1 - 20 of 1,721 Works in Toni Shalifoe
Navigation
Listing Works
-
Tags
Summary
One mistake. One year of exile.
Shelby Goodkind thought a year in Texas would be enough penance for what happened between her and Toni Shalifoe in a darkened room after Becca Gilroy's funeral. She was wrong.
Returning to Constance Billard, Shelby finds her former best friend Fatin wielding secrets like weapons, Toni embedded in a new social circle, and everyone pretending that good Christian girls don't do what Shelby did that night. But in a world where reputation is everything and Gossip Girl sees all, some secrets refuse to stay buried.
Now Shelby must navigate the treacherous waters of Manhattan's elite while confronting the girl who whispered her name in the dark—and now won't even look at her in the light.
XOXO, Gossip Girl -
Tags
Summary
The Firebirds and The Golden have been enemies forever. So why does Shelby Goodkind make Toni’s mind go blank every time she sees her? Is it possible to sleep with the enemy while you’re seeking revenge?
There’s only one way to find out.
-
Tags
Summary
Shelby Goodkind has lived her whole life in the spotlight as the President’s daughter. Now, headed to college, she just wants a taste of normal. But Toni, a daring and unpredictable new student, might turn everything she thought she knew upside down.
Or
First Daughter movie but make it Shoni
-
She's not a saint and she's not what you think by Daylight1312
Fandoms: The Wilds (TV 2020)
20 Sep 2025
Tags
Summary
High School soccer rivals to lovers au where Shelby moves to Minnesota and joins the same soccer team as Toni
-
Tags
Summary
Five summers of silence. That's how long it's been since Shelby Goodkind vanished without a word, leaving nothing but questions and a broken heart in her wake. Now, as Toni Shalifoe returns to Camp Blackburn for what should be a perfect, drama-free summer, she's about to discover that some wounds never truly heal—especially when their cause happens to be the new Theater Director.
Meanwhile, Leah Rilke returns to camp after being in London for two years, practically a stranger to the friends who once knew her best. After an almost-kiss shattered what could have been, she and Fatin Jadmani find themselves forced to work together again, their creative energies syncing even as they pretend their hearts don't.
As a financial threat looms over the camp, these eight friends must navigate broken trust, unspoken feelings, and the people they've become in each other's absence.
Some roots run deeper than time or distance. Some wild things grow even in the darkest places.
A story of second chances, chosen family, and finding your way back home—no matter how far you've strayed.
-
Tags
Summary
When Fatin shoved Leah up against the rocks and told her not to cut the threads people are hanging by, she didn't realize she may have accidentally cut Leah's last thread too... and Leah's thread looks a little like Fatin.
Based off of Season 2 of the Wilds and beyond. Heavily focused on Leah's suicide attempt, the aftermath, and beyond. If you struggle with mental health or suicidal thoughts, please read with caution and remember the world is always a better place with you in it
-
Tags
Summary
Leah viciously scrubs her hands in the water. The blood had turned brown. It clung onto the creases of her fingers, to the crevices of her nails, unwilling to easily let go.
She had come to the conclusion long ago that she would die for them, and now in every sense of the word she would kill for them too. Maybe, telling herself that would settle the rising panic of what she had done, and what it could actually mean. A singular choice could create a domino effect of great consequences for fifteen individuals. The question is could they live with it?
A dark continuation of The Wilds where season 2 left off. Gretchen’s “experiment” is about to go completely off the rails.
-
Tags
Summary
If you ever watched The Notebook (2004) and thought "I wish this was sapphic", then this fanfic is for you. There will be minor changes, but overall the story will remain the same.
-
Tags
Summary
Toni is a famous actor and is forced to lie about her and Shelby's relationship. Until a night at the Oscars changes everything.
-
Tags
Summary
Hey guys, I've never written a fic before, but I've always wanted to. I love the Shoni fandom, but as you guys know, it's kind of thinning out. So, I'm requesting anyone and everyone to leave a comment about ideas. Whether it be just a prompt, a plot-line you've always wanted to see written; anything! I'm English major but I never write creatively and I wanted to give it a go, but unfortunately I don't think I'm creative enough (kind of a problem lol). Anyway, like I said, leave a comment! (If you see this same thing written in the Clexa fandom, it's me.)
-
Loved you since seventeen (our love is all we need) by sawyers_moon
Fandoms: The Wilds (TV 2020)
05 Sep 2025
Tags
Summary
Summary: Toni is ready to ask Shelby to marry her, and so is Shelby for Toni. So it's not like they unintentionally plan to propose at the same time, in the same place…….right?
-
Tags
Summary
Dearest Toni. You don’t know who I am but you will one day. I’m glad you didn’t kiss the girl. I would have been very upset. I’ll be seeing you around. Love always.
Toni wants a normal life. After Regan dismantled her heart, she never thought she'd feel again. But a certain blonde changes everything. In more ways than one. Then the notes appear. Then the van appears.
-
It's a Goddamn Blaze in the Dark (and you started it) by WivesWhoWrite
Fandoms: The Wilds (TV 2020)
26 Aug 2025
Tags
Summary
Shelby Goodkind has always had a bit of a *thing* for Toni Shalifoe. It doesn't mean anything, because Toni's a fired-up, hot-headed, foul-mouthed TV chef that Shelby knows she’ll never actually meet and won't like at all in reality.
So imagine Shelby’s surprise when she’s selected to be a contestant on Toni's cooking show. Especially when, before the competition even heats up, Shelby discovers Toni Shalifoe might just have a *thing* for her too.
It’s a recipe for disaster.
Can they make it out of the kitchen before getting burned?
-
Tags
Summary
The club was supposed to be safe.
Then the story broke.
A sealed record. A missing friend. A photo that shouldn’t exist.
Now Toni and Shelby are caught in the blast radius.
Fatin and Leah are watching each other burn.
This is the one where love gets weaponized.
Where survival isn’t enough.
And nobody walks out clean -
Tags
Summary
Toni's been secretly sleeping with Shelby since their second of year of college.
Shelby claims it's all for practice, that it doesn't count if she doesn't finish.
Toni doesn't buy it.
90% smut, 10% pining. 100% idiots in denial (love).
-
Tags
Summary
Leatin and Shoni but instead of being sent on the 'retreat' the girls get sent to an all girls boarding school in the middle of nowhere, England.
Series
- Part 4 of Unsinkable
-
Tags
Summary
The girls and boys find themselves stuck together on the third island and have to work together to get out. But here's the twist: Fatin's got a big problem—she can't admit she's into Leah. And Leah? Well, she's dealing with her own issues and a savior complex, oblivious to Fatin's more-than-platonic feelings.
This could seriously mess with the group dynamics, so they'll need to come together to navigate through it while also figuring out how to escape from the experiment.
-
Tags
Summary
Toni sneaks into her girlfriend's performance of Legally Blonde.
-
Tags
Summary
Fatin finds pancake mix in the bunker’s pantry. Her and Ivan (and Shelby) make breakfast for the group. A touching gesture, until it goes south.
-
Tags
Summary
Toni moves to Texas after her last six foster home didn't quite work out. Now she's living in deep red texas, away from the one girl who she can call family. So yeah, life isn't going great for her.
Until she meets Shelby in her new school.
Shelby, the gorgeous, intelligent, perfect, blonde hair, green eye, popular....christian....homophobic girl...
Okay so she's not perfect.
And maybe she gets on Toni's nerves, and maybe Toni's very existence is against her beliefs.
But sometimes luck is just on your side.