell me about what you're experiencing? Maybe start with what it feels like. Is the heartburn sensation getting better or worse?"
"I don't know. Better? Agh! No, worse. Definitely worse." It feels like I've eaten an entire plate of ghost chili peppers and choked on one of them. Now a pressure is painfully building between my femur and hip bone. I swivel around to try and crack it. A familiar dramatic thumping forces me to jerk a hand over my heart, but the pain is only getting sharper. Now it feels like every joint in my body needs to crack. It feels like my actual bones are grinding against each other. Are my bones breaking? I want to explain this to Juliet, but when I try to, all I get out is a pitiful whimper.
Gail's hands are cool against my feverish face. She's saying something because her mouth is moving, but I can't hear what it is. Pain coils in my lungs like fire, burning up my throat until I have no choice but to try and cough it out of my system.
A spray of blood splatters across Gail's dress. For a second, I refuse to believe it belongs to me, then I take in a breath only to gurgle and choke. I don't even have the air to tell them I can't breathe.
"Freyja?"
I'm floating on air—only, I'm not. Once I get a good look around, I realize I'm standing at the bow of a ship gliding through a dense fog. Wooden boards creak and groan as we slowly bob across the waves.
"Frejya?"
A woman sitting near me smiles when I look over at her. There's a small child a few seats away, waving at me. Heavy booted steps thump across the ship as a red-headed man approaches, kneeling when he reaches me.
"Thank you for speaking with me, Freyja," he booms in a jovial tone. "I've been waiting a long time to meet you. My name is Ragnar. I have something important I'd like you to tell my daughter."
I wake to an invigoration that can only come with recovering from illness. Despite my pounding headache, general lethargy, painful need to crack my neck, and blurry vision, I feel amazing in comparison to what I went through last night. I force my eyes open and watch a woman drop the bowl of water she was carrying to my bedside.
She screams, dashing away with a flurry of excited Norse words.
Gail practically slams into the bedpost. I feel her fingers brush against my face. I feel her press her forehead down against my shoulder. My eyes swivel uselessly around in my head. I'm too weak to conjure the air needed to ask her to please stop rubbing her face all over me. I'm okay. You can stop crying.
"I'm so sorry," Gail sobs hoarsely into the bedsheets. "I'm so sorry. I didn't know it would take so much out of you. I never would have encouraged it."
When I'm able to move, I push up into a sitting position—in part to finally get Gail off me. I'm on a bed in the infirmary, and from the looks of it, Gail, Liv, Juliet, and Jack have all been in here long enough to have nodded off while they waited for me to wake up. Juliet's still blinking her way out of a dream.
Ethan walks into the room and yawns. "Oh, good. You decided not to die."
I'm the most surprised to see Jack. He smiles, but it looks like he hasn't quite figured out what he thinks of me yet. Jack gives a small nod. "Cora."
I nod in return. "Jack."
"Glad to see you're finally awake," he says, and there's a comfort in talking to him without him glaring at me. "How are you feeling?"
"Fine. I'm fine." Judging from the state of my headache, I imagine I've been unconscious all night. Possibly all day as well. "How long was I out?"
Jack listens to my lungs with a stethoscope and Ethan sticks a thermometer in my mouth. "You've been in a coma for almost four days."
I almost open my mouth and drop the thermometer. Four days?
"Follow my finger with just your eyes, please." Jack waves a finger from one side of my face to the other. "Good. At least until we can run some tests, it sounds like your lungs are clear."
"My lungs?"
"Filled with blood," he says and points to his own chest. "We had to drain them, and by then you were already healing."
Jack is in doctor mode at this point, and there's no stopping him. Even though I only understand a fraction of what he's saying, I furrow my eyebrows and nod like everything makes sense. He explains how he and Juliet and Ethan have come up with a theory about my power. Something to do with my white blood cell count dropping? They took blood samples while I was dying? Cool. Thanks guys.
I don't know what to say when he finishes. I simply settle on, "Thank you."
"It was touch and go there for a second," Ethan notes grimly. "When Juliet brought us here, you were already gone."
I understand him. I understand him perfectly clear, but I still need to hear him say it. "What do you mean?"
Jack blinks, presses his lips together, and nods. "He means for the five and a half minutes it took us to get here, you were legally dead."
Snapping the book shut, I fight the urge to fling it across the room. Tom has terrible taste in literature.
I have a suspicion the reason no one has visited me in the infirmary yet is because Gail won't allow it. For the first day, it was nice. Quiet. Peaceful. Easy to nap, eat, nap some more. Fenrir and Pumba have thankfully stopped fighting and find ways to entertain themselves while I read. But one day turned into two, and now that I feel mostly recovered, I'm getting a little stir-crazy.
I try to tell Gail this when she checks in on me, but all she does is offer another book to help me pass the time. She's convinced I need a few more days of doing absolutely nothing before we sail back to Hydra, while the rest of my people prepare for the wedding. It's supposedly such an undertaking, it'll be at least a week before I'll need to return for the ceremony.
I'm not even sure how many days it's been when I see Alex army crawling across the floor towards my bed.
I'm laughing before I can stop myself. "What are you doing?"
"Shh! Gail won't let any of us in," she whispers conspiratorially. "She says you need absolute silence to recuperate. Got the whole place on lockdown."
"How'd you get in?"
Alex crawls up to the side of my bed and sits on the floor. "Back window. Had to unscrew like 7 bolts, but I heard you wanted to try our cheese. Here." She hefts up a backpack, checking to make sure Gail isn't storming into the room. "It's as fresh as you can get."
I marvel at the delicious looking spread. "You made all this?"
"Dad and I did. I was milking animals for hours. I never want to make cheese again. Oh, here." Alex pulls out The Hobbit from her backpack and places on my bedside table. "Dad wanted me to give this to you. I hope I didn't get cheese on it."
"Is that my notebook?" I frown, pointing. "Did you read it? Is that how you knew I wanted to try the mainland's famous cheese?"
"Sorry." Alex smiles and shrugs with embarrassment. "I was just keeping it safe for you. I liked the sketches of Fenrir. They're funny."
They're not supposed to be funny. "Thanks."
We nibble at various homemade cheeses while Alex gives me the latest island news. She explains Jin's still alive because apparently my people will no longer kill anyone without my permission. I'm about to ask her for more info when suddenly she's gone—swiftly rolling under my bed, taking her backpack with her in one fluid motion.
"Do you need anything?"
I look up at Gail and smile despite myself. "Nope." Don't laugh. "I'm good." Stop smiling so hard. "Thanks, Gail."
"I brought you some lunch and another book." I watch her mouth curl upwards into a small amused smile of her own as she nods down towards the bed and soundlessly words, "Is she bothering you?"
I finally let myself laugh and shake my head. "No, I'm good, Gail. Thanks for the food."
"You're welcome." Looking especially amused, Gail nods, turns, and walks back towards the entrance, disappearing with a click.
"Whoo, that was close," Alex says as she rolls out from under the bed. "No offense, but Gail scares me."
"Why?"
"Liv is technically your body guard, but Gail's just. . . she's like, your number one follower. I mean, she went kinda ballistic when she found out you were poisoned."
That's right. That's a list item I haven't checked off yet. "Do you know what's going to happen to her? The woman who poisoned me?"
"Far as I know, she's going to rot in prison."
All at once I remember what Jane told me before I wandered off and got Liv shot: I killed this woman's parents. What was her name? Daisy? Daphne? "Do you know who she is?"
"Oh, I never met her," says Alex. "But Hazel has."
"Who's Hazel?"
"One of my friends on Hydra." Alex's demeanor saddens a little. "I haven't seen her in a while."
"She doesn't come visit?"
"She used to, but. . ." Alex takes a small nibble and shrugs with one shoulder. "I haven't seen her since her dad died."
That's why Alex wants to go to Hydra so badly. Wait, are there any children here at the barracks? The only child I've see so far is Indiana, and she's years younger than Alex. "Are there any girls your age here at the barracks?"
Alex's sadness slowly sours into annoyance. "No. I mean, Indiana's nice and all, but she's six. I can only play pretend ponies so many times a day before I want to scream."
What about Karl? "Are you saying you and Indiana are the only kids in all the barracks?"
Alex folds her arms over her chest. "I'm not a kid. I'm sixteen."
"Sorry. I meant are you and Indiana the only young people here?"
Alex shrugs again. "Yeah."
I know better than most what it's like not to have friends. Even when I did have friends it was like I didn't. One of the girls I regularly hung out with in college once invited me to a party, and when I showed up with the food she requested, she and the other girls in attendance made it abundantly clear I wasn't welcome. Bitch never even gave me my baking dish back. Why did I leave it there? Should have stormed out with the food when they—
"I'm legally allowed to go to Hydra if I wanted to," Alex grumbles. "It's totally unfair. I haven't been able to practice with the band in months."
I almost choke on cheese. "You're in a band? My brother was in a band! What do you play?"
"Electric guitar."
"You're in a rock band? That's so cool!" Alex looks surprised at my enthusiasm. "And that's so lame your dad won't let you hang out with your friends. What's his deal?"
Relaxing completely at the opportunity to complain, Alex says, "I don't know. He never gives me an answer. It's always I'll let you go next year. He's been saying that since I was fourteen."
I hate seeing Alex like this. "Maybe I can ask him for you. Come on, I'm sick of being in this stupid room." I take an excited bite of mozzarella and confirm this is quality enough cheese to constitute as famous. "He can't say no to a Goddess."
Ben doesn't even look up from his desk. "No."
"That's it? You're not even going to listen to my pitch?"
Ben's still hard at work rummaging through stacks of paperwork for the new treaty draft. He flips a page to reveal a mixture of English, runes, and something else. There's a pause as he reads, then he circles a cluster of runes. "I apologize that Alex put you up to this, especially so soon after your recovery. I'll have a talk to her about it later."
"She didn't put me up to anything," I explain. "I just think it would be good for her to visit her friends."
Ben takes off his glasses and finally looks up at me. "If I wanted your opinion, I'd have asked you for it."
I feel my body go through all the physiological reactions to being chastised, but although my face is burning, my thoughts remain surprisingly clear. Granted, he's not yelling at me, so that helps. "Does Alex have any friends here at the barracks?"
"Yes," he snaps, "of course she does. Everyone adores her." He's still not yelling, but his tone suggests he might as well be, and it makes my palms sweaty.
Still, what he's doing isn't fair. Alex is a good kid. Too good. I mean, honestly, he has no idea how easy he has it. Take my younger twin sisters, for example. They took any excuse they could get to cause trouble. If anything, our incredibly sheltered hell-hole of a household only perfected their art of never getting caught because the consequences were so high. Alex may argue with Ben every once in a while, but she still listens. If what she says is true about being legally allowed to visit Hydra, Alex could technically hop in a boat and visit whenever she wants. But she doesn't. Because Ben told her not to, and she listened.
"I meant does she have friends her own age. And no," I add, "Indiana does not count. They're ten years apart."
Ben leans back a little in his chair until it squeaks. According to the ticking clock in the distance, fifteen seconds pass before he leans forward and clasps his hands on the desk. "Are you at all interested in feudal Japan? I have a historic scroll you are more than welcome to have."
"Huh?"
"No? How about James Bond," he offers. "I have a signed first edition of Casino Royale. You want it?"
"Not particularly, no. Why?"
Ben leans closer, shadowing his face from the desk lamp so he looks even more annoyed than usual. "I'm trying to figure out what I can offer you to leave me in peace. You want a greek salad?"
What I want to say is Wow, you're an asshole. What's your plan here? Keep her away from Hydra. . . because? What are you worried about? Why don't you seem to have a problem keeping her here on the mainland where the men and older male teens live? Wouldn't you want her as far away from them as possible? Again, what's the plan here? She's eventually going to snap and do whatever she wants anyway. That's always how this ends. Can't you see being this inflexible is only widening the rift between you two? Don't you care that you're driving her away?
What I say is, "You're very unpleasant." Before he has a chance to respond, I'm speed-walking out the front door.
Oh no! I forgot to thank him for making me all that cheese! Nonna would have a fit right now if she knew someone had made me food—especially something as complicated and time consuming as homemade cheese—and I didn't thank them. Oops. I didn't even ask him about his x-rays.
"Sorry," I tell Alex when I find her sitting on a bench not far from the house. "It's a firm no."
"Yeah, I figured. Thanks anyway." Alex hops up and throws her arms around me in a tight hug. "Promise you'll come and visit soon? It's so boring here."
Stop it, stop it, please. I grit my teeth so hard I'm surprised I don't crack a molar. "Yeah," I say and shake her off. "Of course. Or," I suggest in a joking whisper, "you can always come visit me."
"I for one am glad to be going home." Gail puffs up and takes a seat next to me. "Sit up straight, Cora. Don't slouch."
I straighten my spine.
The last of the crew climb aboard. Ropes are unfastened from the shore. The plank we used to walk into the ship is pulled up. A man standing near the sails complains about the weak winds and the need for oars.
"Wait," I say. "Stop!" The crew immediately stops talking. I point at the trees in the distance. Someone is running full sprint towards us, their voice so faint I can barely hear it. It's a while before I recognize Alex.
A man lowers the plank for her, and she climbs aboard, gasping and choking on air. "Dad changed his mind," she huffs when I ask what's wrong. "He said I can stay with you for the week before the wedding." I watch her eyes dart to the trees in the distance before darting back to me. She smiles, seemingly unable to stop coughing. "We can shove off now."
"Alex." She tenses at the sound of her name, and I smile at her, knowing full well Ben didn't change his mind. It's only going to be a matter of time before he comes to bring her back home. Oh well. "You better get a weeks worth of fun out of the next few hours."
Chapter 13: Shieldmaiden of Hydra vs Goddess of Love
Chapter Text
Liv was wrong about one thing—it was not a "matter of time before I got my sea-legs back." After two close calls, I finally feel the glorious stability of land and swallow down the bile in my throat for good.
"Lady Cora," Gail announces, "it was an undertaking of sorts, but rest assured, Hydra is now the safest place on Earth. If you need anything, feel free to ask just about anyone. That being said, unless you need my immediate services, I'll be in the longhouse. I haven't had a good nap in weeks, and at my age, a good nap is crucial to my survival."
I laugh and tell her to enjoy.
"So…" I turn to address a very nervous Alex. "I guess it's time to find your friends."
We've barely gotten past the brush separating the beach from the jungle when a small child drops down from the trees and presses a knife's blade to my stomach. "Join my crew or perish where you stand!"
So much for Hydra being the safest place on Earth. I look down at the frowning child and conclude she can't be much older than seven or eight. "Okay."
"Excellent," she says and sheathes the knife. "I'm the captain and you're my first mate. Carry me on your back."
"Uh, no, I don't think…" I stop talking as the incredibly hyper child climbs on my back anyway. "Okay. Please don't do that. You're choking me."
"I need to make a pitstop at home," she continues. "Ouch! Hold my legs. Oh, hi Alex!"
"Hey, Peregrine." Alex gives a small wave. "Do you know where I can find your sisters?"
"Yeah, they're all at home. You can follow me. Onward, first mate!"
I'm at least somewhat familiar with the layout of Hydra. Or at least with the path that leads to the houses. Alex remains completely silent as I struggle to carry Peregrine up the hill towards the longhouse and the Hall of Freyja. Now that I have the time to do so, I look around more and admire just how colorful and vibrant this area is. Best of all, nobody approaches me. At most, a passing woman or two will nod their acknowledgement and smile at the squirming kid ordering me around.
"We're here," Peregrine yells triumphantly. "Take me inside, first mate. I have business to conduct."
A door flies open, and chaos tumbles out in the form of four excitable young women and Flint—Annie's young son I stopped from fighting a superhuman named Thor. Alex barely gets a greeting out before they knock her down in a dog-pile, lost in a fit of screams and laughter.
"I can't believe you're here," one of them screams.
"This is the best day ever," another girl chimes in. "What did you think about what I wrote you last? You never wrote back!"
"You'll have to tell me about it all over again," Alex says when she's finally released from the pile of bodies. "I ran out of raisins as payment, so Loki tried to eat your last letter. I could barely read it when I wrestled it out of his beak."
"Alex?" Annie wanders outside to see what all the commotion is about. "This is a surprise. Girls, get off her. Let her breathe. Lady Cora." Annie spots me and starts to bow but stops when she sees who has hitched a ride on my back. "Peregrine, you get off of lady Cora right this instant."
"You're Cora?" Peregrine asks. "Yippie! Lady Cora's my first mate! I didn't get to see when your eyes were bleeding, but now my crew will be the most revered in all the high seas. We shall pillage the word and take none alive—hey!"
Annie pulls Peregrine off me and restrains her tightly against her chest. "I apologize on behalf of this one, Cora. Takes too much after her father. I'm still attempting to civilize her. Speaking of which, it's time for your bath."
"What? No!" Peregrine struggles against her mother's grip, but Annie holds her up sideways off the floor, like a plank of wood, and starts walking deeper into the jungle. "Unhand me, woman! Help! First mate, save me!"
Poor Alex has finally been freed of the dog-pile, but she doesn't at all seem to mind being squished. The group stands huddled together, like if they don't hold tightly to some part of Alex, she's going to blow away at the first strong breeze. The sight of them makes me nostalgic for memories I don't have.
As if just now realizing I'm here, the once boisterous group of girls have quieted to barely above a whisper as they regard me shyly. Even though they're all smiling, they look like Jack did—unsure of what to think of me. All at one time, they say, "Hello, lady Cora."
The tallest girl—a brunette with a face full of freckles—steps forward and bows. "Lady Cora, would it be okay if we showed Alex around the island?"
Is that a tattoo? I'm taken aback by the sizable dragon snaking up this young girl's neck. I catch myself staring. Who is this? I never actually officially met any of Annie's daughters, so I have no idea who I'm talking to. Considering the rest of them are redheads, I can't even say for sure that this is one of Annie's children. "Yes," I tell her. "Of course. That's why she's here. You all go have fun."
I smile when their excitement seems to return in full force. Holding tightly to Alex's arms, the girls take off into the jungle in a cloud of laughter, leaving poor Flint struggling to keep up.
Now that I'm alone, I'm not entirely sure what I want to do. This is the first time I haven't been bombarded with requests or introductions. I eventually walk to the longhouse in search of my bedroom. I'm sick of this dress. Maybe I have pants in one of the clothing chests?
"Here." Gail holds out a small rolled paper when I step into the room. "Pris says this letter came for you about half an hour ago."
I unroll it and instantly frown.
I humbly request Alex's prompt return home. —Ben
Gail points to the corner of the room. "There's fresh paper on your desk, if you need it."
I shake my head and reach for a pencil. "No need to waste paper. I'll just write on the back." In big block letters I respond REQUEST DENIED and hand the newly-folded sheet to Gail.
I suddenly know what I want to do more than anything. I want to eat. More importantly, I want some more of that delicious bread and jam. "I'm going to check out the jam house. Can you point me in the right direction?"
"Welcome, my lady. To what do I owe the pleasure of your visit?"
It's nice to see Charlotte again under more pleasant circumstances. This workroom is beautiful and filled with a decadent sugary smell that instantly makes my mouth water. Large vats of ripe fruit line one wall and an assortment of empty jars line another. I smile at her. "Just wanted to see how you're doing."
"Me?" Charlotte sets down a full jar of mango jam and wipes her hands on an apron. "I'm doing as well as everyone else, I guess. If you don't mind my asking, I'm curious as to how you're doing. Loki sent us word while you were healing."
How am I doing? About what part? Being poisoned? Agreeing to an arranged marriage so people stop trying to kill each other? Healing Liv and literally DYING in the process? "I've recovered," I answer and walk further into the room. "Honestly, I don't really want to talk about it. I'd much rather learn about what you're doing. Can I help? I've never made jam before."
Charlotte perks up. "Actually, I'd love some help. If you don't mind. My sister's are out sick this morning, and I need to finish canning this fruit before it rots."
She has sisters? "Are your sisters okay?"
"Yes," Charlotte laughs lightly and shakes her head. "They're not actually sick. Just very hungover. They've been partying since we got word you'd woken up from your coma."
I glance around and sigh internally. Not a bread roll in sight. "Are you not much of a drinker?"
"Nothing wrong with a little mead now and then," she explains with a wink. "It's the hangover after a binge that's never quite worth it to me. Is something wrong?"
"Oh. . . no, no. Just—" It's embarrassing to beg, but I'm just so hungry. "You wouldn't happen to have some of that bread from the party, would you? I'd love a snack. If you don't mind me taking some jam."
"Please, have as much as you'd like." Reaching down behind the table, Charlotte pulls up a nice soft loaf and offers it to me. "Enjoy yourself while I show you how the magic happens."
I rip off chunks of bread as she explains how to preserve the fruit by skinning, cutting, and mashing mangos, papayas, peaches, and berries. Next, she demonstrates the amount of gelatin and honey to add and what consistency it needs to be before scooping them into a jar. Since honey has no moisture, it doesn't spoil and helps to give the jam a longer shelf-life. Charlotte shows me how to fill the jars, how to close them properly, and where to store them when they're finished.
"We usually eat it as fast as my sisters and I can jar them. But ever since you've returned, our orchard has been running wild. We've been harvesting such an abundance, we have to freeze some fruit for later. That's not even counting what's in this store room." Charlotte laughs again and gently nudges me with her elbow. "So, thank you."
This is fun. I'm happy I decided to check this place out because I'm genuinely interested in how they make such delicious jam. It's practically all I ate the last time I was on Hydra, and it's one of the few foods I've never tried to make homemade. Thankfully, half the battle is something I excel at—chopping. Charlotte gave me a quality knife to work with, and it's no time at all before I've sliced up an entire barrel of peaches while lost in a methodical stupor.
Please say something, Charlotte.
I scoop thick globs of mashed peaches into a big bowl and mix in the appropriate amount of honey and gelatin. Charlotte hasn't said anything since we've begun working. "I'm gonna be honest," I tell her. "I have no idea what gelatin even is."
She smiles kindly and reaches across the table for a bowl of mangos. "We boil bones for ours. It's a very long process, but it keeps the jam firm."
"Oh." Come on. Think of something else to say. This is the first time—outside of conversations with Alex—that a person I'm working with hasn't gone on and on about the things they want or need me to do. In fact, Charlotte's silence is starting to make me anxious.
It's not that I'm quiet because I have nothing to say. I would never shut-up if I had the self-esteem to do so. I'm usually quiet because nobody listens to me, and it's exhausting to have things I want to share with others and a room full of people who don't want to hear it.
"Can I ask you something?" I instantly flinch with regret at the memory of Ben responding to my question with a snarky, I don't know. Can you?
But Charlotte only looks up from the mound of sliced mangos she's working on and fixes me with another kind smile. "Of course."
We talk about everything, switching from one subject to the next like we're old friends. I learn about the rock pool not far from here where they get their drinking water, and the orchards where they harvest crops, and the small farm where they raise cows and goats for milk, sheep for wool, and chickens for eggs.
I relax the longer the conversation goes until she asks me about the wedding. I skirt around the question and ask if she's seeing anyone. She skirts around the question and asks me about Asgard. I ask about her family. She's the oldest sister, and we bond over that shared commonality. As she divulges more about her family, it becomes clear why she still has a British accent. Both her parents raised her here on Hydra after the Dharma Initiative was disbanded and its people adopted by mine. I guess that explains why Miles is here.
It's as easy to talk to Charlotte as it is to talk to Claire. Claire. "Do you know where the female survivors are? I haven't seen them since I returned."
"They're settled in the guesthouses," she answers. "Pris put them to work in the gardens. I can take you there after we've finished canning, if you'd like."
I finish screwing on the top to a finished jar of papaya jam and walk over to the organized shelf. One jar lies away from the others. I pick it up and squint to confirm it's what I think it is. "Is this strawberry jam? I love strawberries."
"It's the last jar for a few weeks." Charlotte suddenly looks irritated. "We hardly ever make it because it takes so many strawberries, and the children are notorious for plucking the plants clean before we can even harvest them." She frowns down at the bowl she's working on. "The last time we canned strawberry jam, Jane sailed all the way here just to break poor Gunnar's nose. Didn't even offer him a trade. Just stormed in and took the last jar."
I raise my eyebrows, even though this isn't surprising news in the slightest. "Yeah, she's a little. . . abrasive."
"Yes, well, she wasn't always like that."
"No?" Now that is surprising news. "She told me she grew up here. On Hydra."
"Mm-hm," Charlotte hums as she works. "But she left as soon as she turned sixteen. You're allowed to leave your community at sixteen," she explains when she sees my confusion. "We call it The Great Wandering. It's a time in a young person's life when they get to choose whether or not they wish to stay with our people or join Jacob's followers." Charlotte spoons more honey into the jar, her eyebrows mashing together. "Nobody ever actually leaves, but Jane couldn't wait to get away from this island. Even started growing her hair out the moment she left. I think she's embarrassed of us."
Charlotte's red hair is relatively long, so I'm confused. "Is short hair tradition here?"
"No, sorry," Charlotte explains, motioning to the right side of her scalp. "Jane has a head tattoo, but you can't see it anymore."
Our conversation dies down. I glance at her while I mash fruit. She looks sad. "Does Jane not visit often?"
Charlotte huffs, looks up at me, and blushes a soft pink. "Basically makes a bi-weekly trip to trade some foolish young person a bottle of dipping sauce for something worth far more than that. I keep telling her to leave them alone. Children only ever think with their stomachs."
I'm not even canning anymore. Propping my elbow on the table, I rest my head in my hand. "Why don't you visit her on the mainland?"
"I have my sisters here. And plenty of friends." Charlotte regards me curiously. Whatever was holding her back from being truly forthcoming seems to no longer matter. "I don't need to beg for anyones attention. If she wanted to visit, she would."
"Jane strikes me as someone who appreciates bluntness." I return my attention to chopping the fruit. "But she also doesn't seem like the type to be very honest with her feelings."
Charlotte stops chopping. "What exactly is it you're trying to say, my lady?"
What am I doing? If I'm wrong about this, I could irrevocably screw up their friendship. And for what? Because I like shipping people? What the hell is wrong with me?
I piece together everything I know about the two of them. How enraged Jane was at the engagement dinner. How Ben told Charlotte to leave after Jane got drunk because he "didn't want her to get any worse." Jane herself admitted she wasn't fighting Erik because he announced his engagement. She was fighting him specifically because he'd chosen Charlotte. Hm. In the show, Charlotte was paired with Daniel Faraday. A character I have no idea even fits into whatever is happening in this universe. So, if he's not here, is there a chance Charlotte could be destined for someone else?
"At the engagement dinner," I continue, staring intently into my jam mixture, "you mentioned Erik proposed to you to embarrass Jane." I'm not entirely sure how to approach the subject, but I'm just too damn nosy not to try. "I don't think I've ever seen someone so angry. It was a lot, even for Jane. It makes me wonder."
"About what?"
I raise my eyebrows and shrug. "That maybe she cares about you as more than a friend."
Charlotte scoffs quietly. "Jane only truly cares about Jane."
"Mmm, I don't think that's true."
"Have you seen something?" she asks, looking up from her bowl. "A vision?"
"Uh…no," I admit. Now my face is the one reddening. "This is more of a theory."
Charlotte nods, and I'm afraid I've disappointed her. "In all our years of friendship, we've had many a falling out. Sometimes she's just so… aggravating."
It's almost like I'm back home, listening to my mother and grandmother talk shit about whatever family gossip is hot at the moment. I lean forward, encouragingly. "Mm-hm?"
"Is it really so difficult to be straightforward? I'm not difficult to talk to, am I? I swear I never know what she's thinking. Just when I believe I've figured her out, she goes and does something asinine."
"Like what?"
"Like propose to Erik," she says in a rush of prickly anger. Neither of them have actually admitted to me how they feel in any straightforward manner, but judging from the way Charlotte's gripping a dishrag while she rants, I think I can guess where she stands. "It was such a shock."
"Wait, Jane didn't tell you beforehand she was proposing to Erik?"
"No," Charlotte exclaims in insult. "I had to find out from Sabine. I thought she hated the man, but then the next thing I know, everyone is planing their wedding, and I'm left wondering what's going on."
"Maybe she was trying to do what she thought was right? Maybe she didn't know how to tell you?" I know why Jane proposed to Erik and then receded the offer, but it doesn't sound like any of this was discussed with Charlotte. "I mean, she just as quickly broke off the engagement."
Charlotte sets down the jar she's working on and turns to give me her full attention. "May I ask you a question? Please answer not as my friend, but as the Goddess of Love. Can you tell me, with absolute certainty, that what you're saying is true?"
"Uh. I can't exactly confirm that's how she feels. But if you give me a day, I can find out."
At the end of the day, Charlotte takes me to the survivors.
Like she mentioned earlier, they've been sent to work in the gardens, but I'd use the term "work" lightly. Most of them are sitting in the grass, talking to the women of Hydra and munching on various produce. Even Kate—who is supposed to be serving time—is lounging in the grass, deep in a conversation. Sun seems to be the only one truly interested in the actual gardening. I spot Claire just as she lets out a particularly mirthful laugh at something an equally pregnant Norse woman has said.
I take one look at them all—satisfied they are safe and at least relatively happy—and decide not to talk to them today.
There's a new letter sitting on my desk in the bedroom. I take a steadying breath before uncurling it.
This matter does not concern you. I would appreciate if you could respect the boundaries within a father-daughter relationship. I am requesting Alex's immediate return home. I will not ask again. —Ben
I snort, flip the note, and grab a pencil.
Get over yourself and stop bothering me!
It's maybe fifteen minutes before a raven named Angrboda returns with a response strapped to her leg. "I require payment," she says.
"You don't want anymore raisins?"
"No." Angrboda hops across my desk and pecks at a ring. "May I have this shiny thing?"
What's a raven going to do with a ring? "Yeah, sure. It's all yours. Can I have the note now?"
I uncurl it, expecting another snide response, and immediately panic. Ben's written an angry cramped letter that takes up every inch of the paper. He's pressed so hard on some of the words that they leave deep indents that almost rip through. I fold it without reading beyond the first four words: I WILL NOT BE—
Breathe in. Breathe out. What's he going to do? Keep sending letters in all uppercase to drive home his point?
But what if he comes here? What if he catches me when Gail's not around? What if he yells at me? Maybe I should talk to Alex.
No. Wait. Calm down. I'm a grown ass adult. What's the worst he can do?
I keep the letter folded, walk over to my fireplace, and toss it in.
It feels weird to wake up naturally and not have anyone vying for my attention. Nobody knocks at my door and asks me to bless their children or heal their gaping wounds. The only person waiting patiently outside my bedroom is Gail, and all she wants is to present me with a breakfast platter. We eat together at one of the many tables in the longhouse and talk about nothing in particular. After breakfast, I let her know I'm going down to the beach to sunbathe, and she helps me pick out some pants, a t-shirt, and sunglasses.
"Not much point in sunbathing if you're in pants." Gail holds up the cotton garment in question. "Are you sure you don't want these shorts?"
No, because I don't want anyone to see my legs. If I don't see my legs, I don't have to think about jiggling or cellulite or—worst of all—the painful chub rub that's bound to happen the second my legs sweat even a little. I don't tell her this, and thankfully she doesn't fight me on the matter.
I'm halfway down the hill when I hear a familiar voice. "Morning, first mate. Where are we off to today?"
Oh, no. Please not right now. "I'm going to go sunbathe by myself for a while."
"Oh."
I just want peace and quiet, but I also instantly feel bad for Peregrine when her expression falls. "You should try and recruit more people into our crew," I say in an attempt to cheer her up. "A two person ship won't get very far."
Peregrine sniffs, looking dejected. "My sisters don't want to play with me. And Aiko's dad won't let her leave the temple anymore."
I stop myself from asking if there are any other children she can play with. If there were, she'd be playing with them. It's a familiar feeling to not have anyone to hang out with. Ultimately, I give in. "You can come with me if you want."
"Yeah?" Peregrine lights up for half a second before falling back into a comedically serious expression. "No need to carry me to the beach, first mate. I give you the day off."
A genuine laugh bursts out of me. "Thank you. I appreciate it."
"Lady Cora? Lady Cora!" Two young girls run towards me, frowning when they see Peregrine. "Ugh. Is she bossing you around too?"
It's not clear if these girls are bullies, or if Peregrine is the bully. I look from one little girl to the other and take note of Peregrine's slouching stature. "No," I answer. "Actually, I joined her crew. You wanna join?"
An angry response is forming on one of their lips before the other jabs her in the ribs and she catches herself. "No thank you, lady Cora." As quick as they arrived, the girls have disappeared into the trees.
I raise an eyebrow at Peregrine's uncomfortable expression. "I'm assuming they're not friends of yours?"
"They're all just jealous because I'm a luck god."
Huh? Honestly, I just want to relax in the sun for a little while, so I smile and nod and continue walking towards the ocean as she trails behind me. Eventually I find a nice palm to lie under and get comfortable in the sand while Fenrir and Pumba run along the shoreline. It's instantly relaxing to toast under a vibrant sun with a cool sea breeze blowing off the water.
This is what I've been waiting for since day one. If there's no way to get back to my actual reality—wherever that is—I might as well be existential in comfort.
I lie back in the sand and close my eyes, lulled into a calm by the sound of the ocean. Sunshine streaks lines of red behind my eyelids, and I watch them dance as a cloud passes over the sun and everything darkens. I open my eyes to find it's not a cloud.
Seeing him doesn't illicit intense fear or nervousness like I thought it would. My natural response to his murderous expression is to frown back up at him with equal loathing. "Do I have to sic Gail on you?" I sit up and rip off my sunglasses. "Because I will."
"We need to talk."
"No thanks. I'm on vacation."
"I wasn't asking for permission," he states flatly. "I'm telling you we're going to talk. I'll even let you choose the location."
"Well, I'm not moving, so I guess take a seat."
"No can do, Ben." Peregrine squares her shoulders and looks up at him. "I need my first mate rested so we can prepare for our next big raid."
"I'll make you a deal," he says, swiveling around to look at her. "You let me talk to Cora privately, and I won't tell your mother you're the one who stole fireworks and lit the pavilion on fire at the last Yuletide."
She squints up at him defiantly. "You have no proof."
"Try me."
Peregrine falls silent, deep in thought. Finally, she nods. "Deal." The two shake hands, and then she's running off back up the hill.
Ben's glare momentarily softens into a concerned frown as he watches her disappear. "You didn't bet her anything, did you?"
"No?"
He nods, his expression souring again. He glares at me a moment longer before sitting in the sand and glaring at me from eye level. "Why are you being difficult? I made a very simple request."
"You sailed all the way over here just to reiterate what you've already told me in your letters?" I pop my sunglasses back on and sigh. "Great use of your time, Ben."
"Do you even know where Alex is right now?"
"She's fine. I've been with her this whole time." Not exactly true, but I did see her walking around with a big group of girls last night.
Ben shifts his gaze from me to the windy shore. "The fact that you've already died in the few days you've been here doesn't exactly instill confidence in your ability to keep her safe."
"I don't know what you want me to say." Without knowing why, I'm suddenly so irrationally angry my throat is burning. "Alex is legally allowed to be here."
"This isn't about legalities."
"Then what is this about? Because right now it just sounds like you want her back home because you're empty nesting."
"This isn't about me," he retorts sharply. "This is entirely about Alex. It's. . . it's seer business."
"What do you mean?" Wait, is being here putting her in danger? "Did Aiko tell you something about Alex's future?"
Ben can't seem to stop blinking as he opens his mouth and changes his mind. "No."
"Then who did? The previous seer?"
"I know you're new to all this," he complains, "but it's incredibly taboo to ask someone about their prophecy."
"Alex is running around with about ten other young girls right now." I sit up on my knees and stare him down when he tries to argue. "If she's in trouble, they all are, and I need to know about it."
He shakes his head, like what I just said was ridiculous. "They're not all in trouble—"
"Tell me," I interrupt. "You want my help? I want you to tell me exactly what the seer said. Word for word."
Ben stills and falls silent for a long time. "She saw me mourning her." He pauses, looking down at the sand, then out at the water. "She saw her die very young."
Think, think, think. In the show, how does she die? Keamy. Martin Keamy shoots her in the back of the head. But does Keamy even exist in this universe? Will there be someone else on the freighter? Some other mercenary? Will there even be a freighter?
"How?" I ask.
"Childbirth."
I stare at him, unblinking. Although, he'd never know because I put the sunglasses back on. "You do realize this island is where they keep the women, right?"
Ben jerks his head over to glare at me. His mouth twitches downward with a handful of snide responses, but all he ends up saying is a curt, "Yes, I'm aware."
"Then you're going to have to do a better job of explaining yourself." Wait a second. I think back to everything Charlotte told me yesterday. "Have you been keeping her away from this island because you're afraid she's going to realize how much more fun my people are and decide to join them? What is it…Wandering Week?"
"That's not at all what it's called."
"But that's what this is about, isn't it?" He doesn't answer, and that's as good as a confirmation. "Wow, this is. . . not your finest work. I thought you were supposed to be good at planning?" At the look on his face, I add, "I get what you're doing, and I actually appreciate where you're coming from. But you greatly misunderstand teenage girls if you think this is a viable solution."
At this, he stops and looks down at the sand before looking side-long at me. "You sound like you have an idea."
"My younger twin sisters are more of a headache than Alex could ever dream to be. Honestly, you have no idea how well behaved Alex is in comparison to most other teenagers I've met in my life." I hold up an index finger. "But. . ."
"I'm listening."
"No matter how well-behaved, it's sort of a teenage right of passage to find ways to give authority the middle finger." I almost laugh at his prickly expression. "I understand why you want her under constant supervision, but I guarantee she thinks you're stifling her because you still think of her as a child."
"She is a child," he argues.
"See? This is what I'm talking about. If she could hear you right now, she wouldn't see your intentions as loving. She'd probably think this was some kind of punishment." Alex said she has no idea why Ben won't let her go to Hydra, which means he's never talked to her about her future. "You've. . ." All the uncharacteristic calmness I've been holding onto abandons me, and I feel a familiar flush burning my face. If she's supposed to die in labor. . . "Have you, I mean, or anyone else, I guess. . . um. Hm." I wave my hands around while he waits for me to finish. "She's. . . um. Okay, like, you know what I'm talking about."
"Your point was so eloquently argued, how could there be any room for confusion?"
I don't think I've ever consciously wanted to slap someone so badly. It's not my fault if you've never had "The Talk" with your kid! If you'd have just told her what her future entailed, she could be best equipped at not letting it happen. Does birth control not exist in this universe?!
Before I can think of something to say, Ben beats me to it. "I'm very busy back at the mainland, and I don't feel like we've made any real headway with this conversation. So, please," he finishes in an almost whisper. "I am asking you to tell my daughter to come home."
I'm surprised to find that the overwhelming emotion I'm feeling is jealousy. Dad would never have fought to keep me or my siblings safe. Dad would have sold us for a case of beers if he could have figured out a way to do so without the FBI finding out. Ben may be incredibly misguided in his execution of Plan: Keep Alex Safe, but his heart's in the right place. He just wants to protect his daughter the way all parents should.
Which makes it all the more difficult to give my answer. "No," I say and watch as his expression morphs into surprise. "Alex is free to go home whenever she'd like, but I'm not going to force her off an island she's within her legal rights to visit."
"Well alright then." Ben's expression is a resigned mask of indifference when he stands. "I guess I've wasted both our time."
"Wait, sit." But he's ignoring me, so I jump up and follow him. "Do you know if her mother talked to her before she got sick?"
Ben scoffs dismissively and keeps walking. "Her mother didn't get sick. She fell off a cliff."
"That's not what Alex told me."
"One of your scouts fished her out of the water." Ben looks over at me. "What? You think I should have told a five-year-old all the gruesome details? I'm sure Alex would have loved to hear all about how the backside of her mother's skull had been cracked wide open. How fish had already begun to eat her bloated flesh. How—"
"Okay, thanks. I get it."
He stops walking, exhales. "Did her mother ask her…what?"
"No," I correct, suddenly thankful for the sunglasses hiding my cringing eyes. "Do you know if—" I am a grown adult who cannot say the words, "Do you know if her mother talked to her about sex?" Which, now that I think of it, the answer is obviously no. Danielle died when Alex was almost too young to even remember her. So, has anyone stepped up to take her mother's place now that Alex is older?
If everything in life were left up to my mother and grandmother, I'd get married, have a bunch of kids, and die without ever even knowing what birth control is. You know, like a good Catholic. But I went to a secular college, and they literally made everyone in the dorms take a "care package" during orientation that consisted of a handful of condoms. I was originally going to try and befriend my roommate by joking around and making balloon animals out of mine, but when I opened the pack, the latex smelt so horrendous I just threw them all away. My roommate turned out to be an asshole anyway.
I can't seem to form the words I want to say, so instead, I cross my arms over my chest and huff indignantly. "Have you ever thought that maybe what you're doing is the exact reason Alex's future turns out the way it does?"
"Excuse me?" he asks in an insulted snarl.
No sex-ed, no friends, no real freedom to travel where she wants. Come on, Ben. That's. . . that's. . . well, shit. That's me. You don't want Alex to end up like me! It's a struggle not to yell. "I'm shocked you don't see how this is a recipe for disaster. First boy her age she comes across is going to give her the Tarzan effect. That's not even taking into consideration all the outwardly innocent but definitely not innocent activities kids are up to nowadays. . . like Netflix and Chill."
"I swear I only ever understand a fraction of what comes out of your mouth."
"Okay," I snap, "so here's a simple question. Do you want Alex to be happy?"
"I want her to be alive."
"Good," I say, smiling. "We can finally agree on something."
I find Alex headed my way towards the beach, dressed in the same pants and shirt from yesterday. I almost get distracted and forget my plan when I notice the young women linking arms on either side of her are also dressed in normal street clothes. All the pure joy in Alex's smile saps out of her at the sight of me running towards her.
"Girls," I hiss. "Girls! Come here, quick!"
Alex and her friends hurry over to meet me as I sprint up the hill out of breath. "Ben's here," I tell her in a sharp whisper. "Just landed at the docks. He'll be up here any minute, and we both know you'll get dragged back to the mainland if he sees you."
Alex's face quickly drains of color. "Dad's here?"
I look behind me to check, and then I fix her with wide eyes. "You girls need to head to the Hall of Freyja. Right now."
"Yeah, she's right," Hazel whispers. "Luna and Pris won't let any man inside. We'll be safe there. Come on, Alex. We'll show you. Thank you, lady Cora!"
"Yes," they all whisper in unison, "thank you, lady Cora."
"Go," I tell Alex. She's completely frozen in place at the thought of suffering the consequences for disobeying Ben's orders. "Go, Alex, I'll talk to him for you. Just go. Look, here he comes! Girls, get her out of here. I'll come get you when he leaves."
I watch as they tug Alex into the town center towards the hall. It isn't until after the group has disappeared into the building that I turn around to meet Ben.
"Ha," I whisper. "Gail doesn't know what she's talking about. They totally bought my act."
I watch his brows draw closer together, but he never ends up truly frowning as he stares off in the direction of my hall. "I have your word this will work?"
"Go home and be thankful she's listened to you this far." His brows crease together even more, and I backpedal. "Trust me, if there's one thing I'm good at, it's taking care of my—" I cut myself off before I say sisters. "Just trust me. I've got it from here." I thought my plan was infinitely better than his, but he still looks unsure. "Please, Ben. Who's she going to believe? Her dad? Or the literal Goddess of Love?"
It looks like his small nod is both reluctant and irritated. "I expect regular updates."
"Sure thing. No, wait," I add when he turns and starts heading back to the docks. "Actually, I have a delivery I need you to take back for me. One second." I turn and hurry down the path to the empty longhouse, past the long tables and benches and firepits, and step into my bedroom to grab the jar of strawberry jam off my desk. I didn't expect him to follow me, but he's there when I turn around. "Here," I say and hand him the jar. "Can you please give this to Jane?"
"Is this from you?"
No, and neither is the note I tied to the lid. "Yeah," I lie.
"Mm-hm." Ben turns the jar around in his hand. "Why do I have the suspicion I'm being roped into your meddling? I'm on Jane's bad side as it is."
"Ugh, fine. I'll give it to Jane." As soon as I extend my arm to snatch it back, Ben reaches up and holds it just out of my reach. It's comedic, in a way. This is something my much taller sisters used to do all the time, but thinking of my sisters just makes me homesick, so my voice comes out flat and irritated. "What are you, five?"
Even through the purplish-yellow bruises covering most of his face, I can tell he's pleased with himself. "I never said I wouldn't deliver it."
I reach for the jar again, but it's useless, and I can feel the frustration building up. "Would you just give it back?"
A sharp metallic clank echoes in the room, and Ben takes a quick step backwards. Someone just loaded a gun.
"Is he bothering you, my lady?" The voice isn't familiar, and neither are the faces of the two angry women casually holding rifles just barely pointed at the ground. "We saw him follow you in here. Everything alright?"
"Yes, everything's fine," I say quickly and hold up a hand in reflex. Please don't shoot him. Ben lowers his arm, and I glance at the jar still clutched tightly in his hand. "I asked him to deliver something to the mainland for me." My eyes travel up and lock with his. "He was just leaving."
Ben nods once in agreement and turns to address the women. "I'm docked at the south shore."
The angrier of the two smiles, still frowning with her brows. "Then we'll make sure he gets there safely." At the last minute, as Ben is passing through the doorway, I watch as the woman not so subtly thwack him hard in the back of the legs.
What a mess. I grab my notebook and scribble all of the plans I have to keep Alex safe from her current lethal future. Maybe I should let her stew a little. It'll make the impact of this situation even more unforgettable. I find a bowl of cashews and stay in my bedroom munching away until they're all gone. Then I start heading to the Hall, making sure not to stare too long at the naked art on the walls.
That should be enough time spent worrying. I'll look like a hero giving Alex the news she can stay on Hydra, and then she'll—
From out of a circle of women, Alex spots me in the flickering candlelight and waves excitedly.
"Oh. . . my. . . God. . .what, what, ahhh, uhhhh. . ." I can't seem to form a coherent sentence as I hurry towards her and reach out to brush my fingers against the side of her freshly shaved head. "You cut your hair?"
"Yeah, we all did." Alex looks around at the group who nod encouragly. Each of the young women she'd been hanging out with—including Annie's daughters—all have various shaved hairstyles. "Why?" I watch her entire expression drop as she reaches up to feel the large triangular undercut by her ear. "Does it look bad?"
All of the nearby women fall silent, waiting for me to assess their work. My already panicked smile widens until I can't feel my face anymore. "No, it. . . looks. . . awesome," I finally get out in a strangled high-pitched whine, which the girls mistake for excited praise. As they talk amongst each other, I sink into the closest seat. She shaved half her head. Half her head is bald. What the hell? She's been gone for, what? An hour? "Girls? I need to talk to Alex for a second. Can you wait outside, please? It's just hair," I muse aloud, trying to calm myself down. It's not permanent. It'll grow back. It's fine.
"It looks bad, doesn't it?" Alex's entire being deflates. "Does my tattoo at least look okay? I got your rune."
Every inch of my body prickles painfully with a debilitating rush of fear. "Your. . . tattoo?" Alex pulls up her sleeve to reveal a patch of reddened skin surrounding a dark black rune of some sort. I can't stop blinking. When I open my mouth, all that comes out is a pained groan. This is a joke. This has to be a joke. Someone is messing with me. Maybe it's a henna tattoo? "Is that real?"
"Mm-hm. I've wanted a tattoo for years now, but all the best artists were on Hydra." Alex covers the slightly bloody lines with her shirt sleeve and takes a seat next to me. "Are you okay? I thought the tattoo came out pretty good."
"No, it's not that. . ." My brain is scrambled. Ben is going to kill me. Alex hasn't even been in my care a full 24 hours and she's already made her way through several Norse initiations. I haven't even had the chance to talk to her yet. "I talked to Ben."
Alex immediately straightens in her seat. "What'd he say? Is he gone? Do I have to go back?"
"No," I answer and finally look her in the eye. "I told him you were safe here with me, and he legally can't take you back if you don't want to go. Just. . . can you promise me one thing?"
"Anything," she quickly answers.
"The next time you and the girls want to do something. . . awesome, can you invite me?"
I sit at my desk—franticly swiping away sweat from my forehead—and crumple a dozen papers before thinking of the perfect icebreaker.
I know you just left, but I'm checking in that the mainland isn't on fire or anything. Also, do you have any strong opinions about tattoos?
I crumple up the paper and fling it across the room into the fireplace.
Any mainland problems I should know about? Alex is doing well here. She seems happier than I've seen her yet. I'm working on the plan we discussed. Nothing really to report on that end, but I'll let you know when there is.
The paper smashes up into a tight little ball in my clenched fist as I start a new note. In the end, I'm too much of a coward to tell the truth.
I forgot to ask about your spinal x-rays. What were the results? Also, any opposition to tattoos? I'm considering getting one.—Cora
I ask a nice woman carrying a baby on her back where I can find the ravens used to send letters to the mainland, and she insists on taking me directly to the aviary. Inside, I find Loki.
"Good, it makes my life easier that you speak raven." Loki hops down off his perch and lands on my shoulder. "You want me to deliver it to who?"
"Ben, please."
"Figures. Most all the mail here goes to that house. Alright," he agrees with a click of his beak. "I require payment in full if you receive a response."
"Okay." I shrug. "What do you want?"
"What are you offering?"
We eventually settle on raisins. I roll up the message, tuck it into the cute little holster belted to his leg, and he whooshes into the sky in a flurry of black feathers.
"What on earth has you so fidgety?" Gail crosses my bedroom and starts unbraiding my hair. "You haven't been able to sit still since dinner."
As if on cue, Loki flaps into the room, calling, "Letter from Ben!"
Loki pecks happily at the raisins I piled on my desk for him while I unroll the message as quickly as I can.
I'm happy to report there is absolutely nothing wrong with my spine. You're either a faulty seer, or you saw so far into the future I won't have to worry about it until I'm too old to care. And as to your other question: I can't be opposed to tattoos, considering I have two. My only suggestion would be to get anything except your own rune. That would be tacky.—Ben
I haven't even finished reading before I start laughing with relief. He has a tattoo. Two tattoos. Even if he does get angry about Alex, I can at least call him a hypocrite. "Oh, thank God." I sink back into my seat at the desk and take a fresh slip of paper.
You have two tattoos? Where?
It's only a few minutes before Loki returns with the message: Not in any places you're allowed to see.
"Are you going to keep me in suspense, or are you going to tell me who you're talking to?"
In my paranoia to shield the message from Gail, I crumble it up in my fist and turn to fix her with a tense smile. "It's nothing." I know she knows I'm lying, but that doesn't stop me from saying, "Just checking in on the mainland."
At the end of the week, I'm left lamenting the fact that this hasn't felt like a vacation at all.
Not only have the female survivors taken every opportunity to complain to me about their living conditions and general confusion as to what's going on, but my plan to watch over Alex hasn't been quite the success I had originally hoped.
The plan was simple and straightforward. As the literal goddess of love, I was going to wheedle my way into Alex's friend group and, after securing myself as a formidable source of relationship advice, convince her to consult me in all romantic endeavors. But it's been almost six whole days of spying on her because I never got an invite to any of their activities. Good news is she hasn't gotten any more tattoos or attempted to get piercings or any other body modification. She and her friends have gone surfing, practiced some songs as a band, and gossiped. A lot.
But surprisingly not about boys. Not that girls should spend all their time talking about boys, but teenage girls who spend none of their time discussing the opposite sex? It's left me confused.
I'm headed back to my bedroom after yet another day of keeping my eye on Alex from far away on the sidelines. I got cheated out of a vacation. Instead of relaxing, I got stuck babysitting. I technically volunteered to babysit her. What a load of crock.
A thought occurs to me as I wade through a patch of tall grass. I haven't heard from Ben all day. He's usually sent an update request by now. I bet there's a letter waiting for me in my room.
A chill wind kisses my exposed arms and the back of my neck, and I shiver with goosebumps. Island days are hot and muggy, but the night air is cool and refreshing after sweating for hours and hours. Best of all, there doesn't seem to be any birds on Hydra because all I hear in the fading light are the various chirps and clicks of bugs. A small blessing.
All seems a little more peaceful in its simplicity until a canvas bag is tugged completely over my head.
Chapter 14: The Naked Truth And All That Comes After
Chapter Text
DHARMA, 1977
They don't think I can hear them, but that's not completely true. I hear bits and pieces through the ringing in my ears.
"It's no use," a man echoes in the fog. "Leave him alone. The boy's brain is busted."
"You do realize when they find out Cora's dead, his testimony won't matter anyway. She was the only thing stopping them from going postal on this compound."
"What are we supposed to do? He has to know something."
"Let me talk to him," a female voice offers.
Warm fingers touch my arm, and I immediately twitch away from them.
All at once I see her. She's standing in the moonlight, hunched, immobile. A chunk of red meat slides down her soaked hair and lands at her feet in the dead grass. All I want is to stand and run away, but my body won't move. She's screaming. Miss Collins is screaming with a sharp intensity of something inhuman as thick strings of blood dangle from her mouth, and all I can do is shut my eyes and pray these screams don't make my head explode. I don't want to die.
"See?" the man says, his voice muffled by the hands I've pressed tightly against my ears. "I told you. The lights are on but nobody's home. And that's not going to change anytime soon. Leave him be. We have other fish to fry."
I don't know how long I've been locked in this room when the Norsemen fling open the door. I close my eyes and focus on breathing. Beheading doesn't hurt, right?
Because that's what this is about. Everyone thinks I killed Miss Collins—everyone thinks I killed Freyja—and now her people are here to dispose of me.
"So. . . you're Ben, hm?"
I open my eyes, surprised to find the question has come from a female Norseman.
"Speak up," she snaps. "Are you Benjamin Linus?" I nod, and she narrows her eyes into angry little slits. "You need to come with me."
"Where are you taking him?" LaFluer asks as soon as we step out of the room. "Gail, where are you taking him?"
Gail's lip curls when LaFluer reaches for her arm, but he never has the chance to make contact. One of the Norsemen hits him hard in the stomach, and the rest of the people in the room—all members of the Initiative—shrink away from the enormous men.
I want to ask where we're going. I want to ask what they're going to do to me. I want to beg them to believe I didn't kill Miss Collins.
Instead, I press my lips tightly together as I follow the angry woman called Gail and a group of bodyguards out of the barracks and into the jungle. I keep waiting for the moment they force me to kneel so they can hack my body to pieces or whatever it is they plan to do to me, but the next time someone speaks, she sounds very, very old.
I'm in some kind of stone fortress, surrounded by men and women whose eyes never leave me as they lean into one another and whisper things I cannot understand. Gail grabs hold of my shirt and roughly pulls me alongside her down a stone hallway and into a high-ceilinged room.
An old woman sits on a wooden throne near a fireplace in the corner, her eyes obscured by a strip of cloth. When she speaks, those in the room immediately fall silent. "Do you know who I am, Benjamin?"
I take in her clothing and jewelry and the fact that she's seemingly blind. "A seer?"
She moves slow, bowing her head only a fraction to indicate I've guessed correctly. "And do you know what that means?"
I don't understand. Are they not going to behead me? Isn't that why they've marched me out here to their Temple?
I shake my head no in answer to her question, but when she doesn't respond, I assume this confirms she is, in fact, blind. "No," I say.
"It means we have much to discuss. Step forward." Slowly, the old woman extends her spindly fingers to me in offering. "Take my hands, child."
"ARE YOU INSANE?" I hear Alex scream at the top of her lungs. In one rough movement, the sack is yanked off my head almost as quickly as it was yanked on. "She could have accidentally killed you!"
I suck in lungfuls of night air and take an unsteady step back with a hand against my throat. A small group of girls stand sheepishly nearby as Alex continues scolding them. Normally, their fear would embarrass me into silence, but I'm running on dangerously high levels of adrenaline and can't seem to stop muttering hallelujahs at the fact that I'm not about to be asphyxiated to death.
"I told you we weren't doing the kidnapping," Alex continues, stopping only when one of Annie's daughters stumbles into view and asks what happened. "They put a bag over her head!" Alex holds up the offending square of cloth, and now Annie's older daughters have jumped into the outrage mob.
The group of much younger girls all stare, chastised, at the ground. To their credit, they do look beyond remorseful. But then again, remorse means nothing if you're dead. Throwing a bag over my head to fulfill some kind of bachelorette kidnapping ritual was about as close as you can get to suicide.
It's only a matter of time before fully grown women wander over to hear what all the screaming is about. A few of them storm forward to claim their shame-riddled daughters staring holes into the jungle dirt. When Annie emerges, asking what's wrong, I realize I'm trembling.
"What happened?" she demands, pushing through the crowd of onlookers. Her attention immediately focuses on her daughters. "What did you do?"
I thought I was going to die. I thought someone was trying to strangle me to death. "They threw a bag over my head," I finally answer.
For all the screaming Annie's daughters did, Annie is even more terrifying. I take a step back, both frightened and embarrassed on their behalf. I don't know exactly what she's saying in Norse, but from the look on their faces as they try to explain they weren't the ones who did it, I can make an educated guess. When all the young women have shuffled out of sight, Annie turns her attention to me. "Are you hurt, Cora?"
"No. I'm fine." That's not the problem. Pressure builds in my finger joints. I flex them out of their tight fists. Despite my efforts, my voice comes out breathy and unstable. "I could have accidentally hurt them. I didn't know what was happening, and I could have hurt them."
Annie looks and sounds beyond exhausted when she says, "I cannot apologize enough. I don't know what to say, my lady. They know better than this."
"What on earth is going on?" Gail emerges from out of the chattering crowd and makes a beeline for me.
"I'm fine," I answer before she can ask. "I'm not hurt."
"It was my four," Annie grumbles, heavy lidded and monotone. "For some reason they got it in their heads that the Idun Ritual was an appropriate use of the goddesses evening. Flint and Peregrine weren't with them, but I'm sure they also had something to do with it." Annie fills Gail in on what happened while I focus on breathing. Both my hands are still shaking from nerves. "I just can't believe your last day here ended on such a sour note," Annie concludes, and I snap back to attention to find her staring at me.
"Hm? Oh, no, that's okay." It's not like my week's stay here had been relaxing anyway. I shrug. "They're just kids. I remember what it was like to have—" I bend my fingers into air-quotes. "—'great ideas' when I was their age."
A woman steps up and says something to Annie, who brightens a little at the suggestion. "Cora, if your night hasn't been irrevocably ruined, we have a way to make it up to you."
It's not a cold night by any means, but the breeze is cooler than it was when the sun was out. Salty ocean air wafts over from the shoreline in the distance, mixing with the thicker air in this partial cave. I watch vibrant ripples sparkle against the rock wall at the far end of the pool and wonder why everyone was so excited to make the hike out here. “So,” I ask, “it's like a natural jacuzzi?"
The woman nearest me asks, "What's a jacuzzi?"
"Oh, uh, it's like. . . it makes the water really warm."
"Yes," she answers, "it's like a jacuzzi. The volcano heats up the water."
"Ugh," Annie groans, "what a day."
I turn to give her a sympathetic smile and immediately avert my eyes, my skin already blistering with embarrassment. Annie, Charlotte, Charlotte's three sisters, Poppy, and two older women I just met—Maya and Olivia—have undressed in a matter of seconds and stand completely naked in the faint moonlight. One by one, still chatting, they settle into the warm pool with little more than a splash. It's a second before they realize I'm not amongst them.
"Everything alright, lady Cora?"
I don't know who asked. All I know is I want to go to sleep.
"Sorry I took so long." It is a blessing to hear Gail's voice. "I figured you ladies would want a little something special after the week it's been."
"Gail to the rescue," one of Charlotte's sisters cheers. "To all our hard work almost being done!" Cheering in unison, the women pass around a canteen full of what I'm assuming is alcohol.
When the canister makes its round back to shore—where I've taken a seat at the rocks edge—I wave away the offer to take a swig. "No, thank you. I'm good."
"Don't force her," Maya says, stretching both arms up above her head in such a fashion that both of her massive breasts bob in and out of the water. "She'll have plenty of time to drink at the wedding."
Gail takes a seat next to me on the ledge. "Are you not getting in?"
How are they so comfortable being naked in front of each other? With nothing to hold their drooping breasts up? Nothing to hide their stomachs? I wouldn't get in that pool even if I had a swimsuit on. I shake my head, roll up my pant legs a little, and stick my feet in the warm water.
It's nice hearing stories from the eight of them. The older married women spend their time coaching Poppy, who is newly engaged and looks slightly terrified by their advice. But as the night carries on, their alcohol intake begins to show more and more prominently until their conversations leave me searching for a way to quietly leave.
"—not to mention I didn't have the best sex of my life until after I gave birth to our first child. It was like he turned into a beast."
I tune back into the conversation at this particular moment and wonder how I haven't succumbed to dehydration from the amount of water I'm losing through all my embarrassed sweat.
"The trick is to train him as soon as you're married, or he'll never learn," Olivia adds. "Poppy, dear, I'm going to let you in on a little secret. It's all in the hands." Olivia raises her hands and wiggles her fingers in emphasis. "Don't you let him try and convince you otherwise."
I make the mistake of locking eyes with Maya, who brightens up and swims closer to my sanctuary on the rock. "Quiet, you old fools! We're leaving out the real storyteller." Maya waves over the visibly drunk women to where she's made herself comfortable at my right side. "Tell us, goddess."
I must look insane with how wide my nervous smile is. "Tell you what?"
"Tell us about your best lover," Charlotte clarifies, promptly dissolving into a fit of laughter. "Out of all of them, surely there was one worthy of a story."
I'm surrounded by horny, naked middle-aged women who whole-heartedly believe that I'm the goddess of fertility and are patiently waiting for me to recount a life event in which I do not have experience. "Ohhhh," I exclaim, as if I just now understood what she's asking for. "You. . . you meant the best. Haha. Out of all of them? Ahhh, there's so many…" I choke a cough to stall for time. "Uh, okay, uh. . . let me see. . ." I am going to blackout from heat exhaustion. "Oh, I don't know? I, um—" I'm so mortified by this conversation I cannot even think up a fake name. "I can’t choose.”
"Boooooo," Charlotte complains and splashes me with a dainty kick of her foot, much to the others amusement.
"Oh, come on. I bet you have some wild stories, Cora." Maya laughs, nudging my arm. She's almost completely out of the water, and I can clearly see her exposed chest, but she doesn't seem to care. "Don't hold out on us. We've only been alive a few decades. Won't take much to surprise these old coots."
"Speak for yourself," Olivia snaps, and they all break out into laughter again.
I'm laughing along with them just to keep from blacking out. Sweat rolls down from my hairline and into my eyes as I try to furiously blink it away. I just want to go to sleep. They're going to keep asking, and then they're going to start getting suspicious as to why I'm so uncomfortable. Just make up a story. You've seen plenty of movies and shows with sex scenes. Use one of those!
"Wait," I exclaim randomly, suddenly remembering an unsolicited story my old roommate told me the morning after a wild night out. I didn't think it was an especially spicy retelling, but by the end of it, you'd have thought I'd just introduced Fifty Shades of Grey to an Amish parish.
"Well," Maya exclaims, breaking the bewildered silence, "that's certainly one way to get the job done."
Poppy looks like she's about to be sick. "I don't understand. What was all the bread for?"
"This lover of yours," asks Charlotte. "Was he from Earth or Asgard?"
This plan is massively backfiring. I just wanted them to stop asking me questions, but it's just emboldened them to ask more. "Earth," I answer and clap my hands together, smiling. "I'm so sorry everyone, but I'm exhausted. I think I'm going to call it a night."
One of Charlotte's sisters swims closer and grabs my ankle. "Oh, please stay! Tell us another story."
I desperately look at Gail for help.
Gail's lip curls up on one side in a reluctant grin. "You lot would spend all night gossiping about sex if you had it your way."
"Nothing wrong with that," says Maya.
"How do you think we have kids?" asks Olivia.
"How do you think we have fun?" Maya adds, and the women break out into more laughter.
One second they're all laughing, and then in the blink of an eye they've surrounded Annie, who randomly bursts into tears.
"Her husband died on the mainland a little over a year ago," Gail whispers as the drunken group continues to console Annie. "Poor thing. Widowed far too young."
"You have your girls," Maya soothes, moving tangled strands of Annie's hair out of her face and wailing mouth. "Those beautiful spirited girls. They remind me so much of Ragnar."
A memory snaps to the forefront, and I blurt out, "Your husband's name was Ragnar?"
And just like that, sixteen pairs of watery, slightly bloodshot eyes are staring at me.
Annie stops crying with one final sniffle, fixing me with what looks like desperation. "You've met him?"
I thought it was a dream. It felt very much like a dream. Maybe that's what dying is. "Tall man. Really hairy arms. Bright red hair. Long beard with silver beads in it." I recall all the details I remember from my conversation with the man on the boat—the man I spoke to when I was dead. "Wait. . . if you're his wife, then who is Hazel?"
Annie, drunk as she is, seems to have sobered up at record speeds. "My eldest." Breaking away from Maya's embrace, she floats up to where my legs dangle into the water and stares at me like I'm the answer to all her problems. "What did he say about Hazel? Did. . . did you talk to him recently? Was he well?"
"He wanted me to tell Hazel something." I try to remember exactly what he said. "He wanted me to tell her that he would have done it a thousand times over again."
It's as if she's been slapped. One look at her crumbling face, and I know there's nothing I can do or say to make this easier for her. I feel a hand on my shoulder.
"Let's get you to bed," says Gail solemnly. "They'll take care of Annie. You need all the rest you can get, Cora. We have a long day ahead of us tomorrow."
I should have expected it, all things considered, but it still surprises me when a small crowd amasses outside the Dharma locker room. It was a huge relief to know that they use regular showers here and won't expect me to skinny dip every time I want to wash up.
There was nobody outside the locker room when I entered, but there's a small crowd now. Gossip passes unreasonably fast here.
The women are quiet but desperate. They ask me questions about their dead loved ones with so much hope in their eyes that I just start making things up. Yes, I spoke with your father and he's very proud of you. Yes, your mother thinks you're doing a great job with the kids. Your aunt—oh, great aunt? Yes, your great aunt says hello.
One woman emerges from the crowd, who graciously step aside to let her through to the front. Just like the other women, she bows. Unlike the other women, she grabs hold of my hand and holds tight. "Lady Cora, did you by chance meet with my daughter, Clover?
"What did she look like?"
I can't help but smile as the woman's face settles into blissful memory. "You would have remembered her. She was the most beautiful creature that ever breathed air."
There was a child on the ship with Ragnar and a handful of other adults. Maybe that was this woman's daughter? "How old was she when she passed?"
"Three months, my lady."
I suddenly can't swallow. Her answer makes all the hairs on my body stand on end. A baby. She lost a baby. There wasn't a baby on the ship. What does that mean? Do babies get a straight shot into the afterlife? Was she not on the ship because babies don't have unfinished business? Where is this woman's baby?
"I. . ." I don't know what to say. All I know is I have the power to lessen this woman's pain, and I therefore have a responsibility to do so. "I did see her," I lie. Squeezing her hand and forcing a smile, I tell her, "She's absolutely perfect."
It isn't until hours later—after I've locked my door and settled into bed, cradling Fenrir and Pumba to my chest—that I allow the tears to come.
Gail and I don't leave Hydra until well past sunrise, so it is midday when I first spot the camouflaged stonewall surrounding the Temple. The aged barrier is cloaked in layers of vine and overgrown trees. Tiny white blossoms sprout from the top of one of the plants hiding the sanctuary, and I have the strangest urge to pluck them and stick them in my hair. I think the women of Hydra are starting to rub off on me.
"Lady Cora!" A man appears out of thin air, waving me forward from an opening in the stone. "Please, come in. Thank you again for agreeing to this."
"Agreeing to what?" I whisper in Gail's direction.
"His son's coming-of-age ceremony," she answers under her breath.
"Oh," I say at full volume, "yes, you're very welcome. . . what's his name," I add in a whisper. My eyes widen when Gail whispers the answer. "Your name's Eomer?" He looks over his shoulder at me with a confused raise of his eyebrows, so I say, "That's fantastic!" As if that somehow clarifies why I would be fangirling over his name. I keep my mouth clamped shut to keep from rambling about how much I love Rohan. Poor guy looks confused enough.
After he's led us inside, the man turns, clasps my hands in his own, and bows his head until his forehead touches my rapidly sweating fingers. "As honored as my boy is, know that it pales in comparison to the pride I take in knowing you'll be here in person to witness his accession to manhood."
I nod and smile and try not to come across as confused as I am. Satisfied, he leaves with one final bow.
"It is tradition that the groom stays at the Temple before the wedding," Gail explains. With one hand on my shoulder, she ushers me further inside with a quick glance around. "Brides stay on Hydra. But I thought it best if you partake in both ceremonies. Get to know your people better. Refresh your memory, so to speak."
We duck under a low stone doorway, and then I stand, motionless, taking it all in. I marvel at how the Temple is like the Tardis; it is much, much bigger on the inside.
For as far as my eyes can see, the Temple grounds are crowded with high arched buildings— some without solid walls. Open air streams through what looks like giant gazebos made of rock. Inside the shelters, great walls of stone stand chiseled into elegant depictions of stories long past by. Everything curves and flows in a harmonious rhythm, like a stream of water down a hillside. Flowers and vines latch onto anything and everything they can grasp. All of the doorways are covered in runes.
I aimlessly wander further into the grounds without listening to whatever it is Gail's trying to tell me. A massive waterfall crashes down from the side of a mountain and pools into a glimmering pond. An elephant stands knee deep in the pool, spouting water out its trunk at a pair of swans, who bob around, swimming just out of reach of the water war. I listen to them honk threats in annoyance.
I sense Gail walk up beside me, but I can't look away from this mesmerizing place when I say, "Please tell me I had everything to do with this."
"Most," Ben answers, "but not everything."
It's not the fact that he's here that startles me. It's the fact that I was expecting Gail's voice that makes me cry out in alarm and flinch away at the sight of him.
"I'm flattered, truly." Ben quirks an eyebrow, but his amused expression quickly flatlines at the sight of Gail huffing her way over. Now it's Ben's turn to flinch away as she wags a finger in his face and chastises him not in Norse, but in French. "How is that my fault?" He sounds both insulted and confused as Gail continues her tirade. "I only just got here," he argues in English, but Gail has apparently made her point.
Abruptly, she spins and fixes me with a disapproving frown. "And how many times must I tell you to stop slouching!"
I've never snapped my spine to attention so fast in my life.
Without another word, Gail turns and hurries down a stone staircase leading into oblivion. I hesitate a second too long to follow her, and then she's gone, leaving the both of us standing around in the awkward silence that accompanies parental thrashings.
I hear Ben clear his throat. "How's Alex?"
"Good," I say. "Safe. Annie's keeping an eye on her while I'm away."
"Good." He nods in approval. "Good."
When it's obvious he's not going to speak again, I ask, "What's with the French?"
"For privacy. Your people don't speak French," he snaps as if it's obvious. "And neither do you."
"Hey, I'm not the one that just yelled at you in front of your friends. Don't take this out on me."
I prepare myself for a snide remark. Instead, he says, "You're right. I'm sorry."
He looks so tired, I feel bad for him. "That's okay. I think you need a vacation," I pause and lower my voice for dramatic effect, "from Gail."
Ben huffs a small laugh. "If only."
There's a weird energy around him that doesn't match his previous moods. It's as if he's losing the will to play pretend but hasn't quite given up yet. I take note of his exhaustion while his attention wanders elsewhere, and the question comes tumbling out. "Ben?"
He snaps his head up and plasters on a fake smile. "Hm?"
"Are you okay?"
By the amount of times he blinks at me, I seem to have caught him off guard. "Why would you think otherwise?"
"Do you want me to be nice or honest?"
"My day could not possibly get worse." Ben sighs heavily and motions with a hand for me to continue. "Give it to me straight."
"You look. . . slightly deranged."
"Please, don't hold back. I can take it."
I'd laugh if a thought didn't just hit me and suck all of the humor out of the situation. "What are you worried about?"
It is this question that finally gets him to look directly at me. "Pardon?"
"You're not sleeping. Your plan worked, but you're still worried about something. You being stressed out is stressing me out. Is it something I can help with?"
Whatever it is that's causing his insomnia, it's clear he has no interest in talking to me about it. He battles with a few responses before answering, "No, you can't help. Don't worry about me. I've never been very good at staying asleep." Before I can press him further, he nods at the bag I packed for tomorrows scavenger hunt. "I'll let you unpack."
"Oh." I shrug off the bag and then immediately put it back on and tug on the straps. I can't seem to figure out what to do with my hands. "Um. . . you wouldn't happen to know where I'm staying, do you? I have no idea where Gail went."
"I take it you have no memory of the Temple layout?"
"None whatsoever."
"Might as well give you the grand tour then," he says and turns to begin his descent down a flight of stairs. I follow, surprised that they snake back up into the light, then wind even higher up into a maze of hallways going who knows where. As confusing as it is, the pathways are all open to the warm air. Every inch of the doorways and archways and columns are carved into painstakingly intricate designs. Long painted murals stretch from one hallway to the next, depicting everything from parties to battles.
"I think I might have just changed my mind." I look over at Ben when he doesn't respond. "About staying on Hydra forever."
"Is the Temple not what you expected?"
"I didn't expect it to be beautiful. I mean, people like Erik don't exactly strike me as a lover of art or gardening. But this place. . ." I spin around to better see the detailing carved into the stone. "It gives Hydra a run for its money. Oh." A rush of blood warms my cheeks as I remember the horrifying statue in the Hall of Freyja. "Um. So, all of this art. . . I mean, just to confirm. Uh. There aren't any. . ."
"Any?"
Just say it. "There aren't any, uh, inappropriate paintings of me here, are there? Or statues? Or carvings? Or. . . anything?"
I can't tell for sure, but it looks like he's enjoying himself when he asks, "Can you please clarify what you mean by inappropriate?"
"Inappropriate," I repeat stupidly. "You know. . . indecent?"
"Are you asking me if your people have painted naked pictures of you on the walls? We haven't gotten to that wing yet. Don't worry, you won't be disappointed." Ben steps around me to continue down the hallway then stops to glance at me over his shoulder. "I'm kidding," he adds with a smirk.
It's so easy to get lost here—pun intended, I guess—so I trail closely behind Ben as he leads me down yet another gallery. He's thus far obliged my slower pace so I can marvel at all the art, but he also seems impatient to escort me to my room so he can be rid of me, presumably to take a well needed nap.
I take in the nearest mural a while longer, and then turn back to make sure Ben hasn't taken off without me. Not only has he not abandoned me, but he's standing so close I almost bump into him. His intense eyes flick from me to the mural behind me. "That was always my personal favorite. But I'm biased."
His proximity makes me stifle a nervous laugh. "Biased how?" It's a stunning piece of art. I'm sure if Charlotte had still grown up an anthropologist, she'd be drooling all over this. I point at a painting of a tiny mouse with a jagged tail. "Why does this look like Pikachu?" As soon as I say it, I realize he has no idea what Pokemon is.
"That is Pikachu," Ben answers. "This mural is nothing but Pokemon. Take a step back, you probably can't see from that close."
Standing behind me, with one gentle hand on either of my shoulders, he guides me backwards away from the wall until I see what he means about the mural. I try to measure my breathing to keep the fact that he's touching me from sending me down a spiral of anxiety, but it's like my entire body is suddenly aware of itself for the first time. I've never actually been this physically close to someone who wasn't my siblings.
I wait for him to let go of my shoulders or move from directly behind me, but his hands slowly slide down my arms until he has my right hand in his. Each motion drags on for an eternity. Deliberate. A caress. He folds all of my fingers into a loose fist, except for my pointer finger, which he guides up to aim at one of the drawings.
"I painted that one." Ben leans down close to my ear, cradling his face in the crook of my neck, his voice low as he says, "Do you like it?"
Before this moment, I would have thought being in this situation would have been exhilarating or hot. I've been waiting what feels like my whole life to have someone pay me attention like this. But here, now, actually experiencing what feels very much like seduction, I feel nothing but a deep, painful nausea.
"Lady Cora?"
At the sound of the man's voice, I break out of my panicked coma and step away from Ben. A small enough step to seem inconspicuous, but far enough away that his hands lose their grip on me and fall reluctantly to his sides.
"I'm sorry," the man says, "I didn't mean to intrude."
"You're not." I'm all smiles, coughing a few times into my arm to stave off the uncontrollable laughter that had been building up. "What do you need?"
He looks familiar—beyond the fact that he's the norseman who I spoke to while he was guarding the survivors. I've met him before, but that's not how he feels familiar. It's something more than that, I just don't know what. He's easily two shades darker than the other norsemen, with a thinner build and more angular face. While not all of the norsemen are blonde or redheaded, they tend to have lighter shades of brown hair. I haven't met any with black hair, but this man has thick black waves tied up tight in a ponytail. He is, quite literally, the odd one out in this community.
"I was hoping to speak to you," he asks. "Privately," he adds with a knowing look towards Ben.
Ben mutters something in Norse. "Really?" he adds snidely in English. "You're going to do this now? It can't wait a few more days?"
"I don't see why that's a problem," the norseman responds with resolve. "I cleared it with Gail."
I can't make myself look over at Ben, but I hear him exhale slowly through his nose. "Alright. Show her to her room when you're done."
I stare at the ground, face enflaming, and wait for the norseman to gesture for me to follow him down some stairs into a beautiful grassy hillside near the water.
Sitting in the grass calms me somewhat. Enough, apparently, to help me remember this man's name. I remember at the time I thought it was funny that there was a Viking named Chris. "Christopher, right?"
He nods—seeming sad and happy all at the same time—and takes a hesitant seat beside me. "I'm sorry for not reaching out sooner. I just. . . wasn't sure when the right time would be."
"Was it a parent? Grandparent?"
Christopher tilts his head in confusion. "What?"
"I'm assuming you want to know about someone in your family who died. I've probably spoken to them recently. Who was it?"
Judging by the look on his face, I've guessed his request correctly. "My mother."
"What was her name?"
"I'm not. . . that's not what I. . . sorry. I should have sought you out earlier." He lifts a hand to swipe at some hair that's escaped his hairband. "Forgive me. I'm a little nervous."
Well, great. Now I'm nervous. “That’s okay! What is it you need?"
"It's about my daughter," he answers after a long pause. "She's. . . she's been waiting to meet you since she was old enough to understand who you are. All she's been talking about since your rebirth is how much she wants to meet you. But," he continues with a small sigh, "for obvious reasons, your attentions have been occupied elsewhere. She's very shy. Even if there were moments where you were alone, she wouldn't have reached out without me there. And I've been detained here on official business for quite a while so—" He's rambling faster and faster with a growing sense of anxiety.
I smile with relief at his request. Why is he acting like this was a big deal? "You want me to talk to your daughter. Hang out for a while, just the two of us? Calm down, Chris. That's not a big ask. What's her name? I'll speak with her first thing when I return to Hydra."
"Freyja," he answers after what seems like a lifetime. "I named her after her grandmother. I. . ." His whole body trembles slightly as he fights to keep still. "I hoped you'd be proud I passed down your name in our family."
I try to joke and put him more at ease. "Your mother's name was Freyja? I'm flattered. Although I'm surprised her parents were allowed to name her after me. Do you not have rules about naming your children after deities?"
"Well, yes, but," he answers softly, "but there. . ." He has to pause to collect himself before he can continue. "There has only ever been one Freyja before my daughter. Her's was not a blasphemous naming because it was for a direct descendant of the deity."
I can physically feel all the blood drain from my face. My eyes dart over his facial features—his dark eyes, long lashes, thick eyebrows and beard that doesn't grow much beyond his mouth and chin— desperately trying to process what he's saying. And that's when it hits me. I know why he looks so familiar. It's because he doesn't look Norse. He looks like my Sicilian relatives.
I can see in his eyes the moment he realizes I've figured out who he is. Christopher smiles with the same tinge of sadness as the women I spent all night consoling. In a quiet, almost breathy sigh, he says, "Hi mom."
Chapter 15: Literal And Metaphorical Closet Skeletons
Chapter Text
DHARMA, 1977
“Shhh,” Annie’s mom soothes. “Listen to me. Dad is going to be okay. He’s hiding. We need to worry about staying hidden. That’s all we need to worry about right now.”
“What if it finds him?” Annie whispers, barely audible over the rush of blood pounding in my ears. “What if—”
“Annie,” her mother interrupts sharply. “We need to stay hidden and stay silent. This is not up for discussion. Do you understand me? If that thing finds us—” Mrs. Freeman cuts herself off with a gasp, reflexively bringing up both her hands to cover her daughter’s mouth.
A biting chill flows into the room, bringing with it a flurry of snowflakes. Even the cement floor becomes so cold it feels like it’s burning my legs.
It just opened the door to the security room we’ve hidden in. It’s in here with us.
I couldn’t scream even if I wanted to. It’s so cold it feels like my sweat is freezing. Annie shivers violently in her mother’s arms, crouched under a desk. Mrs. Freeman closes her eyes and silently mouths what I assume is a prayer, both her hands still pressed tightly against Annie’s face to keep her from screaming. All I hear is the furious and frantic beating of my heart.
And then I hear the grinding of metal against the concrete floor. A long scrape, then stop. Scrape, then stop. Scrape, then stop. Whatever it is, it’s getting closer. It passes by our hiding spot and keeps going.
At the far end of the room, the monster rips open a drawer and throws it across the floor. Blank papers and assorted security documents float down near us. It is a lifetime before I allow myself to take a shaking, silent breath, the air fogging up like dragon smoke. Mrs. Freeman still has her eyes closed. I don’t know what compels me, but I lean just enough behind the desk to see where exactly the monster is. If it’s not paying attention, maybe we can make a run for the door.
In all the many possibilities I prepare myself for, nothing comes close to the truth. The monster that triggered the emergency alarms, the monster that Annie’s mother brought us here to hide from, the monster that has caused nothing but terrified screams outside the walls of our hiding place, is Miss Collins drenched in dirt and blood.
With one final metallic scrape, she pulls a large silver axe next to her and leans it up against the wall. She seems to be looking for something. Drawer after drawer, she flings papers and file cabinets around, muttering nonsense, hissing and snapping her jaw as blood runs down her chin and speckles the concrete. Her hair is impossibly long. It’s so long, in fact, that it it takes me a second to realize she’s naked.
I don’t understand what’s going on, but I know we need to get out of here.
Mrs. Freeman yanks me back behind the table so hard I hit my head. It's just a small thud. Only a second long. Barely audible over all the noise Freyja is making. But it’s enough.
We’re all three running frantic, up the stairs, taking two at a time, pushing wildly with all our might against the stubborn doors that always need oiling. I can hear the scraping of the axe behind us, getting closer. And then we are free. Panting in the frigid open air. Stumbling out onto the snowy grass. Stumbling out onto a pile of corpses.
Annie’s screaming. I don’t do anything but stare at half of someone’s body lying next to a slew of half-frozen organs. I count five dead people before my brain goes fuzzy. Annie stops screaming, but it’s only because she’s fainted. Mrs. Freeman struggles to lift her up into her arms and stumbles off in the snow towards her house. I wish I knew where my dad was. I wish he was the type of parent that would carry me away from danger.
A polar bear and its cub rip and tear at a dead women’s stomach, pausing when they realize I’m nearby. The mother—thick strings of blood dripping from her muzzle—lets out a terrifying roar and stalks towards me, no longer interested in the cold corpse. Then it stops, hunkering down at the sight of something behind me. But the excited polar bear cub scampers past me. Its roar is nothing more than a high-pitched whine.
My brain screams to run, but my legs won’t move. Instead, I turn and look at the outline of Miss Collins slowly shambling out of the doorway, dragging the axe behind her as the polar bear cub circles her legs.
I think of everything she’s taught us about the norsemen and their deities. There’s Odin, Thor and Loki, Baldr, Hel, and the rest. But these norsemen worshiped none of them to the degree they worshiped Freyja—goddess of love and babies and food. Goddess of both life and death. War and peace.
Miss Collins—Frejya—is peaceful. She spends her free time negotiating with the norsemen to keep the peace between them and the Initiative. None of this makes sense. She’s told me time and time again that all life is sacred, and now she’s gone and killed most of the compound.
Was this always a matter of time? She’s spent so long as the goddess of life she’s unable to hold back the death and destruction she’s denied herself all these years?
Each of her slow inhales wheeze eerily and high pitched, like a teakettle. She’s close enough now for me to see that blood is gushing from more than just her mouth. It drips down her reddened eyes, pours out her nose and out of her ears, runs sticky red lines down her naked body. Her head rolls from side to side, like it’s too much of a struggle to keep it upright.
I want to say her name in a last ditch effort to remind her we’re on the same side, but I can tell by the angry dazed look on her face that she has no idea who I am. Even though it’s already snowing, the closer she gets, the colder I become.
Fear overwhelms me until suddenly I don’t feel afraid anymore. Isn’t that what the norsemen believe? You get a straight shot into the afterlife as long as you aren’t afraid of death?
So I stare, unblinking, up at the Goddess of Death, and I wait patiently to die.
"I'm going to be honest." Considering my voice is trembling almost as unsteadily as my hands, I'm probably going to slosh steaming hot tea all over my fingers, but I reach for the cup anyway. "I have absolutely no idea how I got here."
"Here as in my house?" Jacob asks. "Or in the broader sense of here as in Earth?"
"Both."
Jacob raises his teacup in a silent toast and takes an equally silent sip. "So," he asks with a slight rise of one eyebrow, "what exactly is it you're hoping I can help you with?"
It dawns on me that I've left the Temple, but I have no memory of leaving. How did I know how to get to Jacob's foot? I've never had to walk here from the Temple before.
Oh no. I can't stay here for long. I need to attend that coming of age ceremony. What's going to happen if I don't show up? Will they reschedule? Will I ruin this poor boys life by not attending? Will his father hold a grudge? He'll be furious. I just know it.
Oh, God, what time is it right now? Have I already missed it?
I'm trembling and sweaty and it's impossible to think straight. Squeezing my eyes tight, I say the one thing that pops back into my overcrowded thoughts. "I have a son."
Jacob's eyes wander around the dark inside of the foot statue. "That was a comment. Do you have a question?"
"Who is his father?"
"I don't know."
"Yes, you do," I snap defensively. "You know everything."
The smallest of smiles tugs at the corners of his mouth. "I'm flattered you think I'm powerful enough to be omnipresent."
I take a sip of tea to force myself to calm down before replying. "You honestly don't know?"
"As I've mentioned before, we're friends. I want to help you in any way I can. That just happens to be something I don't know. Ask me something else."
Chris is Ben's. He has to be Ben's. We're about to get married. Chris is the age he'd be if I gave birth after time-traveling. I must not have told anyone. That's why Jacob doesn't know. Why didn't I tell anyone? I guess it would be a little complicated to explain, but it's not impossible. Unless something happens after I travel back to the 70's? An issue of trust? How do I know I can trust Jacob? How do I know he's not lying to me?
Jacob places another split log on the fire. "Technically," he says, "you don't. Although, no, I'm not lying to you."
"Did you just—" I pause, teacup half raised to my lips. "Hold on. . . you can read minds?"
"Thankfully, no." Jacob laughs at the idea and shakes his head. "That would probably have driven me to madness by now. If anything, it's more like the world's weakest radio transmission. Never get more than maybe a word out of someone. You're the first person I've ever heard a full sentence from. So," he adds with a small shrug, "I suppose I can read yours. Not that I'm trying to. It happens without warning. Never know what I'm going to get. Sorry."
Interesting. I pause to see if Jacob has heard me think this word, but he doesn't respond.
Jacob was nobody's favorite character in the show, mostly because the writers didn't seem to know what to do with him. He was always more of an allegory than an actual character, which doesn't make for a very interesting life. I know about everyone else on this island—well, most of the survivors, anyway—but I cannot think of a single interesting fact about Jacob. All I know for certain is he accidentally killed his brother and he has intense mommy issues. Which, to be fair, who on this island doesn't?
I finish my cup in a final swig and place it on the smooth carved table beside me. "You've always had this power?"
"Long as I can remember. But like I said, I don't view it as a power per se. Nothing really useful in suddenly hearing someone think tuna or uh-oh."
"But you can hear me think in full sentences?"
"Not entirely, but this is definitely more than I've ever heard from anyone else."
"How close do you have to be to hear it?"
"Fairly close. Again, it works more like a worthless radio."
"Did this happen before?" He's so low energy, I honestly can't tell if he's surprised by this discovery or not. "Have you been able to hear my thoughts any of the other times we've met in the past?"
"Not like this," he admits. "I don't know what changed. Maybe you've become stronger after your rebirth?"
I'm so tired of being scared. I'm so tired of people speaking to me in half-truths and riddles. I just want to know the same amount as everyone around me. "Can I ask—I mean," I correct self-consciously. "May I ask you a question?"
"I assumed that's why you trekked all the way here."
I want to know. I need to know. But that doesn't make asking any easier. "Do you know how I died? I've been told I was murdered. Stabbed a bunch of times."
"Stabbed?" Jacob looks up with the most expressive look in his eyes and I startle, considering he's only ever had a completely blank expression until now. "You weren't stabbed. At least, that's not what Richard told me."
"Ben told me I was stabbed."
"Mmm," Jacob hums in thought. "That's what he remembers, but that's not what happened."
I lean forward so far I almost fall headfirst into the fire. "What do you mean?"
"It's my understanding that Ben's never been a reliable source of information as to the truth of your death. Memory is already such a fragile and unreliable thing, and that's without whatever horrors he saw before Richard got there."
Much like the spa night on Hydra, I'm overheating from anxiety. It was relatively cool in this foot when I first arrived, but now the air is stifling. "If I wasn't stabbed, then how did I die?"
Jacob takes a long sip, taking care to set the cup gently down on the saucer before setting it aside. "You were beaten."
"Beaten? Like, with a bat?" I frown when Jacob gives a slight shrug. "By who?"
Jacob stills, looking especially serious. "Is this you asking for answers?"
"I've literally been asking for answers this entire time."
He doesn't smile at my words. If anything, he only looks more serious. "Before you died, you visited me and said there would come a time when you would ask me for answers. But you were very specific about making sure you were ready for them. I'll only ask one final time. Is this you asking for answers?"
Without pause, I answer, "Yes."
Jacob stands, walks to a dark corner of the room, and opens a chest I hadn't noticed was pushed against the wall. In a sudden bright gleam of silver, he walks towards me and offers up a long metal axe the likes I've never seen before. "This is yours," he says, holding it out in offering.
I feel a snarl curl my lips up in angry disappointment. "The big secret I asked you to keep from me was an axe?"
"Your reasons are your own. Here, take it."
A biting cold digs into my fingers the second I touch the hilt, but as soon as I've wrapped both my hands around it, Jacob lets go. In an embarrassing blink of an eye, the full weight of the axe drops to the sand, bringing me down with it. I strain to at least pull it a little up off the ground. "Please tell me I'm not supposed to carry this around."
"You have a holster to carry it on your back. I'll show you how it works, but first," he says and holds up a worn journal that looks very similar to the one Harper gave me. "This is what I presume you wanted to keep secret."
I practically rip if out of his hand, flipping wildly through the pages at random. My mind is racing so quickly, filled with so much panic, that it takes a while to understand what I'm looking at.
I'm looking at nothing. I'm looking at absolute nonsense. Words strung together in some sort of crazy word soup. Letters so unintelligible, I'm not even sure what half of these words are supposed to be. I flip from one page to the next, stifling a horrified gasp at multiple papers warped and stained with dried blood.
"This was mine?" I manage to squeak out. "I wrote all this?"
Jacob just stares at me, so I start flipping through more incoherent ramblings. Long streaks of blue and black ink dip and swirl in manic lines from top to bottom of several pages, followed by sketches that prickle my skin with goosebumps. Horrible frantic sketches straight out of a nightmare—things that would always have frightened me, but now they paralyze me completely knowing this is what I have to look forward to in the future.
"To answer your question," says Jacob, "I don't know who killed you. I'm sorry. You seemed to think this journal would be of some help." He pauses, fixing me with a pitying softness in his eyes. "I see that's not the case."
This was it? This was my grand master plan to warn me of my impending doom? A journal filled with future-me's insane ramblings? How does this help me? How is this a warning worth telling me if it doesn't explain how to keep it from happening?
I try to suck in a lungful of air, but all I manage to do is bring a hand up to cover my mouth.
Two bodyguards wait for me outside the statue, but I don't know who they are and I definitely don't remember asking them to escort me here. Did I Berserk again? Or did I just disassociate? I hope I didn't hurt anyone.
We're deep into the jungle before I muster up the courage to speak to them. "I'm sorry for leaving so close to the ceremony. Are we going to make it back in time?"
The older of the two smiles. "Why would you apologize for such a thing? All that matters is that you attend. Eomer would reschedule to any day of the year if it would be more convenient to you. But," he adds, "I believe there will be no need for that. The sun has only just set. There is plenty of time tonight."
When we finally arrive back to the Temple, I'm relieved Gail seems to have calmed down from her earlier mood. But my relief doesn't last long as soon as she escorts me to my bedroom.
Pumba hops up from his bed next to the fireplace and rushes over to me. At first I think he wants comfort, so I lean down to pick him up, only to take a step back when he rams full-speed painfully into my shins.
"Ow, easy," I say, but he's quick to cut me off with a loud oink.
"You abandoned us!"
I look up at Gail as if she has any idea what Pumba's saying.
"You didn't tell us where you were going!" Pumba presses his wet snout against my leg, but he hops away when I try to pet him. "You said to stay near you, and then you left me without even saying goodbye!"
"I wasn't gone that long—"
I can hear it in his voice—the anger, the unfiltered fear. He's so upset, each honk lifts him up in a small bounce. "You're supposed to look after me! You said everything would be fine if I stayed close to you, and then you abandoned me!"
Again, I reach for him to no avail. If I could just calm him down, he'd realize he's safe here and this is all being blown out of proportion. "I'm sorry you were scared, but—"
"You're a liar!"
"Listen, please, I was just—"
"My real momma would never have lied to me!" Pumba emits an earsplitting scream and takes off for the partially opened door. With a final flail of his little body, he's squeezed through the opening and disappears.
Fenrir seems to be either afraid or embarrassed by Pumba's outburst. He doesn't move from his spot by the fire, melting against the stone floor like a puddle.
It isn't until I stand up that I realize my face is inflamed, though I'm not sure whether its from the realization that Pumba's anger is justified or from the shame of not being able to mitigate his fear. I have to clear my throat twice before I can ask, "Do you agree with him?"
"We were just worried," Fenrir says. "Since you always tell us where you'll be. You rushed away so quickly, and they wouldn't let us leave to follow you."
I want to comfort him, but I don't know how. Good job, asshole. Look what you did. Pumba hates you now, and Fenrir won't even look you in the eye. Do I pet him? Apologize? I don't even fully understand what I'm apologizing for. No, that's not true. I made a big deal about staying near me, and then I left to talk to Jacob without even thinking about bringing them with me. Pumba's right, I suck.
I am suddenly unbelievably tired.
Clearing my throat again does little to relieve the rapidly growing pain. "I'm sorry I worried you two. I hope you know I would never abandon you. I just. . . had to run a quick errand is all, and then I came right back. I should have told you. I'm sorry."
Fenrir slinks over and licks my hand, and it seems all is forgiven. At least with him.
"Can you please go find Pumba and convince him to come back? You have such a good nose," I praise, smiling as his tail begins to wag. "I know you can find him."
"You found your axe," Ben comments flatly. "Good for you."
I adjust the dead weight on my shoulder and wish Gail would come back. She's the one who told me to bring this stupid hunk of metal. After dressing me in a layering of dark cloth and fur, braiding my hair, painting my face with intricate thin black lines, and showing me where to stand for the ceremony, she disappeared, leaving me alone with a tired and irritable Ben.
Ben and I stand atop one of the open balconies overlooking a torch-lit courtyard where Eomer and his son Andor are preparing for the ritual. From here, I can see most of the crowd gathered on various levels below us and circled around the courtyard itself for the best view. Another uproar sounds from the crowd below as the younger teen boys hoot and holler and shove each other excitedly. Even though the party is outside, the voices of all these people combined rise to deafening levels. Everyone is talking to someone about something.
Gail has prepped me for every other social gathering I've attended on this island, but nobody prepared me for what this ceremony entails. I lean against the balcony railing and watch as a group of teenagers laugh raucously, pushing and shoving in an ever-increasing physical match.
When Eomer raises his arms to make an announcement, I expect the crowd to quiet down somewhat so I can hear what he's saying. Instead, the group explodes into ear-splitting chants of what sounds like an owl's hoot.
Ben stands directly beside me, but I don't turn towards him when I ask, "What is he saying? I can't hear anything over all this screaming."
"I think he's thanking you for being here. He's looking up here now. You should wave."
I'm trying to piece together what Ben's saying, but his words sound like an unintelligible hum next to the screams and cheers and whistles. "What?" I yell over the noise.
"Wave at them," he yells back.
"What?" I finally turn to look at him and point to one of my ears. "I can't hear you!"
Ben grabs my wrist and flings my arm up until it's fully extended above my head, holding it there until the impossible happens—the shouting somehow intensifies. I watch as a particularly boisterous group of boys all simultaneously blow me a kiss. It is only when someone tosses Eomer what looks like a bamboo pole that Ben releases my wrist and takes a seat.
What's with the bamboo? Are they going to play a round of father-son golf? Host a limbo competition? I smile, shaking my head at the absurdity of it all. How low can you go? Hope it's low enough, or we won't consider you a man!
Eomer twirls the pole around once in his hand before gripping it tightly like a baseball bat and swinging it full-force into his son's chest. Andor immediately buckles, dropping to his knees as the crowd cries out in sympathy pain.
I can't immediately move. I can't scream. I can't run. I can't even blink. My eyes dart to a group of young boys gathered near the edge of the onlookers and watch as they break out into laughter as Eomer brings the pole down hard on the back of his son's spine.
Sweat is already pooling in-between my fingers when I turn to Ben and try and ask, "Why is this happening?" and "What is the point of this?" at the same time and end up screaming, "What this?"
He yawns, evidently too tired to make fun of my misspeak. "Typically, a coming-of-age ceremony represents—"
"No," I try to clarify, panic rising in my voice, "what is the point of this? Eomer's just beating him!"
"Yes, that's the point."
"Why doesn't Andor fight back?"
Ben doesn't look shocked at the sight of the violence. He motions for me to take a seat next to him so he doesn't have to yell. "This ceremony is not about fighting back."
"Then what does this accomplish?"
"Fear of death is a mortal sin," Ben explains in a completely putout rush. "If you no longer fear pain, you've won half the battle. That's what this Temple is primarily used for."
"For beating children?"
A roar so loud it vibrates my ribs echoes throughout the darkness. I look back down just in time to watch Andor attempt to stand, only to receive a sharp crack of bamboo across his back, sending him sprawling out on the floor.
"For endurance training," Ben continues as soon as we can at least somewhat hear each other again. "You start as soon as your mother approves it. Usually no later than ten. That means Andor has been training for—" Ben pauses again to yawn. "About six years. I know it may look bad, but I guarantee this is nothing for him at this point."
My jaw hangs open in horror as I try to process what he's saying. "All these dads get together and beat their sons to prepare them for an even worse beating when they're older?"
Ben shrugs one shoulder half-heartedly. "It doesn't take very long to become desensitized. Well," he winces, pausing to tilt his head at the commotion down below. "That one probably hurt. He's not supposed to get that close to his skull. A concussion is not the end-goal." I don't notice I'm staring until Ben looks over at me and asks, "What?"
"They did this to you, too?"
"No one is exempt if they want to live among your people."
If Erik descended from a line of Jarls, that probably means he's been training his entire life. "Erik still seemed pretty terrified of death the last time I saw him."
Ben barks a laugh and rubs his tired eyes. "To be fair, fear of you is a little different than fear of death."
"You still seemed terrified at the prospect of a spinal tumor."
"That's because I—" He catches himself, even through his apparent exhaustion. "That's different."
"How?"
Ben brings up a hand to rub at his eyes. "Can't you please just watch the ceremony? It's almost over."
"This isn't right."
There's a moment's pause, and I think the conversation has ended. Without warning, Ben reaches over and punches my arm.
I've never been punched before. Not properly. Nothing beyond a girly smack in class to get my attention. It's so sudden and shocking and genuinely painful, I just stare at him in confusion.
"Did that hurt?"
"You just hit me," I whisper in disbelief, bringing up a hand to rub the throbbing pain away. "Yes, it hurt."
"Well," he says, already turning away to focus his attention back on the ceremony, "it wouldn't have hurt if you'd trained like the rest of us."
As if my self-defense instincts are delayed beyond reason, it's a few seconds of deliberation before I reach over and punch his arm as hard as I can.
"See?" He smiles smugly. "Barely even registered. Are you. . ." Ben's bloodshot eyes widen slightly as he turns fully in his seat to gawk at me. "Are you crying?"
I swipe at my face and sure enough my hand comes away wet, my cheeks already dampened with a silent stream of new tears. I'm so confused and scared and hurt that I can't speak. I can't ask why he's doing this. I can't tell him to leave me alone. All I can do is stare at him. His shape blurs more and more as the tears come quicker, waiting for his inevitable apology.
All he says is, "Can you please not mention this to Gail?"
From over the roar of the excitable crowd, one voice pierces the noise and makes Ben shoot up from his seat. "Benjamin Linus! What did you do this time?" Gail's blurred form hurries towards me, swiping away stray hair from my face and cradling me against her chest. Her worried expression turns to fury as it locks on Ben. "You absolute wretch. Why can't I leave you two alone without you upsetting her?"
"Of course I'm upset," I say, breaking away from Gail's smothering. Ben sinks in his seat just the tiniest bit, slumping under Gail's stare as he waits for me to tell her the details. I wipe my face and cough. "This ceremony is upsetting. You expect me to sit here and watch this and not be upset? Why didn't you tell me this was going to be applauded child abuse? Why did you think I would want to watch this?"
Gail attempts to regain her composure, but it's evident she's surprised I'm angry at her. "I understand this can be a little upsetting to watch the first time," she stumbles to explain, "but these boys have been—"
"Training their whole lives. I know and I don't care!" It's too loud, too hot, too claustrophobic. I'm hyperventilating and I don't know how to stop. "I don't want to be here," I scream with a crazed resolve only anxiety can bring. "I don't want to be here!"
"You can't leave," Ben interjects. "Do you have any idea how insulting that would be?" Gail tries to cut him off, but in a surprising show of defiance, he completely ignores her. "Cora, if you don't go down there and offer your congratulations, you are going to ruin that poor boy's life."
"How?" I refute stubbornly. "How will it ruin his life?"
"Because you're here," Ben answers. "The rest of us just had to contend with the thought of you watching and approving our ceremony from the great beyond. But you're physically here now. So if you don't at least make an appearance at his celebratory dinner, it's going to look like you—" Ben stops talking, looking away from me at the new sound coming from the arena.
And by new sound, I mean absolute silence. Even Gail looks spooked at the drastic change in audience atmosphere, so I walk over to the balcony to see what happened.
Andor lays sprawled out on the ground, motionless. His father stands off to the side, waiting, watching. He's not even holding the bamboo rod anymore. Nobody so much as coughs a noise.
It feels odd whispering when just seconds ago I had to scream to be heard over all of the noise. "Ben, what's going on?"
"It's over," Ben answers in an equally hushed tone. "If he can stand up unassisted, the ceremony is over."
"What happens if he can't stand?"
I watch Ben's throat bob as he nervously swallows. "He'll get up."
He just has to stand up? But by the looks of it, that's much easier said than done. Andor's entire upper body shakes like he's freezing, but he doesn't manage to push himself up very far from the dirt. His chest heaves once, twice, then he tries again, this time managing to push himself to his knees as we all watch in complete silence. It's a slow process, but he eventually manages to stand, swaying slightly, then righting himself.
He's barely had time to straighten his spine before the roaring returns and everyone is running to lift Andor up and body surf him through the audience.
"Gail," Ben yells over the noise and wipes a thumb under my eye. "Can you fix this paint in a hurry? It's all smeared."
"I'm not hungry," I blurt out. What I want to say is, I'm starving, but I'm also going to throw up from anxiety, and I would prefer to do that alone, thank you. "I don't want to go to the dinner."
"Then don't go to the dinner," Ben answers. "But you need to talk to Andor while there's still an audience. It won't count if nobody sees you do it."
"Okay." I can do that. Congratulate him and GTFO. "Okay."
Ben wipes off the paint I ruined with my tears and Gail proceeds to re-paint the lines under my eyes as quickly as she can.
"There," she says. "Just make sure not to touch it. Won't be dry for another few minutes, but we don't have that kind of time if you want to catch Andor before those boys carry him out of the courtyard."
I'm expecting to be pushed and shoved and melded into the excited crowd, but as soon as one man sees me and inclines his head, it starts a chain reaction until a path is formed for me to approach the center of the courtyard. Andor's friends don't seem to have noticed I'm here and continue to tease him about how hard he fell down for the first hit.
"I for one was impressed." I ignore the rowdy boys and walk right up to Andor as a hush falls over the group. "You took that like a true warrior." I wait for him to say something, but he just stares at me like I've reached into his brain and shut it off manually.
What am I supposed to do now? I congratulated him. Was that enough? Ben seemed genuinely worried I would mess this up. Better go all in just to make sure.
Much like most people are, Andor is taller than me, so I have to reach up and tilt his head down so I can kiss his forehead. I ignore how uncomfortable I am and smile at him as his face inflames the deepest shade of red I've ever seen. Nobody says anything. "Well, uh. Carry on, boys. And congratulations again, Andor. I hope you don't mind that I won't be at the dinner. I need to rest for the journey tomorrow."
Finally finding his voice, Andor stumbles over a few different sentences before giving up and offering a meek, "Thank you, my lady."
As I turn to make a break for my room, I smile when I hear one of the boys say, "Aw, come on, that's some bullshit. Lucky bastard! I had my ceremony just last month. Do you think she gives retroactive blessings?"
I hold tightly to Pumba and Fenrir, curled up on my lap, staring into the void. I'm overjoyed Pumba was willing to hear me out, but I'm still sick with anxiety over what I just saw at the ceremony. I'm so embarrassed Gail and Ben saw my breakdown that I haven't been able to eat, which is freaking me out. Usually, my anxiety lessens by gorging on some good food, but even the thought of the vegetarian stew Gail brought me makes bile rise up my throat.
They must think I'm pathetic. A worthless weakling. I cringe at the thought of crying so easily. As horrifying as this all is to my American sensibilities, it seems to work fine for the norsemen. Culture shock is absolutely kicking my ass.
Maybe I can do something about it? Talk to the right people to wean them off such barbaric and violent rituals? Would they be insulted at the idea? Or would they be open to the idea by virtue of me being the one to recommend it?
I have so many questions that I need to write down before I forget them, but when I reach for my notebook, I don't find it.
Great. Just great. Where did I leave it? Where do I remember last seeing it?
The mural. The Pokemon mural. I was holding it when Ben showed me the painting. And then. . . yes, that's when Christopher showed up and we went. . . down the stairs to the creekside to talk. I ran away after that, but I didn't have it at Jacob's. It must still be by the creek.
"Hey boys," I whisper to a drowsy Fenrir and Pumba, "I'm going to go down to the creek to get my notebook, okay? You can come if you want, but it honestly looks like you sleepyheads are ready to pass out." I tuck them into the foot of my bed and say, "I'll be right back. Promise. Okay?"
The night is cool and quiet now that the party has ended and the men have all retreated to their rooms. I try to retrace my steps using what I remember of the artwork on the walls to guide me back to the Pokemon mural, but I soon begin to worry that this temple is much bigger than I anticipated.
Just when I think about swallowing my pride and knocking on a random door to ask for help, I see him sitting on a bench. For a split second he looks frightened, but he immediately relaxes as I walk closer. His mouth twitches into a small grin. I frown in return.
"You can cut the act." I scan the area for my notebook, but I don't see it. "I know you're not happy to see me."
"Of course I'm happy to see you," he says. "I thought you were Gail at first, and that would have been much worse."
It's almost a disappointment that it didn't take very long to get used to the same old bullying I've put up with my whole life. His insults don't even hurt enough to cause physical pain anymore. I ignore him as I pass by his bench seat in search of the journal. I left it here. I know I did.
Ben's voice is so soft, I barely hear him over the distant crashing of the waterfall. "I'm a little out of sorts lately." It takes a second for him to roll his head over to look at me. "Sorry."
For as much as I'd like to flip him off and cancel this whole treaty plan—war be damned—I feel slightly less angry when I get a good look at him. "You look like you got hit by a truck."
"Thank you. For earlier today," he clarifies. "Not for the insult, although I'm sure it's warranted."
I lean down to check closer to the creek, but I'd need a lantern to get a real view. Sighing, I give up the search and resign myself to starting over with a new notebook as soon as tomorrows scavenger hunt is over.
"You're welcome, I guess." Walking up beside his seat on the bench, I cannot keep myself from frowning. "Although, you've racked up quite the list of favors you owe me. This is, what? The fifth time I've covered for you?"
"Please," he interjects, sounding insulted. "I owe you two favors, at most."
Even though he probably can't see me in the flickering of the nearest torch, I fix him with an unamused smirk. "Fine. I'm calling on one now." Ben shifts away from me when I take a seat next to him on the bench. "I want you to answer my questions to the fullest extent of your knowledge."
"Oh goodie," he mumbles.
"Do you trust Gail?"
He looks up at this, startled. "You left me under her care before you died. I don't really have a choice."
"Is there anyone you don't trust? Anyone I should know about?"
"Where is this coming from?"
"Why did it take so long to discover Dolores had tried to kill me? I killed her parents. That should have made her suspect number one."
I think Ben rolls his eyes, but it honestly might have just been a flickering attempt to keep his eyelids open. "There's absolutely nothing unique about her situation. You killed a lot of peoples parents." He twitches awake, as if paranoid he's said the wrong thing. "You have beautiful eyes."
"What?"
"Your eyes," he repeats. "They're very beautiful when they're not bleeding."
"Thank you?"
I honestly can't tell if the dark circles under his eyes are remnants of the beating he got from Erik or if they're from lack of sleep. Ben doesn't seem to notice me staring at him. More than once he twitches awake to swipe at something that isn't there.
"Ben, you should go get some sleep."
All of his movements are incredibly slow, as if to prove he's reached his limit. Ben blinks, his head unsteady on his shoulders. He gives no indication he's heard me. I think he just fell asleep.
"Hey," I call, but still no response. Despite the angry voice telling me to leave him out here to rot in the moonlight, I'm calm enough now to think about what my grandmother would want me to do. I lean closer to make sure he's breathing, and he looks worse the closer I get. "Are you drunk?"
By the tone of his voice, he wants to be intimidating, but it's hard to look threatening when your eyes are flickering in a losing battle to stay open. "I haven't slept in almost four days, Cora."
"Why not?"
"I don't want to talk about it."
Great, is there some other threat he hasn't mentioned yet? Someone else that wants to kill me? Destroy his people? Is Widmore still a thing? Is Widmore still alive?
"Why not?" I repeat.
Ben brings a hand up and rubs at his eyes. "Because I'm trying to spare your feelings."
"Like that's ever stopped you before. Spare my feelings about what?"
He doesn't sigh—by the looks of it, he doesn't have the energy it would take—but his answer is so drawn out, it feels like a sigh. "About how all of this is your fault."
There's a cool breeze tonight that whips right through my dress. I cross my arms over my chest. "What's my fault?"
"I used to have nothing but nightmares the first year after you died. They spaced out after a few years, and it's been a while since I've had one at all. But ever since your rebirth, it's all I dream about." Ben stares straight ahead, although I'm not sure his vision is clear enough to actually see anything. "I hoped at first this was a good sign. Maybe seeing you in person again would spark a memory to prove my innocence, but all it's done is make it impossible to sleep throughout the night."
"You dream about my death? Have you remembered anything? Even the tiniest thing?"
Ben scrunches his eyebrows together in what looks like a mixture of confusion and anger. "No, Cora, as I've stated a thousand times before, I don't remember what happened that day, so I just dream about absolutely everything else." His eyes only grow more resentful when I stare back with my own confused expression. "Everything else you did. To us. To the Initiative. To. . . You're being serious," he says, still sounding slightly suspicious. "If this is some kind of game, I don't find it amusing."
He waits for me to answer, but I don't understand if he's asking a question or making a statement. It doesn't matter anyway. Without a word, he stands, grabs my sleeve, and tugs me back up the stairs.
"Where are we going?" I ask as we twist and weave through corridors. I only truly begin to worry when we descend a staircase into an underground passageway. "Ben, where are you taking me?"
"Behold," he shouts sarcastically, slingshotting me in front of him. "Your wondrous legacy."
It's the largest painting I've seen yet, spanning from floor to ceiling and stretching from left to right into the darkness not lit by our flickering torch. I'm standing atop a mountain—at least, I think it's me. It's difficult to tell because I've been painted to have a polar bear's head tilted back in a roar. Each hand is raised up, holding something. Heads. Disembodied heads. I'm holding disembodied heads up by their hair. And I'm not standing atop a mountain. I'm standing on a massive pile of random body parts.
I turn to look at him at the same time an offended laugh bursts out of my throat. "This is obviously not me."
"So you don't remember? Well, allow me to bring you up to speed. This is you," Ben clarifies. "And do you want to know how I can confirm that? Because I was there. I watched as this exact scene unfolded before my very eyes."
There's something missing. A mistake. Something he's not telling me. Surely there's something he's not telling me. "What do you remember of me before I died? Before," I don't have the courage to look at the mural again. "Before all this happened."
Ben squints at me in the dark. "What's the absolute worst thing you can think of?"
I'm not even insulted at the question, just horrified. "I'm the worst thing you can think of?"
"Did you grow up with fables? Cautionary tales? Monster stories?" he continues without apology. "You are our monster. You're without a doubt the worst thing that ever happened to those of us who lived with the Initiative. I for one can't sleep, and Annie has a perchance for. . . a bit too much wine. And Dolores," he adds with an amused huff. "Well, Dolores just tried to kill you."
"I. . ." Stumbling for a response, I think back on the times I've heard his people talk about the monster. "What about the smoke monster?"
"What about it?" Ben huffs again, shaking his head like I've just said the dumbest thing he's ever heard. "You honestly think we're afraid of whatever that thing is? We can hide behind our sonic fence and keep our families safe. But you? Nothing can keep you out. Nothing can protect us from you. But don't worry," he adds snidely, "my people have all done a thorough job of explaining death to our children, so when you inevitably turn on us again, at least our deaths won't come as a complete shock to them."
I have no time to think about what he's said before he begins another tirade.
"Those of us who survived were mostly children who either hid and were spared the carnage or have blissfully repressed the memory." Ben takes a step closer, and I can physically feel animosity wafting off of him. "But Annie and I were in the thick of things the day you destroyed our people. We saw everything. We were among the few lucky enough to remember exactly what you are."
Too many anxieties flood my head at once, and I scramble to think of something to say. "Why are you letting me look after Alex?"
"And what exactly was I supposed to say? No? So you could find a reason to unleash your anger on us all a second time?" Ben shakes his head again, looking even more enraged as he hisses out the rest of his speech. "Everything I've done has been to give Alex something I never had—a trauma-less childhood. And if that means I have to submit to your demands and pretend like everything you say is a good idea, then that is the price I am willing to pay for my daughters sake." It happens again—a shift in his eyes. Like he's waking from a dream and trying to piece together where he is. "I'm sorry," he whispers. "I'm sorry, I'm just so tired."
I point behind me at the art. "Is everything you just told me true?" There's a part of me that holds on to the hope that he'll tell me this is all an elaborate prank, so my stomach sinks with disappointment when he nods yes. "Then there's nothing you have to apologize for." If even half of what's painted on this wall is true, of course he has night terrors. "Do your people have any sleeping medicine?"
"Sedatives," he exclaims in an overly sarcastic whisper. "How have I never thought of sedatives?"
"I'm just trying to help."
Ben cuts me off, somehow finding the strength to raise his voice. "By not listening to me? I told you the problem is not falling asleep, it's staying asleep." He closes his eyes and sighs. "I'm sorry."
He's right, and I can feel my face burning with unwarranted indignation. "Look, I don't know what you want me to say. All I know is if you don't sleep soon, you're going to die."
"That's looking more and more appealing every day."
I know he's being hyperbolic, but there's a hint of truth in his statement that makes me sad. I don't know how to help him, but he's right. This is my fault. I owe it to him to think of something.
"Ben?" I'm going to help him. As soon as I think of something, I'm going to help him. But first, I want an answer to a question I've had since we first met. One I haven't been able to figure out myself. A question he would never answer if he was well rested and of sound mind. "Has Gail been telling you to flirt with me?"
"That's incredibly rude, you know." I don't get the chance to ask what he means before he smiles. "Asking me questions you wouldn't otherwise ask me if I wasn't impaired." I don't know what to say, so I just stand, shifting my weight from one foot to the other before he finally answers, "She ordered me to be amicable."
And just like that, I'm flooded with a rush of calm. It's comforting to get confirmation that this is nothing I don't have years of experience with. Men used to flirt with me to get to my friends. Ben has been flirting because he's just following orders. Being around him doesn't seem so scary anymore.
"Where's your room?" I tap his shoulder when he starts slumping forward. "Hey, where are you sleeping tonight?"
Of all things, he looks scared. "Why?"
"Lead the way. I have an idea."
Chapter 16: Dishonor On Your Entire Family
Notes:
Are y'all ready for the disaster wedding of the century? *air horns*
Chapter Text
Crackles from the fireplace sound so loud in this otherwise silent room that each pop makes me flinch. I was surprised to find Ben had been given his own room. I've grown used to the idea of a mass guesthouse, like the one on Hydra.
I add more wood to the fire before taking a seat on the floor next to the bed and hold up the copy of The Hobbit he gave me. "When I was a child, I used to—"
He interrupts with a bewildered, "You were once a child?"
I pause, fighting the urge to smile. "Are you going to let me finish? When I was younger, I used to have bad nightmares about—" I used to have terrible nightmares about my parents getting into a car accident, but I'm not in the mood to talk about that right now. "They were. . . you know. Bad kid nightmares. The ones that feel real even after you initially wake up. The only thing I remember helping is when my grandma would read to me. Falling asleep to the sound of her voice made me feel safe enough to sleep soundly throughout the night. Maybe falling asleep to the sound of. . . not scary me will help keep the nightmares at bay."
Ben's eyes flicker open and closed, but he somehow musters the strength to quip, "You think reading me a fairytale is going to magically cure my condition?"
It takes a surprising amount of willpower not to say something especially snide in return. "Well, if it doesn't, at least you won't be any worse off."
"Fair enough," he mumbles into the pillow.
I clear my throat, suddenly self conscious, but it doesn't last long. I read until his face is relaxed into what I hope is a peaceful sleep, and then I flip to the chapter I've been putting off reading.
"Well, that was. . . underwhelming," I whisper when I finish reading. "I hope you didn't pay too much money for this."
I jolt awake in the darkness at the sound of someone pounding on the door. A book slips out of my hands and slaps against the ground.
Blinking fast, I can somewhat see where I am, but as I rush to push myself to my feet, I realize I'm not in my room. Standing immediately floods my stomach with nausea to the point where I resign myself to my fate, although I mercifully never end up vomiting. Sleep deprivation is the literal worst.
That's when I remember where I am. That's when I remember why I'm here. I look over at the bed and confirm Ben is still asleep. Thankfully, it looks like my plan worked.
I flinch at the sound of someone banging on the door again.
They're going to wake Ben up and all this will be for naught. I hurry over and fling it open mid-knock. "Shhhhh!"
I bet my life Ben would have given anything to be awake so he could see the look on Gail's face. Her eyes dart behind me, and her question comes out incredibly slow. "Is he here?"
"He's not up yet."
"What do you mean he's not up yet?" Gail frowns, seemingly snapping back into her usual angry disappointment. "The sun rose half an hour ago, and you're departing soon."
I don't know how much sleep I got last night, but I do know it wasn't nearly enough. My body and brain feel disconnected, like the night of Margo's funeral. "Don't wake him." The dreaded heavy-lidded dry eyes fight against me as I struggle to keep them open. "He needs extra sleep more than any of us."
"He's not a child," she scoffs. "It will make—"
"Gail," I command sharply, "leave him alone."
Of all things, it looks like I've hurt her feelings. "Of course, my lady," she huffs indignantly, yet somehow manages a smile. "I'll be in your room when he finally decides to grace us all with his presence."
I blanche at her tone, but what am I supposed to do? Gail was so kind and attentive when we first met, but she's been acting straight up childish recently. I'm tired of having to defend Ben from her mean spirited energy, but even more importantly, I'm tired of feeling compelled to defend him. They're both at least 20 years my senior, but it's mornings like this when it doesn't feel that way.
It's stressful enough that I have so many actual human children to look after. Not to mention animals like Fenrir and—
"Oh no," I whisper, already halfway back to the door. I forgot about Pumba! Fenrir seems to be a little less paranoid, but Pumba is rightfully concerned with losing another parental figure. I hope he slept throughout the night. I hope he isn't mad at me again for not coming back to my room.
"One hundred and eighty thousand dollars."
"What?" I spin around, surprised to hear the sound of Ben's voice. I didn't realize he was awake. Did he even sleep? How long has he been silently lying there? "What did you say?"
"The book you've so carelessly tossed on the floor," he clarifies, rolling over to look at me with eyes that reveal it's unlikely he slept at all. "To answer your earlier question, it cost one hundred and eighty thousand dollars."
Ben shifts his backpack and squints at me in the sunshine. "What are you doing?"
I turn and fix him with an enthusiastic smile. Or, at least I would if I could stop yawning for five seconds. "I'm cheating. Excuse me?" I yell up at the birds. "Hi! Could any of you tell me which way a group of humans went? Would have been around sunrise, and they would have been carrying a bag about this big?"
A brightly colored bird asks, "What does the human want?"
"I. . . I just told you what I want?" It comes out like a question, but it's only because a whole rainbow of small birds have congregated to gawk at me.
"Is that human talking? How cute!"
"Look," another bird joins in. "A talking human. I didn't know they could do that."
A bright green bird glides down from the safety of the trees and lands gracefully on my shoulder. Then he screams, "Do you have food?!"
"Uh, yeah. Sure." I shrug off my backpack and pull out a granola bar. "You want this?"
Each and every one of the birds breaks out in a frenzied screaming match of "She has food!" I contemplate abandoning my entire backpack, but luckily they switch from swarming me to swarming the granola bar I toss on the ground as Ben and I make a run for it.
"So," Ben says when we've finally outrun the flock, "do you have any other bright ideas you'd like to try, or may I finally have custody of the map?"
I don't know why he bothers to ask because he pulls it out of my hands before I can give an answer.
"Why were we going this way?" Ben squints at the map like a tired parent desperately trying to navigate Disneyland. "We should have been going this way."
"No," I snap in defense of myself and point. "That mountain is there, right? So, we need to go through the valley here."
"First of all," Ben clarifies with no shortage of annoyance, "the marker you just pointed to on the map is that mountain."
I watch him point at a range of mountains on the opposite side of where I thought the map indicated. "Are you sure?"
"Is that a serious inquiry?" he deadpans while rolling up the map. "Or are you just mad about the bird comment?"
I am mad about the bird comment.
I once stayed awake for 32 hours straight because I massively procrastinated a final term project. After many mournful tears of frustration and unsteady trembling, I felt myself pass over into the mysterious world of sleep deprivation. It felt like a mix of floating on a cloud and the ultimate existential crisis. You no longer feel human. You feel like death.
I'm thankfully not quite there yet, but I'm getting close.
There's no telling what time of day it is, but I'm hot and sweaty and, if I'm being honest, bored. Which comes as a surprise. A part of me was looking forward to this scavenger hunt because it would have allowed Ben the one thing he wants more than anything—a chance to be rid of Gail. I was hoping this newfound freedom would cause him to open up a little, or at least make polite conversation. But he hasn't said a word to me since the birds.
For the first time since I've woken up on this island, I'm truly thankful for Gail's braiding skills. Having my hair up and off of the back of my neck is literally saving my life in this humid heat. I watch as Ben trudges steadily ahead and wonder if we're silently being followed. I haven't been allowed go anywhere without a guard "secretly" hiding behind a bush. Are they watching? Are they laughing?
Everything around us suddenly feels like a threat. I take a quick look around at the thinning trees as we make our way closer to shore. "How much—" A yawn overtakes me. "How much longer do you think it'll be?"
Ben doesn't turn around to answer. "We're only a few minutes away."
"A few minutes?" I surge with adrenaline at the thought of this finally being over. "Wow, they really took it easy on us, huh? Two days seems like a rather excessive time allowance."
Ben finally stops and turns to glare at me with a look of contempt. "You do realize this map is leading us to another map?"
"Oh." That's right. Scavenger hunts require multiple stops, dumbass. Of course this map doesn't lead directly to our goal. "Right."
"And that map will lead us to yet another map," he continues. "Which, if you haven't already guessed, will lead to yet another map before we eventually find the canvas bag we're required to bring home. I wouldn't be surprised if they added more maps than usual just to make my life miserable."
"Ok, jeez." You can tone down the rude comments, thanks. "I'm sorry I asked. And I thought you said we were only a few minutes away?"
"We are," he says without further elaboration.
Being this tired is strange. I don't recoil at his anger because it feels disconnected from myself. All of this feels disconnected. Like I'm watching us traipse through the jungle instead of actively participating. I feel disoriented. I feel angry. "Let me see the map."
"I know what I'm talking about." Ben points in the direction of screaming gulls. "This clearing is the only one in this area, so if we can pinpoint the exact—"
I'm about to throw an exhausted tantrum like a toddler. He felt comfortable snatching the map out of my hands earlier. Let's see how he likes it. I don't know if my reflexes are especially slow or if his are especially fast, but Ben holds the map up out of my reach before I can even touch it.
With a loud rip, all but the corner of the paper Ben has gripped in his right hand detaches from the rest of the map, taken away on a random strong gust of wind. It would be the funniest thing I've ever seen if world peace wasn't hinging on our—now hopeless—success.
Ben stares blankly as the map flutters and loops on the breeze, unceremoniously drops into the ocean waves, and disappears forever. "And on that note," he says, "I'm going home."
"But what about the scavenger hunt?"
"What about it?" He's already turned away from the ocean, heading back into the jungle. "Without the finer details of the map, there's absolutely no chance of finding the next piece."
"But you've been staring at the map for hours," I say. "How do you not know where it's buried at this point?"
"Because," he seethes, "I was looking for the marker on the map so I could begin the separate compass navigation instructions. Did you not wonder what all those numbers were on the bottom? Steps, Cora. Steps in a variety of directions that would have led to the next map. Do what you want, but I for one am not going to waste the rest of the day digging countless holes in a wild goose chase."
This was supposed to be easy. This was supposed to be fun.
I honestly don't even care anymore. You're telling me no-one has ever failed this scavenger hunt before? No-one? I find that hard to believe.
As I walk closer to the sounds of water, I realize we're a lot higher up that I initially thought we were. Peeking over the edge, I look down at the waves crashing against the side of the cliff and shiver with a burst of fear.
Maybe he's right. We could spend hours combing this area only to come up empty handed at the end. Without some kind of specific guidance, it's a useless endeavor. Great. Just great. Now everyone's going to want to hear the story about how we couldn't work together long enough to win a stupid scavenger hunt.
Does this mean the truce is off? Was this some kind of test, and now that we've failed, the war is back on again?
I turn around to follow Ben down the cliffside and almost slam face-first into my dad.
Someone is screaming. It's dark and cold, and someone is screaming. I open my mouth to call out to them, and my lungs fill with water. All four of my limbs thrash, weightless.
I break the surface of the ocean and cough like I've never coughed before. I'm in the ocean. Why am I in the ocean? I kick as hard as I can to stay afloat, but a wave crashes over me and sends me back underwater. Back to the darkness. Back to the sounds of the ocean that sound a lot like screams.
Someone has my arm. I'm pulled up into the air and gasp wildly, clinging to my rescue, unsure when I'll get pulled under again.
"Let go of me! Swim that way. That way," Ben emphasizes and gives me a push. I immediately sink, and he has to pull me up again. "What are you doing?"
I don't get a chance to answer. Like some kind of river rapid, the current pulls us towards the rocky cliffside with alarming speed. We're either going to drown, or we're going to be smashed to bloody pulp against the rocks.
Ben lets go of my arm and disappears. It's only a few seconds before the current pulls me under, thrashing me against rocks and slicing open my upper arm. I'm spun upside down and lose all sense of direction as my body smashes against rock, like I'm stuck in a washing machine.
Unable to hold my breath any longer, I resign myself to my fate and gasp, only to be met with air. I'm choking. Why am I choking? Who's choking me?
Ben finishes pulling me by my cloak onto solid ground. Then, and only then—as I lay in a sopping heap of heavy wet fabric, coughing so hard I fear I'm going to vomit—does it sink in that I'm not going to die.
"What happened?" I splutter, wiping wet hair and salt water out of my eyes. I can hardly even see Ben in this darkness, and he's sitting right next to me. "Where are we? What is this? Are we in a cave? How are we in a cave? How are people going to find us? How long will it be until they even realize we're missing? Do you think they—"
"Cora," Ben snaps with a quiet but seething force. "Stop. Talking."
Cave water falls from the high ceiling and ripples the calmer waters nearby, but I don't hear anything over the roaring waves rushing in and out of a small crevice in the side of the cliff. That must have been where my wounds came from. What I thought was me being crushed against the cliffside was actually me being slapped around the narrow opening to this cave.
I'm so full of paranoia at seeing my father that I'm not as scared of Ben as I probably should be. "Stop yelling at me."
"I'm sorry," he yells even louder in disbelief, "but which of us just jumped off a cliff? I forgive you for almost drowning me, by the way."
All this salt water has left me dehydrated, but I don't have my backpack. I'm not sure if it fell over the side of the cliff with me, or if I shrugged out of it after landing in the ocean. All I know is I need water to help calm my erratic mind. "Where's your backpack?"
"I took it off before leaping after you. You're welcome." Ben pants in the darkness, quieting for only a moment before continuing his tirade. "What the hell were you thinking out there? You don't grab people by the neck when they're trying to help you! You almost—"
I tune Ben out as memories come flooding back. Horrible memories from my childhood. Seeing my father, standing behind me at the cliffside, unlocked a primal fear that no smoke monster or scary story about the homicidal maniac I grow up to become can match the feeling I had in my very bone marrow at the sight of him. What does this mean? Was that actually him? Is this some kind of smoke monster trick, or does my family actually exist in this universe?
"Answer me," Ben yells louder than ever.
I don't specifically know what he just asked me, so I tell him the root of my problem. "I can't swim," I whisper.
"What do you mean you can't swim?"
Crisp cave chill, the unfiltered rage in his echoing voice, the fear from seeing my father, and the fact that I almost just died again is too much to process. Without even the slightest warning, I cough a phlegmy sob.
Ben thrashes and fumbles to remove his cloak, flinging it into the water with a silence louder than if he'd just kept yelling. Without another word, he quickly turns away and sloshes through puddles in the grooves of the rock until he's far enough away for his liking.
He's angry. Of course he's angry. He has every right to be angry. I've ruined this. I ruin everything.
Ben is silent for so long, I almost forget he's there. "Do you have any idea what they'd do to me if you died again? Do you even care?" It sounds like he has more grievances to unleash, but instead he sighs in the echoing darkness and makes no moves to come closer. "Why did you jump after the map? Especially if you can't swim?"
"I didn't." He waits for me to elaborate, but it's difficult to speak. "I didn't jump. I fell."
"You fell," he repeats in the most unamused tone.
"I thought. . ." I'm trying to explain myself, but thinking about my father is bad enough. I don't have the strength to talk about him as well. "Did you see someone? Someone standing behind me?"
Ben's voice echoes in the darkness, just as flat and unamused as before. "What?"
"Was there someone standing near where I fell?"
"We were the only two people up there." Ben pauses. When he speaks again, his voice is softer. "Who do you think you saw?"
I swallow the burning lump in my throat, "My father."
"Oh, fantastic," he groans. "More gods. Thats just what we need."
Tears continue to well in both eyes, but I literally don't know what to do with myself, so I stay completely still.
"How does the daughter of a sea god not know how to swim?"
Despite the stress of the situation, I'm able to think back on my studies to recall the Norse deity family tree. Ben thinks I'm talking about Njord, Freyja's father and god of the wind and sea. He has no idea I'm actually talking about some alcoholic hick from the deep south who could barely hold down a job.
"I don't know who you're talking about. I was born into a human family." I'm too tired to think up a good backstory, so I just tell the truth. "I was raised human. Until I landed on this island, I had no idea about any of this. Never talked to animals. Never healed myself. Certainly never lifted grown men over my head. And I don't—"
"Cora," Ben interrupts. "You're going to explain this all to me in great detail as soon as we get out of here, but for now I need you to remain calm."
"About what?"
I hear him sloshing towards me. "You've decided to fall off a cliff at the most inopportune time." Fingers briefly touch the side of my face, pulling away almost immediately when they make contact. "The tides coming in, and this cave is filling with water."
We emerge from the ocean like a pair of cranky wet rats. Ben pulls out a knife and severs the makeshift fabric rope he tied connecting my wrist to himself in case I lost my grip on his belt as he swam us out of the cave and back to shore.
Without instruction, Ben leaves me sitting in the sand as he disappears into the trees. Despite my initial worry that he's fulfilling his original declaration of going home, he returns with his backpack and a bundle of firewood.
"You're more than welcome to walk all the way back to the Temple soaking wet," he says, reaching down to hand me his canteen. "I'm going to dry off a little."
It took the survivors a considerable amount of time to figure out how to light a fire, but Ben has one roaring in only a few minutes. Perks of growing up with Vikings, I guess.
I'm so lost in my own thoughts—so drowsy after the receding effects of adrenaline from our cave escape—that I jolt when I look over and see Ben pulling his shirt over his head. "What are you doing?"
"Auditioning for The Price is Right." He twirls the shirt in on itself and twists out excess water. "What does it look like I'm doing?"
As he bends to pull off his boots, I notice two thin lines curling up and over the very tops of his shoulders. Guess I know where at least one of his tattoos are. As nosy as I am, my eyes flick back to the fire, embarrassed at the sight of so much skin. In a paranoid attempt to ensure he's not going to take off all his clothes so he can dry them near the fire, I ask, "Just your shirt?" I realize too late that my question actually sounds suggestive.
"If you want me to take my pants off, you can just ask. No need to be coy."
I'm sure under different circumstances, I'd be mortified. Instead, I heave a sigh and rub my trembling fingers against the bridge of my nose. "We can't keep doing this."
"I wasn't aware we were doing anything."
"This." I flop an arm to motion between us. "The yelling and sarcastic retorts and. . . we have to be able to talk to each other if this is going to work. Yes, we'll have the treaty, and our marriage means you won't have to worry about random raids anymore, but if we can't talk to each other, we're still screwed. What if something happens? What if I have questions? Look, I—" Just to make sure we're alone, I take a quick look around, but even if there is someone spying on us, we're too close to the ocean for them to be able to hear. I lower my voice anyway. "To be completely honest with you, I have no idea what I'm doing."
"Nooo," he says slowly with an extended drawl. "I for one am thoroughly shocked at this news."
"You see? You're doing it again." We both fall silent and then yawn in unison. I've only been deprived one nights sleep. I can't imagine how horrible he must be feeling. The fact that he just swam us out of a cave and all the way back to shore on God knows how little sleep is suddenly exponentially more impressive. "Thank you." I look over at him for only a second before needing to look away at literally anything else. "For rescuing me."
"I had no choice." Of all things, he smiles. "Now I only owe you one favor."
"I'm going to be charitable and say you only owe me two."
"I panicked," he says after a long stretch of silence. "Up to this point I've been at least somewhat prepared, but this. . . Gail failed to mention this would be quite the disaster it's turned out to be."
"Can you make me a promise?" He doesn't nod, but he does narrow his eyes, intrigued. "Can you let me know when Gail has plans? I know she's just trying to help, but I don't see how keeping me in the dark is helping anyone. Case in point," I add, "you'd be dead if I listened to Gail at your Holmgang. She thought she was doing what's best for me, but—" What I want to say is, She thought she was doing what's best for me, but how is you being dead better for anyone? Maybe it is. How would I know what Gail's ever actually thinking?
"She likes the power it gives her," Ben says. I was starting to wonder that myself, so it's nice to know our theory is the same. "She likes playing at being a Seer."
It makes sense. Ben would have been too young—and too ostracized—to have been trusted with whatever information the Seer had about my arrival here. Or, as these people keep calling it, my rebirth. "The previous Seer…Olga?"
"Helga," he corrects.
"Seer Helga. You mentioned before the Holmgang that she told you to practice swordsmanship. Did she tell you that directly? Or did you hear it secondhand through Gail?"
"Firsthand," he answers slowly, remembering. His mouth twitches with displeasure. "I was forbidden from visiting with her alone though. There isn't anything I know that Gail doesn't, if that's what you're leading up to asking."
I stare at him in the dwindling afternoon sunshine until he looks at me. "You're actually afraid of her."
"You'd be too if you knew what she's capable of."
"Listen, we don't have to tell Gail everything, right?" I snort a laugh before he can answer. "What am I saying? We're grown adults. We don't have to tell Gail anything." I hold out a hand for him to shake. "Deal? No more games of telephone. Just open and upfront."
"Am I to assume this is a secret truce?"
"We can continue letting Gail think she's running the show, if you think that'll be easiest. Just. . ." I'm fighting extra hard to keep eye contact so my eyes don't wander down to his bare chest. "No more secrets. Between us, at least. It's not very productive."
Ben yawns again and shakes my hand. "I don't want to talk about Gail anymore. And speaking of secrets, I believe you were going to share some of your own before our impending doom cut you short."
As emotionally exhausting as it is, I try my best to explain to him what life was like before landing here. I explain being a god is like watching tv, acutely aware of the fact that it was—in my case—literally watching tv. I cheer for my favorite humans and boo the ones making poor decisions, but I can't interfere. I watch. I judge. I laugh. I cry. That's it. That's all. Then, one day, I wake up here, and that's why I know so much and so little all at the same time.
He has so many questions about my human life, but I only give him the brief overview of my family—partially because it's making me homesick to think about them, and partially because I don't want to be reminded of all the bad memories. I tell him about my grandmother, and my strict Catholic upbringing, and—
"Wait, wait, wait, wait. . . You were—" Ben leans forward, barely able to get the question out through a disruptive bout of laughter. "You were evangelized?" I don't see what's so funny, but Ben has to hold a hand pressed tight against his stitches as he winces and laughs at the same time.
“What’s wrong with you?”
"This is officially the most absurd thing I've ever heard in my life. You do realize you can't tell anyone?" Ben wheezes, still laughing. "Your people are absolutely not ready to learn you've been converted to the enemy." He calms down a little, only to lay back in the sand and break out in more laughter. "The Norse goddess of war. . . is Catholic."
I roll my eyes, but his laughter and my own lack of sleep is making me laugh. We sit in the sand, laughing like lunatics, absorbing the heat from the fire until our clothes have finally dried.
Ben happily tugs his shirt back on. "There's nothing quite like being dry. Ready to head back?" With a few kicks of sand, Ben extinguishes the fire at the precise time the skies open up wide and it begins to pour.
We look up at the sky in bewilderment, look at each other as we're immediately drenched all over again, and practically choke to death as the laughter hits us even harder than before.
I could handle the Norsemen's taunting questions when we returned to the Temple early and empty handed. I could handle Gail's disappointed expression as I refused to give her details about what happened. I could handle renegotiating the timetable of this wedding to allow Ben and me an entire day to just sleep.
What I can't seem to handle is Ben's constant snorting of air in a losing battle to keep from laughing at the obscene garish costume Gail forced me to wear for the wedding.
"A vacuum threw up on you?" His eyebrows are set seriously, but a small smile twitches at the corners of his mouth as he takes in the fact that Gail covered my hair in ash for some reason. "You've decided to become a professional chimneysweep?"
"One more word," I threaten, frowning with everything I've got. "One more word and I'll break your kneecaps."
"I'm only guessing," he defends. "Although, now that you mention it, you do look like an unhinged Vegas showgirl who barely escaped a fire. Can't be more uncomfortable than my collar though."
"I understand this ridiculous dress," I hiss from across the table. "It's the ash I don't understand. You're wearing, what? A suit? You poor thing. Remind me again why I'm supposed to feel sorry for you?"
"You make a valid point," he says.
"You're just jealous that I have a cape."
"Am I that transparent?" Ben turns from where I'm seated at his kitchen table, starts to review the final treaty, stops, knits his brows in a bewildered frown, and turns to look at me. "Break my kneecaps? What kind of Italian family raised you?"
Gail opens the door to Ben's house, momentarily flooding the entryway with the insane volume of chatter and traditional music coming from the courtyard. With a snap of the door, the noise quiets to a low yet constant hum.
"So sorry about that," she says. Dumping a pile of bobby pins on the table, she gets back to work pinning my hair up in the most complex mess of braids I've ever seen. "I thought for sure I'd brought enough. Luckily, I was able to borrow some from Juliet."
"Cora?" I catch Ben's eye, and he slides the final page of the treaty across the table. "Do you need to read it again?"
"For the love of Mímir," says Gail. "No, she doesn't need to read it again. Here, Cora. Here's a pen. Sign right here and let's get this over with. It's barely two in the afternoon and half the party's already drunk."
I'm not even entirely sure where one ceremony ends and another begins. One second I'm signing the treaty, then I'm blinking in the sharp sunshine and standing next to Gail as she chugs a mug of alcohol.
"What do we do now?" I ask her.
Gail raises her mug and smiles. "We try to enjoy ourselves."
A woman approaches Gail and the two begin a lively conversation I can't understand. Unsure of what to do with myself, I wander around and try to remain calm at the fact that everyone seems to be in such high spirits. Great, that means this worked. Just have to hold out for a few more hours, and then I can relax and try to figure out a game plan for how to keep myself from devolving into insanity.
Even though both Gail and Ben alluded to the amount of people who were attending the wedding, I am in no way prepared for the reality of it all. As I squeeze through yet another crowd of cheerful party-goers, I stop and watch as Jack finally gives into peer pressure and starts a drinking game with a man who already seems drunk.
Now that I think of it, where are the survivors? I scan the crowd and immediately find Sayid fighting in an arm wrestling match. A few other survivors have been recruited into a round of tug-of-war, with my people and their people dispersed equally on either side of the rope.
I make my way around the different pockets of festivities, sampling foods from various tables laden with bowls and plates. Taking a few fistfuls from a few different platters, I shove the food in my pockets and spare a shameful glance around to ensure nobody saw me. When the coast proves clear, I grab another handful of some kind of dish wrapped in a leaf.
I eventually run into Charlie and Hugo and try to make small talk about musical tastes. Charlie admits to enjoying the traditional wedding tunes while I dive into the one thing my family could actually agree on—a shared love of ABBA. I walk away only when Charlie tries to convince me that disco isn't music.
That's when I see him.
"Jacob?"
"There you are." All smiles, he hands me a bulbous decanter full of liquid. "Brought you the very best wine money can buy. But not as a wedding gift," he adds. "My wedding gift is forgiving you for not inviting me."
"What are you doing here?" Eric and Liv both claimed to never have met Jacob, so why is he out of hiding? I look around at the faces nearest me, but nobody seems to care that he's here. "I thought my people didn't like you?"
"So far most of them are convinced I'm your brother." It's weird seeing him happy. It's even weirder hearing him laugh. "They think my appearance is the ultimate show of peace. But I'm here for the food, of course."
"Of course," I parrot. "Any recommendations?"
"Don't eat anything with a blue ribbon tied around it," he answers and takes a bite of what looks like an empanada. "I was told they're made with repurposed animal meat."
"Lady Cora?"
I look over at the voice and smile a little too hard. "Annie, hi!" I can tell she's drunk, so I overcompensate by focusing all of my energy into seeming like I'm having a good time. I shoot a nervous glance at Jacob, but he's long gone in the ever rotating crowd of faces.
Her eyes immediately travel to the bottle in my hands. "Is that wine?"
"This? Yeah, it's a gift. I don't want it," I add quickly. "Do you want it? Here. You can have it. It's apparently top quality, but don't take my word for it. I don't know anything about wine." I start laughing, still smiling, until my face is in unbearable pain.
Annie happily accepts the wine, uncorks it, and takes a hearty gulp. "It's a nice wedding," she says randomly. "You look nice."
"Thanks."
Annie takes another swig. "Where's Ben?"
"Uh. . ." I look around seriously, as if I know where anyone is. "I'm not entirely sure."
Something dawns on her, and she closes her eyes and lets out a huff of a laugh. "Oh wait, he's probably hiding."
"From?"
"His rugby team. Retired, of course," she adds as if it's obvious. "Team captains have a habit of getting the groom to drink until they vomit before sunset. . . but that's not what I wanted to talk to you about."
Annie keeps getting closer, so I keep taking tiny steps away from her.
"Peregrine won't stop talking about you," she says. There's no real way to know for sure, but judging by how slow and deliberately she's speaking, she's had more than a few drinks before the wine. "I hope she's not bothering you too much. I can talk to her if you'd like. Is she bothering you? You can tell me. Please tell me."
"No, no, no," I plead, wringing my hands and smiling even harder. "She's great. No trouble at all. Don't worry about it."
"I didn't raise them to be afraid of you," Annie continues with a serious expression. "I made up my mind before I had children that I wouldn't tell them what you did. They're loyal to you. My girls and Flint. All of them."
"Oh? Okay. Thank you."
"If you need a sacrifice," she manages to get out before her voice wavers and she slumps against me. "If you ever need a sacrifice in the future, you can kill me."
I try to help support her weight, amazed at how quickly I feel like I'm going to throw up. "Annie, listen, I'm not going to kill anyone—"
"It's okay. You can kill me. Just—" Annie grabs a fistful of my dress, panting the rest of the words through a fresh batch of tears. "Please don't hurt my children. Don't hurt my children. I'll do anything. Just leave them alone."
Time slows. Noise dulls. All I hear and feel is my rapidly quickening heartbeat. I free myself from Annie's grip and hold a tight fist against my cramping stomach. Breathe. Just breathe. In through the mouth, out through the nose. Panic attacks don't last forever. You just have to—
It's not working.
I spin around, aimless, my mind blank. A man runs into me, or maybe I run into him. I can't understand what anyone is saying, and I need to get away from all these smiling faces. I need to get away from this stupid party.
Slumping against a tree bordering the barrack houses, I'm finally able to get my stuttering breaths under control. As more oxygen returns to my brain, I suddenly remember my pockets are full of food and take a bite of a fishy scented brittle. It tastes horrible, but I find myself mechanically reaching for another bite after bite after bite, when I finally force myself to stop.
What the hell am I doing with my life? I'm hiding from my own party, eating food that tastes disgusting in an attempt to feel better about something that can never be forgiven. How many people's lives did I ruin? How many adults on this island are completely dysfunctional because of me? I can't even blame Dolores for trying to kill me. In fact, good for her. Maybe that would be better for everyone—
"OW!" A sharp pain swells on the top of my head just as an apple tumbles into my lap. I reach up and rub at the pain, simultaneously craning my head back to look into the tree. "What are you doing up there?"
"I was here first." Ben sits on one of the highest branches, carefully concealed by the tree's abundance of leaves. "What are you doing down there? Please tell me you're not going to start crying again. I'm sorry for the apple. I was aiming for your lap."
A distant bout of laughter erupts from the party.
"Did I kill Annie's parents?" I struggle to fight against my quivering jaw just to spare me the embarrassment.
There's no fanfare in his immediate response. "You decapitated her mother.”
“And her dad?”
“You stuck both hands in his mouth and tore his jaw off." Ben takes a bite of his own apple, chewing thoughtfully before continuing. "Why are you asking about the dead? Shouldn't you know where they are and how they died?"
I don't answer. I can't answer. All I can do is cover my ears with the palms of my hands and try to think of literally anything else.
"Here." Ben has silently climbed down the tree and holds out a croquette in offering. Without waiting for me to accept it, he grabs the seafood brittle out of my hand and chucks it into the distance. "Nobody actually eats those. They're just a wedding tradition. These are much better."
I laugh through the tears when I see the basket nestled in the crook of his arm. "Did you steal all of the croquettes?"
"They taste so much better when I don't have to make them."
"I'm sorry. I don't know what to do." I'm acutely aware of how close he's sitting, but he doesn't prod for answers and seems engrossed in the food. "I just had a mother beg me not to kill her children because I traumatized her in the past. How am I supposed to apologize for something like that?"
"Never put her children in danger, or give her a reason to worry about their safety. That's about as close to an apology as you're ever going to get."
"What happened to him?" Ben was right about these croquettes. I reach for another. "Ragnar?"
"Your people used to travel much more freely between islands," he answers, and I notice how much easier it seems for him to speak now that he's had a day to rest. "What happened to Ragnar was tantamount to a fluke. He was returning to Hydra when he was attacked by the. . . other monster. Hazel was with him. That was a year ago."
"That's why she doesn't come visit Alex anymore," I mumble to myself. I reach for another croquette and think about the message Ragnar gave me on the ship. "Oh, that's what he meant. He was trying to assuage her guilt."
Ben pushes the basket closer to me and takes more food for himself. "Does that happen often?"
"What? Communicating with the dead? Only since I died."
"You ever talk to my parents?"
I stop mid-bite and stare at him in horror. "I killed your parents?"
"No."
"I killed your dad?"
"No, he did that himself. Said some things about other people's wives that he shouldn't have," he clarifies. "Cora." I look up, but his eyes are focused off in the distance as he takes another bite. "You spell it different than Kore, but it's pronounced the same. Does that mean the Greek pantheon exists?"
"You ask too many questions when you've had decent sleep."
"There you are," a deep voice booms, and I turn to look up at one of the tallest, beefiest men I've ever seen in my entire life. "I've been looking everywhere for you."
Ben smiles at the man, but his words come out exhausted. "Well, you found me."
As if picking up a kitten, the man reaches down and lifts Ben up off his feet, tucking him under his armpit and tussling his hair. "How's my favorite bear boy?"
"Cora," Ben wheezes, still trapped in the massive man's grip, "this is Kyle. Team captain back in our rugby days."
"Kyle," I repeat, already smiling up at the drunk norseman. You have won the funniest viking name I've heard so far, my good sir. "Is that short for something?"
"Short for something?" Kyle lets out a booming laugh. "I'm the farthest thing there is from short, my lady. This one however," he shouts even louder, shaking Ben around like a rag doll. "This one was a good gamble! No one else would have him on their team, but I knew he'd be useful. Our ace in the hole! Ha ha! Darted right through enemy forces like a rat."
"You couldn't have picked any other animal comparison?" Ben asks, and Kyle breaks out into more laughter, finally setting him back down on his feet.
"Bear boy?" I whisper.
"Our team name," he explains.
I stare at the both of them in bewildered amusement. The most surprising thing is realizing Ben has friends after all. Are these the men he was laughing with at Poppy's engagement party?
"There's the bears," Ben continues, "boars, wolves, and falcons."
"The falcons! I hate the falcons! The falcons can suck my balls, ah—pardon me, my lady," Kyle apologizes, suddenly looking sheepish. "I'm a little drunk. Speaking of which, you look remarkably sober, Ben. Let's go fix that."
As night falls, I anticipate most of my people passing out and falling asleep in the grass, but unfortunately the party only seems to intensify. At one point I'm corralled into the middle of the courtyard, and I look around in the sky, expecting fireworks or some other nighttime entertainment. As more and more people gather near, I begin to worry. I lean closer to Ben and whisper, "What's going on? Why are they all just staring at us?"
"Now that you're back, they won't do much without your permission," he answers. "They're waiting for you to start the dance."
"I don't know how to start the dance."
"Here." Ben takes hold of my shaking hand, lacing his warm fingers through mine. "I'll show you."
It looks easy, and that's why it's so frustrating. Ben actually knows what he's doing—each step in time to the drums in what looks like simple footwork—but when I try to emulate him, it's like my feet and my brain disconnect. At least everyone else has started dancing, so I don't have an audience to snicker at my attempts.
"Don't be discouraged," says Ben, as if he could read my mind. "It is more difficult than it looks. Try closing your eyes for a second and get a sense of the beat before trying to copy me."
Just as I think I'm catching on to the rhythm and footwork, a new song starts and a completely different dance begins. I'm sweaty and embarrassed and covered in ash, but when all of the people nearest us grab their partners hands and start hopping in a circle formation, I rush to copy them. "This is a viking hoedown from hell," I tell an amused looking Ben. "The Christian one, too. Not the cool Norse one. Oh, wow. Don't look now." I nod my head conspiratorially towards one of the massive cases holding the mead. "You're officially off the hook for the night. Gail is absolutely wasted."
Ben leans in close to the side of my face, so he doesn't have to shout over the roaring crowd. “Why haven't you asked about the tattoo on my back?”
His breath tickles a loose strand of hair near my ear, but I don’t move away. “What are you talking about?”
“I know you saw it on the beach.”
“What about it? I’m more curious about where your other one is.” I pull away and narrow my eyes. "Is this Gail approved flirting?"
“Don't insult me,” he retorts, smiling. “If this were Gail approved, I'd never have clearance to ask to see your ankles.”
“Can’t see them anyway in these boots.”
“The night is young.”
“How are you not drunk, by the way?” We break apart, spin once, and rejoin. "I thought Kyle was supposed to make you vomit before nightfall?"
"Ah, well, fortunately he'd already gotten a head start before he found me. I simply waited for him to knock one back so I could toss my serving in the grass while he was distracted.” Ben raises his eyebrows in amusement. “He thinks I've had four horns full.”
"Genius." As the song ends, I take note of how the jumping and rushing around the courtyard has made my feet sore and swollen in my boots. "Well, not that this hasn't been fun, but I'm exhausted. Do you think Jane would mind if I crashed on her couch? I don't feel like sailing back to Hydra tonight."
Ben tilts his head ever so slightly in confusion, his eyes momentarily widening with understanding. "Oh. I'm. . . Cora, I'm sorry, I thought. . . I thought surely Gail would have told you."
I can feel my brows pulling themselves into an automatic frown. "Told me what?"
"The wedding ends at sunrise. You're not allowed to leave the circle until then."
"Circle?" I spin around just as a long loop of women lock arms together, chaining us within the parameter of the courtyard. "Wait. . . sunrise?"
Ben is suddenly swarmed by women, and it's then that I realize that the only people enclosed in the dance circle are women. I can't understand what they're saying to him, but he nods and responds in Norse and they leave him alone.
"It would seem I'm being expelled from the dance-floor," Ben tells me, not seeming particularly aggravated. As if to prove he was joking, Ben offers the most genuine smile I've ever seen on him. "Enjoy yourself."
"Whoa, wait." I reach out and grab hold of his hand as an unfamiliar surge rushes up from my stomach, filling my head with endorphins. "Where are you going?"
"Oh," he exhales. "I'll be around here somewhere. Puking an obscene amount of alcohol, if the rest of my team has anything to say about it."
A confusing feeling settles in the pit of my abdomen. "Do you have to go?"
"Afraid so."
"Do you think they'll let you stay if I ask?" I feel my face burn at his curious expression. "You're the only sober person I know here. What am I supposed to do for the next five or six hours?"
"What everyone else is doing," he answers. "Drink."
"I don't drink." Yes, well, I also said that I'd never get married, and I'm literally at my own wedding right now. "Ive never. . ." I don't know why, but I'm suddenly embarrassed. "I've never had alcohol before."
"You can drink or you can dance." Ben's expression suddenly softens when he realizes how uncomfortable I am. "You don't have to drink if you don't want to. Do what makes you happy." Another round of women begin yelling at him to leave the circle. He gives my shoulder a light squeeze before disappearing into the female mob.
I am so unbelievably bored. How long has it been? How much longer until I can leave this circle and take a nap? Would anyone object if I just took a nap right now in the grass?
All of the Norse women know each other and have broken off in their own specific cliques—drinking, laughing, gossiping, and dancing together. Nobody pays me any mind.
I am a literal god, and I still can't make friends.
When I finally see a familiar face, I make a beeline for her.
"Well, well, well, if it isn't little miss world peace." Jane holds up a wobbly arm in a toast and then downs the horn in a few gulps. "You need a refill?"
“I'm not drinking.”
“What do you mean you're not drinking?”
“Not a fan of alcohol. Not a fan of drunks,” I elaborate when she pushes the matter.
“That's bullshit. It's your wedding. One horn isn't going to get your drunk. Come on," she orders, holding out her horn. "Get me a refill while you're at it, your majesty."
I wander around in search of one of those tubs filled with mead when a women calls me to a table. "Enjoying the festivities, my lady?" She scoops Jane's horn full of mead and hands it back to me.
The realization hits me like a brick.
I just got married. I just broke the most important promise I ever made myself. I'm married and Jane's right. One horn isn't going to get me drunk. Isn't that the sinful part of drinking? You can drink if you want. Jesus used to drink wine. You just can't get drunk. One horn won't get me drunk.
I inhale and ask, "Can I have another, please?"
"Oh," the woman says in surprise. "Of course, my lady. Be careful!"
I don't bother explaining only one horn is for me.
Jane lights up when she sees I have two horns. "You got one for yourself? That's more like it! Come on, I'll do one if you do one. Skol, skol, skol," she chants, grabs her horn, clanks them together, and downs it in a few gulps.
I plug my nose and chug, expecting the burn of alcohol. All I taste when I unplug my nose is a terrible earthy aftertaste. "That didn't taste anything like alcohol."
"Who made this weak brew?" Jane sniffs her cup. “I swear, if they let Helga back into the brewery… ugh, that was actually pretty disgusting. Get me one from a different batch, will you?”
I return with two more horns, not intending to drink mine. Jane downs hers in a few gulps.
“Much better,” she gasps and wipes her mouth. “So, what do you think?”
“About what?”
“About what?” she mocks in a drunken singsong voice. “The wedding, Cora. What do you think about the wedding?”
I shrug. “It’s nice.”
“That’s not very specific.” Without me offering, Jane grabs my full horn and takes a sip. “Hey, can you do me a favor? Take it easy on him. Ben,” she clarifies. “He’s had a shit life.”
I don’t know what to do with my hands, so I tug some gold embroidery on my wedding dress.
“I mean, most of us have had a shit life,” she continues. “But he’s had. . . you know, a shit life. I kinda hate seeing the poor bastard so sad. He stays out of my way, so he’s automatically not on my shit list.”
“What was so. . . shit about it?” I stumble over the swear, having never actually said it aloud before.
Jane blows raspberries and coughs a laugh. “You should know,” she accuses. “It was entirely your fault. And. . . and. . . why is. . . why is the table purple?” Jane holds her hands up to inspect them. “What did you give me? I don’t think that was alcohol. What the hell is—Oh, shit. Oh, no."
"What?"
Jane looks down at me with wide eyes. "Was that the Beserkr Bride Tea?"
"The what?"
"Where did you get the cups from?"
I point behind me. "At that table."
"Which one?" She sounds panicked, so of course my stomach begins to cramp with worry. "That table? The one with the ribbon on it?"
"I. . . yes? Jane," I yell over the festivities, my heart sinking. "Jane, what was in that? Jane." I grab her by the wrists. "What's in the Beserkr Bride Tea?"
"Shrooms!" Jane shakes my shoulders in return, looking terrified. "You gave me shrooms, you crazy bitch! This is supposed to be an exclusive religious experience for the bride, not me!"
"I didn't know! It wasn't labeled! I thought it was mead!"
"Oh shit," Jane screams. "I think mines hitting!"
I turn and run, as if I can simply outrun this problem, and I find I am weightless. Should I stick a finger down my throat and throw it up? Is that how this works? Or is it too late? I need help, but all of these women are drunk. Each beat of my heart pulsates throughout my entire body until I can feel the individual blood vessels under the layers of skin.
Whatever was in that drink has already started to take effect because all the pain in my feet is gone. I walk past the core of dancing women and find we are surrounded. Enclosing us, an outer circle of sober women stand linked together.
"My lady," one of them asks, "do you need something?"
I smile and wave at her. "I need to find my husband." A whole new wave of endorphins flows up from my stomach and into the back of my head at the realization I have a husband. "Can I please get by?"
"Our chain will not break until sunrise," she answers proudly. "Your husband is at the other end of the circle. See if you can get his attention."
Despite my initial panic, I'm smiling when I finally spot Ben standing amongst a loud, rambunctious group. I jump, weightless, waving my arms so he'll see me over the women guarding the outer circle, but the sky is suddenly hanging much lower, and I get distracted by the stars.
"Goddess," the men cheer happily. One of them jumps onto a table to dance and immediately falls off.
"Cora," Ben addresses me with a small smile. As he walks closer to the wall of women, I notice he's holding a full horn and shows absolutely no signs of having drank alcohol, so I guess he's successfully tricked his rugby teammates. "Giving up already? We're quite a few hours from. . . are you all right?"
I only partially hear him because I'm so busy trying to catch a star. Are they supposed to be this close to Earth? I hope they don't burn my hand. I should put one in my pocket. Oh! Maybe Ben wants one?
"What are you doing?" Ben's question sounds especially suspicious, and when I look at him, he seems worried.
"Ben." Try as I might to fight it, my smile only gets stretched farther across my face until I physically cannot smile any wider. "I've made a horrible mistake."
A blast of feedback sounds through the PA system, and the band dies down as everyone looks up at the speakers in confusion. "I hope you can all hear this. DJ Pace is in the house tonight! This one goes out to the bride, despite my better judgement. Cheers!" There's a crackle, and then the familiar opening beats to Abba's Lay All Your Love On Me begin to play.
Charlie? I look up at the swirling vortex of night sky and definitely know I'm under the influence of something, but I no longer care. It doesn't matter anymore. Nothing matters anymore except dancing, and I'm missing out.
I squeal happily and turn to leave.
Ben reaches past the women and grabs my sleeve in a vice grip. "Please, let me through," he begs, but the guardian nearest Ben looks dangerously close to punching him.
"It's ok," I tell her. "He can come in."
"I'm sorry." She gives me a pained look. "Men are not permitted inside, my lady."
"It's fine," I reassure her, trying my best not to laugh. "Groom exception. Let him in. I command it."
After a brief exchange with the women on either side, they relent with a reluctant nod, and Ben slips through.
Pouring out his mead onto the grass, he quickly throws the strap over his shoulder so the horn hangs across his back and frees both his hands. I try to walk backwards into the fray of the party, but he's grabbed hold of my forearms to steady me. "What's wrong?" he asks.
"Have you ever wanted to know what it'd be like to be in an episode of Scooby-Doo?"
Ben narrows his eyes in confusion. "I'm not following."
"You're really attractive,” I say, taking a step closer and pressing up against him. Staring into someone's eyes has never been this easy. "Do you want to make out with me?"
I wait for an answer, but he just stares.
"Oh no. You don’t want to make out with me?” I look down at my damp palms and watch my multicolored sweat sparkle in the moonlight. Another quick rush of happiness gets complicated by a small burst of panic at the rate my heart is beating. I hold up my sweaty hands to show Ben the weird colors, and then I start screaming in horror.
Ben turns to the wall of women and yells, "What did you people give her?"
“What's going on? I don't . . . I don't like this.” I grit my teeth to keep from crying. "I think I'm dying. Am I dying?” I grab a fistful of Ben’s vest and tug him closer. “Please don't let me die again!”
"You're not dying." He sounds scared, and it makes me feel better knowing he cares. "What did they give you?"
I love the feeling of his hands on me. I don't ever want him to let go. I sigh and lean against his chest. "Dance with me."
"Cora, show me what you took."
In my attempts to stifle a laugh, it comes bursting out in one loud, slow motion honk. I step back, swinging his arms from side to side in time with the music as it speeds up and slows down and speeds back up again. I am an unstoppable dancing machine. I don’t think I’ve ever moved like this before. Suddenly, I cannot stop walking backwards.
Ben follows me, always staying close enough to catch me as I stumble around. He keeps me from falling yet again, and in thanks I lean up and wrap both arms around his neck, pulling him down for a kiss. But I never get it. He reaches up and pulls my arms halfway off him before I start fighting back. I’m not even trying, but Ben is giving it everything he’s got, straining to pull my arms down to my sides. He’s making very slow progress, but it impresses me all the same.
“Wow, you’re really strong.” I praise in a breathy huff against his face. “But not strong enough.” Then I hoist him high above my head.
"Put me down," he yells. "Cora, put me down, now!"
“I’m sorry. I drank one too many horns," I admit and place him back on his feet. "They keep my feet from hurting. Look, they don't even hurt anymore!"
"So," he says, straightening his suit and pausing to appraise me, "you're just drunk?"
"I think so?" I stare at my hand and then slice the air and watch as the movement lags so badly it looks like I have five separate hands. "I don't know what that feels like."
"Ah." It's almost too much to bear when his brow relaxes and he smiles. "I see."
"You're not dancing."
"I'm not supposed to be in here." He turns back towards the wall of women. "If you're okay, I have to leave—"
I don't mean to jerk him back around quite as hard as I do, but it's even more difficult to contain my strength surges in this state. His eyes fill with surprise as he stumbles into me. “I don't want you to leave,” I tell him. “I want you to dance with me.”
“I’m not supposed to—”
“Well, I say you are. Dance with me.”
I watch his eyes dart from one side of my face to the other before he relents. Ben twirls me out and back in again. I forget everything Ben taught me about dancing and start flapping my arms like a chicken. I've never danced with a man before, and the combination of his well-groomed appearance and the cool night air makes it impossible to focus on anything other than him. I want to tell him to wear a suit all the time. Instead, I grab his chin and move his head from one side to the other. "You have such a nice nose."
Ben opens his mouth to say something, but he ends up laughing instead.
"If I'm Freyja, and Freyja's a witch. . ." I release him and flap my arms like my life depends on it. "Why can't I fly?"
Hands grab me around the middle, and Ben makes a grasping attempt to keep me in his possession, but there are too many women vying for my attention. I'm suddenly flying through the night in a swirl of colorful cotton skirts. I spin with a woman only to be guided to another who kisses my forehead and twirls me into yet another smiling face. Everyone is so happy to see me.
Charlotte is trying to tell me something, all smiles, but I cannot hear what she's saying. It doesn't matter anyway because she is promptly sucked into the blob of a crowd and becomes nothing but another hopping body of joy.
I have so many friends here. It feels good to be liked.
Flashes of laughing faces, the brush of grass against my elbows as I fall, a woman's insistence I lean my head back, the rim of another horn against my lips as I close my eyes and chug the tea that no longer tastes rancid. Before I can finish the contents, someone rips it out of my hands.
From out of the chaotic happiness, I hear Ben asking, "What is this? What are you giving her?" I open my eyes and watch him sniff the horn in an effort to deduce what the tea is. "Where is your water?"
"This is our water," someone yells mid-twirl. "And you're not supposed to be in here."
Time slows and blurs out the whole world except for him. I take in his dress-shirt and vest, the dark colors highlighting everything I find attractive about his features. He's the most handsome man at this party. I push my way between two women and reach up to cup the sides of his face. "You're so beautiful."
This gets his attention, and he flinches slightly at the touch. "What?"
"Kiss me, Benjamin." I have never, in my entire life, felt this euphoric. "I think I'm in love with you."
Ben stares, unblinking, a million unreadable thoughts behind his eyes. "Are you high?" I try to kiss him again, but he leans away before I make contact. "Cora," he says firmly, "sit. Right here. Sit down. Don't move."
My mouth is unbelievably dry. It's getting harder to concentrate on one specific thing. I watch as Ben has a very angry conversation with the punch bowl woman. I stand up to tell him to leave her alone, but I'm stopped by an offering of more mead. I grab at it to quench my thirst, gulping as fast as I can.
"No!" Ben intercepts, rushing over to hold the horn out of my reach. "No more of that. Let's go find some water."
I'm so happy Ben's here, and he's mine, and he has a steady arm around me. The contact tingles with the slight pressure of each finger. His cologne swirls in a visible cloud of gold, enveloping me, perfectly in tune with the bass of my beloved Abba. It feels safe. It feels like love.
Ben spots another drink headed my way and glares at the holder to tell them to stop, so I take the opportunity to push up on my tiptoes and rest my head on his unsuspecting shoulder. My nose slides against his neck. I inhale and it all goes straight between my legs. "Mmm," I hum. My tongue darts out and licks where I feel his pulse.
Ben's grip on me tightens. "Jane," he says loudly. "Jane? I need you to—"
"Huuuuuh? Whaaaaaaat," Jane shouts happily. "Oh, Linus! Whatever you do, doooooo noooooot drink the tea." I'm not sure what she's doing with her shoulders, but it looks fun. She lunges forward and pulls me towards her, only to push me back out and back in again, both of us laughing as we accidentally knock over multiple women. Jane suddenly yanks me close as she leads us around in some sort of ballroom dance. "Listen," she yells over the fray, "I think I want to tell Charlotte I'm in love with her."
I gasp exaggeratedly, my cheeks aching from my smile. "That's a good idea!"
Jane's nod wobbles comically as her eyes widen at my excitement. "Yeah?"
"Yes, definitely! You should definitely go do that right now!"
"Yeah?"
"Yeah!"
"Yeah?"
"YEAH!" I grab her shirt to pull her down to my level so I can kiss her forehead. "You've been blessed! GO! GO! GO! GO!"
"Gail's drunk," Ben announces. "Annie's drunk. Jane's drunk. Who here isn't drunk?"
I raise my hand. "I'm drunk."
"Yes, we've established that." Ben adjusts his grip on me as we're jostled through the crowd. "Come on, we're getting water in you one way or another."
“No water," I moan, grabbing his swirling face. I just want him to kiss me, but I cannot keep track of his mouth as it becomes one, then two, then three, then one again. “I want something else inside me right now.”
"Why is this happening," I hear him mumble miserably under his breath. Instead of looking embarrassed, he just looks incredibly sad. "Cora, I need you to listen to me. Ok? Are you listening?"
"I'm listening."
"You see those women over there? Look, the outer circle? I need you to—what. . . what are you doing?"
Flinging myself down into the grass doesn't hurt at all. I roll to a stop and flop my arms at my sides. "I'm a bowling pin."
Ben closes his eyes for a second before continuing. "You see the women over there? I want you to tell them you're not feeling well and need to go home. They won't listen to me, but they'll listen to you." Our eyes lock and I want nothing more than for him to rip all my clothes off. "What are you going to tell them?"
I just want to impress him. I want him to know I listened to what he said. "I don't feel well and I need to go home."
"Yes, perfect." He looks relieved as he helps me stand and we maneuver our way through the dancing crowd to the very fringes of the circle. "What are you going to tell them?" he asks one final time.
I smile, happy that I know the answer. "I don't feel well and I need to go home."
"Pardon us," Ben says politely. "We need through. I know it's not sunrise, but I'm sure you can make an exception for the bride," he pleads. "She's not feeling well."
"I feel great," I say and wink dramatically. "He's just trying to get me home so we can. . ." One hand forms an O that I stick my pointer finger in. I look up at him, surprised that he looks comedically betrayed. Wait, that's not what I was supposed to say.
"That's not true," Ben tells the frowning woman nearest him. "She's dehydrated and delirious."
"Just try to enjoy yourself a little longer, my lady. Only a few hours more and we can let you pass," one of them tells me kindly before sternly looking back up at Ben, "after sunrise."
"Can somebody please just get her some water? That's all I'm asking for! Drag a hose over here for all I care! Hey!" Ben yells around the women, "Excuse me, Hugo? Hugo! Hugo! Are you drunk?"
"Uh, no?"
"Then you're a rare find. I would very much eternally be in your debt if you could please bring Cora some tap water. If I leave the circle now, they'll never let me back in."
All I can discern as truth is my legs have gone limp, I'm slumped against Ben, my head is flopped backwards and my mouth is wide open. Am I making any sound? I have no idea.
"Dude," I hear Hugo say. "Is she okay?"
I snap back to attention and cough. "Watch this." I bend my pinkie wildly.
"As soon as possible, Hugo?" Ben prompts.
"Yeah, dude. No problem. One sec."
"Cora," Ben's voice echoes like black silk in the dark. "Cora?"
"Ugh?" I peal one dry eye open and smile when I confirm it's him. "Hi."
"Hi." I feel his hands on either side of my body, steadying me while I sway in the silent sunrise. "Congratulations. You did it. Look," he says, nodding at the mounds of slumbering bodies nearby. "You're the last one conscious."
"Yay." I yawn. "What do I win?"
"You get to sleep in an actual bed instead of the grass." The pressure of his hands shifts to my hip, and suddenly my feet are moving. "There we go. This way. No, you don't have to dance anymore."
"I don't want to dance anymore. I'm tired and I don't feel good."
"I know," he soothes. "We're almost home. Excuse us, please."
Somehow, the women of the outer circle still look surprisingly alert as they move aside and offer me their congratulations.
"Ughhh." I want to go to sleep, but I cannot take another step. "Ben, I can't walk anymore."
One second I'm standing, and the next I'm cradled against his chest. Nobody has ever carried me before, unless you count Erik's piggyback ride to the barracks after first seeing Jacob. I like being held. The fact that he's able to carry me so easily just makes me love him even more.
There's the sound of pipes running water. A cup is against my lips, and I gulp.
I'm sitting. I'm finally sitting, and it makes me happier than anything else that's happened tonight. I'm on a bed. I want to sleep. "My feet hurt."
"I'm working on it." Ben keeps one hand on my calf as he unlaces the boots, and the touch brings my heartbeat back to my attention.
I hiss when he finally manages to pull one off.
"Don't heal yourself," he says gently, and my heart pounds harder. "I'm going to clean this up the good old-fashioned way." There's cotton balls and a bottle of something next to him on the floor. I watch as he shakes medicine onto a cotton fluff and very carefully cleans the bloody cuts where the boots rubbed me raw.
I did this for my mother when she was hurt.
A flash of memory resurfaces. My mother, bloody, skin ripped to shreds. Blood on the ground. Blood smeared across my hands. I swipe at her wounds to clean them, but there's so many. There's just so many. This is all my fault.
"Forgive me," Ben apologizes as the tears spill down my cheeks. "I should have warned you it might sting a little."
He's nothing but a fuzzy blur through my watery eyes, so I blink until I can see him more clearly. "Why are you being so nice to me?"
"What's 13 plus 10?"
"Aghhh," I groan. "I can't think."
"Good." Ben doesn't look up. Instead, I watch his eyelids flutter a few times as he continues to swab medicine over my cuts. "I've been so worried about your return, I find myself unsure of how to behave around you. For years I've stressed over the details. Failsafes. Plan B's and C's and D's incase. . . incase another incident happened." Finally, he says, "But you're not the monster I was expecting."
"Aww, thanks."
His eyes quickly roll up to the ceiling before he caps the bottle and pushes up off the floor. "Let me wrap your feet, and then you can go to sleep. How does that sound?"
"My whole mystique is ruined." I pout. "You've seen my ankles." I smile when I hear him huff a tired laugh. I love making him laugh. I love the sound of his voice. I want him to keep talking to me. "Show me your ankles, handsome."
"You are going to be so embarrassed when you wake up." Ben looks like he's struggling not to smile as he blurs in and out of focus.
I smile and lie back against a pillow, my feet feeling even better as he ties a protective layer of gauze around each medicated foot. This is the kindest, most intimate thing someone has ever done for me. "Don't you want to kiss the disco dancing champion?" I sigh in an exhausted whine. “Please? I've never kissed someone before.”
“Tell you what,” he whispers. Ben leans down, and I flood with adrenaline, but he stops short and flits his eyes down to my mouth before returning my stare. “Ask me again when you sober up.”
I smile. “Ok.”
"Goodnight, Cora."
I'm asleep before I can complain.
Chapter 17: What Have I Done To Deserve This?
Chapter Text
New York City, 2014
I don't even know why I'm here.
Another drunk body presses up against me, knocking me off balance as I try to make my way further onto the dance floor as shitty pop music blasts loud enough to deafen someone a mile away.
I don't even like my roommate, so as to why I agreed to go clubbing with her to ensure randos don't try and take her home is beyond me. As far as I'm concerned, clubbing is a hot, claustrophobic, dangerous waste of time. Who wants to be surrounded by sweaty strangers who may or may not drug your drink?
Besides, I don't even drink. So that means I get to follow my wasted roommate around the club as she sways into guy after guy after girl after guy so I can ensure none of them try to slip something into the glass in her hand. A dead roommate is not on my Christmas list, thank you very much.
I check the time and yawn. 2am may be early for some people, but I'm ready to go home.
"Excuse me?"
I turn towards the muffled voice and look up at a man in a suit. Who the hell wears a nice suit to a low end club like this? "What?" I yell at him.
He quickly flashes the contents of a tiny plastic bag, raising a single eyebrow in question. "You here alone?"
Ew. Not even a 'what's your name' or 'how's your night going?' We're skipping straight to the 'want to go to the bathroom and do some blow after you blow me?' What is it with guys and offering me drugs? Is it because I'm blonde and they think I'm stupid? Is it because I'm fat and they think I'm desperate?
"No," I yell back, annoyed. I don't have time for this. "I'm looking for my friend."
"Your boyfriend?"
"I'm not interested, thanks." I hurry to put some distance between me and the creep, pushing and shoving my way through disgusting sticky bodies—slipping a little in a mysterious puddle of either spilled drink or vomit—until I finally find her locked in a random man's embrace. "We need to go," I yell.
"She's not going anywhere," the man coos, "are you honey?"
I tug her arm, attempting to pull her away from the stranger holding her upright.
I've never been in a fist-fight before, but for a horrifying second, I brace myself for the very real possibility that I might have to fight this much taller, much stronger man who currently has an iron grip around my blackout drunk roommate.
His voice carries over the music as he glares down at me. "Who are you?"
I open my eyes as wide as I can and scream with absolutely everything I've got, "GET YOUR HANDS OFF MY SISTER! HELP! HELP!"
My screams have attracted some attention, and the man quickly decides it's not worth it and sets my roommate free. Then this grown ass man leans down close to my face, pushes the tip of his nose upwards with his index finger, and oinks.
It's a miracle in itself that I can support her enough to get us both outside and into a taxi. Only after I've buckled her seatbelt do I allow myself to close my eyes and decompress.
"He totally wanted to bang you." She slumps against my shoulder as we bounce over another manhole in the backseat of the taxi, her words so slurred I can barely understand her. "He totally wanted to bang both of us."
"Mm-hm."
"No, like, he totally did."
"Mm-hm."
"Cora. . . babe. . . you need to, like. . . believe in yourself. Ya know?"
"Mm-hm."
With a final sigh, she's fast asleep. A chill runs up my spine as I watch her chest rise and fall, counting the seconds in-between each rise and each fall, making sure she's still breathing. For a moment I shift my attention to the dark New York streets, but a choking fear forces me to double-check she is, in fact, still breathing.
What would her mother think? Doesn't she have any shame? Any self preservation? What if I hadn't gone out with her tonight? What would that man have done to her?
I continue to watch her breathe, comforted, at least, by the thought that I'll never have to know what she's going through right now. I'll never have to worry about waking up in a stranger's bed. I'll never have to suffer the fear of not remembering.
"I took the liberty of bandaging your feet last night." Ben holds out another cup of water, and I happily accept it. "I hope you don't mind," he continues. "It seemed a waste to use your abilities on such a small injury. I didn't want you to wake up tired and confused. Although," he adds with a twitch of his eyebrows, "I don't believe you'll remember much of last night regardless."
I feel the bandages around my feet from under the blanket, but I have no memory of receiving them. "I can't believe—" I bring a hand up to my tightly closed mouth in an attempt to keep my sick from spilling all over the bed. Taking in slow but heavy breaths, I focus all of my efforts on not throwing up. "I can't believe people do this for fun. It feels like I have the flu."
"You might find this hard to believe, but I've never been invited to one of their weddings before. I was unaware they would be serving. . . whatever it was you were drinking." Ben takes a seat on what I assume is a kitchen chair he dragged in here. "You're just dehydrated. Keep sipping water and you'll start to improve. Oh, by the way. Did your tattoo finally heal?"
"My what?"
"Kidding." I catch his smile as he turns to grab a pitcher of water so he can top off my glass. "Would you like some breakfast?"
The thought of food makes me bring a hand up to my mouth again. "No," I manage in-between a surprise dry heave. "No thank you." Breathe in. Hold. Breathe out. "I seriously cannot wrap my mind around how people do this recreationally." I pause to give myself a second to think up the last thing I remember, but I don't remember anything after drinking that tea. "Did I. . ." I blanche at all the possibilities and settle for asking the broadest question. "Did I embarrass myself last night?"
Ben brings an espresso cup to his lips and takes a small sip. "I suppose that's a matter of perspective."
"So, that's a yes." I cover my face with a hand. "Did I do anything I need to know about?"
"Need to know is a strong phrasing of things."
I can't help but think back on that night at the club with my roommate. I was so smug. I felt so superior. Look at me now. "I don't like this," I whisper. "This is. . ." Terrifying. Absolutely terrifying. "I don't remember anything. All my memories are of flashing colors, but I don't—" I sit up a little as it finally processes where I am. "Is this your bedroom?"
"It is," he answers, taking another sip. "I had to carry you here this morning."
This morning? It's not currently morning? What time is it? How long have I been here? Judging from the fact that my sleeves match those of my wedding dress, it's safe to say I'm still wearing my clothes from the party. But Ben carried me here, took my boots off, and wrapped my feet up, and I have no memory of any of that happening. None whatsoever. If I don't remember that, what else have I forgotten?
"You. . . you and I. . ." I trail off, not knowing how to ask, but more than that—I don't know if I want the answer. He wouldn't have. That goes against his character.
Then again, it's clear he's not the same Ben from the show. Not exactly. How do I know the fine details of my people's culture? I haven't bothered to ask why the norsemen don't just move to Hydra. Why do they separate the sexes? Even married couples don't live their daily lives on the same island. Is that for the women's benefit? Is this a culture of machismo and dominance that forces them apart for their own good?
If so, then where does that leave Ben? Ben, who grew up in that environment? Who still has a friendship with his old rugby team?
Was that who he was sitting with at Poppy's engagement party? The men who were laughing? Were they all in on it? Cheering for their friend as he weaseled his way into marriage to a deity, all so he could share the ultimate sex story in the locker room?
Or what if it was an accident? What if he got drunk at the party and we were both too out of it to realize what we were doing?
Oh my God, did I have sex for the first time last night and I don't even remember? I'm a statistic. I can't believe I'm a statistic.
All of the subdued nausea comes barreling back. "To—" I start, but I have to huff a few times, trying to catch my breath as my panic reaches a peak and I flush with extreme lightheadedness. "To confirm, last night. . ."
"Yes?"
"You and I. . . we didn't. . ."
"Didn't what?" Ben furrows his eyebrows in confusion, and then he understands my implication and sets his espresso cup and saucer down with a sharp clack that rings continuously in my ears. "I sincerely hope you're not insinuating what I think you are, because if you are, I'm going to be very, very angry."
The frankness in his voice instantly dissolves my fear but leaves me without a response.
"Are you serious?" His question comes out flat, but I can still hear the hurt buried in there somewhere. Without another word, he's up and heading for the exit.
I swell with the overwhelming fear of abandonment. I'm nauseous and confused, and the last thing I want is to be left alone with the uncertainty of not knowing what happened. "I'm sorry. Wait. Wait, Ben, I'm sorry. I just. . . can't remember anything from last night."
Ben spins around, but instead of a deeply furrowed brow or an expressive frown, his face is set in what I've come to realize is a much more frightening blank stare. "You don't seem to understand the severity of such an accusation, so let me explain it to you. Your people torture and hang offenders and don't burn their body afterwards. It is the highest insult they can give a corpse." He reaches the bedroom door and rests a trembling hand on the wall. "What have I ever done to make you think I should be associated with such filth?"
"I'm sorry," I plead, desperately trying to damage control, but I'm dizzy and don't know what to say to fix this. "It's just. . . I'm in your bed."
"And I slept on a chair, if you haven't noticed! You think that was comfortable?" Still standing in the doorway, Ben turns to face me, and this time his expression is furious. "I spent all night following you around to ensure you didn't die of dehydration, and this is the thanks I get? You almost broke my arm."
I'm grasping at straws, calming somewhat because I'm starting to believe him. "You changed out of your suit."
"Because you woke up and vomited on me. Twice. I don't have to listen to this," he huffs under his breath and turns back towards the door. "When you can stomach the thought of food, I'll be in the kitchen. And you got ash absolutely everywhere, by the way."
He closes the door with more force than necessary, and I'm left with only my paranoid thoughts and the gaping holes in my memory.
I'm not sure if the queasy stomachache is because I'm still recovering from last night's party or because I'm anxiously awaiting the perfect apology to magically form in my brain.
Ben sits silently on the couch across the room, seemingly engrossed in a book as he continues to ignore me. I stand in the kitchen, leaning against the counter, watching as water slides off my hair and collects in little droplets by the plate of breakfast Ben made me.
He was right about the ash. Thick streaks of it stained his sheets and both pillowcases. The whole thing just made me feel like more of an asshole, so after I took a shower to clean the ash off my hair and face, I stripped all the bedding and tossed it into the wash downstairs in the basement.
But being down there just escalated my feelings of guilt. Next to the washer, I noticed a single clump of white fur and remembered all over again what had happened to Margo. I remembered all over again that it was my fault.
Ben didn't comment on the fact that I never asked if I could use his shower, and he didn't so much as hum a thank you for doing the laundry unprompted. In fact, even though I've been standing in the kitchen, in full view of him, he hasn't acknowledged my presence at all. As delicious as it was, the omelette he made was perfectly timed to be plated, still hot, and waiting for me on the table by the time I got out of the shower, so he wouldn't have to talk to me.
Finally, the silence becomes too unbearable.
"Hey, I've been meaning to tell you." Little by little, I make my way into the living room. "I have some interesting intel, but I'm sworn to secrecy." Ben doesn't look up from his book. "Okay," I relent and take a seat next to him on the couch. "Listen to this. Jane and Charlotte are. . . a thing."
"Yes, I know," he replies, still reading.
I immediately deflate with disappointment. "She told you?"
"No, I just have functioning eyes." I'm surprised when his eyes finally leave the page and travel up to lock with mine. "The only people on either of these islands who don't know about Jane and Charlotte are Jane and Charlotte. And if you were sworn to secrecy, why are you telling me this?"
"I don't know." I shrink under the gaze of his disappointed stare. "I just thought. . . I don't know."
"Was that your version of an apology? Because I'm afraid it leaves something to be desired. Mainly the apology."
"I'm sorry."
"Are you apologizing for not apologizing? Or was that supposed to be the apology?"
An embarrassed flush heats every inch of my face and neck. "I don't know why you're so mad at me. I didn't accuse you of anything, I just asked a question."
"You shouldn't have had to ask," he snaps back.
"Yes," I agree, "I shouldn't have to ask, but I do. Because guess what? It's actually a very big problem off-island. A lot of people wouldn't have even considered it rape. That's great and all that my people take this seriously, but rapists don't get tortured and killed where I come from. They get a few months jail time, or sometimes just a slap on the wrist. So. . . so. . ." I'm so upset my whole body trembles like a chihuahua. "You don't get to be mad at me for being scared and confused. I don't even know you!"
He doesn't look at me.
I wish I hadn't come over here.
I wish I hadn't sat down next to him.
When he finally speaks, his voice is low and calm. "I understand now what you're saying." I feel his eyes on me and force myself to look over at him. "I was unaware that your people have an. . . unorthodox sense of justice."
"You're telling me you of all people were unaware of the state of the world?"
Ben's blank expression sours into a frown. "What is that supposed to mean?" His book is all but abandoned at this point. I have to push myself up and away from him on the couch to maintain a decent distance as he turns fully in his seat to face me. "What do you mean me of all people?"
"You've been off island before," I snap, still feeling defensive. "I don't know how many times, but I'm guessing it's been enough times to know how horrible—"
"Are we going to have a productive conversation, or are you going to continue lobbing accusations at me?" Ben checks his watch. "Because I have better things to—"
"Stop interrupting me!"
Neither of us are actually yelling, but it feels like we might as well be.
Back and forth. Back and forth. Bickering like our lives depend on it.
"—you have any idea how difficult it was to keep an eye on—?"
"—not a baby, I don't need—"
"—couldn't even stand on your own! What do you mean you—"
"Get your finger out of my face!"
We're standing. I don't know when it happened, and I don't know for how long, but we're standing. Immobile. Each too stubborn to admit defeat.
It takes a long while, but my frantic heartbeat eventually starts to slow, and I calm somewhat. "Can I suggest a compromise?"
Stone-faced as ever, Ben gives a curt nod.
"I will apologize for my misunderstanding, if you apologize for yours."
"I'm sorry you woke up so frightened," he says. "I had tried my best to mitigate that. Cora, I know we did all of this for a truce, but we're still technically married. It is…" Ben twitches his brows upwards, rolling his eyes as if the thought is overwhelmingly burdensome. "It is quite literally my life's purpose to make sure no one hurts you. That includes myself."
"Thanks for the omelette. I'm sorry I got ash everywhere." Even though he's not beaming, he's at least not furious anymore. "And I'm sorry if I insulted you. My reaction this morning wasn't because I think you're a bad person, it was just. . . I've never had memory loss like that before. I panicked. I would have panicked no matter whose bedroom I woke up in." Never again. Never, ever again. Mead and whatever that tea was is henceforth banned from my diet. "Has anyone ever been killed over. . . an accusation?"
"A few," he answers, solemn. "Only one in my lifetime, though. A woman," he clarifies. "It was one of the most chaotic ordeals I've ever seen. Her accuser was nine." Ben raises his eyebrows, his mouth flatlining in agreement with my shocked disgust. "Let's just say there wasn't much left of her body to hang once the other women of Hydra were done with her."
There is no excuse for such a heinous act, so all I can do is try to distract myself from thinking about it. I look away at the far wall and notice a framed childhood photo of Alex. "Where are all the children? I didn't see any at the wedding."
"On Hydra," he answers. "It's interesting, but your people fought over who would stay behind to protect them. I suppose it was more honorable in their minds to make that sacrifice than it was to actually attend the wedding. Cora, what's wrong?"
"I don't know." I take a seat on the couch again. "This is probably going to sound stupid."
"Well, now you've piqued my interest."
"All of this feels too. . . easy. Like, I'm just waiting for something bad to happen."
"What do you mean?" He's quick to sink into the couch next to me. "Did you have a vision?"
"No. That's the thing. I think it's just. . . anxiety." I raise my hands up and wiggle my fingers. "It's a specialty! No offense, but I'm glad this is all over." Embarrassed, I stand up and wish I had something to wear other than my sooty and sweat-stained wedding dress. Oh well. I'll be back on Hydra soon enough, in a fresh outfit, drinking delicious fruit juice under a palm tree. "I wonder if enough people have sobered up to take me back to Hydra."
It's a subtle change in his demeanor—one most people probably wouldn't notice—but I do.
"You've got to be kidding me," I whisper.
"I hate to be the bearer of bad news." Ben fixes me with a pained squint. "But as of this morning, it was decided—in the interest of convenience—to host Poppy and Bjorn's wedding here today. You'll be expected to attend in about—" Ben checks his watch. "—an hour."
I plop down next to Ben at one of the many tables refilled with food. As the traditional band plays yet another song with head-splitting loud drums, I lay my temple down against the wood and mumble, "This is officially the worst migraine I've ever had."
As hard as everyone partied last night, I expected todays festivities to be at least somewhat subdued, but my people just seem to have been emboldened by their hangovers. Only the survivors look as miserable as I feel.
"Ugh," I groan. "I still feel like I'm going to puke. How long do hangovers last?"
"Depends," says Ben. "For alcohol it can vary from a few hours to most of the day. For whatever you had? I have no idea." I expect him to smirk at me, but he doesn't have the usual teasing bite when he asks, "Do you need me to get you anything?"
I let out a lungful of air and frown. "Can you knock me unconscious so I can sleep this off? I'm only half joking."
"I'll gladly knock you unconscious." Someone sits down heavily across the table. "Do you also feel like death?"
I raise my head up just enough to see who's asking. Jane sits, arms crossed, looking miserable and murderous. I cough. "Does it look like I'm enjoying myself?"
"Serves you right," she says. "I woke up on the roof of Beatrice's house with cotton mouth and no memory of how I got up there. You however," she adds with a sly grin, "seem to have had a worse time of it. I heard she threw you up in the air."
"Spun me around over her head," Ben corrects, "but it was equally unpleasant."
"Yeah, yeah." I flop a hand up to wave Jane away, and then I have my first flash of memory. "Oh, by the way, how did it go?"
"How did what go?"
"With Charlotte?"
"What about Charlotte?" Jane stares daggers at me as I realize she doesn't remember my pep talk last night. I must look as horrified as I feel because Jane repeats her question even louder than before. "What about Charlotte?"
"I think you should probably go talk to her."
"Why?" she seethes, although her eyes look more frightened than they do angry. "What happened?"
"Uhh," I start, but I have nothing. "I don't remember everything that was said."
Looking pale as a ghost, Jane stares down at the table and then stands and wanders off like she's just been told she has 3 days to live.
"Well," Ben says, turning to give me his full attention. "Now you have to tell me what happened."
I make a face on her behalf. "While we were all dancing, Jane came to me for a pep talk about Charlotte. Whatever was in that tea loosened her inhibitions to a point of crazed elation. I'm pretty sure she decided to confess—"
No.
Oh, no.
Oh, God, no.
All of my hopes and dreams are rendered meaningless. My world is being sucked into a cringe blackhole, never to be seen or heard from again. I'll never recover from this. This is the end.
I remember. I remember confessing some very embarrassing things to Ben. Not that I remember verbatim everything that I said, but I remember trying to kiss him. Multiple times. And I distinctly remember his horrified expression as he pulled away.
This cannot be happening. Think, think, think. It couldn't have actually been that bad, right? Maybe I was dreaming? Was it a dream?
"Hmm," Ben hums to himself, the ghost of a grin on his lips. "Something tells me you've remembered one of your many embarrassing moments from last night."
Oh no. It wasn't a dream. "I'm so. . ." I cough on a laugh as it quickly snowballs into something uncontrollable. "I am so sorry."
"Don't worry," he says in a teasing tone. I wonder if he fully understands that I'm laughing so hard because I'm mortified, and not because I find this funny. "I won't report you for incessant harassment."
No wonder he was so angry about my earlier questions. He spent all night trying to keep me off him, not the other way around. "Oh my God, I'm so sorry. I didn't. . . I didn't. . . I never would have insinuated that you—I mean, if I had known that I—" I'm panicking again, finding any opportunity in-between laughter to try and explain myself, and I can't think straight enough to figure out how to make this situation bearable. Covering my burning face with my hands, I ask, "Can we please pretend like last night didn't happen?"
"Was that really your first time under the influence of anything?" I nod miserably and he snorts a laugh. "Apology accepted. Besides, it's not every day you have a goddess compliment your nose."
"Please stop talking." And then I see a ferret struggling to carry what looks suspiciously like a firework.
Ben looks at me. I stop laughing and look at him. We don't say anything because we don't have to. We simply shoot up from the table in unison and follow the ferret away from the party towards the field leading to my shrine.
"Peregrine!?" I shriek loud enough to scare a firework out of her hands. "How did you even get on this island? You're supposed to be on Hydra! And fireworks? Really?"
"It was the ferrets idea," she claims. "I've just been sitting here the whole time. I swear."
One of the two ferrets asks, "What's going on?"
"She's snitching!" the other yells. In a wild, unstable flop, the ferret jumps up high enough to bite the tip of Peregrine's pinkie.
"Ow!" Peregrine yanks her hand away from the squeaking ferrets and sucks on the bloody finger.
"Was one disaster not enough for you? You had to try for wildfire number two?" Ben steps forward and confiscates a handful of the contraband. "You cannot play with fireworks."
"Why not?"
"Because I don't want you blowing all your fingers off."
"Impossible," she states matter-of-factly.
"Peregrine," Ben warns, "we've been through this a hundred times. You can't keep partaking in reckless behavior simply because you think you're a goddess of luck. That's not how it works."
"Sure it is," she refutes. "I can't blow all my fingers off because that would be unlucky, and luck gods are lucky all the time."
Ben pinches the bridge of his nose and leans his head back to sigh up at the stars.
Which turns out to be a foolish move on his part, because it allows Peregrine to snatch a single firework out of his hands. Before either of us can stop her, she's up a tree at the speed of a squirrel.
"I'll prove it," she declares and points the firework at her face. There's the sound of a match striking, and a bright bulb of match-light in the dark, and then the sharp sizzle of the fuse being lit. "I'll prove it once and for all, Uncle Ben."
But Ben's not listening to her. Instead, he drops the remaining fireworks in his arms and rushes to the tree, commanding she extinguish the fuse as I watch in immobilized horror. Even if he were as quick as Peregrine, he'd never be able to climb the tree in time. With a soft hiss, the fuse reaches the end of the ignition, and then fizzles into nothing.
I find my footing at last and hurry after Ben, both of us now yelling up at the child in the tree. "Peregrine," I shout, "come down from there, right now, or I'm unenlisting from your crew!"
"Ok, ok! I'm coming down—oops!"
I see the firework seconds before it can hit me on the head. Thankfully, I have enough reflexes to catch it.
Unfortunately, the second I catch it, it promptly reignites and explodes.
"It looked like you were blackout drunk and trying to fist-fight the air." Charlie laughs at the memory as he mimics the movement. "Honestly, I felt kinda bad. Near the end, you looked bloody miserable."
"Yes, thank you Charlie."
His laughter dies down as he takes in the charred state of my dress. "What happened to you, anyway? You catch fire?"
"Something like that." I frown down in Peregrine's direction.
"It was an accident," she yells. "I'm sorry, lady Cora, but you're not a goddess of luck."
"Goddess of luck?" Hugo perks up at this. "Can you give me some? I'm sorta. . . notoriously unlucky."
"Hear that Peregrine? You two should hang out sometime. Maybe you'll cancel each other out. Excuse me, please." I nod to Charlie and Hugo. "I've got to drop this one off for the night."
I don't know how Ben plans on keeping an eye on Peregrine until sunrise, but we both agreed it would be best not to let her mother know she's here. I'm supposed to stay with her at Ben's house until he returns. For now, he's busy extinguishing the small fire that ignited a patch of grass.
With an iron grip on Peregrine's tiny arm, I hold her tight to my side as we maneuver our way through the jovial crowd. As tired as I am, it does put me in a good mood knowing I haven't dampened someone else's wedding. I stop for a moment to watch Poppy and Bjorn flit from one clique to the next, happy and smiling as they receive congratulations.
Hey! Why doesn't Poppy have ash all over her hair? I thought that was a bridal tradition?
I hear nothing but happy Norse sentiments from every direction, so it sticks out like a screeching instrument to hear someone insult me in Portuguese. I halt immediately and turn to the offending speaker, unsure of how to respond.
"What did you just say?" Ben asks. I didn't realize he'd already returned, and I startle at the sound of his voice behind me.
"I said this is a magnificent party," Paulo lies.
I give Paulo a second to feel safe before turning around to look up at Ben. "Actually, he said—"
"I know what he said," Ben interrupts softly. I can tell he's furious because he doesn't look furious. "I'm trying to figure out if he's suicidal, or simply stupid. We have a therapist for the first option. I'm afraid I can't help him with the second."
A small part of me wants to smile at the look on Paulo's face as he turns slightly green. I'm not fluent in Portuguese, but you don't grow up in Southern California knowing one romance language without having exposure to several others, so I have a pretty good idea of what he said. Dumbass even has sauce from something all over his chin. Mustard? Looks like mustard. I give in and grin widely. "You probably shouldn't gossip in front of people before you know what languages they speak."
"Miscommunication," he offers weakly. I let him prattle on about how there must be a regional difference in our translation, and that he's only been remarking on this wonderful party the entire night, and blah blah blah.
"It's fine. Paulo? Okay. It's fine, Paulo," I tell him more sternly. "Just. . . go away."
"Wait," Ben calls at the last minute, and Paulo spins back around. Ben reaches up and taps at his own chin, mirroring the blot of sauce caught in Paulo's stubble. "You have something on your face. No, no. I'll get it for you." I don't even have time to consider telling him to stop before Ben's thrown a hard right hook, sending Paulo sprawling out on the grass.
Ben flexes his fingers and glances down at me, looking pleased with himself. "My debt is paid. I owe you nothing. And as for you," he says, picking up Peregrine and holding her like a plank of wood, the exact same way Annie does. "You're under house arrest until I can send you back home on the first ship tomorrow morning."
"Aww man," Peregrine complains, and the two disappear into the crowd.
I squat down next to the groaning man in the grass and say, "Hey, Paulo? How about a prophecy, free of charge? You need to pick better friends. And by friends, I mean girlfriends. Because your current one will literally be the death of you. And over what? Some diamonds? Are diamonds worth your life? Plus," I add, nodding across the courtyard at where Nikki is laughing loudly as she feels a grinning norseman's bicep. "It looks like what you had wasn't all that special if you've already been replaced."
Paulo nods miserably. Then, he says, "Hey, I think he broke my nose. Can you heal me?"
"You're kidding right?"
"Ha ha." He accepts a napkin I hold out and blots at the blood streaming down his chin. "Yes," he corrects nervously, "just joking. I'm okay."
As the night grows darker, I start counting down the rituals so I can keep track of what time it is. Everyone eats and drinks their fill, then they all start dancing, then a very drunk Poppy comes and finds me to bring me into the circle.
It's exhausting to smile this much, considering how tired and nauseous I still am, but I do it for the bride.
"I'm soooooooo happy you're here," Poppy slurs cheerfully, knocking into me for the third time. A woman served her a cup of the Berserkr Bride Tea a while ago, and I can already see the effects. "I was worried your rebirth wouldn't be for another few years, but here you are!"
"Here I am," I reply, all smiles.
"I love you so much, Freyja." Poppy bursts into tears, and it takes all my strength to keep her from collapsing to the ground. "You're my favorite god," she says in-between sobs. "I'm so happy you're here."
I literally don't know what to say. I do, however, feel a lot worse about how I treated poor Ben. Poppy doesn't have any of my extra strength, and it's still a lot of effort to keep her from flinging around and hurting herself. I really, really hope I didn't cry this much.
"We're going to sit down for a second, okay?" I struggle to help her down to the ground. "How're you hanging in there?"
"Huggh," she answers.
Thankfully, it isn't long until Poppy falls asleep against me in the grass.
I'm in the Swan. A man sits at a diner-style kitchen table, gun gripped tightly in his hand. He finishes reading a letter as I walk closer.
"Desmond?" I call out to him, but he doesn't look up. I must be dreaming. "Wow, I'm so sorry. I totally forgot you existed."
Without acknowledging me, Desmond raises the gun up into his mouth and pulls the trigger.
I mean, I guess I could have asked Hugo and Charlie to look after her, but I don’t think they’re equipped to handle Peregrine.
"We'll try and make this quick," I promise to the one party-goer whose religion forbids him from drinking. "Again, thank you so much."
Sayid nods and turns to look at where Peregrine is sitting, smiling innocently.
I'm not fooled. "This is Sayid," I say as sternly as I can. "You are to listen to Sayid while I'm gone. You cause trouble for my friend here, and I swear I will unenlist from your crew. You leave this house? Unenlist. You light anything on fire? Unenlist. You break anything, or steal anything, or cause any kind of damage to this house—or Sayid—and I unenlist. Do you understand me?"
Peregrine nods with enough fear that I choose to believe her. Then she hops up and approaches Sayid. "You look like you can hold your own in a fight. You ever kill a man?"
"Yes," he answers honestly.
"Excellent," says Peregrine. "Want to join my crew?"
Ben emerges from his bedroom with the last of the supplies and straps on his backpack. "Do not let her out of your sight," he tells an amused Sayid, and then we're off.
"How did you get out of the circle?" Ben asks as we ride Brego through the Barracks, past the sonic fence, and into the jungle. "That would have been helpful last night."
"I told them to move." I think back on the memory and cringe. "Let's just say I didn't have to ask twice."
I had woken from my nap next to Poppy, screaming so loud a small group of drunk women were knelling beside me, trying to calm me down. Once I was officially out of the circle, I made a break for Ben's house and told him what happened. He's the only one who both knows where the Swan is and is sober enough to take me there.
We're riding a lot faster than we did on our trip to burn Margo, so I'm forced to wrap both arms around Ben to keep from falling off the saddle. A few times Brego rears up to jump over obstacles in the path, and I stop apologizing for my death grip.
The second we arrive and Ben helps me off Brego, I run over and rip away vines until the Swan Station logo shines through. I start banging on the metal door with my fists. I tug at any piece of metal I can get a grip on. I scream for Desmond to open the door. Nothing.
Please don't be dead. Please don't be dead. Please don't be—
"Alright," says Ben, "now what?"
The door swings open and a man dressed all in bright yellow comes storming out, a rife loaded and pointed at me. Slowly his rife drifts down towards the ground. Muffled speech barely reaches me from behind his mask. As if burned, he tosses the gun away and sinks to his knees with his hands raised in surrender. He's trying to say something, but his mask is in the way.
"You don't have to wear that suit anymore, Desmond" I tell him. "We're not under quarantine."
Without a moment's hesitation, he rips the helmet off. "I surrender!"
"Yes," says Ben, "we can see that."
"Are you her?" he drawls in his thick Scottish accent. "The goddess from the movie?"
Ben and I exchange a quick confused glance before I ask, "What movie?"
A few crackles on screen, a few dips in the weathered sound, and the movie finally projects on the wall. It begins exactly how the Swan Station orientation is supposed to start. The obnoxious 70's music starts blaring over the loudspeakers while a Dharma logo flashes. Then Dr. Pierre Chang begins to speak.
"Welcome. My name is Doctor Pierre Chang, and this is the orientation film for Station 3 of the Dharma Initiative." I notice the stiffness in his posture. He's rigid as an ironing board, and his voice has a worried edge to it. "In a moment you will be given a simple set of instructions for how you and your partner will fulfill the responsibilities associated with this station." Chang then goes into a brief history of Dharma—why it was founded and by who—and a video of two polar bears fighting flashes on screen.
I think of Margo and sneak a glance at Ben, but his expression gives away nothing.
"You and your partner," Chang continues uncomfortably, "are currently located in Station 3, the Swan, and will be for the next 540 days. Now, Station 3 was originally constructed as a laboratory where scientists could work to understand the unique electro-magnetic fluctuations emanating from this sector of the island. Not long after the experiments began, however, there was . . ." His eyes dart off-screen for a fraction of a second. ". . . an incident. And since that time, proper protocol has been observed. Every 108 minutes, the button must be pushed. From the moment the alarm sounds, you will have 4 minutes to enter the code into the microcomputer processor. It is highly recommended that you and your partner take alternating shifts. In this manor you will stay fresh and alert as it is of the utmost importance that when the alarm sounds, you enter in the numbers correctly and in a timely fashion."
And then the script I know—the script I've had memorized since this episode first aired—deviates into a warning. A warning about me.
Dr. Chang instructs them not to go outside. Sketches flash on screen of what is supposed to be me, but it's a little comedic how inaccurate it all is. I'm 4'8, but this Freyja is described as 6 feet tall, almost always covered in feathers, face painted, sometimes veiled, with two antlers sprouting out of the top of her head.
"You are under no circumstance to engage with the goddess Freyja or her people," Dr. Chang continues. "If in the unforeseen emergency the norsemen breech this facility, we can only recommend you immediately lay down your weapons and hold your hands high over your head. The governing rules and regulations of their culture are far too complicated to be listed here. Please consult your Norse Manual and Guidebook for more specifics. Again, until your replacements arrive, the future of the project is in your hands. Congratulations, and good luck."
Norse Manual and Guidebook? There could be something of importance in there! Where is it? I hope Desmond knows where it is. That sounds like a great place to start my research.
Instead of inquiring about the video, or the manual, Ben turns to Desmond in the semi-darkness and asks, "Have you been down here alone this whole time?"
I immediately feel selfish for focusing on the manual and not focusing on the fact that the entire reason we're here is because Desmond is suicidal. "He's been down here for a little over a month," I answer for Desmond, and he startles at the fact that I know this. "It's way past time for him to get some fresh air. We'll need to find his replacement. Get a few people on a rotation."
Desmond stays silent as Ben turns to me and asks, "A rotation for what?"
"The. . . button? Were you not paying attention to the video?"
"I always knew this place existed, I just didn't know it was active." Ben glances around, an air of fascination in his eyes. "Your people are superstitious of all things Dharma. Nobody I know of would step foot near this place."
"Well, looks like they're going to have to get over their superstition," I say. "Because somebody needs to be alert enough to push a button every 108 minutes. Maybe you can get some of your people to volunteer?"
"I hate to interrupt," Desmond says at last, "but does this mean you're not going to kill me?"
1 Week Later
Most people are unaware of this, but you don't need to trick others into divulging their deepest darkest secrets. You simply have to smile and treat them with the most basic human decency. When people trust you, it's not long before they'll tell you anything—sometimes completely unprompted.
This is how I learn about my people. Which families hate who and why. Complaints about the young men most interested in their daughters. Who has the ugliest baby.
I've already half-filled my replacement notebook with everything from random to-do lists to mindless gossip. Most of the notebook is just frantic scribbling about who has a crush on who. It's now common knowledge that any and all romantic problems are now my problem to solve. The irony is not lost on me.
"Hello Goose," I say, waving at the aptly named swan. I greet the chickens, goats, a horse, two raccoons, and a very confused rat on my walk down to the beach. It feels like I should have met every animal on this island by now, but there's always a new name for me to memorize when I wake up in the morning. And that's just the animals.
For the past week, my schedule has consisted of enjoying a nice breakfast with Gail, then an excruciatingly long day of sitting on a throne, blessing babies, and listening as people tell me their problems. Adults. Children. Animals. Everyone needs something from me.
At first it was kinda fun. The problems were almost all things I could offer good advice on. For example, this one pair of bickering children literally needed me to explain that yes, taking things without asking is theft. Even if you really, really want that thing. But as nosy as I am, I'm also introverted, and being forced to talk to people from sunrise to sunset has worn me ragged.
It's been a long week, but today is the first day that I've woken up to an empty longhouse. No long line of people looking for answers. No more babies left to bless. I guess there are only so many people on this island, so there are only so many problems I can solve. You won't hear me complain. To the beach!
"Lady Cora? Oh, my lady, I apologize." A woman rushes towards me, and I recognize her face but can't remember her name. "I hate to interrupt your day, but my youngest has run off and I can't find him anywhere."
Oh well. Maybe one day I'll get the chance to actually relax on the beach. "Oh no," I exclaim and give the woman my full attention. "What happened?"
"One of our chickens passed last night. Sten was very fond of Henrietta, may she rest in peace." The woman presses her hands together and bows slightly. "My husband let slip that he was looking forward to chicken soup tonight, and now Sten has run off with her body."
"Ah," I exhale, smiling. "I see. Well, if I can find him, I'll talk to him." This unfortunately isn't the first time I've had to chat with the children of Hydra about death and the circle of life, and how it's ok if they want to eat animals after they die. Many a tearful little face has come crying to me about a dead pet rabbit or goat. This is my first dead chicken.
It takes a few hours to find him holed up in one of the many pseudo-caves near the main source of freshwater. Poor thing doesn't even know I'm there until it's too late.
Instead of screaming at the sight of me or flying into a slew of arguments for why this particular animal shouldn't be eaten, the little boy simply sobs quietly and cradles the wrapped up body against his chest.
"Hey, Sten, it's okay." I approach slowly, hands raised, palms up. "I'm not here to take Henrietta away from you, alright? I promise I'm not here to take her from you."
Sten looks up at me, sniffling so hard I can barely understand him. "No soup."
"I won't let anyone make her into soup." I finally get close enough to touch him and slowly sink to the ground next to him. "Ok, we're gonna breathe. Ready? Deep breath in." I suck in a lungful of air. "Slow breath out." I exhale, waving my hands in emphasis. "Good. Let's do it again, ok?"
Now that he's calm, Sten doesn't seem to know what to do next.
"You loved Henrietta very much, didn't you?" I smile and pat his back when he nods. "She knew that."
At this, he looks up. "She did?"
"Of course she did. Animals can tell friend from foe, and you were a very good friend. I can tell." Sten seems comforted by this, so I continue. "What do you think we should do with her? No, no soup. I promised she wouldn't be made into food."
Sten holds tightly to the dead hen while he thinks.
And that's how I attend my first chicken funeral. Sten and I watch as the twig pyre ignites, filling the sky with a tiny trail of smoke. Honestly, my biggest fear was the scent of roasted chicken making my stomach grumble loudly, but I quickly learn how awful burnt feathers smell, so that isn't a problem after all. Sten sobs and leans into me as I pat his back and flatten down his wild hair.
When Henrietta is nothing more than a charred black mass, we dig a small hole with our hands and bury her remains. Then I kneel down to his level and ask, "You want some ice cream?"
Sten thinks for a moment before sniffling one final time and nodding.
Lifting his tiny body up and balancing him on my hip, I begin the walk back to the longhouse. "We just made some yesterday. What kind do you want? I think I have some strawberries. You want strawberry ice cream?"
Pris—my assistant of sorts—nods hello when we enter the longhouse. She waits patiently for me to get Sten situated at one of the long dinning tables before announcing, "Your husband is looking for you."
"Thanks, Pris." I open the door to my bedroom, but I don't see him. I take one last look around the longhouse before walking back over to her. "He's not here."
"I sent him away."
"Pris, I told you to stop doing that."
The young woman shrugs indifferently and wanders over to check on Sten.
I find his boat docked in the sand, but there's no sight of him.
"I don't think your new assistant likes me very much." Ben emerges from under the shade of a nearby tree, pausing to slide a bookmark into place. "It's a good thing I had the foresight to bring entertainment."
"Sorry." I shake my head to try and express the full extent of my exasperation. "I explicitly instructed her to let you wait in the longhouse when you drop off Alex. I think she took it as a suggestion instead of a direct order. Actually," I add, "why are you still here?"
"It's nice to see you, too. I'm doing well, by the way. How about yourself?"
Since the wedding, we communicate almost exclusively in overly sarcastic jabs, even though we both promised we would stop. I have no real way of knowing how much of his quiet contemptuousness is genuine or not, but he never says anything insulting—either in person or through letters—so I see no reason to complain. “I just held an exclusive funeral for a chicken destined for soup.”
Ben pauses, pensive. “I will admit, that was fairly low on my list of expected responses.” He doesn’t smile when I laugh, but his eyes give away his amusement. Amusement slowly shifts into one too many blinks, which means he’s nervous. “I brought you this. Might be a useful alternative to carrying that notebook around under your arm.”
I accept the satchel from him and wonder why I never thought of that. “Oh, wow, thanks!” Slipping my notebook and pen inside, I sling the strap over a shoulder and make a show of swinging my arms. “Free at last. Now maybe I can finally catch the kids who keep filling my socks with moss.”
Ben finally smiles.
I wait for him to say something because this hasn’t happened before. He usually drops Alex off or picks her up without bothering me, but he keeps shifting his weight in the sand from one foot to the other. It doesn’t look like he wants to leave.
My stomach plummets. “Did something bad happen?”
“No,” he answers quickly.
“Has the first submarine left on schedule?”
“Yes.” Ben checks his watch. “Left for the mainland two hours ago. Won’t be due back for six months.”
“Six months?” That’s going to be tons of fun explaining to the remaining survivors. We had a lottery to see which lucky few got to go home first, but it was my understanding the trip was going to take about three weeks at most, not half a year.
“If all goes well, yes,” Ben says, and then stands quietly, his eyes eventually shifting from me to the sand.
“Are you hungry?” To keep away the awkward silence, my domestic training kicks in at last, and I blurt out, “I can make you something to eat before you head back. Or if you're craving sweets, we just made ice cream. And no, I’m not interested in a lecture about how your ice cream is superior.”
“I would very much appreciate some inferior ice cream, thank you.” Ben falls in step next to me on the hike up the hill to the longhouse. I feel his hand on my sleeve. “This is new.”
“Yeah, Astrid made it for me.” I smile and reach down to show him the hem. “Look, it has little goats embroidered on it!”
“It’s lovely,” he says, and I feel my face warming. I’m used to people my age overusing words like hot or gorgeous or beautiful. For some reason, lovely sounds more complimentary. “How have you been?” Ben asks. “Exhausted yet?”
“Way past that point,” I answer under my breath. “There are so many kids, I can’t keep track of them all. If I’ve learned anything in my stay here so far, it’s that children are really, really weird.” The comedic timing could not be more perfect, as a small excited child bursts out of the bushes and approaches.
“Lady Cora! Watch this.” He stands with his arms out, concentrating. Nothing happens. He shifts his feet, then deflates. “Nevermind,” he says, disappearing back into the jungle.
“Case in point,” I tell Ben right as another small child approaches. “Connor? Yes, hi. No, I’m sorry, I’m kinda busy at the moment.” I exhale heavily. “Connor, I’ve already told you, it’s not nice to scare people.”
“No, no, it’s not a scary surprise,” he promises, but his barely contained giggles say otherwise.
I accept the tiny box he’s presented me with and raise a suspicious eyebrow. “So, what you’re telling me is there’s not going to be a spider in here? Because if there is, I’m going to have to have a very serious conversation with your mother.”
Connor’s mischievous grin flatlines, and his eyes widen in fear.
“Okay,” I announce, slowly reaching for the lid, “I’m gonna open it.”
Connor snatches it out of my hands with a mumbled, “It’s not ready yet.” Tripping in his haste, he scampers off into the trees.
Ben waits until Connor is completely out of sight before huffing a laugh. “I’m suddenly very thankful for Alex.”
"Mama? Wake up!" A cold wet snout presses against my feverish cheek. "It was just a dream."
I open my eyes, momentarily too disoriented to recognize Pumba or Fenrir. As I take in my surroundings, I choke and cough up phlegm, bringing even more water to my already teary eyes. My whole body trembles in the aftershock of my nightmare.
My nightmare.
I tear out of bed in search of my shoes, disorientated in the darkness, my path only lit by the glow of a dying fireplace. I'm in the Temple. What was I doing here? Not important. I need to get to that tree. Should I ask for an escort? Everyone's asleep and there's no time. There's no time!
As I sprint through the jungle in the middle of the night, flashes of my nightmare cut through my thoughts, fueling me to run faster when my legs ache and my lungs catch fire. I have to keep running. Keep running. I'm losing steam. My legs are cramping. I'm here. I'm here!
"Alex?" I bend over and cough. "Alex? Where are you?" It's so dark tonight because there's no moon, thanks to a thick clump of clouds. I scream into the night, hoping and praying I'm not too late. This is the tree, right? I see it whenever we travel between the barracks and the beach. This better not be the wrong tree. Where is she? Please God, don't let me be too late.
I suck in lungful after lungful of air to scream for Alex, but there's no answer. I'm spinning around in the darkness, dressed only in my nightgown, screaming with a feral terror that only increases the longer I go unanswered. I start running towards the tree in search of her, in case she's here and I just can't see. Maybe it hasn't happened yet? Maybe I saw too far into the future?
I'm down on my knees, searching the ground near the trunk when a horrible pain shoots through my skull and down my spine. I slump forward, dazed.
My attacker's fingers tangle in my hair as I'm yanked backwards, slamming into the ground, pinned by their suffocating weight. I can tell it's a man, but I can't really see the details of his face, not enough to recognize him. I can see it well enough to gather up saliva and spit on him, thrashing with every ounce of strength I have, freeing one arm and clawing at his face until I feel blood.
White flashes behind my eyes, and I'm suddenly so dizzy I don't know where I am or what's happening. An arm presses down against my throat. He hit me. He hit me, and he's going to kill me. What's happening? I'm afraid… but where's my strength? Why can't I toss him around like I did Erik? I'm dying. I can't breathe. He's killing me.
I close my eyes and think of my sisters. There's no music this time as I drift off, just flashes. Old buried memories that feel like dreams. Small moments of happiness in a lifetime of tension. I remember their smiles. Their laughter. The way they always tried to trick people into confusing one for the other.
I come to with a jerk, finally able to gasp the cool night air. For the first few seconds after I open my eyes, I am in a transcended state of confusion. Blood pours from the gurgling man's neck, coating me in thick spurts that match the tempo of his heartbeat. I thrash and struggle to push his limp body off me, and then I sit up, rubbing my sore throat as I try to piece together what happened. A disgustingly salty-copper taste is in my mouth. I bring up a hand to get it out and wipe away blood. I am covered in his blood.
Alex stands behind him, wide-eyed and stone faced, holding a bloody knife in a trembling hand. She won't look at me when I call her. She won't stop staring at the man she's just killed.
"Alex?"
"It was self defense," she says quickly, assuredly. "He attacked you. I had to. It was self defense." Alex looks at me, then back at the man, his motionless body now pouring blood out onto the grass. A sliver of cloud parts, giving us just enough moonlight to illuminate the body. "You'll be a witness at my trial, right?"
"Alex?"
"I think we have to report it to my dad." Her neck twists from one side to the other as she whips her head around. "This is our territory…I think? Which means I have to report it to dad. Oh." A lungful of air exhales in a rush, and she sinks to the ground. "You'll be a witness at my trial, right? Cora? You'll speak for me, right?"
"Alex?"
"We have to. . ." Alex holds tight to the knife, her body now wracking with grief. "We have to report this. . . to my dad. He's. . . he's never going to let me leave home ever again—"
"Alex? Alex," I say sternly, and she stops bawling and looks at me. "Go back to Hydra."
"What?"
"Go back to Hydra," I repeat. "Tell Gail what happened and immediately send your dad a note that you're running really late. I'll take care of this."
Alex looks beyond confused.
"You're in shock." I smile in an attempt to calm her down. "You're going to be fine, but I need you to go back to Hydra and tell Gail what happened, okay? You can trust Gail."
"My dad's expecting me for dinner. I can't be late again, or—"
Alex's entire body trembles, and I wonder why mine isn't. In fact, I don't feel anxious at all. I don't feel anything, really.
I stand and get close enough to take her hands in mine. "Keep the knife, and go back to Hydra. Talk to Gail. Tell her what happened. I'll talk to your dad. This man attacked me, not you."
"Matt," Alex whispers. "His name is Matt. Was Matt. He was kinda creepy. I should have told dad."
"Hey," I soothe, making sure to keep my tone jovial. "You didn't do anything wrong. I mean, he's dead. What's he going to do now? Nothing." I squeeze her hands. "Go. I'll talk to your dad. Just get home safely."
"Are you sure?"
"Go," I whisper, and she nods, finally running back down the path that leads to the beach. The path I saw in my nightmare. The path that would have ended differently had I not gotten here first.
I wait for the flashes of my nightmare to return—the screaming, the fear, the pain—but nothing happens. I don't feel scared, or angry, or sad. I feel empty, like instead of being overwhelmed by too many thoughts, I don't have a single one. For the first time in my life, my mind is truly blank.
Hurley squints at me in the dim barracks lighting, swearing and backing up when I get closer. Someone is whispering. A door slams shut. A woman stares at me, too terrified to even run. I stop and look down, realizing all at once what the issue is. I forgot I'm covered in blood. I can sense it now, dripping from my hair down onto my dress, drying against my face, sticking my nightgown to my body. I blink and look around at the people staring at me from their barrack houses.
How did I get here? How did I get past the fence?
I walk to Ben's house as if in a silent dream. I find him in the kitchen, stirring something on the stovetop, his back to me when I step inside.
"You're late," he chides, not turning around. "Curfews are instated for a reason, Alex. What's the point of a curfew if you don't—" Loud clanging echoes through the kitchen as Ben turns, sees me standing in the doorway, and drops the pan of food in his hands.
I watch his body freeze so completely that I can't even tell if he's breathing. A droplet of blood tickles down my cheek and I jerk a hand up to wipe it away. I sniff. I clear my throat. I say, "I need to report a crime."
As anxious of a person as I normally am, I'm remarkably calm as Ben pulls a gun on me.
Chapter 18: Faith In Humanity Restored
Notes:
(See the end of the chapter for notes.)
Chapter Text
“What did you do?” Ben’s question quivers as violently as the gun in his hand. “What have you done?”
Ben is very slowly making his way from one side of the house to the other, never taking his aim or his eyes off me. He asks me questions, but I can’t keep track of what he’s saying. Instead, I silently watch as he pulls a phone off the hook, dials a number with his free hand, picks up the receiver, and starts speaking nonsense.
I’m still standing near the front door when Jane bursts in, shouting obscenities and pointing a shotgun at me.
I’m thirsty. Ignoring the both of them, I walk over to the sink and get a glass of water from the tap. It’s only after I’ve downed the water that I tune back in and catch the end of their conversation. “Oh, no, don’t worry,” I announce with a smile. “It’s not my blood.”
Jane looks like a weird mixture of nauseous and wanting to cry. “What did you do with her body?”
Her body? “Who?”
“Alex,” Jane snarles.
“Ohhh.” A small laugh escapes me. “No, this isn’t hers either. She’s fine. She’s still on Hydra.”
“That’s a lie,” Ben interjects. “She sent me a raven hours ago that she was heading home.”
“If that’s not your blood,” Jane asks, “and it’s not Alex’s blood, then whose blood is it?”
I shrug. “I don’t know. I never met him before.”
Jane’s expression never wavers. “What happened?”
“I don’t know. He just attacked me.”
“You were attacked?” Jane frowns so deeply it looks like her eyebrows are touching. “You honestly expect me to believe there was someone on this island stupid enough to attack you?”
“Believe me or not,” I say, bored. “That’s what happened. I can show you the body if you want.”
“What were you doing when he attacked you?”
Her question catches me off guard, and I tilt my head slightly in confusion. “What was I doing?”
“Yes,” she snaps, “what were you doing? Where did it happen? Where were you going? Why are you in your nightgown?”
My brain is completely blank, but for some reason, I don’t care. Instead of answering her questions, I refill my glass with water.
“So, let me get this straight.” Jane takes a few steps towards me, the barrel of her shotgun pointed at my head. “You went out for a walk, in the dark, in your nightgown. . . to do what, exactly?”
I finally feel something, and my eyes meet hers with a spark of outrage. “Someone just tried to kill me. Why are you asking me about my nightgown?”
“Because I don’t believe a single word that comes out of your mouth.” Jane’s focus never leaves me as she addresses Ben. “Send a raven for Miles.”
“What?” I perk up at this news. “What does Miles have to do with this?”
“Miles,” Jane explains in a mocking tone, “will be able to tell us what really happened, since you seem so hell bent on lying to my face.”
“I’m not lying.” I roll my eyes. “We don’t need Miles. I’ve already told you what happened.”
“You haven’t told us anything.” Jane is so close, I could reach out and take a swipe at the shotgun, if I wanted to. “You’ve only been here, what, five weeks? Is this some kind of new record for you? Don’t move,” she yells when I turn to walk into the living room.
My words come out as a breathy sigh as I sink into the sofa. “If you’re going to shoot me, then shoot me and get it over with.”
A raven swoops in through an open window, cawing loudly, “Letter for Ben!”
Ben practically rips the paper in a one-handed haste to read it. He sinks into a kitchen chair as his aim wavers. Slowly, the handgun lowers to the table with a soft clink. He looks dizzy. “It’s Alex,” he announces softly. “She was delayed and is asking to stay on Hydra tonight.”
Jane readjusts her gun, squinting at me in the faint kitchen lighting. “Send for Miles anyway.”
Miles doesn’t look happy to see me, and he definitely doesn’t look happy to see me covered in blood. I hope Aiko is doing better. I want to ask, but I keep my mouth shut. Thinking about having that conversation makes me tired.
Miles finishes listening to the last memories of. . . whatever his name was. With a sharp intake of air, he turns to Jane and announces, “Cora’s telling the truth. He attacked her unprovoked.”
I smirk up at the surprised woman. “See?”
Miles makes a small motioning action with his fingers, and Ben steps away from me as the two walk a few steps away. I can’t hear what they’re saying, but Miles tells Ben something and the two of them look over at me.
I’m uncomfortable. It’s difficult to breathe. It’s cold. I don’t want to be here.
I’m walking back to the Temple on autopilot. It’s so strange to not have music playing in the background as I lose all sense of time. Hands on my upper arms stop me from moving forward, and I blink back into consciousness to see what’s going on. It’s Ben, standing in front of me, impeding my path.
“Where are you going?” he asks.
“Back to the Temple. I need a bath.”
“Alright, well. . .” Ben’s thought dies on his lips as he glances behind me at Jane and Miles. “We actually need you to come back to the barracks for a little while.”
Silence. My head is still silent as Ben explains what’s going to happen from a legal standpoint. About how Jane is putting the entire community on lockdown until we can interview the survivors and figure out what’s going on. That’s who this man was. A survivor. A survivor who probably would have died if I didn’t exist. But he did exist. How many other random monsters were on Oceanic 315? Are there any serial killers? How do I know the true motive of anyone not of the core cast?
There’s kids on Hydra.
“What?” Ben still has a hold of my arms, but his grip is loose and gentle. “I’m sorry, I can’t hear you.”
“There’s kids on Hydra,” I continue to mumble. “I have to go back to Hydra.”
A voice from behind me says, “You’re not going back to Hydra, we need you to—”
“Jane,” Ben hisses in warning. “Not now.”
“Where’s my shoe?” Why am I just now noticing I’m missing a shoe? “Has anyone seen my shoe? My satchel.” I reach up and grab hold of one of Ben’s hands, trying my best not to squeeze too hard. “I left my satchel at the Temple,” I whisper. “I left Fenrir and Pumba at the Temple.”
“Okay,” Ben says evenly. “Alright, Cora. Don’t worry. We’ll go get them.”
Someone in the courtyard is yelling, and as we get closer, I recognize who it is.
“What’s going on?” I ask the nearest man. “Why is he tied to a stake?”
“Sorry, my lady, but he—” the man’s apology gets sucked back in as he takes a look at me and steps away.
Right. I’m covered in blood.
Ben starts speaking to the man in Norse as I step closer to the screaming man in the center of the courtyard. “Sawyer?”
He’s in the middle of a frothy rant when he sees me and adds, “Goddess or not, you women are all the same!”
“Yeah, because none of them want you!” A man yells from out of the crowd, and the surrounding men all roar with laughter.
I look around at the small group of men, expecting answers, but they carry on as if I’m not here. “Why is he tied up?”
“Safety concern,” a norseman answers. “He keeps trying to fight the young ones.”
I’m suddenly overwhelmed with rage as I spin towards Sawyer and scream, “You’re fighting children?”
“No, no, my lady,” the norseman explains. “The safety concern is for him.”
“I don’t need your damn coddling!” Sawyer thrashes and pulls at his restraints, but my people have done an excellent job of securing him. “You don’t know me—”
“There’s a note in your pocket addressed to a Sawyer,” I interrupt, and the surrounding men all fall silent. “But you’re not Sawyer. You were born James Ford. Sawyer’s the pseudonym of the scumbag who convinced your mother to give him all your family’s money.”
Sawyer is silent for only a few dazed seconds before he tries to interrupt me, so I just keep talking louder and louder and louder until he stops.
“Your mom got conned out of the family’s life savings, and your dad was so angry he shot her in the hallway, then he came into your bedroom and sat on your mattress and shot himself in the head, all while you were hiding under the bed. You’ve spent your life looking for the conman who stole your childhood and somewhere along the way you convinced yourself the best way to do that was to support your search by becoming the very thing that ruined your life.” I step closer, secretly begging him not to speak because I don’t know what I’ll do if he interrupts me again. “You think I don’t know who you are? You think I don’t know what you’ve done? You think I don’t know about Clementine? What exactly is it I don’t know about you, James?"
A curious crowd, roused from their rooms by my yelling, has congregated around the stake where Sawyer hangs limply.
“Oh, you know what? Actually, I am missing something.” I swing back around, pointing an accusing finger at Sawyer’s face. “You murdered an innocent man in Sydney. Someone you thought was the real Sawyer. But he wasn’t. You want to know how I know that?” It’s obvious that his furious expression betrays what he’s actually feeling. He’s angry and scared, but even more than that, he’s sad. Still, knowing how much this is hurting him, I lean forward and taunt, “Because I know who the real Sawyer is. But I don’t consort with assholes who pick fights with children!” I spot Michael in the ever-forming crowd and point furiously in his direction. “And why are you laughing? Don’t even get me started on your dumb ass!”
Men leap away from Michael as if I just announced he has the plague.
Adrenaline pumps hard and fast in my veins, and I’m honestly elated to be feeling anything at all. I point at Sawyer. “Cut him loose. If he wants to fight so bad, let him fight.”
“Can I do it?” A young man I’ve yet to meet pushes through the crowd from down the hall. “Please dad?”
The second Sawyer is cut free, the young man approaches, only slightly taller than he is. It looks as if Sawyer is literally bouncing with energy, and when he swings, his fist makes contact with the boys face, but not much happens. In fact, the young man lets him take one more swing before grabbing Sawyer’s shoulders and smashing their skulls together in a violent headbutt. Sawyer falls to the ground like a sack of bricks.
“Father, that didn’t feel good,” the young man complains, looking slightly sad. “It felt like fighting a child.”
“Some men are like that, my boy.”
Everyone looks disgusted and embarrassed by Sawyer’s unconscious body. I think I’m supposed to feel sorry for him—I don’t even know what had led to him being tied up—but I don’t feel anything except pure rage.
“What?” I snarl as two men escort John Locke over to me. “Do I need to give you your life story, too?”
“No, ma’am,” John answers, smiling sheepishly. “I was just wondering if you were the one I have to thank.”
“For what?” I wait for him to formulate exactly what he wants to say, but he’s taking too long. Besides, I already know what it is he’s trying to ask. “Are you asking if I’m the reason you can walk again? I heal people, John. This is my island. Come to your own conclusions.” I swipe at my nose and dried blood flakes off. “I’m happy your spine is healed, but just so you don’t get your hopes up, I can’t regrow your missing kidney. Sorry.”
I’m surprised to hear him chuckle, but I’m too emotionally drained to try and deduce if it was genuine or not. “No,” he continues, “that would be too much to ask. And I’m not asking.”
All of the anger I was incapable of feeling about Alex misdirects itself towards John. “Then what do you want?”
“To finally thank you properly.” I’ve gotten used to people bowing at me, but John’s is different. It feels less fearful. He rights himself and nods once. “Thank you.”
He turns to leave, but stops when I say, “I know what it is you want.”
“What is it I want?”
“To belong to something. Something that isn’t going to take advantage of you.” I look up at him, and it’s clear he’s attempting to hide the intensity of his hopefulness. “As long as you don’t try to undermine me,” I add, “this place is exactly what you’ve been searching for.”
His entire weathered face scrunches in confusion. “You’re not going to send me back to LA?”
“Do you want to go back?” John shakes his head no, and I turn to walk to my room, waving a hand in Sawyer’s general direction. “And would somebody clean him up?”
I do everything they say. I sit through their bullshit trial. I make my bullshit statement. I listen to their bullshit hearing.
Oh, wow, they’re gonna let me go? Holy shit! I never saw that coming! It’s the shock of the century that nobody wants to piss off an already pissed off goddess of war. A real turn of events, ladies and gentlemen.
Jane has ordered her most intimidating wolf—Eddard—to watch over me while I’m on the mainland. Gail hasn’t left my side since the night I returned to the Temple. At first, she was a blessing and a comfort. But it’s been a few days and I’m starting to become annoyed with everyone—including Gail. It’s not even that she’s done anything particularly annoying. It’s just that I want to be alone, and with Gail being alone is truly impossible.
After the trial, I return to Hydra with the hope that life can return to normal. Most of the married men return with me on one of the larger ships, and I watch as they hurry to their homes to check on their wives and children, who have all been painted with what I assume is some sort of protective spell.
From the way people stare at me as I make my way to the longhouse, it’s obvious everyone knows what happened. So I do the only reasonable thing I can think of.
I lock myself in my room.
There’s something I would like to show you. May I visit? —Ben
I’ve been staring at the piece of paper for what seems like hours, although I’m not actually sure how long its been. I waffle between: Yes, for the love of God I want to talk to another human being who isn’t Gail and No, I never want to talk to anyone ever again, thanks.
I scribble, Okay.
Surely he must have just beaten some kind of record in the amount of time it takes him to paddle to Hydra and come knocking on my bedroom door. I peek my head out and ask if there’s anyone else in the longhouse. Only after he assures me we’re alone—and that Gail is watching the entrance—do I muster up the strength to leave my room and sit down at one of the nearby tables.
“Thank you for meeting with me.” Ben flips open a backpack, pulling out a folder and shuffling through some documents. He eventually finds what he’s looking for and holds out an old Polaroid, patiently waiting for me to take it. “I hope we can keep this between us,” he says.
Eyebrows scrunched in confusion, I study the photo. “Who is this?”
“The boy on the left is Kyle.” Ben opens his mouth to answer, but it’s a few seconds before he admits, “The boy on the right is me.”
I look from him back to the picture two or three times and snort. “Oh wow, this is you.” It feels like I’m waking up after a long nap when a laugh bursts out of me. I feel fully awake for the first time in days.
“I’ll take that back now,” says Ben.
“You will not.” I scoot my chair backwards, away from the table and out of his range. “You made a big mistake giving this to me. I’m framing it.”
“Funny.” Ben frowns but makes no more attempts to take it away.
“How long did you grow out your hair?” I ask. “It’s almost as long as mine.”
“I only cut it after I retired from the team. Too much upkeep.”
“Your beard is absolutely precious.”
Ben huffs a laugh. “That one I disposed of much earlier.”
“Lady Cora,” Pris announces, stopping short to blink with surprise at the fact that Ben’s here. “Gail wanted me to tell you Ana Lucia is requesting an audience.”
I’m up and headed back to my bedroom before she can even finish her sentence. “No, sorry,” I tell Pris. “I. . . I’ll have to get back to her later. I’m . . . busy.”
Ben is still seated at the table, so I wave for him to follow me. His eyes glance over at Pris—probably to check if she’s going to start stabbing him with the nearest sharp object—but she does nothing but bow at my instructions and leave.
“Sorry.” I hurry to shove a pile of dirty clothes off of the only chair in the room so he can sit down. My face warms as I take a look around and realize my bedroom is an absolute mess. “I would have cleaned if I knew you would be here so soon.”
Ben closes my bedroom door behind him and tries not to make it obvious that he’s cataloging the current state of destruction within. As I rush to finish tidying what I can, he walks over to my desk and thumbs through the Norse Handbook and Manual Desmond gave me from the hatch. “Anything useful in here?”
“Not so far.” I readjust a mountain of pillows I’d propped up and finally take a seat on my mattress. “It’s actually wildly inaccurate.”
“You don’t grant wishes to anyone who can best you in an arm wrestling match?” Ben looks over at me with a comedically disappointed expression. “You mean to tell me all that upper body training was for nothing? I’ll need to burn half my reference library if you don’t actually—” he pauses to read, his eyes squinting in disbelief as he brings the book up closer to his face. “—sustain yourself on a diet of acorns and mossy rocks. Who wrote this?”
It’s nice to laugh after being too tired to do anything but sulk. As I watch him flip through the manual—lit only by the soft glow of what a few candles can provide—I’m suddenly intensely aware that we’re completely alone for the first time since we were trapped in that cave.
A rush in my stomach slowly leeches out to my limbs until I’m almost as lightheaded as I was at my wedding. I’ve started dreaming about him almost every night, and the worst part is I can’t talk to anyone about it. I’m not good enough friends with any of the women on Hydra, and I’m not exactly bitting at the bit to tell Gail about all of the embarrassing fantasies that leave me frustrated and sweaty when I wake up in the middle of the night.
And now he’s here, alone with me. Not that it matters. I’m 45 million pathetic therapy sessions away from having the courage to do anything about it.
Ben flips another page and smooths it out. “Gail told me you haven’t left your room in a while.”
Ugh, of course Gail’s involved in this. “And?”
He’s just as quiet when he asks, “Is everything alright?”
“I’m fine, Ben.”
Ben turns to look at me. His gaze moves to a candle on my desk, and finally he stares back down at the manual, thinking, his brows only slightly furrowed. When he's thought up a response, his voice is gentle and diplomatic. “I’m not sure that’s true.”
“What do you mean?”
“You’re not crying.”
“Oh, so you’re mad at me when I cry and you’re mad at me when I don’t cry?”
“I’m not mad at you.”
“I said I’m fine.” It comes out way more hostile than I intend, so I make sure to smile when I add, “I’m just taking a break.”
“For five days straight?”
“Listen, you don’t wake up everyday to people waiting right outside your door to talk to you about all of their tedious little problems! Do you have a million kids trying to show you their crazy stunts? Or crying uncontrollably over their dead pets? You're asking why I've been in here for five days? Five days rest is nothing! I’m exhausted. I’m beyond exhausted! I just. . . want some peace and quiet.” I rub at my tired eyes and sigh, embarrassed at my outburst. “I’m sorry.”
“Don’t,” he interrupts, quietly adding, “There’s nothing you need to apologize for. Have you thought about talking to Harper?”
“I don’t want to talk to Harper.” I want to talk to you. “I wrote you a bunch of letters.”
Ben looks up in surprise. “Oh?”
“I tossed them all in the fire, though.” I don’t even know why I’m telling him this. “I couldn’t figure out the right way to apologize.”
“For what?”
Like falling into a dream, the drowsiness returns. “I promised you I’d watch over Alex.”
“But you did watch over Alex.” Ben pulls the chair over until he’s right next to my bed. “I don’t understand what you feel the need to apologize for.”
“I would have died if she wasn’t there,” I whisper. “He was choking me, and I couldn’t even muster up the strength to push him off.” It’s suddenly freezing, and I wrap my arms over my chest in an attempt to keep warm. “I can’t do this.” It feels good to say it aloud for the first time. “I can’t protect these kids. I can’t even protect myself.”
“You’re still not giving yourself any credit.” Ben’s words are soft and calming and much more reassuring than the pep talks Gail’s tried to give me. “You changed the course of the future to protect Alex. That’s no small thing. And you continue to protect her by claiming responsibility for all this. You’ve saved her a lot of additional trauma within the courts.”
“Is she going to be okay?” I ask. “She didn’t seem okay the last time I saw her.”
“Gail’s on top of it. For obvious reasons, Alex can’t talk to Harper about this, so I suppose Gail will have to do.” Ben gives me a small smile. “Don’t worry, I haven’t blown your cover. Alex is unaware I know what really happened.” It looks like there’s more he wants to say, but he doesn’t.
I want him to keep talking to me, so I hold up the vintage photo between my middle and index finger. “You sailed all the way over here just to show me this?”
“Well, no, not exactly. Today is the last rugby game of the season.” Ben pauses, his eyes roaming my face before looking down and away. “I was wondering if you’d like to make an appearance. I will admit, it’s an entirely selfish request, and it will once again indebt me to you.”
I lean back into my pillow cocoon and sigh. “I’m really not in the mood for more ceremony—”
“No, no,” he refutes gently. “You wouldn’t have to do anything. I just think your presence will be a morale boost for the team. We’re playing the Falcons,” he explains. “I would love nothing more than for them to lose.”
I’m not entirely sure I understand what’s being asked of me. “My being an audience member will be a morale boost?”
Ben glances up at me, and his smile crinkles the ends of his eyes. “Full disclosure, but the boys actually asked if you would attend.”
“Wouldn’t my attendance be a morale boost for the other team as well?”
Ben bops his head from left to right, looking resigned. “Yes, but you’re my wife, and I’m the co-captain.” He chuckles lowly when I don’t respond. “It seemed to make sense to them. But I understand if you’re not feeling up to it. . .”
It hits me hard, deep within my chest, and I don't know why. A painful sadness washes over me at the thought of him leaving. The overwhelming feeling of abandonment is back. I try to force the ridiculous thought away, but it won't budge. If he were anyone else, I’d tell him to go away.
But I actually like talking to Ben, and if following him back to the mainland means I get to hear him refer to me as his wife more often, then to be perfectly honest with you, we can’t leave soon enough.
“In the unfortunate possibility that we lose,” Ben tells me on the walk to the Temple’s version of a boys locker room, “make sure to stay far, far away from Kyle. He’ll be inconsolable for weeks.”
“Noted.” I slow down until I’ve almost stopped walking completely. Beyond this stone archway is the harmonization of multiple young men singing Mariah Carey’s Fantasy.
“Wait here,” Ben tells me. “Let me make sure they’re clothed.” It’s no time at all before Ben appears back in the archway, waving me in.
I step inside what looks like a normal room within the Temple, and the most surprising thing about it is the fact that it doesn’t smell like unwashed teenage boys. Three young men sit wrapping their knuckles in preparation for the game. Two of the boys immediately stand and bow when they see me, but the other one raises both hands over his head and yells, “YES! I told you she’d be here!”
A fourth boy struts into the locker room with a comedic little dance in his step. “Look alive, dill weeds. I heard Lady Cora is here—” It’s at this point he finally sees me and belts out the most feminine high-pitched scream I’ve ever heard. As the other boys cover their mouths and choke on their laughter, the young man who screamed folds his hands behind his back, smiling widely as he desperately attempts to back up enough to hide behind one of his teammates.
“Cora,” Ben announces and points to the boys one by one, “this is Kyle’s eldest, Ulf.” It’s not surprising that the tallest, most muscular of the group belongs to Kyle. Ulf bows so dramatically his long blonde hair sweeps the ground. “This is Finn.” The happiest of the bunch waves excitedly and then runs a hand through his dark fauxhawk. “The falsetto is Rune.” I watch the freckled redhead turn an embarrassed shade of crimson. “And you’ve already met Andor.” Ben scans the room a second time and frowns. “Where’s Karl?”
Karl? Alex’s Karl? I look over at Ben and realize he doesn’t know. There’s no way he knows that one of his players is destined for a romance with his daughter. I mean, if Ben wouldn’t downright kill Karl, he at least would have forced him to join another team. Does that mean Alex and Karl haven’t even met yet in this universe?
“He went to go kiss his mommy goodbye,” Finn says at the same time Rune says, “He forgot his good boots.”
“Congratulations on killing that absolute waste of space, my lady,” says Ulf. Even his voice is the deepest out of all of them. “I’m only sorry you had to trouble yourself with such a pathetic creature.”
I have to crane my neck all the way back to look up at him and I think, What are they feeding you kids?
“Yeah,” Finn adds. “May his damned soul wander Midgard in ceaseless agony for all eternity!”
All at once, the young men hack up a mouthful of phlegm and spit in unison.
"Damn outsiders are getting too comfortable." Andor nods at Ben. "Coach, you can't seem to ship these people out of here fast enough."
“Hey,” Finn pipes in. “Lady Cora, I’ve got a cousin on Hydra. Is she going to be okay?”
“Yeah,” Rune yells, “my mom’s on Hydra!”
“All of our mom’s are on Hydra, dumbass.”
I hold up my hands, and their yelling quickly dies down. “Everyone on Hydra is safe. I wasn’t attacked on Hydra. I was attacked not too far from here, actually.”
This seems to surprise them, and the group is suddenly a low rumble of discontent.
“He’s lucky I wasn’t there,” Andor proclaims. “You wouldn’t have had to trouble yourself. I would have fucked him up good.”
“The only thing you would have fucked up is your bum knee,” Finn yells, and all of the boys roar with laughter.
I don’t know what I was expecting, but they seem like perfectly normal teenage boys to me. They’re slightly awkward, always laughing, and very springy—like they haven’t quite mastered the aftermath of a generous puberty. I look over at Ben, smiling at the fact that he looks like a father goose proud of his little goslings. Or, rather, humongous goslings.
Finn points at something outside of my line of sight. “Hey, Micro-dick, what took you so long? Games about to start!"
“Guys!” Karl comes crashing into the room, sliding to a stop and panting wildly. “Guys! There’s girls in the audience! Oh,” he says and quickly bows. “Hello, lady Cora.”
“Yeah, we know.” Ulf swings his long hair over a shoulder and starts to tie it up in a knot. “My mom always comes to my games.”
“No, not moms,” Karl emphasizes, wide eyed and out of breath. I almost don’t recognize him with the long hair. “There’s girls in the audience. Like. . . girl girls!”
Everyone is suddenly pushing and shoving for the door to get a good look for themselves. Ben rolls his eyes and I don’t bother following them. Slowly, they return to their seats, looking miserable and slightly green.
“Coach? I’m not going out there,” Finn proclaims loudly into the silence. “This’ll be the one time I get my ass beat on the field, and then Hazel will never marry me.”
“Freyja’s in the audience,” Ulf adds in a low voice. “I’m not making a fool of myself in front of her.”
I’m not in the audience, I’m standing right here. Oh, wait, does he mean my granddaughter? Shit. I never officially met her, even though I promised Chris I would.
A choir of agreement rumbles through the room. Ben tries to calm the young men down, but I immediately have a much better idea.
“Hey,” I call their attention and they fall silent. “Does anyone have water and mint?”
Finn hops up from his seat. “There’s some mint in the cellars.”
I make sure to put on my most excited smile when I say, “Good, go get it. Hurry.” The boys all gather around as I crush up some mint leaves, sprinkle them into a big mug of water, and wave my hands randomly around the container. “Okay, it’s done. Everyone take a drink. And don’t go telling the other teams I did this, unless you want to be disqualified.” I watch each of them as they pass the mug around, sip, and wait for something to happen. “Careful. This is very powerful magic. You feel it?”
“Yeah,” says Andor, standing up taller. “I think so.”
“I don’t know about you all,” says Rune, “but I’m feeling unstoppable.”
As the boys get louder and louder, Ben leans in close to my ear, careful to keep his voice barely above a whisper. “You didn’t actually do anything, did you?”
I smile up at him and he laughs.
Try as I might, I don’t understand what I’m watching. If I were to make an educated guess, I’d say it’s some kind of bastardization of both rugby and American football. None of the boys on either team are wearing protective body-wear, but at least they’re wearing helmets.
I’m sitting alone on a chair overlooking the courtyard where Andor’s ceremony took place. I was hoping Ben would be in the chair beside me, so he could explain what’s going on, but he’s down on the sidelines strategizing with Kyle.
Eventually, someone wins, and judging from the way the Bears are jumping around like fish out of water, I take a wild guess as to who is victorious and head down to the field to congratulate them.
I find Ulf slamming the palms of his hands into his face.
“What’s wrong?” I ask. “What happened?”
“I. . .” He looks somehow completely calm and completely out of his mind all at the same time. “I saw Freyja in the audience. I said…”
“You spoke to her?” Finn stops celebrating, his eyes going wide. “Damn, Mr. Balls-of-steel over here. What did you say?”
Despite being the biggest and oldest of the group, Ulf seems to shrink miserably as he confesses, “I said she has nice teeth.”
Everyone bursts into the loudest choir of laughter I’ve ever heard. Finn laughs so hard he falls to the ground. From out of the chaos, I hear someone yell, “Dude, no!”
Ulf is quick to defend himself. “I meant smile,” he roars, but I doubt any of them are listening. In fact, they’re all headed back to the locker room as Ulf continues to yell, “I meant to say she has a nice smile! Stop laughing! It’s not funny!”
I’m just as surprised as the next person to find myself alone with the Bears as they chatter excitedly in their post-game victory. After double-checking I was fine on my own, Ben headed home to the barracks, leaving me with Eddard, Fenrir, and Pumba.
“Don’t beat yourself up over it,” says Rune. “You’ll have another chance to talk to her.”
“I, on the other hand,” Finn boasts loudly, “only need one chance to woo my beloved Hazel.”
I scribble these names down in my notebook and raise a suspicious eyebrow. “Oh really? Okay, pretend I’m Hazel. What would you do if she were standing where I am now?”
Finn holds a hand against his forehead, rolls his eyes into the back of his skull, and pretends to faint.
I can’t help but laugh at his dramatics. “Be serious.”
“I will simply charm her with my ability to laugh at anything, especially myself.”
“And what will you do if that doesn’t work?”
“Pffft, easy.” Finn immediately drops to his knees, pawing at the hem of my dress, screaming, “Please! I have absolutely no shame! Please, I’ll do anything! HAVE MERCY!”
I listen to them. Laugh with them. Encourage them not to give up hope if they make a bad first impression. I try to give them dating advice, but I realize fairly quickly I don’t actually have any because I’ve never dated before.
“Lady Cora,” Rune interjects. “You’re a lady.”
“Forgive our boy here, Cora,” says Finn. “He’s all brawn and no brains.”
“Shut up,” says Rune, laughing. “I just mean. . . well, how did you pick your husband?”
I look up from my notebook. “Huh?”
“Yeah,” Andor perks up. “What made you pick Ben?”
“I didn’t pick Ben.” I close my notebook and look up at their five eager faces. “I married him to stop the war.”
Rune seems relieved to find everyone else is just as confused as he is. “What war?”
“How do you not know about this?” I ask. “All of your fathers were involved.”
There’s a brief moment of pure silence for the first time all day, but it doesn’t last long.
“I love how our goddess has a sense of humor.” Finn’s laughter dies down just enough for him to say, “Listen, my parents are madly in love, but my mom would literally kill my dad in his sleep if he ever plotted to defy you.”
“Same,” says Ulf, and the rest of the boys chime in to confirm. "You're my mom's favorite god."
Rune nods. "Pretty sure you're everyone's favorite god."
“Oh really?” I strangle my notebook and take a deep breath to try and keep calm. “Did you all not hear about what happened to Erik?”
“About when you kicked his ass?” Finn belts out a squawk of a laugh. “It’s about time someone did.”
I laugh along with them to throw them off the scent. They'd probably run away if they knew how I was actually feeling. “He was trying to rally troops to kill everyone in the barracks.” I study their faces to see if they are surprised to hear this, but they either groan with disdain or roll their eyes.
Andor says, “That’s because Erik is a total tool.”
“Yeah,” Ulf agrees. “Dad says that whole family has delusions of grandeur.”
“Ugh,” Karl groans. “I can’t stand that guy. Or Thor, for that matter.”
This sparks an entirely new set of conversations about their shared dislike of Thor.
“We all know damn well he’s not half-god.” Finn makes a shooing motion and laughs. “I bet my eternal soul that dude doesn’t have a single drop of Aesir blood in him.”
Thor is human, right? So does his family claim he’s partially related to the “real” Thor? Are there other people who claim to be part-god? Are they lying, or do I need to start asking more questions about Norse deities? I mean, if I exist, whose to say another Aesir or Vanir also exist?
As interesting as this information is, my brain is still hyperfocused on their comments about Erik. “What did your dads say was the reason I got married?”
I note by the way they all stop laughing and shoot uncomfortable glances at each other that none of them want to say anything. Finn eventually takes one for the team and answers, “Dad says you have a fetish for mortals.”
“I beg your pardon?”
“Is that the right word?” Finn whispers to the others and they shrug. “Uh, you know, you. . . prefer mortals to gods.”
I blink at them all, too stunned to speak for a good 30 seconds. “Your dad said I married Ben because I prefer mortals to gods?”
“Isn’t that why?”
It takes all my strength not to scream at them to please stop laughing because if you don’t, I’m going to break something. Instead, I calmly say, “You got me there, boys.”
Finn belts out a loud bark of a laugh and then self consciously runs a hand through his fauxhawk. “I’m sorry, lady Cora,” he apologizes. “I’m not laughing at you. As a mortal myself, I just find it funny that you picked Coach of all people."
Their laughter fuzzes into nothing more than white noise as my brain tries to process what they’ve told me.
I excuse myself for the night, claiming to be tired. Then I grab my satchel, gather up Eddard, Fenrir, and Pumba, and make the hike to the Barracks.
I find him eating dinner at his kitchen table. He glances over when I enter unannounced, but he doesn’t stand.
“Oh, Cora,” he says, “hello. Would you like me to make you a plate?”
Even though the table is only set for one, I need confirmation we’re alone. I even told Eddard to take Fenrir and Pumba on a walk while I’m here. “Is Alex home?”
“No.”
“Good.”
“Oh dear,” he mutters jokingly, “which of them got on your bad side today? Apologies in advance for their behavior, but they are teenage—”
“I’m going to give you one chance and one chance only to tell me the truth.” I’m already trembling and I don’t know how to stop. “And then I’m going to give you one chance to try and explain your reasoning.”
“Ah.” Ben slowly looks up at me, but I can tell from his tone he’s not taking this seriously. “I see I’m the one in trouble.”
“Was Erik ever a legitimate threat to either of our people?”
Every facial feature freezes, and that’s how I know the answer when he tries to deflect my question. “Depends on who you ask.”
“Yes or no, Ben,” I interrupt. “Answer yes or no. Was Erik ever a legitimate threat to either of our people?”
There’s a few responses on his lips, but he ends up asking,“Why do you care?”
I’m so upset, I start spluttering. “Why—why do I. . . what? Why do I care? Are you even listening to yourself? Why do I care you lied to me? That you stole my agency? Is that what you’re trying to ask? I had a right to say no, and you took that away from me. Did you honestly think I wouldn’t be angry?”
He continues eating as if this isn’t a serious conversation. “Nobody forced you into anything. The decision was all your own.”
“Because you convinced me I had no other choice! I never wanted to get married. I only married you because you said this would stop people from killing each other.”
“And it will,” he retorts snidely, taking another bite. “In the long run, this will all be worth it. So again, I repeat, why do you care?”
“Oh. . . oh-ho-ho, no.” A low, enraged laughter coughs out of me in-between my words. “I am actually going to. . . if you don’t stop talking, I’m going to—”
“You’ll what?” he questions dryly. “You're going to wag your finger at me?” Ben slowly pushes up out of his seat, so I'm forced to look up at him. “Give me a good chastising?”
I feel it rush up both my arms until they sting so badly I have to move them right now. Locking my fingers together over my head, I belt out an infuriated yell and turn to swing down hard against the nearest thing. I make contact with a loud crunch as wood splinters and pieces scatter around the kitchen. Bits of Ben’s dinner are smooshed all over my fists, and I immediately feel horrible, but it doesn’t last long.
“Did you just. . . break my table?” Instead of looking frightened, Ben’s expression scrunches into pure rage. “I made this table! Do you have any idea how long it took me to make this table?!”
“Nobody was actually going to support a war. Their wives never would have let them.” I think about all that’s happened since I first woke up on the beach, and everything starts to fall into place. “You and Gail ordered the norsemen to pretend to listen to Erik over me. You orchestrated this from the beginning. Was everyone in on it? Or was Erik the only one you left out of the loop?”
He’s not even trying to deny it.
I rush him, pushing him away with only my regular strength. “What is your problem, you psycho?”
He backs up, shaking his head. “I don't expect you to understand.”
“Understand what?”
“That this isn't fair,” he snarls sharply, and I recoil at his anger.
“What isn’t fair?”
“You're supposed to be dead,” he yells, his outburst accusatory.
This time something feels different. Instead of shrinking away and thinking of music and food to keep from facing the fight I’m in, I feel my back straighten. “And whose fault is that, Ben?”
“Are we really doing this?” His rhetorical question hangs in the air for a few seconds, and then he says, “Alright then, let’s do this. You want to know what my problem is? You are my problem. You have always been my problem. I haven’t had a decent night’s sleep in almost 30 years because of you!” All the muscles in his jaw twitch as he seethes. “Do you have any idea what I’ve had to do in preparation for your return?”
“You want an award?”
“I have only ever done what was asked of me, and all I get in return is sarcasm?” He says each word in their own sharp little sentence. “You asked me to wait. So here I am, Cora. I did what you asked for. I waited. I've been very patient.”
I scoff. “I’ve never asked you for anything.”
This seems to be the absolute worst response because now Ben is visibly shaking with rage. “I’ve spent the majority of my life mourning you, and now suddenly here you are, as if nothing ever happened? And I’m just supposed to act like nothing’s wrong?” I back up, but he closes in on me, ranting louder than ever. “You don't know who I am! You don't even know who you are!”
“Fair? Y ou want to talk about fair?” I counter, pushing back and reclaiming some of the space he’s taken. My nose scrunches as I frown deeply, my teeth bared at the audacity of him yelling at me. “You’re mad at me for something I have no memory of.”
“Oh,” he chuckles humorlessly, throwing up a dismissive hand and turning away. “Forgive me. I forgot I’m not allowed to be angry with you about the past because you’ve been reborn. How incredibly convenient to be blessed with such selective ignorance.”
He’s walking away, but that means he wins, and I can’t let that happen. I follow him to his desk, yelling, “You’re mad at me for something I can’t fix. You have no idea what I’ve been dealing with. I never asked to be here!”
“That’s your argument? The old I didn’t ask to be born angle?”
“This isn’t my fault!”
Ben sharply swivels towards me again, nostrils flaring in outrage. “Everything’s your fault! Absolutely everything has always been your fault! You think I wanted to stay here in these ugly houses? You think I enjoy being ostracized and spat on by your people?” He takes another step towards me, and I tighten my fists. I feel my whole body tensing, preparing to fight. “I’ve never asked you for anything, and all you’ve ever done is give me uselessly vague orders! I don’t even know why I care,” he says, softer, more as a rumination with himself. “Is this just something you do for fun? How many other mortals have you done this to? Why me? What made you pick me? Why couldn’t you have just left me alone?”
Nothing he’s saying is making any sense. To be honest, I’m not even entirely sure what we’re fighting about anymore, but I’ll be damned if I’m the one to back down. “What the hell are you even talking about?”
“You ruined my life,” he roars louder than ever, loud enough for me to flinch away. “I didn’t have a childhood because of you! Everyone on this island hates me because of you! I haven’t had a moment to myself since I was thirteen because your bright idea was to leave me in the care of Gail! I’ve had her breathing down my neck for twenty-eight years! And still I’ve—” Ben sucks in a steadying breath, but his words come out just as loud when he says, “I shouldn’t have to babysit a deity. So why is it I am constantly having to clean up your messes?”
My eyes flit down at his fists and find—just like my own—his fingers are balled so tightly his knuckles shine white. “You want to hit me, don’t you? Will that make you feel better? Is that what you want?”
Ben's intense eyes slowly narrow as he stares down at me, his hoarse voice thick with loathing. “You have no idea what I want.”
“Then tell me!” It feels so good to yell at someone who is angry with me, and Ben is deliriously furious, which just makes it all the more satisfying. If he wants a fight, I’ll give him a fight. “For once in your pathetic life,” I scream up at him, feeling brave enough to step closer, “just say what you actually—”
Ben abruptly leans down and cuts me off, tangling his fingers in my hair, holding my head secure as I try to voice my intense confusion, but it only comes out as muffled garble against his eager lips. He must mistake this for excitement because I hear him moan as he deepens the kiss, slipping his tongue inside my mouth, pushing me up against the wall.
I don’t know how long it is before I regain control of my limp arms, but when I do, I get my hands on his chest and shove him away from me, our lips finally parting with a loud smack. There are a million things I want to say as I stare, open-mouthed and horrified.
All I manage to scream is, “WHAT?”
Ben slides away across the hardwood floor from the force of my shove, but he easily rights himself, his eyes heavy-lidded and crazed as he slowly advances. “What would you like me to say?”
“Stop,” I order. “Stop.”
“Cora,” he continues, despite my interruption, “I love—”
“No. No. No. No, you don’t,” I splutter, backing away until I bump into a kitchen chair, frantically jabbing a finger at him, trying to make sense of all this.
“Everything you said was true,” he continues as we circle each other around the broken kitchen table. “Every last thing. It wasn’t easy—gods, it wasn’t easy—but it worked,” he adds with an elated smile. “I made it work.”
“You said. . .” Gulping another breath, I motion between us. “This isn’t. . . You told me this was a contract marriage.” I back away until we’re separated by the couch, but he’s still advancing, slowly, dazed elation in his eyes. My head is spinning so fast, I’m in very real danger of blacking out. “I thought. . . I thought you hated me?”
“I should,” he confirms, chuckling like we’re sharing an inside joke.
“What do you mean you should? If you should, then why don’t you?”
“Cora,” he pleads, staring in a deeply longing way that makes me even more confused, “I devoted my entire life to you years ago. I will do whatever you ask of me. You need only ask.”
We circle his desk, cross the room again, and end up back in the kitchen. “Our marriage was to save people.” I mean to continue shouting, but my voice is too weak to carry the weight. “It was never about us.”
Ben easily sidesteps the kitchen chair I’ve pulled out to slow him down. He never even breaks eye contact as he catches up to me. “Can it not be for both?”
I never realized just how blue his eyes are, especially in contrast to his now dilated pupils. They trail across every inch of my face and finally settle on my mouth.
As I grew into an adult, I couldn’t help but fantasize about what it would be like to have someone look at me the way Ben’s looking at me now. But this isn’t anything like I thought it would be. All of this is wrong.
I have to get out of here. My eyes flit around wildly. Do I go for the door? Should I jump out the window?
I’ve always been attracted to men, but in an appreciation sort of way. There was never a lustful spark. Never any kind of sexual urge. Now my heart actually hurts from the ferocity of its beats as my entire body grows warm with desire.
This wasn’t supposed to happen.
A horrible heat pulses through my core. I'm so aroused I start to panic at the thought that Ben can somehow tell. It was easy to keep my distance when this was a nice little daydream I had control over, when I had no physical reactions other than slight embarrassment when he’d say something suggestive, but now that he’s admitted his flirtations were always actual flirtations—that I was the desired recipient of his attention—I’m consumed with so much lust I can't even think straight. I want him to kiss me again. I want him to touch me. I want to know what he feels like.
But when he brings a hand up to cup the side of my face, I flinch away.
Ben moves backwards, hands raised. “Cora, I’m not going to hurt you.”
“Anything?” I question, whispering the rest. “You would do anything for me? No matter what I ask for?”
His face brightens at the opportunity. “Whatever you—”
“Good.” I try to swallow, but my mouth has run dry. “Good. Sit, right there. Over there. On the couch.”
He doesn’t immediately move. I watch his eyes follow my index finger to the seating on the other side of the room. Instead of arguing, he stays true to his word and backs up, slowly sinking into the cushions I’m pointing at.
I turn and rush for the door, but I spin back around when I hear him stand. “Sit down,” I order.
“Wait, where are you going?”
“Sit down,” I repeat. Something in his confused expression shifts and saddens as he realizes what I’m doing. Now that he’s not so close, the adrenaline rush lessens, and I am suddenly egregiously drowsy. “Don’t follow me.”
Ben stares, his expression blank. He sits. It feels like a lifetime before he gives a small nod.
Notes:
Don't worry y'all. They're not going all the way back to square one.
Chapter 19: I Want To Know What Love Is
Notes:
(See the end of the chapter for notes.)
Chapter Text
In New York, you ride the subway to get anywhere in the city. Taxis and Ubers are expensive emergencies and a luxury a broke college student like me can’t afford. Depending on the age of the subway car, the rusted wheels grating against the rusted tracks can be anywhere from mildly annoying to migraine inducing as it echoes endlessly throughout the tunnel.
My head is currently a rusted subway car, screeching so loudly I couldn’t hold onto a coherent thought if my life depended on it.
I close my eyes to blink away the tears, but the second I do, I see her. Standing over me. Soaked in blood and staring down with disgust and hatred. I open my eyes, but night has fallen and darkness is everywhere.
I spin around in circles, seeing her behind a house or a tree or the gazebo. She’s everywhere, and I don’t know where I can run to get away from the memory of what happened. I don’t know where I am. I collapse in the grass and wrap my arms around my head.
“Did he hurt you?”
I gasp and turn to see who is speaking, finding Eddard, Fenrir, and Pumba trotting towards me in the moonlight. “What?”
Eddard gallops over to my side and lowers into a threatening stance, his hair bristling and rising as he emits a deep warning growl. “You weep. Are you injured? Did he hurt you?”
I choke out a laugh because I can’t help it. “No, I’m not hurt.”
“Why do you weep?”
“He told me. . .” Eddard waits for me to calm down and finish, and for a moment, I’m not sure I can. “He told me he loves me.”
“You’re upset . . . because your mate told you he loves you? I’m afraid I do not understand.”
“He’s lying,” I whisper, not bothering to wipe away the new tears.
“And what makes you say that?”
An ache in my chest blossoms into something so painful it’s difficult to tell what specifically hurts more. “Because nobody loves me.”
With an affronted oink, Pumba climbs into my lap and presses his snout against my stomach. “I love you, mama.”
Fenrir props himself up on my leg and licks my arm. “Me too.”
“I am protecting you because you are important,” Eddard huffs lowly. “Jane does not instruct me to protect those she does not care about.”
I don’t understand why I was never enough. I never did anything wrong. I was a goodie-goodie child who was too paranoid of my parents wrath to cause anyone trouble. I’ve spent my life apologizing for existing by trying to be the nicest, or the smartest, or the funniest in any given situation because simply existing isn’t enough. My parents both made that abundantly clear.
Your parents are supposed to protect you. They’re supposed to love you when no one else will. I’m shaking so much my teeth chatter. Why didn’t they love me?
No amount of laughter will release the tension in my throat. I want my Nonna to comfort me. I want someone to comfort me because I feel like I’m seconds from splitting open from loneliness.
I’m suddenly engulfed in rough fur as Eddard leans forward and rests his massive head on my shoulder. I reach up, wrap my arms around him, and wait for the flashes to start. I wait for the panic to rise up inside me like a sweltering sickness. Instead, I feel the comfort I was longing for, but this only makes me cry harder.
I once read in a medical journal that humans need an average of 4 hugs a day for survival, 8 hugs a day for maintenance, and 12 hugs a day for growth. Technically, I should have been long dead.
I’ve denied myself physical touch for too long, but now I’m receiving three hugs at the same time, and that has to count for something.
Minutes go by as I stand in front of Ben's front door with my hand raised and ready to knock. I decide to just let myself in.
“You're back?” It’s been an hour, or two, or three—or maybe it’s only been fifteen minutes—and Ben hasn’t moved from his seat on the couch. He looks genuinely surprised and sits up straight, but he doesn’t stand as I enter.
I should have thought harder about how I would start this. I’m worried I’ll be too mean. Or not mean enough. I’m worried I’m only going to make this worse.
“Okay.” I take a steading breath and force myself to start talking. “I ruined your life. You looked up to me when you were young, and I messed up. I ruined your life just like my parents ruined mine. So I’m going to give you something they never gave me.” My legs are moving all on their own as I cross the room and take a seat next to him. “A chance to talk.”
Ben stands abruptly. “I would really rather we didn’t,” he cuts in, avoiding my eyes on his way to the kitchen. “What is there to talk about? I misread the situation.”
“But—” I don’t know if this would be easier or not if he’d give me his full attention, so I say it to his retreating back. “I’m trying to explain that you didn’t.”
“Didn’t,” he echoes, and I can’t tell if he’s mocking me or not, “didn’t what?”
“Didn’t misread the situation.” I don’t know what to do when he turns to fix me with his brows furrowed in extreme confusion. The sight of him so perplexed makes me swallow all of the inappropriate laughter fighting to free itself. “I came back because. . . I wanted to say I’m sorry.”
“You’re sorry?” I can’t tell if he’s angry or just processing what I’ve said. “You’re not the one who made a complete fool of themself.”
“Ben, this isn’t about you.”
“Right. Right, apologies—”
“No,” I clarify. “That’s not what I mean. What I mean is. . . my reaction earlier wasn’t about you. It’s. . .” I try to think of the easiest way to explain, but I end up giving up with a sigh.
“Maybe,” Ben offers, “if you talk through what you were thinking I can better understand what happened.”
“I was. . . very surprised.”
“Oh.” Ben presses his lips tightly together while he thinks of a response. “I thought I’ve been rather forward since your rebirth.”
“So you have been flirting with me this whole time?”
“Evidently not very effectively, or you wouldn’t have to ask.”
I raise a hand to point at him, ball my fists, and fold my hands in my lap instead. “Why did you say Gail told you to flirt with me?”
“Because she did,” he says matter of factly. “But that doesn’t mean I needed her orders to do so of my own volition. To be honest,” he adds, his eyes shifting down and away, “this is entirely my fault. I've been misreading your words and actions as something they are not and was mistakingly under the impression you were returning my advances.”
“When?"
“Before the wedding,” he answers sheepishly. “And. . . during the wedding. I realize now that you weren't returning my advances, you simply exist in a perpetual state of kindness.”
"Advances? What advances? What are you talking about?" I unclench my fists and rub both hands over my eyes. "Ok, can I be honest? I don't do well with ambiguity. If you've been flirting with me, it's never been obvious enough for me to know for sure you aren't just being nice."
"I see." Ben pauses, and I watch as his index finger picks at his thumb's cuticle. “As unfortunate the circumstance in which they were expressed,” he murmurs, “my earlier sentiments were still genuine.”
“Stop saying that,” I respond a little too sharply. “You don’t love me because you don’t know me. You can’t love someone you know nothing about.”
“No,” he refutes, “I love you more than anything. I’ve dedicated—”
“I don’t want you to worship me,” I interrupt loud enough for him to immediately fall silent. “Do you have any idea how uncomfortable that makes me feel?”
“I—” His eyes are cloudy with fear and desperation. “Then what do you want?”
“Ben, listen to me.” He’s still standing in the kitchen, sullen and embarrassed, so I turn completely in my seat on the couch to face him. “I need you to listen to me. You are in a cult. You’re in a cult, and that’s entirely my fault, and I am so, so sorry. But what this is—” I motion between us. “—isn’t love. It’s a lot of things, but it isn’t. . . look, I’m not an expert, but I do know this isn’t healthy.”
I watch as he silently thinks through a million responses before settling for, “You said it’s impossible for me to love you because I don’t know you, but that’s not true. I know a lot about you.”
He’s not listening. He’s not understanding. “Oh, you do, huh? Okay, what’s my favorite color?”
“Green.”
“What’s my middle name?”
“June.”
I nod my head as if I’m impressed. “Do you know on which of my birthdays I tried to kill my father?”
Ben’s confusion is brief and muted—nothing more than a few confused flutters of his eyelashes and a twitch of his brow.
“Do you know why the first alcoholic drink I ever had in my entire life was at our wedding?” I reach down and gather my skirts, pooling them up around me to show him the long blotted scar just above my knee. “Do you know how I got this? Because these are all fundamentally important to who I am, so I’d think someone who claims to know me would be able to answer.” Fueled by his silence, I continue. “Ben, you don’t know me anymore than I know you.”
I’ve barely finished speaking before he asks, “What do you want to know?”
I sigh with frustration.
“Ask me anything,” he continues.
“What makes you think I even want to know you? You’ve been lying to me since the moment I landed on this stupid island!”
“Then tell me more about yourself.” Ben takes a few steps towards me. “I want to know you.”
“What do you want to know, exactly? I ruined your life, right? That’s what you said. I ruined your life. Well, guess what? It seems to be a talent of mine, because I ruined my parent’s lives, too.”
“Yeah,” he says solemnly, and I realize he must be thinking about his mother. “I know what that’s like.”
All these years of secrecy. All these years of bottling up the worst moments of my life. I’m tired of holding this misery inside of me.
“Your dad was an asshole, but at least your parents wanted you.” Despite having never told another living soul before, I find myself blurting out, “I was a mistake. My parents got married because of me, and then they spent the entirety of my life making it clear I wasn’t wanted. It was night and day how they treated my siblings. And don’t even get me started on my brother. My parents practically worshiped the ground he walked on for no other reason than he was a boy.”
The anxious shivering returns, so I clench my fists and take a steading breath as every ugly memory resurfaces, crawling up from the dark places I shoved them in long ago.
I'm 6, watching my father torture my mother over her post-baby weight after my twin sisters were born.
I'm 10, and my drunken father has just thrown away my birthday cake in front of my embarrassed friends because he says I don't need to get any fatter than I already am.
I'm 12, coming home from school everyday, eating anything and everything my grandmother puts in front of me because it feels good to eat and she’s the only person who has ever shown me kindness. I want her to love me because I love her and she loves cooking.
I'm 16, and I can't buy the same matching skirt all my friends are buying because the store doesn’t have my size.
I'm 18, completely on my own for the first time, and I'm sitting in my dorm room on the other side of the country mourning my grandmother by eating far past the moment my stomach alerts me I'm full—sinking my teeth into pastries and pastas and slices of pizza from down the street and bagels from the corner bakery and whatever else I can get my hands on to help dull the pain of homesickness.
I'm 19, struggling to pull myself out of bed in the morning. Struggling to force myself to walk around the city more. Struggling to rid myself of the shame my parents have caused me.
I'm 20, unhappy despite the health progress I've made. Nothing will ever impress me at this point. I'm too far gone. Nothing I could ever do will be enough to love myself. Nobody will ever want me because my own parents don’t even want me.
I thought leaving my childhood house would free me, but I'm not even in the same dimension as my father and I'm still not free from him.
“So, it's 2am, right? And I’m—” There’s nothing threatening about Ben’s movements as he slowly takes a seat beside me, far enough away that we’re not touching. He nods for me to continue, and I cannot stop myself from saying, “Ma just. . . disappears all day and I have no idea where she went, or if she’s okay, or when she plans on returning. If she plans on returning at all. And now it’s 2 in the morning, and I’m just so tired.”
I shared a room with my siblings, and even though they were all fast asleep, I was wide awake, playing the role of the concerned parent waiting up for their child to return home.
“The second I heard someone come through the front door, I ran out to check on her, and she’s just standing in the entryway.” Long gashes slash up and down her jeans and shirt, shredded fabric stained with clotted blood. Almost the entirety of her forehead is missing. Just gone. Blood is everywhere. I can smell it from here. “She was hurt. Badly hurt. But my father looked completely fine. And I just remember thinking it’s happened. It’s finally happened. He’s going to finish killing her, and then he’s going to kill us. So I took my siblings and locked them in the bathroom. And then I ran to the kitchen and grabbed a knife.” I’m not cold, but I cannot stop shaking. “I don’t remember everything that happened, it all happened so fast. I stabbed him. I must have, with the amount of times I tried to. But he pushed me, and I fell on the knife and cut my leg, and he ran. When I went to check on my mom, I realized she wasn’t dead. She was blackout drunk.”
I try to take her bloodied face in my hands, but she lashes out and smacks me hard on the nose. My sweet, loving, gentle mother has been soiled with alcohol, and it's turned her into a monster. A horrible, truthful monster.
“She told me she hated me,” I whisper, as if this will lessen the blow. “She said I ruined her life. Ma was one of the most religious people I knew, and I was such a source of shame for her. She said—” I trail off, hearing her voice echoing in my memory. “She said I never should have been born.” I look up at him. “I didn’t know what to do, so I cleaned her wounds until she fell unconscious. And I just watched her breathing. All night long. I couldn’t stop watching her breathing because I was afraid if I looked away—if I looked away for even a second—she would stop.”
Ben stares at me, silent, but it doesn’t make me uncomfortable. There’s something in his eyes that tells me he understands. "How old were you?"
I will never forget that day for as long as I live. It was my birthday. “Thirteen.”
“What happened after that?”
“When she woke up in the morning,” my voice cracks, so I clear my throat, “she didn't remember anything she said.”
“What happened to your father?”
“He eventually came back,” I answer dryly. “He always came back. And they acted like everything was normal, or as normal as life in our house could be. I was always having to take care of them.”
Ben’s eyes dart back and forth, deep in thought. “But if you were taking care of your parents, who was taking care of you?”
I frown at the idea. “I don’t need anyone to take care of me.”
“But then why were you taking care of your siblings?”
“Because they were just children,” I snap, as if it were the most obvious thing in the world.
“Cora,” he says slowly, “you were a child.”
It's what I've needed to hear my entire life, but I don’t know what to do with it. Every conceivable emotion tries to take control at once: I’m angry that I was never allowed to be a child, I’m in mourning for the person I would be today if my parents had been better people, I’m scared that there’s no stopping their influence from destroying my life.
I’m going to become my father. My actions are going to directly result in Ben feeling as alienated and lonely as my father made me feel. Ben’s right. I ruined his life. I’m going to ruin his life and there’s nothing I can do to stop it.
“I ruined your dinner.” I stand, dazed, and head towards the kitchen. “Let me make you something.”
“Don’t worry about that, just please, sit down—”
I stiffen and shrink away at the feeling of his fingers on my arm. “Let me do this,” I barely get my request out in a croaking sob. “Please?”
Reaching into a cupboard, Ben pulls out a container of salt and sets it down next to me on the counter. “Continue seasoning with your tears if you so wish,” he says. “I just want to let you know you have options.”
It’s a struggle to breathe while laughing and crying at the same time.
It turns out Ben made one of my favorite NYC staples for dinner—before I broke his table and sent his food flying all over the kitchen. There was still plenty of uncooked falafel in the fridge, but Ben made everything from scratch, so we need to make more pita bread and tahini sauce. I stand at the kitchen counter, chopping up tomatoes, onions, lettuce, lemon, and garlic while Ben insists on helping by grinding up the required herbs in a mortar and pestle.
“I need two sprigs of dill.” Ben wipes his hands on his apron, riffles through a drawer, and pulls out pruning shears. “All of the herbs are around the side of the house, under this window,” he adds, wagging a thumb at the window over the kitchen sink.
“Why do I have to go get it?”
His expression is serious, but his teasing tone gives him away. “You do know what fresh dill looks like, don’t you? For starters, it’s green.”
I snatch the shears out of his hand and head outside to where he indicated. Up against the side of the house is an herb garden with thriving plants of dill, oregano, basil, rosemary, and what looks like thyme, among others. I return with the dill, wipe my face dry of tears, and watch him grind the herbs up. I’ve never met someone who actually uses a mortar and pestle. “You’re a food snob,” I announce into the silence.
I didn’t mean it as a complement, but his face brightens. “Thank you.”
We continue prepping and cooking in silence until I have nothing left to chop. Ben silently waits for the falafel to finish frying and the pita to get a nice char. Not knowing what to do with myself, I stand nearby and wonder how I’m going to get him a new table without all of this drama unleashing into the rumor mill.
All of the blood rushes out of my face, only to immediately return in a searing blush as I think about his table. The dreams I’ve been having about him? I’m starting to think they’re not just fantasies. It's foresight. According to one of my recent dreams, this entire encounter was supposed to end very differently. I mean, the table still would have ended up broken, but Ben wouldn’t have been mad about it. Not in the slightest.
No matter what I do, we’re eventually going to have sex, or Christopher wouldn’t exist. But he does exist. Which means our relationship is inevitable.
I watch him concentrate on the food and realize that out of everyone on this island, I enjoy talking to Ben the most. He makes me laugh, and I like making him laugh. Maybe I feel safe around him because he can empathize? I mean, that's why I never told anyone my sob story before. Nobody would get it. My friends sure wouldn't have. I guess in a way it feels good to know somebody else—someone human—knows.
Besides, there is a direct cause-and-effect that results in me getting blasted into the past. For the time being, my future may be inevitable, but if I just live life exactly like I always have, I can hold off the inevitable for longer than usual. But if I’m going to try and remain friends for now, there are some uncomfortable truths that need addressing. “So are we just not going to talk about it?”
Ben flips the falafel with a set of metal tongs. “Talk about what?”
“Christopher.”
“What about him?”
“About how he’s my son?”
“And I’m sure he’s not the only one,” Ben muses. “You're thousands of years old. You have a lot of children. How is that any of my business?”
He doesn’t know. He doesn’t know Christopher is his. Which makes sense. From his perspective, how could Chris be his son? I died when Ben was just a tween. He’s unaware something terrible is going to happen that sends pregnant me back to the 70s. Then why was he so upset Chris wanted to introduce himself as my son? Oh, I guess he was worried I’d panic at even more surprising news and call off the wedding again.
I have no idea how to restart this conversation, so I blurt out, “What’s the tattoo on your back?”
“A dragon.”
“What does it mean?”
Ben chuckles lowly. “It means I thought it was cool at the time.”
“Can I see your other tattoo?”
Ben’s hesitation makes me momentarily worried that his second tattoo actually is on an embarrassing part of his body. So I’m surprised when he reaches down and pulls up his pant leg to show me a row of runes in the soft flesh behind his knee.
“What does it say?”
Ben pulls his pant leg back down, seemly all too eager to cover it up. “A group of men pinned me to the ground and gave me this shortly after your death. It is the worst insult they have in their language. A word so cursed I’ve only heard them say it out loud once, when they were marking me.”
I lean back against the countertop and stare at him in horror. “Gail didn’t stop them?”
“Gail’s job was only ever to ensure nobody killed me,” Ben answers, shrugging. “So she stood nearby and made sure they didn’t kill me.”
Nothing can compare to the guilt I feel right now. Not Margo’s death. Not Erik’s injuries. My mind reels for something to say to selfishly take away some of the blame I’m feeling. “Someone told you to marry me. Right?” Ben looks over at me, ready to respond, but gives up and returns his attention to the food. “See? Someone told you to marry me, so you told me to marry you. Neither of us ever really had a choice.”
Ben continues cooking, but it looks as if all the light has washed out of him.
“Ben? Please say something.”
“Cora,” he gets out in a low, exhausted voice, “I was raised for you. My entire life’s purpose is to be your husband. Every significant thing I’ve ever done has been in preparation to marry you. So you’re essentially telling me my life is meaningless.”
“What did I say to you? Earlier, you mentioned I had given you orders. When did I give you orders, and what did I say?” I lower my voice at the look of panic on his face. “I’m not angry, I’m just trying to figure out what’s going on.”
Ben finishes removing the falafel and pita from the stovetop and begins assembling the sandwiches. “When I was fifteen—” Ben busies himself with the food, the memory evidently too painful to tell me without sufficient pauses. “I went out to your shrine to kill myself. I’m not proud of it,” he adds. “But. . . I was just so lonely. This was before Kyle recruited me to the team, so I had no friends. I had no one to talk to. Everyone was constantly threatening to kill me anyway, so I thought why not save them the effort?” He laughs, but it’s not funny, and I finally see for myself what I must look like when I laugh inappropriately. “And then suddenly, there you were,” he continues. “Wandering out of the trees. You took the knife away from me and said when you came back for good, I’d find a way for us to be together. You made me promise to wait for your return. You said we’d be happier than I could possibly imagine if I could just wait a little longer.”
Nobody prepared me for the physical effects of heartbreak, and I can literally feel my heart breaking. All I can do is stare at him when I ask, “Why didn’t you tell me this from the beginning?”
Ben starts to respond, but he clears his throat instead and says, “Because I have no way of proving it even happened.”
“I’m sorry,” I whisper, but it feels hollow. Sorry is for when you step on someone's foot, or accidentally burn dinner. Sorry does not excuse the poor decisions I made that led him to a lifetime of pain and suffering. “Ben, I am so sorry you’ve been. . . waiting for me to return for so long.” We lock eyes and I force myself to keep the contact to ensure he understands how serious I am. “But I need you to understand I don’t owe you anything. I’m not sleeping with you tonight, if that’s why you’re making me food.”
“No,” he says, looking increasingly insulted at the idea. “What? No, that’s not what I—”
“Well,” I interrupt, “after everything you’ve said, what am I supposed to think?”
“Cora, I’m making you food because I want to,” he says. “And because, if you’ve already forgotten, you destroyed my dinner, and I’m hungry. I just want to take care of each other. Can we do that?”
“Ben, you don’t want to date me.”
“Why not?”
Now it’s my turn to laugh when I don’t mean it. “Because I’m a mess. You’re a mess. Two messes don’t clean themselves up, they just make a bigger mess.”
“I see,” he says, and it's hard to tell just how upset he really is. I watch his index finger tap soundlessly against the countertop. His throat bobs as he swallows. “So, you want me to leave you alone? Because if that’s what you want—” I can hear the carefully concealed pain in his pause. “If that’s what you truly want, Cora, I’ve already told you. I’ll do whatever you ask of me.”
Why are you lying to him? What is the point of lying anymore? Fear of rejection? There’s nothing to fear because there is no rejection. He’s made that abundantly clear. So, what is it? You can only keep him at arms length for so long. Christopher exists. Our future together is inevitable.
I watch Ben steel himself for more rejection, but the thought of doing so somehow physically hurts even more than the thought of being rejected. If anything, the way he’s looking at me just fills my chest with painful sorrow for being the one to disappoint him so severely.
Tell him the truth. He deserves the truth.
“ Ben,” I whisper, trying my hardest not to be embarrassed that my eyes are already swelling with tears. He’s busy watching steam waft off the sandwiches, so I catch him unawares when I reach for his hand, squeezing with what I hope is reassurance. “I don’t want to be alone anymore.”
“I don’t understand.” Ben looks transfixed at our clasped hands. His eyes travel up to rest on mine. “ What do you want?”
“I . . . I don’t know what I want. I don’t know how to have a relationship.” I heave a sigh in an attempt to keep from crying. “I just want to stop hurting. I want to stop feeling like this all the time. I don’t know how to do that.”
All of his fingers curl around my hand. “Let me help. We can. . . start all over. Want to help me run some errands tomorrow?”
I laugh, but this time I mean it. “You’re supposed to date before marriage, but you skipped that part.” Despite my lingering frustrations with learning this marriage was technically built on a lie, I smile at the adorable eagerness on his face. “Can I get a rain check on that? I need to go back to Hydra and change. Oh! How about you come visit me? We can have a picnic on the beach. I could use your advice on some cultural matters.”
“I. . . can’t do that. It’s not that I don’t want to,” he adds quickly. “It’s just that we’ve worked so hard to secure this treaty. We have to be cognizant of who is around at all times.”
“What does that have to do with anything?” I’m starving, and he’s just watching the food get cold, so I grab my plate and take a bite. It’s so delicious I have to force myself to chew slowly so I can savor it. “I thought you said this was all manufactured?”
“Your people only let me marry you because it’s a formality. I’m a joke to them otherwise. Gail has worked very hard when communicating the situation, so the men understand our marriage to be—” Ben suddenly looks uncomfortable as he tries to formulate his thoughts. “They see me as your. . . pet, of sorts. But their wives believe you married me purely as a favor to calm Erik’s instability. He actually is certifiably unhinged, by the way. But they never would have allowed this if they believed I’d actually pursue you. And I don’t believe they’d be very happy to find out their husbands lied to them.”
“Like you lied to me?” I realize something and sigh. “Actually, you’re right. We can’t let anyone on Hydra find out. Or anyone here, for that matter. Especially Alex.”
“Alex?”
“Listen, if one of my friends started dating my dad, I would immediately disown them. You want me to continue giving you intel? Alex can’t find out.”
“Who says she has to know? Who says anyone has to know?”
“Are you suggesting we secretly date?” That actually sounds nice. I already have no privacy as it is, so taking the extra steps necessary to keep our true relationship completely private seems like a dream come true. “Okay, but you have to promise me something.”
“Anything.”
“Can you ask next time before kissing me?”
“Of course.” I watch a flush rush up Ben’s throat and spread to his cheeks. “I apologize for earlier. May I kiss you?”
“Yes, like I said, just ask next time.” I wait for him to nod or say something, but he just stares expectantly at me. “Wait, are you asking now?” At this, he simply nods, and now I’m the embarrassed one. “I. . uh, I mean, I. . . I guess so. Sure. Yes. Just one,” I add nervously.
I’m pretty sure you’re not supposed to have this many endorphins clouding your judgement just for a kiss. But when Ben leans down, my heart soars straight out of my chest, and I finally understand why Hydra island has so many children. Our lips press warmly together, but it’s not deep, or feverish, or impatient. It's as light as the flap of a butterfly's wing. It's barely a kiss at all.
Ben pulls away first, and his eyes dart to my falafel. “We should finish our sandwiches before they get cold.” When he smiles, I’m happy to find his eyes are at least a little less sad.
Alex’s room was a treasure trove into understanding her better. Posters for bands I wasn’t allowed to listen to as a child are tacked into the walls, her electric guitar is nestled in its case in the corner, and her bed is overflowing with hand-sewn stuffed animals.
I may have snooped through her belongings last night when Ben and I parted ways after dinner, but that’s just because I’m taking my job as her guardian seriously! I even found a box of letters she’s been exchanging with her friends on Hydra and didn’t read them, thank you very much. Trust me, what I found hidden in a box under a loose floorboard is much more entertaining, and I literally can’t wait to see the look on her face when she finds out I know her secret.
“Lady Cora!”
I’ve had quite a few nuisances in my life, but Artz is starting to top that chart. I made the mistake of stepping in and defending him, and now he’s obsessed with tracking me down when I visit the Barracks and feeding me trivia about the Vanir and the Aesir, as if I’m going to reward him with a gold star for his efforts.
I originally stepped into a situation in which another survivor was mocking his name. He did a very good job of hiding it, but I could tell how much grief people have given Artz for his name over the course of his life. I can’t even imagine the level of bullying that must have happened back when he was in school, and it made me angry on his behalf, so I told him, “There’s absolutely nothing wrong with the name Leslie. Any grown adult who says otherwise probably laughs unironically at poop jokes and isn’t worth your time.”
And now, yet again, I’ve been spotted.
Jane, Ben, and I have compiled a list of survivors who I know nothing about and cannot vouch for in terms of a safety risk. Then they cross checked my lack of knowledge with whatever they could pull up with their off-island research connections to determine a new schedule for sending people home. Some of the survivors are being watched more closely than others. Artz, evidently, is not one of them.
I see him and force a smile. Even though he is currently low on the list, I need to have a chat with Ben about including Artz in the next sub shipment home. “Hi, Leslie.”
Paying my obvious annoyance no mind, Artz starts in again on his stupid Norse trivia. I can’t even get a word in to explain that I don’t have time for this and need to get back to Hydra. In the end, I turn around and hurry away from him as he trails behind me, spouting factoids.
“Who are you running from?”
I spin around and find Ben leaning against his porch railing. He adjusts his backpack straps before walking down the front steps and standing beside me.
“I’m not running,” I say. “I’m. . . power walking.”
“Fair enough.” Ben steps past me, nonchalantly looking around the side of the house. “Who are you power walking away from?”
“No, no,” I say in a rush. “He’s—” Artz rounds the corner, and I’m caught all over again.
Ben’s tone is friendly, but he doesn’t smile when he says, “I don’t believe we’ve met.” He holds out a hand. “Benjamin.”
Artz shakes it, briefly smiling with disinterest before looking back at me. “Like I was saying, I took quite a few classes on Norse Mythology for my doctorate. Wasn’t really required for my major, but I—”
“Hold on,” Ben interrupts sharply and gestures towards me. “Did you just refer to her as a myth?” Artz starts spluttering something, but Ben ignores him and turns to me with one eyebrow slightly raised. “Has he been lecturing you about . . . yourself?”
“Look,” Artz says. “I didn’t mean to offend—”
“No, please continue.” I can tell by the ever so subtle change in Ben's eyes that he isn’t angry. I’m proven right when he stops fighting a small smile. “This is more amusing than it has any right to be.”
“I was wondering if you could show me around, Lady Cora?”
Ben glances at me, and I worry that he won’t be able to read the panic in my completely blank expression, but in the end it’s a useless worry. Ben notices everything. “Actually,” he tells Artz, “I’m afraid she’s already made plans to check on our pasture.” Ben turns towards me and tilts his head towards his house. “You left your bag inside.”
Artz lights up at the news. “Pasture? What kind of animals do you tend? Mind if I join you?”
“Yes, I do mind,” Ben answers immediately, his voice quiet but still deceivingly friendly. “This is an official matter, not a tour of our facilities. If you’d like a tour, I suggest you ask Ethan. He’d be more than happy to show you around.”
“Right. Well, ah. . . I guess I’ll see you around?”
“She lives here,” Ben says snidely. I can tell he’s getting annoyed. “So there’s a high probability of that, yes. For now, goodbye.” As soon as Artz has rounded the corner out of sight, Ben turns to fix me with a raised brow. “What did you do?”
“Me? I didn’t do anything,” I snap. “Someone was making fun of his name, so I stepped in. I was just trying to be nice. And now he won’t stop giving me lectures about my own people like some kind of mobile Jeopardy game.”
Ben nods, the lingering amusement from before returning in full force. “You should probably meet our cows sooner rather than later. What do you think?”
“. . . and Rune said he meant no offense because I was basically everyones mom.” I smile at the memory. “And that’s when Finn said he loves his mom dearly, but thanks Odin every day that he wasn’t born Greek.”
“And I’m sure he said that very confidently for someone whose family tree is a wreath.”
I break out into fresh laughter as we step out of the trees and head towards a grassy field. My steps slow until I’m standing still. “Is that. . . Mikhail?”
A man that looks suspiciously like Mikhail stands off in the distance, scrubbing a herd of lounging dairy cows with a mop and bucket of soap water. The only reason I’m not fully convinced it is Mikhail is because whoever this is keeps cooing at the cows and calling them my beauties.
Ben calls out to him in greeting, and the man hurries over to us. As he gets closer, I can confirm it’s Mikhail after all, and he notices me as well.
Mikhail reaches up and rips off a flower crown, snarling at Ben under his breath, “You didn’t mention she would be with you. You give me no warning? My Lady,” he proclaims loudly and bows, “it is beyond an honor to meet you at last. Forgive my appearance, as I was not expecting you today.”
I have yet to officially meet the cows on Hydra, but I highly doubt they are as well pampered as these cows are. They greet me kindly but lazily, not bothering to get up from their comfortable seats in the grass. Ben pulls assorted vegetables out of his backpack and feeds each cow their own particular favorite.
I don’t have a gameplan yet for how I’m going to right the wrongs of the future/past hybrid, but I do know one thing. As long as I don’t get pregnant, I’ll stay in this time period. But between watching Ben cook and seeing the attention to detail he’s paid to know each individual cows favorite snack, I start to regret our secret dating pact. Being alone with him is a very bad idea.
“Thank you for joining me,” Ben says. I think for a moment he’s leaning down to kiss me, and I find I’m disappointed he’s following my request not to kiss me without my permission. Instead, I feel his face hover near my ear. “But you should probably head back to Hydra. Send me a raven when you’ve rested up. And have Gail request you a new swimsuit.”
“What for?”
“Because I’ve decided on our next date,” he whispers. “I’m going to teach you how to swim.”
Notes:
This is so much fun to write! Thank you to all who have commented so far :) Y'all keep me motivated for real.
Chapter 20: A Whole Lot Of Labor
Notes:
(See the end of the chapter for notes.)
Chapter Text
Why did I agree to this? I should have said no. I have the power to say no. Why didn’t I say no?
Ben’s already in the water, shirtless, arms crossed in annoyance. “Are you just going to stand there all morning?”
I can’t focus. I can’t avert my eyes. I stand immobile in silent admiration for the way he’s built. Ben’s not loudly powerful like Erik or Kyle, he’s quietly powerful like Christopher. They don’t need bulging arms of visible muscle to have the strength to dominate a fight. Erik and Kyle are lions, but Christopher and Ben are equally deadly vipers.
Ben calls for me again, but I still can’t focus. My mind keeps imagining the rest of the evening because I already know how the day ends. It ends with laughter that leads to kissing which leads to his deft hands stuffed down the inside of my bathing-suit.
This is miserable. Who wants to feel like this? Surly love is not worth the turmoil my poor intestines are suffering at the hands of extreme anxiety?
Ben cups a hand to his mouth and yells, “I’m not going to let you drown! Just come out here.”
“I’m not worried about drowning,” I mumble under my breath before charging forward into the ocean waves. At least the water is relatively warm.
Ben waits until I’ve waded in up to my chest before reaching for my arm to keep me from floating away. “We’ll start with the basics. The most important lesson about the ocean is knowing when to swim and when to float.”
I do give it my best effort.
“No,” Ben corrects with an amused smirk, “you’re fighting it again. Even you can’t fight the ocean. If you just relax, the salt in the water makes you buoyant, and you’ll float without even trying. Here, relax.”
All is well until he puts his hands on my shoulders and massages. I flinch away from him, immediately aware of the hot tingling between my legs. “Sorry, I wish I could relax,” I grumble. “Being able to relax would solve half my problems in this life.”
“What’s wrong?” he asks, but his voice is too slow for this to be happening in real time.
I turn to look at him and watch the sun rise and fall beyond the horizon in a manner of seconds. I watch the moon take its place, only to be pushed out of the sky by the sun, over and over and over until time loses all meaning and the ocean spits me out onto the sand.
My face slaps against ice, and when I grip the earth, it’s not sand at all. It’s snow.
Ben is gone. Endless night has fallen over the island, and the air is silent with flurries of snowflakes. A gurgling wolf snarls at me as I try to stand, but when I look up, I see only myself hunched in the moonlight, soaked in blood, both eyes nothing but hollow holes that stretch on into infinity.
I wake up screaming. All of my fingers go numb from a deathgrip on the knife Ben gave me, the blade unsheathed and ready to stab. As my eyes dart around my bedroom, I start to fully wake up and gulp air in a desperate attempt to calm down. Fenrir lifts his head in confusion, but I convince him it was nothing and to go back to sleep. Pumba remains dead to the world as he emits little oink-snores on his bed near the fireplace.
There’s no way I’m falling back to sleep tonight.
Strike a match, light a candle, grab a pen, flip to a fresh page, write: I understand now why Ben has insomnia. I would too if I saw that every time I closed my eyes. How can he even stand to look at me if that’s the last memory he has of my face? What if he thinks he likes me, but he’s actually just trauma bonded?
Thinking about Ben only sparks my earlier arousal, and I shift uncomfortably in my seat. Just to be safe, I write the next words entirely in Italian, just in case—God forbid—this notebook gets left somewhere and a child picks it up.
I want to do unspeakable things to Benjamin Linus. Things I can’t even write because to speak it into existence would make it real, and I don’t want to shame my grandmother.
Actually, who cares? This is my journal.
And then my pen flies wildly as I frantically write everything I want him to do to me, followed by everything I want to do to him—90% of which is most definitely not condoned by the Catholic Church. I lean back in my chair when I’m done, sweaty and quickly filling with a weird sense of guilt.
I continue in Italian: Is this creepy? Am I being a pervert? I feel like I’m being a pervert. I wish I didn’t know what will happen to me when I get pregnant. Does that make me selfish? Knowing about something I can’t avoid is torture. Why is this so difficult? People find each other attractive, and then they have sex. It’s not rocket science. People have been procreating since the dawn of time.
And then I hide my face in my hands because I’m pretty sure normal people don’t refer to it as procreating.
In English I write: I’m wasting time. There has to be something I left behind that could be helpful. Something beyond the useless notebook full of terrifying scribbles Jacob gave me. There’s no photos? No physical records of my working with the Dharma Initiative? And where the hell is Richard? It’s been over a month since he first disappeared! He’s the one who found my body. Maybe he saw something Ben didn’t? Maybe he’s the missing piece of the memory puzzle?
“Burning the midnight oil?”
“What?” I slam my notebook closed and turn in my seat to better see her. Since I no longer lock my bedroom, she’s cracked the door open and peaked inside, a lantern in hand. “Hi Gail,” I say, smiling. “I hope I didn’t wake you.”
“You did,” she admits good-naturedly, “but that doesn’t matter.”
“What do you mean?”
“Cora, taking care of you is my job.” Placing her lantern on my desk, Gail takes a seat across from me on the edge of my bed. “What was the dream about this time?”
I lie to her, just like I’ve been lying to her every night since I started dreaming about Ben. I know lying is a sin, but I’d rather burn for eternity in Christian Hell than admit to Gail that I can’t stop dreaming about spreading my legs and grinding against Ben’s hand like it’s the source of all life.
I’m still turned on from thinking about everything I just wrote down in my notebook, and it takes considerable energy not to resent Gail from being in here. I just want to be shamefully horny in peace. In my frustration, I blurt out, “I know this was all orchestrated. Ben and mine’s marriage.”
Gail doesn’t seem surprised that I know. “When did he tell you?”
“I figured it out myself, actually.”
Gail nods slowly, thinking about something with what looks like disgust. “When I first met him, that boy was spoiled, stubborn, and weak. In some ways, he still is. But at least now he can cook.”
I watch her face flicker in and out of view in the candlelight. “Why do you talk about him like that?” Gail frowns as if she has no idea what I mean. “He always does exactly what you say, and you still treat him horribly.”
“You think this was easy for me? You think it was easy to mold him into something worthy of you?”
“You’re still doing it. He’s not a thing, Gail. He’s a human.” Gails’s frowning at me, so I frown right back. “You should have treated him like a human. He was a child in mourning.”
“Benjamin is not the only one who has spent their life mourning you,” she hisses sharply, and I immediately fall silent as she stands and lords over me. “I held Christopher in my arms as he screamed with a pain only an orphan can scream. I held your grieving child in my arms while I kept my composure so I could better care for him. Don’t talk to me about mourning.” There’s more she wants to say. I can see it in her glistening eyes. Instead, she turns and heads for the door. When she reaches the handle, she stops. “Are you happy with him?”
I try to look at the situation through her eyes. Maybe she believes raising Ben was her life purpose, like how Ben genuinely believes marrying me is his life purpose? I don’t want her to think she’s wasted her life for nothing. And besides, my answer, for once, isn’t a lie. I nod in affirmation and say, “Very happy.”
Gail seems both surprised and relieved at this news as a smile pulls at her lips. “Good. You’re welcome,” she adds curtly and flees back into the night.
I’m not a midwife, but no amount of begging and pleading can stop the women of Hydra from dragging me to the hut where Claire is currently giving birth.
Annie is already there, doing her best to try and calm Claire down in-between her screams of raw agony. A young woman kneels beside Claire, one hand resting on her shoulder as she recites something in a low, soothing voice. It’s obvious Claire’s still in pain, but whatever the young woman is doing is at least calming her down enough to pay attention to Annie’s birthing instructions.
I stand in the doorway, unsure of how to be helpful. I’ve never seen a live birth before.
“Cora?” Claire questions as soon as she sees me.
I step forward, and the young woman beside Claire shrinks away and takes my place in the doorway. Claire’s hands are hot and sweaty when I take them in my own. “What do you need?”
“Make sure,” Claire pants, her face red and damp. “Can you make sure he’s healthy?”
I smile at the realization that she already knows it’s a boy. “That’s what I’m here for.”
Aaron’s labor is difficult, and it takes an hour or so before Annie is holding a wailing baby in her arms. She hands him to Claire, and it is as if we no longer exist. Mother and son seem to melt into one another.
Annie attends to Claire as the young woman in the doorway hurries outside to the eagerly awaiting crowd and announces it’s a boy. A combination of clapping and excited sentiments in both Norse and English echo in from outside.
The women of Hydra have spent the last few weeks making Claire and Aaron gifts that they happily present to her one at a time. Newborn clothes. Teething toys. A wrap meant to secure newborns to their mother’s chest. A new dress for Claire that’s especially breastfeeding friendly.
They dote on her hand and foot, crowding around to gently pull off her sweaty clothes, clean her with sweet smelling oils, brush her hair, feed her food and water, give unprompted advice and unwavering congratulations. Claire doesn’t seem to know what to do with all of the support and bursts into tears.
“It’s her first child,” Annie scolds. “Give her some peace. All of you, shoo.”
Just as well. I’m expecting Ben soon anyway.
As I start to head closer to the beach, I bump into—of all people—Aiko. Todd trots beside her, tapping his bushy fox tail against her left or right side to guide her around bends in the road or especially uneven pavement. When she finally reaches me, Todd steps in front of her and snorts loudly as the signal for her to stop walking. I lean down to her level and say hello.
Aiko makes sure to keep her hands to her sides, no doubt in fear of touching me and seeing more terrifying glimpses into the future. I watch as her eyes dart around and settle on where she thinks I am. “Thank you for saving mommy.”
It’s so nice to hear her sweet little voice again. “She saved me first,” I tell her solemnly. “I was just returning the favor. Your mom is the real hero.” Aiko sways a little, almost like she’s unsure what to do next. So I say the only thing I can think of to make her feel better. “Let’s not have you see my future anymore, okay?”
Aiko nods with noticeable relief, and then unexpectedly flings herself forward and wraps her arms around my shoulders, pressing her warm cheek against my own.
“You frightened my favorite human,” Todd snaps irritably as he starts to guide Aiko home. “Don’t do it again.”
“Lady Cora?”
Still smiling widely, I turn around to find the young woman who was helping Claire earlier. I’m not sure how old she is because we’re the exact same height—which isn’t saying much, as I’m only 4’8—and she looks too young to have had a growth spurt yet.
It’s as if she doesn’t know what to do with herself. She shyly fidgets her hands, deciding at last to straighten her spine and fold her hands behind her back. It seems to take all of her resolve to look me in the eyes. “Papa says I’m not allowed to call you grandma.”
She has Christopher’s hair—my mother’s hair. It’s thick and almost black, perfectly spiraling over her shoulders like the untamed mane of a Mediterranean goddess. Actually, she technically is a Mediterranean goddess.
“Freyja,” I say aloud, and I’m rewarded with the most beautiful smile I’ve ever seen. “I’m so happy to finally meet—” She cuts me off with a powerful hug for one so small. I awkwardly pat her back until she lets go of me.
Christopher mentioned she was shy, but even I’m unprepared for just how shy my granddaughter is. I smile and ask innocent questions to try and set her at ease, but even asking the easiest of questions—like her favorite color or animal—results in a brief burst of excitement that always leaves her quiet and embarrassed afterwards.
Am I this anxious? Is this what I look like to people?
Linking my arm through hers, I pat her hand and start walking towards the beach. “How old are you?”
“Twelve,” she answers quietly. “Lady Cora?”
“Just Cora,” I correct with as kind a smile as I can muster. “If there’s anyone on either of these islands who doesn’t need to call me lady, it’s you and Christopher.”
Freyja’s olive skin darkens with a blush. “Cora?”
“Yes?”
“May I ask a favor?”
“You can ask me anything.” As we round over the sloping ridge leading to my longhouse and the path down to the beach, Freyja slows to a halt, and I follow suit. “What’s wrong sweetheart?” She mumbles something down at her feet. “What was that? I can’t hear you.”
“Can you pick my husband for me?”
She can’t even look me in the eye and tell me her favorite color. Why is she asking about marriage? In a powerful rush that seems to come out of thin air, I fill with the motherly instinct to protect her. “Well, for starters, I think you’re a little too young for a husband.”
I mentally note to start carrying my axe everywhere so I can brandish it at the first fully grown man who proposes to her. I don’t even feel comfortable with her dating Ulf, who is at least sixteen. When you’re this young, every year matters. Four years is an eternity for a twelve year old.
“There are so many suitors,” she explains, darkening again with embarrassment. “I suppose I don’t need you to pick one. . . just narrow down the list? It’s a little overwhelming.”
I’m about to start giving an impassioned lecture about how creepy it is for men to already see her as a viable option for marriage, but a familiar voice distracts me. I only catch the tail end of their fight, but Alex and Hazel are in a shouting match further down the path.
“—can’t believe you actually want to date?”
“I don’t know,” Alex yells back at Hazel. “Maybe?”
“This. . . this ruins everything! Why didn’t you say something sooner?”
“I was going to say something, but then your da—” Alex catches herself, but it’s obvious what she was about to say.
“What?” Hazel snaps. “Because what? Because dad died? Oh, I am so sorry my father dying was such an inconvenience to you!”
“I didn’t say that,” Alex pleads, but Hazel has already stormed off.
I’m not sure if I’m supposed to pretend like I didn’t hear their fight. I decide there’s no point when she looks over and see’s me and Freyja. “Alex?” I ask. “You okay?” She tries to wave away my concern, but I can see the raw sadness in her eyes. Still linked arm in arm with Freyja, I link my free arm through Alex’s. “Come on, let’s all go sit on the beach. I’m expecting your father any minute now.”
Alex’s mournful expression twists up into confusion. “Dad’s here?”
“Not yet, but I’ve requested some precious cargo from the mainland and need to be there for the dropoff.”
When we finally reach the beach, I wait for Alex to tell me what’s wrong, but she never says anything.
“Alex? I just want you to know that I’ll support you no matter what. And I know your father will, too. He loves you very much.” Alex looks confused, so I continue. “If you want to date Hazel, you have my blessing.”
Alex’s already confused expression twists into even more confusion. “Why would I want to date Hazel?”
“Is that not what you were fighting about?”
Alex is about to tell me exactly what they were fighting about, but she changes her mind at the last minute. I sigh, surprised to find just how much it hurts my feelings that she doesn’t feel comfortable sharing with me.
All three of us sit in an awkward silence on the beach, watching the ocean slosh against the shore.
A boat approaches in the distance, and I’m happy for the silence to finally end. “Oh, there he is! Wait.” I release both of their arms and hold a hand up to shade my eyes. As the boat gets closer, I yell, “What are you boys doing here?”
Ulf, Andor, Rune, and Karl wave at me as they finish paddling to shore, hop out, and begin stacking firewood. “Finn’s about to become an older brother,” Ulf answers. “We’re here to help celebrate with a surprise party.” Ulf suddenly notices Freyja hiding behind me. Poor thing is so shocked to see her that he pretends like he hasn’t seen her, spins in a nervous semi-circle, shifting aimlessly, opting at last to wander back over to where the boys are feeding a small flame.
Ben approaches, guiding the precious cargo over to where I’m standing. The aforementioned precious cargo is bound, gagged, and obviously pissed off. All of his character development is messed up because he hasn’t had a reason to bond with anyone yet. I can’t help but smirk at him. Sawyer has absolutely no idea what I have in store to speed up his good-guy arc.
Ben eyes Sawyer wearily before turning to face me. “Should I even bother confirming you think this is a good idea?”
“Trust me,” I say with noticeable relief. “I know how this looks. But this is the first decision I’ve felt completely confident in since I got here.”
Sawyer hums unintelligibly through the thick fabric tied around his mouth. At my request, Ben removes the gag so I can hear what he has to say.
"So,” he says, looking around with an impressed expression, “where are all the ladies, anyway?”
“You can gag him again,” I tell Ben just as Peregrine runs up beside me in the sand.
“Who is this? Oh, oh!” Peregrine bounces with excitement. “You’re the one who fought Magnus and almost won! Join my crew! Please?”
Sawyer hums his response, and against my better judgement, I ask Ben to remove the gag again. “Piss off, Short Round,” Sawyer snaps.
I’m not expecting it, so there’s no time to tell her to stop. Peregrine rears back an arm and then punches Sawyer hard in the groin.
“Peregrine!” It takes all my willpower not to laugh at the sight of Sawyer taken down by such a small child. Ben, however, has absolutely no qualms with huffing a low chuckle as Sawyer falls to his knees, wheezing and coughing in pain. “Why would you do that?”
As per usual, Peregrine looks up at me with an air of innocence. “Mom says I’m allowed to punch men in the dick if they harass me.”
I’m shocked at her language, and I have to force myself to close my gaping mouth. “But. . . he didn’t harass you.”
“He won’t join my crew!”
“Peregrine,” I sigh. “That’s not harassment. Harassment would be if someone was saying creepy things or trying to touch you.”
“Oh, okay.” Without even acknowledging Sawyer writhing around in pain, she takes off back up the hill.
“Stop,” I call, curving a finger in a direct order. I wait for her to hurry back over to me before I command, “Empty your pockets.”
“What?”
“Don’t what me.” A muffled cry for help gets louder the closer she walks. I hold out a hand, palm up. “Empty your pockets.”
“I don’t have anything in my pockets.”
“Don’t lie to me. I can hear him.”
It takes a minute or so before Peregrine stops arguing, reaches into her pocket, and pulls out an angry treefrog. “FREE,” the frog screams in a flurry of croaks. “FREE AT LAST! UNHAND ME, GIANT FIEND!” With a crazed gusto, the frog attempts to bite her fingers, but he has no teeth and accomplishes nothing.
“I’m not hurting him,” Peregrine argues. “He’s just easier to carry in my pocket.”
“Well,” I counter, “he doesn’t like being in your pocket. Hand him over.”
“Why can I understand you, giant? Can it be? Oh, heavens! What luck! I’ve found a lady frog at last!” The little tree frog springs through the air and lands on my face. “Pleasure to make your acquaintance. Would you be interested in bearing my children?”
“Uhhh?”
The tree frog climbs all over my face with his gooey little suction-cup hands. “What is your name, oh great and glorious queen of the frogs?”
“Cora,” I say. “And I'm sorry to disappoint, but I’m not a frog. I'm a human.”
“I’m not picky!”
“Did I mention I’m already married?”
“Oh, cruel fate! After such a long search. . . cursed fate!” He leaps from my face to my shoulder and croaks, “You say you are human? I wish I were human like you.”
“What’s your name?” I listen for his answer, but his name is an unintelligible sound only a frog can make. “Hm. Would you mind if I called you by a nickname?”
Freyja lights up with excitement and eyes the frog with a childish gleam. “Are we naming that frog? Oh, can I hold him? I love frogs!” Just then, the frog takes a leap of faith and miraculously sticks to Freyja’s face. She gives a squeal of delight and tenses up. “He's cold,” she exclaims, giggling.
I’d have thought the innocent sound of my granddaughter giggling would bring me unbridled joy, but it just makes me selfishly sad. I don’t think I’ve ever giggled once in my entire life.
“Such soft skin!” He proclaims with glee, climbing up the side of her cheek. “It is a treat for my froggy feet. Are you single, by any chance?”
It takes all my willpower not to roll my eyes. “He likes you, Freyja.”
Freyja gently plucks the frog off her face and cradles him in her little cupped hands. “Look at him,” she coos. “He's so cute!”
“Cora,” he croaks, “what is this sweet angel saying? I cannot understand her!”
“She says you're cute,” I tell him and instantly wish I had lied.
“Words of love? I accept!” He springs back onto Freyja’s cheek. “You shall be my human. Keeper of the perfect skin, I shall stay by your side till my dying day! I hereby forsake my search for a lady frog, for I do not need one!”
I sigh, realizing that I’m the only one who understands his little speech. “I’m thinking Frogger,” I offer. “Any other ideas?”
Ben hums in thought. “A little violent, don’t you think?”
“How about Kermit,” says Alex.
“Chrysanthemum!” Freyja looks between me, Ben, and Alex and then deflates and says, “Or Kermit. I like that one, too.”
Night falls, and the boys keep the fire pit blazing as they dance and play a variety of instruments to celebrate the safe arrival of Finn’s first sibling.
“You have to see her,” Finn yells to anyone who will listen. “She’s no bigger than a loaf of bread, but much cuter than a loaf of bread!”
I sit on a blanket next to Ben—Sawyer is seated in the sand nearby, still tied up—since it’s our responsibility to chaperone the party. But my initial worries about a co-ed party is almost immediately squashed. Turns out the Bears have known Alex for years and treat her like a little sister. It takes the group quite a few tries to pry little Freyja from her grip on my arm. Alex finally convinces her to give me Kermit, and the two girls end up spinning around the fire in time to the music, lost in a cloud of delighted laughter as they shout the lyrics to a song I can’t understand.
I pull out my notebook. “What can you tell me about Ulf?”
“Ulf?” Ben raises his brows in contemplation, turning to look at the giant of a teenager playing drums near the fire. “Well, he’s team captain for a reason. Strong and contemplative, although surprisingly shy. Why?”
“He has a crush on Freyja, and she’s asked me to dwindle down her prospective suitors. I’ve already crossed off anyone over the age of eighteen, but I’m still uncomfortable with—” I look up from my notebook and motion to Ulf with my pen. “—their age difference.”
Ben looks confused. “Of a year?”
“What?”
“Isn’t Freyja 12? Ulf just turned 13.”
“Ulf is not 13,” I counter with no shortage of annoyance.
“You clearly haven’t met his mother yet,” says Ben, chuckling lowly. “She’s even taller than Kyle.”
“Wait,” I say, pausing to look up from my notebook again. “You’re serious? He’s 13? Well, in that case.” I start scribbling notes in the matchmaking section.
“Here, Cora.” I look over at what Ben’s offering me. “I saved you the best of the batch.”
Keep your cool. Only take one. And only take one bite, don’t shove the whole thing in your mouth—oh, Jesus, Mary, and Joseph, this takes like magic. I close my eyes as I chew. “You make chocolate?”
“Only to celebrate births,” Ben answers, smiling. “I made Finn’s mother a batch, and I added a peanut butter center for Claire’s.”
His thoughtfulness brings a rush in my chest that makes me blush. “Thank you. That’s. . . thank you.” I take another bite and stifle a groan. “It’s like you pumped these full of drugs.” I gasp loudly and bring a hand up to my mouth.
“What?” Ben’s immediately on edge. “I didn’t actually add drugs, if that’s what you’re about to accuse me of.”
“No, just. . . don’t be mad.” I lean in close so Sawyer can’t hear and whisper, “Charlie’s a heroin addict.”
Ben doesn’t frown, which worries me. “Why are you just now telling me this?”
“I forgot.”
“You forgot that there’s a heroin addict living freely in the community where I keep my daughter?”
Ben stands, but I’ve grabbed hold of his arm before I can stop myself. “Where are you going?”
“Home,” he answers. “To deal with said drug addict. If he’s not shown any noticeable signs of withdrawal, that must mean he’s been stealing medicine from the infirmary.”
“You don’t have to leave Hydra. You can just send word to Ethan from the aviary.” It takes no effort at all to loop a finger through his belt, and I accidentally yank him forcefully back down onto the blanket. Now that my powers are fully manifesting, I need to be more careful so I don’t hurt people. “Sorry,” I apologize at his startled expression, “but I am not chaperoning these kids on my own.”
Sawyer has been silent for so long, I feel bad and pull down the fabric across his mouth when he starts humming something. “Can one of you please shut that frog up?” Sawyer complains from his seat in the sand. “He’s giving me a migraine!”
“Freyja!” Kermit bellows from inside Ben’s shirt pocket. “Where is my Freyja?”
I poke a finger in Ben’s pocket, and the frog climbs out. “Kermit,” I tell him, “I just told you a few minutes ago. She not gone, she’s just too close to the fire. You don’t want to dry up, right? You’re safer in this pocket until she’s done.”
“Ah, yes. Sorry.”
“Cora? Cora?” Hazel rushes down the hill, pulling a small child alongside her. I notice she’s cradling something in her free hand and is speaking so quickly I cannot understand her. In her panic, she stops trying to explain and opens her hand to show me what she’s holding.
At first I’m worried that she’s hurt herself. Blood drips from her fingers and pools in her palm. It takes my brain a moment to realize it’s not her blood. It takes me a moment to realize she’s holding the severed thumb of the crying child next to her.
I’m pretty sure this is what it feels like to be a doctor. I move entirely on instinct, snatching up the child and thumb and yelling for Ben to follow me. We’re going to need something sterile to wash the dirt off and much better lighting than the fire-pit on the beach can provide.
“Boys,” Ben shouts in a no-nonsense bark. “I need you to watch the prisoner until I return. Can I trust you to do that?”
“Aye-aye,” Finn yells gleefully, saluting us, and the rest of the boys follow suit.
I don’t know where Gail is, but there’s no time to go looking for her or Annie.
There’s so much blood. I wash it off with water, but it’s difficult to even keep a grip on the thumb, let alone align it correctly and keep it steady. Ben is able to do it in one try, but to be fair, he’s completely desensitized to this sort of thing and doesn’t shake with nerves like I do.
I’m not even sure this will work. I can’t grow body parts, but can I re-attach them? I hold tightly to Sigurd’s hand and wait for the pain to flow from his toddler’s thumb to my fully grown one. To everyone’s shock, including my own, it works.
Sigurd stops crying and bends his newly attached thumb. “Thanks, lady Cora!” I’m so deep in shock I can’t even stop him from scampering off before I have the chance to lecture him about the dangers of playing with sharp objects.
“I’ll make sure he gets home safe,” says Hazel, and then Ben and I are alone again in my bedroom.
Only a very faint wick-pop of the many candles lighting up my desk make any sound in the silence that follows Sigurd’s departure. I’m seated on the floor and Ben’s seated right next to me at my desk chair, since he was the one who needed the most light to ensure the thumb was perfectly realigned. Sitting at this angle, with my face so close to his lap, I feel embarrassed for being so unbelievably horny right now.
Does everyone feel like this all the time? Or is this agony exemplified by the fact that I’m supposedly the goddess of love?
Since his attention, for once, isn't on me, I take this opportunity to study him up close. His face is sharper than I remember it being in the show. In fact, his whole body is thinner than I remember it being. His ears stick out from under his neatly combed black hair. His shirt—the same color as his eyes—is a deep blue button-down tucked into pristinely ironed kaki slacks. His usual pair of dress shoes have been replaced with boots, and I silently wonder who made them for him. Attention to detail, even in his clothing. I should have expected nothing less.
“Cora,” Ben asks, his voice low and melodious.“Are you alright?”
“Uh, no?” I look up at him with a bewildered frown and finish wiping off my bloody fingers on my dress. “I’m happy to find out I can do it, but I wasn’t expecting to have to reattach a child’s severed finger tonight. And the fact that you don’t seem fazed makes me worried this is a common occurrence.” At this, he smiles one of his rarest smiles, the ones that relax his eyebrows and crinkle the ends of his eyes.
I need to get far away from Ben or we’re all traveling back to the 70’s tonight.
“Ow,” I hiss as a sharp pain boils under the skin of my right thumb. “Oh, great. I forgot about the aftermath.” I put pressure on it to ensure it doesn’t detach itself. When I healed Liv, my body absorbed her wounds. I literally had the bullet trajectory inside my body. Does that mean my thumb is going to fall off? “Ben? Could you do me a huge favor and wrap my hand? I don’t want to lose my thumb.”
I don’t know what’s going on when he untucks his shirt, but it makes my mouth salivate. He’s quick to pull out a pocketknife and cut a strip of fabric from the newly freed material. “I’ve wrapped more than my fair share of broken hands,” he tells me as he works in record speed to loop the long strip of fabric over and around my fingers, tying off the end around my wrist.
Standing up, I turn to head for the door, and then suddenly I’m blinking awake into the blue eyes of a very distressed Ben kneeling beside me, saying something I can’t hear. He sounds far away and underwater. “Cora?” His voice echoes softly, and then rushes back into focus. “Cora? Can you hear me?”
“Sorry.” I groan in pain as I come back into consciousness. “Not good with blood, and I stood up too fast.”
With one hand Ben pushes me back up into a sitting position, and with the other hand he cups my face and gently guides me to look at him so he can check my head for injuries. Having Ben’s face in such close proximity, all of the lust I was previously feeling comes rushing back with a vengeance, and I’m powerless to stop myself from closing the distance between our mouths.
I’m the first to pull away, but that’s only because I need to breathe. Neither of us moves, our eyes locked, our noses brushing lightly together as we both hesitate to lean back in the rest of the way. Something about huffing each other’s air makes me more turned on than anything I’ve ever experienced in my entire life.
But instead of closing the gap for another kiss, Ben exhales heavily against my lips. “We have to go back and chaperone.”
“Yes,” I whisper, mortified. “Yes, sorry. I shouldn’t have done that. I’m sorry.”
“Don't be.” Ben has to suppress a smile as he helps me stand. “I’m not.”
We don’t say anything else to each other as we return to the beach.
You could probably dedicate an entire room of arts and crafts with the amount of paper I waste trying to pen the perfect letter to Ben. Everything I write sounds cheesy or desperate or doesn’t actually make any sense.
I settle for: I’m sorry this is so random, but I’ve always wanted to start a bad poetry club. Don’t feel pressured to join, but if you do send anything, it needs to be truly awful. Please find my first Haiku below:
I just milked a cow
and stopped a Pokemon fight.
World peace is boring.
Nothing comes for almost two days.
Every neuron in my body starts firing off endorphins the second I hear Loki swoop into the longhouse cawing, “Letter for Cora!”
I stare at the small pile in my lap, wide eyed and giddy at the fact that Ben wrote a whole bunch of horrible hilarious poetry, my favorite being the haiku:
Garden filled with bees,
or bee zoo enclosed by brush?
Perspective is key.
“What’s got you in such a good mood?”
I stop laughing and almost crumple the letter to hide it, but I thankfully stop myself from seeming incredibly suspicious. “Nothing,” I tell Pris. “Just more fanmail from the mainland.”
A few days later, I get one long letter instead of smaller scraps of poetry.
I only make it two lines in before hastily folding it in half and trying my best to inconspicuously glance around to ensure nobody is close enough to read over my shoulder. Coast is clear. Painfully aware of the fact my face is red hot, I make my way to my room and double-check Gail and Pris are off doing their daily duties. Then, and only then, do I unfold and begin to read in giddy earnest.
Ben’s written me a traditional love letter.
One full page of carefully worded sentiments that make my chest swell. Without ever saying the phrase, “I love you” the letter conveys as much. It only makes me more euphoric to think that someone actually misses me. His words are smart but earnest, and kind, and very very flattering. I finish reading and immediately start over.
I understand it now. Those obnoxious scenes in movies where grown women get some sort of romantic news and suddenly devolve into a squealing teenager incapable of sitting still. I can’t stop kicking my heels into the mattress as I hold the letter tight to my chest. A flood of euphoria rushes up my chest and into my head until I feel the same high I had at the wedding.
I read the letter again.
Gail unbraids my hair and brushes it out in preparation for my nightly shower. When I return from the locker room and enter the longhouse, a rush floods me with excitement at the sight of the bird flying overhead. Loki means letters from Ben.
But instead of landing on my shoulder, Loki announces, “Letter for Gail!” and flies over to her.
I’m surprised by the intensity of my disappointment as the excitement of getting another letter from Ben slowly starts to dissipate.
Gail unrolls the letter, huffs loudly into the night air, and tosses it on the table.
“What happened?” I ask, expecting her to dish out some newfound—but altogether unimportant—mainland drama.
“Oh, it’s just Ethan.” There’s no sense of urgency in her voice when she looks over and says, “Ben’s been injured. It seems he’s gone and shattered his spine.”
Notes:
Hello all you beautiful people! HUZZAH! I’ve written the final chapter to this story! (Hence the title change) Also, sorry for the upload delay. Due to some extreme family health emergencies, I’m stressed and unmotivated... but I want to make it crystal clear that I’m not abandoning this story!
As a side note, for anyone who isn't reading this for the smut, just be forewarned that the next chapter onward will contain an increasing amount of spicy scenes. I just don't want anyone getting jumpscared lol
Chapter 21: Completely (In)Appropriate Bedside Manner
Notes:
(See the end of the chapter for notes.)
Chapter Text
Darting my eyes over to where Jack’s preparing for surgery, I see he’s sufficiently preoccupied, so I lean down close to Ben and lower my voice to barely a whisper. “You know. . . there are easier ways to get my attention.”
“Ha. Ha. Ha,” he wheezes, wincing at the effort it takes to talk. “I specifically asked for you not to be here.”
“But I live here,” I joke, trying to put him at ease. I can’t imagine how he must be feeling, having been shipped all the way to Hydra less than an hour after his injury. “You’re technically trespassing on my island, but I’ll allow it because we have a better surgery station.”
Ben lies limp on the operating table, his usually expressive eyes now dulled with exhaustion. “Why are you torturing me?”
“Torturing you?” Why wouldn’t he want me here? The plan is to have Jack put his spinal column back together, and then I heal him. “Pretty sure healing is the antithesis to torture.”
“Cora,” Ben begins, but he has to pause to catch his breath. It’s a struggle for him just to breathe, so I kneel down until our faces are level so he doesn’t have to raise his voice. “People have been—” Wheeze. “—healing with abnormal haste—” Wheeze. “—since you’ve returned.”
Is he unaware I already know this? I saw Erik walking around the Temple unassisted only two weeks after I shattered all the bones in his arm and legs. And right before young Peter and little Darcy were cleared to leave on the sub, Peter’s ankle had healed without any signs it had been broken in the first place. Gail told me that people tend to heal quicker on the island than off the island, but now that I’m here, my proximity seems to have significantly sped up the process.
“You’re asking me not to directly heal you. I’m still indirectly healing you, so either way, you—”
“Please, be serious—” Wheeze. “I am asking you not to heal me.”
There’s a glimmer of sadness in his eyes that wipes the disingenuous smirk off my face. This means something to him. I don’t know why—pride, perhaps?—but healing on his own is more important to him than he has breath to fully describe right now.
“Hey,” I whisper. “Okay. I won’t. I promise.”
“You’re just going to—”
“No, I’m not just going to wait until they put you under anesthesia and then do it anyway.” I reach up and gently hook my pinky in his. “I swear on my grandmother’s soul.”
At this, he lets out a breathy sigh and closes his eyes. “Am I going to die?”
“You got trampled by an angry rhinoceros.” Despite my attempts to be serious, I’m bursting with nervous adrenaline and cannot help but snort a laugh at the ridiculousness of this situation. “I’m surprised you're not already dead.”
“Am I—” Ben pauses, but I can’t tell if it’s because he’s more tired or terrified. “Am I going to walk again?”
You haven’t taught me how to swim yet, and that’s apparently a canon event. . . so, yes. “You’re going to be fine. I don’t know how long it will take, but yes. You’ll walk again.”
“Can you call—” Wheeze. “Alex in?”
“That’s really not a good idea.” My eyes flit up to the glass observatory overlooking this operating room. Alex is leaning against the glass, sobbing uncontrollably, surrounded by Annie’s daughters who mouth comforting words I cannot hear. “She’s completely inconsolable at the moment.” Ben tries to protest, but I cut him off with a steady, “Whatever it is you need to tell Alex, you can tell her after the surgery. You’re not going to die. Goddess of foresight, remember?”
“Cora,” Jack calls from down the hallway with all of Ben’s x-rays fixed to the walls. “Are you ready?”
At the questioning look in Ben’s eyes, I promise, “I’m just hanging around in case anything actually life threatening happens. I promised Alex I wouldn’t let you die, and in my defense, I make that promise to her before I made my promise to you.”
“I don’t know why I bother.” Ben sits idly by in a wheelchair as Alex helps carry my bags into her room. “When I said your proximity speeds up healing, I wasn’t suggesting you move in.”
“You should have thought of that as part of our agreement before the surgery. Oops,” I mock and follow Alex down the hall.
“This is awesome!” Alex is so excited she’s practically bouncing like a kangaroo. “Infinite sleepover!”
I finish unpacking and listen as Alex excitedly rambles on and on about all the things she wants to do together while I’m living here, even though we’ve technically been living next to each other on Hydra this whole time. Smiling and nodding along with everything she says, I realize rather quickly that I’m actually excited to have a sleepover. As pathetic as it may sound, this is my chance to experience the sleepover I never had as a kid, and I eagerly add to her list of planned activities.
Alex quickly looks at the door to make sure Ben hasn’t wheeled himself down the hallway. She ends up lowering her voice anyway, even though the coast is clear. “Has Indiana’s mother come to talk to you yet?”
I let out an exaggerated gust of air. “Yeah. What a mess.” Alex’s eyes widen in anticipation, so I give her the gist of the conversation. “She basically offered herself as a human sacrifice. I asked her if it made any sense to kill the primary caregiver to the child my husband almost died protecting.” Alex laughs at my annoyed expression. “Everyone wants to be a human sacrifice these days.”
“I’m just glad everyone’s alive,” Alex agrees. “It sucks dad got the brunt of a rhino horn, but at least Indiana didn’t get trampled. You ever figure out what happened? I didn’t see it, but I heard Zeus just went nuts.”
“Zeus isn’t speaking to me or anyone else right now. Best to let him settle down for a few more days. So. . .” I begin looking around the room, spotting the shoebox Noodles and Jellybean are napping in, until my eyes settle on a Slipknot poster. “Do your friends know you’re hiding *NSYNC and Backstreet Boys cds under your floorboards, or am I part of the lucky few?” I watch about a dozen shades of confusion flash across Alex’s face before I say, “I have x-ray eyes.”
“You didn’t tell them, right?” Alex leans forward, looking distressed. “You can’t say anything!”
“Whoa, whoa, I haven’t told a soul.” I expected the both of us to have a great laugh about hiding her love of bubblegum pop and boy bands from her “hardcore” friends. I didn’t expect her to look on the verge of tears at the thought of them knowing. I make myself comfortable on the edge of her bed and nod for her to continue. “There’s a story here. Start talking.”
“It’s silly.” Alex looks over longingly at one of the posters on her wall, and I sense there’s a lot more to this than I originally thought. “So it kinda started back when I was ten. Tom gave me a video he burned of this really great show called Friends—”
“Oh my God, I love Friends!” I do not love Friends.
Alex’s anxious worry seems to settle a little. “Yeah,” she says, smiling, “me too.”
“So Tom gives you a video of the show, and then—?”
“And it. . . I don’t know. It kinda became Hazel’s obsession to move to New York City. Like, she was obsessed obsessed. When she visited me, she’d spend the entire time planning where we would live and what we would do for jobs. At first it was kinda fun to imagine, but. . .” Alex pauses, thinking. “I guess I grew out of the fantasy, and she didn’t.”
I nod. “And then her father died, and you didn’t feel comfortable bringing it up?”
“Exactly,” Alex says in emphasis. “And her opinions cover everything Norse. Annie sews Hazel a dress, so we exclusively wear jeans. Annie wants her to have long hair, so we cut ours short.”
Remembering about my initial negative reaction to the shaved side of her head, I interrupt with an excited, “But yours looks so good!”
“Thanks.” Alex’s eyes soften a little, but it’s obvious no amount of compliments can stop her long list of complaints. “The only music we’re allowed to listen to is loud and angry. I’m so tired of rebelling. Like. . . I understand I made a pact with her when we were kids, but we were kids. And it feels like everything has stayed the same for Hazel, but everything’s changing for me. For example,” Alex says, throwing up a hand, “dating. Maybe I do want to date. I don’t know! But to completely shut down the conversation because she wants to stay single forever isn’t fair.”
Do not make a weird face. Am I squinting? Ease up. There. Definitely a normal expression. “Who? Who do you want to date?” In an attempt to sound less suspicious, I dramatically toss my notebook over my shoulder and say, “Completely off the record, of course.”
Alex laughs, but not in a nervous way. “I mean. . . I don’t have anyone in mind, it’s just the fact that it’s against Hazel’s rules. There were so many times I should have said something, and now it’s gotten completely out of control.”
“What do you mean?”
Alex checks to make sure her father isn’t in the doorway before whispering, “Hazel’s trying to figure out a way off the island. She hates it here and doesn’t want to get married or have children, so she’s. . .” She pauses again, checks the doorway, and then lowers her voice even more. “You have to swear you won’t tell anyone. Please, Cora. You have to swear.”
I feel my clammy hands start to sweat even more. “I swear.” God, I hope this secret isn’t something I’ll have to tell Annie about for Hazel’s own safety.
Alex searches my eyes for a moment longer. Satisfied, she explains, “Hazel stole a seiðr manual from the archives and is trying to figure out how to use it to leave the island.”
“Seiðr?” Every muscle in my face fights the urge to twitch with relieved laughter. “Magic? You’re talking about magic?”
Alex nods, wide eyed.
“Alex, magic isn’t real.”
Instead of looking mad, Alex just looks confused. “Of course it’s real.”
I can tell I’m treading on dangerous territory here, so I try to be as gentle as possible. “How long has she had the book?”
“Two years.”
“And in those two years, have any of you successfully casted a spell?” Alex shakes her head no. “Ever wonder why that is?”
Alex shrugs. “We’re probably doing the spell wrong.”
“Why is this such a carefully guarded secret?”
I watch as Alex chews her bottom lip in thought, finally answering, “Seiðr is illegal.”
“Illegal?” I sit up straight at this news. “Why?”
“All I know is Gail burned all the spell books in the archives. Except for the one Hazel found, obviously.”
I make a mental note to ask Gail about it in a way that won’t incriminate the girls. For now, I decide to leave it alone, rather than risk pissing off Alex and losing a valuable source of intel. Instead, I turn the conversation towards regular island shenanigans.
Alex is in the middle of telling me a funny story about the last time one of Freya’s cats stole Annie’s favorite wool socks when a deep rumble of men’s laughter echoes down the hallway. Alex and I sit up straight, our heads swiveling towards her door in unison as the laughter builds up again.
Unable to mind my own business, I head down the hall and into the expanse between the kitchen and the living room. A group of rowdy men sit all across the living room sofa, some standing near Ben’s desk, and one of them sitting cross-legged on top of the kitchen table.
Table?
“Your table,” I say aloud, and all of the men turn to look at me. Smiling widely, I say the first thing that comes to mind. “I don’t remember your table being so beautiful. Look at these carvings!”
“Yeah,” Alex answers, walking up behind me, “didn’t you hear? I guess our old one got infested with termites and just kinda. . . fell apart. Rune’s family made us a new one.”
“If this one doesn’t break it under the weight of his giant ego,” Ben quips, pointing at the man sitting cross-legged on top of the table.
The men give me a cheerful hello, but they give an even more enthusiastic hello to Alex, who quickly makes her way around the room to greet each of them. I can already tell who they are before Ben officially introduces me to the father’s of every player on team Bear.
I’ve already met Kyle. I’ve also met Andor’s dad, Eomir, who waves at me from the couch. Finn’s father is the man sitting cross-legged on the table, but he jumps off and hurries over to kiss my hand. It’s so interesting to see them all together because they act just like their sons. I can tell which boy belongs to who, especially Karl’s dad, who looks like a wall street accountant playing dress up. He doesn’t even have a beard.
I regret coming out here almost immediately after I’m introduced to them all. There’s no true silence because the men are always finding something to laugh about, but there’s enough of a silence for me to feel responsible for filling it.
What do I do now? I decide to tell a joke. “Hey, guys! Wanna hear a joke?”
“Is it about the size of my hands?”
“No, it’s about a bee. He’s at a work event and searching for—”
“Eomir’s allergic to bees! Remember that time you almost died?”
“Because you pushed me into that hive, asshole!”
Kyle throws his head back and rumbles with laughter, and I am once again forgotten. Which is all well and good, as far as I’m concerned. I wait for the men to turn their attention back on each other, and then I slip back down the hall before they can stop me.
As the men continue to joke around loudly, Alex and I hole up in her room, blasting CDs in her portable player. Hidden out of sight, she has a collection of classics including Spice Girls, Britney Spears, *NSYNC, Backstreet Boys, and Hanson. We sing off key, paint our nails, and gossip about who would make a good husband for her.
“Aw, man,” Alex holds up her glass and clinks the ice around the empty space. “I’m all out of lemonade.”
“Stay put,” I offer and hop up off the floor. “I’ll get it.”
I find Ben seated near his desk, staring off into space. I clear my throat and ask, “Are they gone?”
“Well,” he starts, sounding genuinely put out, “as far as I know, they’re not all crammed inside the only bathroom in the house, so my intuition says yes.”
I can hear the 90s pop music echoing from down the hallway and wonder if the Bears held their own private dance battle after I left. “Need anything?”
“Would it matter if I did?”
“That is the entire reason I’m here.” I fight the urge to frown. “Why are you being such an asshole?”
“I’m just. . .” Ben rolls his eyes up at the ceiling before looking back at me. “. . . frustrated. With this chair.”
“This would all be solved if you’d just let me heal you.” I raise both my hands at the look on his face. “Okay. Okay. I won’t heal you. But you can’t have your cake and eat it too. Either let me heal you, or stop being an asshole.”
Instead of apologizing, he asks, “Did the bee find what he was looking for?”
“What?”
“You never finished the joke about the bee.” Ben is physically more than a few feet away, but his eyes close the distance between us with the laser focus of a bird. “What’s the punchline?”
I’m anxious, not amused, but you’d never know it by the sound of my laughter. “You were listening to that?”
“Of course I was listening. You were speaking.”
I stare at him for an uncomfortable amount of time before I admit to myself that I have absolutely no idea what to say in response. He’s obviously flirting with me, right? What do I say? What am I supposed to say?! “The punchline is there is no punch line,” I announce, defeated. “See? I’ve already ruined the joke.”
“Tell it from the beginning.”
“Ok.” I sigh. “There’s this worker bee who goes to a networking event in the hive. He’s flying around, chatting with coworkers and meeting bees from other departments. Anyway, he eventually realizes that the hive has provided refreshments for the event, so he heads to the nearest line. He waits his turn, finally gets to the front of the line, and finds out it was the line to get a plate of food. He eats the food and gets in the next line, which turns out to have dessert. At this point, he’s parched, so he’s flying around, desperately looking for the punch line and realizes there isn’t one.”
Ben snorts.
“Thank you for the pity laugh.”
Ben shifts slightly in his chair to face the hallway, his eyes narrowing and his brows knitting in confusion at the sound of Vanilla Ice’s beloved one hit wonder. “I hope Alex’s room is sufficient for the time being. Feel free to take the sofa if you get tired of sleeping on the floor.”
“Appreciate the thought, but she’s sleeping on the floor next to me in sleepover solidarity.”
“Ah,” he simply states, and I have to turn away and head towards the fridge because the alternative is to stand here forever bleeding the conversation dry in an attempt to listen to anything and everything he has to say.
I’m in the middle of refilling our lemonade when an unrhythmic pounding at the door almost startles the cup out of my hand. Ben looks just as confused as I do when I ask, “Are you expecting more guests?”
Finn is the last person I expected to find when I open the front door.
It looks like he’s barely keeping it together. “My mom told me the worst she could say was NOOOOOO.” At the final word, Finn’s expression crumples and he begins to wail uncontrollably.
Turns out the worst thing a woman can say isn’t no. The worst thing a woman can say is nothing at all.
Finn sobs his way through an explanation of what happened while curled up in a ball on my lap, or at least what he can fit. It’s like trying to cradle a human-sized spider.
It seems Finn finally decided to shoot his shot with Hazel, and it went spectacularly. And by spectacularly, I mean spectacularly awful. Rejection in this culture is a woman remaining completely silent when you hit on her. From the sound of it, it looks like Hazel was so disinterested, her eyes gleamed with the glossiness of a dead fish.
From her spot near the couch, Alex mumbles, “I could have told you that.”
“You knew?” Finn slowly rises from my lap, puffy eyed and obviously shocked. “You knew she hated me and you never said anything?” For a bizarre second, it looks like he’s going to strike her, but his hand simply rests against the side of her head and brushes against the smooth skin. “When did you shave your head?” Finn asks between sobs. “It looks really good.”
Alex looks both confused and exhausted. “Thanks.”
Finn dramatically flops back into my lap and continues wailing. I have never wanted to laugh so hard in my entire life. I've never seen a man cry like this before, and I don't know what to do. No amount of pep talks or comforting seems to ease his panic that he "will never know true happiness." I give Alex a pained look, and she decides to step in.
“Come on, Finn.” I can tell Alex is giving it everything she’s got. “It’s not you! Hazel doesn’t like you because Hazel doesn’t like anyone. Trust me,” Alex adds with exceptional dryness, “she won’t shut up about it.”
“Hazel's your best friend. You can help me,” he surmises, seemingly coming back to life at the idea. “Yes, you can help coach me. Help me win her back!”
“No, Finn, you’re not listening—” But it’s clearly no use because Finn won’t stop coming up with ideas until Alex finally cracks. “Fine! Okay! I’ll help you! Just. . . go home.”
Finn sniffles one final time before wiping his face dry and announcing, “Sorry for the dramatics, everyone. I’ll leave you to it.”
As soon as the door closes behind him, Alex whirls on me. “Cora, please tell him this isn’t going to work. He wouldn’t listen to me!” A raven swoops in through an open window and glides over to Alex’s shoulder.
“Wow,” I say, “that was fast.”
“It’s not from Finn.” I watch as her expression turns to wide-eyed shock. “Charlotte’s engaged—”
“Finally,” I huff loudly.
“—to a man,” Alex finishes.
“Who the hell is Gunner?” I ask, tossing the letter in Jane’s general direction.
Her eyes dart all over the scrap of paper, but she gives none of her true emotions away when she says, “Good for her.”
“I’m sorry. . . did I have a stroke, or did you just say good for her?”
“Yes,” Jane says, doubling down, “good for her. Took her long enough.”
What kind of bullshit is going on here? “You’re okay with her marrying someone else?”
“Of course I’m okay,” Jane snaps. “Why wouldn’t I be okay? It’s none of my business.”
“Jane, you realize she’s in love with you, right?”
Side-stepping me, Jane heads towards the kitchen to pour herself a glass of water. “Apparently not.”
“What the hell is going on?” I walk over and turn off the sink. “You fist-fought Erik when he proposed to her, and now suddenly you don’t care someone else has proposed?”
“Cora,” Jane interjects, “leave it alone.”
“No.” I cross my arms defiantly. “This is my job.”
“Pissing me off is your job?”
Grilling her is obviously not working, so I try a different approach. I lower my voice and say, “Somethings wrong. What are you not telling me?”
For as stubborn as Jane is, I honestly don’t expect it to work. But when she finally turns to face me, I’m surprised to find genuine upset in her eyes. “You don’t understand how any of this works. You don’t just marry someone. There’s. . . customs.”
“Like?”
“Like you have to get her mothers permission first.”
Erik got Charlotte’s mothers permission before announcing their engagement? “Look, I don’t know what your problem is, but you need to stop this wedding from happening. Charlotte loves you, you’ve admitted to me you return her feelings, so why don’t you ask her mom for her permission and end this pointless drama?”
Jane is usually a short-tempered surly grump. The woman who looks down at me is anything but. “I did,” she whispers, quickly turning away and heading into the living room.
Finally, we’re getting somewhere. “What do you mean you did? She said no to you but yes to a genocidal maniac?”
“You’re a genuine Sherlock Holmes.”
I follow closely behind Jane as she wanders aimlessly around her house in an attempt to escape me. “Why’d she say no? Did she give you an answer?”
Jane finally spins around at this, leaning down to yell, “You really think I’m stupid, don’t you? Coming in here, telling me shit I already know! Charlotte—” Her voice hitches at the name. “I followed every custom. Every last one. The day I turned 18, I went to her mother and asked permission to marry Charlotte, and her mother said no."
“And that’s that?”
“That’s that,” she responds. “A mother’s word is final.”
I think about my granddaughter and how feral I feel at the through of fully grown men trying to marry her. “Jane, these customs you’re talking about are in place to protect children and teens. Both of you are grown adults who can make your own decisions. Isn’t Charlotte, like, 30?”
“What does that have to do with it?”
“You’d think if she was going to pick someone else, she would have done so a long time ago. Don’t you find it weird she’s settling for Gunnar after all this time? Because it looks to me like she’s trying to get your attention.”
“Go,” Jane whispers. Almost immediately afterwards she screams, “Just go! Get out of my house!”
A month ago, I would have been terrified of her expression. Now, it just makes me sad.
“Charlotte’s wedding is in two days. Can I go?”
“Of course you can go,” I answer. “Why wouldn’t you go?”
Ben frowns in my direction. “She was asking me.”
I watch as Alex straps on a backpack and heads towards the door. Wiping my hands clean on my apron, I turn away from the stove. “You’re leaving right now?”
“Yeah,” she answers, smiling. “Don’t worry. Christopher is meeting me at the fence to escort me to Hydra. I’m going to help everyone set up for the wedding.”
“But we’re about to eat dinner,” I say. “Here, take some for the trip.”
“I actually packed all of last nights leftovers.” Alex shrugs, looking sheepish. “Sorry.”
“No, no, that’s good! As long as you eat,” I say as Alex hurries over to give me a hug. “I won’t be there until the day of. Have fun!”
I turn back towards the stove as Alex says goodbye to Ben and hurries out the door. As soon as I hear the wheels of his chair rolling against the hardwood floors, I spin away from the stove and yell, “Hey! You’re not supposed to wheel yourself around for another few days!”
Ben gives me an unamused smirk as I walk over to wheel him into the kitchen.
Luckily, his food snobbery works to my advantage. I’ve had a craving for Cacio e Pepe the last few days, and his kitchen was stocked with the cheeses I need, as well as a pasta press to make fresh noodles. Just as I finish cooking, Hugo knocks on the door, asking if we have any tomatoes. With a little persuasion, he agrees to take Alex’s spot at dinner and eat with us.
I wheel Ben to the table, plate everyone’s food, and take a seat, ready to dive in.
I’m not even able to take a first bite before Ben asks, “What the hell do you think you’re doing?”
“I. . . uh, nothing.” Hugo closes the cap on a ketchup bottle. “Sorry.”
“Sorry for what?” I ask. “It’s just food. You can put ketchup on it if you want.”
“I’m going to do you a favor and pretend I didn't hear you just now.” Ben’s response is directed at me, but his eyes never leave the bottle of ketchup in Hugo’s hand. “You do not eat Cacio e Pepe with ketchup.”
“Why not?” Ben has no way of knowing, but he’s hitting a sore spot of mine, and it takes a concentrated effort to keep my voice calm. “If Hugo wants to eat it with ketchup, then let him. No! No,” I say, stopping Hugo from getting up to put the bottle away. “You eat your food however you want. In fact—”
“Cora.” Ben looks like he’s about to have an aneurysm. “Don’t you dare.”
I hear the wails of my ancestors as I dump a heaping glob of Dharma-brand ketchup all over my perfectly good pasta. The second it touches my tongue, I feel my entire face pucker in protest, but I don’t give Ben the satisfaction. “Mmm!” I hum unconvincingly, take another tart bite, and swallow without chewing just to get it out of my mouth as quickly as possible.
“Yeah, so, uh,” Hugo says, “I’m really not all that hungry anymore. . .”
I turn in his direction—face still slightly puckering—and order, “Eat.”
Hugo immediately starts shoveling food in his mouth.
I spend all of dinner thinking up what to say to Ben as soon as Hugo leaves. My mind is a whirlwind of possible counters to his counters. I’m so riled up when Hugo thanks us for the food and leaves, that when I close the door behind him, I just stare at the doorknob for a moment, decompressing from all the fake conversations in my head.
Once my mind has settled, I spin around, shoot Ben a scathing look, and then riffle through the kitchen cabinets in search of a container.
Ben doesn’t ask me what I’m doing or what I’m looking for. “As someone who was raised by Italians,” he comments flatly, “I cannot believe you sat idly by and defended such an insult to the craft.”
“Ben,” I say evenly, through I’m not sure how much longer I can remain measured, “it wasn’t your food. I put it on a plate and gave it to Hugo, which made it his food. Which means you shut your mouth and let him enjoy it in whatever way he wants.”
“You do not eat Cacio e Pepe with ketchup,” he sneers.
“Of course you don’t eat it with ketchup!” I turn to scream at him, and the ferocity in my voice finally makes him look chastised. “What kind of psychopath puts ketchup on white sauce?” I don’t like the way he’s relaxing at my outburst, like he’s slowly starting to feel smug that I agree with him. “ In matters of food,” I continue more calmly, “being rude is worse than being wrong. You shouldn’t have said anything.”
“This is my house,” Ben returns in a clipped, quiet tone.
“Yes,” I raise my voice again and toss the cloth napkin down on the table in rage. “This is your house, and you were a terrible host tonight! Ugh, you still don’t get it! You should have known better.” I can’t help but feel like I’m scolding Fenrir as I step closer to his wheelchair and wag a finger in Ben’s face. “I don’t ever want you to embarrass me like that again. You hear me?” When he doesn’t answer, I yell, “Do you hear me, Benjamin?”
There's a noticeable change in the air. Some sort of shift in dynamics that brings a startled blush to my face. I’m not entirely sure how I know, but he’s enjoying this in a way that makes me deeply uncomfortable. Unsure of what to do next, I grab the last plate off the table and turn away from him, dumping the dirty dishes in a sink full of sudsy water.
Hesitantly, Ben wheels closer. “I’ve upset you, and I’d like to apologize.”
“Go away,” I snap. "And stop wheeling yourself around. You're going to rip your stitches!"
“Cora, I’m sorry.” He studies me a moment, and then relents. “I’m not too proud to admit I’m very confused as to why you’re so upset.”
Once the table is cleared off, I turn back towards the stovetop of leftovers and start shoveling what’s left of them into Tupperware. “We have to deal with enough bullshit as it is,” I huff under my breath.
“We?”
I didn’t think he could hear me, but since he has, I start talking and can’t seem to stop. “Hugo and I are the only two fat people on this island.” I wait for Ben to say what everyone tends to say—no you’re not!—but he just gives a little jolt of his head, acknowledging it as fact but encouraging me to explain my point. “Fat people can’t just eat food.”
“I still don’t understand,” Ben says slowly.
“We can’t just enjoy our food because people feel inclined to comment on every single aspect of whatever it is we’re eating. All the time. It literally doesn’t matter what it is. If I’m eating pizza, I get comments about how I should make better choices. But if I’m eating. . . I don’t know. . . a Greek salad, then people say I should have altered the ingredients in my dressing, or used less feta, or added carrots—”
Ben looks enraged. “You don’t put carrots in a Greek salad.”
“That’s not the point! Oh my God, you're exhausting.”
“Where are you going?”
“Out,” I answer vaguely and slam the front door behind me.
“Nah,” Hugo says, waving away the thought.
Now that Hugo and Libby have finally met, I’ve spent the last ten minutes trying to convince him that she is, in fact, interested in him. “I’m being completely serious, Hugo.” It’s easier to act goofy around Hugo because you can sense he doesn’t judge you the same way everyone else does. I point a thumb at myself and proclaim, “Goddess of Love, remember?”
“What would somebody like her see in somebody like me?”
“Oh, come on,” I complain. “Everyone loves you. You’re hilarious, and kind, and you’re easy to talk to.” Hugo looks pleased at my encouragement, but I’m also well aware of all the self-doubt that comes with being bigger. I know all too well how exhausting it is to wonder if people like you or are simply allowing you to exist peacefully in their vicinity. The answer is almost always not because they actually like you.
Neither of us are directly acknowledging the obvious—we’re the only two people who understand what it’s like to be bigger than everyone else in the room.
“Ehh,” he says in an attempt to brush me off. “Well, so are you.”
Huh? “I am?”
“You were helping people gather and organize food as soon as you woke up from the crash. You gave me a blanket.”
I don’t remember any of this. “I did?”
“Yeah, and you helped Walt calm down when he lost Vincent. You were actually stressing Jack out a lot because he kept trying to get you to sit down but you kept wandering off to help people.” He smiles and brings his shoulders up in a quick shrug. “I guess that’s why it was such a shock you turned out to be the leader of the vikings.”
“There’s a lot of reasons people were surprised that I’m the leader of anything.” Great, and I’ve somehow managed to make this awkward. Abort mission. “Well, I won’t keep you any longer. Again, I am so sorry about dinner.”
“It’s cool, dude. No harm done. And thanks for the leftovers.”
I take a look around the small bungalow Hugo shares with Charlie. Or, rather, shared with Charlie. “Be sure to say hi to Charlie for me when he’s out of rehab.”
Hugo waves from his spot on the sofa. “Will do. Oh, and Cora? I promise to keep your secret.”
My mind immediately races with every possible scenario. What if he figured out I'm only pretending to dislike Ben? Oh my God, he's accidently going to tell everyone on the island and our perfect plan will be ruined. Everyone knows Hugo can't keep a secret! I smile to try and hide my panic. "What secret?"
"You totally ate a chicken enchilada when we first crashed."
"Oh, wow, I did, didn't I?" I'm so relieved it's not about Ben that my laugh comes out loud and obnoxious. "Thank you," I say on my way out the door. "You're a real pal, Hugo."
Night has fallen over the community, and everyone has retreated into their snug little bungalows. I pass by Juliet's house and hear the amused laughter of Jack through an open window. At first I dismiss it, but then I hear Juliet laughing alongside him, so I inconspicuously peak into the nearest window.
How long has this been a thing?
I scribble down notes by the light of the moon as I reluctantly head back to Ben’s house.
Without Alex as a buffer, I have no idea how to act around Ben. Our last interactions were a series of love letters that made me swoon, but he’s done nothing but piss me off since his injury.
Cut him some slack. He pushed a kid out of harms way and is suffering the consequences of ‘no good deed goes unpunished.’ I wish he would just let me heal him so he could stop moping. I want to talk to him, but I can’t think of anything that won’t remind him that he’s stuck in a wheelchair for the time being. As the silence drags on, I scrape the recesses of my memory to think of something, anything, to talk about. I think back on a conversation I had with Alex and decide to ask, “What can you tell me about seiðr?”
“Absolutely nothing,” he answers. “But that’s only because men do not practice seiðr.”
Alex mentioned seiðr is illegal, but is it illegal for everyone or just women? “All men?” I ask. “Why? Are they not allowed?”
Ben looks up from his book and shakes his head no. “It's not that they’re forbidden from practicing, it’s that they physically can’t. Men do not inherit magic.”
That's not true. I've seen Christopher use magic almost every single day on Hydra. I want to ask him more, but he’s already turned his attention back to his book.
Emboldened by the fact that he can’t easily rush over and snatch things out of my hands, I walk over to his desk and flip through the stacks of seemingly endless papers. A strange sadness wells in my chest at the sight of so many documents with runes on them.
I hold one up to the light, but it’s gibberish to me. “How long did it take you to learn their language?”
“Conversationally?” Ben looks up from his book again, his face thankfully not set in any detectable annoyance. “A year or so. Fluently? Many, many years. Why?”
I contemplate lying to save myself potential embarrassment, but I end up telling the truth. “I hate how I can’t understand what people are saying half the time. They would never admit this to my face, but I can tell they’re disappointed I can’t understand my own language. I don’t know. It’s just. . .” I think about all the times the women on Hydra make comments in Norse, laughing like it’s the funniest thing they’ve ever heard. “It’s kinda lonely.”
“I could teach you, if you’d like.”
“Thanks. Any help would be much appreciated.” I find a leather sketchbook under the papers and flip through it, looking back up at him with a massive smile. “Are these yours?”
“Can you please stop rifling through my things?”
I ignore him and continue flipping through pages. “You’re an artist?”
“In a manner of speaking,” he says, sounding flustered. “I’m only good at portraits. I’m terrible at anything that isn’t human.” Ben holds out a hand. “May I have that back, please?”
“It’s so unfair.” I hand him the notebook and start holding up fingers to countdown my list. “You’re a first rate cook, you can draw better than anyone I’ve ever met—”
“I’m actually a much better painter.”
I hold up another finger. “You’re incredibly modest.” My insides swell with pride when I get a chuckle out of him.
Ben asks, “Penny for your thoughts?”
“What?”
“What are you thinking about? You look sad.”
My initial reflex to say oh, nothing dies almost immediately. “I was thinking about how much my siblings would have loved it here.”
“Did they look like you?”
I burst into loud laughter at the thought. “No, they didn’t look anything like me.” I tell him how similar they looked to Alex but explain how they’re different.
Talking about my siblings makes me homesick in a way I’ve never felt before. I spent my life wishing my parents liked me, but a part of me always knew that was a fools hope. But my siblings? Our bond was shatterproof. We had no choice but to band together to survive. As annoying as they could be sometimes, I would die for them, no questions asked.
“Did they look like this?”
Ben turns the notebook around and my vision literally tunnels. All I sense is the faint chirping of night bugs congregating by the window outside. It’s just bugs chirping and the sight of three people I never thought I’d ever see again. He was so quiet, I didn’t even know he was sketching. I make my way across the room in slow motion, focused solely on the realistic likeness of my younger twin sisters and little brother. When I’m close enough, Ben hands it to me so I can get a better look.
“You’re allowed to cry.” Ben looks exhausted, but he smiles anyway. “I’m used to it by now.”
I laugh as the tears finally spill over. “Thank you.”
“You don’t need my permission to cry.”
“No,” I whisper through the tears, clinging to the notebook for dear life, “thank you. For this.”
“You’re welcome.” He nods in acknowledgement, offering the rare sight of softened eyes. “If you don’t mind wheeling me back to my room, I think I’m about ready to turn in for the night.”
I wipe my face dry, marveling again at the sketch. “Okay, don’t make this weird, but before you go to sleep, I need you to take your shirt off so I can redress your stitches.”
Ben sighs. “I wish I could shower. The humidity was not kind today, and I can still feel the sweat on me.”
I know how he feels. I felt the same exact way when I first landed here. It seems so long ago that we were all on the beach, washing up in the ocean with nothing but spare clothing for a washcloth. Oh! “Want a sponge bath in the meantime?”
Ben’s eyebrows twitch up in amusement. “Why? Are you offering?”
Having been raised by a devout Catholic mother, I was never taught anything about sex other than abstinence is always the answer. We’re not supposed to talk about it, not supposed to think about it, and obviously not supposed to do it, or else we go to Hell. Now I'm a married woman, and I haven't a clue in the world how to approach the subject.
Wait, why am I thinking about sex? Nobody mentioned sex. What is wrong with me? He just wants to get clean. Why am I always thinking about sex?
No, wait, he’s flirting. Yes, definitely flirting. I’m not reading this wrong. What do I say? Is flirting just one giant game of chicken?
I stare him down, desperately trying to mask how terrified I am. Finally, I think of something to say. “That’s the entire reason I’m here, remember?”
Notes:
Massive THANK YOU to those who kindly left reviews and kudos!!! You have no idea how much your external validation keeps me going lol. I know I promised more spice, but I had to break this chapter up...so expect spice from the next chapter on, scout's honor.
Chapter 22: I'm Glad You Came
Chapter Text
“Do you want the good news or the bad news first?”
I’m standing behind Ben’s wheelchair, so I cannot see his expression when he asks, “How bad is the bad news?”
“It’s not great,” I answer.
“Good news first.”
“Well, the good news is you haven’t ripped any of your stitches. The bad news is, your dragon tattoo is all kinds of messed up.”
Ben’s quiet for a moment. “Do you think it's hideous?”
“No, of course not. I. . . uh-oh."
"What?" Ben asks. "What do you mean uh-oh?"
"I think your stitches are infected. It's hard to tell because of your tattoo. We should call Jack and have him come look at it.”
“Let him sleep,” Ben answers softly, and the way he seems to have lost all his energy saddens me. “I’m not going to die of infection by tomorrow. You can fetch him then.”
“Or,” I offer, walking around in front of his wheelchair so he can admire my exaggerated and ridiculous dance, if you can even call it that. Most people would probably say it’s less dancing and more me flailing my arms around. I finish with a clap and say, “You can just let me heal you!”
It was a shot in the dark, considering he’s turned down my offer to heal him every single time since I landed on this island. Still, I wasn’t expecting him to bare his teeth in a silent snarl at the offer.
Annoyed, I drop my arms and snap, “What? I’m just trying to help you. Why are you looking at me like that?”
"If you believe asking the same question multiple times will yield a different answer, I'm sorry to disappoint you.”
I’m not even annoyed anymore, I just want a straight answer. "Why won't you let me help you?”
I’ve barely asked the question before he answers, “Everyone, for my entire life, thinks I killed you. Why would I willingly put myself in a position to make that a reality?”
“Healing your stitches isn’t going to kill me,” I counter.
“It might not,” he agrees. “But why would I take that risk? My body can heal on its own.”
There’s a newfound fire in me that makes it difficult not to fight back, but I take a deep breath and process what he’s saying. Stop pushing him. He’s obviously tied up in complicated PTSD about my death. He’s not just scared about hurting me, he’s also scared of the societal ramifications that come with that. Let it go. He’s right. Just drop it and go get Jack in the morning.
“I’m sorry,” I tell him. “I won’t suggest that anymore.” He says something, but I’m so focused on walking back behind his wheelchair so I can push him over to the edge of his bed that I miss whatever it is he said. He doesn’t repeat himself, so I don’t bother asking. Instead, I busy myself with squeezing all the water out of the washcloth I set on his bedside table and mentally prepare myself to touch him.
Neither of us say a word as I scrub his face first, running the warm washcloth over his forehead, down his nose, and across his cheeks while I try and keep my eyes focused on the washcloth to distract me from the fact that he’s staring directly at me with zero embaressment. The longer he remains silent, the more my anxiety builds. I can’t seem to figure out if I like being brazenly adored or if it freaks me out. Right now, it's a strange mixture of both. Please, say something, Ben.
"I’m sorry for asking to heal you earlier,” I whisper. “I don't want you to be mad at me anymore.”
“I’m not mad.”
“Yes you were.”
“I'm not mad anymore,” he clarifies, gifting me with a small smile. “Thank you for—” Ben pauses, darting his eyes down to my hand before looking back up at my face. “—this.”
I have no idea what I’m doing, and yet I know exactly what I’m doing when I say, “You should brush your hair back more often, like you did at the wedding.”
Ben opens and closes his mouth about a dozen times, thinking and rethinking an answer. I reach out and gently brush back some hair so it softens the spikes and falls in line with the style I mentioned, my fingers lingering against his temple. For once I don't feel completely stupid because judging by the stunned look on his face, he doesn't know what to do either.
“Okay,” he breathes. “Noted.”
Now. Lean in and kiss him now. Wait, no, that will freak him out. Right? Oh my God, stop making excuses and just do it. He’s literally confessed an undying devotion to you, so why are you still afraid of rejection? “What do you like to do for fun?” I blurt out, my heartbeat suddenly pounding against my ribs. “I just realized we’ve never talked about hobbies. Well, I mean, besides cooking and drawing."
To distract myself from the rising panic, I move my attention to scrubbing his arms. Ben remains silent, so I hold off for as long as I can until the silence forces me to look at him, only to find his eyes heavy lidded, his mouth set in a shit eating grin. Having his full attention is wonderful, but it's also awful because it paralyses me. If men do not inherit magic, then why can't I force myself to look away?
“What I like to do for fun will have to wait until after I’m fully healed,” he says, and every hair follicle on my body stands on end. It’s at this moment that I realize our positions. He’s trapped in a wheelchair, but I’m still physically below him because I’m kneeling. Ben locks his eyes to mine, lording over me like a king awaiting worship. “I’m afraid you'll have to wait."
I get it now. I understand. I feel it. Magic. Coursing through my veins, making it easy to say what I would normally never think to say. “And what if I don’t like waiting?” This seems to take him by surprise, which only makes me more bold. “What if I'm really impatient?”
“I don’t think. . .” he starts, but I watch as he takes a few seconds to try and process the situation and his place in it. “I don’t know if I can?” he says, but it sounds like a question trembling with nerves.
The world stands still as I push up to my feet. I’m not terribly taller than he is sitting down, but it’s enough to draw clear lines as to who’s in charge. “What are you going to do to stop me?” I croon. “Wheel over my toes?” I have him ensnared, and there’s nothing he can say or do to escape. “You know. . . I’m getting sick of you ordering me around. Who do you think you are, anyway?”
Ben’s trying—and failing miserably—to keep his breathing measured as I trail downward, passing the washcloth over the dip of his bellybutton. He keeps his intense eyes trained on me as I make little circles with the cloth, dipping it back into the bowl and squeezing out the excess with one hand. I take my time, making sure I do a thorough job of passing over every inch of skin above the waistband of his pajamas.
“I need to wash your legs now.” Even I can hear the husky, erotic desire in my voice. “You’re fond of saying you don’t need my help, but let me help you out of your pants.”
What the hell is going on? What is happening? Who am I? I’m sorry God. I’m sorry grandma. Please don’t be watching me right now. I don’t know what I’m going to do once his pants are off, but for some reason the uncertainty just makes me more excited. I’ve never even seen a penis in real life before. I hope it doesn’t look weird.
All at once, the worry racing through my mind stills, and I can literally feel the magic wafting off me. Look at him. He probably doesn’t even remember his own name at this point. I could ask him for anything and he’d do it. Ha. Men are so easy. Pathetic.
Ben’s moving much too slowly for my taste, but I don’t tell him to hurry. Something about the way his big beautiful eyes light up with equal amounts of desire and terror does something to me that I have absolutely no plans to psychoanalyze anytime soon. My breathing quickens as his waistband slides further down—
—and then the front door slams shut and there’s the sound of muffled footsteps in the hallway.
“Dad?” Alex calls.
“Jesus Christ,” I whisper in horror and jerk away from him. Someone knocks on the closed bedroom door, and there’s no time to open the window and shimmy out. I help him back into his shirt and hide in the closet, pulling the door closed as quietly as I can.
“Dad?” Alex cracks the door open a fraction and whispers, “Dad, are you asleep?”
“Hi Alex,” he answers with a smile, having successfully buttoned his shirt closed at record speed. “You can come in.”
“Just checking on you,” she says from the doorway. “I totally forgot to pack Charlotte’s wedding present, so I had to rush back. I can’t stay long. Hey, do you know where Cora is? She’s not in my room. If she’s not here, do you need help getting into bed?”
“I’ll need help getting into bed, but I’m not quite ready to lay down yet. I’ll ask Cora when she returns. I believe she went for a night walk.” Ben clears his throat. “She should be back soon.”
I wait until Alex leaves, closing the door behind her, before revealing myself. I wag a thumb at Ben’s bedroom window, unable to even look in his general direction. I silently mouth the words, “I’m gonna go.” Alex is still digging around for something in her room, and I cannot bare to spend another second trapped in here with Ben. Careful not to make a sound, I pull up his bedroom window, shimmy out, and run into my son.
Christopher blinks at me in the light of Ben’s front porch, his eyes darting behind me, where he just saw me come from. We’re both too shocked to be the one to speak first.
“Oh, there you are!” Alex closes the front door behind her and hurries down the porch steps to give me a hug. “What are you up to so late?”
“I. . . was. . . out walking.” I give Chris what I hope is a pleading look and turn to answer Alex with a wobbly, “Nothing like a night walk after such a muggy day, right? I was just about to check in on your dad. What are you two doing here?”
“We were halfway to Hydra when Alex remembered she left her wedding present at home,” Chris answers, and I turn away from Alex and towards him.
“You could have sent me a letter,” I offer. “I could have brought it when I sailed their tomorrow.”
“Yeah,” Alex cuts in, “but I. . . kinda haven’t finished it. I really need to pull an all-nighter so it’s ready in time.”
“Oh, okay.” I bring a hand up to swipe at my already sweating forehead. “Well, in that case, I won’t keep you any longer. Safe travels. And good luck finishing that gift.”
I wave as they walk away, through the courtyard and out of sight. Face inflaming, I pause with my hand on the doorknob, mortified at what might have happened had I pushed Ben to take his pants off faster.
Ah, there it is. Good old Catholic guilt.
How does someone even find themselves in a situation like this?
It’s 2am, and I’m wide awake, fully clothed, lying on my back directly beside Ben on his bed. I couldn’t even explain the psychology behind this if I tried.
I was headed to Alex’s room, initially. I only came in here because I needed to help Ben out of his wheelchair and into bed. What I failed to realize until just now is that this was just a classic case of manipulation. Ben turned down Alex’s offer of help because he wanted me to know he had the power to demand my help. It was his way of ensuring I didn’t flee to Hydra and leave him stranded here alone before we had a chance to talk. As to why I agreed to lie here until he falls asleep? Even I don’t know the answer to that.
I close my eyes and whisper, “Are you asleep?”
“Not anymore,” Ben answers
I'm a selfish bitch. I haven't told him about his future yet because I'm a selfish bitch. I want him all to myself before he's riddled with more anxieties. I'm sure there's not a person on either island that wouldn't freak out if they knew they were going to die. Kinda takes the mood out of it, right? I want him at his most free, and that makes me a selfish piece of shit. . . like my father.
Just like my father.
“We can’t ever do that again. We can’t ever do anything like that again.” I don’t realize I’m crying until I taste the inescapable tang of salt. “Or you’re going to die.”
There’s a bewildered pause before he asks, “Right now?”
“What? No.”
“Then when?”
“I. . . don’t know.”
“Soon? Do you at least know if it’s soon?”
“No. I. . . I don’t know when, I just know you’re going to eventually die.”
“Yes,” he immediately replies. “That’s definitely the biggest downside to being mortal.”
“No,” I try to explain, but now it’s obvious I’m crying.
Ben sighs. “What did I do this time?”
I’m so upset at the thought of losing him, I cannot stop the word vomit from flowing. “I had a vision that you’re going to get me pregnant, and then you’re going to die.”
“How very black widow of you.”
“Stop with the jokes,” I yell, and he stiffens at my tone.
“Cora,” Ben treads carefully, “what you’re telling me is, as far as you know, we could live perfectly normal, happy lives for months. Years. Decades, even.”
“No, that’s not—”
“You just said you don’t know when it will happen.”
Wait, he's right. I don't actually know when it's going to happen. I only know that in the future, I haven't aged too much because everyone recognizes me in this current form. But. . . at what point would that stop? 24? 25? 30? 35? Men can get women pregnant up until the day they croak, but women go through menopause and lose their fertility. But is that even a possibility for me? Could I remain fertile forever, and Ben doesn't get me pregnant until he's an old man, so when I time travel back to the 70's everyone just thinks I'm still 21 when in reality I'm 60? Could Ben be right about all this? Could we have an entire lifetime of sexual fulfillment, so that when the day of his death finally does come, it will at least have been a life well spent?
Or what if I'm wrong and I'm about two seconds from accidentally killing my dream man with my magical coochie?
“I’m going to get pregnant," I whisper up at the ceiling. "It happens while I’m pregnant.” With Christopher.
“Okay. And? Do you at least know how old you are when you’re pregnant?”
No. “No.”
“You don’t have any other information? Is it after you birth our first child? Will it happen after multiple children down the line?”
Is Chris my only child? “I don’t know,” I croak miserably.
“Okay,” he concludes. “Then I’m going to choose not to worry about it.”
“But what if—”
“Cora, if what you’re saying is true, and you can’t change this from happening, then I’m not going to waste whatever time I have left worrying about death. I’m not afraid to die. Although,” he adds, “it is a little concerning how upset you are about this. Do you not plan on sending me to Fólkvangr? Do you not plan on visiting me in Fólkvangr?” I don’t even have a chance to think up an answer to his strange question before I notice the exact moment he fully realizes what I’ve said. “Pregnant,” he deadpans. “I see.”
I sigh, wiping my face dry, relieved that he at least seems to fully understand the danger he’s in. “As long as we don’t have sex, you’re safe.”
“Well,” Ben counters, “certain kinds, at least.” A light blush dusts across his cheeks and nose when my face scrunches up in confusion. “I feel like this is some kind of test,” he says, squinting with suspicion. “I’m not going to be so presumptuous as to explain lovemaking to the Goddess of Love.”
“Oh, I see what you mean.” Shit. I’m so stupid. “I mean, yes. Of course. Obviously we could. . . do. . . other things.” I might have gotten away with my lapse in understanding if I’d just laughed it off from the start, but now I’m babbling, and I can tell Ben’s now fully aware that I don’t know a damn thing about intimacy, which just makes me more embarrassed.
“Have you—” Ben pauses for a painful amount of time, probably to ensure his question is not insulting. “Have you had any lovers since your rebirth?”
I don’t even bother trying to answer because the answer is written all over my mortified face.
“None?” Ben’s eyes widen, and he sighs with what sounds like intense relief.
“What?” I’m immediately on edge, ready to defend myself from whatever stupid joke he’s about to make at my expense.
Instead of poking fun at me, Ben smiles and says, “You have a habit of flinching away when I’m close to you. I’ve been worried it meant you secretly find me repulsive. Never in a million years would I have thought it was because you were nervous.” I watch as his expression slowly shifts from nervous excitement to a completely different type of excitement. “Goddess, why would you be nervous around me?”
Why are you just laying here? You know what you want. Say what you want. Tell him every little thing that you want. Tell him how much you want him. Tell him how much you want him inside you—whoa. Whoa. Whoa. Hold on. No, snap out of it! Resist! Breaking out of the magic lust barrier helps bring me a brief moment of clarity, even though it’s exhausting to do and leaves me trembling. I don’t know what I’m more embarrassed by—what he’s saying or my inability to calm down and flirt back with him. It’s impossible to flirt because all my body wants to do is strip naked and ride him until my legs cramp. In my panic, I snap, “You know why.”
“I do,” he clarifies, darting his eyes down to my mouth and back up to my eyes. “I just want to hear you say it.”
I can’t answer him, so I roll onto my side and silence him with desperate kisses, our lips crushing together so urgently it's hard to breathe. He's right in front of me, but he's nowhere near close enough for my liking.
If I'd had known how good making out feels, I would have pushed for this sooner. Why would I ever choose to turn away from this? I never want this feeling to end. I would do anything to keep going like this forever. I would do anything he asked of me. I would raze entire cities to the ground if he asked me to. I would stop death itself. Yes, that’s what I’ll do. I simply won’t let him die. That’s how I’ll save him.
There’s a hand on my leg, gripping my upper thigh. He tells me how good I feel between kisses, and it doesn’t make me uncomfortable because, at least in this moment, I believe him. So much so, that I feel a crackling surge of what can only be described as intense magic.
“No!” By the way he gasps, you’d think I’d just plunged a knife into his stomach. “No, no, no, Cora, what did you do? What did you do?”
“I’m so sorry,” I gasp, pulling away. Did the crackling electrocute him? “Did I hurt you?” I’m legitimately confused why he's so upset until I feel a sharp pain sending lightning up my spine, and I buckle from the intensity. “Oh no! I didn’t mean to! I swear I didn’t mean to—agh!” I scream. Another stabbing pain shoots through my spine, and all I can do is hiss through clenched teeth and focus on breathing. “How the hell have you been putting up with this. . . this whole time? I can barely breathe.”
“Lay on your side,” he instructs kindly and hops out of bed, as if he didn’t just have major reconstructive surgery. “It hurts less when you’re on your side.”
“No,” I hiss. “I can’t move. It hurts. Everything hurts. What did you do to me?”
My eyes are squeezed shut from the pain, but I can hear his frown when he shouts, “What did I do to you? You healed me without permission!”
“No,” I hiss even louder. “You’re not listening. Everything hurts. I think I accidentally fixed more than just your spine.”
Ben quickly bends his knees and swivels his torso, seeming surprised. “Well, now that you mention it—”
“See?” I gasp. “Do you understand now? I need a distraction." My body feels a little more healed when I think of him without a shirt on. Take your shirt off. "Talk to me."
"You need a doctor. I'm going to get Jack."
"No," I shriek. "Ben, please, please believe me when I say it was an accident. I never would have intentionally healed you after promising not to. It's these stupid magic surges. I can't control them. I've been trying to, I swear."
It takes a second, but he says, "I believe you."
I nod with gratitude, trying my best to subdue the pain so it doesn't look like I'm about to pass out. "Thank you. Since it was an accident, I'm hoping you can continue to honor my wishes of dealing with this on my own." I swallow down a scream of pain, only for it to bounce back up my throat as a moan. Hopefully, he didn't notice. "Please. . . I promise you I'm not going to die. Goddess of foresight, remember? Please just distract me from the pain. Tell me something I don’t know.”
It’s like he’s been waiting all day to tell me when he blurts out, “Jack and Juliet are an item.”
I blink away the sweat dripping into my eyes and shoot him an unamused look. “I already know that.”
“Tom’s gay.”
“Ugh, I already—”
“And he is having an affair off-island.”
“I already know that, too. Come on,” I moan in pain, attempting to hide my embarrassment at how sexual it sounds when it echoes throughout the room. “Tell me something truly shocking to distract me.”
Without missing a beat, Ben confesses, “When I touch myself, I can’t come unless I think of you.”
For what it's worth, his confession does, at least momentarily, shock the pain away. I blink at him in the darkness. “You. . . what?”
Ben’s expression is an ever evolving mess of embarrassed confusion and pure mortification. His voice comes out soft and incredibly measured when he says, “Clearly that is not what you meant by tell me something truly shocking. Ahem. I. . . would. . . like to apologize—”
“No need to apologize,” I interrupt, feeling slightly dizzy but otherwise pretty damn good. Why doesn't my back hurt anymore? "Enjoying the knees?"
I watch him blink rapidly as he cuts his apology short. “What?”
"Your new knees," I clarify. Tilting my head down ever so slightly, I look up at him and bat my lashes. “I didn't mean to heal you, but now that I have, you might as well enjoy yourself, right?”
Ben doesn’t seem to gain his confidence back when he realizes I’m coming onto him. If anything, he just looks more terrified. He takes a small step away from where I was huddled in pain on his bed, and I realize it's because I've completely straightened my spine. I'm already fully healed. “Careful, Cora," he warns, "I think you just healed yourself.”
“Do you honestly think I don’t know that?" I’m fully aware of the boost in my abilities. “Of course I healed myself.” My head is heavy with seduction as I roll out of bed and walk towards him, slowly, never breaking eye contact. “I’m a Goddess,” I brag in a whisper, stepping close enough to rub my hands up his chest. “I’m your Goddess.”
Please, Ben, I’m begging you. Do something to stop me. Anything. Damn it, Ben, snap out of it! Oh, no! Neither of us can snap out of it! Unable to wait any longer, I hook a finger under his chin and guide him over to his bed like the pathetic little animal he is.
Everything blends into one overpowering sensation as he works me out of my dress. Fingers brushing against my exposed nipples, the cold dampness left behind by his eager mouth, the never-ending need to press myself closer to him by any means necessary.
A low moan escapes my throat when I realize I’m so aroused it’s bordering on painful, and there’s only one thing that will help alleviate it. “Touch me,” I whisper desperately. “Now. Right now.”
Ben doesn’t reach down between my legs like I ordered. Instead, he positions himself so he’s propped up over me, trapping me against him and the mattress. “You know,” he says lowly, waiting for me to look him in the eyes before he continues, “I don’t like being told what to do either.” Leaning down until his teeth scrape against my ear, he whispers, “Even by a Goddess.”
I thought I liked being in control, so why am I even more turned on by the fact that he’s not letting me order him around anymore?
His demand comes out in a single, clipped word. “Beg.”
My response is nothing more than a shaky gasp of air. “What?”
“You heard me,” he repeats. “Go on. I’m waiting.”
“I. . .” Try as I might, my magic isn’t enough to take control of him anymore, and I think I like it. It’s all the rush of danger without any real fear because I know he would never hurt me. He’s getting drunk off me the way I just got drunk off him. We’re getting drunk off each other. With this thought comes the relief of knowing this is a push and pull of power, not a hoarding of it. He’s taking charge for now, but it’ll be my turn again soon enough. I could accidentally kill him by moving too fast. I know it. He knows it. He values his life too much to actually piss me off. This is a game. I can play games. With a newfound confidence, I look at him with softened eyes, begging like the world will end if he doesn’t reward me with his hands down against my—
A loud cry rips from my throat, but it’s already replaced with another wild gasp before I even have the chance to think about being embarrassed. At first, it feels amazing just being touched at all, but after the initial shock wares off, I take note of what feels the best and guide his hand, teaching him where to touch, how hard or softly, and with what speed. The fact that he’s so focused on making me happy brings a surge of magic back, ensnaring us both until every movement of his fingers is exactly what I need to ride out the most intense orgasm I’ve ever experienced.
I wait for him to frown and demand we switch spots, but he just smiles and kisses my forehead. “You’re glowing,” he says, laughing when I roll my eyes. “No, Cora, you are quite literally glowing.”
I hold up a hand in the dark and see that he’s right. It's not a blinding glow, but my skin shines with light. I look back over to find him smiling triumphantly, shifting to tuck an arm up and behind his head, sighing with self-satisfaction. It’s as if all that matters is me and my needs.
It is his lack of aggression that makes me feral. I roll over and straddle him. There’s no accounting for where my hands are at any given moment. Every inch of his body needs to be caressed—over his face, down his neck and across his shoulders, my fingernails raking down his back, circling around to his chest, inching down ever closer to his—
Ben pins my wandering wrist against the mattress. “Careful,” he warns, his voice low in the back of his throat. “I don’t like being tortured. Please don’t start something you have no intention of finishing.”
“Are you telling me what to do again?” I can see he absolutely does not intend for me to rip free from his grip because the sound he makes when I take him in my hand is not any of the measured, practiced sounds I’ve heard from him so far. It is the drowning gasps of a desperate man, desperate to do absolutely anything and everything I say. “You’ve gotten into a bad habit of doing that, Benjamin.”
Understanding what I want, he gasps, “I’m sorry.”
“Are you?” Not impressed with the apology, I frown with annoyance. “I know how you can make it up to me. Don’t move.” Slowly shifting myself so I’m lying next to him with my free hand already teasing his erection, I whisper sternly, “Not a single muscle. No bucking, no twisting, no twitching, no nothing. I don’t want to see you move at all, do you understand me?”
“Yes,” he accepts in a strangled huff.
Nothing is a distraction—not the fact that it’s hard but fleshy and hotter than I was expecting, not the fact that I have absolutely no experience with this, and certainly not the fact that there’s a small voice in the back of my mind telling me there’s only one type of acceptable sex and that I’m doing it wrong. No, none of that matters. Nothing can get in-between me and my mission to hear him screaming my name.
I figure out early on that he likes when I praise him, he likes being called Benjamin instead of Ben, and although he doesn’t need eye contact to be satisfied, anytime I roll my eyes over to look at him, his jaw starts twitching in a losing battle to follow my orders not to move.
I think I like being worshiped after all. He’s close. I can hear it in his voice, but I don’t know what he’s waiting for. He adores me, so I might as well give him even more reason to adore me. I am, after all, a very generous goddess. I rest my mouth against his ear and murmur, “Good boy, Benjamin. I want you to come for me.”
Every cry of ecstasy widens my smile as he begs me not to stop. He breaks my demand not to move by once again propping himself up over me, but only so he can kiss my mouth, so I allow it. He has no idea how pathetic he sounds right now. Look at him, utterly consumed with a need for me. Weak little human thinks he can do whatever he wants. Gail was right. Men need to be reminded of their place, crushed under the sole of my boot. At this last thought, I snap out of it just as Ben collapses against me, sliding off and beside me with a sweaty slickness.
Immediately, I feel it. Like someone’s pulled the plug on a record player and all the lovely music has slowed to a halt. Seeded deep in my gut, I feel it.
Shame.
Why? What am I ashamed about? We’re married. This is literally one of the major perks of being married, right? There's nothing wrong with what we just did, right?
Am I ashamed that I’ve put our lives in danger by doing this? No, we had it under control. Right? He stuck his hand down past the waistband of my underwear but never actually took them off. We were never in any danger of getting pregnant. I'm incredibly strong willed. I mean, if he had asked me to, I absolutely would have let him pound me until he came.
And there it is. I’m dangerous, and I’ve let this go on too long.
I gather up my clothes in a frenzy to get dressed as quickly as possible.
"You're mad at me." Ben shoots up in bed, panicked. “It's because I moved, isn't it? I'm so sorry. I tried not to, I really did, it's just that. . . Cora, please, please don't leave.”
“No,” I stammer, “no, no, no, you didn’t do anything wrong. That was nice.” That was nice?! “I mean, it was more than just nice. I mean, I. . . it's not you, I just. . . I’m so sorry, but I need to go back to Hydra.”
"At 3 in the morning?"
"Your back is healed," I whisper, thinking of any and all excuses to justify wanting to leave. "You don't need me here anymore."
"WHAT?"
I can't seem to think of anything to say other than, "I'm sorry." Unable to look back to see if he’s following, I shake into my boots and practically sprint out the front door.
Sawyer is angry at me about something. Why is he shaking me? What the hell? Why the hell is he shaking me? Get off me! Wait, he doesn’t look angry, he looks worried. What is he saying? Breathe?
I open my mouth but nothing happens.
“Breathe, goddammit,” Sawyer's voice echoes in my mind.
Where am I? Hydra? When did I get back to Hydra? Suddenly, I remember how to breathe.
“Easy,” Sawyer soothes. “Easy, darlin'. There we go. Just breathe.”
Sawyer lifts a kettle off the clay stove and pours us some tea. I’m seated in the only room in his house. House is actually a generous term, considering he was given nothing more than a glorified shack. Not much to look at from the inside or outside.
He waits until I’ve taken a sip before saying, “I don’t want to leave.”
“Huh?”
“The island,” he clarifies. “When the sub comes back, I don’t want to leave the island. That’s my deal. Take it or leave it.”
“Deal? What deal? What are you talking about?”
“Listen, sister, I just damn near pulled you back from the brink of death at 4 in the damn morning. If you think I work for free, you’ve got another thing coming."
“I was having an anxiety attack. I wasn’t dying, it just felt like I was dying.” I think of something and frown at him. "What were you doing on the beach at 4 in the morning, anyway?"
"Not that it's any of your business," he says, "but this is the only time I have to myself before those damn kids start bothering me come morning. If you must know, I was reading."
"You were reading on the beach at 4am?"
“Yes, and it doesn't matter if you don't believe me because I have something you want. That is, if your babbling on the beach is to be taken seriously. And boy-howdy do I have the experience to guarantee I’m not bullshitting you in my advice.”
I’m annoyed that whatever he’s trying to tell me makes no sense. “James,” I snap, “just say whatever you’re trying to say. This time in English, please?”
“I’ll make you a deal,” he clarifies. “You let me live out the rest of my days on this island, and I’ll teach you how to seduce your husband.”
Chapter 23: Show Me Yours And I'll Show You Mine
Notes:
(See the end of the chapter for notes.)
Chapter Text
Sawyer eyes me with restrained amusement as I stomp around his house, stopping every few steps to gasp, all the muscles in my face pulled tight in a horrified expression, as I finally process what the hell just happened.
Ben’s seen me naked. We haven’t even officially had a first date yet and Ben’s already seen me naked. How in the ever-loving hell did this happen? I gasp again, reaching up to cover my chest. He saw my boobs. He kissed my boobs! Full body twitches rack through my limbs. I can’t stop freaking out. I can’t stop mumbling “oh no” in rapid succession.
“That bad, huh?” Sawyer leans back in his seat as I continue pacing the small room. “This is worse than I thought.”
“I’m not talking about this with you,” I snap.
“My mistake. Want me to go get Gail?” He belts a laugh at the look on my face. “Take a seat, Goldilocks. I’m not gonna go off gossiping about your love life. A deals a deal. . . right?”
Sawyer holds out a hand for me to shake our deal into a reality. I don’t see anything wrong with him staying here forever. He’s already noticeably softened now that the kids have taken a liking to him. He won’t tell. Besides. . . whose going to believe him over me anyway? If he ever tries to rat out our relationship, I’ll just feign ignorance. That was the original plan with Ben, right? Pretend not to like each other in public? Okay. I don’t see anything wrong with this deal.
I grab his offered hand and shake. “You’ve had almost two months to think of a real zinger, and the best you can come up with is Goldilocks? You need to step up your game.”
“I need to step up my game? I’m not the one who ran away from my poor little mortal husband because I got a case of the jitters. So,” he asks, leaning forward with a raised eyebrow, “what’d he do?”
“He didn’t do anything. It was me. I was. . . you don’t understand. I was so weird. I was so, so, so weird.” I called him a good boy?! “I said a lot of things that I can’t repeat. I said the f-word!”
Sawyer’s amused smile only intensifies as he snorts a laugh. “Oh, no. Not the f-word.”
Groaning in pain from the memory, I practically slam my head down against the table. “I can never see him again,” I huff against the wood. “I can never go back to the mainland.”
“Well, hold on, now. I thought you wanted me to help you seduce your husband, not hide from him.”
I suck in a deep breath. “It’s fine. Everything’s fine. I’ll just spend the rest of my life in the temple. He’s not allowed in the temple.”
Sawyer’s knitted brow softens. “Ah, I think I see what’s going on here. Alright, time to switch tactics.” He stands abruptly and strides towards where I’m sitting on the other side of the table. I wait for him to stop walking, but by the time he stops, he’s practically touching me. “Don’t move,” he orders, leaning in.
His body language is saying he’s going to kiss me, and I’m suddenly so afraid, I can’t move. “What are you doing?”
“You don’t get good at anything without practice,” he explains, leaning an arm against the table to support himself hovering over me. “Don’t move.”
Is he actually going to kiss me? I freeze so completely, time itself sits still. Wait, nothings happening. Sawyer doesn’t say anything, but he also doesn’t touch me. He just stands uncomfortably close. I can smell the saltwater on his skin.
I watch him waft a hand through the air, and I realize he’s reminding me to breathe. He inhales. I inhale. He exhales. I exhale.
“See?” Sawyer finally leans away from me, smiling. “Nothing bad happened. It’s a work in progress. For now. . . talk.”
I talk to him for hours. Or maybe it’s only an hour. It may actually be half an hour, I’m not sure. I don’t own a watch. Regardless, talking to Sawyer somehow makes me feel a little better about future encounters with Ben. Sawyer’s right. Practice makes perfect. I just need to learn to better control my anxiety, so I can stop running away anytime I’m overwhelmed.
“For example,” I say, “I can never get a straight answer out of him. Like, I asked him what his hobbies are and he said his favorite thing to do has to wait until he heals. Like. . . duh? He just had major spinal reconstructive surgery. All activities have to wait until he recovers.”
Sawyer stares at me like I have lobsters crawling out of my ears. “You’re not serious.”
“What?”
“It’s you, Cora. You’re the hobby.”
“I’m the hobby? That doesn’t even make any sense.”
Sawyer looks very concerned I’m not understanding him. “You asked him what he likes to do for fun. You. He likes to do—you know what? Now I’m starting to think you’re just messing with me.”
“No,” I refute, “he didn’t mean it like that. He couldn’t have meant—”
“Did he have a hard-on when he said it?”
“Ew, James.”
“What? Hard-on is too vulgar for you? And why do you keep calling me James?”
“Because that’s the name your mother gave you.”
We fall into a deep silence, and I fear I may have overstepped a boundary.
“Well?” Sawyer adds when I refuse to talk. “Was he pitching a tent or what?”
“I don’t know,” I snap back at him, embarrassed. “I couldn’t tell because he had his hands resting in his lap.”
“Bingo.” Sawyer raises a finger gun at me and fires. “He meant what he said, girlie.”
“I think I’m gonna faint.”
“Cora.” Sawyer sighs loudly and rubs his tired eyes. “Do you like this guy?”
Very much. “Yes.”
“Do you trust him?”
Probably more than I should. “Yes.”
“Then that’s all that matters. And that’s the end of tonights lesson. Now scram. I’m only gonna get a measly two hour nap in before Thyra starts trying to cover me in more shitty tattoos.”
I smile at the thought of little Thyra. Her career aspirations are to be a great tattooist, which might be one of the reasons she's taken an intense liking to Ana Lucia. Ana seems more than happy to indulge the child’s dream by allowing her to draw all over Ana’s arms and legs and face and neck with a black pen. Now, I guess she’s found Sawyer and sacrificed him to the art gods as well.
“Hey, Dr. Dolittle,” Sawyer calls at the last minute, and I turn away from the door to look at him. “I’ll give you one last piece of advice for free. Men are stupid. If you want this guy, be obvious.”
There’s a note waiting for me when I return to my bedroom.
It simply says, I’m sorry
Ben doesn’t even understand what he’s apologizing for, and it makes my stomach cramp at the thought of how confused he must be right now. I send back an olive branch in hopes of mending whatever damage I’ve already caused. It reads, I would like you to attend the wedding tomorrow as my guest.
I regret it the second Loki takes flight back to the mainland, but he doesn’t double back and return to me when I chase after him and shout for him to stop, even though I know for a fact he hears me. There’s nothing to be done for it now.
“Lady Cora, can I get your help with this string of lanterns, please?”
A powerful yawn overtakes me. “I’m so sorry,” I tell the woman, “but I didn’t sleep at all last night. The last thing I need to do is climb a ladder, fall off, and break my neck.”
Hydra is abuzz with anticipation for the final wedding day of Charlotte and Gunner. Everyone else is much more excited—if her expression is anything to go off of—than Charlotte looks right now, seated at a beautiful wooden table decorated with the finest flowers. She looks out of place surrounded by such color, considering her face is drained of any and all color.
Come on, Jane. Where are you? Stop this from happening!
A voice right behind me says, “Hello.”
I spin around and stifle a scream. “Hi.”
Ben takes note of the women nearby, who thankfully are so preoccupied with finishing their decorations that they couldn’t be bothered with him. Satisfied that we’re as inconspicuous as possible, he whispers, “Can we talk?”
“Yes,” I answer in a whisper. “But not here. Wait in my room. I’ll meet you in a few minutes. And Ben,” I add, reaching out to touch his arm, “don’t let anyone see you go in there.”
Ten minutes or so later, I work up the courage to sneak away from the festivities and head towards my empty longhouse. I slip into my bedroom at record speed, sliding the lock in place to ensure no-one accidentally walks inside while we talk.
Ben shoots up from the edge of my bed, where he’s been sitting and stewing silently in his own anxious world. “Cora?” he asks nervously. “Tell me what I did wrong, and I’ll never do it again.”
“You didn’t do anything wrong. I’m sorry.” I can’t seem to stop apologizing, as if that will solve everything. “I promise I’m not mad at you. I’m just—” We’re in my bedroom. Alone. My legs literally begin trembling with desire. I haven’t even had a chance to start talking to him in earnest, and I’m already so horny it’s frightening. We met in here to talk, but now I can’t think.
What do I do? Am I allowed to just ask him for it? Do I even want to ask for it? How do you ask for it without sounding weird?
Sex means getting pregnant. Getting pregnant means giving birth to Christopher. Which means time travel. Which means all of this will end. I can’t get pregnant. Not now. Not now that I’ve gotten to know him a little better. Not before I’ve figured out how to change the future to save him.
Aching with desire at the mere sight of him, my body gives an involuntary shiver. “I’m dealing with a lot of. . . I don’t know. Guilt?”
Ben nods at this, encouraging me to explain. “About what?”
“Religious guilt,” I clarify, but by the looks of it, he still doesn’t understand. I dart my eyes around the room and lower my voice to a distressed whisper, even though we’re the only two people here. “I’m not sure how I feel that we haven’t officially had a first date and you’ve already seen me naked. I touched your. . . and I just. . . I’m so sorry, but I couldn’t stop. I tried too, but my body just—”
Ben immediately laughs, stopping short to tell me, “I’m laughing at the situation, not you.”
“How is this funny?”
“Okay, I admit, this is probably only funny to mortals, but. . .” Ben steps closer, his eyes suddenly softening with what looks like love, and then sharpening with what looks like lust. “The fact that my favorite goddess blushes at the thought of touching me is doing some very unhealthy things to my ego.”
Rough wood brushes against my fingers. I realize all at once that my back is pressed up against the closed door, and he’s almost close enough to reach out and touch me. Almost.
“So. . . that’s it,” he questions softly, eyeing me up and down until it feels like a physical caress. “That was the problem? You were nervous?” Ben’s entire body deflates with relief when I nod. “Okay, that’s good to know. I was worried you were faking your pleasure and I was so bad at my job that you fled to spare me the bad news.”
“What? No. Definitely wasn’t faking it.” I immediately blush at his apparent excitement at the confession. It’s getting hard to stand up. Hurry up and talk to him so he can leave and free us of this torment. “Do you feel anything? Right now? Anything that you would describe as magic?”
Ben takes another step closer, and I can smell the detergent from his clothes, the scent of his skin, the cologne I’ve grown obsessed with. “Yes.”
“Me too,” I whisper, suddenly unable to project my voice. “And it just seems to be getting worse the longer we’re around each other.” Rip all my clothes off you stupid man. “I don’t think we should see each other for a little while.”
“What?” All at once, the magic severs, and I’m left with nothing but his insurmountable fear. “Why not?”
“Because I can’t be around you without. . . see? You’re doing it right now!”
Ben’s not even trying to hide the fact that he’s leaning away from me to get a better view of my breasts. “Doing what?”
I frown at him, but he’s too preoccupied to notice. “You’re staring at my chest.”
Ben acknowledges my words with a quiet laugh and an amused smile. “Yes, I am.”
“Stop.”
This seems to catch him off guard and he pauses before giving a halfhearted, “No?”
“Excuse me?” I bristle at how different he’s being to last night. Last night he was so obedient and attentive, and now he won’t leave my room when I ask? “What do you mean no?”
Ben’s expression stays the same, but I sense a flash of fear in his eyes. “Okay, I fully admit I’m ruining the mood here, but I genuinely can’t figure out what you want me to say. It seems like you’re actually angry that I’m—” Ben swallows as his eyes slowly trail up and down my body. “—looking at you, even though you’re the one undressing.”
What is he talking about? I look down and find myself bare chested, halfway done pulling off my wedding attire. I’ve been undressing this WHOLE TIME and didn’t realize it?
I turn away from him and scramble to pull my dress back on. Mortified that he’s right and I didn’t even realize I was half-naked, I yell, “This is exactly what I mean! This never used to happen before I met you. This is all your fault!”
At first I’m afraid I’ve hurt his feelings, but Ben breaks out in low laughter. “I’m sorry,” he gets out in the space between laughs, “but are you telling me I was the Goddess of Love’s sexual awakening?” Making himself comfy on my bed, he flops back onto the mattress with both arms folded behind his head. “Nobody will ever be able to tell me a damn thing after this.” Without looking over at me, he lifts a hand and points in my direction. “And that includes you.”
“Can you at least try to take this seriously?” I can’t be anywhere near him or all my anxieties get replaced with some kind of lusty magic. This is a very big problem if I can’t fight it. And right now? I can’t fight it.“This is a problem.”
“Oh, no,” he says in an overly sarcastic drawl, “whatever shall I do? Woe is me that a beautiful goddess wants my frequent attention.”
“Why do you keep saying that?”
“What?”
I clear my throat, painfully aware that I’m close to crying. “Beautiful goddess.”
“Because you are beautiful.” Ben sits up against my headboard and huffs a laugh. “Has your ego inflated so much since your rebirth that you wish us all to repeat basic truths to you all day long? I mean, I will if you want me too, I just don’t want you to be annoyed with the repetitious—”
“Stop it.”
Ben’s eyebrows scrunch in confusion. “Stop what?”
“Stop talking,” I whisper in an attempt to conceal the pain in my throat. “Just stop talking.”
“Why are you always being coy?” Humor rings through his question as he slides back off the bed and closes the gap between us. “You are without a doubt the most beautiful woman I have ever laid eyes on.”
“Then you don’t get out much.”
When Ben’s expression lights up, I realize he thinks this is a game. He thinks I’m fishing for compliments. “Quite the opposite,” he happily proclaims. “It’s only because I’ve been off-island that I can confirm you have no equal anywhere.”
“Please, stop.” I roll my eyes. “Enough already with this stupid script. You don’t think I’m beautiful, you just wanted to get laid.”
“Nobody gets to tell me what I think,” he says softly, an edge of actual anger concealed just under the surface. “I had hoped you of all people would have shown me that respect.”
There is so much I want to say. Instead, all I can do is open and close my mouth as I rethink my entire strategy. “You. . . you’re not. . . you’re being serious?” Misplaced anger mixes with sadness, leaving my stomach in shambles. I give up trying to blink away the tears. “You’re not lying to me?” Like you lied about this entire relationship?
“Lying about what?”
“What do you mean lying about what?” I still don’t believe him, so I continue to push back. “Lying about finding me attractive.”
All the tension eases from his expression. It’s obvious he’s relieved, but now he looks extremely confused. “Why wouldn’t I find you attractive?”
He’s goading you. This is all a joke, and he’s goading you so you accept his compliments. He’s only giving compliments so he can take them away later. This is all a joke to him. “Because I’m fat.”
Ben looks wildly around the empty room like he’s searching for someone to explain to him what the hell is going on. “Why are you so obsessed with that? Who cares?” He’s struggling to finish his thought. “I’m trying to tread carefully here, but you don’t seem to believe anything I say, so I’m not sure it’ll matter. Cora, I love your body because its yours. Why else would I like it?”
I want nothing more than to believe him, but my brain is literally frying at the thought that someone could care about me no matter what I looked like. If I gained weight or lost weight or gained it all back again—to have someone who genuinely didn’t care? It doesn’t compute.
That’s not reality. That’s not the world my mother lived in. That’s not the world plus-sized actresses lived in. That’s sure as hell not the world I lived in. Women in the media? That’s it!
These people literally view bodies differently because there’s nobody to tell them otherwise. No outside forces trying to shape their preferences. It’s why the women bathe so freely out in the open, where everyone can see their stretch marks and cellulite. They do it because nobody cares. They do it because as far as they’re concerned, a body is simply a vessel that keeps you alive.
I’m in literal paradise, and I can’t enjoy it because the real world still won’t leave me alone.
Ben's voice is softer than usual when he asks, "Did somebody say something to you? Is someone putting these ideas in your head?" He fixes me with another piercing stare that makes me feel like prey, and I watch as his pupils constrict into pinpricks. "Who is it?" he demands. "I'll rip their throat out with my teeth."
The speed in which Ben has shifted from loving to murderous is so sudden, I take a hurried step away from him. I'm not entirely sure what to make of Ben's expression as his eyes flit over my body and his eyebrows twitch together as he studies my reaction.
After a pause, his question is dripping with confusion. "Why are you afraid of me?"
How do I explain this in a way that won't make him more angry? "You just threatened to kill somebody."
"My job is to make you happy," he answers slowly. "If someone is making you unhappy, I need to step in."
"Okay, well. . . maybe that's a little extreme."
Ben seems genuinely confused. "How so?"
I stare at him long enough to realize he's being serious. If I give him a random name, he'd swim back to the mainland right now and stab a fork under their ribs. As my head fills with the faces of men I'd love to kill, I blink away the thought. Jesus Christ, I get ahold of one unhinged cultist and immediately start planning the downfall of every man who's ever made me miserable. "Nobody said anything to me," I tell him. "Nobody on the island, anyway."
“Interesting," Ben says into the silence. "You really were being serious about the groveling bit? Alright, let’s see.” And then he starts listing off everything he loves about me. My floral scent. My loud laugh. The way my right shoulder—and just my right shoulder—shoots up if I’m particularly impressed with someone's cooking. How often he wants to reach out and trace his finger down the peach fuzz on the side of my face.
I find myself once again entranced by him. He likes me and is attracted to me, and I don’t know what to do with this information. Ben’s still listing off things he loves and admires about me when I interrupt with a breathy, “I love you.”
He blinks at me in surprise. “What?”
Why did I say that? Do I mean it? Hell if I know. I’m not even sure what being in love is supposed to feel like. I know I like him, and I guess that’s enough. Taking a deep breath, I say it with more conviction. “I said I love you.”
I’ve never said those words before to someone, not even my parents. We were never an I love you family. My mother put all of her love into cooking, and I’m pretty sure my father was incapable of love. I’ve never told someone I love them, but even I know Ben’s reaction is not ideal.
I watch as Ben slowly sinks into a state of annoyed discomfort. With a sigh, he turns away and says, “That’s not funny.”
I’m completely thrown by his reaction. Honestly, I was expecting an emphatic I love you, too!
“Why did you have to ruin it?” Ben asks, sounding more disappointed than angry. “We were having a nice moment.”
He thinks I’m lying? “I’m not lying. Why would I lie about something like this?”
Ben’s voice is dripping with sarcasm when he says, “Oh, yes, the most beautiful creature in all of heaven and earth is in love with me. Ha, ha, ha. Who told you to say that?” A flash of real anger shines in his eyes. “Was it Thor Thorson? Please tell me it wasn’t Thor Thorson.”
A small warbling in his voice gives away that he’s not lying. He actually doesn’t believe me. Just like I don’t believe him. But I’m not lying. So, maybe there’s a chance he’s not lying either?
I frown at him and ask, “Who the hell is Thor Thorson?”
At my question, something clicks in his mind. I can only assume he’s finally realized I’m telling him the truth. As if to prove my theory correct, he asks, “You’re being serious?”
“Of course I’m being serious,” I snap angrily. “You’re the one making up wild claims that you want me.”
Ben’s left eye literally twitches.
“What?” I ask. “You’re trying to tell me you’re not a liar while calling me a liar. Do you see what’s happening here? Okay, if you could have anyone, anyone at all. On Hydra, on the mainland, anywhere. Anyone. Who would it be? And don’t lie. I can read minds.”
“If you can read minds,” he answers after a pause, “then you already know the answer.”
I take in a deep breath before continuing. “And that is?”
“I’ve already had the woman I want most.” Ben leans in close, like Sawyer did last night. “All I can ever hope to ask is if I can have her again.”
We can’t do this right now because I’m weak and I want all of you, but that means you die! Leave! Save yourself! But I’m not speaking my thoughts. Instead, I rush him at the same time he rushes me, both of us frantically trying to take each others clothes off. I basically shred the shirt off his body with a series of loud rips and reach up for the collar of my dress.
“No!” Ben cries out. “No,” he says more calmly. “Don’t rip it. This is my favorite dress.”
“Really?”
“Really.” Lifting me up off my feet, he carries me to the bed and gently lays me on it. “If anything were to happen to this dress,” he says, his words coming out in a warning hiss, “I’d be very upset.”
I end up on my back, arching my spine as a tingling chill runs from my head down to the tips of my toes. I've never wanted something more in my life. I'm so lightheaded I don't even bother to try and unzip his pants, choosing instead to channel just enough magic to rip them at the seams until they fall off. Ben trails kisses from my cheek, across my jaw, along the column of my neck, and down my sloping chest. I feel my nipples harden as soon as they’re freed, but I don’t have time to worry about what I look like before he wraps his mouth around one and sucks.
Losing control of my hands, I run my impatient fingers over his shoulders and down his back. “Ben,” I gasp. “Please . . . wait,” I say when I feel him pulling the rest of my dress off. “Wait. Just kiss me. I only want to kiss right now.”
Before I can finish my sentence, he's returned his mouth to my neck, and my pleas all turn into nothing more than a stifled moan. Ben stops kissing me long enough to catch my eye, grinning mischievously. “May I kiss you?”
I can’t help a nervous laugh from escaping. “You already are.”
“Yes, but may I kiss you. . . everywhere?”
Shivering at the thought of his tongue in places only fingers have been before, I squeeze my eyes shut and shake my head yes.
“Look at me, Cora.” We lock eyes, and I can see the same hesitation mirrored in my own. “Do you want me to stop?”
How dare you even suggest that. Trembling again at the tingle of his fingers brushing slowly up my inner thighs, I moan, “No.”
“No, what?” he whispers.
I lift my hips up off the bed so he can finish pulling my dress off, huffing my response against his lips, “I don’t want you to stop.”
Everywhere he places his mouth leaves a prickling sensation. He’s careful, gentle, caressing me like I'm made of glass. I run my fingers up his neck and through his hair and down over his shoulders. I savor the sound of his voice in my ear, murmuring sentiments that make my blush deepen.
Then, he stops and sits up.
Unable to lift my head to see what he’s doing, I stare at the ceiling of my bedroom and impatiently wait for him to touch me again. When he does, its with a firm grip on either of my ankles as he lifts my legs and spreads them.
He can see me. He can see all of me. I think of something and finally find the strength to lift my head. I didn’t shave! I didn’t shave anything! I calm slightly when I remember the women that skinny-dipped before my wedding all had body hair—some of them shaved their armpits, some of them shaved their legs, but none of them shaved their pubic hair. Okay. It’s okay. Its normal. He doesn’t look disgusted at all.
Ben never breaks eye contact when he lifts my right leg as far as I’m able and plants a kiss on my ankle first, lingering before placing another kiss right below it. Down, down, down, painstakingly slowly, until my entire body is trembling with anticipation. Just as I flop my head back into the pillow, awaiting his mouth between my legs, he stops again, only to start kissing the other ankle.
And when he finally runs his tongue over me, I beg, “Softer, please.” He immediately obliges, and I buck against him, braying like a dying animal.
I tell him what I want, what I need, and for a few moments at a time my heart breaks out in a flurry of beats that leave me babbling and begging. Heat radiates off my feverish skin as it grows damp with sweat, but I’ve stopped caring. This feels too good to be ashamed.
My heart begins to pound furiously again, my labored breathing escaping in frantic gasps, but this time it doesn't stop, and I am begging him desperately for release. I reach down and dig my fingernails into his scalp, trying my hardest to keep coherent, as an all encompassing trembling takes over. Bucking against his face, I scream the most unhinged things, half of which don’t even make any sense. I end up a sweaty mess, panting so hard I end up coughing. I can't even lift my head off the pillow.
Ben lies next to me, his arms wrapped tightly around my body, holding it against his hammering heart. I roll my head to the side to look at him, and the expression on his face says more than a million I love you's ever could.
Nothing could have prepared me for what it feels like emotionally in the aftermath. All of my fears that Ben would reject me were dismissed as soon as I shed my clothing. Being stared at as if you are the most important thing in the world did more for my libido than a thousand kisses ever could.
But the pleasure doesn’t last long before I feel it again. Shame. But this time, I feel ashamed at not offering to take care of him the way he just took care of me. Looking at him gaze upon with me with adoration is too much to handle, so I roll my head back against the pillow. “What about you?” I pant up at the ceiling.
“What about me?” he asks, and I’m suddenly painfully aware that quote was one of the last things he said to Jacob before killing him. “My mouth was preoccupied with you,” he continues. “My hands were preoccupied with me.”
We just had sex and yet I’m still embarrassed at the thought of him masturbating. “Oh,” I whisper. “Okay. Good.”
“Cora?”
I force myself to look over at him, surprised to find him staring at me with a stern seriousness. “Yes?”
“What did you mean when you said I don’t need you anymore since my back is healed?”
“I have to return to the wedding. Gail’s going to have a conniption if I don’t show up to the dance circle.” One second he’s lounging beside me, and the next moment he’s on top of me, pinning my arms down to keep me from leaving.
“You brought me in here to talk,” he says. “So, let’s talk.”
I don’t want you to talk. I want you inside me. “Okay,” I agree.
There’s a pounding on my bedroom door. “Cora?” It takes me a moment to realize the voice belongs to Alex. “Can I come in please? It’s an emergency.”
Alex heard us. She heard me screaming her dad's name a few minutes ago, and now she’s going to. . . I don’t know, disown me? I don’t want her to disown me!
"How does this keep happening to us?"
“Shh,” Ben soothes, barely audible over the sound of blood rushing in my ears. “Calm down, Cora. Let me think of something.”
“Put your clothes back on,” I suggest in a whisper that matches the volume of his own.
“I can’t,” Ben hisses in panic. “You tore them apart.” His eyes shift around as he thinks. “Is there no other way out of this room?”
“No,” I answer in a hushed yet high-pitched whine.
“Cora?” Alex yells. “I really need to talk to you. Can you please open the door?”
“Hide in my wardrobe.” I push his naked body off me and hop off the bed. But when I try to re-dress myself, I’m shaking so much my fingers won’t cooperate. I feel Ben behind me, working at record speed to get everything tied shut correctly. As soon as I’m dressed, he gathers up the tattered remains of his clothing off the floor and dashes to my wardrobe, shutting himself safely inside.
“I’m coming!” I call loudly to Alex, furiously blushing at the choice of words. “Be right there!” One look at myself in the mirror and I panic all over again. My hair is an absolute mess from thrashing around in the bedsheets, but I don’t have time to fix it. I’m so anxious I start randomly patting at my gown, as if this will keep me from vomiting.
I have absolutely no idea what she wants, or what I’m going to say, and I wish I had more time to think. But I’m out of time.
I head to the door.
Notes:
Thank y'all for your kudos and reviews! You have given me the creative sustenance needed to provide a double chapter upload *as a treat!*
Next few chapters will ease up on the smut. Or maybe they won't? Sue me.
Chapter 24: Consensual Hex
Notes:
(See the end of the chapter for notes.)
Chapter Text
Despite her tear-stained face, the first thing out of Alex’s mouth when I open the door is, “Why are you glowing?”
Why am I glowing? What’s a good answer? “Oh, that just happens sometimes.” Good job, dumbass.
My plan was to open the door just enough to slip outside so we can talk, but she’s so much thinner than I am that she has no problem sneaking by me before I have the chance to stop her.
“It’s dad.” There’s more she wants to say, but she cuts herself off with another bout of sobs.
She knows. It’s all over. She knows and she’s here to demand an explanation.
“He’s missing,” she finishes, and now I’m even more confused. “I asked Tom to check on him today since you'll be at the wedding, and he just wrote to me that dads not home. His wheelchair is by his bed, but nobody on the mainland has seen him all day.”
Alex is talking so fast that it takes a few tries before she’s calm enough to listen to the almost-true excuse I’ve just formulated in my head. “Oh, Alex,” I soothe, “I’m so sorry. This is my fault. I should have told you.” I wipe away the hair clinging to the wet skin of her cheeks. “He’s healed! My idea worked, thank you very much. Being in the same house sped up the healing process way more than I had expected it to.” I smile when she stops crying. “I’m sure he just wondered off without telling anyone. I mean, can you blame him? One second you’re in a wheelchair and the next moment you’re nimble enough to evade the notice of an entire community.” I pull her back into a hug, and instead of feeling uncomfortable, I feel happy that I can bring her comfort. “Oh, sweetheart, don’t cry.”
“I’m sorry.”
“Don’t apologize for caring about your family,” I whisper into her hair. “You’ve been worried since his operation, haven’t you? I promised I wasn’t going to let him die.”
Alex nods, but something else has caught her attention. Reaching down, she picks up something off the floor and hands it to me. “What’s this?”
I accept the small shredded remains of what was once Ben’s shirt and over-exaggerate my annoyance to the point that I start worrying I’m acting suspicious. Thankfully, all Alex does is smile when I say, “Once upon a time this was a shirt, if you can believe it. That would be Fenrir’s doing. Where do you think he and Pumba have been this past week? I got sick of them teething on my clothes, so I sent them both to stay with Jane so Eddard can train them to. . . you know. . . not ruin every decent dress I own?”
All the tension in my body starts to ease when she laughs. Alex sniffs, wipes her eyes, and says, “Do you think Jane’s going to crash the wedding?”
I immediately take the opportunity to leave this room. “I don’t know, but I’m not about to miss it. Let’s get out of here.”
Alex and I step outside and head down the path to the beach when suddenly I hear a man shouting angrily within the jungle. Oh great. What is it this time? “Alex,” I instruct, “you go on ahead. I’ll meet you at the beach. Gotta deal with this first.”
I stop running when I see it’s just Sawyer and Peregrine playing cards in the grass. I don’t know the rules of poker, so I just stand nearby and watch the spectacle.
“What’ll it be, kid? You fold’n?”
“Never!” Peregrine tilts her head dramatically from one side to the other. “Wait, folding is bad, right?”
Sawyer sighs, most likely having already repeated this rule many times. “Not if you’re losing.”
“Oh, good. Then I do not fold because I’m not losing.”
“Yeah? We’ll see about that. You discarding any cards this turn?”
“Hmm. Okay, yeah. I discard these two.”
Sawyer takes the discarded cards and adds them to the bottom of the pile. I roll my eyes. Is he really trying to con a child? Maybe I did make a mistake bringing him here.
Sawyer shuffles the cards so much you’d think his life depended on Peregrine losing this round. Just as soon as it looks like he’s stopped shuffling, he straightens the cards in a stack and begins shuffling all over again.
“Shuffle all you like,” Peregrine taunts. “You’re still going to lose, old man.”
“Would you stop calling me that?”
Eventually, Sawyer asks her to show her cards. Peregrine tosses them down and asks if she won. It’s difficult not to laugh and give away my position when Sawyer’s eyes bulge out of his face at the fact that a small child who doesn’t even understand the rules of poker just beat him again on sheer luck alone.
Peregrine looks confused. “Why didn’t you just cheat?”
Sawyer throws his cards down, yelling with angry exhaustion, “I have been cheating!”
“Ah-ha!” Peregrine hops up and points a finger in his face. “I knew it! You’re a cheat! I’m gonna report you to the Valkyries and then they’re gonna—“
“Okay, fine,” he snaps. “Just take it and leave me alone.”
And then Sawyer pulls out a handgun and hands it to an eight year old child.
“WHAT ARE YOU DOING?” I burst out of the trees, screaming at the both of them. “Give me that!” Rushing forward, I snatch the handgun out of Peregrine’s tight grip—completely ignoring her protests—and hold it away from me like a piece of stinking meat. “Have you completely lost your mind?”
“It’s okay, first mate. I’ve shot guns before.”
Never averting my glare from Sawyer’s direction, I tell her, “That’s not the point, Peregrine. This is a dangerous weapon that children shouldn’t be playing with, and James knows that. You could have accidentally shot yourself.”
“No,” she refutes with an angry stomp of her feet. “No, no, no, no! Why is father the only one who ever believed me? How many times do I have to tell you people! I’M A LUCK GOD!”
I put the gun down in the dirt and try to process Peregrine’s tantrum logically, the way Ben would. Peregrine was obviously close to her father, but I have no idea what it’s like to mourn a loving father. I can’t even begin to comprehend her grief. When I spoke to Ragnar, he didn’t call her Peregrine. He called her Pippin. Maybe if she won’t listen to me, she’ll listen to him.
I decide to change tactics and sink to one knee, so she’s forced to look directly into my eyes. “Who are you trying to prove that to, Pippin? You don’t need to put yourself in danger to prove you’re a luck god. I already believe you.” This surprises her, and her disbelief makes me sad. I cradle her reddened, freckled face in my hands, wiping away fresh tears. “How am I supposed to dedicate my life to a captain if she gets herself killed trying to prove she’s a captain?”
Peregrine never looked so young as when she weeps. Tears stream down her face as she rushes forward for comfort. I hold her as tight as she needs, the way it would have comforted me as a child. Not too tight to incite fight or flight, but not too loose as to seem fake.
I wait until she pulls away first before gently tucking the gun into my satchel and whirling around to show Sawyer just how serious I am. “You ever do something like this again, I’ll kill you. Do you understand me?”
“Oh, come on,” he complains. “What’s the big deal? She wanted a gun. I’ve seen literal toddlers running around with axes. Everyone here has a gun—”
Magic surges just beneath my skin when I interrupt him with, “Do you understand me?”
“Cora, the damn thing isn’t even loaded—”
“Do you understand me?”
Something shifts in his expression that makes it feel like he finally comprehends how angry I truly am. Instead of trying to further explain his piss-poor reasoning, he says, “Yeah, I understand you.”
What would possess him to even consider doing something so stupid? I brought him here because a huge turning point for his character was being forced to watch over Arron. But although he’s made a lot of improvement from the completely anti-social asshole he was on day one of the crash, he’s still not where I’d like him to be. What’s missing?
It finally dawns on me. Kate. He needs to be around Kate for the rest of his development to click. She humanized him just as much as Arron did. “I’ve decided your punishment, James. You’re going to be working the orchards from now on. I’ll find someone else to help Christopher with the fish.”
Sawyer looks a little confused but very relieved that his punishment amounts to hanging around women all day tilling the earth and picking produce to eat. “Sure,” he agrees hesitantly. “You got it, Princess.”
Peregrine tugs on my sleeve and whispers in my ear when I kneel down again.
“It seems the captain is pulling rank on me and tacking on one more punishment. She has ordered your undying loyalty effective immediately.” I salute him. “Welcome to the crew, sailor.”
I’m only a few feet from dropping off Peregrine at her house on the far side of the island when someone appears out of thin air and falls in step beside me.
“I’m so glad you didn’t turn out to be boring,” Maya quips with a sly smirk. “I don’t know if I could find it within myself to worship a boring goddess.”
I don’t know what to say, so I laugh.
“I mean, if he were just ugly,” Maya continues, “I’d be disappointed. But fucking your own murderer who also happens to be ugly? Now that is interesting.”
I can’t help myself. I panic and turn to fix her with frightened eyes.
Maya gasps over dramatically. “I knew it!” Leaning all her weight to one side, she rests a hand against her jutted hip. “To be fair,” she deadpans, “I’m fucking his ugly one-eyed lackey, so who am I to talk?”
I laugh, grateful for the release. “You’re sleeping with Mikhail?”
She shrugs. “What can I say? I like ugly men just as much as you do.”
“Ben’s not ugly,” I argue.
“To you,” she adds. “If we were to take a poll, I’m not sure you’d like the other ladies opinions.” Maya smirks as I try to figure out what emotion I’m feeling so I can correctly display the right expression. “Do you find Mikhail attractive?”
I’m not prepared for this question and end up revealing my true disgust. “Oh,” I say, embarrassed. “I see your point. I’m sorry.”
Maya roars with laughter. “I’m old, Cora, not dead. My husband is dead, and I am not. Why should I act like I am? At my age, I’ll see him again soon enough. Until then,” she adds with a mischievous twinkle in her eyes, “I’m going to do whoever it is that strikes my fancy.”
I sneak a cautious glance at her out of the corner of my eye, but she’s all smiles as we continue walking. I’ve met Maya a few times already, one of which was right before my wedding when everyone decided to skinny-dip. She’s about Gail’s age, but she’s shorter and stockier than Gail. Maya’s more like me, and I can’t help but count that in her favor. “You’re not going to tell anyone about Ben and I, are you?”
“Am I to assume the reason why you’re glowing is because he’s good in bed?”
“Yes.” I think so? I wouldn’t know.
“No shit?” Maya raises her eyebrows. “Well, how about that. And no, Cora. I wouldn’t dream of ruining whatever game you’re playing. Where’s the fun in that? Speaking of fun. . .” She knocks me gently in the side, still smiling. “What has that poor boy tried on you so far? Has he used his hands? Oh, don’t look so embarrassed. It’s just sex. What is there to be embarrassed about?”
Too shy to verbally answer, I nod.
“Has he used his mouth?”
I nod again.
“Please tell me he didn’t try to eat you like a sandwich.”
I can’t help it any longer and burst into loud laughter, quickly bringing my hands up to cover my burning face. “Yeah, he kinda did.”
“Why do men always think we’re goddamn sandwiches?" Maya flops her head back and sighs with disgust up at the sky. "We’re ice cream, for the love of Odin.”
I can’t seem to stop laughing. “Ice cream?”
“You need a nimble tongue to make sure it doesn’t drip all over your hands. Who bites into ice cream?” she asks with another affronted frown. “Nobody worth letting between your legs, that’s who.”
Ben didn’t bite me, thank God, but I get what she’s saying. “Huh. I never thought about it that way.”
“Oh, how I love talking to you.” Maya loops her arm through mine, both of us still laughing as she guides us back down the trail.
It’s nice to be seated at a random table and not on a stage at the front of the party. That spot, unfortunately, belongs to a miserable Charlotte and an ecstatic Gunnar.
I’ve only been to two weddings here, but even I know the vibes tonight are abnormal. There’s a nervous energy among the partygoers that makes me fidget. “Why does everyone seem on edge?” I ask Maya.
“You think Jane was given the position of sheriff on a whim? She’s one of the more powerful witches among us.” Maya waggles her eyebrows. “We’re all waiting for the fight to begin.”
“You really think Jane’s going to show up?”
“That poor child is stubborn, not stupid. Jane won’t let her beloved marry another.” Maya starts laughing under her breath and stands up from her seat. “Look, my lady. It’s starting.”
I turn to look at what she’s talking about and find Jane leaping out of a canoe before it’s even finished docking on the beach. Every attendee falls silent as Jane—dressed head to toe in what I can only assume is traditional warrior attire—storms the beach and makes a beeline for Charlotte’s table. As she passes through the crowd, I note the intricate way her face is painted and finally catch a glimpse of the head tattoo Charlotte mentioned. Jane’s shaved half her hair off to proudly display detailed artwork of a dolphin.
Jane approaches the couple and collapses to her knees. You could hear a pin drop in the silence that follows. Without warning, Jane speaks, and I cannot understand what she’s saying. Whatever it is, Charlotte doesn’t look too impressed because she’s not responding. Jane’s voice gets more hoarse the longer Charlotte continues to ignore her. Finally, Charlotte speaks. But even though I can’t understand what she’s saying, I still understand enough through her tone alone.
Maya makes a sad gasping sound and brings a hand up to her chest at whatever it is they’re saying now. I’ve never been so annoyed to not speak Old Norse fluently. Jane must have just proposed, and Charlotte must have just accepted because the two of them passionately embrace and the crowd happily applauds. I am so confused.
“My lady, this isn’t fair!” Gunnar rushes towards me, breathless. “Freyja, do something! Jane is stealing my bride! This is illegal!”
Maya is up and out of her seat at record speed. “Everyone, run! Move!”
I’m not sure what she’s talking about until I see Jane approaching. Magic crackles dangerously all around her, and then she opens her mouth and a thick stream of pure fire shoots directly at the spot Gunnar was standing before he leapt out of the way. The force of the flame is so strong, it leaves a deep smoldering indent in the ground.
“You can’t do this!” A new voice rings out, and the giddy crowd falls silent again. “Charlotte, sweetheart, be reasonable. You’re already married to Gunnar, like we talked about. It is illegal to marry another.”
Jane shields Charlotte behind her like someone is about to rip her away. Whoever this woman is, she must be important because Jane makes no attempt to spit fire at her.
“Who is that?” I whisper to Maya.
“Charlotte’s mother,” Maya answers disdainfully. “And an eternal pain in our asses.”
Did she reject Jane’s engagement proposal on the basis that she’s a woman? Is this about wanting grandchildren, or is she just baseline homophobic? She’s caused nothing but pain and suffering for her own daughter for over a decade simply because she wanted grandchildren? She kept these two apart because she can only think about her own wants and desires. She’s wasted enough of both their lives. Enough is enough.
“Well,” I yell loudly into the silence. Suddenly, a hundred or so eyes are on me while I struggle to look unbothered by that fact. “Then I guess they’re in luck that the Goddess of Love has the power to make or break relationships.” Turning in the direction of Jane and Charlotte, I smile at their fearful—now hopeful—embrace. “I herby announce your marriage to Gunnar annulled, and your marriage to each other. . . um, official.” I finish with a wave of my hand for good measure. “Does anyone have a problem with that?” I sigh. “Does anyone other than Charlotte’s mom have a problem with that? No? Then by the power invested in me, go forth and be happy!”
Jane easily looks ten years younger when she’s not scowling. I catch her dark eyes long enough for her to mouth thank you. Satisfied no one else is going to object to the annulment, Jane easily slings a laughing Charlotte over one shoulder, carries her across the beach to the boat she arrived in, and paddles the both of them away from Hydra.
Maya claps once into the stunned silence that follows and yells, “Who wants cake?” Turning to look at me, she says, “What are you still doing here?”
I laugh and wave a hand at the crowd as the party swings back into full force and someone breaks out the alcohol. “I mean. . . there’s still a party. I’m here for the party?”
“That’s a shame,” she whispers conspiratorially. “Considering I was just about to start spreading the word that our lady is exhausted and absolutely is not to be disturbed for the remainder of the night.” With a wink, Maya disappears into the crowd.
“Jane breathed fire?” Ben looks intensely disappointed. “Damn. I always miss it.”
Ben and I sit on my bed—me dressed, him completely naked—as we eat the plates of food I snagged from the party and I tell him all the details about what’s happened today. Should I tell him about Sawyer and Pippin? I decide it might be best not to open up that can of worms, at least for now. “Want a gun?”
“What are you doing with a gun?”
“Hopefully giving it to you. It’s in my satchel, and I don’t want it.”
“Whose is it?” Ben reaches for more of the wedding leftovers while I try to pretend like I’m not ogling his bare chest. “Guns are all carefully accounted for here, so it belongs to someone.”
Do you have any idea how badly I want to lick the salt off your skin? I shrug and tear my eyes away from the dark hair on his forearms. “Found it on the ground.”
Ben starts mumbling something about the carelessness of so-and-so. Halfway through an angry tirade, he looks over at me and I feel his mood shift from angry annoyance to confusion and, finally, lust—more than evident in the movement under the sheet he’s draped over his groin.
Oh, for God’s sake. “Ben,” I sigh in exhaustion. “What are you doing?”
He doesn’t pick up on my disinterested tone. If anything, my words only seem to deepen his attraction. “I haven’t quite decided on the details yet.” All within the same quick movement, he pulls the sheet off himself and sits up on his knees. “Although, twice in one night? I think I rather enjoy when you’re needy.”
Rolling off the bed, I take a few hurried steps away from him, but he thankfully doesn’t pursue.
Ben smiles lazily as I back away towards my desk. “Am I supposed to chase you? No? Are you sure? Alright.” Instead of looking apologetic for making me uncomfortable, he lounges provocatively against the mattress. “You mean to tell me that you aren’t even a little interested in me just lying here, completely exposed, just waiting for an immaculate goddess to come strolling by and—”
“No.”
He sits up and asks, “Really?”
“Yes,” I snap. “Can you please cover yourself?”
Ben knits his brow in thought and makes no move to cover his erection. "Are you. . . sorry, to clarify, this isn't some kind of goddess game?"
Damn, just how strong is my magic? "No! Can you please cover yourself?"
“Oh,” he says and pulls the blanket back over his lap. “You’re being serious. I’m sorry. Sometimes it’s difficult to tell the difference.” All the mischief in his eyes turns to confusion. “So. . . you're not coming onto me right now?”
“No!”
Ben tries not to look hurt when he says, “Cora, you’re going to give me an ulcer.”
I look down and find my hands provocatively caressing both of my exposed breasts.
“Alright, listen,” he seethes as soon as I tug my dress back on. “This is ridiculous. We can pull ourselves together and resist this for one measly night.” Ben pauses to breathe, and I’m not sure if he’s trying to convince me or himself when he says, “We are not animals, Cora. We can—” But it’s too late. His fatal mistake was saying my name out loud, like a spell. Immediately, he snaps into a heavy lidded daze, pushes off the bed, and approaches like a lovesick zombie.
So I reach behind me, grab a cup of water off my desk, and splash it in his face.
Ben blinks out of his stupor and says, “Thank you.”
“You’re welcome.”
As if just now realizing what’s happened, Ben finches to cover himself with his hands. “At the risk of sounding rude, might I suggest I sleep elsewhere tonight?”
Pain, right below my ribs. It spreads down into my stomach and makes me sick at the idea of him leaving. I don’t want him to leave, but he’s right. It’s for the best. “You can stay here until everyone falls asleep. I’ll keep scouting the beach and will let you know when you can return to your boat.”
“How long do you think that will be?”
I plop down at the edge of my bed and sigh. “A while. I mean, the sun just set a few minutes ago, and even though the wedding is cancelled. . . well, try telling that to my people. They’re partying anyway.”
“So, all night then? In that case, I was thinking.” Ben doesn’t look at me, which is sign number one that he’s nervous. “Maybe we could try something. While we wait.”
“Something like what?” I don’t mean to sound suspicious, but, I mean, he sounds suspicious. “I already said I don’t want to have sex—”
“No, not sex. They said it was different.” He pauses and finally looks at me, like he’s worried he’s said too much. “Our wives are off limits,” he says quickly, and I can tell he’s more anxious than usual because he’s not making much sense. “What I mean is,” he attempts to clarify, “is we don’t talk about our wives. To each other. Teammate to teammate or otherwise. We just don’t.” He’s getting frustrated that his attempts to explain himself seem like rambling, so he takes a moment to compose himself. “Team Bear doesn’t talk about our wives to each other any more than we would talk about our wives to—” He pauses, snarling. “—Team Falcon.”
I nod even though I have no idea where this is supposed to be going. “Okay.”
“What I mean to say is. . . please don’t be mad at them. They were only taking pity on me by trying to help.”
“Mad at who? Who are we even talking about?”
“Sorry, I’m just. . .” Ben takes another moment to compose himself. “My team let me know about something that married couples do. Sometimes. But only if you’re interested, obviously.”
“Ben?” I watch him anxiously fidget his fingers against the bedsheets. “You’re actually starting to scare me. What are you about to suggest we try?”
He blurts out the suggestion with a rushed, “May I share my memories with you?”
Huh? I can’t help but smile at how weird and adorable the question is. “That’s it? Of course you can. I love talking to you.”
“No,” he refutes, looking even more anxious, "it’s different than talking. You have to go into my mind.”
“Go into your mind?” It makes me sad when he flinches at my tone because I’m not angry, I’m just confused. “I mean, yes. I’ll do it. I just don’t know how.”
“They said it’s like a feeling.” Ben flits his worried eyes down to the bedsheets and then over at the door. “I’m afraid I don’t know much else about it.”
The Bears, however minimal their advice, were correct. It is a feeling. A feeling I can reach out and take hold of. When I do, the air momentarily gets sucked from my lungs, and then I’m standing in a dark abyss. Just Ben and I standing in a dark abyss.
“Uh. . . hi.” I offer up a wave. “What’s with all the doors?”
“They’re my memories.” Ben waves a hand around the otherwise dark expanse. “Pick whichever one you’d like. My life’s an open door. For you,” he clarifies with a wink.
“Are you sure you’re okay with this? What if I see something embarrassing?”
“Are you going to laugh at me?”
“No.”
“Problem solved. Now, pick a door. Any door.”
It’s impossible to choose because I want to see what’s behind all of them. But that would be rude to just start flinging open doors, right? Floating up only a few stories high, I knock on the first door to the right, and it opens.
I step into Ben’s living room. Or, rather, into the long expanse in-between his living room and kitchen. “When was this?” I ask, but I figure out the answer almost immediately.
A different Ben—the Ben of a few months ago—opens the front door, pauses on the threshold, has an entire war with himself inside his head, and then forces his face into an expression of blankness before stepping back outside to ask, “Would you like to come in?”
I hear my own voice out on the porch say, “No, thank you. The fresh air is nice.”
Ben nods curtly and then steps fully inside and shuts the door behind him. As soon as a sharp snap signifies it’s closed, Ben’s expression twists into what looks like mortification. “Would you like to come in?” he whisper-mocks himself and proceeds to have a silent meltdown—dragging both hands down his tired face—before taking a steadying breath and rushing to the fridge. You’d think slicing cake was rocket science by the incredibly careful way he cuts and plates the tiramisu.
“Aww.” I nudge him in the side, and he finally looks down at me. “I didn’t know you were nervous.”
“I was terrified.”
“That’s a strong word.” I snort. “This was more terrifying than fighting Erik?”
“Infinitely more terrifying. Hey,” he complains with what I hope is a teasing tone. “You said you wouldn’t laugh at me.”
“I’m not laughing at you. I’m laughing at the fact that you’re being so sweet and thoughtful and it’s all going to go to waste because my cake is about to be eaten almost entirely by a raccoon.” I wait for the both of us to stop laughing before I say, “I think it’s really admirable how much preciseness you put into your food.”
Something in his eyes tells me his response is unfiltered. “Really?”
“Absolutely.” I smile at his pleased expression. “It’s so weird seeing this from another perspective. I was fully convinced you hated me. I mean, see?” I walk through the front door like mist and point at where he’s sitting ridged and frowning in the porch chair beside me. “You just snapped at me.”
“No, I very politely asked you to warn me if you’re about to pass out. The last thing I wanted was for you to collapse faster than I could catch you and chip a tooth. Or worse,” he adds irritably. “I apologize if I seemed a little abrasive. I was running on no sleep. My reflexes were not what they should have been, and that worried me.”
A warmth blooms in my chest, but it never travels between my legs. It simply sits behind my ribs and makes me happy. Watching us eat cake makes me smile. Both of us were entirely unsure of what to do or say to each other, and now I’m literally inside his mind. I want him to keep talking to me, so I say, “That cake was delicious. I mean, everything you cook is delicious. How did you learn to cook so well?”
For some reason, he can only seem to look down at me out of the corner of his eye. “I studied for a number of years at Le Cordon Bleu in Paris.”
“Wait, what? Like. . . the Cordon Bleu?”
“Among a handful of other schools,” he adds, waving the words away with a hand like they’re nothing. “But I spent the most time there, yes.”
“How have you just been sitting on that information?” I get excited and bring my hands up to cradle my face. “Why did you not introduce yourself as Benjamin Linus: he who has trained within the culinary arts in France? I would have totally followed you into your house if you’d introduced yourself like that.”
Ben looks both embarrassed and pleased. It’s only when he can’t seem to keep any eye contact with me that I realize he finally trusts me enough to express when he’s shy.
“Can I see? Oh, please? Show me some memories of your time in France.” I grab hold of his hand because he seems to love holding my hand. I don’t care if that’s considered cheating in whatever game we’re playing. I really want to see France. “Please?” I coo affectionately. “I’ve always wanted to go to Paris. Show me what life was like in school.”
“Yes, anything you want.” Ben’s grip on my hand tightens as he flies us to another door. “Here’s one of the more pleasant memories.”
I knock and the door opens into a hot, steaming kitchen. I waste no time finding younger Ben hard at work on a dish, and my mouth falls open. “Wow. You were really handsome.”
Ben’s already expressive eyes widen. “Were?”
“No,” I laugh, mortified. “No, that’s not what I meant. You’re equally handsome now. You’re just. . . differently handsome.”
“Differently handsome?” I’d be more worried that I’ve actually hurt his feelings if he wasn’t laughing. “That’s just ugly repackaged.”
“No, I mean—” I wave my hands at younger him mincing a pile of garlic. “You’re just younger here. It’s a completely different kind of handsome.”
“Less wrinkles,” he says. “More hair.”
“I like your wrinkles. It wouldn’t be your face without them.” I take hold of his hand again and marvel at how strange it feels to control a man completely with just a smile. Is this what flirting is? “Can you show me more of France?”
“Yes, of course.” I never thought I’d see Ben Linus of all people become a golden retriever husband, but there has never been a man happier to cart me around and show me every tiny thing I ask for.
Louvre? Check. Mona Lisa? I didn’t have to wait in line! Eiffel Tower? Obviously.
I step through another door and immediately bring both hands up to cover my ears. It’s dark and loud and—from the looks of it—very obviously the 1980’s. People crush together, smoking, drinking, and desperately trying to seem too cool to be within 20 feet of this place. I wander around the smoky nightclub while Blue Monday blasts on the speakers overhead. I try not to think about how many people over the years have suffered seizures from these aggressive strobe lights.
From across the dance floor, I spot younger Ben huddled against a wall. I almost don’t recognize him through all the fog machines and flashes of light. As I get closer, it’s easier to notice how uncomfortable he is this close to so many people. Every time someone bumps into him, his body stiffens even more than it already is.
“Oh,” Ben says, disappointed. “I remember this night. Maybe we should pick another one?”
“Are you here by yourself?”
“Gail used to force me to come to these places so I could observe what it means to seduce out in the wild.”
Ben looks ashamed at the sight of his younger self, but I don’t want him to be ashamed because I understand. I try to shape my face into an expression of sympathy and yell, “Don’t you just hate it?”
“Hate what?”
“People touching you.”
He looks surprised. “Yes, actually.”
Relief rushes through me at the thought that someone else understands. “Me too. I don’t know how to describe it. It just feels wrong.” I hold up my hands and yell, “Not you, obviously! Not people I trust with my life like you or Alex or little kids, but like. . . adults I don’t know? Why are people always trying to hug me? It’s disgusting. Like. . . do most people seriously not comprehend personal space?”
He’s nodding along in agreement in a way that excites me.
“Which really sucks,” I continue, “because my family. . . I don’t know. Nevermind.”
Ben reaches out and touches my arm, like he’s afraid I’m going to run off. “What? What were you going to say?”
“It’s just. . .” It’s just that I don’t know if I was born this way or if I was molded into this through a love-deprived touch-starved childhood, and the not knowing part makes me grieve because I’m just now realizing I have no idea who I am if my siblings don’t exist. “It’s just. . .” I’ve always felt like I didn’t belong to my Mediterranean heritage because it’s a culture built on physical affection—cheek kisses and tight embraces and hands against your face and pats against your back. All things that people claim are comforting but have always brought me nothing but nausea.
I’m not sure if Ben can hear my thoughts, or if he just innately understands, but his contact against my arm shifts down until he’s laced his fingers through mine. “Do you want to dance?” Ben waves his free hand through the nearest partygoer, and his body passes through them like mist. “We can finally see what the big deal is without anyone touching us.”
The absolute last thing I want to do right now is dance, but I find myself squeezing his hand in return, like I’m the one afraid of him running off. “I’ve never really been one for clubbing. I don’t understand how you’re supposed to dance at these kinds of places.”
“How would you dance?”
“What?” I yell, not because I can’t hear him, but because I’m embarrassed to answer the question and have resorted to stalling for any spare seconds I can get.
“I don't care what everyone else is doing,” he yells loudly over the noise, flashing me one of his rare smiles again. Whether or not he knows I’m stalling for time is unknown. “How would you dance?”
“I. . .” I cough a laugh. “Honestly? I usually just stand by the bar because I’m on guard duty.”
It’s so rare to see him genuinely confused and comfortable enough to reveal emotion in his expression. “Guard duty?”
“Yeah, like. . . the designated driver?” I’m suddenly mortified at how insanely uncool this all sounds, but I can’t seem to stop talking because it feels so good to have someone listen to me. “My job was to make sure everyone got home safe, so I’d usually stand at the bar so I could have a clear view of my friends.”
“That doesn’t sound like any fun.” Ben waves away the thought when I start to shrink in shame. “Doesn’t matter. Would you like to dance with me now?”
“Now? But. . . but what about all these people?” Suddenly, being honest isn’t difficult. “I don’t like the idea of all these people judging me.”
“This is just a memory. None of these people can see you.”
“You can see me.”
All the tension in his face relaxes when he smiles, and I start to rethink why I’m feeling embarrassed.
“But seriously,” I yell, laughing for no other reason that I’m ashamed by my inability to figure out how to flirt. It felt so easy a few minutes ago. “I don’t know how to dance.”
“Cora,” he says dismissively. “Everyone knows how to dance. It’s as innate as breathing.”
“Not to me it isn’t.” All these people blur in and out of focus. Out of nowhere, I say, “You’re right. This is stupid. They can’t even see us, so who cares? Just promise you won’t—” I cut myself off and turn to face him. “You can’t laugh at me.”
“I would never laugh at you.”
Surprisingly, I decide to believe him. Even more surprising is the intense relief that comes with trusting him. Trust feels wonderful beyond words. Both my arms spread out and I spin around once, laughing at how ridiculous this all is.
I actually can’t dance, so I decide my mission is to make him laugh by whatever means possible.
Nothing is held back. I pull out all the tried and true novelties like the lawnmower and the shopping cart and a bunch of random movement that can be summed up as flailing. I stare at him in confusion when he start mimicking my every move. No, you’re not supposed to copy me, you’re supposed to laugh! But he promised not to laugh, and he’s keeping his word.
After I inevitably run out of dance moves in a failed attempt to make him laugh, I stand motionless in the middle of the dance floor. That’s when I notice he’s missing, only for him to reappear from out of the crowd like a panther. Each flash illuminates the room just long enough to be able to tell he’s approaching.
All the warmth behind my ribs finally finds its way down south, and I twitch to try and stop from thinking about how much I want him to push me up against a wall.
I decide to stifle every complicated emotion roiling inside me and reach out to grab his hands, spinning us around and around and around. Our hold on each other is tight, but in the end it’s no match for my sweaty fingers. With a surprised shriek, I go flying backwards and crash into a wall, crumpling into a pile on the floor. By the time Ben reaches me to help me stand, I’m laughing so hard I’m crying. Or maybe I’m just crying. I can’t tell.
“I’m so sorry,” he apologizes, flitting his hands over random parts of my body like he’s unsure what to do. “Are you hurt?”
“No, I’m okay. Really, I’m fine. Just. . .” I wipe my eyes and smile to show him I’m not lying. “That was actually kinda fun.”
“Are you sure you’re okay?”
“Never better,” I get out in-between laughter.
Ben twitches an eyebrow up—a sign he doesn’t believe me, but he’s going to concede anyway. “How about we ditch this place and go watch one of your memories?”
He wants to get to know me better? I try not to look too desperate when I answer with an eager, “Okay!”
Ben pulls me up off the floor with one arm, and I end up stumbling forward against him. His smile is small but enthusiastic when he brings his hands up, but he pauses before touching my forehead. “May I come in?”
I literally feel as happy as I did at my wedding. “Yes,” I say.
A horrified scream rips from my throat as the music stops, the club disappears into darkness, and Ben materializes right in front of me in the sanctity of my own mind. I take a few hurried steps away from him. Although, by the time I stop screaming and right myself, it feels like there’s an expansive gulf between us because he’s also taken many hurried steps backwards.
Every attempt to slow my breathing fails, so I decide to just pant my question. “How did you get in here?!”
Ben looks as if I’ve just made a bomb threat. “You let me in,” he says low and gentle, the way I talk to mice. “I asked if I could come in, and you said yes.”
I did? Oh shit, I did. “Oh, right. Um. . . I’m sorry. I. . . sorry. Do. . . do you —“
“No,” he counters, still looking equal parts sad and terrified. “I’ve clearly pushed things, and I apologize for that. I’m going to go.”
I feel him leave completely. When I open my eyes, we’re kneeling on my bed. Both of my hands are pressed against his forehead and both of his hands are cradling the back of my neck. Our heads are pressed together in the most comforting embrace I’ve ever experienced.
Suddenly, the comfort severs because Ben has pulled away.
Ben lies beside me, but it took a lot of convincing to get him here. Neither of us are touching, or even looking at each other. Instead, we lay on our backs and say what we’d like to say up at the ceiling instead.
“It’s not that I don’t want to be vulnerable to you, it’s just. . . there’s a lot of things in my brain I don’t want you to see.”
“Cora, I love you, but that is quite literally you not wanting to be vulnerable, so the first part of your sentence doesn’t make any sense.”
In my frustration, I blurt out the truth. “I don’t want you to laugh at me.”
“Laugh at what? Moments of you being uncomfortable? Why would I find that funny?” He shakes his head, looking exasperated. “It’s almost as if you’ve forgotten we were just trapped within a memory of me in my twenties crying alone in the corner of a nightclub. I don’t think it gets anymore embarrassing than that. You didn’t laugh at me.”
“Because it wasn’t funny.”
“Then why do you think I would ever laugh at you? Listen, forget about it,” he relents kindly. “You can share anything and everything with me when you’re ready. This isn’t a quid pro quo. I like sharing my memories with you. Do you want to go back to Paris? There’s a bookstore I think you’d love. Let’s go.”
Drugs have nothing on love.
Love brings out the vibrancy of color. Mundane scents smell sweeter and more pure. Breakfast has never tasted so decadent. I can feel life replenishing with each gulp of freshwater I drink before heading out into the glorious sunshine, happier than I thought humanly possible.
I don’t realize I’m skipping down the dirt path to the beach until the skipping becomes twirling, and the twirling becoming dancing, and the dancing becomes running, and the running becomes giggling until my attention is diverted by a group of women waving and calling for me to join them.
I glide down the rest of the path, my feet floating a few inches off the ground. Gravity seems to have different rules today. Landing softly in front of the women dismantling the wedding decor, I spread my arms up and over my head in a cheerful morning stretch. “Good morning, everyone! Isn't it a wonderful day to be alive?”
I only start to feel awkward when they continue to stare, wide-eyed, and nobody responds.
“My lady,” a woman finally dares to speak, “please tell me it was my husband.”
“Was it my Bjorn?” Another woman bounces with excitement. “He’s an amazing lover, but I’m biased, of course.”
“My lady, have mercy,” Maya cuts in dramatically, smiling because she’s the only one here who knows the real answer. “Don’t leave us in suspense. Tell us who he is.”
Another woman interrupts with a giddy, “He? Who said it was a man? Maybe it was one of us!”
“Wasn’t me,” a pouting woman says. “You’d all know about it by now. I’d never shut up!”
“Lady Cora, at least tell us if they are a man or woman. I simply must know!” Looking overly excited at a thought, the woman mouths, “It was my husband, right?”
I drop my arms and start to wonder if I’ve made a mistake talking to them. “I’m sorry, but I don’t know what you’re talking about.”
“My lady, your magic is on the outside. I can feel it from all the way over here.” Maya’s lips pull up into a mischievous grin as she says, “A lover took you for a tumble last night. And by the looks of you this morning? I’d say they must be one talented lover if they impressed the Goddess of Love.”
How were they able to tell just by looking at me? Ben and I didn’t even do anything except run around his brain all night. Am I not normally this peppy and talkative? Is it the glow? I was hoping they’d think it was just run of the mill magic.
“I do not wish to say,” I announce as evenly as I can.
“It’s James,” Maya guesses, and I relax when I realize she’s giving me an out. “Oh, my lady, you’re blushing! It was the outsider! How interesting.” Maya’s grin slowly spreads into a wide smile of satisfaction. I guess this is enough drama to placate her boredom for the time being. “Honestly, I don’t blame you. He’s easy on the eyes and the children all adore him.”
“Yes,” another woman agrees, giggling like a schoolgirl. “Sometimes I walk all the way to the far side of the island just to watch him help Christopher haul fish back to the longhouse.”
“Yes, me too,” I lie, rather unconvincingly. “I’m always watching him fish. He has nice. . . muscles. Really nice muscles. To, you know, carry all that fish.” Fortunately for me, Maya is the only one amused by my lie because the rest of the women believe me and break out into scandalized snorts and stifled giggles.
I find Sawyer asleep in his shack, and I can only imagine what it must feel like to be shaken awake by a sleep-deprived goddess who recently threatened to kill you and hasn’t brushed her hair in 24 hours.
His tired voice is thick with sleep when he asks, “Why the hell are you glowing?”
“Long story, but that’s not why I’m here. Wait, no, actually that’s exactly why I’m here.” I try to calm down as I watch him roll out of bed and pour a glass of water to help wake himself up. “There’s no time to explain, but I need you to lie to anyone that asks and tell them you’re my lover.”
Sawyer jerks violently, legitimately choking so hard on his drink, tears pour down his face and it takes more than a few minutes for him to stop coughing. “I’m your what?”
“I’m so sorry. I panicked.” It’s a struggle not to tangle my fingers in my hair and rip all the strands out. “They were going to find out it’s him, so I panicked and claimed it was you.”
Sawyer clearly doesn’t understand what I mean, and from the looks of it, even the shock of what I’ve just said is losing its potency. “What are you talking about?”
“When I woke up this morning, I was still glowing, but they all started trying to guess who was responsible and—”
“Cora? Still not making any sense. Why didn’t you just. . . I don’t know. . . tell them you’re sleeping with your husband!?”
“I can’t do that,” I explain, equally irritated. “It’s complicated. My people think this marriage is a sham. If they ever found out I was tricked into it? I don’t exactly know what would happen, but I can make an educated guess.”
Sawyer fully wakes up at this news. “Ben tricked you into marrying him? You’ve been leaving out the juiciest bit of drama this whole time?”
Jesus, Mary, and Joseph, why can’t I ever just shut my stupid mouth? “James, listen to me. You can’t tell anyone. And I mean anyone. I married him to stop a war, but if anyone finds out it wasn’t exactly my idea? I think that will be enough for all the women to literally start a war.”
Thankfully, Sawyer seems to respect the fear in my voice and backs off. He simply says, “You owe me.”
Two days after the wedding—when I’ve had a chance to sleep and life starts to return to normal—I enter the longhouse after a tiring day of helping Chris haul fish up and down the beach to distribute throughout the community. I haven’t heard from Ben in the two days since he borrowed some of Christopher’s ill-fitting clothing and snuck himself away from Hydra. So finding a letter waiting for me on my desk sends me into a love surge.
I instantly blush when I see the envelope is signed From Your Secret Admirer. Eager to read whatever sweet sentiment he’s sent me, I rip into the paper and unfold the sheets.
I barely get three sentences in before my excited bouncing stops and I start frantically skimming the rest of the letter to see if I’ve somehow misread. Each word makes all the hairs on my body stand up straight with dread. This isn’t a love letter as much as it is a threat. And if that’s what he was going for? Congrats. I feel threatened.
I’m hurt. I’m confused. I can’t help but feel betrayed that he would even think to put these kinds of disgusting fantasies to paper. And now? Now I’m angry. Angry at myself for thinking trusting him was a good idea.
I write, What the fuck is wrong with you???
His response is immediate. Quite a lot, actually. You’re going to have to be more precise.
My response is a scribbled, You think this shit is funny? Why would you think this is okay? Please don’t contact me for a while.
His next message reads, Don’t leave Hydra. I’ll be there within the hour.
“No,” I scream in horror and toss his message away from me. “No, don’t come here!”
I can feel in my bones that he’s not going to hurt me, but I still fear him as if he would.
“What happened?” Ben hurries towards me, out of breath from having rushed here on short notice. “What are you so upset about?” I show him the letter, fully expecting him to apologize. Instead, he curiously inspects it and almost immediately has the same reaction I did. “Is this your idea of a joke?”
“Oh, yeah,” I yell sarcastically. “I wrote all this disgusting shit to myself to get you all riled up.”
“Wait. . .” Ben looks angry for a split second before it morphs into sadness. “You thought I wrote this? Do you really think so little of me? This isn’t even my handwriting. I didn’t write this filth.” Sadness becomes anger again as his hands stop shaking, his expression closes off, and he very calmly asks, “So who did?”
“Pris said it was delivered while she wasn’t here. I don’t know who sent it. I’m sorry,” I tell him sadly. “I was so confused because I didn’t believe you wrote this. And if you did, I was hoping this was just some kind of bad joke.”
“There’s nothing funny about this!” Ben holds out a hand, and I’m surprised to find his grip is gentle when I lace my fingers through his own, considering his other hand has completely crushed the letter in a terrifying vice grip. “Come with me,” he says, still sounding dangerously calm. “I think I know how we can figure out who—” Ben pauses, the rest of his sentence nothing more than hiss. “—this belongs to.”
Notes:
Hope everyone has a very happy new year!!! Party hard and stay safe everyone!
We're roughly halfway through this story, and I am (as always) looking forward to hearing your thoughts so far...more island shenanigans to come in the new year ;)
Chapter 25: The Beginning Of The End
Chapter Text
Our first stop is the aviary to talk to the ravens, but they turn out to be a dead end. All they offer is young man, blonde, tall.
“So very helpful,” Ben quips when I translate Loki’s guttural kwak kwak’s. “That really narrows it down.”
It could literally be anyone. Young, tall, and blonde fits the description of like 60 people back at the Temple. “Now what? We go door-to-door asking if they’re the author? They’re just going to lie and say no.”
“There’s no need to go door-to-door,” Ben says, lost in thought for a moment before continuing. “I have a better idea.”
Ben’s voice booms throughout the stadium as he shouts at the unmarried men and boys down in the courtyard below.
“Earlier this morning, Lady Cora received a very disturbing letter. I’m not going to repeat what was written, but you know who you are and I’m only going to give you one opportunity to confess. Whoever wrote this. . . filth needs to step forward. NOW.”
This was your plan? I’m so confused. If we agree they would never confess when confronted individually, why would they confess in front of all their peers?
“Alright, fine! We’ll do this the hard way. Everyone line up single file!” Ben nods at me. “Okay, go ahead. They’re all yours. Read their minds and tell everyone which of them is too cowardly to confess!”
What are you talking about?I don’t read minds—wait, I see where he’s going with this. I don’t need to read their minds. I just need to make them believe I can. “Did he stutter?” I yell to the boys down below, and a few of them start to cry. Although, I can’t tell for certain if it’s because they’re guilty or because they’re scared little boys. “Everyone line up! Hurry. Single file. I don’t have all day.”
“It was me,” a voice calls from the crowd and everyone’s panicked voices silence. I watch as young men step away from the person who spoke, leading a trail in the crowd so I can see who it is.
Ben points at the young man. “My office. Now.”
Thor Thorson the Fourth looks like he’s two seconds from leaning back in his chair and falling asleep. He’s the son of Ben’s arch nemesis, Thor Thorson the Third, head coach of the Falcons. I remember meeting him. He’s the tool that was about to fight Annie’s only son over their shared proposal to the same girl. Judging from how bored he looks, he’s not taking any of this seriously.
“Have you lost your mind?” Ben continues to rant, and I let him. There’s no use trying to stop him when he’s this committed to something. “Sending something this disgusting to your fiancé would be bad enough, but to send it to Goddess Freyja?”
Thor finally reacts to this by sitting up straight in his chair and shouting, “That stupid raven was supposed to give it to Pris, not her.”
Ben doesn’t respond to this, and I can only assume it’s because he’s seen the look on my face.
Why would Thor have sent this to my assistant? Pris doesn’t even like men. Magic simmers just under my skin. My voice comes out low and measured when I say, “You’re not engaged to Pris.”
“Yeah?” Thor waves a dismissive hand. “Well, I’m not married to Helen yet, either, so who cares? Love loophole, Lady Cora.”
I see my father in him, and then I see red. “I don’t even know what to say to you,” I tell him very, very calmly. “You’ve obviously not listened to a word I’ve said and instead focused on correcting me to which of the poor misfortunate women on all of Hydra was the intended recipient of your disgusting letter.”
Looking bored again, Thor mumbles under his breath, “You married a mortal when you should have at least married a demigod from my family. What a waste.”
It’s as easy as breathing. Magic overtakes me. Without trying, I grow two feet taller. Then four. Then eight. The room darkens in shadow as I grow so tall I have to duck my head to keep from hitting the ceiling.
In the blink of an eye, I’m Thor’s exact height, bending over his seat, mere inches from his face. He’s so startled by the speed of my movement that he falls backwards out of his chair and scuttles away from me on his hands and knees.
“Did you say something?” I stare down at him, slowly shrinking back to my normal height. “Because it sounded like you said something.” I wait for Thor to answer, but he only starts shivering. Sighing in bitter disappointment, I turn to Ben and ask, “Did you hear him say something?”
Ben walks up beside me so both of us are glaring down at him. “Yes, I believe he said something. What was it you said, Thor?”
“I didn’t say anything,” he whispers hoarsely.
“Thor?” I say much louder than either of us were expecting. Smiling, I take a deep breath and tell him, “Are you calling me a liar?”
The big oaf has to think about it for a second. “No,” he whispers.
“Because it sounded like you had some opinions about who I can and cannot marry. Is that right? Is that what you said, Thor?” Darkness billows around me like smoke, black as a starless sky. “How dare you tell me what to do. You giving me orders? You’re nothing but a misguided little man playing at being a god. Do you honestly think you’re a descendant of Thor? Alright. Let’s test your theory! Smite me down, Thor! I’m threatening your great-great-grandson! Come and stop me!”
I try to do my best to save him. He’s still young and hopefully receptive to what I’m saying about the cowardice of breaking promises before they’ve even been officially made and what a pathetic excuse for a man he is and that physical strength is not what makes a person worthy of power.
“Your parents lied to you,” I seethe, still conjuring a room of windy darkness. Thor’s hair whips around as his eyes flit all over in paranoia, but to his credit, he doesn’t run away. He sits curled up in a ball on the floor and listens as I shout, “I know Thor—the real Thor—and you and your family have absolutely nothing to do with him. If I were you, I’d be embarrassed to spread their lies further. Don’t you agree?”
By the desperate way he’s shaking his head, I wouldn’t be surprised if he’d agree to anything I suggest. “Please,” his deep voice wavers, and I realize he’s crying. “Please don’t tell my mom.”
“You best believe I’m telling your mom, first thing when I get back to Hy—” Ben hurries to stand behind Thor, so I can see him wave his hands, pleading me to stop. “I mean. . . I mean, you’ll be lucky if I don’t tell your mother!”
“Please don’t tell mom.” Thor sobs so hard, I start to feel bad for him. “I didn't mean any of it. I'm sorry.”
All at once, the smoke clears, and I’m back to my regular self. “I’m afraid an apology isn’t good enough this time. You are no longer engaged, effective immediately. And I will not approve another engagement until you prove to me that you’ve done the hard work to completely rethink your place in this world.” Thor starts to cry again in protest, but all I do is hold up a hand to tell him to quiet down. “I need to make sure you won’t go back to the same misguided ways after the adrenaline runs out. Women are not here for your entitled entertainment, and if I ever even suspect that you pose a danger to Hydra, I'll break your soul into a thousand little pieces and scatter them across the universe, so you'll find no peace in this life or the next.”
"I won't, I promise." This mountain of a teenager, full beard and all, sniffles loudly and asks, “You’re not going to kill me?”
“You’ve killed yourself,” Ben answers. “You think anyone is ever going to speak to you again after finding out what you’ve done? You’ll be lucky if your fellow Falcons can bear to look you in the eye.”
“But. . . but you’re not going to kill me?”
“You stupid boy,” Ben snarls. “Social death is death. I would know.”
“Was that too much?” I ask as soon as Thor leaves the room. “I feel like I took it too far.”
Ben shakes his head. “You didn’t take it far enough, if you ask me. Have you already forgotten what he wrote?”
“Yeah, you’re right. Hey, what was with the mom thing? Talking to her would do a world of good.”
Even though Thor is the detested son of his arch nemesis, Ben can’t help but exhale sadly. “She was one of the rare women on Hydra who died in childbirth.”
“Oh shit," I say, panicking. "Oh shit. I didn’t say anything bad, did I?”
“No, and I think we’ve thankfully had an impact on him, if you can believe it. Let’s just hope it sticks.”
I look over to find Ben studying me, eyes narrowed, with a smile that twitches at the corners. I ask, “What?”
“Goddess of Death is mean.” Before I can open my mouth to say sorry, Ben’s already raised a hand up to cut me off. “Do not apologize.”
I’m not too proud to admit that I’ve fully committed to stalking my husband.
Ben’s baseline life-force is always a beating presence within me, but I can also sense when he’s nearby, so I use that ability whenever I enter the permitter of his last known coordinates. If he’s supposed to be in the Barracks, I’ll head to the Barracks, and if everything goes well? I’ll be able to sense when his presence is getting closer and pinpoint what direction it’s coming from. All I have to do is look around without being suspicious and see if I can find where he is.
The problem is it never goes well. I’ve never once successfully snuck up on him, and when I’m caught, I always have to force a smile and wave and think, oh, hi, hello! Yes, I definitely just got here and haven’t been following you around so I can watch you without you knowing! Oh, God, I hope he can’t read my mind.
In the early days of our secret lovers meet ups, Ben used to exclusively wait for me to come to him, but that started to piss me off for some reason, so I wrote him a letter demanding he swim to Hydra if he has to, which made our game far more interesting.
Which is exactly why I’m trying to stalk him again. This is the closest I’ve ever gotten without being caught. Ben’s house is within sight, and I can feel the pull of magic grow in intensity as I approach. Ducking near the windows, I make my way around the house, towards his bedroom. Ben must be inside his bedroom, because the closer I get to this room, the stronger the pull. I get right up to his window, practically suffering an anxiety attack from the intensity of the magic. I just need to reach up on my tiptoes and peek into his bedroom window and—
A familiar voice is low in my ear. “Who are we spying on?”
I whirl around, screaming up against the house.
Ben’s eyes flit between me and his own house behind me as he feigns surprise. “Oh, we’re spying on me? Wonderful!”
Realizing it’s him, I laugh with relief. “I need to put a cowbell on you, so I know where you are at all times. You’re too quiet.”
“How do you think I survived this long? And need I remind you, you are stalking me.”
“Then how did you know where I was just now? Looks like we were stalking each other. I’m just not very good at it.”
“I’ll concede to that.” Ben laughs when I give him a playful shove, but the laughter fades into nothing more than a disdainful hmmmm at the sight of something over my shoulder. “Not this again.”
“Lady Cora?” Artz approaches, and I feel my energy draining before he’s even started lecturing. “I was doing some reading in the library and I found this interesting text on historically accurate textiles of your people.”
Ben looks like he smells something rotten. “You say that as if we care.”
I shoot Ben a look and whisper, “Be nice.”
“I am being nice,” he refutes loudly. For his credit, Ben remains silent as Artz prattles on and on until he pronounces something wrong and Ben is quick to jump in again with a snide, “It’s not pronounced that way, you insipid chatterbox!” There’s a moment where Ben doesn’t do anything but glare at Artz. Then, he spins sharply towards me and asks, “Cora, may I hit him?”
I bring a hand up to rub my eyes. “No.”
Ben’s so disappointed at my answer that he literally starts sulking.
Instead of backing off at the threat of violence, Artz’s ego seems to inflate beyond the limits of sanity. “You don’t need to protect me, Lady Cora. I’ll fight him.”
Ben doesn’t look at me this time when he asks, “May I kill him now?"
“Kill?”
Ben sighs, annoyed at the slip-up. “Maim, kill, whatever. You know what I mean.”
“Ben? Go in the house,” I order.
Ben fixes me with disappointed puppy eyes before finally relenting and aiming one final scathing glare in Artz’s direction. "You're lucky she's nice," he snaps angrily.
I wait for Ben to close the front door behind him before saying, “Leslie, I’m very busy. Can you come back another time, please?”
“Oh, okay. Can you pencil me in?”
“Pencil you in?”
“Yeah, like a reservation. In the notebook you carry everywhere.” For some reason, Artz thinks it’s a good idea to reach out and touch my satchel. Whether accidentally or not, he misses and ends up poking my stomach.
“Okay,” I proclaim loudly and take a big step back, “let me explain something to you. If you ever touch me again, he—” I wag a thumb behind me at Ben’s house. “—is going to come flying out that door and stab you over and over and over until you’re nothing more than a glistening pile of hamburger meat.” Goddess of Love and War. Goddess of Life and Death. I feel it. Goddess of Death made a brief appearance to stop Erik from killing Ben, and then to teach Thor a lesson in what happens when you defy a Goddess, but I’ve been holding her back for a long time, and she’s starting to break free. “And guess what?” I continue, smiling. “I’m not going to stop him. Because you’re annoying. There, I said it. You are the most annoying mortal man I’ve ever met, and I loathe the way you talk to me like a child. Yap, yap, yap, yap, yap! Do you honestly think I have any interest in listening to you ramble? About my own damn people?! I do not care where you got your degree. I do not care where you work. I couldn’t care less that your wife divorced you, and to be honest, I don’t blame her!”
By the time I’m done ranting, Goddess of Death simmers down enough for me to start feeling bad for him. To his credit, Artz simply apologizes, bows, and leaves looking especially pale.
Ben is waiting for me by the door when I enter his house, and I can tell he’s annoyed by the intensity of his sigh. He turns to look at me and says, “It’s about time you started advocating for yourself.”
That’s twice in one week I’ve been Goddess of Death. This is getting out of control. I used to be able to suppress my rage. Why is it so difficult now? “That was a little much. Actually, that was way too much.” I turn towards the door. “I’m going to apologize.”
“No, you’re not.” Ben quickly situates himself between me and the door. “You’re allowed to say no, and he needs to learn how to listen.”
Great, now Ben’s mad at me, too. “Sorry.”
“You apologize too much.”
I do? “Sorry.”
Ben’s expression softens with amusement. “Are you that incapable of saying no? What do you usually do when people ask you for favors?”
“Depends on the favor,” I say.
“Okay, so let’s say a child approaches and asks you to heal a scraped knee. You don't actually heal it, right?”
“How bad is the scrape?”
I realize that’s the wrong answer when Ben looks disappointed and shouts, “Cora?!”
“That’s important to my answer! How bad is the scrape?”
Ben scrutinizes me, and I realize there’s no point in lying because he wouldn’t believe me anyway. “You’re telling me that you don’t heal every minor cut or bruise on those children?”
“No,” I say pointedly. “I mean, yes. I mean, wait. . . is it yes for a yes answer or yes for a no answer?”
Ben’s voice comes out flat. “You’re lying to me.”
I immediately fold. “Okay, yes, I’m lying to you. I always heal their little boo-boos. I’m sorry! They’re just so young and they need my help.”
“Cora,” Ben says gently, “they don’t need you to heal every tiny injury. They need to let their own body heal itself. What exactly is your plan? To teach them there are no consequences for clumsiness? That no matter what insane activity they partake in, you’ll always be there to take away the pain?”
Yep, that about covers it. “But I can’t say no.”
“Why not?”
I blurt out the truth before I can stop myself. “Because I would’ve wanted someone to do that for me.”
“I know,” he says, even more gently. “But you don’t have to give away every part of yourself to be worthy of affection.”
“You don’t know that.” I immediately regret letting the truth slip and hurry to correct my response. “I don’t want to say no and disappoint them.”
“What would disappointing them do?”
I had no one to run to when I was a child, and I like being that person for the children on Hydra. “I don’t know. . . I guess I just don’t want them to hate me.”
“You’re always so good with them,” he says. “How could anyone hate you?”
I turn to shoot him an annoyed look at the tasteless joke—um, I don’t know, maybe because 30 years ago I killed their parent or grandparent or sister or brother or cousin or uncle or dog or cat or some other important member of their family?—and find him swaying somewhat limply, like he’s sleepwalking. “Ben, are you okay?”
Ben’s head rolls up in slow motion, his dazed blue eyes lazily following suit. “Yes,” his voice echoes through the room. “I think so.”
“Do you need to sit down?” I think about how much I want his mouth against my neck, and then suddenly his mouth is against my neck. What’s even more bizarre is when I start to lean away from him in surprise, I end up not moving at all because he’s already removed himself. I feel the pull of magic as gravity shifts, and I begin to feel floaty without my feet ever leaving the ground. I am way out of my league here. On instinct, I reach out a hand to touch him, and he stills completely at the contact.
Like a sonar wave, his voice reverberates throughout my mind, but his mouth never opens. I’m sorry. I didn’t mean to do this. It just happened. Do you want me to leave?
I jerk my head up to look at the ceiling, as if I can see his words. When I look back at Ben, I’m a little more worried about his current state. He looks disoriented.
Am I reading your mind? Hello? No, that’s stupid.
How funny would it be if you slapped yourself across the face?
I’m not sure an expression has ever conveyed betrayal quite like Ben's the second before his body compels itself to lift a hand and smack it hard across his face.
“No! I’m so sorry,” I squeal in horror. But, of course, since my embarrassment has exceeded well beyond the realm of mortification, I end up laughing until I free from the magic. “I didn’t know it would do that! Im so, so sorry! What just happened?”
“I’m not sure. I think. . . I think—” A thought dawns on him and his expression quickly cycles through all the stages of grief before settling into a blank stare at the ground with wide, mortified eyes.
“What?”
“I. . .” Ben wasn’t this nervous to lie to me about the war, or take Jane’s place at the Holmgang. No. Whatever secret he’s keeping is bigger than anything he’s deceived me about in the past. Which just makes what he says next that much more surprising. “I think I just submitted to you completely. I couldn’t move a single muscle in my body until you thought about slapping me, and then I couldn’t stop my hand from slapping myself and—”
“I know,” I interrupt, “and I’m sorry! It felt like. . . it kinda felt like you were my puppet. It was awful.”
Of all things, Ben looks mildly disappointed. “You didn’t like it?”
“Did I like having full control over you? No, not really. I mean, I didn’t have control for ten seconds before the intrusive thoughts won over. I’m sorry again for slapping you. Or, having you slap yourself? You know what I mean.”
“No. . . that’s. . .” His words die off as he readies himself to finish his thought. “That’s what I’m trying to explain. I don’t want you to be sorry.”
I’m confused for a little longer than I’d like to admit before it hits me like a brick to the face and I have to fight to keep my expression blank. “Ohhhh, I see.”
Ben instantly pales and settles into a calm mask. “I don’t mean to make you uncomfortable. Forget I said anything. I know it’s weird.”
“Hey, it’s not weird. I promise I don’t think it’s weird.” I hold a hand over my heart. Boy, you have absolutely no idea what weird is. “Honestly.”
Ben still doesn’t look like he fully believes me. “Are you sure?”
“Absolutely. But, to be honest? It’s a lot of responsibility having all the control. I’m not sure I want to try that, you know, tonight. Eventually, just. . . not right now.”
“No, of course not. I mean, yes, please take all the time you need.” Ben shakes his head at the thought and then looks at the kitchen. “Speaking of which, I should probably get to work. Will you be wandering around until nightfall?”
“No, I’m hanging out with Charlotte and Jane until dinner. 8pm, right?”
“Eight sharp,” he adds, gesturing to the door. “And please come in through the front door and not my bedroom window. Thank you.”
“Damn, Cora, you are so getting laid tonight.” Jane gives Charlotte the bobby pins she asked for and laughs with amusement. “Good for you.”
“Annnnnnnnd you just made it weird,” I respond. “Thanks, Jane.”
Charlotte rolls her eyes at her wife and continues pinning my hair up. “Ignore her.”
“I’m not going to tell anyone!” Jane crosses her arms and leans against the bathroom door in their shared barracks home. “Sheesh. I can keep a secret just as well as the next person.”
“That’s exactly the problem, darling,” Charlotte says, laughing. “The next person can’t keep a secret either. That’s why rumors are so dangerous.”
With Charlotte and Jane’s help, I finish my hair and makeup and dress in one of my favorite gowns for the evening. The sun has set and the night is cool and loud with the sound of bugs as I walk the few feet separating Jane and Charlotte’s house and Ben’s front porch.
Ben opens the door, offers a hand to walk me inside, and then proceeds to try and have a conversation with me in French.
I stare back at him in confusion. “What?”
Ben’s friendly expression looks slightly annoyed as he repeats himself in French.
“Ben, I don’t speak French.”
His annoyed expression falls into a deeply annoyed expression. This time, he speaks in English. Only, everything he says is in a strong Parisian accent. “Oh,” he sneers. “American.”
I finally get the joke and burst out laughing as I follow him over to a well-dressed table. Still looking annoyed, he pulls out my chair and offers an immaculately handwritten menu.
“This is so not what I meant when I said to give me the European experience.” I can’t stop laughing as I wipe my eyes dry of good-natured tears and glance at the menu. “What does this even say?”
“The disclaimer at the top says we do not offer french fries, so please do not ask. I am obligated to toss you out if you do.” He raises the volume of his accented voice so I can hear him over the sound of my own laughter. “What would Madame like to order?”
“I don’t know! I can’t read any of this.”
“That is good for me,” he says, still accented heavily. “It means you will not know what you’re pointing at. Everything we serve here is exceptional, so it does not matter what you choose.”
I point to the first dish I see.
“Excellent choice.” Ben pulls a dish out from behind his back and places it on the table in front of me. “This is what you ordered.”
I can’t stop laughing at how well thought out this joke is.
Ben stands silently nearby, but I don’t realize he’s waiting for me to try the food until he says, “Shall I send your compliments to the chef, or shall I have him disemboweled in shame?”
I have never, in my entire life, felt comfortable flirting with someone the way I feel safe right now. I could get up and walk out that door without an explanation, and he wouldn’t attempt to hold me down and keep me here. He’d simply let me leave and then send me letters trying to apologize for something that isn’t his fault. I don’t have to fear him.
I don’t have to fear him.
It’s as if his body is my own. I hear and feel his heartbeat quicken as a rush of blood courses through his veins and into his arousal. But now I’m worried. All of my upper chest sings with overwhelming love, but for some reason I have zero desire to have him inside me. Goddess of Love, not Goddess of Lust.
But doesn’t lust come with love?
I mean, I guess not. Lust without love leaves little incentive to stick around if something were ever to take sex out of the relationship. But love without lust? Love makes you want to stay regardless of what happens. The only truly pure form of love is love.
Shit.
I’m not lusting after him while I’m the Goddess of Love, but I hate disappointing him. I mean, he went through all this trouble to make me food and make me laugh, and I can clearly feel lust and love wafting off him. He definitely wants me, but he’s not going to hurt me if I say no.
It dawns on me. A workaround.
Ben’s confident smirk shrinks into something much less confident as I stand up from my seat and slowly slink towards him. “I’m sure what you made is delicious, but Goddess of Love was hoping to order something—” I place a hand against his chest and slowly run it up his shirt until it rests behind his neck. “—off the menu. Do you do special requests?”
His Parisian French accent is gone when he answers, “Depends on the request.”
“I noticed a complete lack of meat on the menu.” One of my hands starts to finger the collar of his shirt, while the other reaches down to cup the bulge in his pants. “Can you make an exception? I’m kind of a big deal.”
“We’re a strictly vegetarian establishment,” he proclaims weakly. “I’ll get fired.”
Not where I thought this was going, and now I’m confused.
Ben catches on quickly and adjusts his answer to, “They can’t fire me. I quit! Now. . . what exactly did you have in mind?”
In answer, I sink to my knees and reach for his zipper, pausing until he chokes out his answer. I free him from his pants and everything turns to dread in my gut. “I want to make you feel good,” I admit nervously, “but I don’t know what I’m doing.” I sense him offer his mind, and I reach out, relieved at the chance to hear him guide me through this in real time.
Being inside his mind makes this easier than anything I’ve ever done before. I know exactly where to drag my tongue, how to situate my lips so I don’t nick him with a tooth, how hard to suck, and where to put my hands.
Darkness surrounds me, as per usual when I’m inside his mind, but he’s usually standing here beside me. I spin around, but I don’t see him. Ben?
His voice doesn’t echo overhead. His voice comes directly from inside my own head. Yes, dear?
Where are you? I don’t scream this time, but I do flinch in fear. Did you go into my mind without asking?
“Stop,” he says aloud, and I suddenly feel a hand on top of my head. “Cora, stop.”
“I’m so sorry! Did I accidentally use teeth again?”
Whatever I’ve done is far worse than that by the look on his face and the amount of time it takes him to speak again. “Listen,” he finally says, “I understand we’re not equals. I get that. I accept that. But why is it whenever something bad happens, you automatically blame me?”
“I do not,” I refute, instantly regretting it.
Ben doesn’t look angry, he looks disappointed, and that’s much worse. “Please just answer the question.”
I don’t automatically blame him for everything, right? I mean, I did blame him for that letter. And I accused him of some horrible things the morning after the wedding. And there was that one time I couldn’t find my notebook and sent a less-than-polite message to him back on the mainland demanding he give it back, even though it turned out to be hidden under some paper on my desk. “You’re right. No, actually you’re right. I didn’t realize until now that I . . . At every chance, I pull away at the last second.” I think back on all the times I’ve attempted to initiate sex but panicked halfway through his acceptance. “I literally grope myself in front of you, and the second you show interest…I feel afraid.”
“You’re afraid of me?”
“No, that’s the thing. It’s not you. It’s everyone. I’m afraid of everyone, and I trust no one. But I want to,” I admit. “I want to trust you, I just don’t know how.”
Ben’s pensive expression lights up at a thought. “You really where inside my mind just now. I can prove it. Go back in my mind and I’ll give you full control to prove it.”
“Prove what?”
“That you can trust me. If I give myself to you completely, you can control my every move. Make me do anything. If you take control of me, you’ll always be safe by my very own hand. You need only think it and I will stab myself through the heart for you.”
“Don’t say that.” I feel a deep-seeded wound heal itself inside me, and the Goddess of Love returns. “At least don’t die before I get to apologize.”
All the air in my lungs gets sucked out as he yanks me back in with an eagerness that makes me giggle. Within the dark expanse of his mind, I think about raising my hands and Ben’s body mimics my thought without me ever speaking a word. Whoa, this is kinda weird. I don’t know, Ben. Are you sure you’re okay with this?
I have never been more sure of something in my entire life.
Okay. If you’re sure. I start to wander around, but there are only a few doors in this expanse. Where are we? Where are all the doors?
These are only my worst memories, I’m afraid.
Do you want me to see?
Yes.
I pick one at random and walk out onto a street somewhere in 1970’s America. Elementary-aged Ben walks home with his backpack slung over one bony shoulder, but a group of boys his age materialize out of nowhere and jump him.
“Hey, hey, hey, hey!” I hurry over and try to break up the fight. “Get off him! What the. . ? Did you just try and bite me, you little Gremlin?” I lift the offending bully up off the ground by his shirt and shake him around like a winning lottery ticket. “Whose feral child with the ugly haircut is this?"
I drop the boy onto the pavement, and the rest of them scatter, confused and frightened by the fat girl who so easily tosses them around like rag dolls. Ben hops up and brushes off his clothes, looking sheepish and embarrassed that he couldn’t save himself.
“You okay?” I nod when he says yes. “Do you mind if I just kinda walk around? This is so cool. I always wondered what the 70’s was like. Oh, let’s get ice cream!” Taking his little hand in mine, we walk in the direction of the city’s nearest ice cream parlor.
“Thanks,” he says in his tiny child voice. “The real memory is those guys held me down and kicked three of my baby teeth in and I accidentally swallowed them, so I didn’t even get any tooth fairy money out of it.”
“Wow, that’s so shameful of them. Being in a cowards cult like that? I wouldn’t be able to live with myself. I mean, four on one? Pathetic.” I look down at him and it’s the same as when I’d comfort my siblings—I’m not exactly sure what to say, so I try to make him laugh. “I can’t believe one of them tried to bite me. I hope I don’t get rabies.”
I make sure to shield him from aggressive drivers and suspicious pedestrians as we continue down the street. It’s only now that I realize Ben’s memory has fundamentally changed enough to make him a completely different person now that he has a big scary mother figure to look after him. This memory went from bringing him shame and fear to bringing him comfort and laughter as I continue to roast his bullies. With my work here done, I leave baby Ben at the ice cream parlor with all the ice cream he could possibly want, and I walk back to the memory door to let myself out.
Of all the things I’m expecting to find when I pull away and wipe my mouth, Ben trying his best not to cry isn’t even on the list, and yet here we are. “Are you crying because you’re sad?”
“No.” His voice breaks, and it makes him laugh at himself. “Quite the contrary.”
I smile as he jerks an arm up to swipe away tears. I enjoy making him feel loved. “Then I’ll take it as a complement.”
“Here.” Ben offers me his hand and pulls me up off the floor. “Do you want to eat some real food?”
Time passes, the sub returns, and we host another raffle to see which lucky few get to go home next. Unfortunately for them, none of the core cast gets chosen. Fortunately for me, Ben rigged the raffle to ensure Leslie was selected.
Speaking of Ben, we’ve fallen into a system that ensures we’re always prepared for the nights we’re together. Even though he’s never been inside me, fingers or otherwise, he’s mastered the art of making me glow like the moon. Through trial and error, I’ve learned a lot about myself and what it means to be a Goddess.
I am the Goddess of Love and War, Life and Death.
Goddess of Love is a mother, encouraging and affectionate. Ben must submit to me fully for me to be able to help him through memories in which he desperately needed and wanted a mother.
Goddess of War is a subordinate all too eager to be led by the one I trust most. Unfortunately, I’m still way too scared of what Ben will think of me to let him have full control. As much as I trust him, it makes me recoil in shame to think of him ever finding out what I crave more than anything.
Goddess of Life wants children, so I can give them a better life than the one my parents gave me. Whenever I see Ben with kids, it takes all my willpower to stop this Goddess from slinging him over a shoulder and tossing him onto my bed so we can make some children of our own.
And the Goddess of Death? I’m scared of the Goddess of Death. She is unbearably dominate, controlling, and in a never-ending quest to punish those who would harm the ones I love. Rage needs to build for a prolonged time for her to make an appearance, and I have a troubling suspicion that she’s secretly Ben’s favorite.
At the end of the day, it doesn’t actually matter which Goddess I am because Ben worships them all.
“More wine?” Ben asks, reaching back to grab a bottle when I nod yes.
This is our third date out of dozens of dates in which we’ve been comfortable enough to drink alcohol together. Turns out my issue with alcohol has little to nothing to do with Jesus and everything to do with not wanting to be like my father. The problem is, I think I like wine. Wine makes it easier to open up and talk to Ben.
The first time we drank together, I freaked out and had a panic attack because I thought I was officially an alcoholic and my soul was going to rot in Catholic Hell forever. Ben was able to talk me down from an anxiety spiral by asking me ridiculous hypothetical questions like, “Would you rather have a kangaroo tail or the power to also understand insects?”
The second time, I was comfortable enough to have way too much wine and Goddess of Death showed up. All night she wouldn’t stop caressing herself and slinging insults at Ben if he attempted to come closer. I denied his request to touch me or himself, and yet he still eagerly elected to give me complete control of his mind. I made him kneel, motionless, in front of my seat on the couch while I spread my legs so he could watch me rub myself. Right when it starts getting good, I give him back the use of his hands, and he practically collapses in gratitude. “I didn’t do it for you. I did it for me,” I told him, never breaking my rhythm. “Go on. I want to watch, too.” It wasn’t at all embarrassing in the moment, but the second I got back to Hydra, it felt like I was literally dying from mortification.
But that was over a week ago.
Ben sits on the floor next to me, slumped against his couch. I’ve only had one glass so far, but he’s had three, and now he won’t stop swirling the wine around in his crystal glass while giving me bedroom eyes. “How is this vintage faring in your esteemed estimation, my sweet summer sunshine?”
I snort. “Just exactly how drunk are you right now?”
“Somewhere between please don’t ask me to stand up and show me your—oh my.” Ben breaks eye contract, staring holes in the floor, mouth open in shock. “Yes,” he says, embarrassed, and takes another sip. “To answer your question, I am, indeed, inebriated.”
Laughter—real laughter—pours out of me like the wine he’s offering. Turns out my real laugh is loud and breathy, like one long elongated HA that eventually dies and rebirths an entirely new HA.
We talk about anything and everything, and I feel myself growing warm—then hot—with desire the more stories he tells me about his life. As Ben continues to share his stories, I feel a desire to reciprocate. This desire only grows stronger when Ben gives me his full attention no matter what it is I’m saying.
“Oh, it was so cute.” I smile just thinking about it. “So they’re all gathered around him, right? Like a little flock of supportive birds. And he finally gets up the courage to approach her on the beach. Now, mind you, he’s literally shaking in his boots as he approaches with the gift he made her. Listen to this,” I add and reach out to touch his arm. “Ulf knows one of Freyja’s daily chores is to milk the family cow, so he carved her a stool to sit on while she milks, and he painted the family cow on the seat. Is that not the sweetest thing? Meanwhile, Team Bear and I are just out of sight, watching everything unfold. He walks up to her, gives his little speech, hands her the stool, and she responded!”
Ben leans forward and touches my arm, so we’re both holding onto each other. “She accepted the conversation?”
I’m already laughing at the memory. “He comes running back to us, and Team Bear is pressuring him to spill the beans, and he just looks down at me and says, She asked if I’m the person who yelled that she has good teeth, and I panicked and said yes. And then I tried to explain that I meant she has a nice smile, and she—Keep in mind that he’s pale as a ghost and completely out of breath—she thanked me for the stool and asked if I want to meet their cow.” I raise my glass in a toast and take another sip. “And then he bent over and vomited all over my boots.”
Ben laughs so hard he knocks over the bottle of wine, and we both drunkenly attempt to stand and retrieve towels from the kitchen. Instead, we end up tripping over each other, wine soaking into the sleeve of my dress.
“Oh no, my dress! Ugh, oh well.” I stare at the stain and thank myself for choosing to wear a dress I’m not entirely obsessed with. “Never really liked this one anyway. Oh, you know what? You know what I’ve always wanted?” Ben gives me his full attention, and I’ve never wanted to kiss someone more in my life. “I’ve always wanted a jumpsuit. Like, a legitimate disco jumpsuit. Isn’t that totally lame? Doesn’t matter. Clothing stores never have things for my proportions anyway. The legs are always too long.”
“Full disclosure.” Ben downs the rest of his wine in one final gulp. “But I am very drunk right now, so I’m sorry for what I’m about to admit. I know it’s creepy.” His usually steady voice wavers with ever-increasing insecurity. “You don’t have to tell me it’s creepy. I know it is.”
“Ben, you haven’t said anything yet.”
“I may have. . .” It is an eternity before he continues, cringing. “I may have some of your old clothing.”
Turns out Ben doesn’t have some of my old clothing. Ben has all of my old clothing. Or, at least all of my old Dharma clothing. I step into the secret room behind his bookcase and run my hands over the fabric of dozens upon dozens of dresses hung up neatly in a row. There’s an area dedicated to short dresses, long dresses, evening wear, work jumpsuits, and fashion jump suits. I wander deeper into the room and pull open a drawer to find bras, underwear, and socks. This is where he got my clothing from when we went to bury Margo.
“I regret showing you this. Can we leave?” By the way all the drunken humor has faded from his now paranoid eyes, it’s safe to say he’s worried I’m about to get angry and call him a pervert.
Instead, I say, “After my grandma died, I gathered up all her shoes and hid them in an abandoned lot near our house. Every free chance I had to sneak away, I would dig them out of their hiding spot, put them on, and use them to say everything I wanted to say to my father—everything I wanted to say but couldn’t—because she was the only person who ever dared to stand up to him.” I huff a fake laugh at the memory. “I was just a child in too-big shoes yelling at no one.”
I must have a confusing expression on my face because Ben asks, “What’s wrong?”
“Nothing, it’s just. . . I’ve never told anyone that before.” I watch his expression relax knowing I’m not angry, and it makes me sad because his grief is my fault. “I guess what I’m trying to say is grief is really strange and uncomfortable and I don’t think it’s weird you did this because grief itself is weird. Plus,” I add, trying to sound extra cheerful, “now it means I get to wear them whenever I want, so you actually did me a huge favor by preserving them so nicely.”
“Thank you.” Ben struggles to keep eye contact. “For being kind.”
“About your secret sex dungeon dedicated in my honor? Yeah, don’t mention it.” Relief floods me when he laughs. This is incredibly messed up, and I should not find this hot. Because this is kinda hot, and I’m worried that makes me a bad person. “Exactly how many times a day do you come in here to jack off?”
Ben laughs, but he sounds deeply uncomfortable.
"That often, huh?" I watch his reaction, but he still looks awkwardly unsure what to do or say. "What's wrong? Why do you look sad?" Ben claims he's fine, but I know him better than that. I ask if I can see what's bothering him, and after a deliberate pause, he pulls me into a memory.
We emerge into the same secret room, and I watch as a slightly younger Ben sits sprawled out on the floor in the corner, tightly clutching one of my dresses and wailing deep pitiful sobs. The sound is too primal to be funny, so I don't laugh. Instead, I turn, grab his hand, and squeeze, pulling us back towards the door and out into the present.
"I'm sorry I asked," I tell him. "I didn't mean to bring up a bad memory. How often did you come in here to cry?"
“Odin himself couldn’t get that information out of me.”
I throw my head back and belt out a genuine laugh. "Wow," I sigh in awe as I touch each and every piece. A familiar sharpness clings to some of the garments more than others, but there is no denying what the smell is. "Do you smoke?"
"Pardon?"
I turn to him and ask, "It smells like cigarettes in here. Do you smoke?"
"No," he answers with a hint of confusion. "You did."
"I smoked?"
"Like a chimney."
"Huh." I mean. . . you can't get cancer on the island, so I guess smoking isn't as dangerous as it would be off island. Right? “Oh! Oh, look!” I hurry over to a jumpsuit in a beautiful green pattern with a matching belt. “This is exactly what I was talking about! No way. No way! Okay, I’m gonna try it on.” I practically scream when I zip it up and realize it’s a perfect fit. “It fits! It fits!” Shocked at my good fortune, I start doing jumping jacks just to prove it’s not too tight. “Oh my God, I’m actually going to cry. I’ve always had big stupid thighs, and they make shopping impossible, but this actually fits!”
“Big stupid thighs? Excuse me,” Ben cuts in, sounding insulted. “I am not going to stand here and allow you to slander my favorite pair of earmuffs.”
I slap a shocked hand over my mouth and try not to laugh because I’m drunk and I don’t know if I’m supposed to laugh or take my clothes off. In the end, he starts laughing first and we both devolve into hysterics.
Still wearing my jumpsuit, I step out of the secret room behind his bookshelf and gasp at an idea. “Do you have a Bee Gees CD? Do you want to dance?” Before he even has a chance to answer, I break out the choreography to Single Ladies.
Two glasses of wine in for me, and four glasses of wine in for Ben, and the two of us become unstoppable dancing machines. Without wine, I’d never be able to move like this because I’d be too busy overthinking if I look foolish. Ben is right. Dancing is intuitive, and people have just forgotten its purpose. It’s a celebratory custom in every culture.
Ben’s CD rotates through all the classic Bee Gees staples as we dance separately and together. He tries to spin me around, but I stop halfway, with my back facing him, pressing my body against his and arching my spine. I dance against Ben until I feel him responding to my touch. Tossing my hair over one shoulder so he can see my face better, I reach a hand up to pull the back of his neck towards me until his mouth is against mine. I like being a tease.
Ben pulls away, panting, and rushes to shut off the music. “I’m sorry, Cora. I can’t.”
Ouch. So much for thinking this was going well.
“It’s just,” he continues, looking stressed out, “the temptation is too much.”
Huh? “Wait. . . do you want me right now?”
I can tell he’s drunk because he barks a laugh at the question. “I want you every second of every day.” Ben shifts from self-conscious to hopeful, and I feel his heart thumping inside my own. “Why?”
“I. . . want you, too.”
“You do?”
I take a step towards him, and I sense all the anxiety I should be feeling morph into an even stronger arousal. “Can I say something crazy?”
Ben takes a step in my direction. “Please do.”
“Promise you won’t get mad?”
Ben holds a hand to his heart. “Swear on my life.”
Life. Yes. Goddess of Life. That’s what I am. I try to fight it. I really do. But in the end, I trust him enough to not feel the need to lie anymore. “I want to give you a family. A big family. One I’ve always dreamed of.”
Ben stills, only daring to look at me when I remain silent. “You do?”
“Is that okay?"
“It's more than okay,” he answers immediately. As if unsure I’m telling him the truth, he hesitantly walks closer, smiling when I don’t move away from him. “Please. I. . . I would be honored.” I must look confused because he explains, "You could choose anyone. If you're choosing me, that means you trust me with the responsibility of children. I could not be more honored to hear it."
“You mean it?” Desire flows through me, as if his hands were already running up both my thighs. “You want to give me babies?”
“More than anything.”
“Really? But—” I shake my head, and the world spins from all the wine. “We can’t.”
“Why not? I have—” Ben scrambles to the far corner of the room, tossing aside books on the bottom of the shelf, and returns with a box.
I’m in love, but I’m also drunk, and I can’t help but laugh at the condoms he’s offering. “Why were these hidden in your bookshelf?” I whisper and then immediately break out into stifled giggles. “Did you hide these all over the house?”
“Maybe.”
“That’s. . . thank you. Resourceful, but—” I hold up the box and shake it. “—this is actually the whole problem. Goddess of Life is a mother. She’s not just motherly, she’s a literal mother. I require life, and you can’t give me life with a condom on. But. . . if I’m a mother, you die.” I think about the Goddess of Life having sex with a condom on and my arousal instantly dries up. “Agh! Why does this have to be complicated?”
“It doesn’t have to be complicated. If I die, I die,” he says, sounding more than a little desperate. “Everyone dies eventually. I’m not afraid.”
I huff a scandalized laugh. “You’re drunk.”
“My answer would remain the same if I was sober. I'll do whatever you ask.”
I no longer feel the need to hide my desire as it rushes back full-force. The love in his voice makes me feel safe enough to order, “Then come over here and satisfy the Goddess of Life. Put a baby in me.” I want to choose, and he wants to be chosen. “I want it to be you. Only you.”
It’s a strange but wholly welcome feeling to pull him in for once and show him my memories. All the things I’d be too embarrassed to share if I wasn’t so warm and comfortable from the wine.
Am I allowed to go into one of these doors? I can leave if you want.
No, it’s okay. I want you to see.
Ben chooses a door at random and steps into my old apartment in Harlem. The memory of me stands alone at the small stovetop in the tiny kitchen within the even tinier three bedroom apartment I share with my roommates. “Cora?”
“Ben?” I spin around and blink at him. “This is the memory you picked?”
“I picked at random. Where are we, exactly?”
“Harlem. 2012.”
“2012?”
“Surprise!” I wave around the spatula in my hand. “You’re in the future.”
“How are we in the future?”
“I experience time differently than you do. Oh! Here, look at this.” I pull a smartphone out of my pocket and hand it to him.
Ben studies it, pensive. “What is this?”
“Cellphone.”
Ben huffs a laugh. “You’re joking.”
Just then, my roommates come walking through the door, and I turn back to the stove in the hopes that they’ll ignore me and go to their rooms. No such luck. I remember this night. They were tipsy and extra cruel.
But instead of allowing them to hurl hurtful comments at me, Ben steps in with an exceptionally dry, “You let fashion students who can’t properly dress themselves bully you?”
Both my roommates take a second to reboot, since it’s clearly obvious they’re unfamiliar with men not fawning over them. “Who are you?”
Ben ignores the question and asks his own. This interrogation goes on until he’s satisfied he’s gathered enough intel. “Cora,” Ben says loudly into the silence, “let me get this straight. Your roommates don’t know how to cook, they don’t pick up after themselves, and they’re not at all charming, funny, or particularly interesting. And you were jealous of these women. . . because?”
“Hey,” one of my roommates snaps, “what the fuck, asshole?”
I ignore her and offer Ben a shrug in answer. “They’re pretty.”
His eyebrows scrunch in confusion. “Next to you? HA! Don’t make me laugh.”
Unable to think of an actual witty remark, my roommates resort to uncomfortable laughter. “Okay,” they say, drawn out and sarcastic.
Ben never stops staring at them like he’s embarrassed on their behalf. “If I could have just a sliver of your deluded self confidence, I could overthrow every major government by tomorrow morning. Just look at you. Fashion is inherently derivative, and yet you still disappoint in every way. And I don’t know why you’re laughing,” Ben says, pointing to the other roommate. “You clearly don’t understand color theory. Looking at you makes me feel like I’ve just woken from a lobotomy.”
He’s mean, and his comments are precise enough to actually hurt their feelings, but for once I don’t feel bad. I never did anything to either of my roommates except play their surrogate mother, and how did they treat me in return? Loudly repeat their shared weekend plans without inviting me, eat all my leftovers in the fridge even though I’m the poorest member of the group, and continue to leave the apartment a mess for me to clean up no matter how many times I ask them to help.
So, no. I don’t feel bad. In fact, the more intense Ben roasts them both, the harder I laugh. It’s nice having someone defend me for once.
"Hey," I ask him, "can I make a special request?"
Ben’s answer is an immediate, “Of course.”
"Can I see a memory from when you knew me in the 70s?"
Our friendship has given me adequate time to understand how to read Ben's actual reaction to things. I usually only need a few months to clock people’s reactions for what they really are, but Ben's poker face is lethal. Trying to figure out tiny change's in his expression or mannerisms took time and patience. And right now? All the signs are there for a solid no.
"Alright," says Ben.
His answer is so surprising, I cannot hide the confusion on my face. “No, it's okay. You don't have to show me."
“No,” Ben says, swiftly turning on his heal and leading me to a door. "No, it's fine."
"Benjamin." I say his name, once, firmly but kindly. Not a warning, but a reassurance. "Come here."
"Cora, it's alright." Ben waves a hand in the direction of the door. "You can look."
Nothing about the way he's standing ramrod straight—or the way his thumb and forefinger have been furiously worrying against each other in tiny strokes—says he wants to show me. Yet, he persists.
Does he think he’s not entitled to boundaries because he’s a man? Because he’s mortal? Because he’s my husband? “Ben, you’re allowed to have secrets.”
“It’s not a secret,” he states flatly, but his rapidly reddening face says otherwise. “It’s just. . .”
I wait for him to finish his thought, but the longer it takes, the more my anxiety begins to stew at all the many reasons he wouldn’t want to show me. He's shown me dozens of embarrassing memories. Why would these be any different? Unless. . . he's afraid I'll see something that will make me hate him forever. What if he did kill me? What if that's why he's skipped over every memory he has from the time I was alive in the 70s?
“I don’t want you to think less of me,” he says.
Oh shit. Did I guess correctly? “Why would I think less of you?”
“Because,” he starts confidently, but the rest of his sentence dies on his lips. “Because,” he repeats after a long pause, “I was a very. . . focused youth.”
“Focused?”
“I was annoying,” he admits in an aggravated rush. “I was an obnoxious child that followed you around all the time and I don’t want you to relive it.”
I'm an asshole. A nervous laugh burst out of me at the guilt I feel for entertaining the idea he killed me. “Ben, all kids are annoying. I was a very annoying child. It kinda comes with the territory.”
“No,” Ben refutes with a wave of his hand, “no, you don’t understand. You were the first adult to care, and not just about my grades. You always made sure I ate lunch. You taught me how to make friends. You’re the entire reason I became an artist. It was the first time anyone had encouraged me to pursue one of my interests, so I didn’t want to let you down by giving up. Any free chance I had I was studying techniques and improving my work. You. . .” Ben sighs deeply. “Gail taught me how to be a good husband. The Bears taught me how to be a good friend. But you taught me how to be a good person. But," he adds in emphasis, "that journey was long and tedious and embarrassing, and I’d prefer not to share it.”
“I’m not asking you to share anything.” I feel the conflicting emotions clashing within him, and I want nothing more than to make him understand he has nothing to be embarrassed about. “Ben, have you ever been to Central Park?”
Outside this memory, our movements are drunken and sloppy and inexperienced, but nothing makes me feel more loved than wrapping my legs around his hips, our tongues swirling in each others mouth, the sound of skin slapping skin as he thrusts into me over and over.
Back in my memory, Ben and I take a walk around the city, since he’s never been to New York. We watch children play in the park and parents pushing their babies in strollers. I watch them, envious. In order for me to have that life, in order for the Goddess of Life to be satisfied, Ben must die.
I’m going to be a horrible mother.
How can I say this in a way that your Catholic mind can wrap around? You’re like the patron saint of children. So, no, you’re wrong. Ha! I got to tell a Goddess she was wrong. I’ll try not to let it go to my head.
What?
Cora, you’re better with children than most of their own parents. Where is this coming from, anyway?
Did I tell you I’m only just now finding out Christopher is a widower? We work together almost every day I’m on Hydra, and I’m just now asking him personal questions. I’ve only been a mother for a few months, and I’m already horrible at it.
Wait until you’ve been a parent for 16 years, then you can feel like a failure.
Oh please. You’re not a failure.
Yes, I am. Alex can’t stand me.
I make an affronted noise and raise an eyebrow. Alex is funny and creative and kind because that’s who she is, but you helped give her a safe place to grow into that person. And I can tell you right now, she loves you more than you will ever possibly understand. You raised a human being by yourself. That’s not something to write off. I had to raise my siblings, and I can tell you right now. . . that shit ain’t easy.
Ben groans, long and loud, his eyes quickly finding mine when the noise in his throat quiets down and he begins to grind against me, still fully inside. You’re already such a wonderful mother. I don’t want to hear you say otherwise.
You’re already a perfect father, and I don’t want to hear you say otherwise. I gasp sharply and then sigh with pleasure when he grinds especially hard, and soon he’s thrusting into me again because I want him to. If I could only feel this safe and happy all the time, there would never be war ever again.
But it doesn’t last forever, and the beauty and wonder of it all is over too soon.
I feel him leave my mind and my body as I lay panting against the hardwood of his living room, staring up at the ceiling. As the endorphins settle, and the throbbing aftershocks lessen, my face crumples up into tears and I begin to weep.
He’s immediately at my side. “Did I hurt you?”
I just killed him. How ironic that it was the Goddess of Life that kills him. The Norns suck. You hear me, Norns? You suck ass, and if we ever meet in real life I am absolutely rocking your shit with my bare fists.
“Cora," he asks again, "did I hurt you?”
“No,” I croak miserably. Magic still leaves my muscles twitching like a drug withdrawal. “I’m just drunk and I don’t want you to die.”
“Oh,” he exhales heavily in a shaking laugh, “is that all?”
“What do you mean is that all? That’s a very big deal!”
“Yes, well, we might have an even bigger deal on our hands.” Ben grits his teeth and hisses with pleasure as magic runs its course within his own body. “Because I need to tell you something.”
“What?”
Ben fixes me with his blue eyes, and it’s only then that I realize they’re especially captivating right now because the irises are glowing brightly. “I think I just saw the future.”
Chapter 26: The Road To Hell Is Paved With Good Intentions
Notes:
TW: Just wanted to pop in here and let you know this chapter has a flashback scene with implied rape/non-con (not the MC). It's not graphic and doesn't actually show the act, but I just wanted to give anyone a heads up in case any mention is a hard NO for you.
Let the bi-panic commence, baby!!!
Chapter Text
“Is it that noticeable?”
“Your eyes are literally glowing, Ben. Yes, it’s noticeable.”
Ben hands me a glass of water as we try to sober up in the miserable few hours before dawn. “Well,” he offers when it’s clear I’m not going to speak first, “I mean, we don’t know for certain that. . . that this is it. Right?”
“No.” I take a shaking sip and wipe my eyes dry so I can see him better. Both the blues of his iris glow in the dim lighting of his house, and it’s equal parts mesmerizing and terrifying. “I guess not,” I say. It’s a lifetime before I finish off my glass and he automatically gets up to refill it. “Wait, what do you mean you saw the future? How is that even possible? I thought men physically couldn’t practice magic?”
“I’m not entirely sure what happened.” Ben fills my glass in the sink and returns looking as worn out and drunk as ever. “It was difficult to discern what I was looking at. To be honest. . . I think we were dead.”
“Who’s we? Us?”
“Everyone.You were visiting me. And Alex. And Chris.” Ben attempts to take a sip from his own cup and ends up dropping it by accident. Sighing heavily in defeat, he looks for a broom to clean up the shards of glass. “Fólkvangr didn’t look anything like I thought it would.”
Ben saw the afterlife? There’s an afterlife? An afterlife in which I get to visit him whenever I want? But. . . how does that work, exactly? I thought I was supposed to die for good? “What did it look like?”
“Well,” he answers as he finishes sweeping up the glass. “For starters, I lived in a normal house in what looked like a normal suburb.” Ben pauses to try and recall the vision. “You came over for dinner. My father was there for some reason. But we were. . . happy.” After he dumps the dustpan in the trash and wipes up the remaining mess, he takes a seat beside me at the table. “It was comforting to know it all works out. Even in death.”
I understand what he means. It is comforting to know that death isn’t really the end. Even if I can’t fix what happened—even if I’m doomed to a violent and bloody destiny—it’s nice to know we still find each other when it’s all over.
“I don’t know when it happens, and I’m sorry what I saw couldn’t be more helpful.” Ben reaches over and takes my hand in his. “But even if I die tomorrow,” he promises, “know that I have no regrets. If I’m about to die tomorrow, know that I love you.”
“I love you, too.” I believe him, and that makes all of this even more unbearably painful. He’s much more drunk than I am, but I still find myself lightheaded with nervous laughter. “But I don’t for a second believe you have no regrets. Not a single one?”
“Well,” he corrects with a sly smile. “To be completely honest, I would have preferred my first time to not immediately result in my demise, but such is life, I suppose.”
I literally tell myself not to do it, and still my brain commands my jaw to fall open. “You’re a virgin?” I point at the spot on the floor by the couch. “Up until just now?”
“Does that surprise you?”
“A little. I mean, if Gail was forcing you to go to nightclubs and stuff, I just thought. . . I don’t know.”
“What? You thought Gail carted me around Europe and dropped me off at brothels like a daycare center?” Ben waits for me to stop laughing before admitting, “When she was explaining my role as your future husband, she gave me the crumpled up paper speech.”
“NO!” I laugh harder, but only because I’m mortified at the thought. I remember the paper speech and the chewing gum speech and the flower speech. Each was it’s own form of misogynistic bullshit about purity culture. “She did not. Please tell me you’re lying.”
“She crumpled up a piece of paper and told me to try and flatten it out so I could write on it the same way I could write on a fresh piece.” Ben snorts a laugh. “I told her anyone who wasn’t able to write on it any differently than a fresh piece was just embarrassed about their poor penmanship, and it had nothing to do with the paper itself. She was not amused. Got beat for that one.”
I don’t laugh at this. All that comes out of my mouth is a sad, “Oh.”
“Anyway, if it turns out my life clock is ticking it’s final minutes, I’d rather not spend them depressed. I have a gift for you,” he announces randomly and pushes up from his seat at the kitchen table. “I was saving it for your birthday, but I better give it to you now while I still can.” Ben hurries away into his bedroom and returns with a clanking sack of something. Reaching deep inside, he pulls out a small box and hands it to me.
Inside is the most beautiful piece of jewelry I’ve ever laid eyes on. The gold necklace has a solid metal neckline detailing dozens of different animals set with sparkling bits of blown glass. I can tell he’s made this himself, and I can only guess how many weeks or months or years it took him to perfect. It’s not a necklace so much as it’s a work of art. I smile up at him and ask, “You trade someone for barbecue sauce?”
“No.” Amusement spreads across his face. “I stole it from a museum. Will you wear it?”
“I’ll wear it right now if you put it on me.” The second it’s fastened, I take off running for the bathroom mirror, his laughter ringing out behind me. Ben’s still seated at the kitchen table when I return.
“Do you like it?”
“I love it.” And I do. I really do. But I’m also dying to know what the hell else is in that bag. I point a finger and ask, “What’s in there?”
He sighs dramatically. “One extravagant necklace isn’t good enough for you?”
“No, I’m just nosy.”
Ben reaches down and dumps the bag out onto the kitchen table. Dozens of boxes containing rings and bracelets and decorative chainlink shoulder-ware tumble out in front of me. I don’t even know where to begin, so I don’t bother trying them on one-by-one. With Ben’s help, I put on every single thing he’s made me over the past 28 years until I’m draped head to toe in gold.
I pose with my arms out, and then I jerk my body back and forth just to hear the metallic tinkling. “I’m going to be the most obnoxious person on this entire island.” Ben laughs again, love and affection evident in his eyes, and my laughter devolves into stubborn tears. “Would you really do anything I ask you to?” I manage to choke out in-between sobs. “I command you not to die.”
We hold tight for hours, each making our peace with what little time we’ve been given.
I see love everywhere I go.
It’s in the conversations between friends on Hydra. It’s in the children who sprint to the beach, screaming their hellos when they see their father has come to visit. It’s in the way couples lean in close and try their best to make each other laugh. It’s in words, and it’s in actions.
There was a time when seeing parents show a genuine interest in their children—not just their sons—that would have given me an emotional meltdown. Now, it brings me peace. There’s nothing that can fix the fact that my parents didn’t love me, but that’s nobody’s fault but their own. It’s not my fault, and it’s not these children’s fault. I understand that now, but more importantly, I accept it. Accepting it has set me free.
Now when I see fathers toss their giggling little ones in the air, or teach their daughters self defense, or encourage their sons to help more around the house, a part of me heals.
So when Juliet shows up on Hydra to personally and privately deliver me the news that I’m not pregnant, it takes a solid ten seconds for my brain to figure out how I feel. The first thing out of my mouth is, “Are you sure?”
“It’s been 16 days,” she answers. “We can usually tell definitively by week two, so your bloodwork is a definite negative.”
I had a plan. A plan to not make this more awkward than it needs to be. Everything falls apart the second she starts talking.
“I’m so sorry.” It’s obvious Juliet wants to hug me, but she’s also not entirely sure if I’m dangerous or not. “I wish it were better news.”
I wipe my face dry and fight the urge to turn away. “No, I’m relieved.” Taking a shaking breath, I say, “I’ve never been more relieved in my entire life.”
“Oh,” she says, surprised. “I. . . does he—I’m sorry. It’s not my business.”
“No, it’s okay. Ask away.”
“Is it because James doesn’t want children?”
I fight every instinct telling me to frown in confusion. Luckily, I’m able to remember that everyone thinks I’m sleeping with him, and I smile sadly instead. “No, he doesn’t. So this saves me an awkward conversation. I would really appreciate if you didn’t tell anyone about this.”
“I haven’t even told Jack.”
“You are at the very top of my Christmas list,” I say, laughing. “Oh! Since you’re here, you should stay for the Freyja festival in a few days.”
“Freyja festival?”
“Christmas. Yule. Freyja festival. Apparently it’s all the same thing. It’s going to be a whole week of. . . I’m not entirely sure, but if my people are throwing it, it’s going to be fun. How is Jack, by the way? Any luck on some kind of healing medicine?”
“No news yet, I’m afraid,” Juliet tells me as I walk her to the guesthouses. “Jack’s working himself ragged trying to figure out why all of your samples are no different than the rest of ours.” Her cheerful smile is less pained than usual, and I can only guess it’s because she’s getting along so well with him. I guess it makes sense. They’re both doctors who just want to fix people.
After setting her up in the guesthouse, I start the walk back to the longhouse to write Ben the good news, but I’ve barely entered the front door before Pris flags me down.
“There’s a very sweaty young man here to see you,” she says.
“Karl?” I spot him sitting at a table close to my bedroom, his head cradled miserably in both his hands. “What’s wrong?”
Karl jumps up from the table and rushes me. “Lady Cora, you have to help me. Finn’s gonna kill me!”
“Okay. Okay. Calm down. Just start from the beginning.”
“I was helping my mom bring in the laundry, and then suddenly my mom was gone, and then she just came out of nowhere and started talking to me, and I don’t—”
“Who?” I interrupt, but Karl’s talking so fast I can barely understand him anyway. “Who started talking to you?”
Karl looks around the longhouse with so much panic in his eyes, I start to worry. “Hazel.”
“Okay.” I don’t like where this is going. “What did she say?”
“She asked me what I was doing on Hydra,” he explains a mile a minute, “and I told her I was helping my mom with my little sisters, and then suddenly we were talking about how neither of us wants children, and she seemed really surprised, so I started trying to explain my reasoning, and then she said—” Karl takes a gulping breath. “—and then she said she thinks it’s nice that I know what I want, and that I. . . I think she said I wasn’t hideous to look at? But that it was a shame she couldn’t tell for certain because of my beard. She said I should shave my face and visit her again, and it felt like I was having a stroke, so I said You’re asking me to visit you? And she said No, I’m ordering you to. And I don’t know what to do, Lady Cora! I was just trying to finish the laundry! I was just trying to finish the laundry!”
“Calm down. Karl? Calm down, everything’s going to be okay.”
“No it’s not!” Karl’s fingers shake through his long hair, his entire body trembling at the thought of upsetting his friend. “I think she likes me, which means Finn’s going to challenge me to a Holmgang and. . . and. . . I can’t fight him! He’s my friend! What do I do?”
“Nobody is fighting anybody, I promise.” I smile and remain calm in the hopes that he’ll believe what I’m about to say. “Do you like Hazel?”
Karl pauses to think. “I don’t know. Finn’s always liked her, so courting her has never been an option before.”
“Well, you think on it.” Doing my job is kinda fun. “Let me worry about Finn.”
Gail is helping me finish preparing for another rite of passage ceremony at the temple when Finn shows up unannounced with more love woes. He’s been spending a lot of time with Alex recently, but despite my third party observation that they would make a great match, neither of them seems to have realized this themselves.
In fact, one of the nights Finn was visiting, he and Alex were hanging out in her room and Ben made me go check on them even though the door was open the entire time. When I peeked inside, Alex was holding up two CDs and asked him to choose between Backstreet Boys or Nsync while he started complaining that nobody told him he had to choose. Alex immediately said “wrong!” and told him the answer is neither because Hazel hates boy bands. Finn literally screamed like he was dying.
Now, just as dramatic as ever, Finn flops at my feet and rests his head in my lap. “Lady Cora, I’m never going to meet another woman like Hazel, and I’m going to die miserable and alone.”
I keep my head up but look down at him with my eyes as Gail finishes painting my face. “I’ve met Hazel. Trust me, you don’t want to marry her. She’s kinda. . .” Back home, she would have been goth or punk or emo or some other kind of subculture.
“Weird? I know,” Finn clarifies miserably. “That’s the entire reason I like her!”
“Finn? You know,” I suggest slowly, “I was thinking. You and Alex have been spending a lot of time together. What about. . . her?”
Finn gives me a look of surprise, and then he bursts out laughing, only stopping when I don’t join in. “Oh, you’re being serious?”
“Serious as a heart attack.”
You’d think I’d just suggested he fling himself into the sun. Both hands find his fauxhawk and worry it as he tells me, “No, no, no, Lady Cora. I can’t marry Alex. It would never work!”
“Why not?” I can’t help but feel defensive on her behalf. “Do you not like being around her?”
“What?” Finn looks confused at the question. “No. Of course I do. She’s a riot.”
“Do you not find her attractive?”
Finn blows a raspberry. “She’s probably the most beautiful woman on all of Hydra.”
The most beautiful? Sounds like a confession to me. “Is she obnoxious?”
“Not at all.”
“I’m not seeing a problem here, Finn.”
Finn looks around to make sure we’re still alone, and then he leans in close and whispers, “She’s the only one who knows I peed my pants when I was nine. An octopus grabbed me with its tentacle, and I’m terrified of octopuses. If any of the guys find out, they’ll never let me hear the end of it.”
“Uh-huh.” I stare at him in confusion, but he just stares blankly back. “Okay,” I say, “let me see if I’m understanding this. You can’t marry someone you find beautiful, funny, who shares your hobbies, and you trust enough to keep your most embarrassing secrets?”
Finn nods, happy that I understand, and then his face goes blank as he finally understands. “Oh, wait, I see your point.”
“Right.” I stand, already laughing, and head for the door leading out into the courtyard. “Well, you think on it and we’ll talk again soon.”
“You’re taking off your dress? Here?"
Making sure to keep it away from the sludgy ground, I roll up my gown and place it on a clean patch of moss. I used to think corsets were for contorting your body into the slimmest shape possible, but now I understand my gowns are corseted to support my chest without the need for a bra, which is great when I want a strapless dress but bad when I need to take it off so I don’t get mud all over it. Humid island air feels strange against my bare breasts. This is the first time I’ve been naked out in the open.
I frown up at Ben and ask, “Why are you complaining?”
“I mean—” Ben looks around the surrounding trees, but it’s no use. His eyes always trail back to me. Thankfully, the light of his iris’s have dulled to a barely detectable glow over time, and as far as I know, nobody has questioned it. “Someone might see you.”
“Shut up before I make you come down here in my place,” I shout up at him from the bottom of a muddy ravine. “I’m doing you a big favor being down here alone. And I like this dress. I’m not about to put Pris through the headache of trying to get mud stains out of it.”
“Fine,” he relents a little too easily. “But if I see anyone come within range, I’m shooting them.”
“Don’t shoot anyone,” I huff under my breath and start sifting through the mud with my boots.
After a while, Ben asks, “What are you looking for, anyway?”
“I’m not sure. Remember how I said this tree looked familiar? I think I may have seen it one of the times I died. Can’t think of any other reason it would look familiar. Hey,” I shout when my boot kicks against something lodged deep in the mud. “I found something!”
“What is it?”
Even thought it’s completely covered in mud, I can tell the shape is human. “Oh no. . . Oh my God!"
“It’s a dead body, isn’t it?”
“Worse.” I squat to get a better look, and suddenly I want to throw up. "So much worse."
“What’s worse than a dead body?”
I swallow down bile as I stare at a pile of small skeletal remains still dressed in a tunic. “It’s a child.”
One thing he’s never outright told me—but I’ve observed all on my own—is that Ben hates being dirty. He hates it so much, I’ve even started carrying Dharma brand wet wipes in my satchel just in case he needs one. I can always fall back on the excuse that they’re for the children if he asks, since the last thing I want is to make him feel awkward. But despite all that, as soon as the words of my discovery were out of my mouth, Ben slid down the incline and into the mud beside me to help me calm down.
It was a whole ordeal. Ben helped me gather and wrap up the bones, clothing, and a sword much too big for the boy, so we could carry them back to the Temple. Miles was called in to hear the final thoughts of the boy, as the entire community waited on bated breath. A collective sigh of pure relief echoed through the Temple when Miles announced he hadn’t been murdered and had slipped down the steep hillside and died on impact.
Turns out the boy’s name was Bo, and he has only one living family member—a giant of a man by the name of Leif, who the Bears are all too eager to tell me is the most renowned rugby player in island history. And maybe he was once. Now? All I see is a grieving older brother. Without saying a word to anyone, Leif collected the remains of his eternally-young brother and set off to finally lay him to rest on a flaming ship pushed out to sea.
Freyja festival was supposed to kick off yesterday, but I’ve been so depressed I had Gail postpone it until I’m not constantly thinking about the dead child I found in the middle of the jungle. I haven’t been able to force myself back to Hydra ever since. I don’t want to see any children and be reminded of how fragile their lives are.
I sit in one of the many common areas in the Temple while the Bears sit all around me and eat with a ravenous hunger. But I can’t eat. Even the smell of food makes me nauseous. I can’t stop thinking about how that poor little boy will never eat or drink or laugh or cry ever again. It’s not fair, and it depresses me that I can’t do anything about it.
Kyle’s deep voice cuts through the clanging of silverware against dishes. “Are you alright, my lady?”
I look across the table to give another customary lie about how I’m just tired, when I feel something cold and wet soak into the back of my dress. I cry out, arching my back as if this can save me from the disgusting sensation of wet clothing clinging to my skin. When I spin around, one of the many unmarried men huffs a laugh, an empty goblet of wine in one hand.
“Apologies, my lady,” he says. “I tripped.”
Ben immediately shoots up from his seat, but I grab a fistful of his sleeve to keep him still. “Leave it alone,” I order sternly. I am so not in the mood for this shit. “It was just an accident.”
“No,” Ben seethes, but his anger is not directed at me. “He did that on purpose.”
“Calm down, little ferret,” the man sneers at Ben. “Lady Cora is right. It was just an accident. I’m sure our lady has plenty of other beautiful dresses she can wear. No harm done.”
Finn’s father—who is usually smiling 24/7—glares at the man and starts saying something in Norse. Kyle pipes in at one point, then Ben says something that makes the unmarried men seated at the back of the room snicker.
The man says something else. A single sentence. All I understand is one word. A swear word. Maya taught me all the swear words. I don’t know everything he just said, but I do know he just called me a whore.
The hall falls completely silent with the anticipation of a fight, but Ben and the rest of the Bears just look intensely confused, like they can’t wrap their head around what he’s just said.
I can’t remember his name, but I’ve seen this man before. Usually, he sticks to a specific clique of unmarried young men and doesn’t talk to me or anyone on team Bear. He’s much taller and heavier than Ben, which probably doesn’t bode well for his chances at another Holmgang. And from the way Ben is staring, the thought of him blurting out a request to avenge my honor isn’t far fetched.
Luckily, Ben doesn’t need to avenge my honor. He never even gets the chance to.
Leif is so quiet, I didn’t even know he was in this room. He doesn’t say a word as he passes by our table and strides towards the man. All the smugness wipes clean from the much shorter man’s face as Leif relentlessly pursues him until he gets backed up against a table. With nowhere else to go, the man cowers down onto a seat like a child, and the silence is deafening. Much like a wolf course correcting an unruly pup, Leif’s message is in what’s not being said aloud. Every man at the table averts his eyes, except for the one who spoke to me. He stares up at the most renowned sports star in island history until shame forces him to avert his eyes.
Out of nowhere, Leif speaks in the deepest baritone I’ve ever heard in my entire life. It surprises me. It surprises every single person in the hall, actually.
“You stupid young bucks.” Eyes drop down to the table in shame, but that doesn’t stop Leif from burning holes into each and every one of them. “If I catch so much as a sniff from any fucking one of you—” His baritone cuts off sharply, leaving the threat hanging heavy in the silence. Suddenly, there’s noise in the form of wood scraping stone as Leif lifts up the table with one hand and shoves it hard enough to cause the sitting men to scatter. “Try your best not to cause your families irreparable shame while you’re still alive. Because if I ever hear that shit again, you won’t have time to pray to any of your gods before I end you.”
Those men don’t respect me, but they do respect their hero, Leif. And their hero just called them cowards and threatened to kill them on my behalf.
Fights are much more common at the Temple than they should be, but after they’re over, everything always goes back to normal. But when Leif exits out into the nearest hallway, the usual hum of amused chatter doesn’t follow in his wake. Even Finn’s father doesn’t have anything to say.
Turns out Leif isn’t some old antisocial grump with a chip on his shoulder. No, it turns out Leif just has massive social anxiety. After dinner, I went to privately thank him for sticking up for me, and we had a very enlightening talk. It took a little bit of coaxing on my end, but we eventually talked, and he’s a sweetheart. An absolute sweetheart who doesn’t know how to read English.
So, naturally, we strike a deal because these people love striking deals. I teach Leif how to read English and he teaches me how to read runes. Every night this week has been spent in his room at the Temple, teaching each other by candlelight.
I like Lief. He never makes me feel uncomfortable, and I’d like to think my company helps him feel a little less lonely. I’m well versed in all the ways depression can wreak havoc on your ability to seek out the company of others, and Leif hasn’t sought out the company of anyone since his younger bother went missing almost 20 years ago. My nights spent teaching him English are just as much a rewarding friendship as any of the friendships I’ve made on Hydra.
It’s a night like any other night when I return to my room after a long but successful lesson and find Ben unexpectedly waiting for me on a chair by the fireplace.
“Hey,” I call to him as I hang up my cloak in my wardrobe. “I didn’t know you’d be visiting.” My stomach does a flip when he doesn’t respond. Bad news from the barracks? What’s happened this time? “Are you okay?”
Ben stares into the crackling fireplace, turning at last to ask, “Is there anything you’d like to tell me?”
I rack my memories to see if I can remember doing something to piss him off, but I come up empty. “No?”
According to Ben’s muted upset, whatever I did is borderline unforgivable. His eyes remain fixed on something across the room. They dart over to look at me without warning. “How long has it been going on?”
“How long has what—?”
“Don’t,” he cuts me off with one hand raised, as if to waft away my answer. “Please just tell me the truth.”
“Ben, I’m sorry, but I genuinely don’t understand what you’re asking.”
“How long have you been—?” It takes him a second to get the question out. “How long have you been sleeping with Leif?”
I open my mouth to respond, but nothing comes out. Usually, when I’m this upset, I laugh to help release some of the nerves. But I just stare at him, silent. “I’m not sleeping with him,” I finally answer. “I’m teaching him how to read.”
Instead of apologizing, Ben just seems to get more upset. “Is that some kind of euphemism I’m unaware of?”
Ben’s supposed to be above all this. He’s supposed to believe me no matter what. Why is he doing this? I’m calm, and it kinda scares me. “If I didn’t know any better, I’d think you’ve been expecting me to have an affair.” As I continue to stare at him in disbelief, my stomach feels like a bottomless pit, and my heart physically hurts. “Random men can call me a whore because I don’t care what they have to say. But you? I don’t know. I guess I thought you’d be different. My mistake.” I hold up a hand when he tries to apologize. “Get. Out.”
I can only guess what thoughts are racing through his mind as he tries to gain control of the situation. I’m not sure what it is that convinces him, but I can see the moment he realizes I’m being serious. By then, it’s too late. Now I’m angry.
We’ve fought a few times before, but never like this. Usually when we fight, we just have sex and then we’re not mad anymore. Right now, I don’t want to have sex with him. Right now, I’m so repulsed by his accusation that I don’t know if I ever want to have sex with him again.
“If you say one more word,” I threaten, “I will never speak to you again. Get out, now.”
Depression is a bitch. Or maybe I’m not depressed? I don’t know. It was easy to tell I was depressed after I was attacked by that psycho who was originally after Alex. Back then, I couldn’t eat or sleep and had no desire to leave my room. This time it feels different, and yet it feels exactly the same. Like I’m rotting from the inside out. Only, this time I have just enough energy to force myself out into the sun.
One night, completely spontaneously, I look at myself in the mirror and have a complete and utter nervous breakdown. Grabbing a pair of heavy metal scissors, I hack through my thick braid until my shortened bob springs free and fans around my face. Now I can’t stop staring at myself in my bedroom mirror in an attempt to figure out if I like it or not.
“Cora?”
“One second, Gail.” I finish wiping off my table and fluff my newly shortened hair, still unsure what I think. “Sorry,” I say as I swing open the door, “I was just—”
Gail eyes my hair with a hint of confusion and steps to the side, allowing Ben more room in the doorway. An overwhelming mixture of sheer terror, immeasurable joy, and deathly rage paralyze me as it sinks in that he’s here.
“Cora?” Gail says loudly, and I have no idea how many times she was trying to get my attention. “Will you be needing anything else? I’m going to turn in for the night.”
“No,” I whisper. “No,” I say louder. “Thank you, Gail. Goodnight.”
Ben and I stare at each other while we wait for Gail to walk the length of the longhouse and leave. I refuse to speak first, no matter how long our game of chicken lasts.
“I can continue standing out here if you’d like,” Ben offers. “Although, I must admit, it makes me feel a bit like a vampire.”
I don’t laugh. I don’t invite him in. I don’t say anything at all because my expression tells him everything he needs to know.
Ben clears his throat. “You cut your hair."
"Nothing gets past you," I snap irritably.
"It looks nice."
"I know. How else is it supposed to look?"
"You don't seem very happy to see me.”
“That’s because I didn’t call for you.”
“Yes, well, my apology wasn’t exactly one I could fulfill by simply writing you another letter. I assume you tossed them all in the fireplace without reading them?” What little hope he was clinging to vanishes as my expression hardens even more. “Cora,” he begs in little more than a breath, “please let me apologize.”
With a jerk of my arm, I beckon him inside and slam the door behind him. Frowning with everything I’ve got, I cross my arms and snap, “What?”
“Cora, my anger had absolutely nothing to do with your virtue and everything to do with…” Ben pauses, and I have no idea why admitting he was jealous is such a big deal. “Fine,” he finally admits. “You want me to say I was jealous? There. I was jealous.”
I can’t roll my eyes hard enough. “Yeah, no shit. I know that.”
“No. No, you don’t know,” he says in a nervous rush, hesitating on the last words. “I was jealous of the both of you.”
What does that even mean? “Oh my God,” I yell, leaning forward in anticipation. “Are you gay? I knew it!”
“Why are you yelling?” Ben’s entire expression wrinkles with confusion. “And I’m not gay, I—wait, what do you mean you knew it?” When I don’t offer up an answer, he continues to explain. “I was jealous that you got to spend time with him. He never talks to anyone! Not even his old Wolf teammates. I’ve never actually heard him speak before.”
“Oh. Okay. So. . . you don’t have a crush on him?”
“No,” Ben says pointedly, but his serious expression softens with nervous worry. “But would that be a bad thing?”
“You can have a crush on him. It’s okay.”
“I don’t,” he snaps, frustrated, and I immediately stop teasing him. “I’m just asking if that would be. . . if it would—” Ben tries a few times to finish his question, to no avail.
“Hey.” I raise my hands up, palm out. “Whatever it is you’re trying to say, you can tell me. I promised I would never laugh at you.”
“Do you like kissing me?”
“Of course I do.”
“I don’t know why I’m telling you this,” he says up at the ceiling. “Ever wonder why I’m good at it?” I can tell he panics at the last second and changes his answer. I can feel his nerves firing off like crazy. “I’m a natural born kisser, that’s why.”
“Who was it?” Annie. It was totally Annie. Ben looks so uncomfortable, I start to feel bad. In an effort to make him laugh, I ask, “Come on, you can tell me. Who did you enlist to help you train in the art of smooching?”
Ben swipes a hand across his rapidly sweating forehead. “Promise you won’t be angry?”
Wow, he’s really nervous to tell me. Oh, Jesus, was it Gail? I am not prepared for the level of messed up that is. “I promise.”
Ben takes a deep breath and admits, “Kyle.”
“Oh! I totally should have guessed that. Wait,” I ask, deeply confused, “so. . . you are gay?"
“No,” he says, exasperated. “It doesn’t have anything to do with him being a man and you being a woman. All that matters to me… is that he is Kyle and you are Miss Collins.”
All the love rising up in my heart stalls at the end of his sentence. Miss Collins? Teacher me. Way before he knew me as Freyja. Back when he thought I was a regular mortal. Nothing special about me except for who I am. That’s the moment he fell in love with me. He fell in love with me all on his own.
I used to think maybe Ben wanted to sleep with a deity, or maybe even a monster, but now I think he just wants to sleep with his mom. Or, at least someone who fills that gaping hole in his heart where she should have been.
“Do you still love him?” I ask. “Kyle?”
“Of course I still love him. I’ll always love him. Love doesn’t have to mean I want to have sex with him. That ship sailed many, many years ago. Sometimes things just don’t work out.” Ben looks at me out of the corner of his eyes. “You’re not angry?”
“About what," I ask. "So you kissed a guy. . . who cares? Seriously, nobody cares. I certainly don’t.”
“You don’t?”
“Does it change what we have? Do you still find me attractive?”
Ben immediately looks exasperated. “I wasn’t lying about that!”
“Yes, but do you find this attractive?” I pull my dress down over my boobs and immediately reverberate with the force of his attraction. “Oh,” I say with a hint of surprise. “Honey, you’re just bi.”
“You want me to leave?”
“No, not bye,” I start laughing, but it looks like Ben misunderstands.
I’m not laughing at him. In fact, the more I think about what he’s just confessed, the less funny the situation becomes. He’s always freely offering up embarrassing or complicated secrets about himself, and I haven’t really shared much beyond the worst night of my life. And even then, I was lying about what really happened. I trust him, don’t I?
“I don’t know why I was so nervous to tell you.” Ben lets out a shaky sigh of relief. “You’re one of very few people who understands.” His eyes trail over to me, and he smiles when he notices my confusion. “You don’t have to be embarrassed about it.”
All the red flags in my brain start firing off at once until I’m lightheaded. “Embarrassed about what?”
“Listen,” he says, “I’m not going to lie and say I’m ecstatic, but I’ve thought about it, and I realized that if sleeping with…listen, you can sleep with whoever you want, and I promise I won’t get angry.” He waves a hand around in the air like that’s only a partially true statement. “Well, I can at least promise not to get angry while you’re around.”
“What are you talking about?” Why would he be pushing for me to have an affair? I’ve never once mentioned I wanted an affair. "Oh! Is this about James? Yeah, funny story, but I actually started that rumor. I'm not actually sleeping with James."
"I know you're not sleeping with James," he says.
Do I have any romantic attraction to James? Absolutely not. But something about Ben's insinuation makes me furious. "And how do you know that? What? You don't think I could seduce him if I wanted to?"
Ben's eyebrows twitch together, matching his uncomfortable frown. "Considering you're related, I sure hope not."
"Related?"
"Are you. . . not related?" I watch Ben's eyes shift around while he thinks. "I mean, I guess you could have meant literally."
"What are you talking about?"
"Sorry," he says with a small shake of his head. "When I was a child, you told me he was like a brother to you. So, when he crashed here coincidently on the same flight, I thought maybe you had said that because it was easier than explaining there was more than one deity on the island."
I snort. "This whole time you thought James was a God?"
"Up until you just laughed, yes."
I think back on the early days of the plane crash, suddenly remembering something that doesn't make sense. "You thought James was my brother, and your first thought was to put him on trial and execute him?"
"I was never going to execute him," Ben says, exasperated. "I was trying to get a feel for who the new Freyja was. None of us could be sure what kind of Goddess would be reborn, so I wanted to test your empathy."
"Test my empathy? Test my empathy? Says the man who manipulated me into marrying him."
"You're still upset about that?" To his credit, Ben immediately realizes his mistake and says, "Yes. Of course you are. Right. Sorry. That was admittedly a horrible plan."
"You think?"
"It wasn't entirely my idea," he offers. "Seer Helga and Gail were the ones who facilitated most of the strategy."
I roll my eyes at the copout answer. "But you were more than willing to go along with it, so it might as well have been your idea."
Ben opens his mouth to argue, but he thinks about it a little longer and ends up silently looking uncomfortable enough for me to genuinely feel sorry for him.
How much of this is actually his fault? Ben was forced into a cult as a child. Still, at what point does that stop being an excuse? "I'm sorry you were roped into all of this when you were young, but you're a grown adult now." I pause, waiting for his focus to trail back to my face. "I looked you in the eye and told you I didn't want to get married, and you chose not to respect that."
"You're right," he says slowly. "You're right. I should have spoken up. It was. . . selfish of me not to speak up. I'm sorry."
If I got my apology, why do I still feel so angry? “Thank you for apologizing. But can you see why accusing me of having an affair adds insult to injury?" Oh no. Are his accusations all projection? "Are you having an affair?”
Ben looks both confused and insulted. “I’m not having an affair! You’re having an affair! Good gods, you’re making this much more difficult than it needs to be. I’m trying to be nice.”
“I literally just told you I’m not sleeping with Leif or James!”
“This isn’t about them.” Ben studies me in silence while I try to figure out what he means. “Oh. This is awkward.”
“Yeah, you think?”
“I’m sorry, it’s just. . . there was a moment there when I was sure I was losing out to Kate. Which, I mean, fair, but—”
I cut him off with an angry, “What are you talking about?”
Ben shoots me a heavy-lidded annoyed look. “Oh please. You still flirt with that woman to this day. You were flirting with her just last week right in front of me.”
“No I wasn’t—”
“See my memories,” he demands, smiling. “It sounds like you need a refresher. Go on.”
“I don’t need to see your memories because I already know I have never flirted with Kate. But you’d like that, wouldn’t you?”
“No,” he snaps in a deceptively calm tone. That’s when I notice there’s no magic pull wafting off him. He’s actually angry. “That’s the entire reason I’m bringing it up. It’s insulting to have my wife flirting with someone else while I’m standing right there. Not that it would be any better if I wasn’t there, but at least I wouldn’t have to see it.”
“Well then you’re in luck,” I yell. “Because I wasn’t flirting with her!”
Ben taps at his temple with an index finger. “You need to see this from another perspective.”
“Fine,” I shout so loud it feels like the longhouse is trembling. “Fine,” I say calmly. “But just so I can prove you wrong.”
The memory starts off exactly how I remember it. Ben and I were walking to the longhouse in one of the rare instances we actually had to talk island policy, when I saw Kate hanging out near the well.
I like talking to Kate. From what I can remember, she was hardly anyones diehard favorite in the show. There were popular internet groups dedicated to bashing her character, and although I never participated, I’m ashamed to have had a bias against her simply because she slept with a bunch of characters. After getting to know her better, I don't understand why she was so unpopular.
No one seemed to give a shit that Sawyer was a certified man-whore. Who cares about who Kate slept with? It doesn't change who she is as a person. She's sweet and caring and considerate and resourceful and really hot.
Really hot? I mean, she is, but what does that have to do with anything?
All my confidence weans, as I see the memory of myself glide over to her and ask, “Who let you out of the orchards?”
Kate smiles at the comment and hooks her thumbs through the belt straps of her jeans, rocking back and forth on her heals. “Sorry. James showed up during my shift and ruined the vibe. I can go back, if you want. I promise I’m not trying to escape.”
“Oh, that's good to hear.” I can see why Ben would think this is flirting, but it’s totally not. Girls can find other girls attractive and it’s not weird, right? I thought that was the entire perk of being a girl? Everything is homoerotic, and it’s completely normal. “Because we have cages just a little farther inland, and it would be a shame to have to lock you up.” Okay, wait. That one actually sounded seductive.
I nervously glance up at Ben, but he just gives me an annoyed look and points for me to pay attention. Kate makes a joke about geese, and I start laughing like it’s the funniest thing I’ve ever heard.
“That joke wasn’t funny,” Ben comments.
“No,” I reluctantly agree. “No, it wasn’t. But. . . I was just being nice.”
James calls to us from out of the jungle, but he doesn’t get the chance to proposition Kate further because I step in front of her like a small little shield. “Is the whole beach-bum-from-the-back-hills thing doing it for you, Kate?” Kate doesn’t answer, so I answer for her. “She doesn’t want to talk to you, James. Piss off.”
I didn’t see it then, but I notice it now. James knows. He knows and his surprise is momentary before it turns into a stunned nod of defeat and he wanders off with a dazed look in his eyes.
As soon as James is out of earshot, I turn back to Kate and touch her arm. I hate touching people. Why am I touching her? “Men are so annoying. Did I tell you he's been a real pain in the ass ever since he found out I'm part Italian?"
Kate looks amused. "How?"
"He won't stop adding A's to the end of every word, as if that suddenly makes it Italian." I roll my eyes. "Heya! It'sa da Cora! Whya don'ta you makea da spaghetti?"
Kate snorts a laugh but quickly tries to stifle it with a cough.
Panic squeezes my lungs until I can’t breathe, so I turn towards the door, and fling myself out of Ben’s mind.
“Do you believe me now?” Ben smiles smugly until he notices I’m having trouble breathing. “Hey, Cora, it’s alright. I’m not actually upset.” But his words don’t help my panic. “Cora,” he asks, sounding marginally more worried. “I promise I'm not angry. Cora, please say something. You’re scaring me.”
Guilt gnaws at my stomach until I blurt out, “I want you to see something. Can I show you a memory?”
“I don’t think that’s a good idea. You’re very upset right now.”
“Please,” I beg in a breathy sob.
I show him what happened, but I don’t watch. I don’t need to watch. I lived it. Turning away from the sight of myself returning home from my first day of 1st grade, I try to block out the memory of how eager I was to tell my mother all about my new crushes—the boy who sat to my left and the girl who sat in front of me. I was trying to explain what exactly I liked about each of them when she completely lost it. Both my hands flinch up to cover my ears and drown out the terrible things my mother screamed at me. Terrible things that have followed me my entire life.
Ben’s arms wrap around my shoulders as he guides me back out the door and away from the sight of a frightened child being slapped over and over by her religious mother.
We sit on my bed as I try to calm down by aggressively chewing my thumbnail. I haven’t chewed any of my fingernails since I was child. To his credit, Ben doesn’t leave after finding out the truth, but I'm still too ashamed to look at him.
I feel his hand in mine before he asks, “Are you okay?”
“Yeah, actually. I’m great.” I pull my thumb out of my mouth and try to practice the many anxiety mitigation techniques I’ve been working on with Harper. Be in the now, she’s always saying. “Sorry, it's just. . . I've spent a long time trying to forget that day, so I didn’t expect to feel so relieved telling someone. And I’m sorry about Kate. I honestly didn’t realize I was flirting, so I promise I’ll stop.”
“You don’t have to stop if you don’t want to."
“I want to,” I answer, but I can't help feeling like I'm lying on autopilot. "It makes you uncomfortable."
"What does that matter? Cora, you're the Goddess of Love. I'm just a human man."
"But you're still a part of this relationship," I say. "I care about your feelings, and I'm not going to do things that make you upset just because I'm the Goddess of Love."
"But that's not. . . listen, I've been thinking." Ben’s grip on my hand tightens just a little. "Everyone else's marriage only works because it's founded on mutual trust. I haven't. . . I haven't been entirely honest with you about my matrimonial intentions from the start. But I've also not been honest about. . . other things. I love you," he admits. "I do. And it's because I love you that you deserve the truth."
He hates me and wants a divorce?
"I'm not—I mean," he corrects uncomfortably, "I wasn't. . . what I mean to say is, that I wasn't—" Ben closes his eyes and clears his throat. His reddening face glistens with fresh sweat. "I lied to you. I wasn't a virgin when we met."
I wait for the jealousy to hit, but it never does. In fact, I flood with such intense relief, I lean forward and pull him into a hug. I feel his tense muscles relax when he realizes I'm not angry, and his arms eventually reach up and press against my back.
When I finally pull away, I ask, "Why did you think I would care?"
"A part of me believed you wouldn't, but Gail was so adamant that you would care, and. . . I don't know. After a while I started to worry that maybe she was right, and maybe you were watching me disapprovingly from somewhere in the nine realms."
"I was your Catholic Church?" I groan and rub my eyes. "This is horrible. I'm so sorry."
"You're not just saying that?"
"Was it Kyle?" Ben's small smile and inability to look me in the eye is answer enough. "Ben, I need you to believe me when I say not only do I not care, but I'm happy to hear it. I've been so worried you didn't make certain choices in life because you were told you had no choice but to marry me. To hear that you lived life anyway makes me happier than you can possibly imagine."
It's as if life has been breathed back into him.
I smile. "Do you mind if I ask why you didn't marry Kyle?"
"He dumped me." Ben snorts a laugh and looks up at the ceiling before looking back at me. "I wouldn't stop talking about you, and he eventually had enough. Said it was obvious who I had chosen. A few years later when he met his wife, I realized I was happy for him instead of jealous. That's how I knew things had officially changed. I'll always love him, but I'm no longer in love with him, if that makes sense. Which brings me to my next point." Gently, he squeezes my hand again. "I appreciate your offer about Kate, but I don't want you not to make certain choices in life because you were told you had no choice but to marry me. My only goal in life is to make you happy. And if Kate makes you happy, then so be it. Or," he adds, "anyone else, for that matter. As long as you don't forget about me."
"We're just two walking abandonment issues," I say, and Ben lets out one of his real laughs. “Huh.”
“What?”
“You and Kate? I just realized I don’t have a type.”
“Of course you have a type,” he corrects, smiling. “Sad brunettes.”
He loves me. He loves all of me. We still choose each other. After everything, we still choose each other over the what-ifs and the could-have-beens. I feel so happy I could cry.
“Do you want to. . .” I pause for only a few seconds before sighing. “Do you want to maybe. . . see more of my memories?”
Back and forth we hop from one of my memories to one of his. It’s scary at first. So scary, in fact, that there are multiple embarrassing memories of mine that literally make me want to vomit. But when I look over and see Ben isn’t laughing, it gets easier to share moments of my life without feeling the need to add caveats.
I step into one of his memories and recognize the main storage cellar in the Temple. Kyle is wrapping something up in cloth while Ben sits on a barrel, gently tapping at his swollen eye and nose and cheek.
Kyle gives a humph and presses some ice wrapped in cheesecloth against Ben’s massive black eye. “You just had to say something.”
“He was asking for it,” Ben complains.
“You couldn’t have waited until we were there to back you up? You know the Falcons roam in packs. They could have killed you.”
I only recognize the both of them because of the polaroid Ben showed me. As I step closer, I smile at how much smaller the two of them are at this age.
“Do you think she’ll be exactly like she was before the rebirth?” Ben asks randomly. “Or do you think she’s going to be a completely different person?”
“Good question,” Kyle responds without actually answering. “What do you think kissing your wife will be like?”
“Don’t talk about kissing my wife, Kyle,” Ben snarls, but it’s obviously in jest when he says, “Or I’ll have to challenge you to a Holmgang, and then I’ll overpower you with my obvious superior strength, and the Bears will lose their beloved team captain, and all of this will somehow be my fault.”
One second they’re laughing, and then suddenly Kyle leans in until their mouths touch.
Ben immediately pulls away from him. “What?!”
“Sorry,” Kyle says, backpedaling. “I’m so sorry. I. . . thought you were like me.”
Ben sounds so unbelievably tired when he yells, “I’m not gay!”
“I’m not gay either.”
Ben wipes his lips on his sleeve. “You just kissed me!”
“Yeah?” Kyle crosses his arms self consciously. “But I still like girls. Like, a lot.”
“Then why did you kiss me?”
“Because I like you, too.”
“That doesn’t make any sense.” Ben hops off the barrel and points at his friend. “You’re not making any sense!”
“Look, I know you’re scared about Freyja’s rebirth, so maybe if you practice, it’ll be one less thing to be afraid of.”
Ben’s halfway to the door when he stops and turns around. “Just kissing?” He clarifies. “Because you’re right. I need to practice so I don’t completely mess everything up. I asked if I could practice with Annie, and she broke my nose, so that's a no." Ben huffs a laugh at the memory. "I don’t have anyone else I trust.”
“I know.”
“No,” Ben snaps, “you don’t. It’s not you that has to impress a Goddess. You have absolutely no idea what I’m feeling right now. Why did they pick me?" Ben starts to panic so much his hands tremble. "She's going to hate me, Kyle. Just look at me! What am I going to do?”
Even though he’s already confessed this scene to me, Ben’s obviously uncomfortable at the sight of his first kiss. I grab hold of his hand and pull us back out the door.
“Come on,” I announce when we’re back in the black void. “Let’s just go back to my room and we can—"
“Oh, no you don’t,” Ben interrupts. “Let’s see another one of your awkward tween memories. Come on,” he begs, and for the first time, he sounds completely authentically himself. “One more? It’s only fair, right?”
“Fine,” I relent, and he takes off running. “Not so fast! You have longer legs, and you won’t shut up about them, so slow down!”
He’s still laughing when I catch up to the door he’s chosen. “I pick this one.”
“Is it unlocked?”
Ben knocks, and the door opens just a crack. It’s enough of an invitation for him to fling the door open and pull me inside.
All of the blood in my body drains out through my feet into pools of fear that pop and sizzle around me.
“We have to go.” Why did I just whisper? “We have to go,” I try again, but my voice is nothing but a indecipherable breath broken up into a million pieces. Our family heirloom—the only one my mother ever convinced my father to keep—chimes 2am, and I’m thirteen all over again. “We have to go!”
Ben looks down at me, really looks down, and says, “Why are you so short?”
But I’m not listening. All my attention is focused on trying to get the door open so we can leave the memory of what really happened that night. Ben pulls me away when I break a fingernail clawing at the wood.
“Cora, it’s locked. Cora, can you hear me? It’s locked and only you can unlock it and let us out. Cora? Cora?” He kneels in front of me and waves a hand in front of my thirteen year old face currently preoccupied with keeping an eye on the door behind him. Mother’s screams echo from down the hallway. “Cora? I can’t open it for you. You need to unlock the door so we can leave.”
Both my hands press tightly against my ears as I slide down to the floor, trembling and chocking on snot. Mom screams to stop, but it won’t work. It’s never once worked in all the years I’ve heard her screaming.
Our bedroom door that leads out into the hall opens, and Ben hurries towards it, all too eager to leave this awful place. But he’s going the wrong way. The door out of here is behind me. That’s the door that leads to him.
“No!” I try to get Ben’s attention, but my voice won’t work. “He’ll kill you!”
I can’t chase after him because I can’t ever bear to see what’s waiting for me in the living room—what was waiting for me that night at 2am.
Turns out I don’t have to worry about Ben. He comes back all on his own, white as a ghost. “This isn’t what you said happened,” he whispers, unfocused, like he’s talking to himself. “I need to get you out of here, but I can’t unlock this door for you. You have to let us out yourself.”
But I’m not listening to him. I’m too busy listening to my mother. I just want him to stop hurting her. I just want to keep us safe from him.
My mind stills with a calm, yet unexplainable rage as I surge with power. Ignoring whatever Ben is trying to tell me, his presence dulls to background noise as I turn towards the door and head into the hallway.
“Stay here,” I order. Ben looks confused when I shove him into the hallway bathroom and slam the door shut in his face. I don’t want them to see me like this. I don’t want them to know what I am. I can’t let them see me like this because I so desperately need them to see me as their sister for a little longer.
I pass by the living room without watching and head towards the kitchen.
Somehow Ben’s gotten free of the bathroom—although, to be fair, that only worked on my siblings because they were so young they couldn’t figure out the door locks from the inside. “Cora?” I feel his urgency pulsate like the echoes of a firecracker, but there’s nothing that can stop the past from happening all over again.
I choose the sharpest knife we have in the kitchen.
Ben’s trying to talk to me again, but doesn’t he understand? I’m trying to save him. I’m trying to show him exactly the kind of monster he married, so he can stop chasing me around like a puppy and fear me as everyone else does. I need him to know that I did not—and do not—regret what happens next.
I scream for no other reason than to ensure dad knows it was me.
Over and over I stab, both hands on the handle, screaming as loud as my voice will allow, fueled by the desire to keep us safe. Until, suddenly, mom pulls me off what’s left of him and the knife slices my thigh open, soiling my blood with his.
We are one and the same. Me and my father. There’s a monster inside us.
It’s what my mother says over and over, for all my life. A prayer to the demon child she bore. You are just like him. Mother screams, Italian mixing with English until her words ring loudly in every language.
She is not the one covered in blood. I am. The only blood on her runs down one leg as she stands over me and asks me how we’re supposed to eat? Don’t I know how expensive it is to live? How will we afford rent now that I’ve killed him?
I realize only now that she was protecting me in the only way she knew how. Our mother had all her softness ripped apart by the same man who forced me inside her for nine months. My sisters came much later, after the damage had already been done. My sisters are not responsible for my mother being forced to marry her rapist. No, that was my fault. And she tells me as often as she can.
“I just wanted to help you,” I try to explain, but she’s not listening. “I just wanted to help you.”
Even after Ben has lifted me up into his arms and hurried us both back to the now unlocked door, I can’t stop repeating this phrase over and over until I blink out of my stupor and realize we’re back in my bedroom on Hydra.
“Well,” I try to say as evenly as I can, but my voice shakes despite my best effort. “Now you know. That’s what really happened.”
“Do you want to talk about it?”
“What is there to talk about?” I’m suddenly so annoyed, I can’t stand the sight of him. “I killed my father.”
“Yes. I know. I was just there.” To my surprise, Ben doesn’t look disgusted or afraid, he looks impressed. “You did good. Your knife bounced off a few bones, but you just kept going.”
“I killed him.” I wait for him to leave, but Ben’s not leaving, and now I’m confused. “I’m a murderer.”
“You killed a rapist actively raping. Good riddance. I’m glad of it.” Ben cradles my confused face in his hands. “I only wish I could have done it for you.”
I have never felt so alive as when I’m the Goddess of Death, controlling the mind, body, and soul of an adorable little mortal man. He’s the sort of well-trained husband that makes me sad at the thought of killing him. I think my every demand and he rushes to complete it. I could never kill such a happily obedient husband.
But Ben hasn’t been entirely truthful. I can see in his eyes. He’s actually just a tiny bit afraid of death.
What do I do? I don’t want him to be afraid of death!
Comfort him. Take away his fear of death forever, so he never has to fear me again.
“Be brave, Benjamin,” I whisper encouragingly and reach out to touch his temple. “Don’t you want to be immortalized forever in legend? What’s more magical than stories? These people will die unremembered, but you? You will live forever in their grand tales of your great conquest.” Breathy words caress him just as gently as my hands do. “Benjamin Linus: he who conquered Death.”
I can feel his erection seconds before he confirms it with a desperate, “Yes.”
“Wow,” I comment on the sudden pull of magic. “You really love this, don’t you?” I force him to walk over to my desk, grab the knife he offered me all those nights ago, and press the blade to his throat, just hard enough to nic him. Smiling, I recite the threat he made when we first met. “I could slit your throat wide open.” This time, I add a little bit of extra flair and wiggle my finger from side to side, watching as his head swivels helplessly around on his shoulders. “Better yet, I could make you slit your throat wide open.”
We’re the same, Ben and I. We understand each other in a way nobody else will. He sees the monster inside of me, and he doesn’t flee in fear or anger or disgust. His monster is in love with mine, and mine with his.
Which makes me feel extra guilty when I notice the blood on his neck. I panic, quickly forcing him to release the knife he’s holding against his own throat. “Are you okay?”
“Say what you will about me.” Ben gulps air, chuckling lowly, as he swipes at his neck and shows me the red dripping from his fingers. “But at least I’ve never drawn your blood, Goddess.”
“I didn’t mean to do that.”
Ben scoffs dismissively. “Don’t lie.”
Wait, he’s right. I don’t know why, but I kinda did want to stab him. But only because he was enjoying it. He wants me to hurt him, but I don’t actually want to hurt him. I'm so confused.
But wait, if he was right about me, then he must be like me. And if he’s like me, then does that mean…
I go over the memory in my head one more time, viewing it through a different lens. “You wanted to stab me that night, didn’t you?”
Ben knows what I’m talking about because he blinks one too many times. “What?”
“The night you threatened me on Hydra.” I immediately stop his head from shaking a refusal and hold tight to his body with my magic. He’s uncomfortable and attempts to look away, but he’s powerless to stop me from forcing his eyes to meet mine. “Yes, you did,” I seethe through clenched teeth. “I can hear your thoughts. Why are you lying to me?”
“This isn’t fair,” he complains, a spark of actual anger shining through. “They’re called intrusive thoughts precisely because they’re intrusive! I never would have actually stabbed you.”
“But you thought about it?”
Ben stares me down, but it’s not a long wait until he relents with a defeated, “Technically speaking, I thought about it. But I never would have done it.”
“And I’m just supposed to believe you?”
“Cora, what do you think trust is? I could kill you whenever I want. You could kill me whenever you want. And we don’t.” He leans forward just enough to get out a sarcastic, “Yay.”
All the magic severs as I release him and take a step back. Not a big step, but enough so his breath isn’t hot against my neck. “Why didn’t you do it?”
Ben looks intensely irritated that I’m not dropping this. “I didn’t want to.”
“If you were thinking about it, why didn’t you do it?”
“Because I didn’t want to.” 28 years of unspoken words flow between us in a single sentence. “Maybe the idea forced its way in at first, but it disappeared almost instantly.”
“But why?"
“I was staring down death itself, and. . . you looked sad,” he admits softly. “I don't like making you sad. In fact, the thought of hurting you disgusted me. I much prefer to make you laugh.”
It’s hard to speak through the lump in my throat. “You really wouldn’t hurt me, would you?”
Ben shakes his head no. “Not unless you ask me to.”
“Wait a second,” I butt in. “You absolutely could not kill me whenever you want.”
Ben’s euphoric expression flatlines into a sarcastic frown. “You’re joking. I could kill you by sneezing too hard.”
“You could not! I’m literally holding a knife!”
“Yes,” he warns, finally looking worried. “Don’t come any closer, or you may trip and fall and impale yourself and somehow it’ll be all my fault. That’s just what I need,” he adds snidely. “More of your problems I’ll have to fix.”
“More of my problems?”
I’m literally wielding a knife, but Ben couldn’t look more unbothered. “It’s always something with you,” he comments slowly.
I start about six different rage-fueled sentences before I realize he’s been submitting to me this entire time, and I’m only just now picking up on the magic. I calm down enough to appreciate the game. Looks like he really likes Goddess of Death. “Oh, you’re good.”
“So are you,” Ben praises, but he’s trying really hard not to smile. “I’m just a little bit better.”
Maybe I’d be more upset at being manipulated if he wasn’t giving me enough power to feel drunk. “Fine. You win.” I keep my eyes locked on his and poke his chest with one stiff index finger, punctuating each word. “But I could kill you if I wanted to.”
“Then do it.”
“I. . . I don’t want to.” I falter at the serious expression on his face. “But I could.”
“Go on.” Ben’s taunts make it clear he’s poking fun at the situation, but it still makes me angry. “Kill me. Crush my mortal skull between your hands. Go on. Kill me, almighty Cora. Look! I’ll even close my eyes to make it easier for you.”
"You're obnoxious, you know that?"
His response is an amused hum of a laugh, his eyes still shut.
Even though I know he’s doing this to make me mad so he can get what he wants, I let him win. With nothing more than a thought, I hand him the knife to hold against his throat again. I think I like having a man fear me. Dad should have feared me. Power screams through my veins with unbelievable violence. “I could end you with the flick of my finger.” But he’s not dad, and I don’t want to kill him. “Do you trust me not to?”
Ben’s answer is immediate. “Mind, body, and soul.”
“Why?” It’s difficult to see him through the tears that have come from out of nowhere. My magical control severs, and his body relaxes from all the tension. Stop crying. You’re ruining this! “I’m sorry I’m this way. I don’t actually want to hurt you.”
“I know,” he says encouragingly. “That’s the entire point. You could kill me.” A small amused smile spreads across his face. “But I trust you not to.”
“Is it okay if I’m not Goddess of Death tonight?” Panic thrashes around inside me until I feel like I’m going to throw up if I don’t tell him. “I want to submit.”
All the light in the world dims to darkness as every ounce of blood in my body pools between my legs, leaving me lightheaded in the most euphoric way.
Oh. Wow. Okay. I see why you like this.
Are you alright?
Yeah, just. . . I guess I wasn’t expecting it to be such a drastic difference. This is. . . a lot.
We can stop if you want.
No! I must sound desperate because his hesitation weans almost instantly. I think about what I want, but Ben doesn’t move. When he looks at me, I get a sinking feeling in my stomach at the sight of his glowing eyes.
“Did you just. . .” Ben looks at his hands in amazement. “Did you just give me all of your magic? I didn't even know that was possible.”
I try to shove his chest to test the theory, and I might as well be pushing a brick wall. Fear and lust mix together in an inexplicably complicated rush of pure carnal need. “Oh,” I stutter, “I didn’t mean to do that. Can I have it back?”
Ben smiles, but it’s not the kind that wrinkle his eyes. “Already?”
“I don’t think I like this,” I whisper.
“Yes, you do,” he ponders, his eyes shifting curiously as he reads my mind. “You love this.”
“No I don’t,” I lie, but it’s no use. "Fine," I reluctantly relent. "Maybe I do."
“You’re cute when you’re shy.” Ben narrows his eyes in thought, staring at something across the room as I continue to allow him to sift through my mind. “It’s a very interesting thing, your fantasy. I saw me. In another life. A life without you.” I feel the change take over him as he realizes what this means. Just his eyes move as they dart over to look at me. Ben’s silent a moment as he contemplates his next move. “I wasn’t very nice. Actually, I wasn't a very good person. Hold on. . .” Ben's eyes shift as he sees more, and he's suddenly frowning deeply. "I'm sorry, I do what to Juliet and Locke?"
"Not you!" I snap a finger to get his attention back. "Different you."
Ben blinks down at me. "How many different me's are there?"
"Hold on one sec," I say, pretending to pull something out of my pocket. "Let me check my Theoretical Physics For Dummies book. Ah, yes. Chapter 23, multiple universes."
Ben's quiet, thinking. Suddenly, he asks, "Do you like this me?"
"I trust this you." Something lights up in him at my words, and I can't help but laugh. "You think I'd let you hold me in such a compromising position if I didn't trust you? I'd crush you between my hands."
"As you should," he agrees. "But there's no time for that now." Ben's never looked at me quite like this before. “Get on the bed,” he commands.
I don’t know why, but I’m terrified of him. Or, maybe, I’m only terrified by how wet I get when he’s angry. Nothing in this world scares me more than feeling powerless. But he doesn’t make me feel powerless. Not really. “I don’t. . . this isn’t—”
“Get on the bed, Cora.”
"Okay." I couldn’t stall even if I wanted to. Magic makes me follow his every order, but it doesn’t scare me as much as it should. I think he’s right. I think I do like this.
“Of course I’m right,” he says smugly. Magic compels me to remove every piece of my clothing painstakingly slow, and then it compels me to remove his clothing. When we're both completely naked, his thoughts become my thoughts as he shows me how to roll on a condom. “Turn around.” Ben waves a finger, and I’m suddenly kneeling on the mattress, facing away from him. “Oh,” he moans in my ear. “So that’s what you want. Why have you left me guessing for so long—” A knee knocks against the inside of my thigh as he pushes it aside to spread my legs. “—when you could have just told me from the beginning?”
Both my arms slide up and wrap around his neck to keep me tethered to the earth. If this is the kind of arousal he feels when I’m Goddess of Death, I understand now why he’s okay with the danger involved. I’m so turned on I would do anything he asked me to.
Ben's voice is low in my ear. “Anything I asked you to?”
“How did you—”
“No more secrets,” he explains. “That’s what you want more than anything.”
“Yes,” I finally admit and stop attempting to protect my thoughts.
“I have a nice view from here.” One of his hands palms my breast as he sits behind me, positioning himself. When he feels just how wet I am, he raises his eyebrows. “Do I really have this much of an effect on you?” he asks kindly with a hint of surprise at the news. “I like knowing you want me. I want you, too. So go on,” he says against my neck, falling back in a dangerous hiss. “Ride me however you see fit. I won’t move until you tell me to.”
Ben’s words catch me off guard, and I open my eyes to look at the glowing blue of his. But. . . you could just take it if you wanted to. You could overpower me. You could take a Goddess by force.
“You still haven’t figured it out yet, have you?” His fingers lightly brush against my neck as he fingers a strand of hair close to my ear. “The only thing more powerful than conquering a Goddess, is knowing how to please one. Now,” his voice lowers even more as his demand breathes hot in my ear, “ride me.”
It’s a relief to feel every taut muscle uncoil as I relax my body back against his chest and sink onto him.
His heartbeat is suddenly in my neck, his breath in my throat, his thoughts in my own mind as he gives some of my magic back. Everything okay?
Yeah, sorry. Freaked out for just a second.
Every ounce of magic shoots back into my body. Ben asks, “Did I do something wrong?”
I stare at him in disbelief, but it quickly morphs back into lust. I can give him full control and he still won’t hurt me. He has the power to make me do anything he wants, and instead he stopped as soon as I seemed actually scared.
Without bothering to explain he didn’t do anything wrong, I give him all of my magic back and wink. I feel powerful, even as he forces me back into the same position and orders me to sink back onto him. After a series of moans I can no longer keep control of, my steady rhythm shifts and changes, and suddenly he’s moving hard against me.
Reaching up slowing with one hand, he takes a fistful of my hair and yanks.
Playfully. Not too hard. Because it wouldn’t feel as good if he actually wanted to hurt me. I just want to be reminded that he could hurt me. If he really wanted to. Which he doesn’t.
I bring a hand up to cover my mouth, but Ben pulls it away with magic and snarls, “No.”
“But someone will hear.”
“I want them to hear,” he huffs against my ear. “I want all of them to hear. I need them to understand that all their prayers and all their parties don’t amount to a damn thing. Because you’re mine. And you want to know the best part?”
I inhale enough air to ask, "What?"
"I'm all yours." I'm so close and he knows it. “Look at me, beautiful,” he rasps, and the blue of his eyes have never shone so bright. “Keep looking at me.”
It’s 2am, and I hear them fighting. They’re always fighting, but lately it’s been bad. Every night it’s gotten worse since my grandmother died. I can hear him hitting her. I’ve seen him do it. Face. Arms. Stomach. Sometimes he’s not even really aiming.
It’s only a matter of time before he starts feeling comfortable hitting me, or Cassandra, or Capri, or Casper. It’s only a matter of time before he starts hurting us in other ways, too.
No.
Tonight is the night. I can feel it. Tonight is the night I rid the world of filth, starting with my father. I plant a kiss on each one of my siblings foreheads, and then I slide out of bed in the windowless pitch-black bedroom I share with them, griping my murder weapon tight. Another thing I lied to Ben about. I didn’t take this knife from the kitchen. I sleep with knives under my pillow, just in case.
As soon as I head towards the door, my siblings dutifully trailing behind me like ducklings, something appears in the corner of the room like mist in the darkness. All the hairs on my arms stand on end, and I stop breathing in the hopes it hasn’t noticed me. Cold air chills my face and takes my breath away as a vaguely human shadow glides across the floor from out of thin air, stopping close to appraise me. I watch, paralyzed, as two blue beacons in the night dart down to the knife in my hand.
A disembodied voice gives me commands in a soft hiss.
Go back to bed. Let me do it for you.
I’m not afraid of this thing, but I’m also terrified of this thing, so I give the monster my knife and guide my siblings back to bed so I can comfort them.
“Hey,” I yell out at the last minute, and the monster stops with one endless void of a hand resting on the door handle. I wait until it’s turned to fix me with its pinpricks of blue light before saying, “I don’t care what you do to him, just make sure it hurts.”
With pleasure.
The monster disappears out the door with inhuman speed.
All three of my siblings sob into my pajamas, but my fear disappears completely the second my mother’s cry for help turns into my father’s cry for help. Dad finally knows what it’s like to scream helplessly into the void, but after a while the yelling dies down and I worry Ben’s already killed him. There’s a crash, the sound of glass breaking, a loud thud against one of the walls, and then I hear the clang of the garbage disposal turning on, and my father’s cries of pain echo through the house once again, until suddenly it’s silent for good.
Ben slips back into the room, each invisible step sticky with blood, his blue eyes shining crisp and bright in the otherwise pitch blackness. He walks over to the bed, where I sit consoling my poor little siblings who can’t handle any of this. They cling to me for protection, but there’s no need to be afraid of him. This monster is friendly.
What little reservation was left melts away, until I’m not afraid of him at all.
From within the darkness under his piercing eyes, a smile forms. You don’t have to worry about him anymore.
My life has been nothing but one, long, continuous scream, but now that scream is free of fear and anger and pain. I trust him not to hurt me just as much as he trusts me not to hurt him. As the two of us rock furiously in tandem like wild animals, Goddess of War opens her mouth to let out a scream of pure pleasure.
After we’ve shifted into a more comfortable position, Ben runs his hand over my hair to try and detangle any knots. “Thank you for trusting me.”
“Thank you for not hurting me,” I respond.
“I would never hurt you.”
“Even if I asked you to?”
“Not even then.” His answer surprises me until he adds, “I dug deep into your fantasies, and you don’t want anyone to hurt you.”
I’ve never told another living soul a lot of these secrets before. Ben is the person who knows the most about me, good, bad, embarrassing, ugly. All of it. He’s the first person to have seen all of me and not go running away in fear, or anger, or disgust.
“Besides,” he says in a much more humorous tone, “that’s my kink. Stop trying to copy me. See? Told you,” he says with a smile that makes me feel important. “I prefer to make you laugh.”
I thought Ben had fallen asleep hours ago, so it’s a surprise to hear him say, “Cora, I know you’re awake. Are you alright?”
No. I’m not alright. I’m paranoid. I haven’t been this paranoid since I was a child.
“Hey,” he reassures in his most calming tone. “There’s no shame in being afraid of the dark.”
“I’m not afraid of the dark,” I hiss. I just want to make sure I keep an eye on my bedroom door to make sure no monsters break in.
“Then turn around.”
I roll over in a single second, facing him with eyes already misting with fear. “See?”
Ben reaches out and cradles the side of my face. “Cora, nothing is going to sneak up behind you.”
He hasn’t even fully finished his statement before I interrupt with, “But what if something does sneak up behind me?”
Now Ben looks playfully annoyed. “Please,” he says, his words dripping with sarcasm. “You honestly think I’m going to let something get to you before I can kill it? Have you so little faith in my abilities to protect you?” He looks so funny when he tries to look sad. “You’re not the only one who sleeps with weapons.”
“You sleep with a knife under your pillow, too?”
Ben reaches up and behind himself, digging around in the space between the headboard and our pillows, before pulling out a handgun. "Sorry," he says. "It's not you. I bring this everywhere."
I start laughing and laughing and laughing and the paranoia fades as the fear clears out, until I can think again.
I can think again.
“Welcome back.” Even in the faint afterglow light shining from my body, I can see his smile. “If you want to sleep, then sleep. I promise I won’t let anything hurt you.”
I burrow into his side, facing away from the door, my eyes already flickering shut. The world is a frightening place full of villains and monsters, but for now I relax against the comforting presence of my husband, and I sleep.
Not being depressed is an amazing thing. I can appreciate food again, and smell, and sound, and color. I close my eyes and inhale the sweet scent of flowers dangling from the ceiling inside the Hall of Freyja, and smile, knowing I made the right decision by coming here.
Ben sits on the nearest step next to my throne. Men are not allowed in the Hall of Freyja, but I made a case for him since he’s technically my husband and it’s his birthday month too. I stressed how I wanted to keep the peace and was able to come to an agreement with the women of Hydra. Ben is allowed to sit next to me at the festival inside the Hall of Freyja, but he’s not allowed to see anything that happens.
“I think I like having you blindfolded.” Leaning forward in my throne, I whisper, “Did you know there are naked statues of me on either side of you?”
“When this is all over,” he whispers back, so the rowdy crowd of women below cannot hear, “you better be waiting for me in your room, naked and ready.”
I laugh loudly, but it’s drowned out by the music and merriment happening down on the ground level. Nobody under the age of eighteen is allowed to attend, so it’s no surprise the night is full of song and dance and food and wine and more than a few women end up naked by night’s end.
Just when I start to get sleepy, a voice rings out from the crowd.
“How long are we going to pretend that our great and glorious Goddess isn’t a complete and utter hypocrite?”
Great. Just what I wanted to deal with at the end of such a nice night. Charlotte’s mother.
Martha glares up at me, no doubt still seething from what happened at Charlotte’s wedding. All night I’ve caught her shooting me looks, but it seems like she's playing it safe by waiting until everyone is drunk and slower to anger. “Lady Cora, I think it’s high time you know the truth. Nobody else is brave enough to tell you!”
Gail notices the yelling and tries to step in to make peacekeeper. “Ignore her, Cora. She's drunk."
Martha screams, “Your marriage to Ben is illegal!"
As the hall quiets down to better hear the yelling, Gail starts walking towards her, wide-eyed, and terrified. “You forget your place, you miserable old bitch.”
Unbothered by Gail’s incredible drunken surge of magic, Charlotte’s mother simply smirks at me and says, “Your marriage to Ben isn’t a sham because he tricked you or lied to you or any of the other excuses I’m sure Gail’s planted into your head. No,” she proclaims loudly into the high-ceilings, her words dripping with malice, “your marriage to Ben is a sham because you’re already married.” Martha looks absolutely insane as she smiles up at me and points at Gail. “To my dear Dharma associate, Dr. Abigail Alexopoulou!”
Chapter 27: Mommy And Daddy Are Mad Again
Chapter Text
“You decapitated all of them?”
“Yeah,” Jane mumbles through a mouth stuffed to the brim with gingerbread people heads. “I was just going to eat one, but it was so tasty I couldn’t stop.”
“Why are you eating just the heads?”
“They have the most frosting,” she answers, still chewing.
I snatch a cookie out of her hand, frowning at all the work it took to make, bake, and decorate these—now headless—gingerbread people. “You’re ruining the batch for everyone else!”
Jane finally stops desecrating my baking and takes a seat at a nearby table. Day two of the Freyja festival is focused solely on food, and no amount of persuading from the women of Hydra could keep me out of the kitchens. If anything, cooking is the only thing keeping me sane right now.
Jane clears her throat. “Any word on Gail’s whereabouts?”
“Nope,” I answer curtly. “I’d rather not think about last night, thanks.”
Chaos. Last night was utter and complete chaos. Multiple women had to ban together to magically restrain Gail as she tried to rush Martha to—if her threats are to be believed—dismantle her DNA with magic. I’m not even sure when Gail’s threats turned into tears, or when she finally fled into the night, or when Ben slipped away among the commotion for his own safety. Maya was able to calm everyone down, and I used the distraction to set out to the longhouse to talk to Ben. But when I opened the door to my room, he was sitting motionless at the edge of my bed with the most horrifying blank expression. No matter what he asked, no matter how I answered, nothing was good enough to keep him from leaving. “You asked me once not to follow you,” he said when I attempted to trail behind him to his boat docked at the beach. “I am asking you now to show me that same courtesy.”
It feels like everyone is mad at me. In reality, only Ben and Gail are mad at me, but that somehow makes it worse. Now, all I can do to calm my anxiety is cook food for other people until my body collapses from exhaustion.
Day 3 of the Freyja festival passes by in a blur. So does day 4, 5, and 6.
The 7th day, however, stays with me long after it’s concluded. Day 7—the final festival day—consists of all women gathering on the beach and screaming up at the full moon. When the first woman starts screaming, I startle. But when ten other women throw their heads back and scream, I’m less frightened than I am confused. It isn’t until everyone—Alex, Hazel, Claire, Kate, Jane, everyone—throws their head back and screams like they’re being murdered, that I start to become frightened again. I feel their pain like an itch that snowballs into a burn. From the looks of it, the younger women treat this ritual like a game, and their screams are often interrupted by laughter as they stretch and contort their faces to amuse each other. The women, however, take this ritual very seriously. I’ve never been to a rage room, but this seems to have the same effect. Every inch of me is uncomfortable as I watch Kate stop screaming and start crying. She’s obviously confused, evident by the way she resists the comfort of the older women all around her, but she eventually gives in when Sun starts weeping, then Claire, then Shannon. I watch as the elders of Hydra comfort them with words and warm embraces.
I’m not cut out for this. I don’t even know what the hell is going on. Gail’s gone, so I can’t ask her, and Maya is busy consoling the very unsettled survivors. I’m filled with a desire to talk to Ben, but he’s back at the barracks and specifically asked me not to follow him. But that was a week ago. Maybe he’s waiting for me to apologize?
First thing in the morning, I convince myself to paddle to the mainland and hike to the barracks to give Ben a formal apology face-to-face. I have no idea why I would willingly marry the person who caused him so much pain and grief throughout his childhood, but I did, and there’s nothing I can do about that now.
But is that true? Can I change the future? I’ve changed my visions a few times so far, so do the laws of space and time not apply to me? I don’t have answers, no matter how much I want them.
I’m halfway to the beach when Alex falls in step beside me, wishing me a good morning. It’s such a shock to see her, I can’t think up a good excuse for wanting to go to the mainland alone.
“Why wouldn’t I come with you?” I should thank my lucky stars her question doesn’t sound suspicious, just genuinely confused. “I want to go home. You know, check in on dad.”
I try my best to sound genuine when I laugh, but inside my gut is roiling with extra anxiety. I was already nervous enough, but Alex tagging along brings a whole new set of worry. “Yeah, of course,” I say a little too enthusiastically. “Let’s get going before it gets dark.”
I truly can’t tell if Ben’s pissed off or just mildly annoyed I’m here. “Alex,” he says, “can you please get me a tomato?” As soon as she’s outside, Ben whirls around and whispers, “What are you doing here?”
Okay. Pissed off. He’s definitely pissed off. “I’m sorry, but I was trying to sneak away and Alex caught me and—”
“I’m not asking why Alex is here,” he snaps. “She lives here. Why are you here?” If there was any doubt as to his mood before, it’s made crystal clear as his angry eyes dart from me to the front door, his entire expression softening at the sight of Alex returning with a ripe tomato in hand.
Ben doesn’t say another word to me for the rest of dinner.
Alex is asleep in her bed, snoring softly as I war against my own body.
Sweat drips into my eyes and stings no matter how much I wipe at them. It’s well past midnight, but I’m wide awake, stewing with sweat in my cocoon of blankets on the floor. It was much easier to fall asleep on Hydra with all those miles between us. But now? As much as I try, I can’t fall asleep.
Using the tiny sliver of moonlight peeking through a gap in the curtains, I navigate my way up and out the door, closing it silently behind me. Being free of those stifling blankets has only offered a small modicum of relief from what’s ailing me. There’s only one thing that can stop the ache, and he’s just across the hall.
“Cora?”
I blink at Ben in the darkness, unsure of when I went into his room, or for how long I’ve been staring at him as he sleeps. In an attempt to course correct, I bring up a hand in a quick wave. “Hi.”
His eyes dart behind me and confirms I’ve closed the door. “What are you doing in here?”
“Alex is asleep.”
“Okay,” he says, sounding both confused and annoyed. “And up until just now, I was too.”
Shit. This is not how I imagined this would go. “Oh, I’m sorry. Do you want me to go?”
Ben slowly sits up until his back is resting against the headboard, his face an unreadable mask. “Please tell me you didn’t sneak in here to seduce me. Are you insane,” he whispers sharply in the dark when I don’t answer. “No, I mean, are you actually insane?”
“I’m sorry.”
“Your sorry means nothing. My one rule is this never happens when Alex is home. And besides,” he adds snidely, “I asked you for some space. Cora, this is not okay.”
Shit, shit, shit. What is wrong with me? “I know.”
“Then why are you here?”
“Because nothing else is working,” I hiss with intense frustration.
Ben tilts his head slightly, like Fenrir when he’s confused. “Nothing else is working?”
“Yeah,” I say as sarcastically as I can, “nothing else is working. What do you think I’m talking about?”
“I don’t know what you’re talking about.”
He doesn’t feel it. He doesn’t feel the pull like I do. Holy shit, this is embarrassing. Does that mean he doesn’t love me anymore? How do I get him to love me again?
“I want you,” I say a little too loudly, and he leaps out of bed to place a hand over my mouth. I want you, I say in his mind. I thought maybe if I just thought of gross things the feeling would go away, but nothing I did would stop your face from flashing behind my eyelids and I’m sorry this is so messed up but I’m no better than a man and I feel like if I don’t have you right this second I’m going to lose my mind.
Are you trying to seduce your way out of an apology?
No! I’m just. . . You want me to say sorry? Sorry for what? I’m just as shocked and horrified by this news as you are! I can’t explain why I married Gail because I never would have married the person who put you through all that pain and torment. I can’t speak for what that Cora did, but the Cora of right now would never even consider it!
It feels like a lifetime before Ben speaks, but this time, his voice is an audible whisper. “Why are you here?”
I can’t think of anything to say except the truth. “I miss you.”
“I know,” he says as if it were obvious. “I just wanted to hear you say it.”
I don’t understand. Is he not mad at me? He doesn’t sound like he’s mad, and he doesn’t look like he’s mad, but am I just reading this wrong? “Are you. . . are you not mad at me?”
“I was,” he admits with a twitch of his eyebrows. “For about two days.”
A week’s worth of tension leaves my coiled muscles, and I relax my body for the first time since he left Hydra. “Two days? But it’s been a week,” I whine to really lay on how desperate I am to touch him. “You’re telling me you could have been inside me five days ago?”
Ben’s expression doesn’t give him away, but the humor in his voice does. “This is surprisingly better than an apology. But we can’t do this,” he whispers mischievously. “We would have to be. . . quiet.”
“I can be quiet.”
“No you can’t.”
I don’t mean to yell, I really don’t. But sometimes he’s just so aggravating and contrarian. “Yes, I can!”
Ben presses a hand against my lips again. “Shhh,” he whispers, barely audible even in the silence. “Didn’t I just say you couldn’t be quiet?”
There's a moment of hesitation before I pull his hand away and lean in until his lips are on mine. His kiss is soft at first, but once he realizes I'm not resisting, it quickly grows into something powerful and consuming.
Oh! I totally forgot, but happy belated birthday! Were you just not going to mention we have the same birthday?
No.
Why not?
Who cares about a mortal man’s birthday?
I care! I would have made you something!
You don’t need to make me anything.
Yes, I do! I’m way behind on gifts if I have any hope to catch up to the amount of jewelry you’ve made me. What do you want? If I make you something?
A shirt.
A shirt?
Husbands make their wives jewelry, wives make their husbands clothing.
Okay, but I make absolutely no promises it’ll look good. So. . . how does it feel to be 40?
About the same as when I was your age.
Damn. You must have really good knees if you feel as spry at 40 as you did at 21.
I thought you were turning 30?
I am not!
Sorry, my mistake. I thought you were turning 29.
I’m 21.
Sure, okay. Twenty-one-hundred.
What are you talking about? I’m 21. As in legal adult?
You. . . no. . . no, you died and were reborn in 1977.
I may have died in 1977, but I was reborn 21 years ago.
“What?” Ben pulls away with a smack, releases me in what looks suspiciously like a flinch, and takes a big step back. “If this is a game, it’s not funny.”
“I mean…no?” I try to lie, though it’s no use. “I’m definitely much older than 21.”
“Ohhh,” he says all in a rush of relief. “Gail’s put you up to this didn’t she? This is her final trial, right?”
Trial? I’m so confused by what he’s saying, I can’t think of a convincing response in a timely manner, and now he knows I’m lying.
Ben stares at me for so long I eventually realize he’s not actually staring at me at all. He’s staring off into space, completely checked out. Eventually, he starts mumbling to himself as he bends his fingers in some kind of tally. However he tries to rationalize it, it obviously doesn’t work because he just ends up more upset than before.
“Put on your darkest clothing,” he says, finally breaking the silence. “You and I are going to have a long-overdue chat with Gail.”
“But I don’t know where she is.”
“No,” he says, but he can’t seem to look me in the eye anymore. “But I do.”
“Shhh,” Ben reminds me for the second time.
“Sorry,” I silently mouth in the scant moonlight. As he continues to carefully guide us through brush and vines and densely packed bamboo, my fingers reach out until they make contact with his arm.
Where are we going?
I told you not to ask me until we get there.
That defeats the point of asking beforehand.
Ben stops and shoots me an unamused frown, and I let go of his arm.
Wherever we’re going, it’s a big deal. Ben is dressed all in black, and he made me wake Alex to let her know there was an emergency meeting at the Temple, even though we’re not headed towards the Temple. Even his footsteps seem carefully planned out, as to make the least amount of noise as possible.
Turns out Ben’s taking me to the Staff Station, hidden deep in the jungle, tunneled into the side of a hill. I watch as he opens a secret door hidden by a tangled mess of vines and nods for me to go ahead. I hear him close the door behind us, and we fall into complete darkness.
Ben’s messing with something. There's a squeak of a hinge, a clank, and then a beam of light shoots through the darkness and lands on my face.
“Thank you for the retina damage,” I say, squinting. “I appreciate it.”
Ben moves the flashlight down towards the floor. “Sorry. I don’t know why Gail has all the lights off.” He shines the flashlight onto a little metal box on the side of the wall and pulls up on a switch. A pale light illuminates the area.
I follow him down a flight of stairs into a cold, poorly lit hallway. Yellowed overhead lamps crackle and flicker with the effort to light up the station.
I remember this was the station Claire was kidnapped and taken to operate on, but that never happened in this reality. Reality. Hm. I guess I've accepted whatever this life is as reality.
As Ben walks through the eerie station, I expect him to make some kind of announcement—like the plea don’t shoot us he made in the original show to Mikhail—but Ben just bursts through the double doors and storms down the hallway yelling Gail’s name.
Gail appears out of thin air, like a ghost. “We don’t have a meeting planned, Linus. Why are you disturbing my peace? Can I not have a full week in which you’re not trying to—” Gail cuts off the second she sees me standing behind him. “Why did you bring her here?”
Ben unfastens the tie straps of his jacket, balling up the garment and throwing it violently on the ground. “Let’s go, Gail. I’ve been waiting for this my entire life. Just you and me.”
From the dismissive sound of her laugh, I’m worried Ben is in way over his head. Gail brings a hand up to her temple like she’s trying to massage the sound of his voice out of her mind. “What on earth are you talking about?”
“We’re fighting,” he explains, and then he rushes her.
I don’t even have time to tell him to stop before Gail flicks a finger and sends him flying across the room in the opposite direction. After his body slides down the far wall and crumples to the floor, all I hear is Ben’s distant groans of pain.
“Men are impulsive and overemotional,” Gail complains, turning fully to give me her attention. “I don’t know why you like them.”
My first instinct is to shame Gail and protect Ben, but honestly? I finally understand why Ben’s afraid of her. Gail’s command of magic is stronger than any other woman I’ve seen on Hydra, and I’m not sure even I could rival her. At least not right now.
Ben limps back into the room like a kicked puppy, switching to French as he unloads more complaints.
Gail’s expression shifts from amusement to confusion as she turns to me. “You’re not 21,” she says confidently.
“Yes, I am.”
Gail shakes her head no, but her smile wains with concern. “You died in 1977.”
“It doesn’t matter when I died,” I tell her. “I was reborn 21 years ago.”
Gail’s entire face darkens in shock. “Oh, Hel help me,” she whispers.
“See?" Ben’s furious voice echoes throughout the empty Dharma station as he glares at Gail. “You're sick, you know that? You married me to a child!"
"I didn't know," Gail shrieks.
“I’m not a child,” I interrupt. “21 is a legal, fully autonomous human being.”
“No,” he says, pausing his argument with Gail to turn his attention towards me. “21 is only 3 years removed from 18. 18 is only 2 years removed from 16. My daughter is 16!”
I try to argue that he’s not making any sense, and that I’m a combined 5 years older than Alex, but then it hits me. I get it. I can see how this would freak him out, thinking someone is pushing 30 when they’re actually closer to their teenage daughters age. In fact, my cheeks redden at the thought of him being upset about this. I’m relieved he's normal. Damn, the bar is in Catholic Hell.
It doesn’t matter anyway. Ben and Gail are arguing in French and aren’t even paying attention to anything I say.
Finally, I get a snippet of English. “I was training him to be worthy of you,” Gail argues, and I realize she’s talking to me. “If I wanted to kill him, I would have killed him. Yet, here he is! Unscathed and ungrateful, as usual.”
“Am I supposed to thank you for not killing me?” Up to this point, Ben’s been surprisingly animated—flailing his arms and shouting—but he’s calmed down, at least for now. “If there is one thing I know about Gail,” he tells me, “it’s that she will not spare you if you slight her. Not even if you’re a Goddess.”
All the lights flicker at the same time as glass bulbs tinkle and shatter overhead, raining down on the otherwise silent room. I’ve never felt such a surge of magic from anyone before. “How dare you,” Gail seethes through clenched teeth. “I am her soulmate, and as such, I put her well-being over my own happiness. Unlike some.”
“Don’t make me laugh! I’m obviously her soulmate.” Ben’s smug smile drops with worry as he jerks his head over to look at me for confirmation. “Right?”
Gail let’s out a loud cackle and flairs bright with magic. “Why are you always so petulant? Of course she thinks she’s in love with you! You won’t leave her alone for five seconds so she can think clearly!” With each word, Gail’s voice elongates and deepens into something etherial and firm. “What Cora and I have is so much more than your pathetic attempts at courtship. Anyone can rut in the dirt like mindless animals. What we have is a spiritual connection.”
“Oh?” Ben’s entire expression lights up at this news. “Because it sounds to me like you’re just a really bad lay.”
This sends Gail into a rage and they both start arguing so violently I can’t even understand half of what they’re saying.
I blink back into the conversation just in time to hear Gail scoff, “Ridiculous. I treated you with more respect than you deserved.”
“More of nothing is still nothing,” Ben yells. “You treated me like trash!”
“I did not! I can’t believe you would do this to me in front of her, after everything I’ve sacrificed for you! You’ve always been so ungrateful!”
“For what, Gail? All the times you found a way to make my life worse?”
“STOP!" Finally, the station is blissfully silent. It’s so abruptly quiet, my ears ring from the previous screaming match. I stare from one to the other, daring them to piss me off by bickering further. “Can one of you please calmly explain what the hell is going on?”
“Gail,” Ben says with the most irritated expression I’ve ever seen, “we have to tell her about the Coven.”
“Linus, I’ll end you right now if you continue this nonsense.”
“You can’t end me,” Ben refutes with a loud laugh. “Cora’s watching!” He swiftly turns to give me another sad-eyed frown and points an accusatory finger at Gail. “See? Gail’s been trying to kill me off ever since your rebirth!”
“So like a man,” she sneers, calm as ever. “Thinking everything is about you.”
It’s weird hearing him swear, but Ben doesn’t even blink when he asks, “What kind of horseshit have you been telling her when I’m not around? Why is it when I take one step forward it feels like I’m taking two steps back?”
“Oh, Linus,” Gail sighs. “What are you yapping about now?”
“Cora still doesn’t trust me,” he yells, but it comes out more like a tantrum than a threat.
“Of course she doesn’t trust you,” Gail scoffs. “You’re a man.”
It looks like Ben has more to yell, but he gives up. His voice is measured when he says, “Gail, we have to tell her.”
“No,” Gail immediately snaps. “She’s not ready.”
Now it’s my turn to yell, “Stop talking about me like I’m not standing right here!”
“Cora, listen to me.” Gail’s voice and expression softens when she turns away from Ben. “You’re young. Inexperienced. You’re not ready to know about everything that happens on this island.”
“Yes, she is,” Ben argues. “I’ve been telling you that for weeks! Cora is ready whether you want to admit it or not.”
“Ready for what?” I repeat, but my question is drowned out again and again as they continue to argue.
“You know what? I don’t need your permission.” Ben stands up straight, but it doesn’t accomplish much because Gail is taller than he is. “I’m going to tell her anyway, and you can’t stop me.”
“Cora,” Gail cuts in, “what your sniveling husband is trying to tell you is he’s a serial killer. There! I beat you to it, you worm.”
“Oh,” Ben responds in a sarcastic drawl, “well when you put it that way it sounds bad.”
What the actual fuck is going on? I stare at Ben in horror. “You’re a serial killer?”
“Cora, I don’t kill people,” he answers proudly. “I hunt monsters. It’s not the same thing.”
I look from Ben to Gail, then back to Ben. “Are the monsters. . . human?”
“I don’t consider them human.” As I continue to stare at him, I can only imagine the shock and horror on my face right now, because Ben quickly starts explaining in more detail. “Team Bear isn’t just a sports team. We’re a specially curated and expertly trained organization of assassins. Our duty to the island is to weed out adults who would—” His words clip off as he thinks of the best way to phrase it. “—harm children. And then we. . . make them disappear.”
I’m so happy to learn the details that I get a rush of blood to the head and almost pass out. “That’s your big secret? You kill child abusers?” I’m smiling ear to ear. “That’s fantastic!”
“I’m glad you think so.” Ben’s entire being perks up at my encouragement, until he looks like a young boy unsure of how to react to all this praise. “Thankfully,” he continues, straightening his posture even more and making sure to shoot Gail a brief smug smile, “by definition, they’re not child abusers. Team Bear ensures they never get the chance to live out their depravity.”
“How?”
“We're the male sect of the Coven of Mother Bears,” he happily explains. “Usually, people make tribute to their favorite of the four forms, but we worship you in all your forms, since it takes Love, War, and Death to protect Life.”
“We wish the world were not this way,” Gail cuts in, “but it is, despite our best efforts.”
I listen as the both of them take turns interrupting each other as they tell me how the women can fend for themselves on Hydra, just as Team Bear can police the men at the Temple. But it takes both mothers and fathers to protect the children of Hydra. Through a delicate thread of communication chains, Team Bear keeps an eye and an ear out for men who voice predatory opinions about children, and then they abduct the men and bring them to stand judgement against the Coven, who use magic to confirm these thoughts are true.
“Then what?” I ask.
“Then,” Ben explains with an ever-growing smile, “we make them disappear.”
Okay, so I guess this is technically murder, but I think defending the most vulnerable among us who cannot defend themselves is the most admirable thing you could do. “But where do you put their remains? Aren’t you afraid that Miles will stumble across a body and read their final thoughts?”
“No,” Ben quips confidently. “Dead things have a bad habit of not staying buried here. It was my idea to hide the bodies in this station, where absolutely no one would think to look. Most people don’t even realize this station exists. And the few who do are all too superstitious to come close, let alone inside. Not that they can access this station without the required keycard anyway.”
“Wow,” I praise, just so I can see a surge of happiness in his eyes. “That was a really good idea! And you do the same on Hydra?”
“Yes,” Gail confirms. “Although, to a ridiculously lesser extent. Men and women both have the potential to be monsters, but men have statistically posed a much greater threat. Again,” she cuts in, shooting Ben a scathing look, “I don’t know why you like them.”
Ben turns to her, hissing, “Because Cora is my soulmate!”
“She was my soulmate first, you horrible little man!”
“Hey! HEY!” I don’t think I’ve ever screamed this much in my entire life. “Gail? Gail! Put him down! NOW!”
“Thank you,” Ben huffs from where he's hanging upside down, suspended in the air by the force of Gail’s magic.
I watch as Gail goes through all the stages of grief. “Yes. Yes, you're right,” she concludes weakly. "We. . . both share that title, I suppose."
Ben, still suspended upside-down and slowly turning red, huffs, "Oh, you suppose?"
Jesus Christ, they’re so much older than I am. Why am I having to parent them? “No more hurting each other. Okay? Put him down, Gail.”
With a defeated sigh, Gail spins Ben back around and lowers him to his feet. “Fine,” she relents. “I knew this would happen anyway. That was always part of the deal.” Gail smiles at me, but it doesn’t reach her eyes. “You and I are technically no longer married. Till death do us part and all that. Of course, you were never supposed to find out to begin with, but everyday is a gamble with Martha around.”
I’m confused because Gail seems to believe what she’s saying about us being soulmates, but in order for what she’s saying to be true, I need to betray Ben in one of the most fucked up ways I possibly could by marrying the woman who is going to eventually become the worst, most reluctant mother figure of all time. Ben asked me why—out of two entire islands full of people—I had to choose Gail. Even after all I’ve heard just now, I still have no idea. “Why didn’t you just tell me, Gail?”
Sorrow is evident in her eyes, but for her part, she keeps smiling. It’s in this moment that I recognize my mother’s mannerisms—smiling as a reflex and nothing more.
“Because I’m not your wife anymore,” Gail explains softly. “You died.”
“But I’ve died a few times since I’ve been here. Does that mean every time I die, Ben and I need to get remarried?”
“No,” she says simply. “As long as you’re not reborn, resurrection does not count as death. Your death in 1977 resulted in your rebirth, so you and I haven’t been married since 1977.”
I’ve been so focused on feeling sorry for Ben, I haven’t really thought about how horrible this must have been for Gail. To marry someone, watch them die, and then be forced to raise your replacement, knowing your wife was eventually coming back?
Gail lifts her head high and points an accusatory finger at Ben. “I want him permanently banished from Hydra. I don’t want to see him. I don’t want to think about him. I just want to spend the rest of my short life in peace.”
“As if I was ever the problem,” Ben mutters.
“Okay,” I say loud enough to cut their arguing short. “Okay. Ben stays on the mainland, and you can stay on Hydra. But if you’re serious about this, Gail, that means you can no longer visit the mainland.”
“I have absolutely no issues with that," she says. "What would I ever need from the mainland?”
“Okay.” Is this negotiation over? Is everything okay now? Did I just stop another world war? “Are you okay with that, Ben?”
“Seems fair to me,” he agrees.
“Perfect.” I clap my hands together like a school teacher who just navigated a schoolyard bully incident. “Okay, so. . . I guess we can all go home?”
“It’s late,” says Gail, “but with the two of us paddling, I’m sure we can get back to Hydra by a decent hour.”
“Huh? Oh, no, I was going to. . .” But when I look over at Ben, he looks uncomfortable. “I mean. . . Alex and I were having a sleepover and I need to go get my stuff.”
“Just have her return them when she visits Hydra,” says Gail.
“On that note,” Ben cuts in, still looking deeply uncomfortable, “in light of recent news, I think we need to have a discussion about. . . us. Moving forward.” Ben waits for me to say something, but I’m too busy trying to gauge whether or not I’m currently having a heart attack.
I think I’m gonna throw up. “Are you breaking up with me?”
“No,” he says sharply, and I’m comforted by how insulted he sounds. “No, I just think we should spend some time away from each other.”
It takes all my concentration to keep my expression blank. “How much time? A week? Forever?”
“No, not forever.”
“Okay, then when?”
“I don't know," he snaps irritably. "I don't know, I don't know, I don't know!" Turning his full attention to Gail, Ben calmly proclaims, "I will never forgive you for this."
"How about you have this conversation again when you are 25,” Gail suggests.
My question comes screeching out, “25? Did you pull that number out of your ass?”
“That’s when the brain has fully developed."
"What the fuck is that supposed to mean?" Unable to hide my rage, my lip curls. "Oh, so you're saying I'm braindead?"
Gail sounds exhausted. "Please don't put words in my mouth.”
“This is so stupid.”
“Cora," Ben cuts in, "I'm sorry, but I agree with Gail. I will not cheat you out of an essential part of growing up.”
“Why do you keep saying that? I am grown up!” I shoot Gail an incredulous look, but her eyes tell me she agrees with him. “This is bullshit. 21 is literally a legal adult.”
“Yes, but. . .” Ben tries to rationalize his thinking, his eyes shifting as he wordsmiths. “I’ve lived a full life. I’ve made iron-clad friendships. I’ve traveled the world. I have hobbies. I know who I am. You said yourself you don’t know who you are without your siblings. Well,” he finishes, tossing an arm up in the direction of the door, “go find out. And don’t rush. You have all the time in the world. I’m not going anywhere.”
I want to rage more, but then I realize this deal will allow him a guaranteed five more years of life. I’d rather suffer sex withdrawals if it means I get to talk to him for a little while longer. Inhaling a steading breath through my nose, I nod. "Fine."
Gail’s expression softens as she considers his offer. It looks like after a lifetime of disappointment, she’s finally impressed with one of his decisions.
1 Year Later
The Island, 2006
I don’t know why I ever hated being a girl.
I love wearing long flowy dresses and shiny jewelry and pretty shoes and doing my hair and makeup and nails. But it’s also so much more than that. Girlhood is spiritual. It’s the cool air that fills my lungs on a morning walk along the beach. It’s in the relaxed way I move freely on Hydra, taking up as much space as I want, knowing I have no reason to fear for my safety. It’s in the laughter of us all in a grassy field, gripping our sides and wiping our eyes until another joke has us rolling around again. It’s in flower crowns and long night heart-to-hearts under the full moon.
On Hydra, I wake up, dress in whatever suits my fancy, eat a delicious breakfast of fresh produce and whatever entree Pris has whipped up, and then do literally whatever I want all day—hangout with Alex and Hazel, help Pippin gather sailors for her ever-growing crew, learn to sew and embroider, help settle disputes between the farm animals and human caretakers, help with the harvest, gossip, dance in the moonlight and walk home alone in the late hours of the night without fear of being assaulted or killed.
I didn’t know what freedom felt like until I moved permanently to Hydra.
“Cora!”
I squint in the early morning sunshine, my smile widening when I recognize them. “Morning! What’s up?”
Alex skips over and links her arm in mine. “We’re going to the North shore to surf if you want to join us.”
Hazel links her arm with mine on the other side. “Yeah, you’ve been really kicking ass. You’re a fast learner.”
“Nah,” I say, waving away their support, “I suck. You’ve been giving me swimming lessons for, what? Six months? I should be a pro by now.”
“What are you talking about?” Hazel lets go of my arm and crosses her own over her chest. “You’ve literally learned to swim in the ocean faster than anyone I know. It took me years to really get the hang of it. You’re improving in record time.”
That’s what I love most about Hydra—everyone is always so supportive. In fact, female solidarity is the main reason Shannon, Sun, Kate, and Claire decided to forgo their names in the last few lotteries. Shannon now has an intensely loyal group of girls who she teaches ballet. Sun was able to convince the other women to allow Jin to live with her as long as he stops yelling (a work in progress) and helps in the communal kitchens with seafood prep. Kate volunteers almost daily at the nursery, where newborns are periodically dropped off by overwhelmed new mothers so they can go home and get a full nights sleep.
And Claire? Well, if everything goes right, I’ll have her married to Christopher soon.
At first I thought Chris was just being his regular kind self, but the gift of a cradle snowballed into a hundred acts of service to the point where I had to sit him down and confirm he was, in fact, pursuing her. If the last year has taught me anything, it’s that Christopher is a dream son. Shy but strong in his convictions. Stern but always fair. Mild-mannered but able to hold his own if things get physical.
I’m so proud to have such a good man as my son. I just wish I knew how to tell Ben about him.
“Thanks,” I say and pull both Alex and Hazel into a hug. I’m so glad you girls talked through your issues and made up. “Let me go get my bathing suit.”
“Almost.” Maya shows me the steps again. “See, right there? Lean your weight on this leg or you’ll lose your balance when you spin.”
I try the dance routine again and everyone claps when I succeed. This used to embarrass me back when we first started dance lessons, but it didn’t take long to learn everyone offers genuine encouragement. If Alex messes up a routine, nobody laughs. Because why would they? Same with Hazel, and same with me. It’s easier to take risks with my body movement when I’m not constantly paranoid everyone is going to laugh at my jerky posture or the way my feet sometimes forget what to do when I start moving my arms. Instead of laughing, the elders offer tips and tricks from when they were young.
“What do you think it’ll be like?” Hazel rests a hand against her hip as Maya helps Alex with her stance. “Dancing with boys?”
An excited giggle escapes me before I can stop it. “I don’t know.”
And I don’t. I never danced with men in the club back in NYC, and the only times I’ve ever danced with Ben were the drunken disaster that was our wedding and the equally drunken disaster of the one and only night I was Goddess of Life. I have four years to become a master at this before I have the opportunity to dance with him again, and that alone has helped boost my confidence.
Hazel pats at her black dress, nervously looking up at the moon. “Do you think Karl is going to propose when I turn 18?”
“Oh, absolutely.”
“Really? You think so? I can never tell if his heart is in it or not.”
“Okay,” I whisper, “you are so not allowed to tell him I told you this.”
“Swear on my life,” she promises.
“He’s quiet because he’s terrified about saying the wrong thing. In fact,” I continue, “I’m pretty sure he’s just overall terrified of you.”
“Excelent.”
We break out into giddy laughter.
Okay, be cool. Calm down and be cool. So you haven’t seen him in a year. Who cares? It’s not a big deal. He’s only a man. A pathetic little man.
Yeah, but he’s my pathetic little man.
As much as I try to pep talk myself, my face enflames the second I find Ben in the crowd. I stare at him and wait for him to look up at my seat on the balcony overlooking the courtyard, but it is Finn’s father who notices me and waves happily from the stands. Confused, Ben follows his line of sight, finally notices me, and his entire being seems to light up from within.
I am so unbelievably sweaty.
It’s the first game of the new season, and the Bears aren’t scheduled to play for two weeks, but I’ve promised to go to every single game so it doesn’t look like I’m playing favorites with my husband’s team. The game begins, and I wish Ben were here beside me to explain the rules again. I have no idea what I’m watching.
Not that it matters. I keep my head forward towards the game, but my eyes always trail back to him.
I’ve been clubbing a few times, but I’ve never actually been to a house party in college. So when the Boars invite me to a victory celebration in one of the larger cellars underground, I jump at the chance to see what the big deal is.
Erik, head coach of the Boars, gives me a curt but not unkind nod as I enter the candlelit room, already booming with celebratory music. Young men eat and drink and laugh together all throughout the space, and I wonder how it is they can have meaningful conversations with so much noise. Some of the younger boys try their hardest to sneak horns of mead, and the older boys pretend not to see.
One of the youngest players catches me watching him, immediately pales, abandons his horn, and commences the walk of shame in my direction. “I’m sorry, lady Cora. Please don’t tell my mom!”
I hold up my hands and wink. “I didn’t see anything, Stieg. Oh! I like this one. What is this song?”
“Búkr, my lady.”
“How fun. Dance with me!”
“My lady?" Stieg’s eyes practically bulge out of his head. “I-I-I can’t!”
“Why not? Do you not like dancing?”
“I. . .” Poor Stieg’s face is lobster red. “I don’t know how.”
Maya and the other elders teach girls to dance fairly young. Who is responsible for teaching the boys? “That’s okay,” I say as encouragingly as I can. “It’s really easy. I’ll show you. You want to be able to impress the ladies later on in life, don’t you?”
Stieg laughs uncomfortably. "Yeah. . . yeah."
"Or men," I whisper, to what feels like his complete and utter shock. "Just give me a heads up when you're ready to court though. Oooo, I think I have someone in mind for you."
As the beat intensifies, so does my movement. I spin, I kick, I sway, I move the exact same way I do on Hydra. Free to move how I please. And I do. Happily. Up until it becomes nothing like when I dance on Hydra, and I feel unwanted hands on my waist.
I instinctively reach for the hands to pull them off me, but when I turn around to yell at the man, I realize it’s not a man. It’s four men.
It’s so safe on Hydra, it takes me a moment to fully realize how unsafe I am right now. Being adored by women is a primal joy, but what I’m feeling from these men is a primal lust. I am nothing to them otherwise. Their leering stares have always been reserved for my much thinner friends, and I don’t know why I was ever envious of the male gaze.
I’ve never been more afraid.
In my panic, I try to quickly scan the room for Ben, but he’s not in here. I scan again for any of the Bears, but I don’t see anyone I recognize at this party. Why don’t I know more Boars? Or Wolves? Or. . . wait. I know these men. These men are Falcons. “Excuse me,” I say, because maybe if I pretend like it was all an accident, he won’t get mad and blow this out of proportion.
But instead of apologizing, the Falcon steals a glance at his teammates, emboldened by their laughter, and grabs me around the waist.
“Hey,” says Stieg, “let her go. Lady Cora doesn’t want to dance with you!”
As touched as I am that a 13 year year old is challenging four adult men on my behalf, my relief doesn’t last long. One of the men tosses him aside as if swatting a fly.
I try to think of something that would frighten these men, but I’m too scared to properly harness the magical strength it would take to overpower them. As degrading as it is, I’m desperate, so I go with the only option they can wrap their mind around. “I don’t think my husband would like you touching me.” If they can’t respect me as my own person, maybe they’ll respect the danger of pissing off a man?
“Lady Cora, we both know you don’t care what your husband thinks. If you did, you wouldn’t have brought that outsider to Hydra so you could fuck him whenever you want.”
I bark a nervous laugh at the fact that my lie actually worked for once, and now I wish it hadn’t. “No, no, it’s actually not like that at all.” But the man tries to kiss me, and my focus becomes to twist away from his mouth. Call for help. Someone at this stupid party has to help, right? Can they even hear me over all this noise?
As he holds me tightly, I can feel the hard outline of an erection forming in his pants, and I freeze. No magic. No words. No strength.
“Let her go,” a voice booms, much deeper than Stieg’s brave but squeaky demands. “She obviously wants to leave.”
I know that voice. “Erik,” I cry out, still attempting to keep my voice measured. “Erik, help!”
“Aww,” the men croon, “pay him no mind, my lady. Dance for us some more. Music! Start the music! Go on, dance!”
A drum plays another steady beat, but all the joy I usually get from dancing has been replaced with disgust. I stand there awkwardly, refusing to taint something that brings me joy just because they want to objectify me. But the men grow tired fast, and the next time someone gropes me, I scream.
I hear Erik’s angry voice, but he’s preoccupied with fighting one of the men, which leaves three more to harass me. Suddenly, it’s only two men.
“Thor,” one of them shouts, confused. “What the fuck are you doing? Get off him!”
Thor the Fourth—of all people—turns on a dime and redirects his fist into his teammate’s face, and now there’s only one Falcon harassing me. The same Falcon who originally groped me. The ringleader of this entire crime. And he still won’t let go of my waist.
Like a flash of light, a knife appears at the neck of the man with his hand around my waist, and I hear the comforting voice of a Bear at last. “Let her go,” says Andor, “and I’ll consider killing you in a manner that doesn’t involve me cutting off your dick.”
I guess the only thing worse than a threat to a man’s life is a threat to a man’s dick because I’m freed in record time.
“Let’s get you out of here, my lady,” says Andor.
"Ben?" I roll over to make sure he hasn't left my bedroom at the Temple.
"Yes?"
"Are you going to kill them?"
"Go to sleep, Cora."
“Ben?” My words come out with a childish paranoia. “You’re not going to leave, are you?”
“No,” Ben confirms from his seat near the door. “Please, just relax and get some sleep. I won't let anything come in here.”
I toss around in my sheets, but the dread always finds it’s way back. “You’re not going to leave as soon as I fall asleep, are you?”
“Cora, I’m not going to leave until you tell me to leave.”
“Okay,” I whisper. Sinking into the pillow, I allow my body to calm down enough to process what happened. I’ve already told Ben the basics, how I was having a good time with the Boars until some fully grown members of Team Falcon showed up and made dancing gross. I told him all about Stieg’s bravery and the strange rescue attempt from Thor the Fourth of all people.
What I haven’t told him is my plan.
I think I understand everything better now. Boys and Girls are both raised on Hydra so their mother’s can instill virtues of kindness, collaboration, and a solid moral compass without their husbands undermining them. So why do some of the men still turn out rotten? Why are there a shocking number of men who believe women are property, or that they are owed a wife for simply existing? What happens after these boys get sent to the Temple?
I could ask Ben, but I’m just so tired.
My plan is simple: I’m going to get to these boys before their father’s have a chance to poison their worldview. That is how I’m going to save them.
And I’m starting with Thor Thorson the Fourth.
Chapter 28: Every Breath You Take
Chapter Text
“Remember to center yourself, my lady. I could easily push you over if I wanted to. Bend your knees.” Erik mimics the stance and nods for me to try again.
Since his rescue attempt at the Boars party, Erik has been desperately trying to win my favor and prove he can be trusted. To his credit, his apology was sincere and detailed, never once making excuses for his failed coup and childish notions about leadership. Ben, however, wasn’t very receptive to sorry I stabbed you, I didn’t actually mean it. His apology to Ben is being my personal bodyguard whenever I’m on the mainland.
“Like this?” I try to mimic his stance, but Erik taps at my shoulders and back until I’ve straightened my posture into the correct shape. “Is standing like this going to make it impossible for you to push me over?”
Erik laughs. “Not necessarily, but once you’ve mastered your center gravity, it’ll make it significantly more difficult.”
We practice our stance until Erik is satisfied I’m not going to hurt myself, and then we start today’s weight lifting session. Before Erik, I’d never tried anything beyond a nice long jog as far as exercise goes, so I was reluctant at first. All my mind can seem to do is conjure memories of my mother complaining whenever women were too buff. . . whatever that means.
I like the power deadlifting gives me. It shows the world that I can can have a soft body and still kick your ass with all the unseen muscle hiding underneath. After a particularly grueling session, I release the weight and relax my core.
“I’m going to help you beat the record,” Erik proclaims proudly. “No one has been able to beat my grandfather’s 900 pound deadlift, but he would have been honored to know you did.”
It’s admirable how simple Erik is, now that I know him a little better. He has a convoluted sense of justice, but his heart’s in the right place. He’s devoutly loyal to Team Boar, is passionate about the gym, and is surprisingly receptive to critique and criticisms, which I found most surprising of all. As we enter one of the cellars to get an after workout snack, I realize the most surprising thing about him is the strange way in which he talks about men.
“Hey, Erik? If I ask you something, do you promise not to get angry?”
“Of course, my lady,” he answers happily and hands me a boiled egg. “Ask away.”
It takes me two days after I’ve sailed back to Hydra to come up with a plan worth sharing with Ben. After gathering my notes, I race up the hillside and into the jungle leading to the medical facility that houses the only phone on all of Hydra. Some things are just too exciting to wait for the response of a letter.
I hear the line ring six times before Ben answers with a groggy, “Hello?”
“Did I wake you?” Wait, what time is it? “I’m so sorry.”
“No,” Ben refutes, but I can hear him yawn. “What happened?”
“Did you know Erik is gay? Full on gay, as in he is only attracted to men.”
I hear genuine surprise in his voice when he says, “What?”
“Yeah, at first I thought he was like us, but when I asked him what he liked about Jane, he basically admired her because she was the only woman who could best him in a fistfight. And when I asked him what he would have done when it came to having kids, he said, and I quote, I would have found a way to persevere. That’s the gayest thing I’ve ever heard. Hey,” I add, “so what’s the deal with being being gay, anyway?”
“Deal?”
“Yeah, everyone is always so weird about it. I mean, even you’re kinda defensive.” I smile against the heavy plastic of the receiver when he starts to explain he’s not gay. “See? Even the accusation makes you upset. What does it matter if someone thinks you’re gay or bi or whatever? Who cares? I mean, nobody on Hydra is weird about it.”
There’s a pause on the line before he asks, “What do you mean?”
“Nobody is weird about touching here. I mean, it’s not for me, but they’re always kissing and hugging and touching each other and it’s just seen as normal. I honestly can’t tell half the time if they’re lovers or just really good friends, and nobody cares either way. I’ve literally seen women kiss on the mouth in greeting and then start gushing about their husbands. Like, not everything has to be sexual.”
Ben chuckles lowly over the line. “Yes, well, you’re essentially asking for a history of each of the four teams.”
I settle on the cold linoleum flooring and twirl the phone cord around my fingers. “I’m all ears, professor.”
“All of the teams, except for the Falcons—”
“Obviously,” I interrupt.
“Obviously,” he repeats, and I can hear his smile over the phone. “The Bears, Boars, and Wolves were founded on the premise that you should be good friends with whoever you're courting. We’ve unlocked the true secret to happiness.”
“Which is?”
“That women are happiest when they feel safe and loved. It’s like their magic becomes palpable enough for us to feel it running through our veins.”
Ben sounds enraptured at the thought, and I don’t know why fear creeps in. Pressing the phone harder against my ear, my eyes dart around at all of the places someone could be hiding in this room. Why didn’t I check the room first? What if someone snuck onto Hydra and are hiding in here, waiting to ambush me as I talk on the phone?
“Cora?” Ben calls over the line. “Are you still there?”
I blurt out, “So, men are only nice to us to steal our magic?”
“Any man worth his weight in salt doesn’t steal anything. That’s what I’m trying to explain. Look at the two of us, for example.” Ben clears his throat, suddenly pausing for a bit too long. “On the. . .” He clears his throat again. “On the night of. . . when my eyes glowed?”
“I remember,” I say, sparing him further embarrassment. “You saw the future. Are you saying that I gave you magic? What was different about that time? I thought I’ve been giving you magic when—” Now I’m the one embarrassed at the thought. “You know, when I’m Goddess of War.”
“Power and magic are not the same thing,” he explains. “Men could theoretically exert their physical power over their wives, but women only share magic when they’re in love. What woman would freely give a man magic for treating her poorly?”
I don’t know why I’m so paranoid, but this version of love feels transitionary and gross. “Why does it feel like you’re saying women are some kind of prize?”
“Because they are,” he says without a hint of embarrassment or shame. “You’re joking, right? Cora,” he starts, but he pauses and sighs heavily. “I know you’ve seen things I will never be able to understand, but I need you to believe me when I say men as a species are no better than birds."
“What are you talking about?”
“Please,” he huffs in a low, comforting chuckle that makes me smile. “We give you shiny trinkets like a penguin or a raven would, we do silly little courting dances and scream for you to notice us any chance we get. Sounds a lot like a bird to me.”
“Sorry.” A rush of anxiety and fear starts to wean, but the paranoia hasn’t completely vacated yet. “I’m sorry, I don’t mean to be so defensive, it’s just. . . I don’t know. It feels like you’re saying men are only nice to their wives so they can get laid.”
“Always an exciting reward for a job well done, but it’s not our main motivator. Well, I suppose I can only speak for myself.”
I sit up on my knees, intrigued. “Okay, so if the ultimate prize isn’t sex, what is it?”
Immediately, he answers, “Being in your presence without fear of you poisoning my food or stabbing me to death in my sleep.”
It’s not even a funny answer, but I’m so nervous and confused I laugh anyway. “Being in my presence?”
“Ever wonder why men don’t live on Hydra? It’s because they keep annoying their wives and get sent back to the Temple.” Ben joins in as soon as I start laughing. “Except for the Bears,” he clarifies. “The only reason the Bears don’t live on Hydra is because we’re on a security rotation. We’re responsible for watching everyone at the Temple, so only one of us can visit home at a time.”
I’ve had a few interactions with the other wives of Team Bear, and they always seemed the happiest and horniest. I swear, the things I’ve heard from those women would have made my grandmother faint. No wonder Team Bear are the only men consistently in a really good mood.
“Sorry,” I say. “I feel like I derailed this entire conversation.”
“You did nothing of the sort,” he says kindly. “But to answer your initial question, the Falcons are the only group who don’t see women as people, so they put no effort into the relationship. To them, talking to women is no different than talking to a goat.”
“Jokes on them. Goats are really interesting conversationalists.”
“You know that, but as far as they are concerned, you’re pretending to talk to animals.”
I gasp, scandalized. “How do any of them have wives when the competition is so steep? Seriously, who would marry a Falcon when you could just pick and Bear, a Boar, or a Wolf?”
“Falcons are master liars and manipulators. By the time their wives figure out who they really are, it’s too late.”
“But everyone is so close here,” I blurt out, and then lower my voice and look around to make sure nobody has entered the room. “I find it hard to believe they wouldn’t gossip with their friends about how horrible their husbands are. They’re all so supportive.”
“I do not profess to fully understand women,” he continues, “but I do know what it’s like to feel intense shame and embarrassment. Couples can legally separate at any time, but I’ve never personally heard of anyone getting a divorce. Maybe they look around at their happy friends and fear the social ramifications of admitting they failed?”
Yes, that’s exactly what’s happening because that’s what’s been happening to the women in my family for generations. “Shit,” I breathe. “Shit, Ben, this is bad. I think I need to make some kind of announcement at the next festival. Do you think. . .” I cradle the receiver close to my face and ask, “Do you think you could help me with a speech?”
“I’d be honored.” Ben pauses, and I literally hold my breath while I wait for him to speak again. “Can we meet at the Temple tomorrow to review? I’d offer to send it by raven, but I’m worried about something this sensitive falling into the wrong hands.”
I notice I’m shaking when the receiver accidentally knocks too hard against the side of my head. Do not make this weird. You can be around him without being weird. “Yes, that sounds great.” And then I slam the phone down on its cradle without giving him a chance to say goodbye. I realize I never thanked him and my fingers fly to punch in the number to his house in the Barracks. The second he answers, I practically scream, “I forgot to say thank you! Thank you!” I slam the phone down again and realize that was way weirder than if I had just left it alone.
I’m glad nobody is in here, so they can’t see me crumple dramatically against the floor in embarrassment.
1 Year Later
The Island, 2007
I watch Amber sob into the arms of her best friends. “I just don’t understand,” she chokes out. “Why did he marry me? What was the point of wasting both our time? Why didn’t he just marry a man in the first place? Doesn’t he realize how miserable I am knowing I had a baby with someone who doesn’t even love me?”
I stand off to the sidelines, nervous that she’s about to point a finger and scream that this is all my fault. Life has been equally wonderful and horrible ever since I made a speech at the Temple. All I did was announce men and women are just people, and adult people can marry other adult people, therefore any adult person can marry another adult person.
At first, there wasn’t much of a change at all beyond everyone at the Temple acting on edge around each other, like they were worried about doing something their friends deemed unmanly and getting questioned about their sexuality. But day after day, young men would drop by my room to ask me privately all the things they didn’t feel comfortable asking their dad. I tried my best to be helpful, but I’ve never hugged so many crying teenage boys before, and a part of me is worried I wasn’t as helpful as I should have been. A small portion of them confessed their undying love for their male best friend, but absolutely all of them shared a base level confusion.
On Hydra, almost all of the women loved me for bringing to their attention that their young sons were living under constant fear of the rigorous made up rules about masculinity. Even more women loved me for pointing out spousal abuse they were gaslit into thinking were normal, resulting in multiple divorces all coincidently from players on Team Falcon. But some—like Amber—hate me for the absolute chaos that has disrupted both islands over the course of a year. Now that gay men no longer fear death from their peers, Amber unfortunately found out she was married to someone who only married her out of a misplaced sense of tradition and duty. Most of the men have happily chosen to stay with their wives and are meaningfully trying to raise their sons without anymore stigma. It’s no surprise that the only men genuinely infuriated by my speech was Team Falcon.
I successfully sneak away and return to the safety of my bedroom, only to find a note waiting for me: Please come to the Temple immediately. We have a problem, and I need you here. Meet us at the Bear’s locker room as soon as you can. —Ben
I enter the Bear’s locker room to find the entire team yelling over each other.
Hurrying over to Ben, I ask, “What happened?”
“Andor’s just made the announcement he has a boyfriend. Wait,” Ben calls as I turn away from him and towards the boys, “that’s not the problem! The problem is—”
“How could you do this to us,” Finn screeches in Andor’s face. “We trusted you!”
I step in-between the two and frown up at Finn. “Finn, you’re the most flamboyant boy in the group. You’re supposed to be better than this. There’s nothing wrong with being gay.”
“I don’t care that he’s gay!” Finn’s usually amped up more than everyone else, but now he’s so upset he jitters like he’s chugged eight cups of coffee. “I care that he’s dating a fucking Falcon!”
I spin around to ask Andor You’re dating a Falcon? But it’s no use because the entire room swells with the angry yelling of Finn, Ulf, Rune, and Karl and my words are completely drowned out.
“Lady Cora,” Andor pleads over all the noise, “please help! They won’t listen to me! Thor is different. He’s not like the other Falcons. He doesn’t even want to be a Falcon!”
Finn flings his head back, screaming in agony up at the ceiling, both hands gripping his face.
“Andor, dude, my guy,” Karl interjects, “you are so much smarter than this! What are you doing?”
“Okay,” I yell, and the boys finally fall silent. “Okay. Let’s all just calm down and talk about this. Calmly. Understood?” As I look from each of their faces, I wait for them to nod before moving on until they’ve all agreed. “Good. Now, Andor, you go first. What happened?”
I listen as Andor tells us the full story of how they’ve been secretly dating for years, but they never told anyone about it because Thor's father is outspokenly homophobic.
“Which is why we need to bring Thor here,” Andor finishes. “He’s not safe around the Falcons anymore.”
“Where is he right now,” I ask.
All eyes turn to me, and then they turn to look at the far corner of the locker room where Thor is currently sitting, hunched and defeated.
"Everyone out," I announce. "Thor and I need to chat."
Ben sits on the edge of my bed at the Temple and attempts to act like everything is fine.
I sigh. “You’re mad at me. I can tell.”
“I’m not mad at you,” Ben confirms, pausing before continuing. “I just don’t think inviting the son of my arch nemesis to join our team is a very pragmatic approach to an intricately complex issue.”
I thought it was a great idea, but now I’m not so sure. I always trust Ben’s judgement, but I may have to make an exception where the Falcon’s are concerned. No matter what argument I made in Thor Jr’s favor, Ben was firm on his stance of absolutely not.
Ben frowns at my lack of response. “Have you forgotten about the letter he wrote you? The boy is a bad seed.”
"He already apologized for that. We talked about this," I remind him. "Thor is a very sad young man who wants to be better, and Andor is a good influence on him. You want to take that away?"
"So your solution is to sacrifice Andor?"
"I'm not sacrificing anyone," I snap. "Look, I know you feel bad for Thor. No, don't try to argue otherwise, I see it all the time. You take it easier on him because he also lost his mother in childbirth."
Ben's mouth flatlines into pinched defiance.
“I think it’s time to talk about this indoors.” I watch his expression at the codeword, and despite a brief flash of worry, he quickly relents with a sigh.
“Yes,” Ben agrees, “you’re right. Where are we starting? Yours or mine?”
“Yours. You’re the one upset.” And then I follow the rules of our game and allow him to pull me into his mind.
My body shrinks down in height as my 13 year old body lands barefoot in the grass. I look around the setting he’s chosen and nod in approval. At first, I was convinced Ben’s agreement to not have sex again until I’m 25 was a death sentence, but over the years, I've learned to be around him without letting my hormones get in the way of good conversation. Turns out we can talk with each other in our minds as any age we want. We’ve decided to take the opportunity to grow up together, starting when we’re six and aging up each time we visit.
Tween me crosses her arms and frowns at tween Ben. “Look,” I say in a child’s voice. “I know you hate Thor, but I think I’ve made a lot of valid points. Any one of the people at that party could have stepped up and helped me, but Thor was one of a select few who actually protected me. Not to mention he publicly denounced his father and the entire Falcon team. That’s a huge deal! Especially since his dad is so dangerous. We need to keep him safe from the bad men he’s been forced to live with.”
Frustrated, tween Ben crosses his arms and pouts. “I still think he’s a spy!”
“Come on, we both know it’s a stretch to think he could pull off being a spy. For example,” I continue, “if he were a spy, then why did he confess his father wanted him to kill you? What sense would that make if he actually wanted to kill you?”
“That’s your problem right there,” tween Ben mumbles. “You trust people when you shouldn’t.”
“Like who?”
“Like me,” he shouts. “People like me! I could kill you at any second, just like I killed mom. So, you should just stay away from me.”
As his outburst ends, and his face enflames with embarrassment for sharing so much, I walk towards him until I’m close enough to wrap him in a hug. “You didn’t kill your mom,” I say. “Sometimes people just die.” I keep repeating myself until he stops trying to argue and finally let’s himself cry in the crook of my arm. During the few years I’ve been here, I’ve finally learned how to hug without it being uncomfortable for everyone involved. “Better?” I ask when he sniffs the last of his tears and pulls away. “Do you mind sharing why Thor’s your arch nemesis?”
“Because they’re the ones who tattooed me.” Ben stares at the ground until he realizes I’m not going to answer because I don’t know what to say. “Thor and the rest of Team Falcon are the one’s who tattooed the curse on me."
No wonder he always looks uncomfortable when I wave at the Temple during games the Falcons are playing. Maybe he wouldn't be so jealous all the time if the Falcons hadn't filled his head up with lies that he was cursed. If they had just left him to mourn in peace, maybe he wouldn't be paranoid enough to feel the need to stalk me. Maybe if the Falcon's had left him alone, he'd be a little less sad.
Maybe the Falcons need to be taught a lesson.
"Hey, are you okay? Cora?”
I open my mouth to respond, but it is not my usual voice that comes out.
SHOW ME
Ben wipes his face dry, looking hopeful. “Really? You’d do that for me?”
SHOW ME WHERE THEY ARE
Needing no other encouragement, Ben hurries over to show me the door, and I burst through with a righteous vengeance. A teenage Thor has his foot on a much younger Ben as Team Falcon stabs him over and over with the razor-sharp bones they use to tattoo.
This is what quells the leftover fear of being a 13 year old girl surrounded by five teenage boys. Not only was Ben outnumbered, he was outnumbered by much older boys.
I HATE COWARDS
“Who in the hells are you?” Thor asks, but I can hear the fear in his question.
GIVE ME YOUR TEETH
All the muscles in the world are no match for a mother's magic. I hold the boys down and rip out each and every tooth until I have a messy little pile and the young men have run off with their hands pressed tight against their bloody gums.
IM SORRY YOU HAD TO SEE ME LIKE THAT
“Are you kidding?" Ben doesn't look afraid of me at all. "That was awesome! But. . . why'd you take their teeth?"
SO THEY CAN'T ENJOY FOOD ANYMORE
Ben's expression brightens with awe. "You’re seriously the coolest person I know.”
REALLY?
“Yeah. Usually, I don’t understand people’s rules. But I like your rules. Especially the one about not hurting kids. That’s a good one.”
I THINK SO TOO!
HEY, WHERE IS GAIL? I THOUGHT YOU SAID SHE WAS WATCHING YOU GET TATTOOED?
"Oh, uh." Tween Ben hunkers down, nervously coiled, like he's afraid I'm about to hit him. "I'm sorry, but I may have. . . uh, lied."
IM NOT GOING TO HURT YOU, I JUST WANT THE TRUTH
"I kinda just said that so you'd be mad at her. If she knew what was happening, she would have stopped it. I'm sorry. I know I shouldn't have lied."
THANK YOU FOR ADMITTING THE TRUTH
"You're not mad?" Ben turns to me, his eyes wide with adoration as he whispers, “Can we be best friends?”
I THOUGHT WE ALREADY WERE?
Tween Ben squeaks in excitement, clears his throat, and tries to compose himself. “Cool.”
1 Year Later
The Island, 2008
“We’re not killing Finn,” Ben whispers sharply.
“Why not?”
"Well, for starters, Alex would never forgive us."
"But—"
“I’m not killing a Bear.” Ben finishes straightening his bowtie in the bathroom mirror and turns to stare me down with a scowl that somehow manages to look disappointed. “That goes against all sense of law and order. I do not condone chaos.”
“But what if Finn is the reason she dies?” I glance towards Alex’s bedroom where she and her bridesmaids are giggling about something. “What if he gets her pregnant? I thought you said her prophecy was to die in childbirth?”
“The future can change.” Ben pulls a stray hair off his suit, sighing. “You’re proof enough of that.”
Fine. He doesn’t want to take this seriously? Then I will.
Weddings are supposed to be a celebration of two lives becoming one, but Alex’s wedding feels like a funeral. I rap my knuckles against her bedroom door twice before they tell me to come in. “Girls,” I say, “could I please have a moment alone with Alex?” After Hazel, Flora, Fauna, Pippin, and three other girls have cleared out, I close the door behind them, sit next to Alex on her childhood bed, and take both her hands in mine, “So,” I ask her in an excited voice, “are you excited to be a married woman?”
Alex only nods.
“You okay?”
“Yes,” she answers. “Well, maybe a little nervous.”
“That’s okay. Do you want to talk about it?”
Alex opens her mouth, pauses, and rethinks her question.
“Hey,” I whisper. “You can ask me anything. No judgement. You don't need to be embarrassed.”
“What’s it like?” Her question comes out in a shaky whisper. “Sex?”
I take Alex's trembling fingers in my own. “What about it has you afraid?”
She’s panicking about everything. I can see it in her eyes.
I ask, “Do you love him?”
“Yes, of course.”
“Do you trust him?”
“Yes.”
“Then that’s enough,” I explain, and she seems to accept this lesson far faster than I ever did. “Want some advice? Don’t be afraid to talk to him. You know. . . during. It’s good to talk about what you like, and especially what you don’t like. Be vocal if you don’t like something. It’s only ever perfect when you’re both enjoying it.” I take in a shaking breath, but it’s no use. It’s as if I’m marrying off my sisters to a stranger. “Do you really trust him?” My question comes out in a croaking sob. Alex nods, but this only makes me cry harder. “I’m so happy for you. I’m sorry. Look at me, a sobbing mess.”
Alex laughs and hands me a tissue.
Tell her. She has a right to know. “Listen, Alex. . . you’re young. You have your whole life to make babies. You should be focusing on each other for now. Just you and Finn. No wailing babies or screaming toddlers. Just you and him.”
“For how long?”
“For however long you need. A few more years, at least.”
“You think so?”
Please don’t ever have babies, Alex. “I need to tell you something.”
Everything comes rushing out, like I’m trying to beat a ticking clock. I pretend the prophecy Ben told me was actually a dream I had about her. I tell her having a child would be a great physical risk, and that if she still wanted to have a baby, she would need to be monitored practically 24/7. I tell her about birth control and make her promise to be diligent in its usage until she’s at least a little older.
And then I’ve done all I can do, and I'm forced to let go of her hand and watch her walk out of the house and into her new life.
“Thank you for letting me stay here tonight.” Yawning, I close Ben’s front door behind us, cutting short the sound of instruments and chatter out in the courtyard. “Alex is already peacefully asleep, and I really did not want to wake up in the grass this morning.”
“My pleasure.” Ben smiles at me, and I smile at him, and we smile at each other until he says, “You can take Alex’s room. It’s fairly empty now that she’s moved out, but it has clean sheets.”
“Thank you,” I call, already halfway down the hallway, but I stop in the doorway.
Ben walks up behind me, but I don’t turn to look at him. “Cora,” he asks. “Is something wrong?”
“No? Maybe.” My eyes dart from Alex’s artwork taped to the wall, to her stuffed animal collection, to a bottle of extra sparkly nail polish left out on her nightstand, and a blackhole forms in my chest. “It’s stupid.”
“I’m sure it’s not.”
An old knitted sock we used to use as a hand puppet, discarded under her bed. A dent in the hardwood flooring where I accidentally dropped a parry knife one night after we snuck to the kitchen for a late night snack, and I narrowly missed stabbing my foot. Her collection of boyband CDs we’d blast at full volume on a summers day, with the window wide open, and a nice cool breeze blowing the curtains as wildly as it blew our hair. I look at what remains of her room. All of her most treasured items have been moved to her new permeant house on Hydra. A house Finn built for her with his bare hands.
“I just. . .” Alex is so happy. Finn is perfect for her, and I trust him because Ben trusts him. But if Alex is happy, then why do I feel so miserable? If Alex is just a few minutes walk from the longhouse, then why does it feel like I’ve lost her forever? I inhale deeply through my nose, but it doesn’t help calm me down. “I just thought I’d have more time.”
Ben’s voice is measured but curious. “For what?”
“To keep things exactly as they were,” I whisper, as if this can stop the truth from unfolding before my eyes. “But now her bedroom’s vacant, and we don’t have sleepovers on Hydra anymore, and I just wish. . . I wish I had known how fast time would pass.”
Coming home after a long day used to be filled with giggles and inside jokes and experimenting with makeup and manicures and music lessons and gossip. Ever since Alex got engaged, I come home to nothing but the roar of a fireplace. It’s as if the springtime of girlhood has changed seasons forever, and I’ll never be able to experience it in its purest form ever again.
I was always going to lose her, just like how I was always going to lose my sisters. It was only a matter of time before they grew up and started families of their own and forgot all about me. “I just thought we’d have more time to be girls together.” It takes a second to realize how drained with grief I am. One moment I’m forcing a smile, and the next moment I’m mourning in deep, choking sobs. “I’m sorry. I don’t know why I’m so sad. Can we get out of here?”
“Do you want to go back to the wedding?”
“No,” I beg. “Please, no.”
“Where do you want to go?”
“Anywhere,” I sob miserably. “Anywhere but here.”
Smoke from the campfire billows upwards and drifts down the cliffside, towards the ocean in the distance. Ben’s picked a beautiful spot to stargaze, and it makes my chest hurt even more as I think about all the things I wanted to do in life but didn’t.
If I could do it all over again, I’d travel the world. Hell, I never even got the chance to leave America. I would have settled for a quick trip across the border to Mexico or Canada, but you have to have money to travel, and money is the one thing I never seemed to have enough of.
I tilt my head back and marvel at how crisp and bright the stars are. “Do you know anything about constellations?”
Ben sits beside me on a log, watching the fire. “I know most of them. Why?”
“I never had an opportunity to see them for myself.” I poke at the flames with a stick, unsure of what to say. “Too much light pollution in LA, and it wasn’t any better in New York.” As much as I’d love to lay in the grass beside him and let him point out every constellation he knows, I’m too melancholy to think of romance right now. In fact, thinking of romance makes me panic. “Ben?”
“Hm?”
He’s calm, so should I be calm? Alex is his daughter. I’m just her friend. “What if we picked wrong,” I blurt out. “What if we gave our blessing, and it turns out Finn’s a maniac? What if we don’t actually know him at all, and we just gave our blessing to a maniac?”
Ben looks over at me, and I can tell he’s had the same thought at least once. “Alex is going to be fine. She’s safe with him.”
"If Finn ever hurts her, I swear I'll—"
"Cora," he interrupts. "You'd never get to him before I do. Your single kill in this life was impressive, but I'm more experienced at disposing of bodies. Which," he adds with a stern look in my direction, "is irrelevant, because nothing is going to happen to her."
“You’ve watched over Finn his entire life.” I pray that Ben understands how badly I need confirmation. “Do you trust him?”
"Alex is my pride and joy. There wouldn’t be a wedding if I didn’t trust Finn.” Ben chuckles lowly and pokes at the fire. "There wouldn't be a Finn if I didn't trust Finn."
“Okay,” I sigh in relief, satisfied at last. Ben offers his hand, and I squeeze it tight. “Okay.”
Orange in the most breathtaking shade finally crests on the horizon. It’s so beautiful, I find myself standing without meaning to, releasing Ben's hand and taking one, then two steps towards it, like a moth to flame. It only becomes more mesmerizing as the sun rises higher and bathes the ocean and grass and my dress in sunlight.
Getting older and watching everyone around you change doesn’t have to be scary. Alex won’t live in the longhouse anymore, but she still lives on Hydra. Alex, Hazel, and I were girls together, but there’s nothing stopping us from being equally happy women together.
“Wow.” I sniffle in an attempt to stop crying. “I’ve never actually watched the sun rise before.”
“Never?”
“I’m not a morning person.” I turn to show Ben how happy I am, and say, “But I think I finally get the hype.”
You have absolutely no idea that you only get sexier with age. I’d tell him to shred this thing off my body if I didn’t like my dress so much. But I really like this dress, so I keep my mouth shut and think about all the things I want him to do to me.
“There.” Ben sets aside black ink and a paintbrush and holds up a mirror to show me his work. The decorative lines and patterns Gail used to paint were okay, but it’s obvious Ben is an artist in comparison. “Finished,” he says with an air of pride. “How does it look?”
“You can never tell her I said this, but this is so much better than Gail’s.”
“Of course it’s better than Gail’s,” he says, laughing. “Let it dry a few minutes before you touch your face. Otherwise, go on up. Your adoring fans await.”
Im addicted to the rush of knowing I’m finally happy. I’ve found a way to protect women from men, while still allowing them to have loving relationships with one another. I’ve not stripped men of anything other than excuses to be a bad person. So when I step up to the balcony and wave as the rush of the crowd reverberates throughout my body and rattles my bones, I finally understand.
I’m never more powerful than when men are more afraid of me than I’m afraid of them.
A group of boys wave at me as one bouncing huddle. I laugh at how cute they are now that they’re not afraid of giving their friends physical affection. In fact, everyone in the crowd seems so much happier, and it fills me with what feels like power. Team Boar are playing the Falcon's in todays match, and when Team Boar collectively throws me a kiss, I throw an exaggerated one back. Suddenly, the crowd grows even louder with cheers, so I throw the entire audience mwah’s.
“Okay,” says Ben. “Okay,” he repeats a little louder. “You think that’s enough?”
I stop blowing the crowd kisses and frown at him. “Why are you ruining this? Leave me alone.”
Ben, looking more and more irritated by the second, grabs my hand. His voice is suddenly in my mind. Can you please stop doing that? The Falcons are playing today.
Doing what? I’m not doing anything.
Are you trying to start a fight? Congratulations. You win. Can you please stop blowing their team kisses?
Let go of me!
I feel death wafting off him. Dry, cold air chokes my lungs as the world stills. A door appears from within his mind and I run towards it for no other reason than to separate myself from this terrifying sensation. But as I reach for the handle, Ben abruptly pulls his hand out of mine and severs the magic.
Looking slightly stunned, Ben blinks rapidly and takes a step back. Instead of fighting, he plops down in the seat next to my throne. I know he’s actually angry because his nose is twitching like a rabbit.
“Hold on,” I ask, “are you actually jealous?” At first I’m angry, then I surge with relief when I realize how easy it will be to explain he has nothing to worry about. Turning away from the crowd, I sit on my throne next his chair and say, “Ben, come on. I'm completely covered in your jewelry. Everyone knows I'm yours. Am I supposed to stop waving at people because there's a possibility Team Falcon is among them? You know I hate them just as much as you do, so why do you think I’m blowing any of those assholes kisses? I'm giving affection to everyone except the Falcons. If I want to keep on everyone’s good side, they have to believe I adore them as much as they adore me. Besides, I give mwah’s to newborns. Baby’s sometimes give them back. It’s a completely exaggerated and platonic gesture of affection. In fact,” I add, narrowing my eyes at a sudden thought, “anyone who finds that sexual kinda creeps me out.”
I brace to defend myself further, but he looks horrified at the thought and says, “No, that’s a good point. I’m sorry.”
Ben’s remorse mixes with sadness, and I realize he’s still upset. “Hey,” I offer shyly, gently nudging his shoulder with my elbow. “Let’s have dinner in my room tonight so we can talk about this. For now, get up and explain to me how the hell this sport works."
Tween Ben has aged to that of a 16 year old with a greater handle on words and absolutely no handle on his frequent erections. “Cora,” he begins, but he has to sit and place a pillow in his lap. “I’ve been angry and short tempered lately and it isn’t your fault, and I’m very sorry you got caught in the crossfire.”
“Thanks.” I sit next to him and pretend to ignore the fact that the pillow in his lap twitches every once in a while. "The memory door I saw earlier. . . the one you didn't want to show me? Was it the memory of your tattoo?"
Ben nods miserably, and I surge with a dangerous calm.
He looks so sad. How can I make him less sad? "Want me to break their kneecaps?" There is no sweeter prize than making him laugh. Ben is usually so guarded with others, it's a treat all its own than he feels so comfortable around me. “I'll do it, free of charge."
"I appreciate the offer."
"So," I begin when he falls silent, "what’s wrong?”
“I’m just. . . I don’t know.” Ben shakes his head in frustration, lifting one shoulder up in a shrug. “Worried? That my best days are behind me? And I only have a little time left before I die and get sent to Folkvangr.” Ben perks up, his glasses sliding down his nose until he swipes them back into position. “In which you will dutifully visit me. . . for approximately 3 years, after which you will lessen your visits to once a year, and then forget to visit for a year or two or three, until you’ve forgotten all about me, and I’ve merely forgotten the sound of your voice.”
I stare at him in silence. “Wow, that’s messed up.”
“Huh?”
“You really think I’d abandon you in the afterlife? That’s. . . that’s really mean. I thought we were friends.”
Looking panicked, Ben sits up. “We are friends!”
“Friends trust each other, and it doesn’t sound like you trust me very much if you think I’m going to ditch you in the afterlife.”
“Yeah?” Ben counters weakly. “Well, you’re one to talk.”
My face contorts into a snarl before I can stop myself. “What is that supposed to mean?”
“You’ve already abandoned me once, what’s one more time?”
Dread pools in the pit of my stomach, but it ignites into anger the more I think about it. “I didn’t abandon you,” I snap back. “I died.”
“You weren’t supposed to die,” he says, tossing the accusation like a grenade.
As he continues ranting, I realize we’re talking about something much more complicated than I’m prepared for.
“I was supposed to save you like you saved your mom,” he says. “I was supposed to save you, and then you’d think I was the best mortal man in the whole world and we’d get married and nobody would ever hurt us again!” Ben’s immediate burst of childlike excitement condenses into an intense stare as he starts speaking at a speed I didn’t previously think possible. “You know how when you first got here I was always so tired? It’s because I spent every waking second watching over you since the first night of the crash. I was always hiding just out of sight, and even Liv wasn’t aware I was there. You saw her, though, right? At least I think you did. She’s never really been the best at concealment.”
I must look stunned because he starts to sound nervous.
“I mean," Ben continues, "in the end, I was right to watch over you. The only times I wasn’t stalking your every moment just conveniently became the time you were poisoned, the afternoon you were shot at, and the night you were attacked? Coincidences are not a thing. I should have been watching you.” His voice rises with panic as he continues his attempt to convince me. “You never would have been attacked if I was watching over you. I would have killed Matt long before he had a chance to hurt you. Or Alex. But I didn’t, because I was too tired to come up with another excuse for Alex to start making dinner without me, and I felt like I was a bad father being away from home so much, so I eased up.” As if just now realizing his point, Ben’s eyes plead with me to understand. “And look what happened! Matt was my assignment! I was supposed to vet him! It was my responsibility to make sure my community was safe, and I failed you, and I failed Alex, and I’m so sorry!”
A part of me always thought I’d be comforted by meeting someone who understands what a childhood under extreme duress feels like, but as I watch Ben spiral into anxiety about the night I was attacked, I realize he thinks he’s right. Ben honestly believes the only way to keep me safe is to watch me at all hours of the day and night. But that’s not realistic, and as flattered as I am to hear he values my safety so intensely, I also recognize that this isn’t fair to him.
“If Alex had been alone,” I explain, “Matt would have dumped her body south of the Temple.” Ben’s face twists with rage and disgust, so I continue with, “But she wasn’t alone. I changed the future to save her, and in return, she saved me. Alone, we both would have died, but you raised a strong woman who saved me when I couldn’t save myself.”
Ben nods with a nervous twitch, blinking one too many times. “Thank you,” he whispers. “That means a lot.”
“Uh, so can you elaborate on the thing about you stalking me since the day of the crash?”
To his credit, Ben does look remorseful and ashamed. “I realized what I was doing was wrong after I found myself trapped under your bed while you were getting ready for Poppy’s wedding dinner. I didn’t watch while you were changing,” he promises in a panic. “But, I’ll admit, as soon as I closed my eyes, it got me to start rethinking the entire operation, and then when you and Gail finally left, I snuck out to the party and asked my team what to do and they. . ."
"They what?"
"Well," Ben says, smiling tensely. "They. . . they said. . ." He clears his throat and falls silent.
"Can you show me, instead?"
Ben leads me through a door, and the world explodes with noise. We're standing in the longhouse the night of Poppy's engagement, surrounded by drunken partygoers and music. Sitting alone at a table on the far side of the room is Ben and the rest of the Bears.
I walk over just in time to hear Kyle threaten, "Listen, let me make something crystal fucking clear, Linus."
All of the Bears are usually in a good mood, so to see them angry gives me pause.
"She may be your soulmate," Kyle continues, "but she's our mother, and we will eliminate any threat to her safety and happiness, regardless of who it is."
"That's what I've been doing this entire time," Ben explains. "I'm just trying to protect her!"
"From who?" Eomer asks.
"You do not understand the situation." Ben looks incredulously between the other men, desperate for them to understand. "This Freyja is. . . she's completely harmless. No, actually, it's much worse than that."
I watch each of their faces morph into different levels of confused. Finally, Finn's father says, "What do you mean?"
Ben leans in closer, and the men mirror his movement like they're all being magnetized. "I haven't officially confirmed this with Gail," Ben whispers, "but I don't think she can use magic."
Kyle flinches back into his seat, looking frightened. The rest of the men digest this by letting out an equally unnerved, "Shit."
"It's going to be okay. We can do this. We can keep her safe." Ben nods down at the table, deep in thought. "Heightened security is the only answer. I'll eventually need one of you to cover for me so I can sleep, but I think I have another four days left in me before exhaustion becomes too deep a damper on my abilities—"
"Okay," Eomer interrupts cautiously, "look, Linus, we understand your desire to ensure she's always safe, believe me, we do. We really do. But she was safe with Gail. There was no reason for you to be in there, especially uninvited."
"Time and place," says Kyle, building on Eomer's point. "You keep an eye out while she's at the party or on a walk. You do not eavesdrop on private conversations. You do not sneak into her private quarters."
Ben looks from one man to the next, and from the slight movement of his eyebrows, it looks like he's finally realized nobody is on his side.
"Ben, this is all basic knowledge, I'm afraid." Karl's dad is so disappointed, he looks sleepy. "For someone so intelligent, you're rather witless."
"I need your word this isn't going to happen again," Kyle demands.
"Or we'll kick the shit out of you," Finn's father hisses. "And we'll tell Gail."
"Okay," Ben coughs out in surprise and raises his hands in surrender. "Let's not be irrational."
"Irrational?" Kyle's already angry expression deepens. "You could have broken her trust with all Bears, and we haven't even had the opportunity to meet her yet! What if she'd dropped something, leaned down to get it, and saw a strange man hiding under her bed?"
"Actually," I say on impulse, "he makes a good point. That would have been terrifying." I look over at tween Ben, but he pinches his lips together in shame. "Why did you think hiding under my bed was a good idea?"
"I was paranoid you were going to die again," tween Ben admits, and I feel the weight of his fear and guilt. "Nobody could hurt you if I was always watching."
I understand him, but if he was really watching my every move, then something doesn't match up. I don't want to scare him off by thinking I'm angry, so I fall into a lazy smile. "Were you following me when Richard and Erik took me to visit Jacob?"
You'd think I'd force-fed him a truth serum. "Yes," he admits freely.
Gottcha. "Then why did you wake me up in the middle of the night and pretend you didn't know where Margo's body was?"
Tween Ben moves only his eyes, darting them off to the side and then back to me as he thinks.
"Please don't make me ask again," I beg.
“Because,” he confesses in an exhausted rush, “as I’ve admitted in the past, I’ve never been very good with grief. My friend was dead, I was hurting, and I needed someone to blame." I can tell he's more nervous than usual because he can't seem to stop shaking his head and sighing. "Sometimes good command decisions get compromised by bad emotional responses.”
I nod because I understand. "I'm very sorry about Margo."
"Thank you. And thanks again for. . . you know. Understanding. Or, at the least, hearing me out." Tween Ben leads me out of the memory and back to the grassy field. Plopping down in the grass, he pulls his knees to his chest as his sad expression softens with affection. "I really like that about you. I feel like we can talk about anything."
"What do you want to talk about?"
Ben shrinks again in embarrassment. "I'd prefer to move on from the stalking fiasco."
"Can I ask you something?" I've barely asked the question before Ben starts jerking his head in an eager nod. "Later in the night, what were you and Team Bear laughing about at Poppy's engagement dinner?"
"Oh." Tween Ben gives a nervous huff of laughter and reaches a hand up to scratch the back of his neck. "They were making bets."
"On what?"
"On how long it would take before I annoyed you to a degree that earned me a permanent ban from Hydra."
I can't help but burst out laughing at the memory. What I thought was a fight between him and a group of random drunks was actually him getting shamed by his best friends.
"That was of course after they tore me a new one about stalking you," Ben continues. "I wasn't trying to pry into your personal space, I just wanted to see you. I mean, I’ve been waiting 28 years to see you again and then when the crash happened it was nothing but confusion. Seer Helga said you’d return on the wings of a giant flaming bird. . . and in hindsight I probably should have deduced she meant plane, but deities walk amongst us so for all I knew it very well could have been a literal flaming bird. But that’s besides the point. The point is, I let Gail call all the shots in the beginning only because it freed up my time to watch over you. I just got you back, and I didn’t want you to go away again.”
Wait. . . if he was watching me all the time. . . what if he heard me talking to myself? What if I did something embarrassing because I didn't know I was being watched? Darkness creeps in as silence washes over the conversation, so I’m confused to see his mouth moving. As I blink at him, I notice Teen Ben’s still trying to tell me something, but I can’t hear him over the ringing in my ears. Ringing turns into the echoes of a pop song, but I remember everything I’ve worked on with Harper and force myself to focus on staying in the present. I come back just in time to hear Ben scream so loud his voice cracks.
“I swear I didn’t kill you!”
“I know,” I whisper. “I believe you.”
Whatever shred of emotional reservation he’s been clinging to is gone, and he unleashes what feels like a lifetime of sadness all in one choking wail after the next. “Then why don’t you trust me?”
How am I supposed to fix this? I don’t know how to fix this. I wish my mom were here to help. I wish my mom were here and she didn’t hate me. I wish I had a different mom. I wish everything in my life had been different.
But I am here. And that was my life. And there’s no going back to fix it. All I can do now is make sure I don’t make the same mistakes as my parents. All I can do now is use them as a warning.
I’ve never been great at deescalation, so I fall back into old habits and turn on the persona I use when taking care of my siblings. “Of course I trust you, silly! Hey, why don’t we share more secrets? You love sharing secrets! I’ll go first. My hobbies include reading, cooking, and drawing.”
“I didn’t know you were an artist,” Ben says with a delightful spark in his eyes. “Let’s draw each other something. Want to?”
“Sure!” Paper and pencils materialize in our mind, and we begin working in concentrated scribbles.
“Done,” Ben announces.
I finish shading the sketch of an animal and hold the paper tight to my chest. “You go first.”
Ben pauses nervously before he flips around his paper, and I feel physically ill. He’s drawn me with attention to detail and impeccable technique. All ten of my fingers claw into my own paper to keep him from seeing it.
“Wow,” I say at last. “Yours is so good.”
“Thanks!” Ben’s entire body sags a little with relief at the praise. “Can I see yours?”
“Uh, no. Sorry. It’s really bad,” I add when his eyes fill with sadness.
“Come on,” he urges. “I’m sure it’s great. Please let me see?”
Back home, not even my own thoughts were private. I stopped keeping a diary the day my dad snatched mine out of my hands and drunkedly read aloud passages to the entire family at dinner. All I have ever known is ridicule, but Ben has never once laughed at me, so I stare holes in the floor and show him the drawing.
“Oh,” he says in one long breath. “It’s a. . . this is a really nice fish.”
“It’s a frog.”
“Oh! Yes. Sorry, I see it now. Yes, yes, there’s the long legs. I see it now.”
Teen Ben may not be the best with social cues, but he’s great at thinking quick about ways to make me happy. As I watch him point out bits of the drawing and praising it for art terms I’m not familiar with, I feel like a blackhole has opened up inside me and stolen my soul.
“What happened?” Ben doesn’t seem to know what to do now that I’m crying. “I thought we were having fun?”
I wipe my face dry and say, “I was.”
“Then why are you sad?”
Christopher exists because he was always going to exist. But that means I don’t have a choice. I have to birth him. But maybe I don’t want kids? Maybe I’m sick and tired of being trapped in a role I never asked for in the first place. Maybe if I have Christopher, I’ll hate him like my mother hated me. “If I have kids one day, do you think I’ll be a bad mother?”
“What? No! You’re great with kids.”
“I wish people would stop saying that,” I scream, and Ben’s face morphs from surprise to the blankness that comes when he’s entirely focused on trying to understand the situation. “Mama was depressed even before she gave birth to my sisters, so her postpartum meant she wouldn’t even get out of bed most days. I was the one cooking and cleaning. I was the one who had to figure out how to set an alarm clock so I could walk myself to school in the morning. I was bottle feeding babies since I was six years old.” I’m spiraling into some kind of mania, where I’m terrified to tell him all this, but I’m even more terrified to keep it inside and allow it to continue eating me alive. “You think I wanted to burp them and bathe them and change their diapers as soon as I got home from elementary school? I was six! There were a million things I’d rather have been doing! I only became their mother because they were small and helpless and I didn’t want them to die! I’d be a better artist if I had the chance to practice, but with what time was I supposed to practice? With what time, Ben? I’ve been in survival mode for as long as I’ve been sentient!”
“I can teach you how to draw,” Ben offers, but he doesn’t understand. I’m not mourning the chance to become an artist, I’m mourning the lost potential of my entire life.
I’m trying to keep my body from wracking with sobs but I’m at war with my own mind. Half of me wants the world to know how angry I am, and the other half feels guilty for feeling this way. It wasn’t my siblings fault we were born into this family. It’s not their fault our dad was worthless and our mother was depressed. But it also wasn’t my fault, and I never should have been the solution to their lack of parenting. “I’m tired of taking care of people. I’m tired of being the island babysitter. I’m tired of—” I suck in a shaky breath in an attempt to get my nerves under control. “I’m just so tired, Ben.”
Ben opens his arms in offering, and I walk over to accept. “Then take a break,” he suggests.
“Ugh.” I laugh and push him away. “Spoken like a mortal man.”
Ben holds a hand to his heart. “Guilty as charged, unfortunately.”
His laughter calms me down enough to confide in him what my real issue is. “Can I tell you a secret?”
“I am honored any and every time you tell me a secret.”
“Promise you won’t be angry?”
“Promise.”
“What if I don’t ever want kids?”
Ben’s answer mixes with a laugh. “Then don’t have kids.”
“You would be okay with that?”
Ben fixes me with a confused stare. “I don’t have any real say in this. You’re the one who has to grow it.”
Unfiltered love pools out of me in waves of light, and Teen Ben perks up at the realization that I do, in fact, love him. Almost immediately, he collapses and convulses with magic like he did the night I was Goddess of Life. I didn’t know I could be more than one Goddess at a time. I must have been both Life and Love that night, and falling in love with him is what sent him into the future. Is that where he is now? I spring into action and kneel beside him, reaching out to pull him into my lap.
I blink and I’m in an unfamiliar house.
“Cora? You’re here!” Teen Ben hurries over and hugs me. “Do you see? This is the afterlife! Isn’t it great? Look! It’s us!”
I follow Teen Ben’s finger to find Roger seated at a small dining table, middle aged Ben seated to his right and middle aged me seated to his left. Intrigued, I step closer and study the lines and cracks near Afterlife Cora’s eyes and lips. Aging is death, and seeing myself aged brings an unfamiliar fear up into my throat. Ben may not be afraid of death, but I think I may be.
Afterlife Cora cheerfully asks Afterlife Ben to help her with something in the kitchen, so I trail behind them because the alternative is staring at Afterlife Roger as he mindlessly watches TV.
I wonder if Ben is still a teacher in the afterlife. I wonder what I am.
Instead of checking on the food like they said, Afterlife Cora and Afterlife Ben slowly move closer together, and then they start aggressively making out by the kitchen sink. A secret part of me wants to watch, but everything is ruined when I start focusing on how my older body bounces and wiggles under his eager hands.
Looking away in shame, I notice Teen Ben is staring at our afterlife selves like he’s studying for an exam. Even more embarrassed than before, I swat his shoulder.
“Ow,” he complains. “What was that for?”
“Aren’t you embarrassed?”
“About what?”
I bring up a hand to shield our afterlife selves from my view. “We shouldn’t be watching this. It’s weird.”
“How is this weird? It’s us.” Teen Ben thinks of something and laughs. "Is this part of the Catholic thing?"
"Yes," I snap. "This is part of the Catholic thing."
A sharp beep of the oven timer snaps our afterlife selves out of the moment. I watch as they straighten their clothing, retrieve the food from the oven, and march back into the dining room to serve Afterlife Roger.
“This is the best day of my life,” Teen Ben whispers beside me. “We’re lovers in the afterlife! I get you all to myself in the afterlife! I literally die happy!”
I bring a hand up to stifle the giggle that explodes out of me when he starts hopping around in some kind of victory jig.
CORA?
All of the clatter and chatter in the dinning room clips itself short, so the only sound I hear is a voice as soft as a whisper.
CORA?
As I stare at the back of my own head at the dinner table, I recognize the voice as mine. Afterlife Cora somehow knows I’m here, and now she’s talking to herself. Wait, Afterlife Cora is dead, so maybe she has the answers I need to change the future! If she’s already died for good, maybe she can tell me who’s responsible and I can stop it from happening! Before I have a chance to think of smart questions to ask myself, I freeze so completely I stop breathing.
A monster cosplaying as me turns its neck, continuing to swivel even after the point of no return, after the bones begin to crack a warning and then snap loudly in protest. I watch as the copy of myself at the table spins her head all the way around to show off a combination of Goddesses I’ve yet to experiment with. Goddess of War and Death flashes me a wide-eyed smile that stretches into something it’s not. No matter how much this thing smiles, I could never be comforted by something currently fueled by everything except love.
War and Death are a cocktail of fear and despair that unlocks it’s jaw like a snake and bellows out a warning:
YOU’RE NOT SUPPOSED TO BE HERE!
Chapter 29: If You Love Me Let Me Go
Notes:
(See the end of the chapter for notes.)
Chapter Text
1 Year Later
The Island, 2009
At the center of all the attention is Sawyer, dressed in an elaborately embroidered tunic and a blooming flower crown. As I approach, he doesn’t notice me and continues his animated conversation with a group of tween girls.
“That’s not even the worst part.” Sawyer leans forward and lowers his voice. “He said that women were supposed to want a bunch of kids because it’s in your nature.”
“Ew, what?" Olive shrieks, and the friends standing around her all gasp in shock. “What if I don’t want kids?”
Sawyer purses his lips and throws his hands in the air. All the girls titter angrily at his silent implication.
“Well,” Olive gets out in a shaking breath. “I obviously can’t continue dating him.”
“No,” her friends all rush to agree in unison.
“Thank you, James,” says Olive. “You saved me from a lifetime of unhappiness.”
All of them break out into cries of, “You’re the best, James!” One by one, they rush forward to give him a crowded group hug.
“Aw, my pleasure, ladies.” Sawyer has never looked so happy and relaxed. “Happy to help,” he says and pats at any random shoulder he can reach as the girls continue to hug him.
As soon as Olive and her friends wander off, another group of young girls hurry over to talk to him.
“Hey-hey! Sally-girl!” I’d roll my eyes at him calling her girl if I didn’t notice his entire being lights up at the sight of the children. “Love the new haircut! Ah-ha, Little Sophie! When did you get new boots?”
I see my opening at last and say, “Is that a new tattoo?”
“Huh?” Sawyer twists to look over his shoulder and points to one specific tattoo out of the dozens he’s gotten over the years. “This one? Got it just last week. Isn’t it great? Thyra’s got some real talent. And I see your tattoo is finally finished.”
A hand flinches down and presses against the Jörmungandr snaking around my ankle, behind my calf, and up my right thigh. Legend says this sea serpent circles the world, biting his tail until the day he releases his grip on himself to signal the start of Ragnarök. It took almost two months and three separate artists to complete, but there was no amount of stinging pain or fear of needles that could have persuaded me not to push through. Last year for our birthday, Ben and I got matching tattoos to cover up the curse on the back of his leg. It felt poetic at the time, but now I also appreciate how cool it looks.
"Yeah," I tell Sawyer, "Wish I would have realized how much tattoos itch. I would have opted for a much smaller one. Hey, if you have a second, can I get your opinion on something?”
Sawyer nods and smiles knowingly. He’s my one and only guy friend that I feel comfortable talking to openly about my relationship with Ben. Team Bear is great and all, but Sawyer and Gail are the only people who know about our plans to remain platonic until further notice. Plus, there’s always a part of me that worries the Bear’s loyalty to Ben will inevitably win out over my desire for them to keep my secrets. Sawyer’s loyalty is mine alone, since I’m the one who allows him to stay on an island where his one and only job is to spy on boys at parties and rat them out to their girlfriends if they’re secretly voicing harmful bullshit. I’m the island matchmaker, and he’s the island matchbreaker. We make a surprisingly effective team.
Once the women of Hydra got word of his good deeds and general helpfulness for their daughters, Sawyer’s crappy shack received much needed renovations until it became unrecognizable in its beauty.
“I’m supposed to be irresistible,” I rant to Sawyer as soon as we’re in his house.“Why is Ben resisting? I was at a party the other day, and the second I started to make my way towards him, he disappeared, never to be see again all night.”
“He’s avoiding you?” Sawyer is usually smiling, and I’m still not used to it because it’s such a stark difference from when we first met. “I thought you said my plan was working?”
“It was. For a day or two. Please,” I beg. “I need a new plan. I have absolutely no idea how to talk to him about this. It’s been a whole week since my 25th birthday, and all he did was give me another piece of jewelry. Don’t get me wrong, I like being friends. But I also like being more than friends.”
“Not much good sharing this with me,” says Sawyer. “Get out there and tell him.”
“Tell him what? Hey! So, I know we’ve been platonic for what seems like forever, but do you want to get naked for the next half-hour and pretend like the last few years never happened?”
Sawyer laughs loudly, and I smile at how much happier he’s become over the years. “That actually might work.”
“Ugh," I mumble into the hands I’ve pressed against my face. "I’m going to mess this up. I’m going to mess up our friendship, and then everything’s going to feel weird moving forward. Being around him turns me into some kind of sex maniac. It’s so embarrassing.”
“Why is it embarrassing? It’s not like y’all haven’t knocked boots before.”
I open my mouth to explain why it’s embarrassing, but then I realize he’s right. It’s been years, but we’ve already made love plenty of times before. What's the big deal?
Sawyer pokes my forehead and snaps me out of my thoughts. “Whatever’s cooking in that Goddess brain of yours, do it. No more thinking. Be like Yoda and just do it.”
“That’s not Yoda, that’s Nike.”
“You’re deflecting.” Sawyer frowns for the first time all day. “Damn, you’re right. That is Nike.”
Calm down, Ben’s not actually dead yet.
This is the third nightmare I’ve had this year about mourning him. I’ve already saved Ben from blowing up in his own home by suggesting he check the gas hookups in the kitchen. My second vision was that Thor the Third kills Ben to get to me, so I secretly dealt with Thor before he had the chance. Unfortunately, this third vision didn’t disclose how Ben dies, it just highlighted that in the aftermath, I don’t take it well. Great. This must be what Desmond felt like when he was trying to save Charlie in the original show.
I attempt to wipe my face clear of tears so I can read my journal by my bedroom’s faint candlelight, but a wet tapping against my arm is what fully breaks me out of my anxiety attack.
“Mom?” Fenrir calls in the darkness.
Over the past few years, my little boys have grown into giant sized versions of themselves. Fenrir and Pumba are both massive, but Fenrir is easily twice as big as Pumba, with tall legs, dark fur, and eyes as yellow as butternut squash. The tiny puppy voice I loved so much has deepened into a rumble that always makes me smile, and Pumba has sprouted two sharp tusks he’s always sharpening against tree trunks. Both my boys are gentle souls, but Odin help you if you threaten me or one of the children on Hydra.
“Mom?” Fenrir plops his massive heavy head on my thigh and rolls his yellow eyes up to stare at me. Once a puppy, always a puppy. “Are you okay?”
I run a soothing hand over his ears. “I’m sorry I woke you, sweetheart. Go back to sleep. I just had another bad dream.”
“I have bad dreams all the time,” he tells me. “Just the other day, I had a nightmare you were being attacked by giant lizards, and I had to bite off their legs so they couldn’t get to you. They were’t very tasty.”
I laugh and then check to make sure I haven’t woken Pumba. But when I look over at his bed by the fireplace, he’s snoring loudly, as per usual. “Really, Fenrir, I’m okay. Thank you for checking on me.”
Staring at my To-Do list is stressing me out, as it should. I’ve wasted literal years of my life running around like a little girl, instead of trying to figure out a way to change the future.
Stop it. Remember what Harper said? It’s unhealthy to be this frequently stressed out over the future. I needed to take a few years to heal my inner child, and there’s nothing wrong with that.
Still, I look at my To-Do list and my stomach sinks.
Figure out what’s happening to the survivors and reunite family membersHeal any life-threatening injuriesApologize to Juliet for acting like a psycho (maybe give blood?)Visit Erik and see if he’s healing okayCheck on Peter and Darcy and make sure Peter’s ankle gets fixedOrder a scout team to scope out any potential wandering survivorsTalk to Richard—he may know something helpfulTalk to Jacob—he’s the oldest thing on this island, so he definitely knows somethingTry the mainland’s famous cheese- Visit Dolores in prison
I stare at number ten before crossing it out twice with a pencil. Visiting Dolores in prison is what made me hide this original journal in the first place. No apology could ever make that poor woman unsee what she has seen. Dolores has every reason to want to kill me, and there’s no way to win. I can’t free her, or I’ll have to worry about her killing me or the people closest to me, but I feel intense shame keeping her locked up when this whole thing is my fault in the first place.
Over the past few years, I’ve tried everything I can think of to learn about the past. I’ve taken a tour of the artwork in the Temple and noted the stories of my death from both men and women. Gail has firmly denied my request to see her memories, but she claims that’s because she doesn’t want to relive our past life together and be reminded that she’s grown old while I have not. I’ve even interviewed Charlotte’s mom, as she’s one of the only surviving members of the Dharma Initiative. Nothing has been particularly helpful, since no one but Ben actually saw what happened the night I died.
As for Richard and Jacob? Those assholes have been on some kind of globe trotting adventure the past few years, with no way to access them. From our few interactions, Jacob acts happy I’m back, but Richard doesn’t seem to like me very much.
There are two immortals on this island who were alive when I died. If they don’t want to talk to me, then it’s time I take this into my own hands.
I write:
11. Break into Richard’s house and find out what he’s hiding
“We need to talk.” I quickly push past Ben as soon as he opens his front door. Item by item, I show him each and every suspicious thing I found in Richard’s vacant Barracks home, including an old Polaroid of Jacob, Richard, and myself—both of them smiling cheerfully while I angrily give the camera the middle finger. “Look at this,” I point out, hastily flipping through a binder full of newspaper clippings. “Why does he have clippings from small local newspapers about murder victims? Look at this shit. There’s so many. All Italian. All from Sicily.”
A tiny part of me was hoping Ben would scoff and tell me he trusts Richard and there is a perfectly good explanation for all this, but he only squints as he studies the items to gather more intel.
“That’s not even the half of it,” I say and hold out an old tattered book. “Look at this.”
Ben takes the seiðr manual and flips through pages so worn they practically disintegrate under his gentle touch. After skimming a few pages, he glances at me with confused eyes. “What exactly am I looking at?”
“Highly confidential and incredibly illegal instructions on how to use magic to travel through space and time.” I watch his face to make sure I don’t miss any half-second reaction before he covers up how he really feels. “Hazel scavenged one in the archives a few years ago, and when Gail found out? I thought Hazel was going to piss herself. Don’t ask why it’s illegal because Gail refuses to talk about it. Which begs the question,” I add, waving at the book. “What is Richard doing with one?”
Ben’s been silent this whole time, so it’s calming to hear him speak at last. “Are you suggesting Richard is trying to practice magic?”
“I’m suggesting he’s suspicious as hell.”
“No arguments there.” Ben nods slowly, solemnly. “I’d offer to interrogate, but I have no way of tracking him down.”
“I’ve only spoken to him maybe two times in all the years I’ve been here, and he didn’t seem to like me very much.” Maybe he’s avoiding me for a big reason? “You don’t think Richard’s the one who killed me, do you?”
Ben’s eyes widen in surprise at the accusation—as if such a thought was inconceivable—but he never actually denies anything. “Honestly? I would have said no before you showed me all this, but now I’m not sure what I think. Richard has always been a solid supporter of your people. However, I would be exaggerating if I claimed to know much about him personally.”
I have so many theories. So many thoughts. I’m not even sure how to formulate what I want to say or do or feel because it’s just all too much. “It’s like everything is staring me directly in the face and I’m still not able to see it.” I grab the Polaroid and study it closely. Now that the adrenaline rush of breaking into his house has mostly worn off, I’m noticing more details I’d originally overlooked. “I look like shit.”
“I beg your pardon?”
“In this photo,” I clarify and hand it back to Ben. “I’m exhausted. Look at my eyes.”
“They look stunning as usual,” he comments, smiling. “I wonder when it was taken.”
Sometime between 1974 and 1977. My eyes flit over one item to the next until they land on the manual. “You know what? I don’t care what Gail says. I want to know what’s in this. Can you help me translate it?”
“Here.” Ben hands the photo back and helps me clear the table of my findings. “We can’t plan our next move on an empty stomach. I’ll start dinner. You,” he clarifies with one of his signature low chuckles, “can be the lucky volunteer who gets to julienne all the carrots.”
I’m walking down a hallway at the Temple when a chill runs up my spine. Someone is following me. Spinning around in the darkness, I can’t make out any humanoid shapes. I shout, “Whoever you are, I know you’re there. Come out.”
I’m expecting a Falcon, or some other pervert, but the figure who steps out of the shadows is Kyle. “Sorry,” he apologizes, “I guess I’m not quite as silent as I was when I was younger.”
Everything life has taught me should manifest itself in a deep-seeded fear of him, but for some reason, my anxiety lessens when I realize the man is a Bear. “Why are you following me?”
Out of all the things Kyle could do, stopping a few feet away from me and taking a seat on the floor—so we’re closer to eye level—is not what I’m expecting. “We’re on a rotation while you’re here,” he explains. “After. . . you know. The party incident? Especially now that Thor the Third is missing. Until his body shows up to confirm he’s dead, we’re not taking chances with your safety.”
“Oh. Right.” Well, this is embarrassing. I guess the entire team knows I can’t defend myself. “I’m assuming this was Ben’s idea.”
“Ahh,” Kyle starts to answer, but the words he was about to form turn into nothing more than a nervous chuckle. “Well, Ben doesn’t know we’re doing this.”
I raise an eyebrow. “Oh?”
“We’ve only just convinced him to stop stalking you and actually sleep at night. Didn’t seem very productive to tell him we’re keeping an eye on you. He’s not fond of hypocrites.”
“Which you clearly are,” I quip.
Kyle smiles. “Fair. I’m not sure how much it helps, but we only watch when you’re traveling the Temple. We don’t go in your room. We don’t eavesdrop on your conversations. We simply keep on eye out for anyone who would do you harm. No one has verbally expressed any ill will, but that might just mean they’re smart enough to keep their mouths shut.”
I guess this is no different from nobility having secret service? “Sorry for putting you all through this.”
“It’s no trouble at all, my lady. We’re more than happy to protect our family’s favorite Goddess.”
Without needing me to ask, he’s taken a seat to make me feel more comfortable so he’s not towering over me. Trust is such an unfamiliar concept, and I’m not sure how I feel about how desperately I want to trust Kyle. Ben trusts him, so does that mean I can trust him? “Yeah, but it’s a little embarrassing,” I confide, and then I can’t seem to stop confiding. “I can muster the power to defend others, but when I’m in danger? I freeze in fear. It’s like my mind goes blank and I just accept that bad things will always happen to me.”
“I can’t help you with magic,” Kyle says, “but the team could show you the proper way to throw a punch.”
“Could you?” That would actually be super helpful! If I know the basics of self defense, I won’t have to rely on magic. And if I don’t have to rely on magic, it may make using magic easier under extreme stress because it won’t be my one and only option to level the playing field. A genuine smile stretches from ear to ear. “You’re so kind, Kyle. I can see why Ben likes you. Not that I'm upset you two didn't work out. I mean, I'm territorial, so that wouldn't have worked out well for everyone involved.”
This seems to catch Kyle off guard, and his smile slowly falters. “He told you?
Uhh, oops? “Yeah, but, like, I’ve never mentioned it to anyone.” At this news, Kyle’s expression noticeably relaxes, so I ask, “Can I ask why it would be a big deal if people found out?”
“It’s just. . . easier,” Kyle explains in a whisper. “We already have enough of a target on our backs simply by being on Team Bear. The last thing we want is for a bad man who is angry with us to target our wives and children.”
He’s whispering, so I follow suit. “Why would they go after your family?”
“We are men who chose to marry women. After everything, we made a choice, and not one the Falcon’s respect.”
“I shutter to think what that team respects.”
Kyle nods in agreement. “Falcons have a complicated structure for their unwarranted hatred. They believe men who like men are an abomination, women who like women just haven’t been with the right man yet, and men who like both women and men should be killed for having the luxury of choice.”
“What about women who like both men and women?”
I must look sufficiently insulted because Kyle looks surprised for a split second before he smiles. “They believe women like you should be jailed, where you’ll have the opportunity to realize men are always the correct answer.”
“Ew, that’s so gross.” I’d hoped for a more mature answer, but when Kyle doesn’t laugh at me, I realize I don’t have to police my speech anymore. At least not around Bears. They’re like my own personal goon squad. “I swear I won’t tell a soul. As far as I’m concerned, it’s none of my business.”
I hold out my pinkie to shake on it, but instead of laughing, a confused looking Kyle says, “I’m unfamiliar with this custom, and I am unsure how to proceed.”
Laughing. Cheering. Song. Jeers. More laughter. Clanking of cups. Scraping of utensils. More laughter.
My eyes flick from one side of the dining hall to the other as I watch over the crowd. I’m trying to figure out the perfect place to make my announcement to achieve maximum effect. There’s very few things I hate more than being the center of attention, but this needs to be said in order to keep everyone safe from ideologies that are going to end in violence against anyone who isn’t a Falcon.
When the time is right, I jump up onto the table—trying my best to ignore how the immediate lull in conversation makes me nervous—and I acquaint these men with the Goddess of Death.
Smiling sweetly, my voice projects louder than usual, my eyes wide and alert as I scan the crowd for the weakest man to target. “Hello everyone! I’m sure you’ve all been wondering when Thor will return from wherever it is he’s run off to. Well, the truth is. . . he’s not coming back. Ever. Because I killed him.” If the fear in the nearest Falcon’s eyes are anything to go off of, my announcement has had the desired effect. “I had a vision Thor was going to murder my husband, so I made sure to remove him from the equation.” I take a few more steps down the table, surging with confidence when none of these men can keep eye contact. “Any threat against my husband is a threat against me and will be dealt with accordingly. Do you understand?” I’ve stopped in front of a random man. This one is always laughing at me. He doesn’t know my community has been teaching me Old Norse. He doesn’t know I can understand him now. “I’m sorry,” I say, leaning forward a little until it is my smaller body towering over his, “I didn’t hear you. I asked if you understand. Do you understand?”
I’m speaking directly to one man, but the entire room answers me out of paranoia.
“Oh good,” I tell this man specifically. “Because if anyone harms so much as a hair on my husband’s head, I’m going to kill you.”
“What? But my lady,” the man pleads with so much desperation, I have to fight the urge to laugh. "I. . . that's not. . ."
He’s not actually in danger of me killing him, but he doesn’t know that.
“I swear,” he continues. “I swear I would never do such a thing!”
“Oh, wonderful!” Dropping my smile into a dramatic frown, I deadpan, “Because if anyone harms my husband—anyone punches him, or steps on his foot, or bumps him too hard in the hallway and leaves the tiniest of bruises—I’m still killing you specifically.”
At the Temple, I’m used to feeling lust. On Hydra, I’m used to feeling love. What sounds like concern ripples through this crowd, until I can feel their fear in an addicting headrush. Good. Bad men should be afraid of me.
“Also,” I continue cheerfully, walking away from one sweaty man and onto the next, “I find it alarming that so many of you don’t know how to take care of yourselves. Did you honestly think growing up into filthy little perverted monsters would mean women would flock to you?”
“They have no choice,” a man yells, but his friends don’t burst into laughter. Nobody laughs because now I’m the biggest threat in the room, and they’re too afraid their laughter will offend me. “They need us to make babies,” he adds in afterthought, but now I can hear the uncertainty in his voice.
I shake my head like the most disappointed mom of all time. “See? Now that’s where you’re wrong because nobody needs you.” I point at him, and the men siting on either side lean away like cowards—like they were’t best buddies only five seconds ago. “I mean specifically you. Women want to marry their best friend, not some big sweaty brute who doesn’t bother talking to her unless it’s to ask for sex. That tends to be the reason Bears, Boars, and Wolves are always the first choice for marriage. They actually like women.”
“Yeah?” Curling his lip, the man I’m pointing at says, “Well, I think you’ve been nothing but trouble since you got here. Life was a lot easier before you started putting your nose where it doesn’t belong. I’ve heard all about your plans to teach our boys how to clean a house, and cook, and rear children. No son of mine is going to learn about women’s work. Right, boys?” The bearded man swings around, only to find his friends shying away in shame and embarrassment.
When it’s just the Falcons, it’s easier to hype each other up with their bullshit ideology. But now? Confronted by an actual threat he can’t intimidate with the size of his body or the size of his voice? Suddenly, they’re nothing more than pathetic little cowards.
“So.” The man sighs heavily with disappointment. “It’s like that, is it, boys?”
I would give anything to hear what he’s thinking right now, but then again, I’d probably need therapy afterwards. Using a little magic, I float across the room and land on the table he's seated at. “Have you ever wondered why you seek male validation so strongly? It’s a little odd, considering you claim to only be attracted to women.” A snorting sound echoes through the room as nearby Falcons realize what my taunting is insinuating. “Do you not find it odd that when you have a question about men you go to your father, and when you have a question about women you also go to your father? Why wouldn’t you go to your mother?” I swell with even more courage when the man sitting next to him pauses, looking like he’s deep in thought about what I’ve said.
Despite the laughter at his expense, the man’s body recoils at the thought. “Why would I ever go to my mother for advice?”
I feel a little piece of my heart wilt at the question. This man genuinely believes women are inferior and impose no real threat. But he has no idea what I’m capable of. He has no idea because as far as he’s concerned, I haven’t been trained in the most efficient way to stab someone. As far as he’s concerned, I haven’t built core muscles with a challenging weightlifting regiment. As far as he’s concerned, I’m only what he can see.
Maybe it’s naive to feel pity for him. Where did your life go so wrong that you decided to dehumanize an entire group of people? I soften my voice and give him one final chance. “Did you not have a mother to talk to when you were young?”
“No, I did.”
Huh. Explaining empathy is difficult when it’s such a foundational part of being human. Why am I having to explain empathy to this man? “Women understand themselves much more than men do. Therefore, it makes more sense to ask your mother questions about women. . . considering she is one. Okay,” I add when it’s clear he’s not quite understanding me, “let’s say you wanted to court a woman. What would you do?”
“Why?” He scoffs, looks back at his friends, remembers all over again that they’ve abandoned him, and shakes his head. “You looking for pointers?”
Nobody laughs.
Anger simmers under my skin in the form of humming magic. You stupid man. “I was giving you the opportunity to stop drawing embarrassment to yourself.”
“Well,” he sneers, “I guess we can’t always get what we want, can we?”
“I guess not,” I mock as annoyingly as I can. “Just like how your wife wanted one single orgasm in all the years you were married. But you’re right,” I add with a smile, “I guess we can’t always get what we want.”
“That’s not what. . . that's—”
One of the Falcons snorts a loud laugh and immediately tries to cover it up, but the dam is already broken and soon most of the men in this room are laughing. For a split second, I shrink at the sound of men—once again—laughing at me. Then, I sense Ben as he climbs atop the table. Suddenly, his arm is looped through mine like a pair of Victorian lovers.
Keep going. You’re doing great.
No, I’m ruining this. Everyone’s always laughing at me.
Cora, they’re laughing at him, not you.
Oh, really?
Ben’s usually soft voice echoes throughout the room. “That’s not even the most embarrassing part of this story, if you can believe it.” His eyes twinkle at the prospect of making fun of one of his enemies. “He’s been telling his friends he divorced her. Not to mention he completely left out the part about how she’s now dating her best friend, Helga.” The already scandalized crowd makes the most hilarious noises of disapproval, but none of them are brave enough to challenge me by actually voicing their disgust.
Having Ben here to hype me up is exactly what I need to feel confidant enough to stop overanalyzing and say exactly what I’m thinking at the exact second I think it. “Oh my god,” I choke out between laughter. “You lied about your divorce? That’s, like, so embarrassing.” I point at one of the random men sitting at the nearest table and ask, “That’s totally embarrassing, right?”
The nervous man smiles and answers, “Right you are, my lady.”
Does he believe that, or is he just afraid of me? Does it matter? I guess for now it’s only important that he’s publicly sided with me. “See?” I yell at the crowd. “This guy gets it! I’m sorry, what was your name again?”
I’m surprised when the man’s face blushes at the attention. “Ivar, my lady.”
“See everyone? Ivar gets it! Why can’t the rest of you? Tell you what. . . are you married, Ivar?”
Ivar seems so stunned at the question, the man next to him slams his elbow into his chest to snap him out of it. Coughing, Ivar says, “No, my lady.”
“Would you like to be?”
Cora, what’s the plan here, exactly?
Just trust me.
“Tell you what.” If I have to wait for Ivar’s response, I’d be waiting here a lifetime. Poor guy’s brain looks like it’s short-circuited. “How about you attend my homemaking classes? I’ll show you how to become a man worth marrying. But,” I add at the ecstasy in his eyes, “I’m only offering you the chance to talk to women. I’m not offering you a chance to marry them or touch them or follow them around. That decision is up to them. Do we have a deal?” I’ve barely held out my hand before the man leaps over the table and crashes in a heap at my feet.
Ivar detangles himself, stands before me, and rethinks his decision when he realizes how much taller he is—even when I’m on a table. Kneeling, he gently takes my much smaller hand in his and we shake.
As the sounds of excited and confused chatter fills the dinning hall again, Ben helps me down off the table. Talk to him. Talk to him unfiltered like Sawyer suggested. Before Ben has the chance to leave, I grab his hand tight and pull him through the crowd until we’ve left the hall completely.
When the sounds of the party are but a distant hum, I force myself to look up at him. “You’re absolutely sure they were’t laughing at me?” A current whips through the hallway and chills me. “I honestly couldn’t tell.”
“Of course they weren’t laughing at you,” Ben promises, and he’s never sounded so excited. “You were magnificent! I’m so proud of you.”
All thought is replaced with the sound of Ben’s voice repeating in my mind. Nobody’s ever been proud of me before. I want to kiss him—I want to stick my tongue down his throat more than I’ve ever wanted to do anything in my life—but I regret it as soon as our mouths separate.
Oh, no, I read this wrong. He wasn’t kissing me back, which means I completely read this wrong. Before I have the chance to literally die of shame, I turn to run, but he grabs hold of my hand and refuses to let go. For a few seconds, Ben plays tug-of-war with my arm, until I say Ow! and he immediately releases me.
Ben sounds frightened when he says, “Sorry, I didn’t mean to hurt you.”
“I’m fine.” There is a very real possibility I’m about to throw up. “I need to. . . to go back to Hydra.”
“Right now?”
No. “Yes.” Actually, no, I don’t need to go back to Hydra, I just don’t know how to navigate this part of a relationship. Because right now I really want to run, but I’m forcing myself not to run because then you’ll be confused as to why I’m upset, and I don’t want you to be upset because of me. It’s just. . . I’m always misreading absolutely everything. Just a second ago I thought you looked disgusted but now you’re acting like you don’t want me to leave, and I’m really confused. "No. “Yes.” Actually, no, I don’t need to go back to Hydra, I just don’t know how to navigate this part of a relationship. Because right now I really want to run, but I’m forcing myself not to run because then you’ll be confused as to why I’m upset, and I don’t want you to be upset because of me. It’s just. . . I’m always misreading absolutely everything. Just a second ago I thought you looked disgusted but now you’re acting like you don’t want me to leave, and I’m really confused."
Wait, why did I just say exactly what I was thinking?
I brace myself for Ben’s reaction, but he only smiles. “I wasn’t disgusted. Far from it. You just surprised me is all.”
The truth is, I’ve never felt anxiety quite like the Freyja Festival celebrating my 25th birthday. It took me hours—and the help of both Gail and Pris—to get my hair, makeup, and gown just right. Slathering myself in the floral lotions Ben’s always commenting on, I sat on my throne and fanned my face in a futile attempt to keep from sweating while the party erupted in full swing. I kept waiting for Ben to pull some kind of obscene gesture like Jane did on Charlotte’s wedding day. Every time someone new arrived at the Hall of Freyja, I’d sit up even straighter than I already was, but my excitement dulled after a few hours with no sight of him. My 25th birthday came and went, and Ben made no special mention of its significance either in person or through letters.
It’s been almost two weeks since then, and I’d be lying if I said it wasn’t a struggle to not feel hurt.
“Oh.” I shift my weight from one foot to the other. “I thought. . . I don’t know. I was expecting you to mention my 25th birthday by now.”
Ben’s eyes flit to the side before he bows his head in a slow nod of understanding. “And I was waiting for you to bring it up.”
“That’s not very romantic.”
Ben chuckles. “Oh, and knock, knock, you’re 25 now, let me in! sounds more romantic to you?”
I snort, mortified at the thought. “Well. . . actually, no. I guess I didn’t think about it like that. So, what now?” I feel my stomach sour at the carefully restrained disgust that flashes for the briefest of seconds across his face. Has he been lying to me this whole time? Was this just one long con? Does he actually find me unattractive and is trying to find the easiest way to break the news? Have I changed so much over the years that he no longer loves me?
Ben’s working overtime to keep his face blank. “To be completely honest, Cora. . . I’m not sure how to say this, so I’m just going to say it.” I wait for the devastating blow, but instead he says, “I wasn't suspicious about your age when we first met because I thought that's just what immortals looked like. But now that I know you're not 30, I’m struggling with the fact that you look exactly the same as the day we met.”
Wait, what? “Oh, thank you.”
“No,” he refutes, looking more than a little uncomfortable. “That’s not a good thing. For me, at least. Considering we met when you were turning 21. Without any visual differences to go off of, I’m struggling with the fact that you still look very much like a 21 year old.”
“Wait. . . are you saying I look too young?” I’m so confused. “I thought husbands wanted their wives to look young forever?”
Ben’s nose scrunches in disgust at the idea. “Why would we want that? The whole point of marriage is to grow old together.”
“Really? Oh. Right. Sorry.” I finally realize what’s going on and shake my head in shame. “I’m still clinging to my outdated beauty standards. When you’ve lived a certain way your entire life, it’s very difficult to see another point of view.” Tell him. Tell him. Tell him right now! “Can I be honest? I only look this way because I translated one of the lesser spells in the manual that hides wrinkles and other signs of aging.”
“Why would. . . Why would you do that?” Ben sucks in a lungful of air and calms somewhat before continuing. “I’m not angry at you, I’m just angry at the thought that someone convinced you wrinkles are a bad thing.”
It’s never been apparent to me how deeply terrified of aging I was until the tears spill over. “They’re not a bad thing?”
“No, of course not. They’re just proof you’re aging like a human.” Ben’s expressive eyes are the only thing I can trust to tell the truth. “I like the idea of you being human.”
Relaxing the magic I use everyday to smooth my skin and brighten my eyes, I show him what I look like without it and immediately feel self conscious, even though I watch his pupils dilate at the sight of an older me. In reflex, I bring a hand up to worry at the small creases in the corner of my eyes. “I’m 25. I shouldn’t have crows feet already.”
“Crows feet,” Ben exclaims, insulted. “You mean your laugh lines? I worked hard for those! Please don't take them away from me.”
A laugh bubbles up my throat, and I attempt to cough it away. “I don’t know why this is so difficult,” I confess, and it takes all my concentration not to burst into tears. “I love you. I’m in physical pain when I’m not near you. And then when I’m near you again, all I can think about is how excited I am to share all the boring little details of my life.” Finally mustering up the courage to look up at him, I find him locked in a surprised state of shock and awe. “I just. . . don’t want this to change.”
“Why would anything change? We finally got the order right. Friends first. It’s the Bear code, after all.” Ben’s mouth twitches as he fights a smile. “Why don’t we ease back into it? You’ll need to be direct, though. I’m a little rusty with the nuances.”
“Can we just. . . start over? Again? I feel like we've started over a few times." I wait for him to stop laughing in what sounds like an exhale. "Would you like to go on a date with me? Tomorrow?”
Ben takes hold of my hand, brings it up to his mouth for a kiss, and I have my answer.
It’s been over a week since I left the seiðr manual with Ben, and I’ve only just now received an invitation to discuss his translations. Despite our date being scheduled for an evening on the beach, his letter instructs me to come to the barracks at my earliest convenience, so I set sail immediately.
I’ve been saving a funny joke to open up with, but when I see her standing in Ben’s kitchen, all that comes out is a very confused, “Gail, what are you doing here?”
Ben starts to answer, but Gail immediately orders him to be silent. I’m more than a little worried when he obeys without argument.
“I expect this kind of recklessness from him,” Gail sneers in Ben’s direction, turning sharply to glare at me. “I expected better of you.”
Making sure to seem calm, I take a seat next to Ben at his kitchen table, but only so I can reach over, touch his foot with mine, and speak freely in his mind.
Please tell me Gail didn’t find out.
She did. I’m afraid we’re in big trouble.
“Cora?” Gail’s voice is loud and displeased. “What exactly were you trying to accomplish with that manual?”
“I was just reading it,” I say, trying not to sound as whiny as I feel. “Ben was helping me translate.”
“Why didn’t you bring it to me first?” Her question is teeming with jealousy. “What does Benjamin know about magic?”
“You know exactly why I didn’t bring it to you,” I snap back. “I’ve been asking for somebody to teach me magic beyond the basics, but no. Apparently, it's illegal thanks to you. I don’t know what made you believe you can just make up laws.”
Gail frowns. “Our laws are warnings that bad things will happen if you break them.”
“Oh,” I say with a sarcastic bite, “so what? What exactly is it you’re so afraid of me doing?”
“Becoming powerful enough to kill every living person on either island,” Gail answers. “You’ve already admitting to killing Thor. Without due process, I might add.”
Stunned silent, I look between them three, four, five times before I’m convinced they’re being serious. “Ben, you know I’m not going to randomly kill everyone, right?”
“That’s what I keep trying to tell her, but she won’t listen.”
“I won’t listen,” Gail interrupts, “because Cora already did randomly kill everyone 30 years ago.”
“She didn’t randomly kill everyone,” Ben argues, shying away when Gail stares him down. “Freyja gave the Initiative plenty of opportunities to change their ways, and they didn’t listen. That’s what you’ve never understood, Gail. All that happened was she—”
Ben stops moving. Not that he’s ever particularly animated, but this is different. I notice his breathing change right away, but it takes a few seconds to realize his pupils don’t look right. Then I feel it inside me. Panic. He's panicking.
“He’s remembering,” Gail exclaims with a smile on her lips and a gleam in her eye. “Cora, quick, read his mind.”
“Ben?” I scoot my chair closer so I can get a better look at his mannerisms to assess just how dire the situation is. “Ben, can you hear me?”
“Hurry,” Gail urges, “read his mind while he’s remembering.”
“I can’t,” I explain. “We don’t do that without asking first. Ben?"
As if coming out of a dream, Ben blinks and darts his eyes over to me. “Yes?”
Is the flashback over? Is he okay? “Do you know where you are?”
Both brows pull down into a frown. “I’m fine Cora,” he states flatly, but he doesn’t sound fine. “I. . .” His throat bobs as he swallows. “I found the memory.”
“Finally!” Gail claps her hands together in celebration. “So who was it? Who killed her?”
“I don’t know,” Ben whispers sharply. I can tell he’s doing worse than usual because he’s still as a statue. “I found the door, I just. . . didn’t want to open it.”
“Cora,” Gail commands, “please just read his mind so we can figure out who killed you.”
I’m annoyed at Gail’s impatience as she walks closer to him. When Ben flinches slightly at the sight of her approaching, powerful magic turns my annoyance into the ability to teleport between them in the blink of an eye. Gail takes a frightened step back as I materialize in front of her. “Leave him alone,” I snarl.
“No,” Ben refutes, sounding sad. “Gail’s right. We need to learn who killed you so we can ensure they’re properly punished.”
“No, I’m not going to force you to open that door.” Look at you. You’re obviously not okay. How could I live with myself if I forced you to relive the worst day of your life? “We’ll find them another way.” I wish I could touch him and telepathically offer reassurances without Gail interfering, but I can tell from the way Ben’s body is taught with trauma that offering physical comfort right now may make everything worse. “Hey. Ben? Look at me.” I use my softest voice, waiting until he decides to look into the eyes of the Goddess of Love to confirm I’m telling the truth. “Nobody is going to make you do anything. Not even me. We’ll find them another way, okay?”
It’s only now that I notice he's shaking ever so slightly. “Thank you,” he whispers.
“What have you done?” Gail asks in horror. “We had a chance to finally deliver justice to your murderer! What are you doing?”
Reading Ben’s mind without permission is a boundary I am not willing to cross. And to be perfectly honest? I don't really care about Gail’s opinion on the matter. “Where’s the seiðr manual, Gail?”
“Gone,” she answers in a single clipped word. “Destroyed, as it should have been years ago.”
I want to ask her: Do you have any idea what you’ve done? That manual was the last surviving hope of me getting back home to my siblings, and now I’ll never get to say goodbye. I’ll never see them have families of their own. I’ll never finish my master’s degree, or move to the midwest to retire as a happy little spinster on a chicken farm. How am I supposed to stay in this universe, knowing I’m doomed to die a violent death that nobody seems to want to help me investigate? You’ve just killed me, Gail. You’ve just killed us all.
Instead, I snarl, “You know what I think?” Stillness hangs in the air, like the air itself is waiting to exhale. “I think you’re angry I returned. You were the most powerful witch on either island, but now that I’m back you can’t stand the sight of your competition.” Look how upset she is. Her crocodile tears don’t fool me. “I will never grow old like you. You hate me because I’m a reminder that all you’ll ever be is a pathetic little mortal destined to die.”
“Cora,” Ben admonishes, sounding both angry and disappointed. “Why would you say that?”
"What?" Even though my rant was clearly directed at Gail, Ben acts like I’ve just hurt his feelings. “Why do you care?”
“Because you are being cruel,” Ben explains, and his voice warbles like he’s barely holding onto his composure. “And you are not cruel.”
It’s only now that I begin to rethink my original processing of the situation. Gail’s crying, but I think Ben’s right. I think her sadness is very much real, which means I’m being a horrible human being and didn’t even realize it.
I don’t want to be angry, but I don’t know how to make myself calm. I wish someone would have taught me how to navigate all these feelings when I was a teenager. I wish anger wasn’t the easiest emotion to conjure when I’m scared. Everything you could possibly feel all at once cycles through me: Shame. Embarrassment. Anger. Rage. Fear. Sadness. Because Ben is right. I’m being cruel.
After a few debilitating seconds pass, my emotions escalate from frightened to angry. “Fuck you,” I scream at Gail, turning swiftly to point a finger at Ben, “and fuck you, too!”
Time and space swallow me whole. All the air in my lungs gets crushed out of me under the weight of indescribable magic. I’m crumpled, only to be uncrumpled and spat out in another area of the island altogether. Materializing three feet above the ground, there’s a few seconds of free-fall before my body slams into the jungle floor.
Where am I? Oh no! Did I time travel? Great. That’s just great! Now I’ll never get to apologize to either of them! I RUIN EVERYTHING!
Letting out an enraged shriek that shakes the ground beneath my feet, I turn and punch straight through the thick trunk of the nearest tree. With a mighty whooshing of leaves, gravity brings it down heavily with a crash. In the long silence that follows, I stop feeling angry and start feeling sad that I may have accidentally hurt any birds that nested in that tree.
“I see you’re having a moment.” A voice comes from behind me, and I spin around to find a very nervous John packing up a bundle of firewood. Obviously eager to leave, he says, “I’ll let you be.”
“Wait.” Pointing is rude, but I’m not myself right now, so I point at him. “What year is it?"
“2009,” he answers. “It’s Tuesday.”
Interesting. I guess I didn’t time travel, just physically traveled across the island. Can I do it again? I concentrate on the thought of Ben’s house, but nothing happens. “John,” I say randomly, “you’re old. Aren't you afraid of dying?”
“I would greatly prefer not to die right this second,” he says.
I sigh. “I’m not going to kill you.”
It looks like Locke definitely does not believe me by the way he says, “Right.”
Just like it did after my first meltdown in front of Harper, all of my rage immediately transitions into grief. “Why is everyone afraid of me?”
John nods at the path of destruction I caused. “Is punching the preferred method of chopping down trees in Asgard?”
The mental image of the Norse pantheon canonically punching through trees instead of using axes makes me laugh so hard I sit down and start crying. “I don’t know what’s wrong with me,” I sob uncontrollably. John has every right to leave, but it looks like he’s thought about it and decided to stay. “I can’t control my magic. I can’t control my temper. Everyone’s afraid of me, but they shouldn't be afraid of me because I would never hurt anyone who didn’t deserve it.”
“You know,” John cuts in, “if you were human, I’d make a comment about how that’s a dictators mindset. But you’re not human,” he adds, and I realize he’s trying to figure out how dangerous I am without pissing me off and putting himself in danger. “So I’m not going to make comparisons to anything.”
“How dare you compare me to a man.”
"Pardon?"
"Men. When you talk about dictators, you're talking about men. I don't make rules based on the selfish, impulsive whims of men, so I don't know why you're comparing me to one." I take a deep, steading breath and turn to face him with what I hope is a relaxed smile. “My rules are simple, Johnathan. Everyone makes mistakes, but having a predators mindset is not a mistake. Anyone who gets joy from harming those who cannot protect themselves needs to be culled from the group. The only person I’ve ever killed was my rapist father who kept eyeing my younger sisters in a way I didn’t like. Are you saying killing him was a mistake?”
John’s eyes widen in fear. “No, ma’am,” he answers. “I see your point. Consider me convinced.”
That was easy. I wish they could all be this reasonable. I soften until I’m a more calm Goddess of Death. “May I ask you something?” John nods, so I ask, “Why are you afraid of death?”
“Humans are born to die, but I’ve never felt closer to death than I do right now.” John shrugs. “I guess I’m not very fond of the idea that I’ve wasted my life.”
“Yeah, me too.”
“I don’t know if I feel comforted or disturbed,” says John, and I can’t help but laugh. “Sorry you’re so upset. Did you want to talk about it?” Just like with Kyle, John takes a seat on the ground so I don’t have to look up at him. It is this gesture of kindness that persuades me to be open and honest with him, even though he’s not a Bear.
I’m afraid of who I become after Ben dies. I stopped Jin from dying, and Alex, and just the other day I had a vision of Aiko drowning, so I made sure to tell Liv and Miles so they can keep a close eye on her. But Ben? There’s nothing I do that changes the nightmares, which means Ben is destined to die.
“After my rebirth,” I confide, “I kept thinking my life would be so much better if I could just find a way to get back home, but I know now that’s not true. I was miserable back home. After I killed my father, they sent me to court ordered therapy instead of juvie, since it was ruled self defense. Didn’t do much, as you could probably tell.” In hindsight, this may be a little too open and honest. “I’ve always hated death, ever since my Nonna passed away. Recently, I can’t stop thinking about birthdays and aging and endings. Not my own, just. . . people I care about. I’ve never had friends before, so I’ve only ever had to worry about my mother and siblings dying. But. . . I love my friends here, and I don’t want them to die.” I fall silent and worry I’ve weirded him out.
John remains silent a while. Then, he shakes his head and smiles. “You know…before I came to the island, I wasn’t quite sure what deity I believed in, if any. It always felt like we were on our own. But a Goddess that cares about our silly little lives enough to weep at the thought of our death? It’s a comforting thought.”
“Cora?” From out of the trees, a disoriented Ben appears. His focus on me is momentarily diverted by the sight of Locke. “Are you alright?”
“I’m fine.” I teleported. He couldn’t have tracked me because there wasn’t a trail to track. “How did you find me?”
Ben pays Locke no mind and hurries over to assess me, like he doesn’t believe I’m unharmed until he can see for himself. “I followed…you know.”
“What?”
“I followed your…I’m not sure. Essence? We’re soulmates,” he adds with an air of superiority. “I always know where you are.” Ben’s smile drops in annoyance. “Can you not sense my presence?”
“I usually can,” I try to explain. “I’m just really emotionally all over the place right now.”
“I don’t believe this.” Ben doesn’t seem to be listening to my explanation. “Is that why you can’t effectively stalk me?”
I effectively stalk you! I watch you all the time without you knowing!
“Anyway, to clarify our earlier discussion,” Ben adds, “Gail has never understood you like I do. She thinks you killed the Initiative because you’re inherently dangerous, but I know you’re not. I’ve looked into the eyes of War and Death, and I wasn’t afraid. It would have been so easy to kill me, even accidentally, but you didn’t. Even when you were a half-mad Berserkr, you didn’t hurt me. You didn’t hurt any of us. Only the adults who knew better than to disobey you.” Ben continues evangelizing, and I pale at the realization that he most likely believes the narrative he’s constructed because the truth is too painful. “Your fury is a great and glorious indignation. The Initiative was an evil organization that deserved what was coming to them. Just ask Gail! Most of their animal experimentation was uselessly cruel. Why do you think she defected?”
Ben could be right, but he also could be misremembering. Memory is such a fragile thing.
“Which leads me to a single request, if I may.” Out of everything Ben could say—every complaint, every dismissal, every love song or poetic praise—I’m not prepared for him to cross his arms and demand, “Can you please stop threatening to kill my friends?”
Despite my ability to keep my face measured, the fact that I feel it enflame in embarrassment is a dead giveaway. “What are you talking about?”
Ben narrows his eyes in annoyance. “Locke is. . . what? The third person you’ve threatened to kill in the span of a few months? For the last time, I’m not having an affair, and I have precious few friends, so please stop threatening to kill them.”
“You ratted me out?” An embarrassed laugh coughs out of me at the sight of John’s sheepish shrug. “Sorry, Ben. I just wanted to make it clear where everyone stands. That’s all.”
Ben looks and sounds genuinely confused. “I have no idea what you’re talking about.”
Liar. You all fawn over him because he’s cooler than I am. John’s like everyone’s fun grandpa, and I’m just the mom who messes everything up and can’t remember the rules to a simple sport. “The afterparty last week? After the Bears won? I watched John leave early, and then you left.”
“Almost an hour after he did,” Ben corrects, still sounding confused. “And it wasn’t early. It was 2 in the morning.”
Wait, really? It was an hour afterwards? I could have sworn. . . I guess it could have been an hour. I wasn’t entirely focused on the timing of things, since I was so focused on watching Ben. You know, just to see if he acts differently when he thinks I’m not around.
Oh no. I can’t tell him that! I sound psychotic!
“You’re joking,” Ben exclaims, his eyes widening the longer he thinks about it. “You’re jealous?”
“Jealous?” I snort, offended. “Of what? The fact that you were laughing at his jokes? What, you think he’s funnier than I am? I’m funny! I’m way funnier than he is!”
“You are jealous,” Ben deduces with the most attractive smile I’ve ever seen. “You think I would jeopardize my relationship with you for him? No offense,” Ben adds quickly.
“None taken,” says John.
In a perfect world, I’d shut up.
In this world, I reach out and touch his shoulder to show him the worst in me.
I FIGURED OUT HOW TO HARNESS THE MAGIC OF INVISIBILITY
I STALK YOU ALL THE TIME AND YOU HAVE NO IDEA I’M WATCHING
No, I knew.
BULLSHIT!
“I could smell your skin,” he explains aloud, and the entire mood shifts. We’re like two rattlesnakes in heat. Each of us flail our tails in warning, signaling death is near, only for neither of us to bite. “Although, to be completely transparent, I didn’t realize it was you at first. I thought I was having a stroke. Then I realized the scent of you was stronger when I was standing near certain men, so I conducted a little experiment.” Ben’s expression has remained rather blank and unreadable, but now his lips have twitched ever so slightly into the smallest smile. “I see now that it worked.”
Is he just pulling an excuse out of his ass? “What experiment?”
“So you didn’t notice I was having a conversation with John while randomly walking from one corner of the room to the other?” All the mirth in his voice condenses into the low-toned sarcasm from when we first met. “At one point, I jumped on top of a table. Did you not find that odd?”
No. Of course I didn’t notice because I was so focused on making sure you weren’t gossiping about me or making out with someone else. My face enflames the longer I try and think of something to say, and my silence is answer all in itself.
“I can’t believe it.” Ben’s voice is barely above a whisper, but it turns out his surprise isn’t fear. “I did it. . . I win!”
A sinking feeling pools in my stomach and makes me queasy. “Win what?”
“I win everything,” he answers cryptically.
No, no, no, no! This was all a game to him? I knew it. “Stop. Slow down. What do you win?”
Ben brings both hands up to his chest, thumping his fingers in emphasis. “A Goddess is obsessed with me.” With each new word his voice rises in volume until he’s yelling. “A Goddess is obsessed with me!”
He’s flattered? Angry? What is going on here? “You’re not mad I’ve been stalking you?”
“Why would that bother me? I've been following you around since the moment you returned to the island.” Ben’s eyes widen with a crazed elation, and I realize he’s not so different from a Death God himself. “A Goddess deems me worthy enough to spy on! I’m better than everyone else!”
If he were any ordinary man, I'd find his display of maniacal ego repulsive. But a man who literally worships the ground I walk on? It makes his ego cute. Laughing, I raise a hand to my heart. “God, I love you."
Ben steps close enough to take my hand in his. "I love it when you call me God."
I’m overwhelmed by the same surge of endorphins that hit after a glass of Berserkr Tea overtakes my head and upper chest until I feel so happy I would do literally anything to keep him safe. Is this what love feels like?
"Happy for you two," says Locke, who I had completely forgotten was still here. When I turn, I find him inching his way backwards into the jungle until he's almost out of sight. "I'm heading back," he says, all too eager to get away from us. "Gotta drop off this firewood."
"Great," I mumble to Ben. "Now he's afraid of me, too."
"Well," says Ben, "you did threaten to incinerate him."
I wince at the memory. “Yeah, sorry for being a little overdramatic. When I was questioning him about your relationship. . . I realized he genuinely didn't know what I was talking about. And that's when I realized—" I pause, lowering my voice and glancing around to make sure we're still alone. "He thinks he's straight."
"Mmm," Ben hums in agreement. "You noticed?"
"It made me sad, and then by that point I had no idea how to save the conversation, so I just. . . walked off." I rub both hands over my face like I can wash the memory away. "I’m sorry about earlier. You were right. I was being cruel. It's weird, now that I have so much free time to exist peacefully, I’m finding out a lot about myself. Like. . . I’m jealous and possessive and I may have a small temper.”
“I know.” Ben says like it’s my best feature. “It’s magnificent.”
“My temper is magnificent?”
“When you first arrived,” he explains, “you let people walk all over you. Now? People move out of your way without you having to ask. You no longer tolerate stupid questions. When people annoy you, you tell them to go away.” Ben closes his eyes and smiles at the thought. “I love your burgeoning ego.”
“What?” All the vertebrae in my spine crack as I stand up straight. “I have an ego? Ew. No. Having an ego is a bad thing.”
“No!" Ben opens his eyes, leans forward, and yells so loudly and suddenly that I startle. “Please don’t reverse all the progress you’ve made. Here, are you hungry? Your brain is always a little foggy when you’re hungry. Let’s go back home and I’ll make you something.”
“I’m not hungry. And you don’t have to feed me, I can feed myself.”
“Cora, I haven’t tried feeding anything but your ego for months. You’ve made some good progress, but we could do so much better. Listen,” he adds, but then he reaches out and touches my arm. You don’t have to worry about your confession with me. I’m glad Thor’s gone. To be honest, I’m flattered you killed him on my behalf. But Gail doesn’t see it that way. She’s beholden to some special moral code I simply do not understand.
“Yeah,” I say with my best attempt at a smile. “You’re welcome.”
“One last thing. I think you should apo—” Ben tries again to get the sentence out. “I think you should apolo—”
“Apologize to Gail,” I finish for him. “Got it.”
I hurry back to my room at the Temple to grab supplies before I sail back to Hydra in the hopes that Gail accepts my apology. All of the nervousness I was feeling morphs into rage at the damage Thor’s caused in the short time I’ve trapped him in here.
“Oh, what the actual hell have you done,” I scream. “Thor! Why? Why!?” I run over to my desk to take note of what’s been destroyed, and I’m so upset I can’t even get a full sentence out. “You shit all over my table? You. . . SHIT EVERYWHERE?"
A green bird the size of a common parakeet flaps towards me from out of the darkness and lands on my desk. Instead of screaming insults or threats, he grabs a pen in his beak and starts slamming it against the wood in a violent headbang. If this were just any little green bird, I’d find his tantrum cute. But the fact that this little green bird houses the soul of an incredibly violent and misogynistic human man makes this hilarious, not cute. I can’t help myself from snorting a laugh at his extreme frustration.
At the sound of my laughter, Thor finally starts tweeting a beautiful sounding string of threats. “Turn me back into a human, or I’ll burn this island to the ground!”
“OW! Okay, that’s it.” I reach into a desk drawer. “You want to bite me? You get the oven mitt of shame.”
“Release me!” Thor’s beak is small but mighty and really stings if he lands a bite, so I hold him gently but firmly in a pink oven mitt as he continues to squawk. “I swear. . . when I get my body back, you’ll be sorry!”
After I dreamt Thor murders Ben, I originally confronted Thor with the intention of killing him. But much like when I accidentally teleported, my rage-fueled magic transformed him before I even realized what was happening. I was hoping he would fall asleep a bird and wake up a normal human man, but apparently no such luck. “Yeah? How about I let you free in the jungle? You’re a big strong man, I’m sure you can take care of yourself.”
“Serves me right for praying to a female deity.”
“Shut up,” I scoff. “You’ve never prayed to me once in your entire life.”
“You really lie with pride, don’t you? You’re nothing but a con artist, but your Goddess brainwashing will not work on me!”
“What are you talking about? Jeez, can’t you guys try to have an original thought amongst you? Just one? I’m a Goddess whether you want to believe I am or not. Your opinion cannot outweigh the proof. I give life, and I can take it away.”
“Yes, and if I would have known what that meant, I never would have started worshiping you in the first place.” Something in the way he says it gives me pause from calling him a liar again. Eventually, Thor continues, “I prayed to the mighty Thor my entire life, like my father and his father before him. For the strength and courage to always do the right thing. But when I met Lavender, everything changed. Life only became worth living when she was happy, and you were her favorite Goddess. I remember the day she asked me to convert to Freyja worship. To have a woman share the most intimate parts of her life? Valhalla on Earth.”
“Thor, I didn’t kill your wife. Life did. You’re mad at the wrong person.”
“What? Oh, I’m sorry," he tweets. "Am I only allowed to be angry with the Goddess of Death?”
“No,” I answer gently. “You should be angry with yourself. Instead of properly grieving her loss, you took out your anger on everyone around you, including your newborn son.”
“Thor is strong because of me!”
“Thor is strong in spite of you.” This is useless. He’s not listening to me, and now my desk is covered in bird shit. Despite the voice in the back of my head begging me to cage him in here forever, I keep a firm grip on Thor as I walk him to the door and toss him out into the night. “You’re on your own now, buddy.”
Gail pours me a cup of tea like this is any other day on Hydra, instead of the day I give her the most important apology I've ever given anyone.
"Gail?" I clear my throat. "I wanted to apologize for what I said yesterday."
"Apology accepted," she replies without pause.
Endorphins rush to my head with relief, but I don't allow myself to dwell on them. "I haven't explained what I'm apologizing for."
"Your comments about my inevitable death? You were upset," she explains. "We all say things we don't mean when we're upset."
"No, I shouldn't have said it no matter how upset I was." I watch her expression to see if I can deduce what she's feeling, and that's when I realize something. I've been so focused on making sure I'm not treating Ben poorly that I've accidentally been diverting that energy to Gail. Gail gives really healthy advice and is at my constant beck and call, and still I lash out at her. Why? Ben literally admitted to stalking me like I'm on a true crime podcast, and still I figure out ways to make excuses and forgive him. What has Gail ever done to deserve what I said? What is wrong with me?
"Well," Gail answers, looking confused at the apology, "thank you."
Without filtering what I'm thinking, I say, "My Nonna was the only one who ever defended me from the world. And sometimes I'd mistake her kindness for weakness, and I'd say things I didn't mean because I knew, no matter what I said, she was the only human being on this miserable planet who was going to treat me like a child. Everyone else would write me off as the quiet responsible one, so when I wasn't quiet or I wasn't responsible, I was nothing more than a problem. But I wasn't a problem. I was a child. And Nonna was the only one who ever understood that." I take a sip of hot tea to stifle the tears ripping at my throat. "But I'm not a child anymore, and I can't be cruel to people just because I'm overwhelmed. I'm sorry for what I said. I didn't mean it, and I hope you can forgive me."
Gail's previous confusion softens into understanding. "Well, thank you for your candor. Apology accepted. Now, since you were the one to bring up mortality, I suppose we should sort out the particulars of the afterlife."
I look up in confusion. "What do you mean?"
"No time like the present." Gail sips at her tea. "I'm not spending this life and the next with the Linus boy, so how do you plan to split the difference?"
"Split the difference?"
"Between realms," she explains, her brows suddenly twitching downwards in worry. "Between Folkvanger and Valhalla."
I'm so surprised by this news, I shout, "Oh! I had no idea you wanted to go to Valhalla."
Gail literally curls her lip at the idea. "Why would I want to spend eternity surrounded by sweaty men whose only dream in life is preparing for war after death? No thank you."
Oh no. Oh no, no, no, no. Shit. Shit. Shit. She thinks Ben wants to go to Valhalla. "Oh, you want to go to Fólkvangr?"
"Where else would I go?" Gail closes her eyes, a dreamy calm relaxing all the muscles in her face. "Enduring this hell on earth is worth spending eternity in a paradise free of men."
Sweat immediately pools inbetween my fingers until both hands are soaked. "Right. Right."
"So," Gail continues, "how do you plan to split the difference?"
THAT’S NOT WHAT I’M SAYING
YOU JUST SAID YOU THINK OF MEN AS ANTS
YEAH, BUT NOT YOU SPECIFICALLY
YOU’RE NOT AN ANT AT ALL!
YOU’RE. . . MY REALLY HELPFUL CAT
At this news, Ben’s expression freezes as he thinks on it. Whatever residual tension was coiled in his brow relaxes completely, and he smiles and breaks the connection. Outside his mind, he leans back in his chair and says, “I suppose every good witch needs a loyal cat.”
Ben is seated at his desk, and I’m seated on top of his desk because I like not having to look up at him. “Cat’s are independent beings,” I add.
“Independent beings quick to temper.”
“Yeah? Well, then that fits the bill.”
“I’m not quick to temper,” he refutes with a laugh. “You’re getting us confused.”
Ever since we confessed to being equally obsessed with each other, we started sharing all of our deepest secrets because I trust him not to laugh at me and vice versa. In the time we’ve been just friends, I’ve had the luxury of figuring out who I am. I’m loud and bubbly and just a little mean, but only if someone is mean to me first.
Ben and I joke all the time, but his comment stings because my short temper is a major insecurity. “You know, sometimes you’re a raging asshole.”
“I know,” Ben says, and I can’t tell if he sounds proud or annoyed. “But never to you.” His assured smile wavers as I lose the ability to keep eye contact. “But never to you, right? Cora? Wait,” he comments in a panic, “what did I do?”
“Nothing.”
“It’s obviously not nothing.” Ben shifts in his seat to get a better look at my face. “You’re upset. What did I do? I’m trying to think of something I could have said, but I’m drawing a blank. Cora, please believe that it is never my intention to hurt your feelings, so I need you to tell me what I did wrong.”
It’s nothing. I’m just being dramatic.
No, he’s right. I am upset about this, and our deal was to share things when we’re upset. As much as I would like to bury this forever, I decide to show him the memory of the time he tried to teach me how to play chess.
In the memory, Ben is seated at the kitchen table next to me. His voice is tinged with trademark sarcasm when he asks, “Can you please move a piece so I can checkmate you? I need to attend to the macaroons.”
“But you haven’t officially won yet because guess what?” I hold up the horse piece. “This. . . ?”
Ben waits patently for me to remember, but I just stare back at him. “Knight,” he reminds me, unamused.
“Knight? This is literally a horse’s head. Why isn’t it called horse head? Pony boy? Something equestrian related?”
Ben looks like he’s in physical pain. “Is this you conceding defeat?”
“Hell no! You didn’t let me finish. I hereby magic my knight into an apocalyptic horse who proceeds to brutally devour your queen and the rest of her subjects. I win.”
“This is quite possibly the worst game of chess ever played in the history of Midgard.”
“See?” I turn to him and point at the memory of the two of us. “You were being really rude.”
Ben shakes his head like he’s confused at my reaction. “I was obviously being hyperbolic. I was joking.”
“I didn’t think it was funny. The worst game of all time? Gee, thanks.”
“And what would you have called it? The greatest game ever played?”
I push him out of my mind and hop off his desk, headed to the kitchen. “See?” I huff indignantly. “There you go again! Sorry I wasn’t born a chess master! Nobody taught me the rules, so obviously I’m bad at it. You didn’t have to be so annoyed with me.”
“You were’t even trying,” he argues. “That was what was so annoying.”
“I just. . .” Crossing my arms over my chest makes me feel a little better. “You explained the rules too fast and I panicked because I couldn’t remember what pieces do what. And then I tried to make up for it by being funny, but by then you were annoyed and didn’t laugh, and that made me rage quit the whole thing.”
“Why didn’t you just ask for me to go over the rules again?”
“Asking for you to repeat yourself over and over? How embarrassing is that?”
“That’s not embarrassing. Most people just call it education.” After what feel like a lifetime of silence, Ben stands up from his desk and walks towards me, stopping close enough to take my hands in his. “Moving forward, when I inevitably make a mistake, can you please tell me? I don’t want to ever actually upset you.”
Logic tells me I’m supposed to swallow the lump in my throat and smile politely, but logic never seems to find me when I’m this upset. “I’m not good at anything.” Tears appear no matter how hard I fight them, one after the other. “You’re so smart and talented, and I’m a talentless hack."
"You are not a talentless hack."
"Yes I am," I refute. "I'm a talentless hack who sucks at things like chess and contract negotiation. And it just makes me feel really stupid.”
“You’re not stupid. Nobody is born knowing how to win at chess. Nobody is born being good at anything, actually. Don’t feel like a failure for not immediately understanding the rules.” Ben squeezes my hands and runs his thumbs over my wrists. “And don’t ever feel bad for wanting to ask questions. I’m more than happy to answer them as many times as you need me to. Besides,” he adds, smiling, "you have something I don't. Good instincts."
"Good instincts?"
Ben randomly asks, "Did anyone tell you to take care of your siblings? Feed them, clothe them, protect them?"
"No."
"Exactly." Ben waves a hand in my direction, like his confusing point has just been made. "You do things because it's the moral thing to do."
I shake my head at the ridiculous attempt at praise. "No, I just do what anyone would have done."
"Mmm," Ben hums in a tone of dissent. "I wouldn't have."
"What do you mean you wouldn't have?" I wait for more explanation, but he doesn't elaborate. "Wait, are you telling me if you had siblings, you wouldn't have cared for them? Even if they were tiny little babies?"
"Look," Ben begins, but he quickly gives up with a sigh. "Cora, you had to teach me what it means to consider others before myself. My life's mission was to survive. That's it. Now, in hindsight, I am embarrassed beyond belief I learned these lessons years after I should have, but just think what would have happened if you didn't take me under your wing? The point is, you have instincts that are far more valuable to the world than anything I have to offer. You know how to take care of people. Really take care of them. I'm just good at following orders."
I'm not sure how to feel about his confession that I essentially had to teach him empathy. Gail would have a field day if she knew. Oh, shit. I forgot about Gail.
"Hey," I start, but my voice catches and I have to clear my throat. "Just curious. . . is there any particular reason you don't want to go to Valhalla?"
I don't think I've heard Ben more paranoid when he says, "Why are you asking me that?"
"I'm. . . I'm just curious." I jerk my shoulders in a shrug. "Most of the men at the Temple want to go."
"Most of the men at the Temple are illiterate bumpkins. Why would I want to spend eternity with them? All that fighting and noise and stink." Ben shakes his head in disgust. "No, thank you. I prefer to spend my afterlife in your realm, where the meadows are strew of picnic blankets and everyone is friendly."
Shit. I already promised him he could go. Maybe the afterlife is huge, and he'll never run into Gail? What if the afterlife is tiny, and they constantly run into each other? Why can't anything have a simple answer? Ashamed, I say, "Got it," and drop the subject.
We’ve gone on a few romantic dates so far, but whenever the night seems to be going according to plan, I remember my vision of his death and always end up making an excuse to turn in for the night, alone. Much like when we first met, I’m terrified of being around him, just for different reasons. I'm not ready to let him go just yet, and the longer I keep him alive, the more paranoid I become at the thought of his death.
I want him to kiss me. Instead, I say, “I made you something.” At the look on his face, I explain, “For your birthday. I was going to give it to you at the Freyja Festival, but then you didn’t show up, and I kept making excuses to hold off.”
“Why would I have been at the festival?”
“It’s so pathetic,” I groan. “Even though you’re banned from Hydra, I fantasized about you crashing the party. You know. . . being my 25th birthday and all.”
“You expected me to somehow sneak past Gail to do so?” Ben lets out a long huff of a laugh. “I’m honestly flattered you find me capable, because I assure you I am not.”
“Can I tell you a secret?”
“I don’t know,” he mocks like old times. “Can you?”
“Remember when you left me alone to finish the soup last week? I. . . uh. . . waited until you were gone and then I snooped through your sketchbook. The one you keep yanking out of my hands when I visit.” Wait, this is not as funny as it was in my head. “I’m so sorry. I don’t know why I did that. Total breach of privacy. Won’t happen again.”
Ben doesn’t fly into a rage at the news, he simply asks, “What did you think?”
“Of the art? I’m flattered you draw me so often. Is that pathetic?”
“There’s nothing pathetic about admiring art of yourself.”
“You’re a very sweet liar.”
“Think of it as a daily offering. Honestly,” Ben continues, “I draw you so frequently because you’re my muse. The only reason I didn’t want you to see my work is because I was worried you’d get the wrong idea. That was, of course, before you found out I've done much more obsessive things than simply draw you in my spare time. Although, in hindsight, I’m eternally thankful you found this sketchbook and not the one dedicated to your ankles.”
I laugh. “It’s so unfair that you’re talented and I’m not.”
“Well, that’s simply untrue.”
“Yes,” I mock in a horrible attempt at an impression of him, “it is true.” Dropping the impression, I cross my arms over my chest and pout. “I’m not good at anything. Do you know how many times I’ve tried making you a shirt? They all looked like a child’s work. I literally held a funeral for them atop a flaming pyre.”
Ben finally cracks a smile at this, which quickly evolves into a low chuckle.
“See,” I complain. “You didn’t correct me. I'm talentless.”
“You’re very talented at being harsh on yourself.”
Thinking about the failed attempts at shirt making has reminded me about the gift I was about to give him. “Oh, yeah, so like I was saying, I have a gift for you. Unfortunately, for reasons I will not mention again, it is not the gift of a shirt, but I hope this will suffice.”
This gift idea was a gamble, I always knew that. Still, I’m not prepared for the confusing expression on Ben’s face when he unwraps the gold ring I made him. Is he disappointed? Happy? Confused? Insulted? I honestly can’t tell.
“I’m sorry if you don’t like it.” Shame and embarrassment flare up at the thought of reading him all wrong. “I can try to make another shirt if you want.”
Ben flinches away from me, finally revealing an insulted expression. “Over my dead body.” By the immediate twitch of his nostrils, I can tell that he regrets it. “Sorry. Poor choice of words. What I mean to say is I love it. Every husband has a homemade shirt. No other man has one of these.” I watch as he pops it onto his finger and holds it up to the light to admire it.
Only after I realize he’s being sincere do I allow myself to relax fully.
“I also have a gift for you,” he confesses.
“But you already gave me a birthday gift.”
“Yes, but this one is special. It took a little longer to make than I thought it would, but better late than never, right?”
I'm expecting more jewelry, but it looks as if we've switched roles this time. Ben’s sewn me a gown with so many layers of intricate blue fabric that it reminds me of something I’d have wanted to wear to prom. Every crease and seam and ruffle and layer has been shaped with the upmost care. It’s the most beautiful dress I’ve ever seen. “You made this?”
“Alright fine,” he admits with an annoyed roll of his eyes. “No. I didn’t make it. All I did was design it.”
“What do you mean all you did was design it? That’s the most important part! Anyone can learn to sew, but designing is literally you sharing a part of your brain.”
Ben’s eyes soften and he gives a nod, more than pleased with my compliment.
“Well,” I say, “don’t just stand there. Help me put it on.”
Ben works to lace up the back as he talks me through his design process. “I’ve noticed you don’t stay at parties for more than half an hour, and you’re tense the entire time because people keep touching you. Hence,” he says and pats at the billowing sleeves, “this dress will allow you to attend parties without people getting close enough to touch you. Oh no. I’ve upset you, I’m sorry.”
After a lifetime of being invisible, it’s an almost painful joy to finally be seen. "This is the nicest thing anyone has ever given me. Thank you.” I look down at where the corseted top ends at my waist and the skirt juts out in an exaggerated bell shape. “But don’t you think I’ll take up too much space?”
“Cora, that’s the entire point. You should be taking up more space. Take up all the space, if you ask me.” Ben finishes fastening the gown and walks around to face me. Without warning, he shouts, “Spiiiiiiiiiiin!”
I’m a completely different person in this dress. Laughing feels different. I spread my arms and spin in circles until the gown fans out around me and I realize this is what thin girls get to experience all the time.
“Come here.” Ben’s hand is warm in mine, and I try not to panic when I realize he’s walking us to his room. But just as I start to strategize my seduction plan, he releases my hand and retrieves a full-length mirror from inside his closet. “Look at it for yourself.”
I stop bouncing, and then I realize he’s noticed my mood shift and I try to overcompensate by swinging my arms. “I already did.” I realize that sounded way less excited than I wanted it too. “How long did it take you to make this,” I ask with much more enthusiasm.
“Cora,” Ben says softly, more of a question than a call. “Come over here at look in the mirror. I want to know what you think.”
I’m clearly excited by his gift, why is that not enough for him? Why is he torturing me? I stall by holding my breath, and when I finally answer, my voice is nothing but a high pitched whisper. “No.”
“Why not?” Calmness tinged with confusion laces his question. “You don’t have to like it. You can tell me if you think it’s ugly. I’ll make you a new one.”
“I don’t think it’s ugly.”
“Then why don’t you want to look at yourself in the mirror?”
“Because,” I answer truthfully, “I’m really happy right now, and I’m not ready to lose that feeling just yet.”
Ben’s never had this expression before and I’m frustrated by my inability to figure out what he’s thinking. Is he sad? Does he pity me? Before I can ask, he places one hand on each of my shoulders and guides me over to stand in front of the mirror.
“Five things,” he announces. “I want you to tell me five things you love about yourself.”
“This is so stupid.”
Even though he’s much older now, I can see the youthful spark of teenage Ben flash across his lips until they’re pulled halfway up one side of his face. “Come on, Goddess of Love. Name five things you love about yourself. Fine, one thing,” he amends with a concerned arch of his brow. “Name one thing you love about yourself.”
“My eyes,” I answer immediately because they are neither the brown eyes of my mother or the blue eyes of my father. They’re all mine. Everyone always tells me I have beautiful eyes because they can’t find a single other thing on my body to praise. “I love my eyes,” I say with significantly less enthusiasm.
“Yes, good,” Ben coaches. “That’s a great start. You have beautiful eyes. Okay, name something else. Anything else.”
I skim over my reflection in the mirror. My eyes? Perfection. My face? Too round. My mouth? Too small. My cheeks? Too full. My arms are too big and my stomach hangs too low and my legs are too short and dimpled with cellulite. There has to be something other than my eyes that I like about myself.
A cryptic expression passes over Ben’s face again, and I flush with embarrassment that all the validation in the world doesn’t seem to be helping. He can tell me I’m beautiful all day till the moment he dies and it won’t do any good.
“You’re remembering something specific.” Ben raises his hands up to hover over my temples while he waits for my answer. “May I?”
I nod, and we’re sucked into one of my many memories of trying to find secondhand clothes that fit somewhat decently. “Not the goddamn Cranberries,” I mutter as the sound of Linger plays over the Goodwill loudspeaker.
Seeing the poorly kept thrift store brings me back to a specific time and place filled with horrible memories. In the corner of the room, past piles of discarded clothing, in the very last dressing room in a long line of empty rooms, I can hear my female rage screaming within complete silence.
A hand flinches up to my heart to try and massage away the pain. “This was so long ago, you’d think it wouldn’t hurt so much. No, wait,” I say, holding out a hand to stop Ben from approaching. This is something I have to do myself. “Thanks, but I’ve got this one.” Sucking in a deep breath, I approach the locked dressing room and knock. “Hey, it’s me. Open up.”
From inside, I hear my child voice answer, “Go away.”
Every memory of the before times strangles my lungs. Time has removed me enough from mainstream societal expectations that I had completely forgotten the misery that comes with being a big girl in a man’s world. “Cora? Listen, I know you’re disappointed you can’t afford to shop at the same stores as your friends. And I’m sorry it feels so impossible to find clothes that fit. I get it. It really sucks to feel like you’re not allowed to be like everyone else. But you don’t even like the current fashion anyway. Like, the skirt your friends bought to wear on Monday? It’s so ugly. You don’t like any of this fucking shit.”
Tween me unlatches the lock and flings the door open, looking scandalized. “You can’t say that word!”
“Which one? Fuck or shit?”
Younger me plugs her ears. “Stop saying that!”
I look tired. I look way too tired for a middle schooler. “They’re just words, Cora. They only hold power if you give them power. And stop changing the subject.” Waving magic through the air, I conjure the offending skirt—an Abercrombie & Fitch micro-mini denim skirt whose biggest size couldn’t even fit halfway up my thighs. “Tell me this skirt is cute.”
“It is cute,” tween me refutes stubbornly.
No it’s not. Come on, Cora. “Look me in the eye and say that. Come on. Look me in the eye.”
Tween me attempts to make eye contact, but Ben is right. I’m a terrible liar. “Fine,” she relents. “It’s horrible. I hate everything about it.”
“There we go! See? You don’t want this, and you definitely don’t need it.”
Still staring holes into the carpeted floor, tween me mumbles, “But everyone else is getting one.”
Talking to my younger self is proving more difficult than I thought because she doesn’t believe anything I say. When I try to explain that adult Cora is a celebrity who marries our dream man and lives on a private island, tween me snorts and rolls her eyes. She won’t believe me when I try to explain we have friends who would literally die for us, and she laughs at the idea of us having access to the finest fashion.
As I continue to explain, I sink to my knees to make her more comfortable. We’re always the short one in the group, so I never had the chance to look down on anyone before. “I know life sucks right now,” I continue, “but we’re not going to be sad forever. We’re going to grow up and learn all these cool hobbies like embroidery. . . and actually, you’re not going to be very good at that. But it’ll still bring you joy because some of your favorite inside jokes will come from nights where your friends gathered to embroider together. Oh! And the best part is you’re gonna make your own clothes—”
Tween me perks up at this. “We make our own clothes?”
“Well, not exactly. But you have access to clothes tailored specifically to our body. Look at this.”
I can’t help but smile as I transform into my favorite disco jumpsuit and younger me starts screaming uncontrollably with glee. Next I transform into my favorite housedress, then my wedding dress, and then I just cycle through my entire wardrobe as I walk up and down the aisles like a runway. Tween me screams and flails and bounces around until I change into the blue gown Ben just gifted me, and she quiets down and stops moving.
“What’s wrong?”
“Nothing,” she says. “It’s just. . . a little much, don’t you think?”
I watch as all the light washes out of younger me, and then I grow angry. “No, I don’t. I think it makes me feel like a princess. What’s wrong with that?”
“It’s just so. . . poofy.”
“What’s wrong with poofy?”
“It’s not flattering. Nonna says anything that takes up too much space isn’t flattering on us because we already take up enough space as it is.”
I bristle with anger. “Nonna didn’t say that.”
“Yes she did.”
“No she didn’t! Nonna never would have said something so mean!”
And then tween Cora reminds me of the time and place in which Nonna said exactly that.
“Oh my god,” I yell, horrified. “Nonna really did say that. What the fuck, Nonna?” Tween Cora flinches away in fear, and the rage in me completely subsides. “Jesus Christ,” I whisper, “sorry about that. I’m not yelling at you.” Terrifying bad men makes me feel sexy. Terrifying children makes me want to throw up. “Hey, sweetheart,” I soothe. “Listen to me. We loved Nonna very much, but she was imperfect just like every other human. Which means, not everything she said was true.”
“But it is true,” she says. “Everyone’s always laughing at us.”
“Okay, but. . . that doesn’t last forever. Kids are really mean, but when you grow up? Your husband is going to think you’re really hot. So who cares what those kids think?”
“Really?”
“Yes, so stop slouching,” I order. “There we go. Stand up straight! Pop those titties!”
Tween Cora points at me, but I can tell she’s not actually insulted because she’s grinning. “Stop swearing.”
“Titties are a body part, not a swear word. And,” I add in a whisper, “it’s okay that you like them. Boobs are great.”
Tween me giggles. “Yeah, they are, right?”
“Repeat after me.” I clear my throat. “I’m a bad bitch.”
“I’m a. . .”
“Come on,” I encourage. “Say it! I’m a bad bitch!”
Tween me takes a look around, notices we’re alone, and squeaks out, “I’m a bad bitch.”
“Yeah you are. Say it again!”
I hype myself up until I’ve hyped myself a little too much. Tween Cora lets out a angry shriek and punches a hole in the wall. Then she punches through all the dressing room mirrors. Then she lifts up a cart of wedding dresses and tosses it across the store as if it weighed nothing, all the while screaming I’m a bad bitch!
Ben raises an eyebrow at me.
“Can you give us one second?” Before Ben can answer, I’ve already shoved tween Cora into a dressing room and shut the door behind us. “What is wrong with you,” I hiss. “Get your shit together! Violence is only the answer when people’s lives are in danger. No more punching random things, okay?”
“Sorry,” she says.
I didn’t have a mom. Not really. I guess I’ll have to be my own mom. If the world is going to be unkind to me, the least I can do is be kind to myself. Making sure to wrap both arms around her, I hug my younger self. “We’re gonna be okay. I promise.”
I feel her hug me back, and I smile.
9 Months Later
Now that we both fully love and trust and support each other, life is great. For us, at least. Unfortunately for everyone else, Ben and I are absolute menaces to society.
When I’m forced into conversation with someone I dislike, Ben will reach out to touch an arm or place a comforting hand on my shoulder so he can make jokes in our mind until I laugh, and it confuses everyone involved except us. I feel more comfortable telling people no without over-explaining my reasoning. With Team Bear’s help, I know how to throw a punch without breaking all my fingers, and the good news is I’ve only had to punch one person so far before the rude comments stopped completely. Even the meanest Falcon has decided to keep their horrid thoughts in their head.
In social settings, I was always the one off to the side, watching the group and making sure everyone is safe. Which, in hindsight, meant I never got the opportunity to meaningfully practice casual conversation. But now that Ben’s glued to my side at parties, I feel inherently less stressed because he’s quick to jump in if I can’t figure out what to say next.
It is precisely because he’s always defending me that I make my first move. At first it’s a slow escalation—flirting openly in front of other people and making out at parties—but kissing led to sneaking off and groping over our clothes, which led to groping under our clothes, which led to me getting pushed against one of the murals he painted in my bedroom. Ben crawled under my skirts and hoisted my legs over his shoulders, holding me up against the wall until I gave him what he wanted. All he ever wants is to let everyone know he’s the reason I’m glowing all the time. All he ever wants is for me to scream his name.
I’m now well acquainted with every storage closet, secret hallway, and hidden passage at both the barracks and the Temple. Every time we’re in close proximity, we can’t control ourselves. Birthday parties. During any game that doesn’t involve Team Bear. Three separate weddings on every day of the wedding. The trick is to not get caught, and as long as I’m always glowing, there’s no way for anyone to tell where one orgasm ends and another begins.
Seduction is just one giant game, and our latest game is to see who can resist sex the longest.
On a bright and sunny afternoon, I hop up onto his desk, lean forward with my elbows resting against my knees and my face resting in my palms, and widen my eyes. “Tell me a secret.”
Ben laughs at my theatrics, but I suspect he’s less amused and more just trying to stall. Finally, he answers, “I wish you would visit the mainland more often.”
“I’m literally by your side every day of the week except Saturdays and Sundays.” I sit up straight. “You think I don’t visit enough?”
Ben opens his mouth to answer, but he’s thinking too hard, and now I’m worried he’s not telling me something. “I just wish you could spend less time away,” he clarifies. “I’m getting older. I’m. . .”
I’m on high alert now. “You’re what? What’s going on?”
“I’m afraid of dying alone,” he admits, “without you near to guide me home.” What looks like embarrassment melts away into genuine fear. “Please don’t let Odin take me to Valhalla. I want to go to Folkvangr.”
“Like I’d ever let that sorry sack of shit take you away.” I expected Ben to laugh, but he only gives one of those smiles that doesn’t crinkle his eyes. He’s actually worried about this. How do I fix this? “You’re afraid of your soul getting lost in the afterlife?”
“Is that a silly thing to fear?”
“No, it’s just not something I’ve ever thought about before.”
“It’s honestly my biggest fear.”
“Well, fear not,” I tell him. “Because your soul is destined for Folkvangr, and that’s final.”
“Is it?”
“Yes, it is. No more, Ben.” I meant to say no more bringing it up, Ben but I don’t bother correcting myself. Although I might have if I’d known he was going to tease me.
“Hm,” Ben hums.
“What?”
“No more, Ben.” He peeks at me from over the book he’s reading. “That’s not a phrase I’m accustomed to you saying when we’re alone.”
I roll my eyes. “Stop.”
“Another unfamiliar sentiment. You are full of surprises today.”
“Is that your kink? Teasing me?”
“Possibly.”
“Well, stop it. That’s not going to work.”
“What’s not going to work?”
“What you’re doing right now. You’re trying to annoy me until I get mad so you can get what you want.”
“I have no idea what you’re talking about.” Ben pretends to look confused. “Is this you confessing you find me annoying?”
“No! This is you trying to make me angry so you can sleep with Death again!”
“Cora,” he says calmly and finally puts the book down to give me his full attention. “I don’t know how to tell you this, but I’m not doing anything. This is just your normal temper.”
“I don’t have a temper! I fixed my temper!”
“Clearly,” he deadpans.
Let me win for once! I’m tired of losing every single game! “I could manipulate you into doing whatever I wanted.”
Ben chuckles lowly. “Oh, that’s obvious. But the question remains, why would you ever need to when you could just ask nicely?”
I give up and take my normal seat on the couch, immediately noticing a pack of cards at the edge of Ben’s desk. A small smile forms at the thought of Peregrine winning eighteen consecutive rounds of Texas hold em’ against Sawyer without even knowing what half the rules are. “Want to play Go Fish?”
A small laugh coughs out of him. “Go Fish?”
“Ok,” I amend, frowning. “Want to teach me how to play poker?”
Ben shuffles the deck, sets the table, and explains the rules. Now that I’m no longer afraid of asking questions, I get a feel for the game much faster than I would have a few months ago. It takes two rounds, but I finally win a hand.
“Let’s up the stakes. If I win. . .” I beg my face to stay pale as my eyes trail over him. “I want your shirt.”
“Which one?”
“The one you’re wearing.”
Both eyebrows slowly rise, but he keeps his attention on the cards as he continues to shuffle. “Are you sure you want to do that?”
“Overconfident much?”
“I only need to win one round,” he replies with a straight face. “You’re wearing a dress.”
“Then I guess I need to try a little harder.”
Even though I listen carefully to the rules and try my best to weigh the risks of discarding certain cards, Ben wins the next round in no time at all.
“You win.” I stare at his left eyebrow to keep up my facade of eye-contact as I raise my hands up behind my shoulders and search for the corset laces.
“I don’t want the dress,” he tells me.
“No?” He’s probably going to act cute and ask for a sock. “What do you want?”
Ben leans back against the couch cushions. “I’ll take whatever you have on under the dress.” He twitches an eyebrow up in question. “Assuming you’re wearing anything.”
Just when I start to make progress, Ben cuts my winning streak short. I throw my cards on the table when he wins the next round. “You’re cheating!”
“Yes. You’ve got me.” Ben gestures to his naked arms. “I’ve got illegal aces hidden in my invisible sleeves.”
After winning the next two rounds, I have no real way of knowing if I’m having a crazy case of beginners luck, or if Ben is letting me win.
“Well played,” he praises. “What would you like this round?”
“Nothing,” I answer, tossing my cards on the table.
Never taking his intense stare off me, Ben slowly settles against the sofa in nothing but his boxers, stretching out his arms across the back of the cushions. “Nothing?”
Even more heat creeps into my face, leaving it completely flushed at the way he’s looking at me. Despite my best efforts to keep my eyes literally anywhere else, they betray me. “It looks like I’ve won. You have nothing else to bet.” I'm not losing this game. Not tonight.
Ben’s eyes narrow slightly, a smug smile tugging at his lips. “Then I guess our game has come to a close. Congratulations, Cora. You’ve finally bested me.”
“I have, haven’t I?”
“If that thought brings you comfort,” he chuckles, “then yes. You’ve won.”
I frown at his flippant tone. “But I have won.”
“And yet you’re still here.”
It is beyond aggravating that my hips twitch as lust courses through me. “So? I could leave if I wanted to.”
Ben lays on the sarcasm when he asks, “Could you though?”
“Yes,” I snarl, enraged. “Of course I could.”
“Then leave.”
“What?”
Ben lightly pats the top of his thighs and says, “If you don’t want to sit naked in my lap, then go. I’m not going to stop you.”
“Don’t look so smug.” I roll my eyes at his ridiculous suggestion. “Like you could stop yourself from leaving. You’re still here.”
“This is my house,” he says, laughing lowly. “I’m not the one keeping you here.”
“Shut up!” I bring both hands up to cover my ears. “Just stop talking! I can't think! I’m leaving! This is me leaving!”
“Doesn't look like you're leaving.”
“I’m trying, damnit!” I stand and it takes all my energy to hide how much my legs are weak from desire. “Have a nice night, asshole!”
See? I’m not whipped. I have full control over my baser instincts. I can say no. I can be a tease and then walk away. Shit, I forgot my shoes. I’m halfway to my house and then suddenly I’m walking just as quickly back up his porch steps and through the front door.
Ben hasn’t moved. “Forget something?” His smug smile only stretches farther across his face as I slam the door behind me and stride towards him, ignoring my shoes entirely.
“Shut up,” I yell as his hands slide lovingly up the backs of my legs, pulling me down onto his lap. He tries to say something else, but I have no interest in listening to him gloat and quickly silence him, our lips crushing together so urgently it's hard to breathe. His fingers work to untie my dress, yanking it down over my shoulders, and I pull away with a smack. “For the record,” I gasp angrily, “I could leave right now if I really wanted to.”
He raises his eyebrows in mock surprise. “I believe you.”
I reach down to pull off his last remaining article of clothing. “This was entirely my idea.”
“Entirely,” he agrees, as if the contrary had never even crossed his mind.
Sunshine filters down through the dense jungle trees, reflecting golden light off my jewelry and warming my naked body. “Guess who has the best grade in my homemaking class.”
“Hm?” Ben looks up from his canvas, paintbrush in one hand and a palette in the other. “Sorry, what did you say?”
As much as I love being a muse, it still always throws me off when I realize just how seriously Ben takes his art. This morning, when I suggested Ben paint me wearing nothing but all the jewelry he crafted over the years, a part of me thought he wouldn’t actually spend the entire time painting my portrait. But, just like all the other times he’s sketched or drawn or painted me, he’s dedicated entirely to the craft, and nothing—not even my attempts to flirt—can truly distract him. I don’t say anything, though. Watching him concentrate this intensely on a hobby is far more intimate than fucking.
Off in the distance, I hear a bird calling out to their friend. Ben and I are the only humans in the surrounding area, but the birds overhead make me feel like I’m naked in public, and I'm not sure how I feel about the shiver of excitement at the idea. “I said guess who has the best grade in my homemaking class.”
Ben finishes dabbing at the painting before offering, “Ivar?”
“Okay, that’s technically cheating.”
Ben laughs while still concentrating on the painting. “How is that cheating?”
“Because there’s like 8 Ivars. And you’re right, by the way. It was one of the Ivars. They’re not perfect,” I add. “But considering they didn’t even know how to do their own laundry before I got here, I’d say they’ve made the most progress. I'm not saying his food is about to win any awards, but it's at least edible. He's actually pretty good at taking care of babies now.” I’m never entirely sure what to do with myself while Ben's hard at work, so I lift my arms in what I think is a powerful pose. All of the delicate gold chains around my wrists tickle my exposed skin as I move from pose to pose until I get bored. “Speaking of babies, I know all babies are special, but Alex may have given birth to the cutest baby I’ve ever seen.”
“Agreed.” Ben smiles. “Although I don’t know what possessed her to spoil a perfectly good baby by giving it my name.”
“I tried to tell you. Alex loves you more than you could possibly understand.” Unable to look at him directly, I stare at a patch of grass at his feet. “You were a natural with him.”
Ben’s eyebrows twitch in confusion for half a second. “I’d hardly call myself a natural. All I did was hold him.”
Nevermind. Take it back. “Yeah, but, like. . . you were really good at it.”
“Good at holding a baby?”
What is even happening right now? “I don’t know? I guess it was just nice to see you with a baby.”
“Why would it be nice to see me with a baby?”
“It was nice to see how good you are with babies,” I huff. “That’s all. Why are you being so weird?”
Ben pauses, thinking. Unable to figure me out, he shakes his head in defeat. “You’re the one that brought it up. I’m just trying to figure out what you mean.”
“Nothing.” I try to wave away the idea, and my jewelry chimes at my movement. “I don’t mean anything. Ignore me.”
“Cora,” he says, finally abandoning the painting to walk over to me. “Can you please tell me what’s upsetting you?”
I think I actually do want children because I have the luxury of knowing our child is Christopher. Our child is one of the good ones, and if there’s anything the world needs more of, it’s good men. I’m not afraid of creating life anymore, but I am afraid of taking yours away. Just give me a few more years together. Just a few more years.
But I don’t know if I have a few more years to stall. Tell him. Tell him now. Stop making excuses and tell him now. Who cares if it's an awkward conversation? Ben has a right to know Christopher is his son.
“Ben? I need to tell you something. I've been meaning to tell you for a while, but. . . I don't know. The timing just never felt right, and then it felt weird telling you at all because I had waited so long to bring it up and—”
"You want a baby, don't you?"
Yes. “What? No," I lie. "Of course not. I’m not ready for you to die.”
“I know this isn’t what you want to hear, but everything dies eventually.”
“You’re right,” I snap, already blinking away tears. “That’s not what I want to hear.”
Something like fear flashes in his eyes for the briefest of seconds. “Are you pregnant?”
“No,” I answer immediately, even though the truth is complicated. When I first felt comfortable talking to Juliet alone, I asked her to help figure out why I no longer had periods. It turns out my reproductive system doesn't undergo cycles of fertility because I am always fertile. I don't have periods. Everyday is an ovulation day, and I just happen to have an unlimited supply of eggs. It's why I'm so horny all the time and can't think straight. My body is literally always begging for me to have children. “But I can’t stop thinking about it.”
“Being pregnant?”
“Taking care of a baby all by myself,” I add. "I don't know if I can do this on my own."
Of all things, Ben coughs a laugh. “What do you mean? You have two islands full of people to help you.”
Yeah, but they won't be able to help me because they aren't coming with me to the 70's. I really will be all alone. "No, that's not. . . Okay, please just let me finish. I need to tell you that—" My confession is cut short by the sensation of being punched. Only, I haven’t been punched, and the dull pain immediately blossoms into the sharp intensity of a thousand beestings. I look down at my chest to figure out what hurts so much and find the tip of a bloody arrow jutting out just above my right breast.
I’m not afraid, only confused, as three more arrows fly past me and sink into Ben in quick succession.
Notes:
Welcome back to another regularly scheduled chapter that was crafted entirely while listening to THE PROMISE by When In Rome. Eternal thanks to all who leave kudos and reviews!! If you've read this far, let me know what you think :)
Chapter 30: Till Death Do Us Part
Chapter Text
All three arrows make contact with Ben’s body, but there’s no blood because he’s not impaled. I watch as the arrows bounce off him and fall to the ground like tinkling stray shots.
Unbeknownst to everyone currently trying to kill us, I gave Ben an early birthday present this year—some of my magic fused forever into his DNA. To be honest, I was only trying to gift him enough magic to heal himself on his own if I’m not nearby, but I guess he’s been blessed with indestructibility instead. For a moment, he looks as confused as I am that he’s completely unharmed.
I, however, am not impervious to the onslaught of arrows, and I crumple to the dirt, desperately clutching at my chest. As my mind spirals into a brainstorm of ways to safely remove the arrow, Ben attempts to simply yank it out.
“AGH! Oh, gee,” I huff, “why didn’t I think of that?”
“Sorry,” he apologizes, never once stopping whatever it is he’s trying to accomplish. All I feel is a searing pain as he breaks the arrowhead off and slides the wood out the back of my shoulder. White flashes behind my eyelids, and then the pain in my shoulder explodes into an unbearable stinging throb.
“Okay, it’s out,” Ben says urgently. “Heal yourself, Cora. I’ll be right back.” Ben glances down at the ripped fabric where the arrows were supposed to kill him. He frowns for only a second before his expression goes blank, and then he’s sprinting into the trees behind me.
Healing myself is like second nature at this point—even an injury this deep. Breathing in and holding for a beat, I let my body fuse all my muscles back together until the gaping hole right above my breast is completely sealed. It’s been years since I’ve had to heal myself in earnest. Thank the Norns I was able to do it in one shot. Now I just have to wait for Ben to return.
Without warning, my stomach roils and I bend over to vomit and vomit and vomit, until I’m so weak I have to kneel on one knee to catch my breath. Exhausted, I spit out the last of my sick and lean against a tree.
Is the wedding finally over? Is this what a hangover is? I’m never drinking again for as long as I live. Wait, where am I? This isn’t the Barracks courtyard! Twisting my neck from left to right, I try to gather as much intel as I can. Why am I in the middle of the jungle? WHY AM I NAKED IN THE MIDDLE OF THE JUNGLE? My hands attempt to cover every inch of my exposed body, and in a fit of panic, I jump up and start running in a random direction. Is this. . . blood? Is this MY blood? Holy shit. Holy shit. Holy shit. What do I do?
Calm down. I just need to calm down.
Was I drugged at my own wedding? Who did this? Ben! Where’s Ben? I calm a little at the thought of him. As nervous as I was to marry a complete stranger, I think I can trust him not to hurt me. But we just got married, and now I’m vomiting the morning after our wedding and I’m completely naked in the middle of the jungle. Wait, what the hell is all this? Jewelry? I wasn’t wearing jewelry last night. What happened to me?
I stop running and hide behind a bush to catch my breath. Just as I suck in a deep lungful, Ben appears from seemingly out of nowhere, completely covered in blood. Sound escapes my throat in a half-scream-half-howl that seems to genuinely frighten him. By some unknown grace, he takes a step back.
“Whoa, whoa, Cora,” he says softly, both hands raised out in front of him, dripping with fresh blood. “It’s okay. It’s me.”
The fact that Ben’s so calm about being covered in blood—and the fact that none of what’s happening explains why I’m naked—fills me with such a primal fear that I lash out, somehow finding the strength to rush forward and push his chest away from me with all my might. But instead of staggering back a few steps, Ben goes flying backwards straight through the trunks of numerous trees.
Oh my God, I just killed him. I just killed him! I didn’t mean to! Confused and still screaming my throat raw, I dart in the opposite direction and sprint through tall grass until I reach another clearing in the jungle. Each inhale rattles my lungs in a painful anxious choke. It feels like my insides are on fire. It feels like I’m being hunted.
“Okay,” Ben announces, smiling as he jogs back into view, “I was always a little worried about how you were going to defend yourself once I’m dead, but it looks like you’ve got that covered.”
He’s still alive?!
“Cora,” he yells as I move faster than I’ve ever moved in my entire life. “It’s okay! They’re dead! You can stop running!”
I am being hunted. There’s no escape from men. I think about how he’s going to catch up to me and kill me. Or worse. . . he’s going to catch up to me and not kill me. I think about how I’d rather be mauled to death by Margo than endure whatever he plans to do after he catches me.
I can hear his footsteps behind me. Then next to me. Then he’s blocking my path, and my mind starts frantically thinking of ways I can get him away from me. I could push him again. But would it matter? He’ll just keep coming back. I conjure the deepest voice I can physically muster and order, “Get away from me!”
In one fluid motion, he reaches into his back pocket and pulls out a gun. “Here, honey, take it.” Ben inches closer, arm outstretched, the pistol laying flat in the palm of his hand. “It’s alright. Take it.”
I’m sweaty, and it’s difficult to breathe, and Ben's offering me a gun. Not knowing what else to do, I snatch it out of his hand and marvel—for just a moment—at how heavy handguns are. The last thing I want to do is seem weak and confused, but I can’t help but scrunch my eyebrows. “Why did you give this to me?”
“Because you’re panicking,” he says, “and I’m not sure how else to help. Are you hurt?”
“You tell me,” I hiss, surging with paranoia again when I realize I can’t decipher his expression. This is some kind of trick. I don’t like that he’s smiling sadly, or how he looks unbothered to be covered in blood, especially since I don’t yet know if its mine. I have never been more afraid of a man since the night I killed my father. What if this is all a trick? What if this is an empty gun and pulling the trigger will only make him angry enough to kill me? What if this is some kind of mind game and it really is loaded and I miss my shot and he gets angry enough to kill me?
Out of seemingly nowhere, my shame and embarrassment at being completely naked shifts into a dangerous rage. I have no way of knowing he’s telling the truth, and I don’t know why he gave me this gun, but if I find out he’s hurt me, I’m no longer afraid to use it. I stand up straight, raising the gun just enough to prove my point. “I could shoot you,” I warn. “If I wanted to.”
Instead of the wide-eyed fear I’d expect from someone with a gun pointed at them, Ben’s eyebrows twitch into what looks like dejection. “Do you want to?”
“I want you to tell me what the hell is going on,” I shriek in horror. Knowledge truly is power, because knowing all the details about what’s going on is the only thing that will make me feel better right now. “What are we doing out here? Where are my clothes? How are you still alive? I just pushed you through multiple tree trunks. You should be in a million pieces.”
Ben’s earlier glee manifests in another lighthearted smile. “Thank you for that, by the way,” he says. “Indestructibility has made keeping you safe infinitely easier.”
“Safe from who? What are you talking about?” I can’t quite place his expression, but I fear he’s getting frustrated with me. Ben takes a step forward, only to flinch away when I scream, “Don’t hurt me!”
“Why would I. . . Cora, why would. . . what is happening?” Ben’s eyes flash with anguish, and then the rest of his face catches up. This is quickly replaced with a blank expression and one too many blinks.
Watch his eyes. His eyes give him away.
“Cora, you’re okay,” Ben says, less aggressively than before. “I’m not going to hurt you. That’s the entire reason I gave you the gun, remember?” Flinging an arm behind him, he smiles and nods. “The men who shot us are dead, but I’m not entirely convinced they were working alone. So I need to get you to the Temple—”
“What men?” I beg for clarity, desperate to believe him, even though he hasn’t offered to give me his shirt so I can cover up. Shame on you! Shame on you for looking at me without my permission! “Who is shooting at us?”
“Okay,” he says, nodding slowly while he thinks. “What’s the last thing you remember?”
Whats’s the last thing I remember? “I—” My voice gets caught in my throat as I try to focus on piecing together last night. Colors. So many colors. “I accidentally drank a horn full of some kind of special tea.”
This seems to confuse Ben. “Were you at a party?”
“I was at our wedding.”
“Oh,” he says, sounding even more confused. It’s immediately followed up with “Oh,” which sounds very much like he’s answered his own question.
All my muscles tense up as he works to unbutton his bloodied shirt as quickly as humanly possible. Making sure to avert his eyes and keep a good distance between us, he holds out the shirt in offering. As soon as I’m covered, he kneels and stares down at the dirt. “I’m so sorry. I completely forgot about the memory regression. I can explain everything.” Having him not towering over me helps me get a handle on my breathing. I calm as I yank my arms through his sticky sleeves and feel the comfort that comes with covering myself. “For starters,” Ben says, “it’s not the day after the wedding.”
“It’s not?” I pull his button-down tighter across my chest with one hand, still holding the shaking gun in the other. “How long have I been out here?”
“We’ve been out here for about—” Ben glances at his wristwatch. “—three hours? I was painting. . . you know what? That’s not important. What’s important for you to know is that we weren’t married last night. Our wedding was five years ago.”
“What are you talking about?”
“Cora, I’m sorry you don’t remember, but you just healed yourself. It’s been years since you’ve had to heal a life-threatening injury, so I’ve not had to think about the memory regression for a while.” Ben’s tone dips into annoyance when he mumbles, “I would have approached this entire situation differently, had I remembered.”
How stupid does this guy think I am? “You honestly expect me to believe that? I just woke up naked in the middle of the jungle, vomiting from a hangover, and your excuse for all this is that we’re actually living five years in the future?”
Ben gives the smallest shake of his head. “We’re not living five years in the future. Our present is five years removed from your memory.” There’s a pause, but I don’t get the chance to say anything before he asks, “How old do you think you are?”
I’m pissed off that he’s being so calm about all this. What kind of question is that? Is this his way of covering his actions? He’s a good liar. No, he’s a great liar. There’s no way this isn’t all some hastily thought up excuse to explain away my situation. Every new piece of information I give is just going to be twisted and used against me.
“You’re not 21,” he says matter-of-factly when I stay silent. “You’re 25. I can prove it. Look, you have a tattoo.”
I follow his pointing finger to find a huge tattoo of a snake wrapped around my leg.
“I have one, too,” he says when I start screaming and trying to rub the ink off. Ben reaches down to pull his pant leg up to show me, but he’s cut short by an arrow to the back of the head. “I knew there were more of them,” he announces, completely calm as the arrow drops to the dirt with a dull thud. “Stay down, Cora. Get behind me.”
“Do you need this?” I hold out the gun for him to take, but he shakes his head and pulls another one out from thin air. He had another gun this entire time?
As Ben starts shooting, I try to piece together a coherent story from all he’s disclosed so far. I’m not 21, I’m 25? Okay. Sure. Let’s say I believe him. I’m 25 years old, and I just healed myself and forgot everything that happened to me past our wedding night. Nothing he’s said explains why I’m naked, though. Or why men are trying to kill me. What did I do? Did I berserk again? Did somebody hurt me, and now Ben’s exacting revenge?
Gunshots echo through the trees, and then there’s the distinct crunch of jungle underfoot. “Honey—” Ben taps at his cheek to mirror a tear trailing down my cheek. I swipe at my face and pull away red. I swipe again just to make sure, only to confirm that one of my eyes is crying blood. “I would love to explain what’s happening right now,” says Ben, “but we simply do not have the time. I need to get you to Gail.”
I don’t know how to feel that he keeps calling me honey.
Another tall man steps out from the trees, and Ben needs only glance at him before raising his gun and shooting him dead. “I need to get you to the Temple,” he explains.
Ben doesn’t look bothered by the fact that he’s just killed multiple people, and I’m not sure if that makes me trust him more or not. On the one hand, it means he could kill me if he wanted to, but he didn’t. On the other hand, it just proves that he is, in fact, dangerous. Blood pools out of the bullet hole in the man’s head. I’m still staring at his dead body when I ask, “What’s at the Temple?”
“It’s fortified, and you’ll be safer with an escort from the Bears.” Ben motions for me to follow him, and I decide to take my chances with a group of Bears, rather than whatever men are currently hunting me in the jungle.
I perk up at this news. “There’s more polar bears?” I thought Margo was the last of her kind?
Something like sadness flashes across his face, but only for the briefest of seconds. “Something like that,” he says. “But we need to run. And,” he adds, holding out a hand, “would you mind giving me back that gun?”
Even though I’ve never shot a gun before, holding it makes me feel in control of the situation. I grip the handle tighter. “Why?”
“Because I need the extra bullets.” Despite how gentle he’s being, I feel my face break out in a sweat when Ben’s mood shifts on a dime. He frowns in annoyance, raising an arm up in a random direction just as another man bursts out of the trees, wielding an axe. He only takes two steps before Ben’s shot him dead, and his annoyed expression softens again when he turns to face me. “May I please have the gun back?”
When yet another man rushes us from out of the trees, I feel the coldness of adrenaline kick in. I don’t need you to protect me. I can protect myself. Raising the gun, I aim and click and click and click, but nothing happens until Ben uses the last of his bullets bringing him down.
Frowning, I turn to show Ben how betrayed I feel. “I knew this thing didn’t have bullets!”
“It has bullets,” he argues, “it’s just on safety.”
“You gave me a gun with the safety on?”
Calm as ever, I notice a little defensiveness peeking through when he says, “I didn’t want you to accidentally shoot yourself.”
I don’t know him. Not really. But actions speak louder than words, and he’s done nothing but defend me from random murderous Norsemen. Who knows if it’s the day after our wedding or five years after that? I have no way to prove it out here alone in the jungle. We’re under attack, and he’s proven he can protect me. I can trust him. For now, at least.
“Okay,” I tell him, reluctantly handing over the gun. “Take me to the Temple.”
I can feel something is wrong long before we reach the stones leading into the secret Temple entrance.
From what little Ben’s told me, the Temple is where boys undergo intense physical training—archery, axe throwing, and a mixed-style of martial arts. Even the youngest child here is capable of kicking my ass. It’s not exactly a place women spend a lot of time, which makes the sight of a woman’s severed head on a pike even more terrifying.
Ben’s fear is palpable when he orders, “Turn around. Get to the beach. Now.”
“Ben?” A deep voice sounds from inside the Temple, but when a man appears, Ben doesn’t shoot him. Towering over the both of us, the bearded man nods at me and says, “You need to get her to Hydra. It’s not safe for you here, my lady.”
I want to ask who he is, but I don’t get the chance. Ben and the man start arguing in a language I don’t understand, speaking rapid-fire. Slowly, I remember why he looks so familiar. Kyle. His name is Kyle. I remember him from the wedding. I remember how funny it was to meet a viking named Kyle.
Ben trusts Kyle. But can I trust Ben?
“You don’t understand,” Kyle argues in English. “Dolores is with them. They freed her, and we never stood a chance. We need to get to Hydra before she does. My lady,” he begs in the deepest baritone I’ve ever heard, “please, watch over my family. Don’t let her hurt my sons. Please, don't let her—”
Something wet speckles my face. I reach up to wipe the liquid away, and my hand pulls away even more red. Ben yanks my arm hard to pull me behind him just as I look down at Kyle’s torso. I frown, confused as to where the rest of him is. As an act of mercy, my mind refuses to process that I’ve just watched a man be decapitated.
“How wonderful to finally get a chance to chat,” a female voice croons from behind a group of heavily armed men. “Thank you for making my job easier, Freyja. Bringing your husband wherever you go? Such hubris.”
Men nervously shuffle aside to let the woman pass, and I see her. Dolores—the woman who tried to poison me. A broken shell of a human being, whose trauma is all my fault. I see her face for the first time, and all I can think about is how she used to be an innocent child.
Dolores takes another step forward, flicking her wrist and snapping the neck of the man nearest her. As his weapon slips from his lifeless fingers, Dolores twists her wrist yet again, suspending the axe in midair with what I can only assume is magic. With a flick, she sends it flying towards me, but Ben steps in its path and takes the blow. Just like earlier, the axe does nothing but bounce off him and clash against the stone floor.
“Interesting,” she says monotone, sounding more than a little annoyed. “Now, why would you go and give a man magic like that, Freyja? I thought you had rules? I thought rules were your thing? I suppose I shouldn’t be surprised to find an immortal serial killer is a hypocrite. Egg on my face, as they say.”
“Dolores, listen to me,” Ben stutters, and I begin to fully accept how dire the situation is because Ben never stutters. “Please, listen to me. The Falcons are using you to get to her. You’re a pawn in their efforts to start a war, nothing more.”
“Do you even hear yourself?” Dolores flares with crackling energy, frowning snidely in our direction. “They’re not using me, I’m using them. They’re my complaisant little meat shields.” Her movements are twitchy, like she’s barely able to keep her body still. “I’ve wanted to kill Freyja all my life. What do any of these men have to do with it? Not that I expect you to understand,” she continues, stretching her mouth into an exaggerated frown. “You took their brainwashing better than the rest of the survivors. Was it because they said you were special? Special little boy who gets to marry a love goddess? Newsflash, Linus. She doesn't love you," Dolores spits out. "We mean nothing to the gods. You’re as much a victim of all this as I am. Let’s stop with the nonsense. You’ve had your fun. You fucked a monster, now let me have my fun.”
“No,” Ben whispers sharply, but his voice catches.
Up until now, I’ve only been able to recognize Ben’s fear by his complete and utter immobilization. His body freezes so completely that it’s difficult to tell if he’s still breathing. This time, however, a tremor breaks through, and it is his inability to keep from shaking that makes my mood shift from intense fear to searing anger.
All of this is my fault, and I won’t let Ben suffer the consequences for my actions.
It doesn’t look like anything can pierce his skin, so he’s safe from weapons. And he wasn’t killed when I flung him through a series of tree trunks, so blunt force trauma won’t kill him either. But that doesn’t mean he can’t die. And right now? He looks terrified of the thought.
“I didn’t want it to come to this, Benjamin, but you leave me no choice. Kill him,” Dolores orders. “But leave Freyja to me.”
Ben swivels away from every attack. Where the Norsemen are all brute strength, Ben is a viper. It doesn’t matter that he is smaller. Ben’s focus is on efficient takedowns with the knife he’s pulled from yet another pocket. It only takes a swift stab in each leg to bring down five men blocking our way, but in the end, we’re still outnumbered.
Ben’s knocked to the ground next to Kyle’s corpse, and I hear the anguish in his voice as he thrashes under the weight of a dogpile. I don’t know if Kyle and Ben were like brothers or lovers. All I know is looking at the dead body of his teammate has flushed the fight right out of Ben's eyes.
The men shift their focus over to where I’m standing alone, backed up against a stone wall.
A memory resurfaces. A memory of Ben scolding me for not being aware of my surroundings—for not anticipating an escape route. It’s not fair for me to rely on him to kill all these men. He’s just one person. I’ve killed before. Maybe I can do it again.
I open my mouth to threaten the men, but instead of words, a stream of fire shoots out, completely disintegrating the four men closest to me. Confusion hangs heavy in the air for a moment while the rest of them weigh the risk of coming closer, and I contemplate how the hell I just did that so I can do it again.
Surging with the same bravery that came with protecting my mother, I raise a pointing finger and order, “Let him go.”
Unlike the men standing around her, Dolores looks beyond giddy. “Ooo, you finally mastered dragon’s breath. How exciting! Killing you is going to be so much more rewarding now that you’re not a pathetic little fledgling goddess. Where’s the fun in that? Now we’re an even match!” Dolores raises a hand, flexing her fingers in preparation for casting some unknown magic. “Goodbye, Freyja.”
I scream to stop, but instead of words, more fire comes out. A small part of me wants to stop so I can get the image of half melted bodies out of my head. I can’t control what’s happening, and I start to panic that I’ll accidentally hit Ben. Fire burns up my throat and sears straight through someone’s arm, and another’s stomach, and the retreating legs of a Falcon halfway turned to flee.
“You did it.” Ben stands before me, staring in wonder at the smoldering carnage. “You’ve been trying to master that move for years!” Ben shakes his head like he’s just remembered the danger we’re in, grabs my wrist, and then we’re running, but not in the direction Kyle suggested. Ben pulls me into the nearest hallway, past dead bodies and blood smeared all over the stone walls. I smell it everywhere—the senseless spilling of iron.
I want to go home. I just want to go home.
I blink and we’re in a candle-lit bedroom. Ben frantically works to bolt the door shut, and then he begins pushing furniture against it for good measure. I feel useless. I feel empty. I feel like none of this is actually happening, and I’m going to wake up in the grass tomorrow morning relieved that this was just one big alcohol induced nightmare.
Gentle fingers brush against my face, and I snap back to attention.
“Cora, I need you to listen very carefully to what I’m about to tell you.”
I’m remembering more now, about the Bears. I’m finally processing what I just saw. Kyle was a part of his sports team. They played sports together. And now he’s dead. Ben takes a deep breath and smiles at me, though his red eyes give away his true pain. I want to look away and give him time to mourn his friend, but we don’t have time.
It takes all my concentration to focus on Ben’s instructions because the music is fighting to take control. I just want to forget any of this has happened and let the music calm me down, but Ben notices and grabs hold of my face, a hand cupping either side.
“I’m sorry I couldn’t protect you.” He’s crying in earnest now, and I don’t know what to do. I never know what to do when people cry around me. “I’m sorry I failed you.”
None of what’s happening is making any sense, and I don't know what I feel anymore. Logically speaking, he’s done a great job of proving he’s someone I can actually trust, but I still don’t know him. Even if he were just like the Ben in the show, I still wouldn't know him. Yet, I can’t help but feel sick at the thought of his death.
Is this the moment he dies? Why didn't we get to spend more time together? I finally find someone who cares about me, and then we can't even go on a regular date without people shooting at us? Or maybe we have spent the last five years together, and he’s right about me not remembering?
“Cora,” he chokes out in what sounds like a sob, “I need you to concentrate. Listen to what I’m saying. I’m going to get you out of here, but I need you to concentrate.”
A great force knocks against the door so hard the dresser Ben pushed against it tips over. Fear coils in my gut as memories of my father paralyze me.
“Don’t worry about them,” Ben soothes. His earlier panic has subsided enough for him to plaster on a brave expression. “I’m not going to let them hurt you. Focus. Repeat after me.” Ben attempts to teach me an Old Norse chant as he frantically burns bits of paper over a candle. Crushing the remains into ash, Ben sinks down to the floor and smears the ash in a circle around me. “Cora, I need you to repeat what I’m saying. Keep chanting.”
I try to listen to him. I really do. But the pounding on the door is beyond distracting. Fear shifts into paranoia. All I know is I don’t want to face whatever’s waiting for me outside that door. “I can’t,” I whisper. “I can’t do it.”
“Yes, you can.”
"Freyja," Dolores yells from the other side of the door. "Come out here and fight me! I haven't waited this long just for you to hide! Are you really going to make me break down this door, you coward?"
There’s a splintering sound, and my head rushes with pure adrenaline. But this time, no light emanates from my eyes, and no fire pours from my mouth. I’m cold and scared and I don’t want to die. “I can’t,” I gasp, twitching my head from side to side in an effort to shake away the fear.
“Yes, you can,” he refutes, and the kindness in his voice makes me think that maybe he’s right. “I know you can. Deep breath, Cora. Close your eyes. Concentrate.” Ben repeats the chant as he adds some kind of design to the circle.
I wish I could help you. “What is this for?”
“Cora,” he snaps, frustration and fear evident in every crease of his face. “I need you to stop asking questions and trust me. Close your eyes. Repeat after me.”
He’s asking me to trust him, so I do.
Eyelids closed, I concentrate on his pronunciation of the chant. I repeat it over and over and over until my voice sounds as unfamiliar as the language I’m speaking. Still, I trust him, and I repeat it over and over and over—
Cora?
I open my eyes. Darkness has replaced the room I was just standing in, but this brings no comfort. “Hello?”
A voice echoes in and out of the void, like a walkie-talkie with bad reception. Cora?
“Gail?” I scream into the darkness. “Gail? Help!”
Follow the sound of my voice.
Reaching through the empty expanse, I feel someone swipe at my arm. Invisible fingers wrap around my wrist, and then I’m yanked through the darkness and collapse back into the real world.
I’m no longer in the Temple. I blink into the much brighter lighting of my longhouse and wait for my eyes to adjust. Someone’s embracing me, and I inhale the comforting scent of florals, desperately wrapping both arms around this person. Hugging a woman from Hydra anchors me enough to finally unleash the tears that wouldn’t come earlier.
“I’ve got you,” Gail says, her breath blowing strands of hair into my face. “You’re alright, Cora. I’ve got you. Oh. . . oh, gods, Cora. Are you hurt? There's blood everywhere.”
Coughing out the last of my panicked tears, I pull away enough to see her face. "It's not mine."
"Oh, Cora." Gail wipes away my tears, only to show me the red on her fingers. "You healed yourself recently? Do you know where you are?"
"Yes, I know where I am! Everyone’s dead,” I croak in a slew of mindless babbling. “They’re all dead! They’re all dead!”
"Easy, Cora. It's alright. Who is dead?"
Ben’s not dead yet. “We have to go back for Ben,” I plead. “Please, Gail, we have to get him out of there before she kills him.”
Gail’s sympathetic smile flips into a concerned frown. “She who?”
“Dolores.”
“Dolores?” Gail’s expression becomes even more concerned. “I knew we should have imprisoned her here. But no, nobody wants to listen to me.”
“Gail,” I screech, “we have to go now! Ben sent me here to get help! We have to help him!”
“Oh, Cora, no. Sweetheart, he didn’t send you here to get help. He sent you here because that was our arrangement.” Gail busies herself with brushing hair out of my face and flattening it against my head. “It’s the only reason I trusted him to watch over you without me on the mainland. I made him promise to send you back to me if he ever found himself in a position where he couldn’t protect you.”
“But he’s still alive!” Why aren’t you listening to me?
“Cora, I know you care for him, but that boy is the most stubborn human being on this island. He’s insisted since day one that he can protect you all on his own, but if he’s killed his ego enough to admit defeat, that means he’s dead.”
You’re still not listening to me! He’s indestructible for some reason, so he’s not dead! But that doesn’t mean he can’t drown, or be choked to death! We need to rescue him while he’s still alive!
But I don’t get a chance to tell her any of this because a young woman rushes into the longhouse, screaming, “Gail. . . lady Cora? Oh, thank the Norns you're back! My lady, you and Gail are needed at the beach. We’re under attack.”
Sawyer stands out amongst the crowd gathered to hear Gail’s strategy, but his hair is way longer than it should be if yesterday was my wedding. Claire is holding a toddler-aged Aaron, even though she was still pregnant yesterday. Anna Lucia is covered in tattoos she didn’t have a day ago. A young man has an arm around Alex’s shoulders, and Alex is holding a baby.
I wasn’t initially sure if Ben was lying to me about it being 5 years in the future—or present—but how can I deny the truth when the entire island corroborates his story?
“Stay close to me, mom,” a fully grown Fenrir huffs in a low—and slightly terrifying—voice. “I can smell them on the wind.”
“I knock them down,” a fully grown Pumba oinks in a deep baritone, “and you rip their throat out.”
“Good plan,” says Fenrir.
The wolf taps his wet snout reassuringly against my sweaty hand, and I pet him between the ears. You were only a puppy yesterday.
Gail calmly gives orders as I awkwardly stand nearby, embarrassed that I can’t be of much help. Sawyer helps a group of women corral the children and usher them into the jungle, away from the shoreline, escorted by the many wolves bred for the very purpose of protecting the children of Hydra. All around me I hear the crisp metallic snap of women cocking their loaded guns. Hydra is alive with rebellion as Gail assigns each armed woman a specific section of beach to protect.
“Forgive me, my lady,” an impossibly tall woman mutters under her breath, “but what a time to lose your memory.”
“Easy, Hilda.” Another woman gives her friend a stern look before softening into a smile at me. “Lady Cora, we’re glad you’re alive.”
“How do I know if my sons are alive?” The tall woman—Hilda—rubs a hand over her heart as if she were in pain. “I can feel Kyle’s absence,” she whispers. “It’s like a part of me has been ripped out. Surely the pain would be worse if my sons were also dead?”
This is Kyle’s wife. She feels his death?
Would I feel Ben’s death? Does that mean he’s alive?
A tiny woman—who can’t seem to stop fidgeting with her small child—sucks in a sharp breath and then bursts into tears. “They are dead,” she sobs. “I can’t feel my Finnegan, either.”
“You should be with the children,” Gail interjects, nodding at the woman’s baby. “The beach is no place for young ones tonight. Cora, you too. Follow James to the center of the island. You’ll be safe there. Are the rest of you ready?”
Ready for what? But I seem to be the only one unaware of what’s going on. I must look frightened and unsure, but these women just look tired and forlorn as they nod at Gail.
I turn to follow the woman and her baby into the jungle, trailing far behind Sawyer. As I reach the brush separating the beach from the treeline, I can’t help myself—I turn and watch as the first ship docks and the men jump ashore.
All is quiet. Too quiet.
We’re at war, but nobody is doing anything. Men trudge up the beach without anyone putting a bullet between their eyes.
Women approach before the men can reach the trees, and from the looks of things, these specific men don’t seem to understand I escaped the Temple and warned Hydra. From the relaxed look on their faces, they don’t realize the danger they’re in—up until the knives carefully concealed by their grandmothers, mothers, wives, sisters, and daughters are swiftly lodged into the side of their necks.
It all happens so fast. One second the beach is full of men, and then suddenly it’s full of dead bodies. As another ship docks ashore, it’s obvious this new wave of men have finally realized Hydra is aware of their crimes. Some men pause, conflicted at the thought of killing, and I wonder what Dolores’ plan was. Did they honestly believe they could just storm Hydra and calmly tell the women in their life that they’re part of a coup against me? Did they honestly think Hydra would accept them for what they’ve done?
As more men run ashore, Helga unlatches the axe at her waist and rushes forward, severing several limbs as she makes her way to the front of the beach. One by one, the rest of the women rush forward, each scream ripping from their throats with the pain of furious betrayal, as they stab and slice and sever.
Screams fade away, and the stench of blood catches on a breeze that blows the scent of iron across the beach. I finally understand what the plan has been all along. The hubris of man is their downfall. Despite all they have done, the Falcons still believed the women in their life would never kill them. Falcons believe love is weak, but that’s because they don’t understand it. Love is what keeps Hydra happy. Love is what keeps Hydra safe.
As the rusty tang of blood hits my nostrils, I turn and hurry after Sawyer and the group of kids marching deeper into the jungle for safety. They’re just in my line of sight when I feel it. Cold, unrelenting magic.
“Evacuating the children?” Dolores’ voice comes from nowhere and everywhere. “Would have loved that when I was a child.”
One second it’s silent, and then the world ends in an explosive heated inferno.
Horrible, horrible noises continue for the next thirty seconds. Trees are split in two, uprooted from the earth and crashing down hard all around me. I can hear people screaming over the roar of fire. I keep my eyes closed, grasping the air with a trembling hand, begging for a miracle to save these children.
Flames flick against my face until my skin feels numb. I heal the burns only to cry out in pain as I’m burned all over again.
Hell is real, and now I’m burning here forever.
The last thing I hear is a woman screaming.
Chapter 31: What's The Hurry?
Notes:
(See the end of the chapter for notes.)
Chapter Text
Everyone at the Temple has long since passed when we arrive.
Bodies slump everywhere I look as my eyes trail over the carnage. Bodies of men I know, bodies of men I don’t, and some are too mutilated to be able to say for sure. Screams fill the night as widows find their husbands and mothers find their sons slain across the Temple grounds. Blood streaks down every wall and spills across the floor until my boots are unbearably sticky.
Dawn has brought nothing but the stench of death and a debilitating flood of memories. While on a ship back to the mainland, I started to remember who I am and when I am, and I really wish I didn’t. Because my people cling to me for answers I do not have and look to me for comfort I cannot give.
I am singularly focused on finding him, but Ben is missing from the room he barricaded us in to send me to Hydra. A cold, sinking dread pools in my stomach at the sight of the destroyed door, and for a glorious second, I convince myself I have the wrong room. But there is no denying the truth when I see the ash summoning circle he drew on the ground. He was here, and now he is gone.
Helplessness overtakes me until I feel so cold I start shivering. Gail’s hand is warm on my shoulder, and when I look up at her, all I can think to say is, “Where is his body?”
CORA?
Like a bird, I jerk my head from side to side, searching for him.
CORA?
Ben! Ben? Ben, is that you?
I feel the intense relief in his voice as it echoes in my mind. You've finally regained your memories? Oh, thank the Norns. I’ve been trying to reach you for hours, but I think the connection only works if you know who I am.
His voice is coming from inside my head, so I close my eyes and concentrate on what he’s saying. Ben’s physical manifestation appears in my mind, looking exceptionally worried. “Hello,” he says, speaking so fast I have to concentrate to keep up. “I hate to be an alarmist, but Dolores is holding me hostage inside the Orchid station, and I’m about to be flung throughout space and time, so if you could please find a way to get here before she figures out how to operate—oh, fantastic. This thing is making noise now.”
“Slow down,” I command. The sight of him alive has reignited my resolve better than an espresso ever could. “Where are you?”
“Orchid station,” he answers, smiling, but his voice shakes with fear. “Lucky me, the Dharma’s experimental time machine is still operational. You know, I’d admire her tenacity if it wasn’t my eternal afterlife on the line.”
I open my eyes and reach for Gail. “Where is the Orchid station? We have to go there, now! That’s where she’s keeping Ben.”
Gail silently regards me, pity evident in her eyes.
“Gail,” I plead, and the crack in my voice is all the convincing she needs.
Gail leads me out of the room and back through the Temple’s main courtyard, making sure to keep a pace my much shorter legs can match. I hurry behind her, each step suctioning to half-dried pools of blood.
I don’t mean to nag, but she’s gotten this miserable machine to make even more noise, so I’m not sure how much time I have left. Where are you?
The Temple. I’m with Gail. We’re coming to get you, don’t worry!
The Temple?
I wait to hear more, but Ben’s fallen silent, and I panic he’s already gone. Ben? Are you there?
When I hear his voice in my head again, his words are steeped in utter despair. You’re not going to make it in time.
Yes, we will! We’re running!
The Orchid station is a good hour from the Temple. I don’t have even half that.
Despite my stubbornness to prove him wrong, I know in my heart he’s right. Ben’s complete lack of emotion stops me in my tracks, and I close my eyes to better see him in my mind. “Hey, listen to me.” I float closer in the darkness, desperate to calm his erratic heartbeat pounding in my own chest. “I promised I would take you to Fölkvangr, and this doesn’t change that.”
“I couldn’t fight back,” he explains, monotone. “She used magic to restrain me. Couldn’t even be bothered with a fair fight. Said this was better than killing me because at least now you won’t have a body to burn.”
“Ben,” I plead with desperate conviction, staring at him until he looks at me. “I swear to you, I will not let your soul get lost. Okay? There's nothing Dolores can do that I can't undo. I promised I would take you to Folkvangr, so that’s where you’re going when you die. End of discussion.”
Ben nods, but I know him too well to trust he believes me. I can clearly see he’s more afraid than he’s ever been before. Suddenly, he jerks at a noise only he can hear and looks around the dark expanse of his mind. “I think it’s happening. Come with me, Cora. Quick.” With a sharp tug on my arm, Ben pulls me toward a door and flings us inside it.
“What are you doing?” I ask.
“Looking for useful repressed memories,” he explains, quickly assessing this memory as useless and pulling us into another one. “If we’re going to spend the last of my mortal years apart, I might as well keep you safe in my absence by finally figuring out who killed you.”
Door after door, we hurry from repressed childhood memory to repressed childhood memory, moving backwards in time. I see snippets of myself in the 70’s, older and yet somehow perfectly preserved. A cigarette dangles between two fingers as I point and scream at child Ben about something I have no context for. Guilt immediately pools behind my ribs at the chastised look on his face.
But Ben’s already pulling me into another memory, and everything suddenly goes dark as ink.
I’m alone at the edge of a quiet grassy field in the middle of the night, with only weak moonlight to illuminate the surrounding trees. Instead of the usual conversations from birds overhead, all I hear is clicking bugs and the occasional birdsong. Only, it sounds exactly like a bird is supposed to sound, and I’m frozen in place at the beauty of something I can no longer experience. Ben can’t understand birds, so his memory of their calls is untranslatable.
A tiny voice asks, “Miss Collins?”
I spin around and find tween Ben kneeling in a large patch of dead grass, clutching a bloody knife like his life depends on it. As soon as he recognizes it’s me, the knife slips from between his fingers, abandoned in the grass, and he flings himself into me. Both my arms instinctually wrap around his tiny boney body, holding him to my chest like a baby monkey, but when I try to ask what’s happened, all I receive in answer is violent shivering.
Night slowly ebbs away, illuminated by the glow of something sinister behind us. It steps closer, crunching dead grass and lighting up the darkness. Its glow brings me no comfort, and from the way tween Ben clings to me even tighter, it’s obvious it brings him no comfort as well. I don’t want to look. I don’t want to see. Even after all these years of grandstanding, I realize I don’t actually want to know what happened to me.
Now isn’t the time to be a coward. Ben’s giving me his last moments, and I will not disrespect him by wasting this opportunity.
I close my eyes, suck in a steading breath, and turn around, expecting to confront a glowing monster with my face. All I find is me, unlit, lying on my back in a large patch of dead grass, bleeding profusely, both hands slick with blood, grasping the open air while I scream for my grandmother. Before I can ask tween Ben what happened, he sobs a chant into my clothing, each I’m sorry growing more wild with every heaving breath.
Like a shock of electricity, I feel Ben’s rapid heartbeat reach an alarming speed that leaves me clutching at my chest in pain. I’m expelled from the memory in the span of a second, forever hurtling out of his mind and back into my own.
Everything stills, and only my own heartbeat pounds in my ears.
An hour or so later, as we slowly descend down the Orchid elevator, I worry about what I will find when the rickety old contraption finally decides to reach the bottom, but nothing prepares me for the waves of grief that hit one right after the other.
Ben is missing, and when I see the containment area Dolores shoved him in, I press my hands against it. I have no idea what I’m doing, or what I think will happen. But that doesn’t stop me from pressing my hands against the cold concrete, begging for a miracle.
Ben? Can you hear me? Hello?
I’m going to fix this, okay?
I’m going to make this right.
I'm going to find you.
I promise.
A hand flutters to my chest, just to check, but the life-force that always proved he was okay has completely disappeared.
Dolores is gone, and in her wake is a path of tech destruction that even Sayid can’t fix. What was once the control panel that sent Ben catapulting to an unspecified year is now a mess of broken glass and jagged metal, twisted together with exposed wires. Without this machine up and running, there’s absolutely no telling where in time she sent him. I stare at the useless machine, eyes wandering around the room in search of a solution.
There is no solution.
I was too late.
Ben is gone.
This is all my fault.
Unintelligible voices echo in and out of my consciousness, even though my eyes are open and I’m wide awake. Gail is here. I recognize her voice. The other, I’m not so sure. That is, until Gail calls her by name.
“Liv,” says Gail, “I understand you’re—”
“You understand nothing! That madwoman has my daughter,” Liv pleads. “Our focus should be on returning Aiko safely to Hydra.” A murmur of empathetic assent from other mothers ripple through the crowd. A conversation starts about who will join the search party and who will stay on Hydra to protect the children, but my focus is elsewhere.
I want to remember Ben’s face, but my sadistic brain can only think to replay his hopeful expression rapidly diminishing into fear the moment he realized I made a promise I ultimately couldn’t keep.
His last moments on earth were supposed to be with me, so I could guide him home safely.
Flashes of his expression play in my mind, even after I squeeze my eyes shut so hard my vision turns white. It’s always the same, his hope shifting to sadness faster and faster until the only memory of his face is one stuck in perpetual despair.
I leap out of my chair, but it was a fool’s hope I’d make it outside in time. Vomit pours out of me, like my body is trying to purge his memory. If only I could purge his despair, I could recollect a happier memory.
Gail is wiping my face, and I let her. I let her lift me back to my feet. I let her guide me to my room in the longhouse. I let her lay me down and pull off my boots. I let her fluff my pillows and drape a blanket over my body. I let her because I cannot do these things myself.
“We should have run faster,” I tell her. “I slowed us down. I’m sorry.”
“Shhh, Cora,” she soothes. “Rest.”
“I’m pregnant,” I whisper up at the ceiling.
“Oh.” Gail’s face remains impassive, although she gives herself away with a twitch of her right hand, which means she’s sad. “I don’t know what to say. Congratulations sounds insensitive, given the circumstances.”
It’s a chore to blink. “What am I supposed to do, Gail?”
Smooth hands brush hair off my face, and I don’t even flinch when a few strands tickle my nose. “You are going to rest,” Gail tells me, and her words bring me comfort despite everything. “I can handle things until you’re ready.”
I should care. I know I should care. So why don’t I feel anything? “Aiko’s missing.”
“Yes,” she tells me, “and I’m already working on it. Just rest for now.”
I trust Gail, but even if I didn’t, it wouldn’t matter.
Nothing bothers me anymore.
In my waking dreams, I spend my time chasing memories of Ben. Door to door, I fly around my own mind, flinging open memories in the hopes of finding a joyful glimpse of him in all the years I’ve lived here.
Strolling through memory lane doesn’t excite me the way it usually does. Every time I come across a fond memory that made me feel loved, I’m reminded of what Ben showed me before disappearing forever, and the memory suddenly warps into something terrifying. I thought I knew him better than anyone else, but I clearly didn’t know him at all.
My murderer was him the whole time. Which makes no sense because Ben let me read his mind, fully and completely, and all I’ve ever felt in the far recesses of his soul was a complete—and somewhat frightening—devotion to my safety and happiness.
So why would he kill me? Has our entire adult lives been one big lie? Was he being nice to me after my rebirth out of a sense of extreme guilt? I think through the vision again, replaying it until I roll over and vomit next to my bed. I’m a bad mother after all. That must be it. I’ve been so worried about Christopher, but he’s not the child I failed. Because this has to be my fault. I was the adult, and Ben was my responsibility. I was screaming at Ben in a memory. Was that why he snapped? Did I fail him like his father failed him? I would never do that. It makes no sense. I could never yell at a child like that.
Desperate to escape my own thoughts, I run in a random direction, flinging open the first door I come across and stepping into the memory of the first night we met. Not literally the first night we met. Rather, the night we decided to play a game by pretending we didn’t know each other.
In the memory, I’m seated atop Ben’s desk in his office, wearing my new favorite outfit—a bright pink top, even brighter pink miniskirt, and an assortment of gold jewelry catching every ray of light, including multiple thin chains wrapped around my hips. If I had gone to college parties, this would have been my dream attire.
Well, actually, it wouldn’t have been my dream attire. Tank tops naturally slide up and over the natural curves of my stomach, and the last thing I wanted was for people to see my midriff. So, no, this wouldn’t have been my dream attire in college. But it’s my dream attire now.
Time has given me an entirely new perspective on my body. All my life men have told me I’m undesirable, but it turns out that’s the exact opposite of reality. To my people, I’m perfect. I can’t count the amount of men who have tried to date me, and the list of women who openly flirt with me at parties is even longer. Over time, I’ve started to believe it for myself. It’s changed the way I move through the world, and now that I know what it feels like to be adored and desired, I have no intention of settling for anything less.
“Come in,” I respond to a knock on the door, and it opens to reveal Finn and Ben. “To me, Finn. You,” I say to Ben, “take a seat.”
Finn bounds over to stand beside me with the energy of a puppy.
Ben, however, plays his role well, taking a seat in front of me with one of his pensive smiles. “To what do I owe the pleasure of this summons?”
Much like the actual first time we met, Ben realizes he hasn’t properly introduced himself and jerks an arm out for a handshake, his name on his lips. I cut him off with a, “I know who you are, Benjamin Linus.”
I’ve learned a lot from the wives of Team Bear. They taught me the art of sensual movement, how to dance for fun and how to dance with intent to ensnare, and above all, they taught me to never let men forget our relationship with them is a privilege that can be revoked at anytime.
I make sure that’s clear in the way I cross my legs, leaning back with one arm propping me up against his desk and the other hand occupied with a manilla folder. Without looking at him, I riffle through the paperwork and pretend to consider it, even though I finished reading through the file hours ago. “Do you honestly not know why I’ve called on you?”
“I—” Ben starts, quickly falling silent. “I’m sorry, but no. I don’t.”
“I’ve had my eye on you for a while,” I explain, finally looking up from the papers.
From the way his eyes focus sharply, and the specific way they crease in the corners, I can tell Ben’s actually worried he’s read this situation wrong. “Have I done something wrong?”
“Let me cut to the chase,” I say. “I think you’re handsome, and from what my spy tells me, you’re a decent human being and a great conversationalist, so that’s in your favor.”
Ben’s smile is brief before he asks, “Spy?”
“You ever ask yourself, who watches the watchers?” I turn and pat Finn’s arm in approval, and he beams like I just awarded him a medal of honor. “Well, who better to watch a group of loyalists than another group of loyalists?”
Ben’s brow twitches together briefly, like he’s unsure how to react to what I’m saying.
“Team Bear Jr,” I elaborate, smiling when I see the moment Ben realizes what I mean. “I had each player follow a different father on the team. I’ve heard nothing but great things about Team Bear, but you can never be too careful. Finn?”
“Yes, Freyja?”
I hold up the thick manilla folder. “Would you please explain to Mr. Linus what I’m holding?”
“My week’s work,” Finn says proudly, spinning sharply towards Ben to finish explaining. “Freyja asked me to stalk you for a week and compile a list of everything you do on a daily basis.”
I was never entirely sure, but now I can tell by his uncomfortable smile that Ben’s completely surprised by this news.
Ever so slightly, I tilt my head and furrow my brow. “What?” I ask, my voice dripping with sarcasm. “Do you not enjoy being followed around without your knowledge? That’s why I picked Finn, after all. Ulf is an excellent fighter, but he is very large and very loud. Finn, however, is as silent as the grave.”
“Thank you very much,” Finn boasts.
Ben looks uncomfortably from Finn to me, and I watch as his smile wavers from confusion to something else. Something that makes me shift my stance, suddenly self aware. Ben’s not angry I successfully figured out a way to stalk him—he’s impressed.
“Finn, go enjoy yourself.” I pat his arm again and smile. “Thank you again for a job well done.”
Just as bouncy as always, Finn makes his way to the door, pausing only to point two fingers at his own eyes and then point them at Ben’s to signify he’s always watching. It’s so ridiculous, I have to fight not to laugh.
I love Ben, that much is clear to me. But the circumstances of our entire relationship were built on lie upon lie. I understand what led us to this situation, but I also need answers to satisfy the lingering resentment in my heart. Starting with the fact that I’ve realized I’m not okay with the fact that he’s been stalking me since the moment I arrived on this island.
As soon as the door clicks shut behind Finn, I stop smiling, cross my arms over my chest, and demand, “Where were you the first night of the crash?”
Ben’s much more assured smile dips down into confusion again. “Pardon?”
“Don’t answer my question with a question,” I snap. “Where were you the first night of the crash?”
We sit in silence as I wait for him to speak. Finally, he says, “Top branch of a papaya tree, about a dozen feet from where the sand starts.”
“And what were you doing up in this tree so close to the beach?”
"I'd be happy to show you," he offers.
“Cora?” I’m abruptly ripped from the memory at the sound of Gail’s worried voice. “Cora?”
I blink into the candlelight of my room in the longhouse, and everything hurts all over again at the realization that all I have left of Ben is memories. Memories are such a fragile thing. Someday, this memory won’t be as fresh, and it’ll be more difficult to recall what was said and done. Maybe one day I won’t remember him at all. Was Ben’s irrational fear not irrational after all? Am I doomed to forget him in this life and the next?
“What do you need from me?” asks Gail. She wipes away tears, and that’s when I realize I’ve been crying. “Do you need water?”
“No,” I croak, suddenly able to scrounge up enough energy to sit up in bed. “I need to find him. He cannot die without me near, but I don’t know when in time his body is. Gail, I’m not asking you, I’m ordering you. Whatever magic you know, I need you to teach me.”
Gail sighs softly, looking very much like she’s in physical pain. “Cora, we’ve put all that behind us—”
“Who is we,” I snap. “Because I still haven’t forgiven you for destroying the Seiðr manual.” Gail opens her mouth to try and argue but I cut her off. “Destroying that book was not your decision to make!”
“Yes, it was,” she snaps, and for once I see genuine fear shine in her eyes. “Yes,” she says more calmly, “it was my decision to make because you are not ready yet.”
“Ready for what?”
“You have no idea what magic did to you,” she shrieks. I fall silent as the tears come, one by one, rolling down the soft skin of her cheeks. “I indulged you then, but I will never indulge you again.”
“I’m not asking to indulge in magic, Gail. I’m asking to—”
“You don’t know what you’re asking,” she interrupts. “You have no idea how dangerous this all is! When I was younger, I helped you train in all sorts of dark magic. And do you know what happened? Do you know what was left of you at the end? You went mad.” All the hairs on my body stand on end as her sharp voice cracks on the last word. “You want to know the truth?” Gail suddenly takes a step forward, towering over me, but I don’t fear her. Gail’s loyalty is a palpable thing. “You want to know the truth about how you died?”
I don’t even need to think about it when Gail holds out her hands in offering. I clench them tight and get sucked into a memory.
Notes:
*emerges from a cave in the deepest recesses of Appalachia* Howdy, y’all. Long time no see.
Oof, it's been a hot second. Sorry about that! I cut this chapter off a little short, but the good news is most of the next chapter is already done so you will NOT have to wait as long as the last update to read more. Hope everyone is well, and thank you again for all the kudos and reviews! It has seriously kept me going this past year.

Pages Navigation
Durinsdottir on Chapter 1 Tue 04 Apr 2023 01:18AM UTC
Comment Actions
thewhitekitten on Chapter 1 Tue 04 Apr 2023 04:19PM UTC
Comment Actions
ironknights (Guest) on Chapter 1 Fri 08 Sep 2023 04:56PM UTC
Comment Actions
thewhitekitten on Chapter 1 Fri 08 Sep 2023 06:16PM UTC
Comment Actions
Guest (Guest) on Chapter 1 Thu 03 Oct 2024 01:21PM UTC
Comment Actions
thewhitekitten on Chapter 1 Thu 03 Oct 2024 04:47PM UTC
Comment Actions
casey26334 on Chapter 3 Wed 03 Apr 2024 02:16AM UTC
Comment Actions
thewhitekitten on Chapter 3 Thu 04 Apr 2024 01:50PM UTC
Comment Actions
Frog (Guest) on Chapter 5 Thu 03 Oct 2024 01:30PM UTC
Comment Actions
thewhitekitten on Chapter 5 Thu 03 Oct 2024 04:47PM UTC
Comment Actions
Durinsdottir on Chapter 6 Tue 04 Apr 2023 04:31AM UTC
Comment Actions
thewhitekitten on Chapter 6 Tue 04 Apr 2023 04:20PM UTC
Comment Actions
Isamary2200 on Chapter 10 Tue 25 Feb 2025 12:38PM UTC
Comment Actions
thewhitekitten on Chapter 10 Fri 28 Feb 2025 04:38PM UTC
Comment Actions
Isamary2200 on Chapter 14 Tue 25 Feb 2025 03:01PM UTC
Comment Actions
thewhitekitten on Chapter 14 Fri 28 Feb 2025 04:38PM UTC
Comment Actions
ironknights (Guest) on Chapter 16 Fri 08 Sep 2023 05:42PM UTC
Comment Actions
thewhitekitten on Chapter 16 Wed 13 Sep 2023 09:52PM UTC
Comment Actions
casey26334 on Chapter 16 Mon 15 Apr 2024 10:43PM UTC
Comment Actions
thewhitekitten on Chapter 16 Wed 17 Apr 2024 06:06AM UTC
Comment Actions
dharmainitiativeofficial on Chapter 17 Tue 28 Mar 2023 02:45AM UTC
Comment Actions
thewhitekitten on Chapter 17 Tue 28 Mar 2023 03:01AM UTC
Comment Actions
zere (Guest) on Chapter 17 Thu 06 Apr 2023 11:58PM UTC
Comment Actions
thewhitekitten on Chapter 17 Fri 07 Apr 2023 02:15PM UTC
Comment Actions
LittleOwlet on Chapter 18 Wed 26 Apr 2023 12:25AM UTC
Comment Actions
thewhitekitten on Chapter 18 Wed 26 Apr 2023 03:19PM UTC
Comment Actions
squior on Chapter 18 Wed 26 Apr 2023 05:07PM UTC
Comment Actions
thewhitekitten on Chapter 18 Thu 27 Apr 2023 03:36AM UTC
Comment Actions
casey26334 on Chapter 18 Tue 16 Apr 2024 11:04PM UTC
Comment Actions
thewhitekitten on Chapter 18 Wed 17 Apr 2024 06:07AM UTC
Comment Actions
queer_codex on Chapter 18 Sun 14 Jul 2024 08:12PM UTC
Comment Actions
thewhitekitten on Chapter 18 Mon 15 Jul 2024 01:30PM UTC
Comment Actions
Elsie_Kay on Chapter 18 Sat 28 Sep 2024 03:08PM UTC
Comment Actions
thewhitekitten on Chapter 18 Sun 29 Sep 2024 10:55PM UTC
Comment Actions
commandervenus on Chapter 19 Fri 26 May 2023 11:15PM UTC
Comment Actions
thewhitekitten on Chapter 19 Sat 27 May 2023 04:00PM UTC
Comment Actions
casey26334 on Chapter 19 Tue 16 Apr 2024 11:59PM UTC
Comment Actions
thewhitekitten on Chapter 19 Wed 17 Apr 2024 06:11AM UTC
Comment Actions
ironknights (Guest) on Chapter 20 Fri 08 Sep 2023 08:18PM UTC
Comment Actions
thewhitekitten on Chapter 20 Wed 13 Sep 2023 09:55PM UTC
Comment Actions
Pages Navigation