Actions

Work Header

Marks of Heaven, Wings of Hell

Summary:

Long before Earth, the first four archangels dreamed of something they were never meant to have — a soulmate, a perfect other half to love without punishment or fear. God told them such love was for humans alone. They tried to believe Him. They failed.

Now, in the middle of the Apocalypse, Sam Winchester is taken by Heaven and his soulmate marks are burned into visibility for all to see — four wings, four elements, four names in a language he can’t read.

He has four soulmates. And they are Michael, Raphael, Lucifer, and Gabriel.

The revelation shatters Heaven’s plans, ignites ancient wounds, and draws the archangels together for the first time in millennia. But soulmates don’t erase centuries of grief, rage, and betrayal — and God will do anything to destroy the bond before it can heal them.

Sam’s not sure what’s worse: being the center of a celestial war, or realizing that the creatures he was raised to fear might be the only ones who’ve ever truly loved him.

Chapter 1: Light and Darkness

Notes:

This story was lovingly given to me by a wonderful commenter from another fic, who shared the seed of this idea and inspired me to explore it fully. Thank you so much for entrusting me with this beautiful, complex universe — I hope to do it justice.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

There was no beginning, not in any way that could be measured.
There was no sun to mark the passage of days, no moon to measure months, no stars to scatter the hours. Only the vast, weightless expanse of the Before.

In that endless stillness, there were two.

Light, warm and unyielding, stood opposite Darkness, cool and endless. They had always been, just as the void had always been. Brother and sister, bound together by existence itself — inseparable, inevitable.

“You’re thinking too loudly again,” Amara said, voice low and velvet-soft, though in this place sound was only an idea. Her presence pooled around Him, vast as the abyss, pressing gently against the light that radiated from His form.

God — though the name had not yet been spoken — smiled faintly. “I’m thinking about beginnings.”

Amara tilted her head, long hair spilling like liquid shadow. “Beginnings are temporary. All things fade. You’re looking to build something that will hurt when it’s gone.”

“Perhaps,” He said, “but perhaps the pain is worth it.”

“You’ve never lost anything.”

“Not yet,” He admitted.

They had argued this before — though ‘argument’ was too strong a word. It was a dance, the same steps, the same turns, each partner holding the other in perfect counterpoint. Light and darkness, creation and unmaking, giver and taker.

But this time, He had an intention. The emptiness between them was not enough anymore. The raw, formless void called to be shaped, filled, given a heartbeat.

“I want to try something,” He said.

“Then try,” Amara replied. “I will be here when it collapses.”

He reached out. Light spilled from His fingers like molten gold, curling into the void. The nothingness trembled under the touch, its smooth surface rippling. A sphere bloomed — swirling gas, radiant heat. Another followed, then another, until the first stars burned in the darkness.

Amara’s gaze followed the light as it spread. “You’re scattering yourself.”

“I’m sharing myself.”

He shaped the first galaxies with patient care, spinning them into graceful spirals, clustering stars like beads on a string. Amara’s shadows coiled around them, pressing close but never extinguishing the flames. She, too, moved her hands, guiding the empty space between the stars, pulling darkness tight where the light burned too bright.

“Too much light blinds,” she said softly.

“Too much dark smothers,” He countered.

And so they wove it together — the fire and the shadow, each born for the other. Nebulas bloomed in vast clouds of color, their edges feathering into black. Comets traced arcs through the newborn space, trailing ice and fire in perfect balance.

It should have been enough.

For an age — though there was no age yet to count — they stood together and admired their work. It was a universe in perfect harmony. Every star shone brighter because it was ringed in darkness; every shadow was richer because light touched its edge.

And yet…

God’s gaze turned inward. He had made something vast and beautiful, but it did not speak back to Him. It did not love Him.

Amara sensed the shift in His thoughts. “You want something to look at you the way you look at this.”

“Perhaps I do.”

Her lips curved in something that wasn’t quite a smile. “Then make it. You always do.”

He closed His eyes. The idea had already taken root — not just creations to fill the void, but beings to share it with. Companions. Children.

The thought of children filled Him with something He couldn’t name. Pride? Anticipation? The desire to be seen through eyes that adored without question?

“I will make them of My light,” He murmured, “so they can hold it without fear. So they will love Me as naturally as breathing.”

“And will you give them my darkness?” she asked, studying Him.

He hesitated. “They would not survive it.”

Her gaze sharpened. “Not survive — or not serve?”

He didn’t answer. He didn’t need to. Amara could feel the choice being made in the marrow of the universe. This was not balance. This was His claim, His shaping of reality in His image.

“You are building an army,” she said.

“I am building a family.”

The difference was paper-thin, and they both knew it.

Still, she did not stop Him. She let Him gather His light, weaving it into forms that shimmered with potential. Four shapes emerged from the glow, not yet distinct, but already vast, their wings unfurled in silent promise. They would be the first. The mightiest. His most beloved.

“They will not thank you for making them to kneel,” Amara said.

“They will not mind,” He replied, smiling as the first sparks of thought began to form in His children. “I will be everything they need.”

She turned away, already knowing how this story would end.

The light swelled, wrapping His new creations in warmth. They would be His sons — Michael, Raphael, Lucifer, Gabriel — and they would shine brighter than any star He had set in the heavens.

But every light cast a shadow. And Amara knew, as she watched them take their first breath, that someday those shadows would rise up and swallow the sky.

The first breath of the newborn universe still hung in the air — if air could exist yet. Time itself was barely a thought, light still finding its footing against the darkness. Where once there had been only God and Amara, now something else stirred.

They stood in the radiant center of it all, where the fabric of reality rippled like water under divine hands. And in that perfect stillness, God lifted His voice.

“Come forth.”

From the shimmer of His will, a figure emerged — tall, radiant, his grace blazing so brightly it seemed to push back the edges of the void itself. His wings unfurled in a span so vast they seemed to shelter the forming stars. His eyes burned with certainty.

Michael.

The first son stepped forward and knelt, not because he was commanded to, but because reverence was his nature. God rested a hand upon Michael’s head. “My strength,” He said softly. “My protector.”

Light pulsed again, and a second form took shape, bathed in a softer glow — silver threaded with healing warmth. His wings curved around himself like a promise of shelter. His gaze was steady, searching the still-fragile universe for imbalance.

Raphael.

“My shield and healer,” God named him. “You will keep what is broken whole.” Raphael’s quiet nod was acceptance without hesitation.

Then came a flare of light that burned hotter, sharper — a star being born. The third son stepped forward with a tilt of the head, eyes full of restless curiosity. His wings gleamed white, yet the light in his gaze carried a fierce edge.

Lucifer.

“My morning star,” God said with pride. “The one who will see the farthest, think the deepest.” Lucifer smiled, just slightly, as though the promise of knowing more than the horizon offered was already enough to stir him.

And then the last — a burst of golden light that rippled with warmth and mischief, laughter woven into the very threads of his being. His wings were the color of sunlight poured into honey, and when his feet touched the ground, it was almost as though the universe leaned closer to listen.

Gabriel.

“My messenger, my joy,” God greeted, His tone lighter now. Gabriel grinned, a spark of uncontainable energy in the infinite expanse.

Four brothers stood before their Father, wings outspread, grace burning bright enough to cast the void into retreat. Each different, yet born of the same light, they fit together as though they had always been — each power complementing the next, strength woven with compassion, wisdom with playfulness, curiosity with protection.

Michael stepped to Lucifer’s side without thinking, a silent pledge of loyalty. Raphael rested a hand briefly on Gabriel’s shoulder, steadying the youngest’s uncontainable fidgeting. Already, there was unity.

God’s voice wrapped around them like the first warmth of sunlight. “This is the universe, My children. It will grow, and so will you. It is yours to guard, to guide, to know.”

They turned together to gaze upon the forming stars — massive, glowing bodies that swirled in colors no human eyes would ever see. Clusters of galaxies spun slowly into being, threads of light stitched through the black.

Michael’s eyes tracked each movement, calculating, memorizing. Raphael watched for symmetry and flow, already alert for imperfection. Lucifer reached toward the nearest flare, fingers passing through light without disturbing it, fascinated by its texture. Gabriel craned his neck to see all of it at once, golden wings twitching in excitement.

“It’s… beautiful,” Gabriel breathed, the first to speak aloud.

Lucifer glanced at him, lips curling in agreement. “It’s only the beginning.”

They moved together without need for command. Michael and Raphael circled a forming star, shielding it from the shadow that pressed too close. Lucifer traced the edge of a nebula with his fingertips, committing its colors to memory. Gabriel darted between them, scattering laughter like comets, making even the cold void feel alive.

They had no words yet for loneliness, no thought for desire beyond this — the joy of creation, the perfect harmony of being together, serving the one who had brought them into existence.

From the edge of the light, Amara watched them. Her gaze was unreadable, deep as the darkness that cloaked her. To her, these new beings were not necessary. The universe had been in balance before them. But she said nothing — not yet.

The brothers didn’t notice her. They were caught in the awe of their Father’s work, wings brushing against one another in quiet, unthinking comfort.

Michael glanced at each of them in turn, a silent promise in his expression: whatever came, they would face it together.

Raphael’s calm presence anchored them. Gabriel’s warmth pulled them closer. Lucifer’s brightness made them want to reach farther.

They were light in its purest form — untouched by fear, unsullied by doubt. And in that moment, it felt as though such unity would last forever.

The garden bloomed in silence before sound was ever spoken into the world. A river glimmered under sunlight that had only just been born, and the air held the scent of earth still fresh from God’s shaping hands. The universe was vast, yet here—within the heart of this cradle—something entirely new stirred.

The archangels stood at the edge of the garden, four shapes of light and will, still and reverent. Michael’s wings folded neatly against his back, his gaze sweeping over the land with a soldier’s careful attention. Raphael’s eyes lingered on the budding trees, on the pulse of life in each leaf, as if he could already hear the heartbeat of the world. Lucifer tilted his head, curiosity bright in his face, as though the soil might speak secrets if he looked long enough. And Gabriel—his hands flexed, itching to touch, to see if the flowers felt the same under fingers as they looked to the eye.

Then God breathed.

It was not like the breath that had summoned stars or stirred oceans. This was slower, closer. From the dust, He shaped limbs and hands, a face turned toward the sky. The clay became flesh; the flesh became a man. The man opened his eyes and saw light, and in that moment the garden seemed to hold its own breath.

The archangels leaned forward as one, their unity instinctive. They had seen stars ignite, seen galaxies unfurl, but this… this was something else. The man’s gaze held wonder, but also something they could not name—an awareness that reached beyond obedience.

God smiled, and the man smiled back.

Not long after, God shaped another. Her eyes sought the man without prompting, and when their hands brushed, a mark bloomed on their skin—a shimmer, faint and fleeting, like sunlight catching water. It pulsed once and then sank into them as if it had always been there.

Michael shifted his stance, uncertain. “What is that?”

“It is My gift,” God said. “To them.”

Gabriel tilted his head. “A mark?”

“A promise,” God corrected. “A sign that they are bound. Two made to find one another, no matter the distance. They will walk this life together, as one.”

The man and woman laughed softly, as though they understood, and the sound struck something deep in the angels—something nameless.

They watched as more humans came into being, each marked in some way: a glint of gold beneath the skin, a shadow shaped like a sigil along the wrist, a soft hum that only their other half could hear. Every pairing different, but all bound by that same thread, invisible yet unbreakable.

Lucifer’s eyes lingered too long on the marks. “And angels?”

God’s expression did not change. “You were made for Me.”

It was said as if it were answer enough.

“But—” Lucifer began.

“Your bond is with your Creator,” God said, voice sharper now. “You are My firstborns. My warriors. You need no other.”

The silence that followed was deep enough to feel. Michael’s wings tightened imperceptibly, an instinct to shield, to protect—though he could not say from what. Raphael looked away, focusing on the curve of the river. Gabriel’s fingers stilled against his thigh. And Lucifer, jaw tight, lowered his gaze.

The humans went on laughing, touching, finding one another as if drawn by some unseen force. Their joy was uncomplicated, their devotion shared. The archangels felt the echo of something they had no name for, an emptiness they had never known until this moment.

They did not speak of it aloud.

Instead, they gathered together that night in the vast quiet of Heaven, wings brushing in the dark. They spoke of the stars they had seen, the worlds they had helped shape. But beneath the words, their minds threaded together, weaving a shared vision—one that none of them would admit they craved.

A love that asked nothing but to be returned.
A bond that could not be commanded or taken away.
A touch that did not carry the weight of obedience.

And in that unspoken dream, they imagined a mark on their own skin, warm and alive, placed there not by duty but by choice.

When morning came, they rose as they always had: united, loyal, ready to serve. But the dream lingered, faint as the scent of a flower after it’s gone.

They did not know it yet, but they would dream it again.

The dream came without warning, yet they all knew it when it began.

It was not Heaven, nor Earth, nor any realm their Father had named. Here, there was no throne to kneel before, no commands to obey, no endless expanse of white perfection. Instead, they stood beneath a sky that bled into a thousand shades — gold melting into blue, indigo fading into rose. The air was soft, warm against their grace, scented faintly with something they could not name.

Michael stood first, his wings unfurled in the light, catching motes of gold that drifted through the air. He looked… lighter, as though the invisible weight he carried in the waking world had been lifted. Beside him, Raphael sat in a field of low flowers, trailing a hand through them as though testing the texture of this strange place.

Lucifer was further off, his head tilted back, watching clouds drift lazily above. His eyes were not sharp here; they were curious, even vulnerable, reflecting the shifting colors overhead. Gabriel darted past him, barefoot in the grass, laughing at the sheer existence of this dream-sky.

They did not speak of where they were or why. They simply… were.

In the waking world, their bond was made of service — brothers united in their Father’s will, each role defined and immovable. Here, there were no roles. Michael did not have to guard; Raphael did not have to mend; Lucifer did not have to prove; Gabriel did not have to please.

Here, they were simply together.

Michael joined Raphael among the flowers, sitting so their shoulders brushed. Neither spoke, but the pressure of Raphael’s arm against his own felt grounding in a way Michael didn’t understand. It was not duty that kept him here; it was want.

Lucifer moved closer to Gabriel, catching his wrist to slow him down. “Stay,” he murmured. His voice held no command — only request. Gabriel smiled, not his usual bright smirk but something smaller, softer. He stayed.

They discovered the others here too — not angels, not humans, but beings that seemed to hum with connection. They moved in pairs, hands intertwined, glances exchanged like whispered secrets.

The archangels understood instinctively: this was what humans called soulmates. This was the love that did not wane, the devotion unbroken by fear or punishment. It was a thread that bound not through obedience, but through choice.

In the dream, they could imagine it for themselves.

Michael imagined a hand in his, steady and sure, someone who did not look to him for orders but for comfort. Raphael imagined tending to wounds — not because it was required, but because it brought joy. Lucifer imagined a voice speaking his name not with reverence or fear, but with love. Gabriel imagined laughter that belonged to him alone.

The air shimmered with something close to longing. None of them said it aloud — not even here — but it hummed between them like a shared pulse.

Raphael broke the silence first. “This place is not real.”

Michael’s hand flexed in the grass. “No.”

Lucifer’s gaze sharpened, his mouth curving faintly. “But it should be.”

Gabriel tilted his head. “Maybe it’s ours. Just ours.”

They stayed until the horizon began to fade, the colors bleeding into gray. The dream unraveled slowly, like threads slipping from a loom. One by one, the flowers vanished from beneath Raphael’s hands; the clouds above Lucifer dissolved into nothing. Michael’s wings dimmed in the fading light. Gabriel’s laughter caught in his throat and was gone.

When they woke, it was as though nothing had happened. They stood in Heaven, wings tucked close, the cold white brilliance of their Father’s realm pressing against their senses. There were orders to follow. Worship to give.

But each of them knew the others had been there.

They did not speak of it. Not because it was forbidden — though it might be — but because words might break it. The dream was a fragile thing, a rebellion too quiet to notice, yet too dangerous to name.

In the silence, they carried it with them — the memory of a love that did not demand, did not punish, did not own.

It was not real. But it was theirs.

The throne room was not like the places of worship humans would one day build. It was not stone and gold, nor bound by walls. It was an expanse of radiance without a horizon — light so pure that it carried no shadow, yet still defined by the will of its Creator. The air hummed with power, the kind that lived in every thread of creation.

God stood at the heart of it, His form shifting between flame and form, incomprehensible and unyielding. The archangels knelt before Him, their wings folded in reverence.

But this time, something different lay in His hands.

It was not light, nor darkness. It was older than both. A seal. A brand. It pulsed faintly, like the heartbeat of some ancient, caged thing. Its edges shimmered with a deep, blood-red light that swallowed the brightness around it.

“Lucifer,” God said, His voice the sound of galaxies being born and stars dying all at once. “You are my most brilliant son. My light-bearer. My will made fire.”

Lucifer lifted his head, pride and love rising in equal measure. “Yes, Father.”

“I give you this,” God continued, extending the Mark toward him, “for there is a danger greater than any other — the Darkness. My sister’s chaos seeks to unmake what we have wrought. This Mark is the lock. You will be its keeper.”

Lucifer’s gaze caught on the seal. It was beautiful, in a terrible way — the kind of beauty that demanded blood in exchange for its touch. “And it will bind her?”

“It will bind her,” God said. “It will also… require strength. Great strength. More than any of your brothers can bear. This burden is yours alone.”

The words were meant to be an honor. They struck instead like the clang of a closing door. Alone.

Lucifer stepped forward. Michael’s hand twitched at his side, a barely-there motion — as if he wanted to intervene, to ask if there was no other way. But Michael said nothing. He trusted their Father’s will.

Lucifer reached out and took the Mark.

It burned. Not on his skin, but in his grace. It dug into him, deeper than thought, deeper than soul. It was as if an ancient nail had been driven through the very center of him and hammered home until it became part of the foundation. His light faltered for a moment, flickering like a candle in wind.

He swallowed the pain and bowed his head. “I will keep it.”

God smiled. “You will do more than keep it, my son. You will prove your devotion.”

And then the Mark pulsed — a slow, deliberate beat that seemed to echo inside his skull.

The days that followed were… strange.

Lucifer still shone, but the radiance had a sharp edge now. His laughter came less easily. His gaze lingered on the shadows between stars. He spoke more quietly, as if measuring his words against some private scale.

Michael noticed first. “You seem… weary, brother,” he said one day, catching Lucifer alone on the balcony where the void bled into creation.

“I’m not weary,” Lucifer replied. His voice was even, but his eyes did not meet Michael’s. “I’m… aware.”

“Of what?”

Lucifer’s jaw flexed. “Everything.”

Raphael came to him with concern masked as curiosity. “The Mark,” he said gently, “does it hurt?”

Lucifer almost laughed. “It doesn’t hurt. It changes.”

Gabriel asked no questions. He only brought him music — soft, lilting melodies plucked from the hum of distant suns — and sat beside him without speaking. Lucifer never told him, but it helped.

Still, the Mark whispered. It spoke in the silences between thoughts. It suggested that he alone bore the weight of protection, that his brothers’ loyalty was a luxury, that his Father’s trust was conditional. It urged him to watch, to judge, to suspect.

Lucifer tried to ignore it. For a time, he even succeeded.

When God next gathered them, it was to remind them of the purpose they had been given.

“You are mine,” He told them. “You were made to love Me, to serve Me, to sing My glory until the end of all things. You need no other. You will have no other.”

The words slid like ice beneath the ribs. Michael accepted them with quiet conviction. Raphael bowed his head in obedience. Gabriel fidgeted, biting back some half-formed protest that never made it past his lips.

Lucifer stood still as stone.

The Mark pulsed. Once. Twice.

And in that rhythm came a thought he could not shake: If we were truly enough for Him… why must we be kept from all else?

Later, when the others had gone, Michael lingered. “You’re quiet,” he said.

“I’m thinking,” Lucifer replied. His eyes drifted toward the far reaches of the universe, where light met shadow in a slow, eternal dance. “There’s so much of it, Michael. Creation. Destruction. Balance. And we’re… one part. Only one.”

Michael’s hand touched his shoulder. “We are the part that matters most.”

Lucifer wanted to believe him.

But the Mark pulsed again. And he was no longer sure whose voice was louder — his brother’s, or the one that had taken root inside him.

Notes:

Thanks so much for reading the first chapter! I’d love to hear your thoughts, theories, or favorite moments — your comments mean the world to me. If you enjoyed this start, please consider leaving a kudos or a review; it really helps keep the story going.

Looking forward to sharing more of this journey with you!