1 - 20 of 39 Works in Connie Rogers (Creepypasta)
Navigation
Listing Works
-
Tags
Summary
Toby loved you even after what he had done to you he still held a special place in his heart where only you can be able to through. His heart will be sealed with yours even though he's your cousin he still loves you. He's nothing but a mistake who was presumed dead by the media. He still wants to be with you.
[Update every Sunday]
Series
- Part 2 of I'll stab you in the heart again
-
Hide and Seek by JBenj
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets, Slender Man Mythos
16 Sep 2025
Tags
Summary
Toby Rogers has just been taken by the operator and dropped into a random cabin in the forest. Confused, scared, and grief stricken, he takes it as a sign that he’s become a burden to his family and this is a chance to hide away from the world. Meanwhile, the proxies as well as other killers under the operator’s care have been given one instruction: find Toby and bring him back to the operator.
-
Tags
Summary
Toby had always been troubled. How could he have not with his piece of shit dad and the lifelong social rejection he's faced? But he wasn't like his father, definitely not. His heart is good, Vienna was sure of that. She's known him for forever after all.
So when the Rogers residency fell into ruin, with Toby missing and Mr. Rogers identified solely by the fact that the remains were found in his own home, it was clear to everyone that the police wouldn’t file an ordinary missing person report. Except to Vienna.
Only when she stood face to face with him again and being unable to recognize the boy she'd loved all these years, did she fear him for the first time. But it was already too late when she awakened in chains.
-
Tags
Summary
“To love me is to suffer me”
The tragic and early death of Lyra Rogers impacted the entire town of Riverbank Point. No one was more affected than her brother, Tobias ‘Toby’ Rogers and her best friend, (y/n) (l/n). When Toby mysteriously disappeared soon after (y/n) believed her life would finally return to normal. It was when she realized that she can never stray too far from the ghosts of her past that she knew her life would never be normal again.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 3,097
- Chapters:
- 1/?
- Kudos:
- 11
- Hits:
- 117
-
Tags
Summary
He wanted to die.
Toby partially wondered if this is how it felt to be his father. Self loathing. Sick like a wet dog on cocaine. Maybe that’s why he coughed all the damn time- and why Toby himself hadn’t been doing much better. He moved himself back to a sitting position where he faced the door, and yet still nothing felt real. He hadn’t realized he’d been crying but the taste of salt was bitter and full of his own grief. The fabric that had been in his hand joined in the whirl of distorted world around him and he closed his eyes.
Her eyes opened in his mind instead, just in front of him.
----
This fic was written and *finished* in November 2022. It has since been edited slightly but most of this is the original writing. 6/6 chapters are written and just need editing so upload schedule will be chaotic
-
Tags
Summary
Toby's got enough on his plate, repeating the eleventh grade while also trying to finish twelfth and graduate on time. Now to add stress on top of stress, his sister's started bringing some hot older douchebag home to "study" with her.
Not on Toby's watch.
No way is his smart, beautiful, probably gonna be a multi-millionaire super-surgeon sister gonna settle for a loser with an annoyingly pretty face and too many abs. And if the only solution is to butt into every second they get alone, so be it. Toby's protected his mother and sister from a lot in the past, and he'll protect Lyra from this too. Even if it means adding stress on top of stress on top of stress.
Toby's got a lot of experience in not breaking. He can handle this. Whoever this Jack guy thinks he is, he won't be around for long. Not if Toby has anything to say about it.
Or: Toby Has a Sister Complex and a Gay Crisis All While Completing Two Grades of School at Once (Among Other Tragedies and Assorted Problems), The Musical
-
If I lose it all will you still hold my hand? (REWRTIE) by StuckLlama
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom
30 Jul 2025
Tags
Summary
You moved again-
In to the same basic ass neighborhoods you've seen throughout your travels,
Starting a new school in senior year isn't going to be easy.Your father the quiet, reserved man he is made slight friends with a man down the street.
turns out he has a son of the same age as you, funny you've never met him at school before.He seems quite nice, a little weird but who isn't?
-
Tags
Summary
Toby doesn't hate his dad; he just doesn't know how to feel about him yet, and he doesn't have many close people in his life besides his family, so he can't afford to hate someone he was taught to love. Toby thinks he can love dad, and his dad can love him back. After all, he wasn't always a bad father.
-
Tags
Summary
Lurching, agonizing, clawing.
The feeling of bile rising in your throat, of spider legs piercing your skull and brain, a hand reaching into your throat to pull out your heart and gaze into your truth.
Welcome to Pitch Pine.
-
Tags
Summary
Five years.
Five years of your radio fizzling with static, of your skin prickling, of insomnia and tears and anger so broiling you've ripped chunks of your hair out over it. Years spent scavenging in libraries and internet chatrooms for a scrap of a clue.
Five long years since he left.
-
Creepypasta Stories But It's Robloxlover69 by noisivelet112
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom, Robloxlover69
14 Mar 2025
Tags
Summary
This is basically just what it would've been like if Robloxlover69 made videos about the Creepypastas.
-
Tags
Summary
where tobias erin rodgers was your best friend.
Series
- Part 1 of songs by adrianne lenker
-
To The Bone by Stargirl7891011
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets, Slender Man Mythos
26 Feb 2025
Tags
Summary
Cooper Springs was born ravenous. She was born cursed. And growing up nestled in small town Vilmoure, Colorado with the missing persons count growing higher everyday didn't account for a normal childhood. Because of a tragic accident involving lighter fluid and the ashes of a dead friendship, Cooper leaves Vilmoure to escape its inescapable darkness. Years later she returns, and discovers more strange and twisted secrets as a young adult than her innocent eyes had seen before.
-
Tags
Summary
Toby Rogers had lived most of his life in limbo, picking apples from his family's farm by day and hitting parties by night in search of some semblance of the life he could be living. Despite his reputation, Toby proves to be the only one in his family capable of leaving his small hick town in Georgia, if not for his overbearing mother, retired sister, and alcoholic father.
Timothy Wright is a charismatic, city guy freshly moved back into his childhood home with his emotionally-devoid, devout mother with stories of experiences Toby could only dream of and a thick air of secrets revolving around his history in the town they grew up in. As they seek refuge in their similarities, finding comfort in their built chaos, Toby latches onto the security he’s been searching for his entire life, doomed to repeat the mistakes of his past.
-
or a shameless small-town age-gap fic where two fellas meet in awful parts of their lives and find out the bottom's not as bad as it gets.
-
Tags
Summary
You've known Lyra for almost your whole life and you had grown to love her but she doesn't love you.
Her brother loves you though and maybe you like him a little. Even though you try to get with Lyra only to unexpectedly find yourself in love with Toby before the incident. After what happened he still remembers you even though he shouldn't but how can someone forget their first love?
-
Tags
Summary
Your parents decided to take you to go live with your aunt and uncle for the summer since they wouldn't able to take you with them in their trip. This won't be so bad,right? [Will update a chapter every Thursday and Sunday]
Series
- Part 1 of I'll stab you in the heart again
-
Tags
Summary
"You just made the biggest mistake of your life".
Three children, glitchy dreams, and unfamiliar memories of a past she thought she never lived...
Until she meets a certain ticking man.
-
Tags
Summary
Toby knows damn well that something rotten and ugly is hiding in the woods. He’s seen it lurking behind trees and he knows it’s looking at him even if it has no face.
There is something in the woods but no one will believe him.
-
Tags
Summary
a small drabble where connie dies instead of lyra; kind of told through lyra’s perspective?
-
Tags
Summary
A much more gruesome retelling of many popular pasta’s stories, I know many many people have rewritten these characters and I’m no different <33 I simply just wanna share my versions of these characters, as well as write some nasty and lovely gore 💋
Now when I say there’s gonna be gore I’m talking cannibalism, torture, vague talk of SA { I absolutely will not be going into that so no worries } and talk of extreme mental spiral
Also talk of Shipping, I’m honestly a heavy multi shipper but this story isn’t exactly a shippy fanfic. As I said before it’s more of a gruesome retelling, but I probably will be going down the route of Toby x Natalie and Toby x Nina { Nat and Toby will probably be something that ends up being a sort of on and off again thing, that is if I end up finishing this }